r/SurroundAudiophile • u/[deleted] • Feb 07 '21
r/SurroundAudiophile • u/Megawashu • Jan 03 '26
Tips & Advice Need help positioning side speakers
EDIT: I currently have the L&R speakers such that they 21.5 degrees from the center. The left is by the window and the right is in front of the fire place. https://imgur.com/a/home-theater-setup-xhnaWZI
I am considering putting the TV flat on the left wall with half of it over the window. Then it would be directly across from the people on the couch. This would allow the left speaker to be completely past the window and the right speaker in the brick corner.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Due to my sectional being against the wall and my TV in the corner, I’m forgoing rear speakers and reducing from 5.1 to 3.1. Note in the photos the orange person is where we sit to watch TV. Red lines indicate sound direction.
My question to Reddit is: should I configure my L&R speakers next to the TV or further away (as indicated in the photos)? Or perhaps another way? We don't want the speakers blocking the fireplace, so that is why they close or far.
r/SurroundAudiophile • u/Nick_V99 • Jun 25 '23
Eye Candy Pink Floyd - JBL Synthesis - Dolby Atmos
The Dark Side of the Moon in Dolby Atmos from their 50th Anniversary box set is sounding absolutely phenomenal on my 5.2.4 JBL Synthesis Immersive System.
r/SurroundAudiophile • u/[deleted] • Jan 29 '23
Music Where can I stream 7.1 music files?
r/SurroundAudiophile • u/[deleted] • Nov 18 '20
Eye Candy Blackbird Studios, all ATC ATMOS System used for mixing
r/SurroundAudiophile • u/ned1son • Dec 05 '25
Music When you see that gold SACD slipcase you know it's gonna be 🔥
Just picked up Live Evil on Quad SACD too
r/SurroundAudiophile • u/ned1son • Aug 25 '26
Review (Recordings) Worth the price of admission for 'The Prophet's Song' alone, let alone Bohemian Rhapsody et al. What an album, what a mix!!
Has anyone on here done an A/B between this and the Blu-ray repress? Same mix or were there updates?
r/SurroundAudiophile • u/Media6292 • Dec 14 '25
Review (Recordings) Pink Floyd – Wish You Were Here 50th Anniversary – the ultimate edition of this album? – Review (Vinyl, CD, SACD, Blu-ray, from 1975 to 2025, stereo, 4.0, 5.1 to Dolby Atmos)
Hello,
Wish You Were Here is the ninth studio album by the British band Pink Floyd, released in 1975. It was recorded at Abbey Road Studios in early 1975, shortly after the massive success of The Dark Side of the Moon.

For this review, you will find 22 versions tested.
If you want to experience the mix with the original tonal character, it is best to choose the original vinyl version (the one tested here is from 1975) or the 4.0 mix available on the Blu-ray editions.
All recent versions, starting with the 1984 CD, feature different tonal balance and spatial imaging, evolving from a less clear mix to the 2025 edition, which is the clearest and most precise.
The comparison of the frequency spectrum for the track “Wish You Were Here” between the 1984 CD and the 1975 vinyl clearly shows a significant increase in low frequencies on the CD edition.

A comparison of the spectrum for “Wish You Were Here” between the 1984 CD and the 2025 Blu-ray highlights a marked increase in high frequencies on the Blu-ray edition, resulting in a clearer presentation than the CD version and aiming to come closer to the original sound.

As a result, the first CD edition introduced a substantial boost in low frequencies, and in the years that followed, subsequent remasterings progressively emphasized the high frequencies in an effort to restore greater clarity to the overall album.
This ultimately comes down to personal preference, but this new 50th anniversary Blu-ray edition remains the clearest and most precise version since the 1984 CD release. The Blu-ray includes the 24-bit/192 kHz stereo version, the original 4.0 mix, as well as the 5.1 and Dolby Atmos remixes. While these newer mixes offer a more balanced tonal presentation, they lose some of the originality that defined the 4.0 mix.



Spatialization for the 4.0, 5.1 and Dolby Atmos Mix.
However, the 2025 vinyl editions show a quality issue around 15 kHz (red zone), likely due to a problem with the cutting heads, which would require adjustment to achieve the level of quality found on other vinyl productions.

Find all the samples in high resolution to listen to and compare the different versions, as well as all the analyses and measurements of each of the 22 versions here (link).
Enjoy listening,
Jean-François
r/SurroundAudiophile • u/ned1son • Jul 24 '25
Spatial Audio IMHO the Quad mix is the ideal way to experience Paranoid's full glory. Finally got around to giving it a memorial spin.
r/SurroundAudiophile • u/gvl_guy • Feb 27 '26
Music Double delivery today
Which should I listen to first?
r/SurroundAudiophile • u/WhatDaufuskie • Sep 10 '26
Music I can't recommend this highly enough
Not Atmos, but this 5.1 DVD slaps! The detail and DR are exceptional. I keep coming back to it.
r/SurroundAudiophile • u/gvl_guy • Aug 08 '26
Music Every quadraphonic Quadio ever released by Rhino Records on one chart.
If you'd like to know every Quadio Blu-ray that Rhino has released since the beginning of this program, here's a fantastic diagram. It includes all the Quadios (and some not labeled as such, but contain the original quadraphonic mixes lifted usually from the master tapes.)
This is courtesy of the QuadraphonicQuad.com board and administrator @JonUrban.
r/SurroundAudiophile • u/Media6292 • Sep 21 '25
Review (Recordings) Phil Collins – No Jacket Required – Is the 40th Anniversary Edition the New Standard? – Review (CD, vinyl, blu-ray, streaming, from 1985 to 2025, stereo, 5.1, Dolby Atmos)
Hello,
No Jacket Required, released in 1985, is Phil Collins’ third solo studio album.
The album features several internationally successful singles, including “Sussudio,” “One More Night,” and “Don’t Lose My Number.”
No Jacket Required received multiple accolades, including Grammy Awards, and achieved major commercial success worldwide.
It remains an iconic work of 1980s pop and an important milestone in Phil Collins’ solo career.

Steven Wilson explains the 2025 mix process for the stereo, 5.1 and Dolby Atmos:
“For recreating the stereo I had a copy of the first CD edition from 1985 and the most recent 2016 remaster as my references for the original mix, but have favoured the 1985, which has a much greater dynamic range and sounds more natural. Using this new stereo mix as a starting point, I then expanded the album out into both 5.1 and Atmos (the 5.1 is a dedicated mix, not a fold down of the Atmos).”
In terms of dynamics, it is indeed the 2016 remastered version that is most heavily affected by the loudness war, as shown by the waveform comparisons of the CD, 2016, and 2025 editions below:

As for the vinyl, we can observe the phenomenon described in article “Vinyl succumbs to Loudness War: more than just collateral damage!”: the 2025 box set edition was produced from a compressed master. This results in a lower-level cut on vinyl, as highlighted by the waveform comparison between the 1985 and 2025 vinyl editions:

Regarding the Dolby Atmos version, we find Steven Wilson’s excellent work, offering a fully immersive mix that allows listeners to rediscover the album in a new way. The Blu-ray edition, in particular, benefits from a lossless encoding in Dolby Digital Atmos TrueHD.

You can find all the audio samples to compare the 10 tested versions, along with the complete set of measurements, at the following link.
Enjoy listening,
Jean-François
r/SurroundAudiophile • u/Media6292 • Jan 12 '25
Review (Recordings) 151 albums reviewed with 844 editions tested, 81 in Dolby Atmos, the complete list …
Hello,
I’d like to start by thanking you all for your encouragement and messages since the creation of MagicVinylDigital just over 3 years ago.

The milestone of 151 reviews, 151 albums tested (including 4 singles) has just been reached, representing 844 versions analyzed across a diversity of media ranging from 8-track cartridges, cassette, vinyl, digital CD, DVD, Bluray, Blu-ray UHD 4K, SACD, DAT, MKV, Tape R2R and streaming media (Qobuz, Tidal, Apple, Amazon).
Some statistics: 198 vinyl records, 128 CDs, 30 blu-rays (81 tracks tested), 81 Dolby Atmos albums (110 versions), 22 SACDs (42 tracks tested) , 12 cassettes, 320 streaming versions (all formats) …
With a diversity of audio formats from mono to spatial audio formats such as Dolby Atmos and Sony 360 Reality Audio.
And in many styles of music: Jazz, Classical, Pop, Rock…
Below you’ll find a list of all the tests, with direct links to each album:
Adele - 30 (5 versions)
Alan Parsons - From the New World (6 versions)
Alicia Keys - Alicia (6 versions)
Alicia Keys - Keys (2 versions)
Alphaville - Forever Young (8 versions)
Amy Winehouse - At The BBC (4 versions)
Amy Winehouse - Live at Glastonbury 2007 (2 versions)
Anna Lapwood - Luna (2 versions)
Anne Bisson - Tiles from the treetops (3 versions)
Anne Bisson - Be my lover (2 versions)
Beethoven - Symphonie N°7 (7 versions)
Billie Eilish - Hit Me Hard And Soft (4 versions)
Bob Marley & The Wailers - One Love (Original Motion Picture Soundtrack) (2 versions)
Bruce Springsteen - Born In The U.S.A. (4 versions)
Coldplay - Music Of The Spheres (4 versions)
Coldplay - Moon Music (4 versions)
Daft Punk - Random Access Memories (11 versions)
Daft Punk - Homework (7 versions)
Daft Punk - Alive 1997 (6 versions)
Daft Punk - Random Access Memories (Drumless Edition) (4 versions)
David Gilmour - Luck and Strange (5 versions)
Def Leppard - Pyromania (9 versions)
Depeche Mode - Memento Mori (2 versions)
Dianne Reeves - I remember (5 versions)
Dire Straits - Brothers In Arms (9 versions)
Dire Straits - Money For Nothing (5 versions)
Dire Straits - Encores (3 versions)
Dire Straits - On Every Street (8 versions)
Dua Lipa - Radical Optimism (2 versions)
Duo Cirla Trolonge - Piuma (4 versions)
Duran Duran - DANSE MACABRE (3 versions)
Ed Sheeran - + (4 versions)
Ed Sheeran - = (3 versions)
Ed Sheeran - – (Subtract) (3 versions)
Ed Sheeran - X (3 versions)
Eric Clapton - Unplugged (10 versions)
Eric Clapton - The Lady In The Balcony: Lockdown Sessions (9 versions)
Eric Clapton - To Save a Child (6 versions)
Francis Cabrel - Trobador Tour (Live) (2 versions)
Green Day - Saviors (3 versions)
Hélène Grimaud - For Clara – Works by Schumann and Brahms (2 versions)
Imagine Dragons - LOOM (2 versions)
Indochine - L’ Aventurier (8 versions)
Indochine - Central Tour (9 versions)
Irène Drésel - KINKY DOGMA (2 versions)
Jean-Michel Jarre - Amazonia (5 versions)
Jean-Michel Jarre - Welcome To The Other Side - Live in Notre Dame VR (7 versions)
Jean-Michel Jarre - Oxygene (15 versions)
Jean-Michel Jarre - Oxymore (7 versions)
Jean-Michel Jarre - Oxymoreworks (3 versions)
Jean-Michel Jarre - VERSAILLES 400 LIVE (3 versions)
Jennifer Lopez - This Is Me...Now (3 versions)
Jerome Sabbagh - Vintage (3 versions)
Jerome Sabbagh - Heart (3 versions)
John Williams - John Williams in Tokyo (8 versions)
Johnny Cash - Songwriter (2 versions)
Joshua Redman - Where Are We (3 versions)
Joy Crookes - Skin (4 versions)
Kate Bush - Hounds Of Love (11 versions)
Katie Melua - Acoustic Album No. 8 (4 versions)
Katie Melua - Golden Record (4 versions)
Kirsten Edkins - Shapes and Sound (3 versions)
Kylie Minogue - Tension (2 versions)
Lana Del Rey - Chemtrails Over the Country Club (7 versions)
Lana Del Rey - Blue Banisters (3 versions)
Lana Del Rey - Did you know that there's a tunnel under Ocean Blvd (4 versions)
Lang Lang - Saint-Saëns (3 versions)
Lenny Kravitz - Blue Electric Light (2 versions)
Les restos du Cœur - 2023 Enfoirés Un Jour, Toujours (7 versions)
Liszt / Sviatoslav Richter - Concertos For Piano And Orchestra Nos. 1 & 2 (4 versions)
Ludwig Göransson - Oppenheimer (Original Motion Picture Soundtrack) (2 versions)
Madeleine Peyroux - Let's Walk (2 versions)
Madonna - Finally Enough Love (2 versions)
Mari Kodama, Momo Kodama, Karin Kei Nagano, Orchestre de la Suisse Romande & Kent Nagano - Mozart & Poulenc - Double & Triple Piano Concertos (4 versions)
Mariah Carey - Merry Christmas (8 versions)
Mark Knopfler - One Deep River (7 versions)
Melody Gardot - Sunset In The Blue (4 versions)
Michael Jackson - Dangerous (13 versions)
Michael Jackson - Thriller (21 versions)
Mike Oldfield - Tubular Bells (14 versions)
Miles Davis - Kind of blue (33 versions)
Muse - Will Of The People (4 versions)
Muse - Absolution XX Anniversary (4 versions)
Mylène Farmer - Histoires de (3 versions)
Mylène Farmer - À tout jamais (2 versions)
Mylène Farmer - A tout Jamais (Remixes) (5 versions)
Mylène Farmer - L'Emprise (6 versions)
Mylene Farmer - Nevermore (Live) (8 versions)
Nirvana - Nevermind (9 versions)
Norah Jones - ‘Til We Meet Again (3 versions)
Norah Jones - Come Away With Me (14 versions)
Oscar Peterson - A Time For Love (2 versions)
Patricia Barber - Clique! (9 versions)
Pet Shop Boys - Nonetheless (5 versions)
Peter Gabriel - i/o (8 versions)
Pink Floyd - Live at Knebworth 1990 (6 versions)
Pink Floyd - A Momentary Lapse Of Reason (12 versions)
Pink Floyd - PULSE (10 versions)
Pink Floyd - Hey Hey Rise Up (4 versions)
Pink Floyd - Animals (17 versions)
Pink Floyd - The Dark Side Of The Moon (31 versions)
Pink Floyd - The Dark Side of the Moon (Live at Wembley) 1974 (3 versions)
PLACEBO - Never Let Me Go (5 versions)
Prince - Prince and the Revolution Live (8 versions)
Prince - Purple Rain (1 versions)
Rag'n'Bone Man - Life By Misadventure (6 versions)
Red Hot Chili Peppers - Unlimited Love (5 versions)
Red Hot Chili Peppers - Return Of The Dream Canteen (3 versions)
Renaud Capuçon - Gabriel Fauré (2 versions)
Roger Waters - The Dark Side of the Moon Redux (3 versions)
Saint-Saëns - Symphony No. 3 with Organ : Kansas City Symphony (5 versions)
Saint-Saëns - Symphony No. 3 with Organ : Charles Munch and Boston Symphony 1959 (6 versions)
Serge Gainsbourg - L'Homme a Tete De Chou (8 versions)
Shania Twain - Queen Of Me (4 versions)
Shania Twain - Come On Over (6 versions)
Sia - Reasonable Woman (2 versions)
Sinéad O’Connor - I Do Not Want What I Haven’t Got (6 versions)
Steven Wilson - The Harmony Codex (9 versions)
Sting - The Bridge (4 versions)
Stray Kids - 5 Star (3 versions)
Taylor Swift - RED (4 versions)
Taylor Swift - Midnights (5 versions)
Taylor Swift - Speak Now (Taylor's Version) (3 versions)
Taylor Swift - 1989 (Taylor's Version) (3 versions)
Taylor Swift - The Tortured Poets Department – The Anthology (3 versions)
TEARS FOR FEARS - SONGS FOR A NERVOUS PLANET (8 versions)
Tears For Fears - Live At Massey Hall Toronto, Canada 1985 (4 versions)
Tears For Fears - The Tipping Point (11 versions)
Tears For Tears - The Hurting (10 versions)
The Art Of Noise - In The City Live In Tokyo 1986 (5 versions)
The Beatles - Now and Then (5 versions)
The Beatles - The Beatles : the 1962-1966 (The Red Album) (4 versions)
The Beatles - The Beatles: 1967-1970 (The Blue Album) (4 versions)
The Cure - Songs Of A Lost World (6 versions)
The Dave Brubeck Quartet - TIME OUT (8 versions)
The Police - Greatest Hits (5 versions)
The Police - Around The World (4 versions)
The Rolling Stones - Hackney Diamonds (7 versions)
Thomas Bangalter - Mythologies (3 versions)
Thomas Schirmann - After The Rain (4 versions)
Trio Mediaeval - YULE (6 versions)
Tsuyoshi Yamamoto Trio - Misty for Direct Cutting (5 versions)
Tsuyoshi Yamamoto Trio - A Shade Of Blue (8 versions)
Tsuyoshi Yamamoto Trio - Sweet For k (3 versions)
Various - Ghostbusters (4 versions)
Various - Back to the Future (2 versions)
Various - Top Gun (8 versions)
Various - TOP GUN Maverick (3 versions)
Various - Barbie: The Album (3 versions)
Yes - Mirror To The Sky (7 versions)
Yuja Wang - The Vienna Recital (2 versions)
Enjoy listening
Jean-François
r/SurroundAudiophile • u/SmilesUndSunshine • Nov 02 '24
Announcement Subreddit should be back up and open now
Seems like the old moderator for this subreddit deleted their account and left the sub on "Restricted" mode so only approved users could post in the sub. I'm not sure if anyone was actually an approved user after the old mod left, so the sub's been idle for several months.
Today, I requested and was granted the moderator role for this sub. I don't know much of anything about moderating, so if any others also want this role, please message me. In the meantime, I'll do what I can while hoping the relatively niche and non-controversial subject matter will keep actual moderating duties pretty light/easy.
Otherwise, welcome and welcome back all, and happy listening!
r/SurroundAudiophile • u/Media6292 • Mar 26 '25
News Dire Straits - Brothers in Arms, Roxy Music, Prince coming to blu-ray Audio Dolby Atmos. Blu-ray: The New Ultimate Standard for Audiophiles?
Hello,
More than a year ago, article titled "Blu-ray “pure” audio: a format for the future?" raised the inquiry regarding whether Blu-ray represents the future format for audio..
When is it today?

For a start, announcements of forthcoming releases are on the increase, with flagship albums such as :
Dire Straits - Brothers in Arms
Elton John and Brandi Carlile - Who Believes In Angels
Roxy Music / Avalon
Prince and the Revolution - Purple Rain
In just over a year, more and more albums have been released in Blu-ray format, featuring the Dolby Atmos track in Lossless Dolby Digital TrueHD format.
But also, by offering a stereo track without dynamic compression, as with Tears For Fears' “Songs for a Nervous Planet” or Ultravox's “Lament”, thus proposing an audiophile approach to this medium.
Also worthy of note is the superb Steven Wilson - The overview, a reference in terms of Dolby Atmos mixing.
Often in special, limited editions from SDE, or more and more widely distributed editions (Pink Floyd, The Rolling Stone…).

Just take a look at some of the titles released since June 2023 to see the diversity and the presence of some very well-known singers and bands:
With The Pineapple Thief “It Leads To This”, we realized that bluray was the most audiophile medium, offering the best audio quality.
The Alan Parsons Project “Pyramid”
...
This is not the case for all albums, but the trend continues.
In parallel, there is also an alternative distribution of the Dolby Atmos track in the Lossless Dolby Digital TrueHD format, with dematerialized music sales sites such as:
https://shop.2l.no, https://immersiveaudioalbum.com, https://www.nativedsd.com
For example
The Tsuyoshi Yamamoto Trio is back with a new album, “A Shade Of Blue”.
Madeleine Peyroux - Let's Walk
The big winner is the Dolby Digital TrueHD Atmos format, and some editions also feature an uncompressed dynamic stereo track, providing the audiophile quality required for stereo and Atmos music reproduction.
We're still a long way from widespread distribution, but we can only hope that the spread of Dolby Atmos in Lossless and stereo without loudness war continues to develop, whether in physical Blu-ray or dematerialized formats.
And who knows, maybe one day a streaming service will be available with the Dolby Atmos TrueHD format. And for stereo with or without loudness war!
Enjoy listening,
Jean-François
r/SurroundAudiophile • u/ned1son • Jun 07 '23
Showing Off Far from the complete collection, but here are some recent 5.1 favorites!
r/SurroundAudiophile • u/ned1son • Aug 10 '26
Atmos Absolutely LOVING the trend of including instrumental mixes in Atmos as well. Hearing their arrangement of Eight Miles High in detailed surround is such a highlight of this incredible release.
r/SurroundAudiophile • u/Media6292 • 14d ago
Review (Recordings) Jean-Michel Jarre - Oxygène (50th Anniversary Editions) - Dolby Atmos preview - A New Benchmark for Dolby Atmos?
Hello,
To celebrate the 50th anniversary of his legendary album Oxygène, Jean-Michel Jarre is orchestrating an exceptional comeback through three major, complementary projects. The pioneer of electronic music has announced his new immersive world tour, titled OXYGENE & BEYOND, featuring three highly anticipated concerts at La Seine Musicale from October 14 to 16, 2027.
At the same time, the cult album is being reissued in a collector’s edition remastered at Abbey Road by Miles Showell, with a Dolby Atmos mix by David Kosten, Steven Wilson, and Jean-Michel Jarre.
This anniversary edition will be available starting November 20, 2026, on vinyl, CD, and Blu-ray.
This preview gives us a first look at this new special anniversary edition.
Jean-Michel Jarre’s electronic music lends itself very well to a Dolby Atmos mix, especially since this mix was created in collaboration with David Kosten, Steven Wilson, and Jean-Michel Jarre.
It’s a real success on this first track, which was released via streaming ahead of the anniversary date.
You’re truly immersed in the album, with sound that surrounds you and moves all around you, this first track is a true showcase of the Dolby Atmos mix. All channels are fully utilized in a 360-degree space. It’s likely to become one of the best Dolby Atmos albums of 2026, especially since a Dolby Atmos TrueHD version will be available on Blu-ray.
The remastered stereo version is also very well done, with excellent dynamic range.
This first track suggests that this 50th-anniversary edition will be of very high quality, available on Blu-ray, CD, and vinyl.
Find all the analyses and measurements of each versions here (link).
And the video of the 3D immersive sound on Youtube.
Enjoy listening,
Jean-François
Other reviews of Jean-Michel Jarre:
Jean-Michel Jarre – VERSAILLES 400 LIVE – Greatest live show – Review – (Test: Tidal Max vs vinyl record vs CD with NFC)
Jean-Michel Jarre – Oxymoreworks – New Oxymore version – Review – (Test: vinyl record, Tidal MAX FLAC 24 bits 48 kHz and Deezer 16 bits 44.1 kHz)
Jean-Michel Jarre – Oxymore – Review (Vinyl, CD, Binaural, Qobuz Hi-Res, Tidal Dolby Atmos)
Jean-Michel Jarre – Oxygene Review (LP, Japanese LP , MOFI LP, CD, Trilogy 40th Anniversary, Qobuz, Tidal, DVD, cassette)
Jean-Michel Jarre – Live in Notre-Dame VR – Welcome To The Other Side – Review (Vinyl, CD, Bluray, binaural, Streaming Amazon)
Jean-Michel Jarre – AMAZÔNIA Review (Vinyl, CD, Binaural, 5.1)
r/SurroundAudiophile • u/Media6292 • Jun 04 '25
Atmos Pink Floyd – Live at Pompeii – MCMLXXII, Video presentation of Echo part 1's Dolby Atmos 7.1.4 spatialization
Hello,
Here is a dynamic video representation of the Dolby Atmos 7.1.4 spatialization of the Echo part1 track.
This is a first version.
What do you think of it?
Thanks
r/SurroundAudiophile • u/Media6292 • Mar 19 '23
Review (Recordings) Comparison of "The Dark Side Of The Moon" from Pink Floyd between 21 versions : CD (1984, 1994, MOFI...), Vinyls (1973, 2016, Japan, Mofi, Quadraphonic...), SACDs, Bluray, Cassette, 8-track, in stereo, 4.0, 5.1.
"The Dark Side Of The Moon" of Pink Floyd celebrates 50 years this year, it is the occasion to come back on this mythical album with these 21 tested versions: Vinyl (1973 French, Japanese, MOFI, Remastered 2016, Quadraphonic), Cassettes, 8-track cartridge, CD (1984,1994, MOFI...), SACD (2003, 2021), Bluray, Qobuz, with stereo, 4.0 and 5.1 versions.

We find a disparity in the sound rendering with versions that are clearer than the others as in this example below which compares the Japanese vinyl of 1973 and the remastered vinyl of 2016. The yellow zone shows an accentuation around 10 kHz which will give more details to the listening. The red area shows a strong disturbance above 15 kHz typical of Bernie Grundman's mastering and cutting.

This mastering difference is also present on digital sources as in the example below between the 1984 CD and the 1994 remastered CD. The yellow zone showing the accentuation of the top of the spectrum for the CD of 1994.

Concerning the DR, no bad surprise, except for the CD layer of the SACD of 2003 which is compressed in dynamics and also for the cassettes which are a little less dynamic.
The differences of these spectra are found in the listening with on one side the original versions and on the other side the remastered versions which generally proposes a sound balance a little more clear.
But, we must not forget that this album was also mixed in 4.0 at the origin, mix used during the concerts. To find this atmosphere, the SQ encoded vinyls allow to hear the 4.0 mix as in the 70's, the decoded SQ vinyl samples are available for listening.
The 4.0 version of the bluray brings a more precise version because directly from tapes, no SQ decoding as on vinyl and allows to obtain a more precise spatial distribution.
The 5.1 mix of the SACD and Blu-ray bring a more homogeneous spatialization, which immerses us totally in the music compared to the 4.0 version.

To listen to the different versions to make your own idea, you can find the extracts in stereo, 4.0, SQ decoded, 5.1 Here, as well as all the measurements.
Enjoy listening.
r/SurroundAudiophile • u/Media6292 • Dec 21 '25
Review (Recordings) Best Albums of 2025 reviewed in Digital, Analog, and Immersive (Dolby Atmos) Formats.
Hello,
The end of the year is a good time to ask the question:
Which albums delivered the best technical performance among those I tested on MagicVinylDigital.net in 2025?
2025 was a particularly rich year for album releases, both in terms of brand-new productions and anniversary editions. It was also marked by a noticeable increase in Blu-ray releases featuring Dolby Atmos versions, along with several high-quality stereo tracks.
Below is a selection of the top albums from a purely technical standpoint, without taking artistic considerations into account, across three categories: Digital, Analog, and Dolby Atmos (TrueHD and Dolby Digital Plus).
The best digital editions of 2025:
Miles Davis – Birth of the Blue : Hybrid SACD produced by Analogue Production. The soundstage is very realistic, transporting the listener into the atmosphere of the original recording sessions.
Simon & Garfunkel – Bookends : SACD MOFI versions. The sound is very clean, precise and natural. The mastering is the most balanced and closer to the spirit of the original version than the other remastered versions.
Pink Floyd – Wish You Were Here : Bluray Stereo Hi-res and 4.0 version. This version is the clearest and most precise in the low frequencies of all editions since the 1984 CD. Its tonal balance is closer to the current sound standard than that of the 1975 vinyl version..
REQUESTS – Tsuyoshi Yamamoto Trio LIVE : SACD non-hybrid disc version. The SACD version offers a remarkably natural sound experience, highlighting each instrument with great finesse. Spatialization is faithful to the microphone layout used during recording, allowing total immersion in the work..
Max Richter – Sleep Circle : Tidal Max version. A very beautiful sound reproduction that immerses us in the concert experience. The rendering is precise, with well-controlled bass that provide solid support and add a wonderful depth to the music.
The best analog editions of 2025:
This category covers analog formats, with the master being either analog or digital.
Miles Davis – Birth of the Blue : Vinyl record AAA. Analogue Production has produced a superb vinyl edition of these four tracks from Birth Of Blue. The quality of the pressing is excellent, with very little surface noise, enabling a fine, dynamic reproduction of this iconic album.
Vivaldi – The Four Seasons : One Step vinyl record.This One Step edition stands out for its very low distortion level, as revealed by the spectrogram analysis. Deeper bass give more substance to the sound reproduction.
Miles Davis – Kind of blue : Analog Production Speed corrected vinyl AAA version. It delivers an excellent sound quality and, above all, a significantly lower acquisition cost, offering great value for money for those who prefer not to invest in the expensive UHQR editions.
REQUESTS – Tsuyoshi Yamamoto Trio LIVE : Vinyl record double album version. This vinyl record benefits from high-quality cutting and lacquer pressing, as well as mastering that restores all the nuances and subtleties of the recording.
Prince – Purple Rain : One Step vinyl record version. This version as a new benchmark for vinyl reissue : it captures all the energy of the album with a sound balance faithful to the original, offering great clarity and remarkable precision in both instruments and vocals.
The best Dolby Atmos editions of 2025 :
What truly sets an excellent Dolby Atmos mix apart?
For some, it’s the way the channels are used; for others, the coherence of the spatialization; for others still, the realism of the rendering, or the quality in terms of spatial definition and precision.
The definition and precision of spatialization depend above all on the format used. We therefore distinguish two categories: streaming versions (in Dolby Digital Plus “DDP” format) and Blu-ray versions (in Dolby Digital TrueHD format).
The ranking will be based on the overall appreciation of the mix in relation to the musical style, taking into account criteria as varied as the realism, atmosphere, and originality of the Dolby Atmos mix.
This year saw a very significant number of Blu-ray releases featuring Dolby Atmos TrueHD tracks, with many high-quality Dolby Atmos mixes. The Top 5 is therefore expanded to a Top 6 for Blu-ray editions.
The best Dolby Atmos “TrueHD” editions of 2025 :
Trio Callas – Mozart_Brahms_Mehmari : MKV Atmos and 5.1.4 versions. ADS presents a beautiful album that immerses the listener fully in the heart of the music. The 5.0.4 recording places the listener at the center of the trio.
Steven Wilson – The overview : Blu-ray Dolby Atmos version. Conceived and designed for spatial rendering, the Dolby Atmos version of the blu-ray is the reference for this album, immersing us in a 360-degree sound universe.
Pink Floyd – Live at Pompeii – MCMLXXII : Steven Wilson’s new Blu-ray Dolby Atmos mix brings a whole new dimension to the concert, plunging the listener right into the heart of the music. The open sky and ancient ruins are not only visually evocative, they are now sonically present, reinforcing the introspective, psychedelic essence of the performance.
Prince – Purple Rain : Blu-ray Dolby Atmos version. Very fine mixing work on this mythical album, perfectly exploiting the possibilities of space sound while respecting each track.
Bob Reynolds Group – Live In Munich : Blu-ray Dolby Atmos version.Bob Reynolds and IAN Records have fully achieved their goal: to offer us the experience of listening to the music as if we were right inside the concert hall, thanks to the Dolby Atmos version of the Blu-ray.
Frankie Goes To Hollywood – Welcome To The Pleasuredome : Blu-ray Dolby Atmos version. Steven Wilson delivers a new reference Dolby Atmos mix for this Frankie Goes To Hollywood album. The mix makes perfect use of spatialization and the immersive potential of the format, with sounds distributed throughout the entire space and subtle movement of certain instruments. Also available in Dolby Digital TrueHD on blu-ray SDE.
The best Dolby Atmos “DDP” editions of 2025 :
Justin Gray – Immersed : Dolby Atmos version.The listener is completely immersed in the heart of the music, thanks to the spatial distribution of the instruments, which makes each track fully immersive. It is a true demonstration of immersive sound.
An Immersive Tribute to Astor Piazzolla (Live) : Dolby Atmos version. If I told you that you’ll be immersed right in the heart of the music, with a lively, dynamic, and surprising sound? It’s an original and unexpected experience for this musical style.
Éric Serra : first two tracks of his new album SPACE PROJEKT U.M.O. : Dolby Atmos version.The music surrounds us completely, filling the soundscape with a precise spatial distribution of sounds. Soyooz Night is particularly illustrative of this effect, enhanced by deep bass that adds a physical dimension to the experience.
Tears For Fears – Song from the Big Chair : Dolby Atmos version. With this Dolby Atmos remix of Songs from the Big Chair, Steven Wilson succeeds in sublimating the original work while offering exceptional sonic immersion. Each song benefits from precise, harmonious spatial rendering, making full use of the audio channels for a natural distribution of instruments. Available on blu-ray SDE (review comming soon).
An initiative worth following.
I would also like to particularly highlight the initiative of this independent musician and sound engineer, JAFF, who makes available two distinct digital versions for his album TRAVELLING : a standard digital version and a digital master derived from the vinyl master, offering greater dynamic range.
This is an approach that would benefit from being extended to all modern productions, provided, however, that masters intended for vinyl are no longer based on excessively dynamic-compressed versions, a practice that has unfortunately become very common. But let us keep hope alive.
Enjoy listening,
Jean-François