r/StrangeNewWorlds • u/Allansfirebird • 2h ago
r/StrangeNewWorlds • u/AutoModerator • Sep 23 '26
Episode Discussion Episode Discussion: 410, "Tomorrow's Enterprise"
This thread is for pre, live, and post discussion of the Star Trek: Strange New Worlds episode, "Tomorrow's Enterprise." Episode 410 will be released on Thursday, September 24.
Expectations, thoughts, and reactions to the episodes should go into the comment section of this post. While we ask for general impressions to remain in this thread, users are of course welcome to make new posts for anything specific they wish to discuss or highlight (e.g., a character moment, a special scene, or a new fan theory).
Want to relive past discussions? Take a look at our episode discussion archive!
Other things to keep in mind before posting:
This subreddit does not enforce a spoiler policy. Please be aware that redditors are allowed to discuss interviews, promotional materials, and even leaks in this comment section and elsewhere on the sub. You may encounter spoilers, even for future developments of the series.
Discussing piracy is against our rules.
While not all comments need to be positive, our regular rules and guidelines do apply to this thread. That means critiques must be written in a way that is both constructive and provokes meaningful discussion.
We want this subreddit to be focused on Strange New Worlds - not negative feelings about other shows or the fandom itself. Please keep comments on topic.
r/StrangeNewWorlds • u/AutoModerator • Jul 15 '26
Message from the Mods Reminder: this is a spoiler-friendly subreddit
With the advent of new episodes on July 23, we thought it would be a good time to once again remind new subscribers that they will encounter spoilers on this subreddit.
Our subreddit has NOT opted into r/all or r/popular. That means its posts will not show up in those feeds. We have intentionally done this because we know our spoiler policy is not the norm on Reddit, and we do not want to catch individuals unaware.
The only way you will be spoiled by our subreddit is if you choose to subscribe to it, or if you manually visit it before you have seen the latest episodes.
As stated in our rules, welcome message, and sidebar, this community is aimed at individuals who plan on staying up to date on SNW and/or don't mind spoilers.
If you can't watch the new episodes as they're released, unsubscribing for a time is a perfectly understandable option. (Just don't forget to come back when you're caught up!)
TL;DR of our spoiler-friendly guidelines:
Expect spoilers about past, current, and upcoming content.
Spoilers will appear in both post titles and comment sections in this subreddit.
Both spoiler flairs and spoiler tags have been disabled to avoid giving new users the impression that this is a spoiler-safe place.
We ask users to subscribe at their own discretion.
If you have any questions or concerns about this post or any of our other guidelines, please send us a modmail.
LLAP, the r/StrangeNewWorlds mod team đ
PS: And while we're at it, there are other subs in our network you may enjoy if you like it here:
r/ClassicTrek (for discussion of TOS, TAS, TNG, DS9, VOY, ENT, and all the films)
r/StrangeNewWorlds • u/JustinCaseyBlewit • 7h ago
In Kirk We Trust: Rewatching SNW 1.10 âA Quality of Mercyâ
The strangest thing about âA Quality of Mercyâ is that I watched it when it first aired five years ago but remembered so little about it. This is the kind of episode that is made for fans. It features Captain Christopher Pike flashfowarding to an alternate future in which he is still in command of the Enterprise and relives (or lives, perhaps) one of Star Trek: The Original Seriesâ (TOS) defining episodes, âBalance of Terror.â The foregone conclusion of âA Quality of Mercyâ ending badly negates almost any surprise it has in store. Perhaps the biggest surprise is how badly Pike screws up while living the life of another Enterprise captain.
After encountering a child destined to become one of the doomed cadets in the accident that leaves Pike disfigured and confined to the beep chair, he becomes obsessed with trying to cheat fate. As he drafts a letter to warn the child away from joining Starfleet, Pike receives an unexpected visitorâhimself. Or rather, himself from several years in the future: hale and hearty and now an admiral. The elder Pike warns that if Chris proceeds along this path, he will cause irreparable damage to the future. He produces a time crystal so the younger Pike can see for himself.
What follows is a near blow-by-blow account of âBalance of Terrorâ with Pike assuming the role of his successor, Captain James T. Kirk. The flashforward even begins that the same way, with the captain officiating at a wedding that is interrupted by news of a mysterious ship destroying Starfleet outposts near the Romulan neutral zone. We are reminded that it has been 100 years since the Romulans and Earth reached an uneasy truce following a devastating war and that no one in the Federation has seen a Romulan.
Pike also finds his crew much changed. Spock is his first officer (going by the title âNumber One,â which Kirk never called him) while his previous X-O, Una Chin-Riley, is nowhere to be found. Erica Ortegas and Jenna Mitchell still operate the helm and navigator positions, though they have switched places, and Erica assumes the belligerent, warmongering stance adopted by Lt. Stiles in the original episode. Pike holds out for a peaceful solution, even after an outpost is obliterated before his eyes.
It would have been an interesting thought experiment if the episode had proceeded along the lines of Pike stepping into Kirkâs shoes and trying to figure out what he should do differently. However, the episode complicates matters by bringing in James T. Kirk, who, in this timeline, is captain of the USS Farragut and arrives to lend a hand. I much admire Paul Wesleyâs take on Kirkâhe captures the assertive energy that William Shatner brought to the role yet makes it his own. However, Pike canât help but look weak in comparison. Despite his crewâs protests that the Romulan ship has already destroyed several outposts and killed many people, Pike clings to the idea that they can find a peaceful solution. It sounds trite when he lectures the Romulan commander and praetor that no one wants a war. Clearly, some do.
The episode comes across as an indictment of Star Trekâs philosophy that our enemies are not really bad guysâwe just have to look at things from their point of view. TOS made this claim in several brilliant episodes, including âArenaâ and âThe Devil in the Dark,â but âBalance of Terrorâ was not one of them. In that episode, Kirk engaged in a cat-and-mouse game with an enemy who showed no mercy toward civilians. Even in this episode, it is stated and restated that Romulans view peace as a sign of weakness. Pike looks like a fool for not recognizing what is right before his eyes. Kirk even lectures Pike on this after the hostilities are over, but by then it is too late.
Making the hero appear weak before the hero of another series is not a good look on the show. To make matters worse, most of the regular SNW crew are sidelined to feature Kirk. As mentioned, Una is nowhere to be seen (and we find out why when Pike returns to his own timeline). LaâAn appears briefly as Kirkâs first officer of the Farragut, and MâBenga and Chapel show up in minor roles. Uhura occupies her usual station on the bridge but has little else to do. (In the original episode, she took over the navigatorâs stationâa famous nod to TOSâs 1960s progressivismâbut this is apparently redundant with two women already occupying the front positions.)
However, it is Spock who becomes the most important aspect of the episode. By the end of the conflict, he is crippled, disfigured, and in a vegetative stateâmuch like the fate reserved for Pike in the original timeline. His fate, we are told, has enormous repercussions for the future. As the older Pike says, Spock âhas things to doââspecifically to broker lasting peace between the Federation and the Romulans, as shown in Star Trek: The Next Generation.
Such nods to continuity can be fun for fans (Scotty is even heard but not seen except for his arm). And, although I count myself a fan, I find it distracting when such nods get in the way of telling a story. âA Quality of Mercyâ strives too faithfully to reproduce the story beats of the originalâdown to all eyes being on Spock when the crew gets its first look at Romulans as well as the Romulan commander saying that in another universe, he and Pike/Kirk could have been friends right before committing suicide. Furthermore, the latter beat is unearned. Whereas Kirk had earned the commanderâs respect after besting him in battle, what has Pike done to merit such sentiment? Commit both of their peoples to several decades of war by showing weakness?
And, in the end, what does Pike learn? That he canât change his fate? That he must simply accept the dire future that awaits him and the cadets involved in his accident? SNW as a whole seems to rely on a fatalistic philosophy that one cannot change the future and that trying to do will make things worse (see, for example, the Season Four opener, âValles Marinerisâ). Perhaps such a philosophy is intentional, but it differs from the optimistic future Star Trek has always depicted. Even in TOS âThe City on the Edge of Forever,â Kirk has to make a painful choice by allowing the woman he loves to die to protect the timeline he knows. Pike, too often, stands by and does nothing.
For good measure, I happened to watch âMatters of Honor,â the Season 3 opener of Babylon 5, right after watching this episode. The contrast between Pike and Captain John Sheridan is stark. Faced with an overwhelming enemy, Sheridan figures out what the enemy doesnât know and bluffs his way to victory. Pike could have used some of Sheridanâs guile, or, for that matter, Kirkâs.
Odds and Ends:
In an apparent continuity error, the young Cadet Uhura is shown on the bridge when Pike returns to his own timeline. However, her training rotation supposedly ended in the previous episode.
In the original TOS episode, it is the groom, Robert Tomlinson, who dies in battle. In the alternate timeline, Tomlinson survives, but his bride, Angela Martine, dies. (The characters are not named in âA Quality of Mercy.â)
Check out this post on Substack: https://greggildersleeve.substack.com/p/in-kirk-we-trust-rewatching-snw-110
r/StrangeNewWorlds • u/Current_Frosting3859 • 1d ago
Scotty is missing a finger.
reddit.comCan we see an explanation of that in the next season of Strange New Worlds?
r/StrangeNewWorlds • u/Geaux • 3d ago
Meme/Joke Season 4,Episode 9's Reference to The Princess Bride
I thought it was super clever that they had Pelia, played by Carol Kane, compliment Queen Neve's chef, Max, by calling him a "Miracle Worker".
Miracle Max was a character played by Billy Crystal in The Princess Bride, who was married to Valerie, who was played by Carol Kane!
I just thought this was a wonderful little Easter egg.
r/StrangeNewWorlds • u/Spirited-Assist-4680 • 4d ago
Interview Matthew Cushman, Orville and Star Trek Cutaway Artist, Visits the Commanderâs Chair!
r/StrangeNewWorlds • u/JustDavid89 • 4d ago
Completely New
Hi all,
Iâve never watched Star Trek but I feel it could be something for me. I know that the series from 30 odd years ago are probably considered superior but is Strange New Worlds worth dipping my toes into?
r/StrangeNewWorlds • u/rolodexlexia • 4d ago
Batman: Why Ethan Peck Should Don the Cowl in the DCU
Most Den of Geek readers know Ethan Peck as Spock from Star Trek: Strange New Worlds. And even if the quality of that show has diminished over recent seasons, no one can deny that Peck does justice to Leonard Nimoyâs character in the way he plays a stoic outsider. What readers may not know is that, in interviews, Peck is all charisma and charm. Furthermore, he is a blue blood as well, the grandson of respected screen legend Gregory Peck. Together, that means Peck could believably play a millionaire playboy born of privilege and a brooding grouch who has no patience for the shenanigans happening around him.
r/StrangeNewWorlds • u/OddSetting5077 • 5d ago
General Discussion Star Trek Strange New World crew are alway wearing their uniforms
Unless it's an episode that involves hijinks, or leaving the ship, the crew is in uniform..in their quarters, in the bar, playing poker, in sick bay.
When Captain Pike cooks for them, they are all in uniform.
Just an observation of season 4. Prior star trek shows, the crew were shown in casual clothing
r/StrangeNewWorlds • u/NoEntertainment8100 • 5d ago
Meme/Joke "There's no such thing as Scottytoberfest."
r/StrangeNewWorlds • u/4evrAnarchy • 4d ago
Cast/Crew Anybody else think Nurse chapel is out of pocket for what she did to Spok?
Like, dude, his feelings for her helped ruin his relationship with TâPring, who was a super solid ride-or-die. And I believe If he wasn't so excited to tell Chapel they had split (which is kinda screwed up) he would've out more effort forth to patch things up. She was absolutely wifey material. And she just said they needed time apart not that they should end their relationship completely. I'm absolutely #teamTâPring. And when Spock gets serious about their relationship, she pulls the super childish and hella petty âI don't do complicated bullshit.â I can't stand people like that. I swear she did it just so she could have that âI conquered a Vulcan mentality.â It's just hella dirty, in my opinion. I really can't stand her after that. Then she pulls up after 3 months, talking about marrying some nerd she met on her supposed âtime apartâ excuse. As soon as she said that, I knew she had been playing Spock the whole time. Yeah, sorry, rant over. I can't stand chicks like that. And now I have to see one every time I watch the show. And then, to top it all off, they write Laâan and Spock having some sort of FWB deal??!! What the hell happened to Laâan and Kirk?!?! I swear they did it to take our minds off how much of a [censored] chapel was for what she did to him. đĄđ¤Ź well I guess I wasn't done just yet. But yea screw nurse chapel. Least favorite character after that.
r/StrangeNewWorlds • u/Allansfirebird • 6d ago
Fan Art A couple more SNW/anime crossover illustrations I did this weekendâŚ
r/StrangeNewWorlds • u/doctorj2u • 7d ago
The importance of Star Trek
I donât know if this link will stay because every time I link a source it is not community approved so I just stopped trying. But this link to me is the core of what Star Trek means to me. What an amazing woman! I understand though. I grew up in New Orleans at the same age as Ruby Bridges and desegregation. I am white and was raised in a racist household. It was Star Trek and its teachings that taught me ideals that helped me break the chain. Also I was raised in a time that any woman could only aim to be a wife, secretary, nurse or teacher. I became a dentist and am now retired after 35 years. Star Trek has had a beautiful effect on the world.
r/StrangeNewWorlds • u/Trekfan74 • 7d ago
Paul Wesley will star in a new TV show!
It's a Netflix show called Icebreakers and based on a popular book. He plays a hockey coach. Good to see him finding a lead in another show so fast. It starts shooting in Vancouver soon but no premiere date yet. But based on most production phases for streaming shows and Netflix a typical show takes around 7 months to shoot and probably won't come out for at least a year.
I really hope to see others in that cast land other TV or movie roles sooner than later. They all deserve it.
r/StrangeNewWorlds • u/JustinCaseyBlewit • 7d ago
Star Trek Does Alien: Rewatch of SNW 1.9 "All Those Who Wander"
The first part of SNW 1.9 feels like a classic TOS or TNG episode: The crew gathers for a farewell party. By the end, the episode has transformed into a monster-of-the-week trope that, though well done, left me wanting more.
The party in question is to bid farewell to Cadets Uhura and the so-far unseen Chia as their training rotation ends. Ensign Duke, also previously unseen, gets promoted. Uhura hangs back from the festivities, not wanting to get involved with shipmates she may never see again. Itâs a good setup and shows how Pikeâs captaincy differs from Kirkâs: He cooks for the crew and treats them like family. They are so much like family that they help clean up while discussing a new mission. Spock in an apron provides levity.
The joyous occasion ends abruptly when the Enterprise is diverted from its current mission to a new one. Pike decides there is manpower and talent to spare, so he sends the Enterprise, under Unaâs command, to complete one mission while he leads an away team to investigate the other: Finding the USS Peregrine, which has lost contact after sending out a distress beacon. . . .
Things turn sour when the crew locates the Peregrine, which has landed in the snow, jutting out of the ground like the Titanic perched out from an iceberg. Iâm not going to worry about the logistics of this happening. I didnât know starships could land. My only frame of reference is Star Trek Generations, in which the Enterprise-D breaks apart when it crashes on the surface of a planet. What matters is that the crew of 99 is missing. However, two passengers have survived: a human girl named Oriana and an alien of unknown origin called Buckley.
Oriana gives the Enterprise team the bad news: The crew of the Peregrin were killed by the Gorn.
Yes, the Gorn again.
And the Gorn are still aboard the Peregrin, infecting people and bursting forth from them when their eggs hatch.
From that point on, the episode becomes a by-the-books horror film with the Enterprise crew racing to defeat the Gorn. They donât have many creatures to worry about, though. It turns out the Gorn hatchlings kill each other until one is leftâthe alpha.
According to Memory Alpha, writer Davy Perez said the episode was influenced by monster films such as Alien, and Predator, and it shows. It is not a bad episode. It accomplishes exactly what it set out to do: Send the Enterprise crew out to fight a monster. If thatâs all the episode was designed to deliver, it succeeded. . . .
But earlier generations of Star Trek shows have spoiled me into expecting more from the franchise. âArenaâ--the TOS episode that introduced the Gorn--portrayed them as a space-faring, belligerent race that was protecting its territory. It is difficult to reconcile that depiction with the one shown here of a monstrous, sub-intelligent species that exists only to kill. . . .
âAll Those Who Wanderâ is most memorable for the demise of Lt. Hemmer, the blind chief engineer, who, in his few appearances, endeared himself to many fans. Hemmer was an example of Star Trek using its commitment to diversity in positive and subtle ways instead of the more overt ways that often derailed Star Trek: Discovery. Hemmerâs sightlessness is a feature of his race, not a disability, and his portrayal by a blind actor, Bruce Horak, added authenticity. In this episode, no mention is made of his blindness. He is treated, refreshingly, as any other crewmember. . . .
Hemmerâs demise so early on removed one of SNWâs most engaging and original characters. If he had been allowed to develop across a season or two, his death might have had more impact. . . .
As the penultimate episode in SNWâs first season, âAll Those Who Wanderâ delivers an action-packed horror tale. It is good for what it is. I just wish it had aspired to be more.
Check out the full post on my Substack: https://greggildersleeve.substack.com/p/star-trek-does-alien-rewatch-of-snw
r/StrangeNewWorlds • u/short_beefstock • 7d ago
Question Anyone else "feeling" the 60th?
reddit.comr/StrangeNewWorlds • u/OverzealousOwl • 7d ago
General Discussion Most Gut Wrenching Moment Of SNW
reddit.comr/StrangeNewWorlds • u/rolodexlexia • 10d ago
Star Trek w/ Ethan Peck | Game Knights 89 | Magic: The Gathering Commander Gameplay MTG EDH
r/StrangeNewWorlds • u/JustinCaseyBlewit • 9d ago
Social Media Strange New Posts: Introduction to My New ST Substack
2026 has not been kind to Star Trek fans. In what should be a gala celebration of the franchiseâs 60th anniversary, we have witnessed the impending cancellations of the two remaining Star Trek series, Strange New Worlds (SNW) and Starfleet Academy (SFA), uncertainty over the future of our beloved franchise, and the deaths of two beloved actors, Walter Koenig and Patrick Stewart, mere days apart. So why start a Substack devoted to Star Trek, especially one that, for now, focuses on the early days of Strange New Worlds, a series that, as it winds down, has proven divisive among fans?
Itâs precisely because this year reflects a turning point for Star Trek that itâs worth looking back to see where weâve been and how far weâve come.
SNW debuted in March 2021 as the 11th Star Trek series and the first spin-off of Star Trek: Discovery (DISC), the series that relaunched the franchise as an ongoing television series. For context, DISC, launched in 2017, was the first Star Trek series since the cancellation of Star Trek: Enterprise 12 years earlier. In between, there were three J.J. Abrams-directed moviesâStar Trek (2009), Star Trek Into Darkness (2013), and Star Trek Beyond (2016) âwhich showed the powers that be that the franchise could still be profitable. And, for a time, DISC and SNW lived up to that potential. It was cool to be a Trekkie again.
SNW was launched with a lot of build-up; the entire second season of DISC served as a âback-door pilot,â reintroducing Captain Christopher Pikeâthe Enterpriseâs commanding officer from the original 1964 Star Trek pilot, âThe Cage.â A major storyline featured a young Spock struggling with his half-human, half-Vulcan identity. When the plot lines continued into SNW, the new show was promised as a prequel to Star Trek: The Original Series (TOS), set only a few years before James T. Kirk assumed command and before Pikeâs horrific accident that would leave him disfigured, mute, and crippled.
For long-time Star Trek fans, SNW promised to fill in the gaps between âThe Cage,â set in 2254, and the first season of TOS, set in the 2260s. For fans who dig this kind of future history, SNW would tell us more about the young Spock, Pike, and the mysterious first officer, Number One (who wasnât even given a name in âThe Cageâ). For newer fans, it promised a continuation of the exciting DISC-style adventures that had breathed new life into the franchise and its multi-generational appeal.
In short, SNW promised a lot of things it has struggled to deliver.
That isnât to say the show is a failure, but it has certainly differed from what many fans expected (puppets, really?). At itâs best, SNW is a fun and entertaining show that uses Star Trek tropes loosely. At its worst, it tries too hard to please fans through callbacks and memberberries (the Gorn, Trelane, Scotty, the increasing involvment of Jim Kirk) as if to say the only purpose of the show is to set the stage for TOS. The 10th episode of Season Four was even a flashforward to Kirkâs tenure as captain of the Enterprise.
Fans have criticized SNW for failing to establish its own identity and to develop most of its lead characters. Pike and Una (Number One) have in particular taken a back seat to Spockâs love life and LaâAnâs worries about turning into an augment. Some of the showâs best ideas and characters, such as Hemmer, have been quickly resolved and discarded in favor of genre-hopping stories and outright silliness. (Pelia, who started out as a fairly serious character with the inspired casting of Carol Kane, quickly degenerated into a joke with a thick accent and Doctor Who references. The character became so superfluous that she was written out off-screen in Season Four. Contrast that to Hemmerâs memorable demise in Season One.)
The overall feel of the show is more of a country club than a paramilitary starship exploring strange new worlds. Pike addresses his bridge crew by their first names and often comes across as too casual even in deadly situations. I do not believe this is the fault of actor Anson Mount. He delivered an inspiring performance as temporary captain of the Discovery during Season Two of that series. But in an attempt to highlight the lighter aspects of Star Trek, the writers too often veer in that direction.
Yet I did not start this blog to rag on SNW. My goal is to simply review it through a critical eye, to discover what worked and what could be improved. Who knows? Maybe I missed something along the way. Maybe time will ripen the show into something to be appreciated and even lovedâas happened to its forebear, TOS, which built a following in reruns after its third season cancellation.
While my focus is on SNW, the blog is not restricted to it. I plan to discuss Star Trek in a broader context and even include some nerdy and fun stuff. Because I view this blog as more of historical record than a proper review channel, I make no effort to hide spoilers. If you havenât seen the episodes in question, proceed with caution. At present, two posts per week will appear, and I may occasionally discuss other topics, such as my recent post on when writing becomes easier. (Spoiler: Never.)
If you like this content, please subscribe or hit the Buy Me a Coffee button (which Iâm tempted to change to Buy Me a Beer or, in keeping with the ST theme, Buy Me a Chech'tluth). Subscriptions and donations help this blog, and your support is welcome.
The future is just beginning.
Check out this post on my Substack: https://greggildersleeve.substack.com/p/strange-new-posts-an-introduction