r/SurroundAudiophile • u/Media6292 • 7h ago
Review (Recordings) U2 - Carnaval De Luz - Review of the album (Blu-ray, Dark Blue Marble vinyl vs streaming, stereo vs Dolby Atmos) Which is the best edition?
Hello,
Released on November 13, 2026, Carnaval de Luz is U2 s 16th studio album. This symbolic album celebrates the Irish band’s 50-year career and marks the triumphant return of drummer Larry Mullen Jr. Musically, the album revisits a unifying and uplifting rock sound, tailor-made for the big stage.
Available in various formats, including Blu-ray, CD, vinyl, and streaming, which edition(s) are best for listening to this album?
For the digital stereo version, with the exception of the track If The World Is At War We Better Not Be, which has a DR10, all the others range from DR6 to DR8, resulting in a less dynamic listening experience compared to the Dolby Atmos version, which offers greater nuance even when downmixed to stereo.
Dark Blue Marble vinyl record - 2026 version shows a good dynamic range confirmed with DR11.
The graph below compares the spectrum of the Dark Blue Marble vinyl record - 2026 (white curve) with the spectrum of the Tidal Max - 2026 (blue curve).The curves of the two spectra overlap almost perfectly, with a slight difference in the upper part of the spectrum (yellow area) above 8 kHz; the treble level of the vinyl record is slightly higher, by 1 to 3 dB. There is also a difference below 60 Hz, with the vinyl record version having a few dB more.
U2 offers an immersive version that allows listeners to fully appreciate the album’s dynamic range and the beautiful reproduction of the vocals, with an immersive mix that makes use of the various channels and utilizes the soundspace differently depending on the track. It s not a full 360-degree experience like on Steven Wilson s latest album, but rather an extended 180-degree experience that fits the tracks perfectly.
After listening to the first few tracks some days ago, it s a real pleasure to discover this album, especially with the Dolby TrueHD (lossless format) version available on the Blu-ray edition; in addition to the beautiful spatialization of the tracks,which doesn t try to be showy, it lets you enjoy great dynamics and a stunning rendering of the vocals and instruments. This is the best edition of this album. For those who prefer to stick with stereo, the vinyl record is a step above the digital stereo editions (which are dynamically compressed), offering a more pleasant and natural sound.
Find all the analyses and measurements of each versions here (link).
And the video of the 3D immersive sound on Youtube.
You can download the 3D spatialization representation file for all the tracks here (link) and open it with the application available on this page.
Enjoy listening,
Jean-François