TLDR: I've been seeing an experienced Dom for a week, and we've moved quickly into exploring a potential D/s dynamic. I'm having a genuinely great time, feel respected, and want to continue. However, I can't verify his identity or professional background, and the STI results didn't have his name. He knows my real name, address, and other personal info. I understand his desire for privacy, but I need more transparency to feel safe. I'm considering asking for references and pausing play until we establish more mutual trust. Is that reasonable, and how would you approach it?
--------
I met someone about a week ago, and things have unfolded VERY quickly. We met for coffee, and two days later, he came over to my place and we had a short introductory scene. We've continued talking and exploring the possibility of developing a D/s dynamic.
For context, I'm not new to BDSM, but I haven't been in a formal dynamic before. I understand SSC/ RACK, can communicate my hard and soft limits, and can express when something is or isn't working for me. He says he has 25+ years of experience and has a 3-step phasing process for how he approaches vetting. He's been giving me some direction via text around things like using honorifics/expressing desire and I'm REALLY into it.
There are a lot of things about our interactions that have made me feel comfortable. He hasn't pressured me into anything. He's consistently double and triple checked whether things are a green light and whether I'm enthusiastically consenting. When I've expressed discomfort or a boundary, he's been respectful, receptive, and reassuring. He encourages me to talk with my friends about what we're exploring, so there's no expectation of secrecy. He's also shared his philosophical and personal worldviews pretty openly, and, almost strangely, align with mine in a lot of ways.
I'm having a genuinely wonderful time. I feel excited, curious, and sexually empowered. I really want to keep exploring with him.
But I can't independently verify who he is.
He gave me a generic name which I worry is a pseudonym. He describes himself as a high-level executive, owns two side businesses, has studied internationally, and has worked in different parts of the world. But I don't know the names of his companies, I don't have his actual phone number (we use Telegram) and when he shared his STI results, his name wasn't on the report.
Meanwhile, he knows my real name, where I live, my professional and academic background, and quite a bit about my personal life. I'm fairly easy to find through public records and my digital footprint. He's been inside my home, and we've already engaged in play.
I understand that privacy and discretion are especially important in the lifestyle. He's also shared a traumatic experience with legal involvement where a former sub threatened to out him to his company, so I understand why he might be extra protective of his identity. (Which could also be made-up, I know...)
I don't need or want unrestricted access to his life, but I do need ENOUGH information to establish that he is who he says he is.
I'd like to ask for references. I'd also like to have a more direct conversation about identity verification and mutual transparency. In the meantime, I think I need to pause further play until I feel comfortable.
Here's where I'm struggling:
Please don't shame me for moving quickly and, perhaps, recklessly. We both have experience with kink, we were mutually enthusiastic, and I made conscious decisions about what I wanted to participate in. I don't regret the experience, and he didn't pressure me. I genuinely feel comfortable when we're together.
But I'm recognizing that feeling comfortable WITH him and having enough information to trust who he says he is are two different things. Trust but verify, ya know?
I'm scared that bringing this up will cause the whole thing to end, and I don't want that. I'm having a shit ton of fun, I think our proclivities align, and I'm genuinely excited to explore. But I also know I shouldn't ignore something that matters to my safety.
For those with experience with vetting:
- How do you navigate vetting and discretion when getting involved with someone who wants to maintain a private or anonymous identity?
- Am I overlooking something about how this typically works in the kink community?
- How would you approach this conversation without making it accusatory?
I hate feeling distrustful but I can't ignore my gut. I don't want to be suspicious that he's misrepresenting himself. I genuinely want to keep exploring with him. I just need more information about him to feel better about moving forward.