r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Oct 30 '18

Reminder: Steven Avery is (Very) Dumb

119 Upvotes

It was mentioned by one of Steven's lawyers in the first episode of the first documentary that Steven Avery has an IQ of 70.

I'm not sure if his IQ is that low... but remember when you are watching and thinking about the case that Steven Avery has significantly below average intelligence.

It's hard to tell sometimes because the doc almost always chooses to show him in situations where he is a sympathetic figure making salient remarks. When they play his phone calls from prison, he is chuckling politely with a loved one, or lamenting his innocence and a lack of justice, or demonstrating some understanding of the legal process, or expressing concern for someone else.

But, every once in a while, his stupidity and immaturity shows through, and we get a glimpse of who Steven really is. Like when he brags that he "french kissed" Lynn Hartman upon first meeting her—this is the mind of a 12 year old; it's the sort of thing a 12 year old thinks and brags about.

Some other examples:

  • When Truthers say, for instance, Steven would NEVER be dumb enough to hide Teresa'a vehicle on the Avery property and just cover it with some branches... they are not appreciating just how stupid (i.e. literally low IQ) Avery is. Avery picks a spot that is obscured by brush and trees, in the corner, away from everyone and away from the entrance and his trailer...and hides his dirty deed like a child who stole cookies, not like some seasoned cat burglar who knows all the tricks.

  • When Steven uses *67 to call Teresa before she arrives at the Avery property, it's possible he thinks using *67 will completely eliminate records (or completely hide the source) of the call. Like, even from the cell phone company's records.

  • And the central issue: That Steven wouldn't commit this crime at all because he'd just gotten out of prison and he stood to gain a lot of money from a lawsuit. This really is sound logic... but, again, Steven is really dumb. His history of violence and crime shows he lacks impulse control, a hallmark of low intelligence criminals. It's very true that an INTELLIGENT PERSON would obviously not commit a crime in Steven's circumstances, but he is not a smart guy. (Smart guys don't burn cats alive or run women off the road and force them out of their cars at gunpoint either.)

Steven Avery is not a criminal mastermind. He lacks basic impulse control. He doesn't think things through in a comprehensive way. He is lying like a 12 year old lies—to just not get in trouble. He is playing tic tac toe, not 3D chess.


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Oct 28 '18

The Way I Became Convinced of Guilt (Spoilers) Spoiler

91 Upvotes

Long time lurker, first time poster here. I just wanted to share with you the very simple series of events that took me from on the fence, then being fairly certain that both SA and BD were innocent (and thus appalled by the disgraceful injustice of the incarceration of that poor simple fool, Brendan), to the position I hold now.

Watching the first season of MaM, I found that the information contained therein was murky and inconsistent. Kicking off with the wrongful conviction and subsequent DNA-exhonoration, it felt as though it could be very likely that a biased county LE may 'double down' on Steven, and take perhaps some liberties with their investigation and prosecution for TH's murder. That being said, I was happy in my position that I wasn't entirely sure of guilt or innocence, but I did feel that certain elements of the evidence felt a bit off. I enjoyed reading the various positions of people here on Reddit, but then, naturally, went on with my life with little regard for the case as time passed.

Then season 2 comes out, and I pick up where I left off, with a pretty open mind, ready to see where this new season follow up would take me. I found after a few episodes, it looked as though this wrongful-conviction-terminator of a lawyer was kickin ass and takin names. As the series progressed, I was finding myself more and more in the innocence camp. I felt frustrated with the US Supreme Court, and the injustice of having poor Brendan being held in prison, when 'clearly' the confession had been coerced by some pretty unscrupulous cops!

Then I finished the season. I knew where I stood. I started reading Ken Kratz's book (which is garbage by the way), and saw many people here on Reddit provide links to court transcripts and other evidence not as readily available to me as when I watched season 1 (or perhaps it was, but I just didn't seek it out).

First thing that threw a spanner in my conviction (pardon the pun) was reading through the trial transcripts. When the forensic state witness describes the 2-3 foot presence of blood in the garage (as evidenced by the use of luminol, and then subsequent test of another blood-reacting agent {big long word that starts with p}). I thought to myself "hang on, there's no mention of that in the show?" In fact, I seem to recall the explicit message was that there was conclusive evidence of absolutely no blood being found anywhere (this lack of blood always made me feel funny, as in if there's no blood, how could there have been a violent crime?). Little did I know that the cleaned up remnants of a THREE FOOT CIRCLE OF BLOOD had actually been found AND was part of the original trial.

Then the next push for me was based on the Dassey 'coercion' interview. I found the entire, unedited video on YouTube, and as I was watching it realised that it was giving me a totally different perspective than when I'd seen the edited few minutes on MaM seasons 1 and 2. But the real bombshell for me is THE SECOND BRENDAN VIDEO CONFESSION. Um, what? I had no idea that there was an additional police interview where he talks about his involvement in the murder. Seriously, if it was mentioned in the series, then I must've missed it, but the general consensus is that immediately after the first "confession", Dassey realises what his 'lies' mean, and so starts disputing it from then onwards, but by that time it was 'too late', the cops had managed to 'get him', and he was totally screwed now. That's not the case though, and in his next taped interview, he tells of his involvement in the murder. I do admit that more than half of the things he says "yeah" to are likely lies or mis-truths, but the one thing that seems pretty clear throughout is his involvement in the murder - which takes place in some shape, at some time, involving him in some way (I do still think most of the details he gives are what he thinks they want to hear). His most honest answer, from the second, May 13 2006 interview is when he describes him crying 2 weeks after the murder, because of how bad he felt.

I guess the message I want to give you all is that just because someone believes that these 2 guys are innocent, doesn't mean they're stupid, ignorant, or have any other societal deficiency. I think my story above shows how organic the transition from one side to the other can be. It's more than likely that those people whom you disagree with simply haven't been exposed to the same amount of information/evidence. That's not a flaw, just the result of a series of circumstances. From what I've read on here from both sides, this can get a little personal and some of us perhaps get caught up in the emotional side of things. Hopefully my story helps us to see that we are all seeking the truth, and that in the end we all want justice.


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Oct 10 '18

Welcome to SAIG - new visitors, please read.

80 Upvotes

Hello & welcome to the sub SAIG (Steven Avery Is Guilty).

This subreddit was created for those who came to the conclusion, after Making A Murderer (MaM) aired in Dec 2015, that Steven Avery was factually guilty of the murder of Teresa Halbach in 2005.

Some came to this conclusion quickly, others slowly, and some even thought Avery was innocent until months or a year or two after MaM aired.

What all visitors need to know is Making A Murderer did not show you all the facts of the case, they did not show all the evidence, and they actually manufactured scenes and spliced together snippets from the courtroom testimony with edits that created a fictional narrative to manipulate the viewer into believing everyone was involved in a conspiracy to frame Steven Avery for this heinous murder.

There are lots of resources that have been compiled to help you learn about the real facts of the case.

Join us and we’ll get you started with some quick links and info.



r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Nov 16 '18

Steven Avery Glorified - And it makes me sick.

76 Upvotes

It's one thing that there are so many people out there that have been duped by the the Netflix Show Making a Murderer, but it's another that a vile man like Avery now has a devoted legion of followers.

I don't think his life on the outside has ever matched up to these past years that he's had all this attention whilst on the inside.

I imagine he has funds sent into his prison account from all over the world and he spends most of his day relaxing on his bed reading all of his letters, full of love and support.

I imagine it's very much like having an online girlfriend behind the face of a computer, where you can offer any kind of version of yourself you want. He can play the part of am unfortunate soul, but he's never been one.

In fact, I'd go as far to say that Avery is possibly the biggest Catfish on the planet.

Anybody who knows him in the REAL world, has nothing but negative things to say about the guy.

Imagine being one of those people, drafting letters of support, sending money to a bloke that's not only a murderer, but a thief and a sex offender.

A bloke that has been accused of having sex with a minor, and was charged with the attempted kidnap of a female at gunpoint.

He's also been charged with cruelty to animals and has had numerous call outs from the police for domestic abuse. A man that threatened the life of his children's mother and sent vile death threats from prison via cassette.

Even if you think he's innocent, why would you want to get behind a man like that.

It's absolutely shameful.


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Oct 21 '18

STICKY: Lies in MaM Season 2. Let's start to collect them right here, all in one place.

67 Upvotes

This comment thread will be where you can post lies/mistakes that you find in season 2 of MaM while they are fresh in your mind.

Simply reply to this post and provide a brief description of the error or link to a saig post** where the boo boo is discussed.


**Note that current reddit admin rules for saig and the other MaM subreddits prohibit linking directly to other MaM subreddits. If you want to refer to a discussion on another subreddit, just screenshot the discussion and post the screenshot in your reply.


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Mar 16 '19

What Brings Me Here

64 Upvotes

Or maybe I should say what keeps me here. We get asked, all the time, why we bother to write here. Avery is in jail, will not get out, what’s the point? I write a lot.

This post is personal about my reasons. Probably too personal. But it is the truth.

Yes, I am a lawyer and like to argue. I am outraged by Zellner’s trial by media. Repelled by the bullshit she pretends is logic. By the harm she does to accidental targets, to the profession, and to civil, rational discussion.

Those feelings are strong, but just part of the story. Maybe just a little part.

It is about Teresa and her killer.

As some of you know, somebody tried to murder me, and almost succeeded. Twice. A complete stranger, much bigger, much younger, insanity in his demeanor. Faceless rage. It was in my early days on this forum that he first stabbed me. Sprung as I strolled down the street at sunset listening to a book. Stabbed me repeatedly with a cheap knife. For no reason at all. No reason I knew. Just because he could.

He said he would kill me, and I believed that he would. So I screamed, as loud as I could. Screamed for what seemed like forever, and almost was. Not thinking he would stop, or that screaming would save me. But that someone would hear, and know I existed.

Teresa is dead. She does not care what we do. She is past caring. But I imagine her final moments, that she had the thoughts like mine. Maybe not. But I believe that she did.

I am enraged her killer is now the smirking star of a movie. His smirking lawyer the star of another. The cartoon filmsters smirk and give interviews. His lawyer tweets about what might be her tiny charred bones. Her thoughts, like everything else in the grotesque entertainment, are mere props. Her death has become entertainment for internet ghouls full of puny hate and boredom. No, I am not jealous of his stupid lawyer. It makes me sick.


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Nov 18 '23

Convicting a murderer changed my mind

59 Upvotes

"Convicting a murderer" changed my mind and I feel cheated and slighted by Netflix. That is all. I just wish it was more easily accessible to everybody to set things right.

I am sure a lot of people refuse to admit they were tricked, but a lot of people also need this.

Also, fuck the Making a Murderer "documentary" makers. No credibility for any future "documentaries".


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Nov 05 '18

That Time When Brendan admitted Steven did it to his Mom on a phone call... (WAS SHE COERCING HIM???)

59 Upvotes

A link for those who like to do research and read:

http://crowdnotate.com/sections/bd/051306_bd_mom.html

And here is a key exchange for the visiting troofers who can't be bothered to read or do research:

PHONE CALL BRENDAN & MOM Phone ringing

M: Hello

B: Hello this is a collect call from Brendan and inmate at the Sheboygan County Jail. To accept charges press 0. This call is subject to monitoring and recording. Thank you for using

B: Hello

M: Ya

B: Did you talk to anybody?

M: No

B: Oh

M: What do you mean? Talk to anybody?

B: Cause Mark & Fassbender are gonna talk to you.

M: About what?

B: About the case

M: When did you talk to them?

B: Today.

M: When are they gonna talk to me?

B: I dunno

M: What do you mean?

B: Well, I guess yesterday that Mike guy came up here and talked to me about my results

M: Ya.

B: And

M: Ya.

B: What?

M: I haven't talked to nobody. I told you nobody calls me and lets me know nothing.

B: Ya. Do you feel bad if I say it today?

M: You don't even have to say it Brendan

B: Why?

M: Because just by the way you are acting I know what it is?

B: What

M: I don't want to say it over the phone

B: About what all happened?

M: Huh

B: About what all happened?

M: What all happened, what are you talking about?

B: About what me & Steven did that day,

M: What about it?

B: Well, Mike & Mark & Matt came up one day and took another interview with me and said because they think 1 was lying but so, they said if I come out with it that I would have to go to jail for 90 years.

M: What?

B: Ya. But if I came out with it I would probably get I dunno about like 20 or less. After the interview they told me if I wanted to say something to her family and said that I was sorry for what I did.

M: Then Steven did do it. (a)

B: Ya

M: (Mom Crying) Why didn't you tell me about this?

B: Ya, but they came out with something that was untrue with me (b) (d1)

M: What's that

B: They said that I sold crack.

M: What

B: Ya.

M: That you what?

B: That I sold crack. (c)

M: Really.

B: Ya, They said that they heard that from someone. (c)

M: Who said that to you?

B: Both of them.

M: Really.

B: Ya.

M: I don't think so

B: No, I didn't and they asked me if l smoked a cigarette and I said I did once but I didn't like it. Then they said that Travis said that I was always talking about it over by him. (c)

M: Really.

B: Ya. Then someone came out with me trying to commit suicide

M: Why did you even go over there Brendan?

B: I dunno, I don't even know how I am gonna do it in court though. (d2)

M: What do you mean?

B: I ain't gonna face them.

M: Face who?

B: Steven

M: You know what Brendan

B: What

M: I am gonna tell you something. He did it and you do what you gotta do. Okay.

B: What will happen if he gets pissed off.

M: What makes a difference, he ain't going nowhere now, is he?

B: No.

(a) Notice how Brendan admits Steven's guilt. To his Mom. (Was Brendan's Mom coercing him, too? Like the evil police?)

(b) Notice also how, after admitting Steven's guilt to his Mom, Brendan then makes a distinction between that true claim...and claims (crack, then suicide) that are untrue.

(c) Notice how Brendan freely offers details about those untrue claims, and seems relatively comfortable doing so in conversation.

(d1) Notice how he diverts the conversation away from TH's murder when it comes up...

(d2) ...and then clams back up when the topic of the details of TH's murders come back up again.

EDIT: I added more text from the conversation I was referencing (EVEN THOUGH I PUT THE FUCKING LINK TO THE WHOLE PHONE CALL RIGHT AT THE TOP OF MY FUCKING POST) because some dicknose made a pretty decent point about where I chose to start the conversation in the text of the post.

For the record: We should all do our own research to better understand the context as we wade through the details of this case, and in life in general. The reason this doc (and politics) has turned so many people insane is that NOBODY FUCKING READS anymore. They just take it as gospel when any old loud motherfucking dicknose comes along and starts saying shit they find the slightest bit interesting.

Also, vote tomorrow.


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Apr 17 '21

Remember when...

54 Upvotes
  1. Zellner took this case in 2016 and vowed that SA would be out by mother's day? (that was five mothers days ago)

  2. Zellner was filming for MAM2 in her rented limo and gloating about how she had secured enough evidence (e.g., the waxy bullet) to overturn SA's conviction? (she hadn't and didn't)

  3. Zellner filed her Big Brief in 2017 declaring that Pipette Ryan as the killer? (that was 2-4 killers ago, depending on what theory you choose to go with)

  4. Zellner staged a call between SA and Barb/ST where ST cursed and truthers were gloating like crazy because ST had a temper, which "proved" he was a homicidal manic, and were telling us to rest our case because it was over? (it wasn't)

  5. Zellner interviewed some rando at ST's work and learned that his nickname was "Skinny" and therefore ST = SiKiKeY and therefore Zellner and truthers had reached a consensus that ST was the killer and it was all over? (it wasn't...because then there was Bobby)

  6. Zellner found some porn on the Dassey hard drive and said it was a Brady violation that infringed on Steven's constitutional rights (it wasn't) and truthers were again gloating like crazy and telling us that Zellner finally cracked the case and it was all over again? (she didn't and it wasn't)

  7. Zellner received a tip that the RAV4 battery was replaced with a battery from a Crowne Victoria and truthers were patting themselves on the back because they unequivocally solved some unexplained mystery about police planting the RAV4? (that was 2-3 RAV-4 planters ago)

  8. Zellner filed a motion to recuse Judge AS after she received flowers from a supposed guilter and some chain smoking truther on YouTube said the flowers were a clear conflict of interest (they weren't) which meant Judge AS had to recuse herself (she didn't), which meant that a new judge would be taking over and would grant all of Zellner's motions? (they didn't)

  9. Zellner learned that the county gave TH's remains back to the Halbach's in 2011 and said that this was a HUGE Brady violation that infringed on SA's rights (it didn't) and truthers were certain that this lead was the real deal and it was finally, finally over (it wasn't)

  10. Zellner filed a motion to remand because some paperboy saw claims he saw Bobby and Santa's 6-foot twin pushing the RAV-4 up a hill 16 years ago and this is a HUGE Brady violation and it unequivocally means that Bobby planted the RAV4 and truthers are hooting and hollering that this time it really is finally over? (spoiler alert: it's not)

These are ten pivotal leads from the last 5 years (that I can think of off the top of my head anyway) that were supposed to crack this case and SA's prison cell wide open. Of course, these leads have led nowhere - literally. It's been over five years and SA is still in prison and Zellner is itching for a remand back to square one. Yet, when each of these events happened, truthers were parading around social media with their "in your face guilters!" "told ya so's!" and "it's overs!" just like they are now, with this brand new "lead" about Shirtless Bobby and 6-foot Santa that will undoubtedly lead to nowhere. It's both tragic and comical how deluded these people are.

ETA: (11) Cellphone Towergate; (12) Airtight Alibi; (13) Brain fingerprinting.


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Dec 17 '18

BREAKING NEWS Retired Manitowoc Sheriff's Office Lt. Andrew Colborn files a defamation lawsuit against Neflix and MaM Creators

54 Upvotes

r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Oct 31 '21

RIP Teresa Halbach

51 Upvotes

That's all.


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Jul 28 '21

Why are people so desperate to defend this monster?

50 Upvotes

I should say I have never seen Making a Murderer, but my friends have talked a lot about Avery (one is convinced he's innocent, but she also believes that vaccines are surveillance chips etc, the other two think Avery 'probably' did it but it's borderline) so I decided to research the case. And it is SO blatantly obvious that he did it. There's nothing uncertain about it!

The police of course have their occasional bad eggs (and I live in the UK so I'm not very familiar with the US police force), but the conspiracy that not a single person involved had a shred of integrity and that no one ever slipped up or blew the whistle is just beyond fantasy.

It reminds me of the Adnan Syed case (I am convinced that he's guilty also - another case where people think there wasn't much evidence against him when in fact there was a huge amount). I haven't seen any of the media about Syed either, I've just read the court documents etc and come to the obvious conclusion.

I mean I guess I know the answer to my own question - these 'documentaries' (I would say dramas) are incredibly biased and ultimately are concerned with attracting viewers, but it is such a grand shame that someone who actually might be innocent doesn't get the attention that this disgusting person is getting. And the victim ends up as a plot device, stripped of her humanity.

I'm not a social justice warrior by ANY means, but I do wonder if there's some inherent misogyny in this insistence of believing the innocence of men who have murdered women. Then again, I'm a man and my 3 aforementioned friends are women, so who knows.

I'm so glad I came across this subreddit, it made me breathe a sigh of relief that there are rational people out there!


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Oct 07 '21

Avery Family Drama....continued

47 Upvotes

I don't know what the rules are for mentioning private citizens in the Avery family/sharing social media posts and screenshots, so I will refrain from doing so unless told otherwise.

I just read a discussion on a private FB page mentioning that Steven is feuding with his entire family because they (the Averys) were trying to setup a GoFundMe fundraiser for Dolores Avery's funeral costs (that has since been deleted) and Steven apparently put the kibosh on it by sending a PSA through Zellner stating that Dolores's funeral expenses were already prepaid for by Allen (when they in fact weren't) and asked his supporters to NOT donate any money towards his mother's funeral expenses or buy any more family merchandse and instead to divert all money to him in prison. So basically, Steven usurped all donations to lay Ma to rest as "payback" to his family because he says his family kept Ma from speaking with him and felt they should suffer because of it.

I think this whole family are a bunch of greedy scum-sucking dirtbags who need to lay this whole charade to rest and stop exploiting the public for money period so that Teresa can finally rest in some godamn peace! But this is yet another example of what a disgusting and greedy person Steven is. Ma is the only person who supported him unconditionally all these years and this is how he repays her in the end. Fuck the Averys and Zellner and everyone who supports the lying POS.

Edited to add: PSA = public service announcement


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Oct 23 '18

The new witness who says he told Colborn about the RAV4! HUGE!

47 Upvotes

... or did he?

Let's review Kevin's affidavit, page 18 here.

He says he saw Teresa's vehicle "by the East Twin River dam in Mischicot at the turnabout the bridge [sic]" on 11/4. He says he stopped at Cennex and saw a missing person's poster. An MTSO officer walked in, and Rahmlow told the officer about the vehicle. In 2016, 11 years later, he was watching MaM and recognized Colborn as the officer he told.

Now there's one obvious problem with this story: Colborn wasn't working on 11/4, and wasn't anywhere near ASY. See trial testimony. He wasn't in the Cennex in uniform as an MTSO officer.

We do have a call from 11/4 of an officer named Ryan, calling dispatch regarding a missing person poster in a Cennex. Seems a bit more likely that Ryan is who Rahmlow reported the car to, than there being two officers at Cennex being asked about missing person posters on the same day.

So why did Rahmlow say it was Colborn? Turns out he did actually remember Colborn's face from a decade prior... when Colborn arrested him for drunk driving. Could be Rahmlow just forgot exactly why Colborn looked familiar. Could be Rahmlow still has a grudge. Who knows.

And what about this vehicle by the turnaround, that looked like Teresa's? I mean, sure Zellner never explains why the vehicle was over there when she says it was at Kuss Rd, but it would still be interesting if it was seen there. Well Kevin isn't the only person who saw a vehicle at the turnaround, and there is a report about it. Officers checked out the report, and it wasn't Teresa's car. It had holes in the windshield and windows, and the color was off.

So to believe Rahmlow actually saw Teresa's vehicle at the turnaround and reported it to Colborn, we have to believe:

  • There were two vehicles at the turnaround that looked similar to Teresa's, one just looking similar and the other being hers

  • There were two officers in Cennex that day looking at missing persons posters, one being Ryan who called dispatch about it, and the other being Colborn who wasn't in uniform but Rahmlow intuited was an MTSO officer.


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Nov 08 '24

Let's review the pertinent facts which reveal why sane people recognize Avery is guilty

46 Upvotes

Steven Avery sold various vehicles through AutoTrader and over time his interactions with Halbach grew. He had listed vehicles for himself as well as for his family. When he listed vehicles for his family he provided their name and also his name and number since the photographer would have to contact him for payment and for the actual ad that was to be run. The last visit Halbach made prior to the visit where she was killed was arranged by Avery bipassing AutoTrader altogether and calling her cell phone directly. Knowing she would be coming Avery made a point of being in a towel when she arrived. Halbach told others about how this grossed her out and she was uncomfortable going to Avery Salvage. Avery told others Halbach was sexy and he liked her. The previous day he also happened to try to arrange a sex meeting with a girl, he said he was really horny because his girlfriend was in prison so he was not getting any.

Avery decided he wanted to see Halbach and he planned to use his sister's vehicle as an excuse to lure her there. He told his sister he would be listing her van. She told police: A) Steven Avery is the one who decided it should be sold and listed on AutoTrader. Steven Avery approached her telling her he was going to list it. B) That she didn't want to list the van because she would not get much money for it and her kids wanted it and she felt it would be of more value to them than selling it for practically nothing. Brendan eagerly kept asking about getting the van, he wanted it badly. She had an argument with him over it but he insisted he was listing it regardless of her wishes. She said she refused to pay for the listing because she didn't want to sell it and felt it was a wasted fee and he told her he would pay.

Avery did not phone Halbach directly like he did last time but instead he phoned AutoTrader. He also did not behave like he did the other times he listed a vehicle for his sister. Instead of calling in advance, he called for a same day appointment, knowing that she did appointments on Monday. He pretended to be his sister providing her name, address and phone number failing to reveal that he would be handling the transaction. He also pretended that he didn't know Halbach's name and asked for the same girl who came out last time. It is quite obvious he did this to distance himself from the transaction so that if anyone did review AutoTrader records they would see no reference to Steven Avery, simply B Janda. Had he called Halbach directly like last time she would have informed AutoTrader she was meeting Steven plus his phone number would be in her phone records.

AutoTrader said they were unsure whether she would be able to make it that day it might need to be scheduled for the next business day and would call back. Since he provided his sister's unmanned number he would not get that message. He left work at 11 to go home and call AT again pretending to be B Janda to find out whether she could come. He was informed she could but would probably not make it until after 2. Instead of going back to work he remained at home preparing for her visit- why would he need to spend such a long time preparing?

Since he didn't reveal his role he had to wait in his window looking for her. He became antsy and he called her phone but to conceal on her records that it was him he used *67. He called a second time using *67 again but he hung up before it even connected to her phone because presumably he saw her pulling up at that point since moments later Bobby saw her there taking photos. Bobby saw her walking towards Steven Avery's trailer then he got dressed and left. When he was leaving he didn't see her just her vehicle so she presumably was in Avery's trailer.

After her visit a vehicle normally stored in Avery's garage had been moved to his driveway. That made room inside for her vehicle to be concealed if so desired and Brendan claimed her vehicle was hidden in there. .

Many spent casings were found in the garage. A bullet found in Avery's garage, that had been fired from the .22 kept above his bed, had Halbach's DNA on it. Halbach's partial skull remains evidenced that she had been shot at least 2 times in the head with a .22. This bullet either exited her or grazed her to get her DNA on it. Since the body was destroyed there is no way to know how many times her body had been struck or grazed beyond the 2 that surely damaged her skull.

Shortly after her arrival Avery was observed conducting a fire in his burn barrel and then a bonfire in his burn pit. That fire was still going strong when Blaine arrived home after 11pm. The number of tires he burned and the duration was determined by experts to be of duration and intensity to have been capable of destroying a human body. In the ash in Avery's fire pit police found portions of nearly every bone from Halbach's body as well as some remains or her teeth and even the rivets from her jeans. In the burn barrel they found the remnants of Halbach's burned electronics.

Halbach's vehicle was found hidden in an area of Avery salvage where Avery was known to dump his junked vehicles. The battery had been disconnected and the battery latch had Avery's DNA on it. The key was found hidden in his bedroom and likewise had his DNA on it. The license plates were found in a junked car that was along the path back to Avery's trailer and they were folded in 3 parts as Avery was known to do.

When police went to investigate her visit and were going to another house, Avery immediately intercepted the cop to control the narrative. He told police his sister was selling a vehicle and from his window he saw her arrive take photos and then leave. He concealed from police that he had arranged it and had interacted with her. Subsequently after police already learned he had made the appointment, he admitted he made the appointment but lied saying his sister asked him to list it for her and asked him to loan her the money to pay the fee.

We are supposed to believe that Avery concealed his role for no reason and it was mere coincidence that Avery had such fires and that some other killer likewise burned her body and electronics in separate locations. That person by magic knew about Avery's fires, and though there was no need to do so he painstakingly excavated both fires and transported the evidence to Avery's property and planted it without anyone catching him. Even without looking at all the other evidence this is simply a crazy allegation. It is equally crazy to claim police and crime lab personnel found the burned cremains and electronics elsewhere and at least a dozen people from 4 different agencies conspired to relocate the cremains/electronics themselves. This is why Avery supporters are called the tinfoil hat brigade.


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Jul 04 '21

Another holiday made safer by the incarceration of Uncle Stevie.

46 Upvotes

I hope you are all enjoying the day with friends and loved ones.

It’s another fine holiday when, despite the cardboard signs made and held high, despite donations sent to help a murderer afford an extra soup, and despite mealy-mouthed hours spent crapping out the laughably specious posts by the fogbound flakes over at MaM, Stevie is still locked up.

The Justice system in the US is broken in many ways. The State of WI is corrupt and dysfunctional in many ways. Kratz is a scumbag in many ways. NONE of this changes the fact that Avery probably raped and definitely murdered Teresa Halbach.

I’ll light a few fireworks off in celebration of one of the times a small town justice department scored a win for the people of its jurisdiction.

And I’ll drink a cold one to the enjoyable fact that Avery is never getting out.

Get fucked Avery.

And to anyone that supports his appellate efforts claiming that it folds into fighting LE corruption: Get extra fucked. You picked this case because of a TV show. There are PLENTY of instances of police misconduct to support. This ain’t it, chief.

Off to grill some steaks and smash some beers, it’s a good day to be free!


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Jun 12 '20

MAM Brendan confession call with Barb in full 06 Track 6 (2-27-54)

46 Upvotes

Brendans confession phone with Barb in full:

Brendan: You might feel bad if I say it today

Barb: You don’t even have to say it Brendan. Just by the way you are acting, I know what it is.

Brendan: About what me and Steven did that day?

Barb: What about it?

Brendan: Well Mark and that took another interview with me and said that... cus... they think I was lying, but... so... they said if I didn’t come out with it then I would to to jail for 90 years but if I came out with it I would probably get 20 or less. After the interview they said if I wanted to say something to her family and say that I was sorry for what I did.

Barb: So Steven did do it?

Brendan: Yeah

Barb: Why didn’t you tell me about this?

Brendan: Yeah but they came out with something that wasn’t true with me. They said that I smoked crack

Barb: What? Really

Brendan: They said that they heard that from someone

Barb: Who said that to you?

Brendan: both of em

Barb: Really? I don’t think so

Brendan: And I said that I smoked a cigarette once but I didn’t like it. And they said that Travis said that I was always talking about it over by him. Then someone came out with me trying to commit suicide.

Barb: Why did you even go over there Brendan?

Brendan: I don’t know. I don’t even know how i’m gonna do it in court though. I aint gonna face him.

Barb: You know what Brendan. He did it. You do what you gotta do, ok?

Brendan: Yeah but what would happen it he gets pissed off?

Barb: What what makes a difference? he isn’t going nowhere is he? Why didn’t you tell me about this earlier?

Brendan: ...

Barb: So did you talk to her family?

Brendan: No, they just asked me if I wanted to say something to em on the tape.

Barb: Did you?

Brendan: Just said that I was sorry for what I did.

Barb: Did he make you do this?

Brendan. Yeah

Barb: Then why didn’t you tell em that?

Brendan: Tell em what?

Barb: That he made you do it, you know he made you do a lot of things

Brendan: Yeah I told them that. I even told them about Steven touching me and that

Barb: what do you mean touching you?

Brendan: well he would grab me somewhere where I was uncomfortable

Barb: Brendan, i’m your mother. Why didn’t you come to me? Why didn’t you tell me? Did he touch you before all this stuff happened? Why didn’t you come to me? Because then he would have been gone and this wouldn’t have happened. And you’d still be here with me.

Brendan: yeah, well you know he always touched us and that.

Barb: I didn’t think there. He used to horse around with you guys.

Brendan: Well he used to do stuff to Bryan and that. Like fake humping him. Like that one time when he was going with whats her name... Jessica’s sister?

Barb: Teresa?

Brendan: Yeah that one day when she was over Steven and Blaine and Bryan were downstairs and Steven was touching her and that.

Barb: Really. He makes me so sick.

Barb: So what did they say to you? How many years are you going to get

Brendan: I don’t know...

Barb: Well what did you just say to me?

Brendan: That the Teresa family might ask the judge to be lenient or whatever. And they asked me if I wanted to have a family later on.

Barb: I don’t hate you Brendan. I hate Steven, alright? I just wish you had told me sooner. Ok?

How did you answer the phone at 6:00 then?

Brendan: They said they have the record and he didn’t call

Barb: How about when I got home at 5:00 and you weren’t here?

Brendan: Yeah, I went over earlier and came home before you did

Barb: Why didn’t you say anything to me then?

Brendan: I don’t know, I was too scared.

Barb: You wouldn’t of have to have been scared because I would have called 911 and you wouldn’t have been going back over there. They would have been there maybe she would have been alive yet. So in those statements you did all that to her too?

Brendan: Some of it...

Barb: Did he make you do it?

Brendan: Yeah

https://youtu.be/5QbND9dFvoo


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Sep 10 '19

SAIG Investigates: The Last Time Zellner Was Involved with a $100,000 Reward

46 Upvotes

Way back when Zellner first got involved in the Avery mess-- before she starred in a Netflix movie and earned a coveted blue check mark on Twitter--I took the liberty of researching her past exonerations to see if she truly lived up to the hype (she didn't).

Zellner's Tweet of a Picture of a Word Document big announcement yesterday - that a concerned citizen has offered a $100,000 reward for information leading to the arrest and conviction of Teresa Halbach's "real killer" (which is totally not Steven Avery except it is) reminded me of something I came across while conducting the aforementioned research.

Back in 2004/05, Zellner represented Kevin Fox, who confessed to killing his 3-year old daughter, Riley. He recanted almost immediately, but spent eight months in jail before DNA evidence - that didn't match him - led to his release.

Which meant that the real killer was still out there. The family had been offering a $100,000 reward for information leading to the real killer as early as 2006, but the FBI joined the investigation in 2009.

The FBI was offering a $10,000 reward if any tips led to the arrest of a suspect. They interviewed people from the neighborhood, and one woman gave them the name of her ex boyfriend. She just had a feeling about him, she said:

"It wasn't that I really thought he did it. I was just, like, check him out. If you're going around asking who's a creep, here's a creep for you, the tipster told the Chicago Tribune.

The FBI put this suspect on the bottom of their list, but when they did get around to investigating him--a full year and a half later--he confessed. The DNA matched. And the FBI paid up.

You know who didn't? The Fox Family. Zellner said the tip was vague, and the tipster should have gone to authorities sooner. In an interview the actual media--not John Ferak Patch-level shit, but the Chicago Tribune, Zellner said:

"I do not think that the Foxes owe her anything, quite frankly. We put out hundreds of posters on (Riley's slaying), and (the tipster) lived right in town. She sat there while Kevin went to jail."

In the same article, the tipster disagrees:

... said she didn't tell authorities about Eby [the real killer] sooner because she didn't want to accuse someone of murder based on a gut feeling. And Kevin Fox had told police he killed his daughter — a confession later found to be coerced — so [the tipster] said she had no reason to believe Eby was responsible.

Zellner "thinks I should have went in there like a white knight in shining armor, you know, that I had this in my back pocket," [the tipster] said. "I didn't know."

[The tipster] said she believes she deserves the reward money and is upset the Foxes haven't felt the same way. It's not so much about the money, but about the principle of offering a reward and then granting it.

"I would have thought they'd be so grateful," [the tipster] said.

The article was published in February, 2011. Nearly a full year later, the Fox family agreed to pay the tipster an undisclosed amount of money.

In an emailed news release (ed. note--was there clip art???), [Zellner] said Fox decided to pay an undisclosed amount after a "full investigation was done" into [the tipster's] "5-year delay" in coming forward.

So let that be a lesson to you tipsters out there (who don't exist, because the real killer is in prison and the only way he's getting out is in a body bag): just because a concerned citizen has offered a reward doesn't mean Zellner thinks you're worthy of getting it.


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Mar 09 '19

Jumped ship

46 Upvotes

I haven't actually been following the case for awhile, but I always felt that Steven was innocent and framed. My curiosity was piqued when I saw a news article recently about Steven Avery winning his appeal. I was pretty pumped and my husband and I decided to watch season 2 last weekend, thinking that it would show the events leading up to Steven winning his appeal. After episode 5, we couldn't really bear to watch anymore. What stood out to me most was the lack of humanity for the victim and her family. They treat Teresa like an object who got in the way of Steven Avery's freedom. I hope to God that Teresa's family did not watch this series. As a mother, I could not imagine how it would feel to watch somebody throw around a doll resembling my dead child. It makes me sick to my stomach.

I started to feel a nagging suspicion that Steven was guilty very early on in the second series just based on the way his attorney tried to account for the evidence. In the first season, the planting theories, which have now been thoroughly disputed in my mind, were at least plausible back then. Sure, I could see police planting blood from a vial in their custody that they knew belonged to Steven, but not planting an unknown person's blood from a bathroom sink into the victim's car.

The experiments in season 2 were downright ludicrous and could not have been designed by anyone who is familiar with basic scientific principles. There were no attempts to dispute the evidence with actual scientific testing. You cannot invalidate a piece of evidence by demonstrating via roleplay that it could not have happened in X way, when there were an infinite number of ways that it could have happened. Holding a key for X number of minutes, touching a hoodlatch X number of times, shooting bullets through a garage, and transferring blood from a sink to a car is not probative of anything.

I skipped over the remaining episodes to the very end, thinking it would show the events leading up to Steven winning his appeal, only to find that he had actually lost all of his appeals. The entire last episode was more or less devoted to his attorney doing damage control about losing the appeal. She drafted a letter asking to judge to recant her decision because they were not done with testing, then tells her employee "Send this to all of the media outlets" before the letter had even been filed in court. What?!

I visited the pro-innocence subreddit hoping to find out more information about steven's winning his appeal. I used to visit that sub pretty regularly, and boy have things changed since I've last ben there. People are grappling with theories like Teresa was still alive, the police were planting sinks and floor tiles, the police illegally gave the bones to Teresa's family, and people trying to intimidate the judge into resigning from the case.

Where is the justice for Teresa in all of this?


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Nov 03 '21

Believe Women

45 Upvotes

Hey! Did you guys know that Steven Avery never harmed Lori? Not once.

He also never hurt Jodi. She just made up that incident where he choked her out and the cops came, incidentally discovering that Steven was a felon in possession of a firearm and doing nothing about it.

Sandra Morris? Just some drunk at the Moose Club running her mouth.

Oh, and MA? Made it up. Or rather, was coerced -- despite 4 separate corroborating statements, she just fabricated the whole rape/statuatory rape thing.

Seriously, this is what a lot of people who support Steven Avery believe and state. That these women all made it up. Every single bit of it. Sweet little Steven Avery is just being targeted by law enforcement, and never did any of that. And he didn't rape or murder Teresa Halbach, either.

So, do people state that all these women are lying because it's too hard to reconcile their supportive stance with Steven being guilty of (non-murder) criminal acts? Or are they misogynists? Or is there another explanation for believing that 5+ women claim to have been harmed by Steven/were allegedly harmed by Steven?


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Sep 17 '21

Say you're arrested for a murder that you didn't commit, and someone records and releases all your jail phone calls. What do you think you'd be discussing?

45 Upvotes

Thanks to the generous bounty from pooled muppets, we have the complete set of Steven Avery jail recordings. But something seemed to be missing.

Had any normal innocent person been arrested for a heinous murder he or she didn't commit, I would expect their jailhouse phone calls to be filled with protestations of innocence, bewilderment at having even been arrested, and panicked thoughts of how to prove themselves innocent or how this misunderstanding could have occurred!!

But not so with Steven Avery Man. Conspicuously absent are his assurances of his own innocence. Instead we get threats that Brendan better not talk. Also conspicuously absent are the reassurances from family that they have confidence in his innocence. They know better.

To me Avery's attitude on the phone is consistent with a guilty guy expecting to go away forever. With the same attitude from everyone he spoke with.


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Feb 20 '16

The "suspicious" plates call and the defense pressuring Colborn - MaM manipulation and reality, disgusting editing

45 Upvotes

For me, one of the most defining moments of creating reasonable doubt in MaM, together with the blood vial, was when Strang confronted Colborn with his call where he verified the plates SWH 582 of TH's Toyota RAV4.

In my opinion the main reason why this actually planted the idea of a conspiracy in people's head isn't the fact that he called in plates. It's rather how Strang seems to be able to force him into a corner, how the defense really pressured Colborn, who "looked like a dear in the headlight" as it's often quoted. How he supposedly can't explain his call. MaM makes it look like they really "caught him" there.

Right after people watched episode 5 they even admitted that there could be other legit reasons for making that call (which of course is denied by now as the conspiracy circlejerk went on) but that it was so telling how Colborn got caught with a lie etc.

As this scene is so heavily and unethically edited, that there are literally answers and single words are cut together with different questions, it's worth looking at the scene in MaM basically sentence by sentence and compare it to the transcript.

The editing starts sort of harmless:

MaM, Call between Colborn (C) and Sheriff's Department (S)

S:Manitowoc County Sheriff's Department.This is Lynn.

C:Lynn

S:Hi Andy

C:Can you run Sam William Henry 582

S:Okay. Shows that she's a missing person. And it lists to Teresa Halbach.

C: All set

S:Okay. Is that what you're looking for,Andy?

C:'99 Toyota.

S: Yup

C: Okay, thank you.

S: You're so welcome. Bye Bye

They cut out a talk between them about some other stuff probably as it took some time to run the plates, that's fine.

However, ehty also cut out exactly one half-sentence by Andrew Colborn, which directly was part of the request to run the plates. They let in the first half of the sentence but cut out the last half. Actual transcript:

S:Manitowoc County Sheriff's Department.This is Lynn.

C:Lynn

S:Hi Andy

C:Can you run Sam William Henry 582 (!)See if it comes back to (Inaudible.)(!)

.....

Why cut out one half of a sentence? Probably because Colborn already expecting the car to come back for a certain person and not being unaware of what he's asking for, clearly strengthens his testimony, that he just wanted to verify information, which was already given to him. It weakens the conspiracy theory that he randomly or however stumbled across the car, learned it was TH's and set somebody up. If you say it's not that relevant, why edit it out? Why move the cursor to the middle of a sentence and cut the last half out? They had some reason to do so. However that's pretty harmless so far compared to later editing.

In reality the examination went on like that:

Q. Okay. That's the entire call. Hangs up. That's your voice?

A. Yes, I believe that's my voice. Yes.

Q. When did you make that phone call inquiring about a license plate?

A. I don't know.

Q. Do you have any recollection of making that phone call?

A. It would have had to have been 11/03/05 or -- I'm guessing 11/03/05.

Q. Okay. But let's -- let's ask -- establish this first, do you remember making the call?

A. Not really, no.

Making a murderer instead jumps right to the part where Strang confronts Colborn with the fact that he was the one who said "99 Toyota" and than adds parts of the dialog above after Strang allegedly "caught" Colborn.

Why would they do that? I think because it sounds more suspicious. It makes it look like Strang is pressuring Colborn after he got "caught" and Colborn denies even remembering that call "after he got caught". It also makes him look like if he now tries to hide something and he looks a bit uncertain about everything he says. It also replaces an actual explanation from Colborn with that dialog, but I'll wrote that down later in the post.

In reality this exchange of words happened before he was even confronted with the accusation of standing in front of the car. He already said that he simply doesn't remember exactly, before there was something "suspicious" brought up.

Then the confrontation basically happened like in MaM, replaying the call to demonstrate that Colborn asked if it's a 99' Toyota.

Q. Actually you who suggests this is a '99 Toyota?

A. I asked if it was a '99 Toyota, yes.

Q. And the dispatcher confirmed that?

A. Yes.

Q. Were you looking at these plates when you called them in?

A. No, sir.

MaM jumps right to "Were you looking at these plates", then adds some scenes where Strang stares at Colborn and Colborn looks around a bit nervous, then suddenly jumps back in time to:

"Do you have any recollection of making that phone call?"

Which is a question that was asked in the middle of the dialog before he asked him about the 99 Toyota thing.

After that, they edited in the last half-sentence of Colborn, which he originally gave to that answer before he was confronted by Strang What he answered in court:

Q. Do you have any recollection of making that phone call?

A. It would have had to have been 11/03/05 or [-- I'm guessing 11/03/05]

Again cutting in a break and a "yaaah" and then the last half of the answer: "--I'm guessing..11/03/05" making his answer seems a bit slow and uncertain.

In the documentary he actually continues to talk as if it was one answer:

"--I'm guessing..11/03/05 probably after I received a phone call from Investigator Wiegert letting me know that there was a missing person. "

The last part starting with "probably" however was not part of that answer. It actually was his answer to another question:

Q.And your best guess is that you called them in on November 3, 2005?

A. Yes, probably after I received a phone call from Investigator Wiegert letting me know that there was a missing person.

But when did he explain that in reality? Well right after Strang's confrontation, the real context is:

Q. Actually you who suggests this is a '99 Toyota?

A. I asked if it was a '99 Toyota, yes.

Q. And the dispatcher confirmed that?

A. Yes.

Q. Were you looking at these plates when you called them in?

A. No, sir.

Q. And your best guess is that you called them in on November 3, 2005?

A. Yes, probably after I received a phone call from Investigator Wiegert letting me know that there was a missing person.

In REALITY he immediatelly gave the explanation when/why he called and asked for the license plates, right after Strang confronted him.

In MaM is looks as if he was guessing around after the confrontation and later tries to find an explanation.

Making a Murderer shows:

Q. Investigator Wiegert, did he give you the license plate number for Teresa Halbach when he called you?

A. I don't remember the entire content of our conversation but,obviously, he must have because I was asking the dispatcher to run the plate for me.

Now they directly jump to another scene of Strang "pressuring" Colborn. But let's look at what they cut out after the last dialog. Following the exchange above Colborn actually gave further explanation of why he'd call in the plates after Strang tried to question his motive:

Q. Did you not trust that Investigator Wiegert got the number right?

A. I don't -- That's just the way I would have done it. I don't -- It's not a trust or distrust issue.

So he says that's the way he does it. He later goes on to explain how it's common to verify information from another agency, of course that's also not shown in Making a Murderer:

Q. Mr. Strang asked whether or not it was common for you to check up on other agencies, or perhaps I'm -- I'm misphrasing that, but when you are assisting another agency, do you commonly verify information that's provided by another agency?

A. All the time. I'm just trying to get -- you know, a lot of times when you are driving a car, you can't stop and take notes, so I'm trying to get things in my head. And by calling the dispatch center and running that plate again, it got it in my head who that vehicle belonged to and what type of vehicle that plate is associated with.

Also later on:

Q. This call sounded like hundreds of other license plate or registration checks you have done through dispatch before?

A. Yes.

So the highly suspicious Andrew Colborn

  1. said he would do those calls all the time

  2. gave a reasonable explanation for it

  3. gave that explanation right after he was confronted, stuck to it and added further explanation when asked

As I said MaM left that out, where did they jump to instead? To another accusation of Strang:

Q. Well, and you can understand how someone listening to that might think that you were calling in a license plate that you were looking at on the back end of a 1999 Toyota? [cutting out one sentence]

Oh he puts on the pressure on Colborn!

And now something magical happens in Making a Murderer. Colborn very hesitantly with desperate face answers:

A. hm Yes.

Well that's strange. Because according to the trial scripts Andrew Colborn never answered that question. Why? Because the prosecution objected:

ATTORNEY KRATZ: It's a conclusion, Judge. He's conveying the problems to the jury.

THE COURT: I agree, the objection is sustained.

Colborn does not say he thinks somebody could think that, in fact nobody answers that question and the defense is forced to back up on that. Why would he think that somebody else could think that, he gave a valid explanation for this call and said he did it all the time.

They literally cut single words out of sentences, put them together and made them the answer to a different question.... Great "documentary".

Very much like the blood vial it's completely made up. At the end of the day without heavy editing and dramatic music there doesn't seem to be anything suspicious about that call.

And as far as Colborn "got caught" goes:

Actually you could interpret that maneuver of the defense as a defeat. Their theory that it's the logical explanation that he was looking at the car was objected. The direct answer if he was looking at the car was negated. The question why he then would call in the plates was answered.

Best mass-manipulation and propaganda since 1945


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Jul 31 '21

Top 25 greatest hits from Appeal No. 2017AP2288-CR

44 Upvotes

In no particular order and replacing "Avery" with "Zellner" where appropriate:

In short, Zellner must show that a hearing would not be frivolous. Zellner cannot make this showing. First, Zellner has wholly failed to demonstrate deficient performance: that trial counsel’s “representation fell below an objective standard of reasonableness."

Zellner's argument is unintelligible and, in any case, we cannot perceive any Brady violation. There was no evidence here to suppress, and the facts in the affidavit are inconsequential.

Although only tangentially relevant to our decision, we note that Zellner misrepresented some key facts underlying this claim in the motion to the circuit court and briefing to this court . . . We point them out because of the high-profile nature of this case, the greater possibility that interested members of the public will read the briefing and motions, and the resulting need, where misrepresentations are particularly egregious, to note where Zellner’s arguments wholly stray from the facts.

The State argues that the Youngblood analysis only properly applies to the destruction of pretrial evidence. We agree generally but need not explore this point, because Zellner’s claim fails on its own terms.

According to Zellner, such an expert would have determined that his “DNA was planted on the key” by law enforcement. Zellner again misstates the evidence.

This evidence is not exculpatory or even particularly relevant, and Zellner's attempt to link it to the alleged reassignment of his groin swab is wholly unsupported by any facts of record.

Thus, once again, the findings of Zellner’s expert are significantly more ambiguous than what is presented in his motion.

In what is becoming a pattern, Zellner has misrepresented the facts.

The DNA expert Zellner has now hired did not determine that Avery “never deposited” the DNA and did not state that Avery was framed.

Zellner’s burden in a postconviction motion is not merely to point to helpful evidence but to show how its introduction at trial could reasonably have led to a different outcome. Zellner cannot meet this burden by misrepresenting the expert’s results as “demonstrating” that he was framed.

Zellner's seventh and final claim is that trial counsel was ineffective for not presenting a forensic fire expert. Zellner's cited factual support once again does not live up to the advance billing.

Zellner also argues that Halbach’s ex-boyfriend was the real killer, but does not present any cognizable claim based on this argument.

A third claim repackages one of Zellner's ineffectiveness claims, arguing that the results of the experiment with the RAV4 hood latch constitute newly discovered evidence. Zellner cannot have it both ways.

To be entitled to a hearing on postconviction claims of newly discovered evidence, the defendant must allege sufficient material facts satisfying these elements. Zellner cannot meet one of more of these elements for either of her claims.

Aside from these cursory statements, Zellner does not address whether technology available at the time of trial could have yielded the same results. Beyond that, Zellner’s evidence is largely irrelevant.

This is a repeated shortcoming in Zellner’s briefing, both to the circuit court and on appeal, and represents exactly the type of “Monday- morning quarterbacking” that we strive to avoid in evaluating a claim of ineffective assistance of counsel.

In sum, the seven ineffectiveness claims in Zellner's June 2017 motion that are based on new investigations fail on the merits. Zellner merely assumes that the need for such experts should have been obvious at the time, based on the later findings of his own experts. These later findings, however, are either equivocal, irrelevant, or both.

We have given Zellner the benefit of several doubts as to why she did not raise these claims earlier. Even considered on the merits, the claims asserted in Zellner's June 2017 motion are speculative, conclusory, and in some cases misleading.

Zellner contends that a blood spatter expert could have advised counsel that its trial strategy for explaining the presence of his blood in the RAV4 was flawed. This assertion is entirely speculative; as a matter of law, such guesswork falls well short of demonstrating ineffective assistance of counsel.

Nor can Zellner establish that this evidence is potentially exculpatory, because even assuming that these bone fragments are Halbach’s, Zellner does not explain the significance of this fact.

The apparent thrust of Zellner's claim is that, if Halbach’s bones were found in the gravel pit, then she was killed by someone else. But as Zellner never explains why Avery himself would have been unable to dispose of Halbach’s remains in the gravel pit, this line of reasoning is wholly speculative.

Zellner speculates that the ex-boyfriend meets the Denny “legitimate tendency” test for introducing trial evidence that a third party committed the crime, but without pointing to any true newly discovered evidence, explaining why trial counsel rendered ineffective assistance during, or otherwise demonstrating why such conclusion entitles him to a new trial.

The presence of Halbach’s DNA on a bullet found in Avery’s garage is particularly damning evidence—regardless of whether it was the bullet that entered her skull—and strongly implicates Avery absent evidence that Halbach’s DNA was planted (a supposition that, even now, Zellner has done little to develop). At the very least, Zellner’s new evidence—if it in fact is new—is consistent with the State’s theory of the crime.

Zellner argues that investigators knew, but did not disclose to [trial counsel], that Halbach’s RAV4 was driven onto the property of Avery’s next door neighbor. It is difficult to follow this argument.

It would be an inefficient use of court resources to now, and once again, delay this appeal’s resolution. Simply put, Zellner's appeal cannot continue indefinitely.

I could go on, but in the words of the great Wisconsin COA District II, this post about Zellner's ineptitude cannot continue indefinitely.

RIP Teresa.


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Aug 12 '16

Brendan Dassey's Conviction Has Been OVERTURNED - confirmed by attorney Steven Drizin!

44 Upvotes

r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Jul 12 '21

The truth is coming out over on FB

43 Upvotes

So it seems the Avery family is coming out against him on Facebook with Earl, Kay Marie - (Kayla Avery) and others claiming Steven is guilty and Brendan was forced.

All the Avery fans are in total denial and won’t accept they have been taken advantage of and lied to for 5+ years now for donations.

Seems that the family were hiding information because they didn’t want to hurt Avery’s mother.

Avery fans can claim it’s because they are after money now but it seems pretty evident that all along they have been defending him only for the money and the support that the fan groups give out.

The family are in true support of Brendan though and claim he was forced into it by Steven.

So Avery fans will have to ask themselves if they want to support someone who has committed such a crime. If Brendan is to be supported then Steven is now the opposition.

All screenshots are on MAM Gossip’s FB page.

https://www.facebook.com/groups/MaMGossip/?ref=share

Quotes from the comments on facebook:

Earl Avery:

‘Fuck Steven Avery he’s not my fucking brother your mother is going to haunt you for the misery you put her through. Why don’t you leave us out of your life because we don’t want you in ours!

His mommy is gone now and I can start telling the truth that fucker is a psychopath

No I am not OK I got a psychopath that keeps threatening my family and his name is Steven Avery…

All i’m going to reply to now is I was the closest one to him and that day that happened and he was acting really really strange I am not replying no more comments

Well i’m out here looking after my mother…while he’s sitting there talking shit all about us …the world deserves to know’

Fan: Why are you saying this now? (Earl)

Earl - ‘Because my mommy died’

Kay Marie (Kayla):

‘We believe Brendan was forced to help cus that was the type of person he was.

No you’re not wrong but he could have been scared of Steven idk i’m not them but ik for a fact now Steven is not innocent n with his past. When he was out how many women he raped when he got out. Its just wrong but no one came forward cuz they know they wouldn’t have won so idk what to tell you people but please understand who you are trying to help ok.’