r/Terminator • u/OrangeR3dSky • 14d ago
Discussion The first Terminator shows at least Kyle's second trip, not his first
We all know the famous paradox of the first Terminator. John sends Kyle back to protect Sarah, Kyle becomes John's father, and John exists because Kyle came. The end creates the beginning, and the beginning creates the end. It's a perfect closed loop, a paradox, and honestly, it blew my mind.
But I want to question it. A loop like that has no beginning. Nobody started it, it just is. And the whole premise of the films is that going back in time can change the future. If the future can be changed, I think there must have been a first time someone went back to change it. So for me, it's a closed loop, but with an origin.
I believe the John Connor we know isn't the original. Just a thought exercise. Not what the movie says.
**An original John and an original father**
In the film, John's father is Kyle Reese, a man who came from the future. But in the original timeline (edit: I meant first iteraction, first time the facts happen, before the time machine being used), nobody had traveled through time yet. So in that first timeline, John's father could only have been some other man. Sarah had a son with him, and that John grew up and led the resistance. In other words, the John we see in the films isn't the original, and Kyle isn't his original father.
**The first trip**
Losing the war, the machines sent the T-800 back to kill Sarah. The resistance knew exactly who the target was, because Kyle went back with one mission: protect John's mother.
Why would the original John do that? Most likely because changing the past affects the present. If Sarah died in 1984, John would vanish from his own present, and the resistance would lose its leader. Sending Kyle meant protecting his mother, himself, and humanity's chance of winning. The other possibility is that he was thinking of a new timeline, and wanted humanity to have a chance there too. Either way, he had no idea Kyle would become his father.
But Kyle got Sarah pregnant. Here's the irony: John sent Kyle to protect his own existence, and Kyle ended up erasing it. By saving Sarah, he wiped out the very John who sent him, and a new John was born.
**The new John**
This time Sarah knew what was coming, so she prepared her son to lead. She told him who his father was. Kyle is still born on his own date, since his parents still exist. So when the new John meets him, he knows exactly who he's sending back.
**What we see is at least the second trip**
And this is the part I find most interesting: what we see in the first film is at least Kyle's second trip, not his first.
Kyle tells Sarah that John learned everything from her. She taught him to fight, to organize, and to prepare for the war. Remember, Kyle comes from a future where Sarah had already done all of this, before he ever traveled back.
Now think about Sarah in the original timeline. Nobody ever came from the future to warn her. She was an ordinary woman who had no idea a war was coming. She'd have had no reason to train her son for anything.
So if the Sarah who raised Kyle's John did train him, someone must have warned her first. And the only person who could have warned her was Kyle, on an earlier trip. That means the Kyle we see can't be the first one. Before him, another Kyle had already come.
The photo points the same way. Kyle carries a picture of Sarah taken in Mexico, pregnant and on the run. In the original timeline, that moment never happened. For that photo to exist, Sarah must have already lived through all of this before.
I say "at least" the second trip because, from then on, everything repeats the same way. Only the first trip is different: the one where the original John sent Kyle without knowing he was his father.
**The closed loop**
I know the films are often read as a closed loop with no beginning: Kyle has always been the father, and John has always sent him. Terminator 3 even suggests Judgment Day can't be avoided. But Terminator 2 says there's no fate but what we make.
Some also say Skynet created John and John created Skynet, because the chip left from the T-800 led to Skynet being built. That's another loop with no beginning. But Skynet already existed in the original timeline, with no help from the future. The chip only sped it up.
For me, everything needs a cause, and a loop with no beginning has none.
The film presents a perfect closed loop, and I love it as it is. This is just a thought exercise: what if that loop had an origin?
So, in short: there was an original timeline, with no time travel, an original John Connor and an original father. Skynet existed there too. The John we see in the films isn't that one, because we're already in a rewritten timeline. And the Kyle Reese we see in the first film isn't making the first trip to the past. It's at least the second, because on his first trip, Kyle could never have told Sarah that she trained John for the war. The original Sarah was never warned, so she never trained anyone. For me, what we see in the film is Kyle's second trip.
What do you think of this idea?
Edit: I wrote a follow-up with my take on how time travel could work in this theory: https://www.reddit.com/r/Terminator/comments/1xw94qs/followup_to_my_kyle_reese_theory_one_timeline/
18
u/Clothes_Chair_Ghost 14d ago
This has been throughly debunked by everyone who wrote and made the movie. Kyle is was and always will be the only father to John. It’s a causal loop. The terminator is the conception of Skynet and Kyle is the conception of John.
The timeline we see in terminator is the original timeline that is destined to repeat itself forever.
1
u/OrangeR3dSky 13d ago
Hi, please read my take on this: https://www.reddit.com/r/Terminator/comments/1xre8to/followup_to_my_kyle_reese_theory_one_timeline/
0
u/OrangeR3dSky 14d ago
Ok, good to know that. Still I've tryied to make it more logical to me
2
u/MovieFan1984 14d ago
May I ask why a predestination paradox is illogical to you?
2
u/OrangeR3dSky 14d ago edited 14d ago
I believe there is allways a first time. Then all the rest unfolded. This in terms of this history. In reality... it is said that everything happens at the same time. I also believe that. But to Terminator, i felt compeled to find some.. logic. There has to be a first time.
3
u/MovieFan1984 14d ago
In the case of "The Terminator," I prefer to defer to the intentions of the writers and director. Reasonable, no?
4
u/OrangeR3dSky 14d ago
I prefer to just watch the movie and try to figure it out myself. Than learn the autors intention. But still the reading of the spectator can survive.
1
u/MovieFan1984 14d ago
Honestly, that's most people: just watching the movie. For both films and series, I've always loved reading up on "behind the scenes" and "the making of" and the original intentions of the writers, director, and producers.
4
u/OrangeR3dSky 14d ago
Yes, that's diving in the creation.
1
u/MovieFan1984 14d ago
There are two expressions: author's intent and death of the author. Author's intent is pretty obvious. Death of the author means the work of fiction belongs to the audience and the author's intent does not matter. Personally, I've always been an Author's Intent kind of guy. How about you?
2
u/OrangeR3dSky 14d ago
I've dwelved in Cameron's idea before. I had fun thinking on it. The paradox. Awesome. But then the original timeline came to my mind, as to many other people. Now this, the loop that came after, and that this is not the first take of it. The original idea is, of course, more interesting, more deep. Still it was good to explore this idea and it is consistent.and maybe more "real" or more possible.
2
u/OrangeR3dSky 13d ago
Hi, please read my take on this: https://www.reddit.com/r/Terminator/comments/1xre8to/followup_to_my_kyle_reese_theory_one_timeline/
1
u/OrangeR3dSky 14d ago
Gender fluid? :) never thought about that before. In this case ... dead of the author! Knew the expression, but not it's meaning.
→ More replies (0)2
u/OrangeR3dSky 14d ago
Yes. But... youbjust watch the movie. And try to understand it. This is a way of seeing it's logic. Only then you reach for the autors intention. Both views can co-exist. And you can come to the conclusion that the authors idea makes less sense than your own.
6
u/Old-Routine-1629 14d ago
Doesn't the fact that its a paradox kind of answer that question?
1
u/MovieFan1984 14d ago
In time travel stories, sometimes temporal paradoxes exist.
2
u/Old-Routine-1629 14d ago
That doesn't make it any more logical though
0
u/MovieFan1984 14d ago
All time travel stories have unsolvable paradoxes.
You just have to decide what's tolerable vs. not.2
u/Clothes_Chair_Ghost 14d ago
It’s time travel. It follows the rules of the franchise not logic.
Every time travel story has its own way the time travel works cause there is no real world example to pull from it’s entirely up to whomever writes the story to decide how it works.
3
u/OrangeR3dSky 14d ago
Yes. But still you don't contact the writer. You just watch the movie and try to understand it. And this is an explanation more plausible than a closed loop!
0
u/OrangeR3dSky 14d ago
It's beautiful. And we understand that at least at the end of T3. Like .. wow .. it all comes together. And the loop reveals itself. But with just T1... without consulting the ones who wrote, we are free to roam in our minds and try to understand what we just saw. And I definitly feel that the hypotisis that I thought, that we see the second coming of Reese, could make sense. Hope you find it also valid.
8
u/Funny_Or_Cry 14d ago
You're a tad overthinking....The whole premise of the films is to depect some super paranormal sh**t without going through an entire Total Recall or Star Trek world building sequence to explain how they got there.
Time Travel has, and always will be, the greatest writing cheat. JC just did it the best.
4
u/OrangeR3dSky 14d ago
Just sharing thoughts
4
u/Funny_Or_Cry 14d ago
Hey sorry man, believe me i love the fanfic,
Though sometimes it seems these theories on multiverse, paradoxes and closed loops (or even acknowledging T3 for example)...tend to take away from the simplicity and magic in a bottle that was T1 and T2.I actually think concepts like yours would work in an anthology type TV series ( not the linear form of Sarah Connor Chronicles, even though that show was great)
Something where the premise would change season to season and popular ideas get bought back for a second act
I say the same thing about that format being the only thing that can save Star Trek.
It would just work and provide massive storytelling flexibility.3
u/OrangeR3dSky 14d ago
No worries at all. I agree, T1 and T2 work great as they are, the simplicity is part of the magic. My theory isn't meant to change them, just trying to find the logic behind them. I like your anthology idea. One season could even show the original timeline, with the first John and the first trip. Thanks!
3
u/OrangeR3dSky 13d ago
Hi, please read my take on this: https://www.reddit.com/r/Terminator/comments/1xre8to/followup_to_my_kyle_reese_theory_one_timeline/
4
u/soto1988 14d ago
I always felt the guy with the Porsche was the father. Sarah's reaction to him breaking plans always gave me the impression they were intimate.
3
u/OrangeR3dSky 14d ago edited 14d ago
Interesting! That fits really well. In the original timeline, before any time travel, the Porsche guy could have been John's father. But in this movie Reese is here for the second time, not the first. He had already made her pregnant before, she prepared John, and then John sent Reese back. On the first time he couldn't have told her that her son was raised by her to be the leader. How could she have known? Please read that part. Thanks
3
u/Alternative_Shoe_113 14d ago
Spot on.
I developed my own theory that goes in line with this.
And with that I have come to the conclusion that T1 is the middle, T2 is the end and what we never saw was the real beginning of how it all started.
Hollywood wanted to continue sequel after sequel but what was actually called for was a prequel.
Which we never got and will never get.
2
3
u/Siva-Na-Gig 13d ago
Its worth considering that since the conditions existed to send Kyle back in the first place its likely the Terminator was never successful
1
3
u/Jolly-Produce-5033 13d ago
I think there was an original leader who was not John Conner. Kyle got sent back to protect that guy’s mother, and succeeded without dying. He then met Sarah and they fell in love and had John. Kyle trained John to fight Skynet in case the didn’t stop Judgement Day. Then when Skynet forms in that timeline John is the leader instead of the original guy.
1
u/OrangeR3dSky 13d ago
Nice! Could be. But in the film we don't see that. He arrives and meets Sarah. For what you day to happen, Reese protecting another mother, that would be in another travel. I think the original was Connor, without time travel an d Reese. But not "our" Connor, the one we know.
2
u/milesamsterdam 14d ago
The terminator succeeding would have prevented Skynet from being created.
2
4
u/Insideout_Ink_Demon Tech Com 14d ago
I've seen this theory a few times. Just to add, its a different Skynet, because the arm and chip will have changed the direction of Skynet development. And if its more than a second time line, every version of John will be different, although siblings are similar and share the same genetic code, they're not identical, a different swimmer could have made it each time.
3
u/OrangeR3dSky 14d ago edited 14d ago
Yes, good point. Skynet would have developed differently. About different new Johns, I don't yet see why. Thank for replying.
1
u/Insideout_Ink_Demon Tech Com 14d ago
The different Johns is because there are millions of semen when a guy ejaculates. Each one with ever so slightly different DNA. Lots will fail to get close to the egg, but plenty will get close, and the chances of exactly the same swimmer getting to the egg must be slim.
So if a different sperm fertilises the egg, we would get a different John, similar as a brother, but not the same.
2
u/OrangeR3dSky 14d ago edited 14d ago
Ok, in that way I get it. But... I would prefere it simple. Same mother, same father, same Connor. But you point is very valid.
2
u/TakingItPeasy 14d ago
Damn, I never thought about that. It's a massive plot hole I never considered before. Kyle would have been a kid or not even born yet. He is younger than his son. So he couldn't exist without a different previous timeline. Good call.
3
2
u/Just_a_blue_pill 14d ago
I agree with you, and we're not the only ones. It's called the Alpha Timeline Theory. I've got this very personal fan made idea the original Connor was the result of Sarah hooking back with that guy that cancelled a date with a message left on the answering machine. It's flimsy and at face value such a jerk wouldn't be a decent father figure, but we've all seen Fate happens in misterious ways 👍 .
2
u/OrangeR3dSky 14d ago
Thanks, I didn't know it had a name! And I love the idea of the guy who cancelled the date. I don't think the writers planned him as John's original father, but it fits perfectly. When writers start a story, it isn't all in their heads yet. Ideas come as they write, some get thrown away, and the story changes along the way. I believe a story is somehow shown to the one who writes it, almost like channeling it. So maybe the answering machine guy is a hint of an original timeline, left there without the writers even realizing it. And only later came the mind-blowing idea of Kyle always being the father.
1
u/NukedDuke 14d ago
Nah, it's both shallower and deeper than that. That guy is John's father in EVERY timeline, the date he blows Sarah off on was not their first date, and Kyle would be shooting blanks from growing up in irradiated craters.
1
u/LonelyReflection1717 14d ago
Good job kyle wasn't firing blanks then
1
u/OrangeR3dSky 14d ago
Yes. By f#cking Connor's mother... Reese f#ck up the plan and the original Connor's life! :)
1
1
14d ago
It's essentially what cane first, the chicken or the egg. It's a paradox, but you know what, when you get into quantum physics, paradoxes happen
1
1
u/Bluefist56 14d ago edited 13d ago
I’m partial to the idea that a predestination loop is the natural result of a singular time travel event. Kyle was always John’s father, and the T800’s remains always lead to Skynet’s creation. This loop has no beginning or end as once started it always existed and always would exist as a fixed loop in time. That is, until a second time travel event resulted an overlap of the original loop with another causal loop; this allowed for the two loops to be orphaned from the timeline and set in motion an unknown future.
Now, all this works well narratively if time travel is a rare event. It breaks down and gets silly when there are too many interacting loops, and this is precisely why the third move should have been a future war movie that ended with Kylie being sent back.
1
u/OrangeR3dSky 14d ago
Nice take. Overlap of the original loop. That is what I was thinking, and somehow will rewrite my post. When I said original timelines I was not thinking on diferent realities happeninv at the same time, but the rhe same timeline being rewriten. So I meant original version, or first iteration.
1
1
u/UnevenFlooring 13d ago
This post is from an llm
2
u/OrangeR3dSky 13d ago edited 13d ago
No. I've wrote it using Ai to translate and to help me construct the sentences in english. Also when stucked in some corners, or lost in thoughs, i've asked it help. 100% all my ideas, my thought process, sequence and words. I've allowed the titles in the paragraphs because i think they are ok. Thanks
1
u/UnevenFlooring 13d ago
You are contradicting youreelf
1
u/OrangeR3dSky 13d ago edited 13d ago
No, men. I've have spoken to Ai. I just finished another post that I will post in a second. It took me hours, like the one you've read. Driving while talking out loud to Ai. Then asked it to read it in english. Sometimes i've said "i didn't said that". I want it close to my way of expressing. In this new post i've talked a lot. Came with 3 hypotises. Then while developing the 3rd, while talking, i've said, "well this comes out in the end very similar to the first, doesn't it?" And Ai replied yes, you are right because of this and that. "So maybe saying this will express better my idea." And Ai said something like "how about this" and i would reply "No, that's not it, it's this. Ok, like this? Yes. But eliminate that part. Etc... i use it as a tool. Not as a substitute. It's the idea that counts here.
1
u/OrangeR3dSky 13d ago
It's taking me a lot of time. By not wanting to write all of that, i keep talking to my phone saying things again and again, trying to perfect them. Erasing ai's sentences. Probably would be better by doing it myself, but this also helps me to sharpen my ideas and sentences.
1
u/SeaOfNoines 14d ago
I said something similar those not as well articulated as your post, but I agree I would LOVE to see the original story of events.
"Cool concept. I've always thought about a movie that captures the original events that led to Judgement Day... let me expand. What James Cameron captures with the first two films are a result of Kyle Reese going back in time. I would imagine that alters the timeline. It's the chicken or the egg thing. What happened as a result of Sarah's life not being influenced by Kyle. I imagine John wouldn't have the upbringing/training he learned in his younger year portrayed in T2. Perhaps he had to get harden during the first few years of the war and eventually rises to a leadership role. How does Cyberdyne develop Skynet if there is no chip to work off of?"
2
u/OrangeR3dSky 14d ago
Thanks! To your question: the same way it was created in the first timeline. For me, there has to be a base timeline: machines rise, Judgment Day happens, there's a war, and only then does anyone travel back in time. In that first timeline, Skynet was built by people, with no chip from the future. The chip in T2 just sped things up, or maybe changed its direction, as someone said here.
Saying Skynet always came from the future is beautiful, almost poetic. But to me it's less solid than having a starting point.
1
u/Wooden-Ad-9925 14d ago
I'll go one further. The first woman who was terminated by the T-800 WAS the original timeline's Sarah Connor, and her son was humanity's Savior. Then Hamilton-Connor just took up the mantle, named her son John and just played out a destiny that was originally someone else's.
(Ignore the fact that Kyle had her pic in the future and this theory would actually work )
7
u/X3N04L13N 14d ago
2
u/OrangeR3dSky 14d ago
All of this think8ng and writing where crowned with this picture. I love it! Ahahah It was worth it
3
3
2
1
u/Strict-Sea-3412 14d ago
No need to ignore it as it was not Kyles first trip, so the new Sarah Connor is the OG Sarah Connor to that John and that Kyle.
1
1
u/IncredibleEdible321 14d ago
This is a common theory, so you're not breaking any new ground here.
2
u/OrangeR3dSky 14d ago
Ok, i didn't read any. Yes today I've seen that many people think of an original timeline. But the point of this post isn't that. It's of this movie showing us the second time that Kyle goes back in time. Did you read that part? Please take a look. Thanks.
2
u/IncredibleEdible321 14d ago edited 14d ago
No worries. It's hard to keep track of all the interesting theories out there. Yes, I read your entire post. While interesting, I must stand with others here who believe you are wrong. There never was an "original timeline". Without Kyle and The Terminator, there's no John and no Skynet. Without John and Skynet, there is no Kyle and no Terminator. It's an endless predestination paradox loop.
0
u/OrangeR3dSky 14d ago
But it would work. Althought it is more poetic in that way, and was the autor's intention, that idea probably only was born after an original timeline was created in the writers mind. The book is not all revealed to the author in the beggining. It's a process, it's an adventure he lives. So before the "mind-blown" moment that he possibly had... there was an original progress of time. Or not. I understand the endless paradox loop. You are right. That's the exploration here. The movie doesn't have to fit our reality in the way we perceive it. But if, like me, you were trying for it to make sense, you find the original timeline. But that is not so important! What I bring here is the ideia of this not beeing Reese's first travel!
2
u/IncredibleEdible321 14d ago
I'll stick with what James Cameron says about the timeline, thank you very much.
1
u/OrangeR3dSky 14d ago
I personaly stick with what the movie shows and with what we can think of it. And ALSO the autor's intention. Both can co-exist.
1
14d ago
Oh wow, look who has just learned about Infinite Martys today! What a fresh and original theory for the year 2026 my friend! *wanking motion
1
u/OrangeR3dSky 14d ago
... did you ever thought that this could be the second time that Reese came? That was my point. :)
4
2
u/Alternative_Cat9144 14d ago
Could Sarah have already been pregnant when Kyle went back and didn't know so she thinks Kyle is the father.
1
u/Aggravating-Big6658 14d ago
Wow è interessante.... Ci ho già pensato... È un paradosso che nemmeno Skinet riuscirebbe a capire 😉
1
u/razorthick_ 13d ago
In the the science fiction universe of The Terminator, the loop extends back in time to infinity. Even saying back in time is no accurate. It just continues.
You cant try to apply our real world concept of origin because even isn't fully understood.
Thats part of the horror of this universe is the loop. Which can be seen as the third antagonist after Skynet and the Terminators.
Sarah defeated this time loop when she chose not to kill Dyson.
1
u/Captain_Sterling 12d ago
Just to add, you're assuming casuality in a time loop. You're thinking that a caused b. . And because it's a loop you're assuming that something cause the loop, let's call it c. . But causality like this only works in time. It doesn't need to happen in a time loop. It might have happened, but it doesn't need to. And to say that it does, you'd need to prove it
What I'm basically saying is the physics and time can be weird. And it's always possible that time loops just occur.
1
u/AlphaRankin 12d ago
Ok but hear me out, I think instead it is the original time travel incident and we are watching in real time as the timeliness changes around the t-800's actions. kyle Reece doesn't show up until after the T-800 meaning that the timeliness had already been changed just from him being there. The terminator started out with a list of people who would be a threat during the war and started killing off the people from that list. And while it's not exactly a good movie we see that changes to the timeliness can affect time travelers after the fact because of Genesis Kyle recieving memories from the alternate timeliness he traveled to. So this is my take on the process of events.
T-800 travels to the past and begins killing off future resistance leaders. This leads to changes in the timeline that result in Kyle Reece being sent back in time, when he gets to the past it rewrites the timeline again to where he falls in love with Sarah Connor and John is born. John being born of Kyle and learning of the future prepares and becomes a greater threat than the list of leaders which creates a feedback rewriting the original mission of the terminator from kill 15 people to kill Sarah specifically. While also changing Kyle's memories so he remembers what happend in the timeline he just created further pushing the timeline towards the Connor centric rebellion. This might have even been the machines plan all along, that way instead of having to hunt down and kill a large network of leadership skynet forced the change intentionally setting up a hero that humanity could rally behind because once that hero is finally killed they then break humanity's will to fight back making it easier for skynet to win the war.
1
0
u/RansomStark78 14d ago
Your timeline diag is wrong
Time paradoxes are hard
Draw it out.
The movie we she is the timeline
2
0
u/TheSquirrelmancer 13d ago
Yes, it's a bootstrap paradox that defies logic, that's the point of the movie. It was created in an era when storytelling was more about "hey look at this cool funky idea" versus "can we make a 10 movie franchise with spinoff tv shows and video games".
Any attempt to try and logistically retcon the whole thing into making sense fails to resolve an impossible paradox. Even the second film logically shouldn't have happened.
1
1
u/SpiritOne 10d ago
You’re looking at time from a linear perspective. Time isn’t actually linear. We experience it linearly. But time is sort of a Wibbly wobbly timey wimey mess.
Skynet always sends back the terminator to kill Sarah, unknowingly creating John through Kyle. In this universe it’s a canon event. A fixed point in time.
1
u/OrangeR3dSky 7d ago
I get the first part but not the second. Aren't points in a linear time also fixed? Thanks


63
u/MovieFan1984 14d ago
James Cameron's intent was to present a predestination paradox. In the first film, Kyle Reese father's John Connor in 1984. The Terminator debris found at the Cyberdine factory leads to the creation of Skynet. There is no original timeline. Without Kyle and the Terminator, there's no John and no Skynet. That said, I do see the fun in trying to imagine that there could have been an original timeline that led to the predestination paradox timeline.