r/StrangeNewWorlds • • Sep 11 '23

Will I miss anything important if I skip Subspace Rhapsody?

0 Upvotes

I really dislike musical episodes. I dont know why but I cringe when they start singing. Fast forwarding is tough because I have no idea when they will start or end. Anyway, does anything major happen in this episode or am I safe to skip it?


r/StrangeNewWorlds • • Sep 02 '25

Love the Show But Two Complaints - Am I Alone?

0 Upvotes

Nothing is perfect (except for Aliens, The Expanse, Arrival, the Murderbot stories, Firefly and Captain Picard - the character…..but I digress), I love the show, love the characters, however, two episodes/scenes took me out of the moment.

  1. The fighting/dance scene - I never saw the chemistry between those two and I like them both. But that scene was next-level ewwww. It looked like a Star Trek version of a bad romance novel. Yes, I fast forwarded through it to avoid the feeling of embarrassment.

  2. The Holodeck episode. MOST of the actors were AMAZING. I didn’t recognize the Captain for at least the first couple of minutes he was on screen. However, Noonien’s “character” portrayal was painful to watch and she is one of my favorites. Admittedly, years of STNG’s Holodeck episodes may have warped my objectivity. But the hat, the make up, the weird accent….I just needed to vent and know that perhaps ONE person out there may have struggled with these episodes.


r/StrangeNewWorlds • • Sep 13 '25

Anyone else disappointed in season 3?

12 Upvotes

I loved seasons 1 & 2. Thought they were fantastic. But I have to say I've been disappointed with season 3, despite wanting to love it.

The cast members were fantastic, as usual. But the episodes were disappointing. I found that they fell into two categories:

  • Silly, stupid plots that were difficult to watch.

  • Good, solid plots that had poor writing and were anti-climactic.

Anyone else?

EDIT: I asked ChatGPT about what might explain this perceived drop in quality. According to it, the ideas for season 3 were locked in before the 2023 Writers Guild of America strike, but the episodes weren't written until afterwards. So that strike, along with the SAG-AFTRA strike, might have caused a tighter timeframe for production.


r/StrangeNewWorlds • • Aug 11 '25

General Discussion Se3 Ep5; Through The Lens Of Time (is bad)!

0 Upvotes

I hated some of the plot lines in this episode. Spock wants to follow policy, which is literally just to step outside to report back to the ship. Chapel and Korby start losing their minds about following policy. Korby claims Spock isn't in charge, but I believe in this instance he literally is. They make Chapel into essentially a dumb blonde in this moment defending her man, ignoring protocol, and putting the crew in danger in the face of a clear threat risk of being trapped inside. Gets a crew member killed by not stopping him. Picking up a glowing orb that very much looks like a grenade should've been stopped before it even started. And somehow Chapel is made the hero by the end. All without repercussions. What about Ortegas last episode?

Ok, I'm done ranting.


r/StrangeNewWorlds • • Jul 24 '25

Was season 3 episode 3 a crossover episode with Shrek?

Post image
2 Upvotes

All I could think of when I saw No 1 on the bridge. How did no one not notice this?


r/StrangeNewWorlds • • Sep 07 '23

absolutely love Anson Mount but can we all agree..

0 Upvotes

The man can't sing to save his life. It's a valiant effort and I respect what he managed to pull off for 2.9 but it is so obvious he's never done as much as sing in the shower. He can make any facial expression known to man, maybe even some new ones, but if I was his kid and he sang me a lullaby I'd look into eardrum removal.

**Please don't attack me I love this show and everything about it, I just think it's hilarious


r/StrangeNewWorlds • • Sep 20 '25

The wasted potential of Season 3.

1 Upvotes

I liked the beginning; I liked the end; I liked a lot of what they did in-between.

But I feel like it could have been magnificent. They were setting up something that I though would have been far more interesting for Ortegas, and then gave us an average ending. They made a holodeck episode that was overloaded with nostalgia instead of drama. And they gave us a documentary that fell flat.

Just a few tweaks, and you've got an Ortegas B-arc for the whole season.

Let's start with what's there. The trauma in episode 1, the hints at lasting psych damage in episode 2, insubordination in Episode 3, and restoring her to duty in Episode 4. That was logically building not to "Ortegas hangs with a gorn and gets over it"; it's a downwards spiral pattern, reinforced by the fact that when she's punished, she's let off easy because she's good at her job. She can be as insubordinate as she wants because they need her more than she needs them.

So let's reframe a few episodes in the middle and see what we get:

  • A Space Adventure Hour could have been murder mystery game as a way to help Ortegas while she's on suspension. Limit the holodeck to just environments and make it a place where our actual characters interact. No AI trickery, just them trying to use the environment to help Ortegas. And throw in a "tactical simulator" program that looks like TOS ... film it at Ticonderoga and everyone is happy. But Ortegas, while technically fit for duty, does not engage like she used to.

  • Then, This is Starfleet becomes not some pablum documentary about Starfleet, but a deeply personal film about the damage Starfleet has done to his sister. This is the one where Ortegas finally realizes how far gone she is because she sees how her brother sees her. She starts doing therapy.

Thoughts?

  • And then Terrarium remains as it was ... getting past the gorn becomes a major step in her recovery. But not the end.


r/StrangeNewWorlds • • Aug 31 '25

Cheesiness of dialogue

0 Upvotes

Big SNW enjoyer here so not meaning this to spark hate please, but what is with the saccharine / cheesy / YA novel level dialogue in SNW?

One example (spoiler) is when Uhura says to Beto that for a communications officer she “can sometimes… urm.. not be that good.. urm with-“ “communicating?” asks Beto. “Yes, that” says Nyota

It’s budget dialogue, more at home in a kids’ Saved By The Bell-esque programme than some of the nuanced and infinitely more impactful dialogue of the 90s/2000s.

Their romantic banter (which perhaps is what this specific exhange should be compared with) had a bit of spark to it (think Jadzia and Julian or Tom and B’Elanna or Trip and T’Pol or Julian and Garak.)

Not saying that exchange was the most egregious example but really stood out to me as phoned-in.

Or is it just me?


r/StrangeNewWorlds • • Jul 29 '25

What's SNW?

0 Upvotes

...Not much... What's new with you?


r/StrangeNewWorlds • • Sep 17 '26

General Discussion The problem with saying "if you don't like it, don't watch it" regarding New Trek

0 Upvotes

It's a common refrain of late to criticisms about this season of SNW and often coupled with comparisons to older Trek having sillier episodes.
There is a key difference though, and not just the season lengths. Old Trek wasn't paywalled behind a subscription service. It was largely on free, syndicated TV. If you're a Star Trek fan, and you want to watch and more importantly support the franchise in TV form, you have to pay to do it. And when you charge a premium for this sort of content, I think it sort of creates three obligations

  1. An obligation as the show makers to provide something of quality, and not just in terms of production value. In terms of thoughtful and well crafted storytelling, which we know they're capable of.

  2. An obligation as the viewer to actually watch the stuff you're paying for to try to get your money's worth out of it. It's totally understandable to find yourself becoming a bit annoyed when you do that and are not satisfied.

  3. An obligation from everyone to recognise that because this is something people pay for, that gives them more of a right than ever to voice dissatisfaction. That's only fair.

Nobody should be called a bad fan for disliking output from something they like as long as they are not crossing lines into genuine toxicity or abuse to anyone involved in the production or who disagrees with them. Constantly seeing people respond to complaints by suggesting the person hates fun or is miserable or is not a real fan is really disheartening, just like I assume it would be if you were accused of being too easily entertained or a corporate bootlicker for not sharing the complaints. A real fan of something should be willing to criticise its flaws if they really care about it, before a fixable issue becomes an ingrained problem. If you don't share the opinion, that's fine, but telling members of an already niche fanbase to just leave isn't going to do the property any favours.

Edit: This is not a post designed to prompt debate of any episodes of the show. This is about how we treat each other as fans, so please don't waste your time with that.


r/StrangeNewWorlds • • Jun 19 '23

General Discussion Worried After S2E01

8 Upvotes

I love Trek. SNW s01 was my favorite trek since Deep Space 9, full stop.

But this season 2 premiere has me very concerned. It’s like they doubled down on the things i hated about discovery and s1/2 of picard, and tossed the things i loved about SNW s2.

Return to drama for drama sake, no internal logic, flash over substance, and random unnecessary fight scenes with terrible choreography.

I like action king fu flicks but that’s not why I watch trek. I like quippy, non serious dialogue in Marvel films but that’s not what i watch Trek for.

I watch trek for an optimistic look into the future where humans use intelligence, empathy, and creativity to overcome intergalactic diplomatic mine fields and impossible odds.

Get Alex out of the god darned writing room please. His paws and hallmarks are all over this.


r/StrangeNewWorlds • • Jun 21 '23

Character Discussion Too much with the Carol Kane accent. Also phaser nitpick

0 Upvotes

I love the actress and I'm happy to have her join the series. But damn if she isn't just doing "The Carol Kane Accent," the one we all know from Taxi and The Princess Bride and (sorta) from Scrooged and and and...

And she's laying it on thick. It takes me out of the story. You can see her working at it, line by line.

Here's hoping she tempers it over time (like Gabrielle Anwar did with Fiona's Irish accent in Burn Notice).

Also: The false flag faction planned to create a fake Federation ship that would attack, and presumably get destroyed by, the bird of prey. So why were they trading with La'an for handheld Federation weapons?


r/StrangeNewWorlds • • Aug 04 '25

What’s gone wrong with ST:SNW S3?

12 Upvotes

I loved the first two seasons of SNW, in my mind some of the best trek ever but I feel like the first for episodes of S3 have been poor.

The season opener was a weak ending to what was a fabulous story arc started at the end of season 2. The excellent story line was not matched in S3E1. While performances, effects and the score were great, the story was too simple and felt like the Gorn were “defeated” too easily.

Episodes 2 & 3 were ok. Again, the cast, effects and score were great but the stories? I am not fond of them.

And now S3E4. IMO, I’m declaring it the worst episode of trek ever. Unoriginal, boring, a waste of quality actors.

Is it just me or are others disappointed with this season so far?

I am praying for immediate return to the great stories of S1 & S2.


r/StrangeNewWorlds • • Jul 03 '23

Character Discussion Unpopular Opinion: I (Mostly) Don't Like La'an

7 Upvotes

I say mostly, because I did enjoy her bad cop scene in the Enterprise Bingo episode, but in general I dislike the nonstop angst; her constant irritation over how people react to her name (just change it or keep it and accept that people are morons who can't accept that you aren't literally the same person as your ancestor); and the fact that so many plots and subplots revolve around her. And don't even get me started on the, "I'm leaving Starfleet to personally find this orphan girls parents no matter how long it takes" plotline.

When I first saw her it seemed clear that the writers were fans of Drummond (Drummer, not Drummond) from The Expanse and I was excited to learn more about this character, but while I loved Drummond Drummer, La'an is just too one-note, too much, all the time.

Meanwhile, Ortegas can't get anything more than a few one liners and I've yet to catch the name of the other woman at the helm.

Obviously this post will be downvoted like mad, since I see how popular she is here, but I seriously don't understand why this character gets so much screen time and plotlines compared to literally any other character on the show.

Edit: I have a terrible memory and had to correct Drummer's name.


r/StrangeNewWorlds • • Aug 01 '25

Hate me if you must, but...

0 Upvotes

...another lame fake-noir holodeck episode? Really?

This is where Star Trek screenwriters go when they run out of ideas. It's a pity that it's happening so early in Season 3.


r/StrangeNewWorlds • • Jan 28 '26

La'an makes a cameo in starfleet academy

Post image
0 Upvotes

StarfleetAcademy's "Vitus Reflux" briefly features a 29th century TCARS interface during the Temporal Mechanics lesson . This type of interface first appeared on the time ship Relativity in the eponymous StarTrekVOY episode and was also seen in

StarTrekSNW's "Tomorrow and Tomorrow..."


r/StrangeNewWorlds • • Aug 20 '26

I simply couldn’t finish 4.05

0 Upvotes

I’m probably not the ideal candidate for this episode because I’m one of the few people who actually doesn’t like The Muppets 😝 I honestly did try to give this episode a fair go, but once the Orions boarded and began confronting the puppet-crew the joke was already wearing thin, and I switched it off. This is the first episode of SNW which I could not be bothered to finish, in fact it’s probably the first episode of any Trek which I have switched off partway through. And this is coming from somebody who loved the musical episode, although the point has to be made that every song in the musical episode was properly tied to a character and move the plot forward.

Anyway, I do hope this is the last ‘stunt’ or ‘gimmick’ episode and the rest of the season sees something of a reset to what more of us expect from SNW, especially given the episode count is so low to begin with.


r/StrangeNewWorlds • • Sep 07 '26

Could the Q Proctor actually be John de Lancie's Q?

0 Upvotes

After watching Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass, I started wondering whether the Q Proctor might be more than simply another member of the Q Continuum.

Could she actually be the same Q we later know as John de Lancie's Q, appearing in a different form?

I know the simplest explanation is that her appearance is visual shorthand telling us, the audience, "this is a Q." But several details in the episode make me wonder whether the connection is much more specific than that.

  1. The costume is specifically associated with Q's first appearance

The Q Proctor isn't wearing some generic costume associated with the Continuum.

Her clothing very deliberately evokes the judge outfit Q wears in Encounter at Farpoint, when John de Lancie's Q first appears to Picard and puts humanity itself on trial.

That seems like a very specific visual reference.

If the only intention were to communicate "she's a Q," there would be countless ways to do that. Instead, they chose the visual identity associated with the exact moment when Q begins his relationship with humanity.

2. She describes humans as "ants"

This immediately reminded me of the language John de Lancie's Q uses when talking about humans as vastly inferior creatures.

In Qpid, for example, Q refers to Picard's "insect existence." In Hide and Q, he describes the Enterprise as being stuck like an Earth insect in amber.

So when the Q Proctor casually talks about humans as "ants," it feels remarkably familiar.

I'm not claiming that Q constantly uses the literal word "ants" in TNG. The point is the recurring comparison: from his perspective, humans are tiny, primitive creatures — insects.

And the Q Proctor uses exactly that same conceptual language.

3. She doesn't just become interested in humanity — she watches them the way Q does

This may be the detail that really made the theory click for me.

At first, humans are basically insignificant creatures to the Q Proctor.

But as Trelane's experiment unfolds, she becomes emotionally invested in what is happening.

And then we literally see Trelane and the Q Proctor sitting there eating popcorn, watching the human drama like it's entertainment.

That staging feels incredibly Q-like.

In Qpid, after Q throws Picard and his crew into his Robin Hood scenario, the original script specifically describes Q as watching the battle raging around him "with delight."

That is classic Q: create an extraordinary situation for humans, step back, observe how they react, and enjoy the show.

But the Q Proctor then goes one step further.

Near the end, she essentially thanks Trelane for bringing these "ants" to their attention and concludes that humans are actually interesting and worthy of closer observation.

That feels almost like direct foreshadowing of TNG.

The Q we later meet doesn't merely know that humanity exists. He becomes fascinated with us. He tests us, observes us, judges us and repeatedly returns to see what we will do next — particularly through Picard.

So maybe Trelane doesn't merely attract the attention of the Q Continuum.

Maybe Trelane attracts Q's attention.

Could we actually be watching the moment when Q discovers humanity?

4. The chronology of the costume doesn't necessarily disprove it

There is an obvious objection.

Why would the Q Proctor already be wearing the judge outfit during the SNW era if John de Lancie's Q supposedly doesn't choose that appearance until Encounter at Farpoint, more than a century later from humanity's perspective?

But that assumes Q experiences time the way humans do.

And we know he doesn't.

Q moves effortlessly through different points in time, manipulates timelines and experiences events in ways that don't correspond neatly to human chronology. Picard even explicitly warns us against thinking about Q's existence too linearly.

So from Q's point of view, there may be no meaningful contradiction at all.

The Q Proctor wearing that outfit during the SNW era could simultaneously be:

  • a visual clue for us, the audience;

  • a reference to Q's future relationship with humanity from our perspective;

  • and something completely consistent with Q's own nonlinear experience of time.

I'm also not suggesting that all Q are secretly the same being.

The Continuum clearly treats John de Lancie's Q as an individual. He has his own personality, history, reputation, conflicts with other Q, and is repeatedly judged and punished specifically for his own actions.

My theory is much narrower:

What if the Q Proctor is specifically John de Lancie's Q, appearing in another anthropomorphic form?

If so, this episode may be quietly showing us the origin of something we've been watching since 1987:

Q's fascination with humanity.

The judge costume.

The insect/ant language.

Watching human chaos as entertainment.

And finally the realization that these strange little creatures are actually interesting enough to deserve closer observation.

Maybe she's simply another Q and all of this is thematic foreshadowing of Encounter at Farpoint.

That's certainly the safer explanation.

But taken together, these details feel specific enough that I can't shake the possibility that SNW may be hiding something else in plain sight:

The Q Proctor isn't just a Q.

She might be Q.

What do you think?


r/StrangeNewWorlds • • Aug 21 '25

“What is Starfleet?“ The real reason(s) this storyline fell flat.

2 Upvotes

Just got finished washing this episode and it totally fell flat for me…

The main questions (and ones which are often debated in real life mostof the times in military or quasi-military situations):

“What happens if those in the ranks don’t agree with those making the decisions - especially if it contradicts one’s or the groups’ ethical belief systems?”

Should those in the ranks go against their own ethical compasses just to ‘follow orders’ (mutiny) or, should they follow orders unquestionably as they were sworn to do - I guess which a kind of blind faith that those making the decisions are benevolent, and the decisions made are always for the best… Whatever that means.

I am definitely not going to tackle these questions… However, it’s been seen in the Star Trek franchise time and time again with different storylines. The one that most recently comes to mind is in discovery when they use the sentient being to jump without the “permission” of the being (sorry, don’t remember the name of the being and only saw discovery. Eliminate amount of times while on airplanes) I’m not saying this was a star fleet decision, but it was definitely a decision of the discovery crew

So, I understand that not every Star Trek episode has to be novel… But, for me, because, of course, there is no answer to this question… I’ve lost my interest.

Also, in the end of this episode, seemingly, Starfleet made the “right” decision in the minds of the crew and, we, the viewers. SF understood the sanctity of other beings and their right to self-determination… And not to be genetically modified/weaponized. OK, nice ending wrap up however it probably would’ve been MUCH MORE interesting If Starfleet did NOT make what the crew considered to be the Correct moral/ ethical decision.

Just my two cents. Nobody else in the household is a trekkie so coming here to vent.

TL/DR: the topic of whether those in the ranks should “ blindly, follow orders” - especially if ethics don’t align… Has been brought up multiple times in Star Trek franchise with more interesting storylines.

Also, the ending of this episode was all wrapped up with a nice little bow … in which Starfleet changed its decision and acted benevolently - so the crew didn’t have to ponder and live with uncomfortable/ heart wrenching ethical questions

= BORING episode

EDA : lastly, if Starfleet didn’t change its mind, it would’ve been interesting to see a story arc next season whereas, the crew has to face the consequences of their actions - finding out what happened to those on the “receiving end” of the Weaponized creature.


r/StrangeNewWorlds • • Jul 20 '25

The original Mitchell has been replaced in this timeline

1 Upvotes

I heard Pike refer to the helm officer as “Mitchell” these last few episodes.

The Gary Mitchell from TOS isn’t on the bridge in this universe. The helms officer there now could either be his sister or some family relation.

I hope they address it with a throwaway line like Kirk asking her “hey, how’s your brother coming along? He got hurt covering my back a few months ago.”


r/StrangeNewWorlds • • Sep 17 '23

General Discussion For a show called "Strange New Worlds", an awful lot of the story happens on the ship

0 Upvotes

Had anyone noticed that the story second season is almost exclusively set in the the ship, in one room (the trial) or literally on the current Earth?

I was expecting Star Gate level of exploration from a show with the title "Strange New Worlds", but instead of that, they only TALK about being explorers while exploring the ships cafeteria...

I am disappointed :-(

EDIT: I have extracted enough salt for my AND my children lifetimes from the comments. Thank you.


r/StrangeNewWorlds • • Aug 21 '25

The love is not cutting it anymore

0 Upvotes

The Only Way To Save Star Trek Is By Abandoning Characters

This video explains it so well.

I love Strange new worlds, I feel like it's the best of Trek, but this new season feels like such a cop out. I waited more than 2 years for it and now they are giving these alternative episodes storylines like side quests, which take over the whole episodes and they lack depth or character developments -


r/StrangeNewWorlds • • Sep 09 '26

They're relying on gimmicks because they don't want to wrestle with canon

0 Upvotes

One of the biggest challenges of doing a prequal is avoiding stepping on and contradicting established lore. That's also very limiting because you may even end up telling a story that opens possibilities that are far more interesting then where the character is pre-written to go.

We know where a lot of the characters are going and the writers seem to have plans on how to get them there, but that leaves limited space to experiment with characters. To put them in situations which will test them. Because it might clash with something in the future.

So because of that, I believe the writers have instead resorted to gimmick episodes because they can play with the characters and not make that development not feel as serious. It's almost like fanfiction AUs where you put all the characters in a different setting like a high school or the recency era and explore how the characters work in that dynamic.


r/StrangeNewWorlds • • Oct 30 '23

Message from the Mods Join us in r/ClassicTrek for TOS, TAS, TNG, DS9, VOY, ENT, and Movie discussions and content!

0 Upvotes

Announcing a new subreddit in our network, r/ClassicTrek!

With the end of Lower Decks' latest season, we're facing months and months without new episodes of Star Trek. Because of that, we're inviting you to stay engaged and keep talking about Trek. In this case, Classic Star Trek.

If you have questions about how the older shows tie into the newer shows, that's a great place to ask. Have an abiding love for those series? Let r/ClassicTrek be your new home. Questions, theories, art, pics, videos, and much more can be found there.

AND we'll be hosting Episode Discussions every Thursday, just like in our subs for modern Trek! Join us for Theme Months such as "Strange Energies," "Klingon-palooza," "Hijinks," "WTF?," "Q-ish," "Damned Kids," "Anomaly of the Week," and many more. The Episode Discussions kick off on November 16 with "First Impressions": the first episodes of each classic series.

Visit r/ClassicTrek and join us! There are 729 episodes and films to talk about. Plenty to pass the time until the return of new episodes ... and beyond.


PS: There are other subs in our network you may enjoy if you like it here:

Thank you.