r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Mar 09 '19

Bobby Bobby bo Bobby

0 Upvotes

Any of you state groupies here agree that it isn't possible to rule out Bobby as having any involvement in Teresas death? Surely one of you must be rational. Even If just a little. Probably not but worth a try. For the rest of you, what rules him out? Remember. Try your hardest to be rational on this one. MAC has spoken.


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Jan 01 '19

The bogus claim that the jury was not convinced beyond a reasonable doubt that Avery is the one who burned Halbach

0 Upvotes

Those who want to pretend Avery is innocent or pretend he didn't receive a fair trial make the false claim that Avery was acquitted of burning her. They variously claim that the jury believed someone else burned her in Avery's pit or that someone else burned her in another location.

The crime he was charged with was not burning her, it was mutilating a corpse.

Whoever mutilates, disfigures or dismembers a corpse, with intent to conceal a crime or avoid apprehension, prosecution or conviction for a crime

That means the state needed to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that she was mutilated, disfigured or dismembered after she was already dead and thus a corpse.

They also needed to establish the motive was to inhibit being caught.

There are a host of things that the jury seemed to have a problem with.

  1. A prosecution witness on cross examination said that there was no evidence to prove beyond a reasonable doubt she was dead when tossed in the fire. That alone is enough to defeat the charge. Tossing a living person in a fire is murder not mutilation of a corpse.

  2. Some on the jury took issue with the concept of burning constituting mutilation

  3. As a result of 1 and 2 the jury struggled with whether her burned bones constituted a corpse and Avery breaking up the bones after burning them could constitute dismemberment ("Whoever mutilates, disfigures or dismembers a corpse") and thus they would be able to find him guilty on that basis. Ultimately they concluded that the bones were not a corpse and whatever he did to them didn't matter.


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Feb 26 '19

Zellner's lack of diligence is fatal to the remanded Motion

1 Upvotes

If it is accurate that the material in question was disposed of in 2011, it could and should have been discovered with due diligence, and accordingly included in one or both of Avery's pro se appeals, and also in the Zellnami filed by Zellner in 2017.

Because Avery and his counsel both failed to assert the argument for eight years after the issue appeared, and after several post-conviction Motions were filed, the issue is waived.

One of the cornerstone issues in the remand briefing will be whether the issue is so waived by the failure to assert it earlier and in a timely fashion.

This is real trouble for Avery and Zellner.


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Mar 03 '16

This is just hilarious

0 Upvotes

You guys mock someone suggesting using a spirit board on the mian sub....

yet two of your top 5 posts listed here are dealing with a reddit user speaking as if they are a handwriting analysist and another linking an article breaking down word for word, where Steven is lying in his statement in court.

You guys are trying to fabricate guilt out of thin air, much like evidence in the trial.

Genius.


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Jan 02 '19

Truthers are back to the brain fingerprinting nonsense and again misrepresenting that Iowa held it admissible

1 Upvotes

In 2000 an Iowa judge held some of the stuff related to brain fingerprinting admissible but ruled Farwell's Mermer analysis not admissible. So the very analysis truthers want to rely on was not held to be admissible. What limited matter the court did allow as admissible the court ruled was unpersuasive and denied a new trial on such basis.

In 2003 the Iowa Supreme Court ordered a new trial based on Brady. Since the trial court rejected the Brain fingerprinting crap as a basis to obtain a new trial and the court didn't evaluate whether the court was wrong in such regard the issue of whether brain fingerprinting was admissible did not come before the court so the claim they held it admissible is absurd.

Because we conclude the due process claim is dispositive of the present appeal, we do not reach the question of whether the trial court erred in rejecting Harrington's request for a new trial on the basis of newly discovered evidence.

The court that admitted it didn't do so in order for it to be used in a trial and the fact it was never admitted since 2000 in any Iowa court should tell someone something...

The brain fingerprinting claims in this case is even more of a joke still.

Zellner offers wild speculation that Halbach was getting something from the cargo hold and was hit from behind. She had no proof that this occurred it is just wild speculation on her part but she misrepresents it as fact. she had Farwell test if Avery had a memory of hitting her while she was retrieving something and he had no such memory so he was confident that Avery didn't hit her over the head as she was retrieving something from the cargo hold. Even if admissible it would be wholly useless in helping establish Avery's innocence. Not remembering something that didn't happen because Zellner made it up doesn't prove squat...


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • May 14 '23

Have we now concluded at some point (or two) in the history of the Avery family, however far you want to go back, the likelihood of first or second cousins breeding is 100%?

0 Upvotes

r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Sep 03 '16

TTM speculation based on extreme ignorance

1 Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/TickTockManitowoc/comments/50y1x0/if_not_dv_or_the_dairy_farm_then_what/

u/foghaze keeps posting a number of nonsense claims about cell tower historical date.

  • First and foremost the false claim someone has to be within a couple of miles of the cell tower for a phone to ping it.

"But numerous experts and telecommunications workers say the FBI analysis techniques are wrong: Cellphone signals do not always use the closest tower when in use but instead are routed by a computerized switching center to the tower that best serves the phone network based on a variety of factors. In addition, the range of cell towers varies greatly, and tower ranges overlap significantly, and the size and shape of a tower’s range shifts constantly, experts say."

“It is not possible,” Daniel said, “for anyone to reliably determine the particular coverage area of a cell-tower antenna after the fact based solely on historical cell-tower location data or call-detail records.” He said weather, time of day, types of equipment and technology, and call traffic all affect an antenna’s range.

Jeff Fischbach, a forensic expert from Los Angeles who assisted the defense in the Roberts case, said, “There are so many different factors [involved] that two cellular devices stationed next to each other making phone calls at the same moment could still get different towers. . . . I’ve seen proof that two individuals, subscribed to the same cellular provider, standing next to each other — on surveillance — can still get different towers.”

https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/experts-say-law-enforcements-use-of-cellphone-records-can-be-inaccurate/2014/06/27/028be93c-faf3-11e3-932c-0a55b81f48ce_story.html

Here are other links debunking such false notions:

http://educatedevidence.com/Viewpoint_J-F.pdf

http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/what-your-cell-phone-cant-tell-the-police

http://www.abajournal.com/magazine/article/prosecutors_use_of_mobile_phone_tracking_is_junk_science_critics_say/

https://www.fd.org/docs/training-materials/2013/MT2013/Law_Enforcement_Tracking.pdf

If police used these bogus claims TTM people would be tearing such apart , as would be proper, but because of their bias they are never consistent and simply argue whatever favors their cause not what is accurate.

What does this mean for the Avery case?

The tower in question is a GSM tower with the capability of a 21.7 mile range. Thus the 13 mile distance from the very lot is within the potential range. There is no way to try to figure out the exact range on 1/31/05 we only know the very lot would be within the potential range. Thus Halbach could have been at the Avery lot at 2:41. She also could have been anywhere else within the maximum coverage area.

  • The erroneous assumption she had to be within 2 miles of the tower is used not only to say she was within 2 miles of the tower but the absurd leap is made that she was either on her way to a location near the tower where she was kidnapped or was already kidnapped at this point.

Even if she had been within 2 miles of the tower at 2:41 totally ignored is the possibility she was driving to a location far away from the tower and simply passing by.

Also ignored is that if she was not at the Avery lot at 2:41 then she had not arrived yet and could not have been kidnapped at this point because she did in fact arrive at the Avery lot.

If she were within 2 miles of the tower at 2:41 all this would prove is that she could not have arrived at the Avery lot until 2:55 or later.

At most this would from Bobby Dassey was 10-15 minutes off in the times he provided.

Why do people even care about foghaze's insane speculations that are clearly contrary to fact? One has to wonder why u/numbnuts666 and the rest even care what she is alleging given every single basis of her claim from state to finish are always wrong.

Foghaze's claim Halbach had to be within 2 miles of the tower- wrong.

Foghaze's claim that Halbach had to either already be kidnapped at 2:42 or on her way to a location very close to the tower where she was kidnapped- wrong

Foghaze's claim Halbach had to have left the Avery lot no later than 2:25 to head towards the tower and be near it at 2:41 is patently false. At 2:12 she left a message on the Zipperer answering machine saying she was in their neighborhood looking for their house but was having trouble finding it and would be there in a few minutes. This evidences the intention to keep looking for their house and Mrs Zipperer confirms she visited between 2 and 2:30. This precludes Halbach being at the Avery lot from 2:15-2:25 no matter what u/foghaze wants to pretend.

Note how not a single poster from TTM bothers to refute her drivel but instead they run with it. That is exactly why TTM is closed off from most people they don't want the truth getting in the way of their nonsense fantasies and people posting the truth would do such.

They fancy themselves as great investigators and yet don't even refute the most obvious nonsense spouted there and instead run with it.

what they do it 1000 times worse than what they want to pretend Calumet police did in this investigation.


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Sep 08 '16

SATIRE SAIG reaches 1000 subscribers!

2 Upvotes

In celebration of us having reached 1000 subscribers, we've decided to add FOUR new mods!

  • NotaNestleShill will fill in for Watwattwo for a couple of weeks while he harvests truffles in North Carolina. He's just temporary, of course, but boy are we looking forward to his new adventure!

  • We'll also be welcoming NewYorkJohn to the team since he has a gift of stimulating discussion between truthers and guilters.

  • If that wasn't enough, we've also decided to add [deleted] and AKEnglish35!

Congratulations to our new moderation team!

Our page views are growing on the daily, and with these new additions we just know that SAIG will continue to be a blue ribbon sub!


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Feb 25 '19

“Stop trying to make ‘fetch’ happen. It’s never gonna happen!”

0 Upvotes

KratzRatz, zombies....they can’t even cooperate long enough to make a crappy nickname stick. Why they’re trying so hard is the question, given the insistence that they take “muppet” as a compliment. Current attempts to be on the same “nickname level” certainly don’t support that assertion, now do they?


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Feb 23 '19

Rules for proper discourse on the internet

1 Upvotes

We seem to be in a muppet frenzy of reporting, downvoting, and general "poor me, the victim." They love trying to enforce Reddit rules on us Fraggles, but they seem to apply the same Steven Avery double standard to their online behavior. Let's review some of the soft rules Reddit has listed that muppets break every single day:

  • Use proper grammar and spelling. Intelligent discourse requires a standard system of communication. Be open to gentle corrections.

  • Don't be (intentionally) rude at all. By choosing not to be rude, you increase the overall civility of the community and make it better for all of us.

  • Don't conduct personal attacks on other commenters. Ad hominem and other distracting attacks do not add anything to the conversation.

  • Don't troll. Trolling does not contribute to the conversation.

  • Don't downvote an otherwise acceptable post because you don't personally like it. Think before you downvote and take a moment to ensure you're downvoting someone because they are not contributing to the community dialogue or discussion. If you simply take a moment to stop, think and examine your reasons for downvoting, rather than doing so out of an emotional reaction, you will ensure that your downvotes are given for good reasons.

  • Don't mass downvote someone else's posts. If it really is the content you have a problem with (as opposed to the person), by all means vote it down when you come upon it. But don't go out of your way to seek out an enemy's posts.

  • Don't report posts just because you do not like them. You should only be using the report button if the post breaks the subreddit rules.

  • Don't editorialize or sensationalize your submission title.

I'm one that thinks Reddit, with the exception of doxxing and threats of ham against another user, should be a free for all where all users can share their opinions without restraint. However, muppets like to whine about how this isn't allowed or mean guilters made them feel bad about themselves. But then they go and break the gentlemen's rules each and everyday. Much like their use of the law in discussions, they only want rules applied to some, but not all. I've seen the 14th Amendment invoked recently, but the muppet seemed to forget it states laws must be all encompassing. Hypocrite much?


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Jun 08 '19

Trump and Avery Fans.

0 Upvotes

Lot of fatties groupies seem to divert onto their hatred of Donald??

Bit weird, He comes across as bit of cunt as well as Steven does. But as far as I know he's not a rapist and a peado like uncle Steven. That must be why they're not fans.

He was over here last week. Donald, not Steven. Mainly because Steven is locked up for murder of course.

Now I have been led to believe that there are Millions of Americans tirelessly fighting and working for Mr Avery. That there are quite simply millions of dedicated, intelligent, passionate and vocal supporters of this fat, sweating bucket of vile filth?

But when Donald was over here, and I watched him in Sky news with the queen and all the other shit. When Donald was here he didn't say Jack shit about the fat murdering cunt?

Why was that?


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • May 15 '16

What would MaM have looked like if they would have replaced "$36 million" with the FAR more likely "$2 million" in every mention of the suit?

1 Upvotes

Not sure it would have had the same ring with the truthers but who knows. It would have made the whole theory seem ridiculous.


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Aug 26 '16

TTM is disgusting

0 Upvotes

Yes, I said it. The disgusting shit they allow on that board is fucking despicable. I'm talking about this:

https://www.reddit.com/r/TickTockManitowoc/comments/4zoxfm/screenshot_i_found_while_wandering_the_interweb/

All this while not allowing anyone with a reasonable opinion to post so no one can defend the VICTIM'S brother.

TTM should be ashamed.

EDIT: I had to edit this three (make that four) times to correct all the typos. That's how pissed I am.


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Jun 03 '19

question

0 Upvotes

as per

TickTockManitowoc

Guilters. A question...knowing what you know about Bobby now.. if he was still Ken Kratz's star witness for the

prosecution, and Avery's conviction relied on him..Would you believe his testimony after all his lies?

edit to add

not a single guilter answered the question

just a lot of typical deflection and answering another question that was never asked


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Nov 17 '18

Why is Zellner so special?

5 Upvotes

By the way some of these alts are filling up my inbox you would think I've shit on the queens cornflakes!

Why does Zellner get a free pass from being laughed at? I mean she is fucking ridiculous for a start.

She's a joke. I actually LOVE that ugly woman. I mean I wouldn't be able to eat around her without something to vomit into, but, I just adore the way she lies to Averys disgusting parents.

Sat in that kitchen with the goblin. Telling those creatures their youngest sex offender will be home any day now. WHAT A JOKER!!! Pure class from old Zellldog!

But that still doesnt give her, and her alone a pass from being ripped at every level. I mean if she didn't want people laughing at her apperance she should of kept her fucking ugly lopsided face of the TV.

Just for the benefit of fair sided abuse.

Ken Kratz. His face looks like you would never get tired of punching it. Proper bellend. If he's the prize then I do not want to enter that fucking competion. He looks like a five year old drew him then threw up on the picture. Fat-sweaty-greasy I want that in my pigs NOT my attorneys.

But, he did put Avery away and for that he is 100x the attorney old zellcunt will EVER be.


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Aug 23 '16

Truthers and Fence sitters should admit the evidence proves Avery guilty beyond a reasonable doubt but they want proof he is guilty beyond all doubt.

0 Upvotes

Self-professed fence sitters constantly discount evidence on the same basis as truthers. In particular they discount the key, bullet with Halbachs DNA on it and Avery's blood in Halbach's vehicle saying they believe such evidence was planted even though there is no evidence to substantiate it. They just rely on specious truther claims to arrive at such. Discounting such evidence out of bias is not rational and fails to provide a rational basis to discount it but in any event even if the only physical evidence in this case was the burned evidence and Halbach's vehicle that sufficiently establishes Avery's guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

Excluding Avery's DNA in the vehicle, the bullet fited by Avery's gun with Halbach's DNA and her key with Avery's DNA this is the case against Avery:

  1. Avery chose to lure Halbach to the scene under the pretense of selling his sister's van.

  • Contrary to Avery's claim that his sister wanted to sell her van and asked him to take care of the sale she stated it was his idea for her to sell her van. She didn't want to sell it because it was only worth $1000, she wanted to give it to her son. He argued with her over it and she stated she didn't have the money for the fee. He told her he would pay the fee and was going to list it.

  • It is crystal clear he wanted to lure Halbach there and that this is why he wanted her to list the van. After it was clear that Halbach was missing and that the ad could not be listed Avery did not schedule to have new photos taken and did not have the van listed. He found out on 11/3 that the ad would not be listed.

  1. There are only 2 possible motives of why he decided to use Janda's van to lure Halbach there and thus gave Auto-trader the name B Janda and provided her phone number as the contact number knowing that she would not be home to answer the phone.

A) He knew he creeped Halbach out and she would not agree to come take photos for him anymore so he had to use someone else's name to get her to come

  • Avery arranged with Halbach directly to visit on October 10 instead of arranging it through Auto-Trader. She told Pliszka that he answered in a towel and creeped her out and said she didn't want to do the Manitowoc Route anymore. Pliszka convinced her to stay on.

  • Maybe Avery tried to call her directly again to get her to come put but she refused to answer his calls and he realized she was avoiding him so this is why he was forced to arrange it through Auto-Trader and decided to use his sister because he feared if she was told it was him she would refuse to go.

B) In anticipation of killing her he was thinking down the road and realized police would scrutinize her schedule and wanted to conceal from police that he wanted her there. Police scrutinizing it would see B Janda and even if they investigated and learned Avery is the one who met Halbach they would think that it was Barb's idea to have her come and that he just did his sister a favor. This conceals form police that he is the one who wanted her there and used the sale listing as a pretext to get her there.


These are the only 2 plausible reasons why he would use her name and number. They wanted a contact number to call to let the caller know if Halbach could make it. If he was honestly arranging it for his sister and not trying to hide anything then he would have announced he was arranging it for his sister and have provided his contact number for them to call back. Instead he provided a phone line he knew would not be answered. On top of that Auto-Trader said it was very hard to understand him it was like he was mumbling or muffling his voice. This suggests he was masking his voice perhaps trying to sound like a female. The bottom line is that either he was trying to keep Halbach from knowing the appointment was with him or he was trying to conceal from police that he made the appointment to lure Halbach there and wanted it to appear it was his sister's idea.

3) Avery told police Halbach parked near the van, that he met Halbach near the van and conducted the transaction by her vehicle and then she drove away. He said she was no where near his trailer. Bobby Dassey though contradicts him. Dassey said that he saw Halbach walking towards Avery's trailer. He said that he left around 3 and her vehicle was still there but she was not outside anywhere. This means she must have been inside Avery's house or garage at the time.

*The last time she spoke to anyone over the phone was prior to arriving at the Avery lot when she spoke to Pliszka from 2:27-2:31.

*The last time Halbach was seen alive she was when she was walking towards Avery's trailer. No one saw her alive after that. Thus there is no evidence Halbach left the Avery property alive.

5) There is zero evidence that Halbach's vehicle ever left the Avery property

  • Her vehicle was found concealed at a remote location on the outskirts of the Avery lot. It was so well concealed that it could only be seen if you were right next to it. It was near a pond where few people would go other than the family to shoot and from the location where they typically shot it could not be seen.

  • No witnesses other than Bobby saw her vehicle because it was gone by the time Fabian and Earl visited. It also was not there when the Dassey boys got home.

Evidence suggests that Avery initially hid her vehicle in his garage and her body inside the cargo area. Her blood was found in the cargo area and it was consistent with blood transfer stains from her hair. Witnesses said he was suspiciously working outside of his garage to get his skimobile off its trailer but made sure to keep the door closed so no one could see inside.

  • Brendan Dassey said that Avery used this snowmobile trailer to drag her body to the fire pit.

  1. Shortly after Halbach's visit Avery was observed lighting a large bonfire and also fire in his burn barrel.

  • Around the same exact time that Halbach's phone was destroyed Fabian and Earl Avery saw a fire in Avery's burn barrel and Fabian said it smelled like burning plastic.

  • In the ashes of Avery's burn barrel police found remnants of electronic items. The lab managed to establish that these electronic items were a specific brand and model of phone, camera and PDA. Police then investigated what kind of phone, PDA and camera Halbach had owned and it wound up that they were the same exact brand/models Halbach had owned.

  • In the ashes of the burn pit police found burned bone fragments that wound up being proven to belong to Halbach further supporting that Halbach had not left alive and that her body had been burned by Avery. Also in such ashes were the zipper and rivets to Halbach's jeans.

  • Some of her bone fragments were also found in one of Barb Janda's burn barrels. That night Avery had also used Barb's burn barrels. There are only 2 realistic ways for the bones to have gotten in the Janda barrel. A) They were on top of the burn pit and Avery decided they were too obviously bone so he took a shovel and dumped them in the barrel to conceal them or B) He decided to take an item that was in the burn pit and move it to the burn barrel to further burn it in the barrel and when he shoveled such item he also got some bone in the shovel load.

  • Numerous witnesses say that Avery had these fires going on 10/31 he even admitted it to Barb in a phone call that was tape recorded but before the remains were discovered Avery lied to police insisting that the last time he ever burned garbage or tires was a week prior to Halbach's visit. He didn't just change the date from 10/31 to November 1 or something like that he made sure to say there were no fires period after Halbach visited. Saying that on Nov 4 and 6 he had no idea these remains were in the ashes of his fires and that he simply forgot that he had a fire on 10/31 and made an honest error thinking it had been a week prior to Halbach's visit is not in the least bit convincing. The evidence supports that he lied on purpose because he didn't want police to know he had fires because then police would suspect he was destroying evidence in those fires.

  • Aside from witnesses saying tires were burned in the bonfire and that it was a huge fire there were and steel belts from the tires that prove they were burned int he fire. Experts say that the size and intensity of such a fire is able to burn flesh, fat and organs and also to cause the burn damage the bone fragments suffered.

  • The skull fragments exhibited at least 2 bullet entrance wounds to the head proving she had been shot before she was burned. Avery possessed a 22 caliber rifle capable of delivering such shots and there were multiple spent casings from such rifle in his garage.

  1. Prior to Halbach's arrival Avery phoned her 2 times to make sure she was still coming. Both times he masked his caller ID. This suggests he did not want her to know the caller was him. After she was dead he phoned again but this time he did not use caller ID block supporting he knew she was dead. Furthermore this call appears to simply have been part of a cover he was attempting to construct. His claim that she left prior to 3 and that he called her at 4:35 to ask her to come take photos of another vehicle is not convincing in the least. His claim he thought an hour and a half or more later she would still be in the area is not credible particularly since he knew she didn't work too late. Around the same time he made this call he lied by telling Fabian and his brothers that she didn't show up. It appears he made the call with the intention of claiming he called her to find out why she didn't show up. However, he later found out Bobby had seen her so he scratched that plan and instead ran with the claim he was calling her to ask her to return since that would suggest she had actually left. he knew she was dead and that her phone had already been destroyed and thus didn't bother masking his caller ID though.


If one views all this evidence in an objective rational manner it establishes beyond a reasonable doubt that Avery intentionally lured Halbach to his property, killed her, burned her belongings and body and concealed her vehicle among junked vehicles.

Beyond a reasonable doubt doesn't mean beyond all doubt even doubt that is unreasonable. It means beyond doubts that are reasonable. In order for doubt to be reasonable it has to be reasonably likely to have occurred.

The law views this from the standpoint of an objective reasonable person. Some nut might subjectively believe that some wild thing is reasonable but that doesn't make it so. For instance some nut might decide it is reasonable to believe that the US was behind 9/11 but from an objective standpoint it is unreasonable. When something has no support and is not logical it is unreasonable to believe it.

The only way for Avery to be innocent is if:

A)

  • Avery lured Halbach there just because he wanted to see her and had no intention of hurting her and didn't hurt her

  • Halbach left the Avery property

  • Someone else grabbed Halbach shortly thereafter

  • destroyed her phone by coincidence at the same time Avery was burning something plastic in his burn barrel

  • by coincidence burned her body

  • the killer or police decided to frame Avery and planted her vehicle on the Avery lot, planted her remains in Avery's pit and some in the Janda burn barrel, planted the zipper and rivets from her jeans in the burn pit and finally planted the remains of the electronic items in his burn barrel.

or

B)

  • Avery lured Halbach there just because he wanted to see her and had no intention of hurting her and didn't hurt her

  • Avery lied about seeing Halbach drive way from the lot

  • Earl or Chuck kidnapped Halbach after Steven finished with her tying her up somewhere

  • Hid her vehicle somewhere

  • Immediately went back to work so no one woudl knwo anythign was wrong and thus Fabian was able to find them working

  • After work they went to where they stashed her and killed her

  • They ran to Avery's fires when no one was looking and put her body and belongings inside or alternatively burned her body and belongings in different fires that somehow no one ever saw and could tell police about and then they later planted the remains in his ashes the Janda barrel and the remains of the property in his burn barrel

  • Decided to move her vehicle from wherever they hid it temporarily to the pit where it was concealed.

Is it objectively reasonable for someone to believe either of these scenarios? NO! It is totally unreasonable for someone to believe either of these scenarios happened based putely on unsupported allegations.

Making the allegations would help establish there is unreasonable doubt and prevent the evidence from establishing Avery's guilt beyond all doubt but would fail to establish reasonable doubt.

A reasonable objective person would not believe that Earl ran and grabbed her and hid her and her vehicle then went back to work and hung out with Fabian and went to buy glasses, returned home, ate dinner with his family and then took her body from wherever he hid it and put it in Avery's fire with no one seeing him do it and then hid her vehicle. Nor would a reasonable person believe that he burned her elsewhere then planted the ashes.

while Chuck live alone there there is nothing to suggest he did any such thing either. It is unreasonable to believe this happened without evidence to prove it happened.

It is likewise unreasonable to believe she left alive and someone else killed her and burned her body then planted the vehicle and her remains on the Avery lot. The notion someone else grabbed her and asked her about her day to find out her last appointment so he could go hide the vehicle and body where she had her last appointment is not believable without proof it happened. It is not reasonable to believe that happened without proof let alone that such person planted some of the remains in a Janda burn barrel. how would someone even know Avery had a burn pit?

Notions that police found the vehicle and remains elsewhere and decided to plant them are likewise something no rational person would believe without evidence.

From an objective standpoint the evidence establishes his guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

Truthers and fence sitters refuse to view the evidence in an objective fashion. Instead what they do is use bias to justify their subjective feelings that there is a good chance someone else did it and that the evidence was planted and then make up that such irrational feelings constitutes reasonable doubt. it doesn't such irrational views fail to establish reasonable doubt. Such irrational feelings can only justify saying he is not guilty beyond all doubt.

Truthers and fence sitters will provide a laundry list of things that demonstrate their bias and inform their irrational views but have nothing to do with the evidence.

Being unhappy about his 1985 conviction in no way affects the question of whether it is reasonable to believe someone else killed Halbach and Avery was framed. Nothing that happened in the 1985 case offers any ability to establish it is reasonable to believe someone else killed Halbach and he was framed.

Being unhappy about press conferences calumet County held offers no ability to establish it is reasonable to believe someone else killed Halbach and he was framed.

A reasonable objective person would not believe someone else killed Avery and police planted her remains simply because Ertl didn't take photos of the pit before he excavated it. He explained that the crime lab doesn't take photos when a scene was altered before they arrived and he thought the scene was altered. No rational objective person would view such as proof that police found the fragments elsewhere and then planted them in the pit and in the Janda burn barrel which is ludicrous. Planting some of the remains in Janda's burn barrel to frame Avery makes zero sense the remains would have been planted in the burn pit simply.

Here is what had to happen for police to have planted the evidence:

  • Someone else would have to have killed Halbach and burned her body and property

  • More than a dozen personnel from 4 different agencies including the crime lab would have to have entered into a conspiracy

  • The conspirators had to have found the burned remains/property somewhere other than the Avery site

  • The conspirators would have to have instantly known the burned remains/property were Halbach's though that is impossible

  • The conspirators would have to have decided to let the real killer go and frame Avery

  • The conspirators would have to have created zero records related to responding to where they found the evidence and have taken no photos because they instantly decided to pretend they found the evidence at the Avery lot. They had to create a false record trail of these people having spent the day at the Avery lot.

  • Ertl had to have lied in this email about taking no photos of the pit before Excavation because he thought the scene had been disturbed and instead the reason what because he simply made up excavating the remains from the pit they were found elsewhere and the email had to be a fraud created just to give Ertl and Calumet cover.

http://www.stevenaverycase.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/Trial-Exhibit-160-Email-Between-Fassbender-And-Ertl.pdf

  • For some illogical reason they would have to have pretended they found some remains in the Janda burn barrel instead of pretending they found them all in Avery's pit.

Would any reasonable person believe the above happened without substantial evidence proving it happened? The honest answer is no. So the possibility of the above happening is remote and fails to establish reasonable doubt.

If bias, emotion and a lack of logic cause people to choose to irrationally believe there is a strong possibility the above happened that doesn't magically mean such creates reasonable doubt. It just means such people hold irrational views. Such irrational views can't prevent reasonable doubt from existing which is an objective measure.

At the end of the day what such people would say if they are honest is that yes the evidence establishes Avery to be guilty beyond a reasonable doubt but I personally still doubt his guilt because I want evidence proving guilt beyond all doubt not just beyond a reasonable doubt.


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Aug 22 '16

FORMAL For the wiki: What are our main criticisms of Avery supporters?

0 Upvotes

/u/adelltfm has done a great job reorganizing our wiki! Go have a look there -- kudos, adelltfm!

While we were discussing the wiki, it occurred to me that one thing we might want to have in the wiki FAQ section is a statement of why we on SAIG have been critical of a lot of the theories and other posts that we have seen on other MaM subreddits or elsewhere, and even here on SAIG.

Thus I wanted to make this post to request input from people who believe Avery is guilty, asking for them to say why it is that they have been critical of the ideas/arguments/theories posed by Avery supporters.

We will then link to this thread from our wiki's FAQ section.

This is not an opportunity to bash truthers or to troll SAIG. It is actually a serious question, and this thread will be heavily moderated to remove anything - from either "side" - that is not thoughtful and respectful.


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Nov 02 '23

If Wisconsin had the death penalty, should Avery and/or Dassey have received it?

0 Upvotes

Guten Morgen abusers of muppet Kotzbrocken!

So Wisconsin was one of the first States to abolish the death penalty, in 1853. Only one person was executed, and the death penalty was repealed after the State had difficulty hanging someone. A poll in 2006 showed that 55.5% of people in Wisconsin wanted the death penalty reinstated.

So, if the death penalty had been available when Avery and Dassey were sentenced, should either of them have received it?

Although Dassey is younger, he was also convicted of more - rape and corpse mutilation as well as murder, while Avery was only convicted of murder and felon in possesssion of firearm.


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Feb 25 '19

Remand? Didn't we just get off this ride?

0 Upvotes

Seems that this is just another dip down to the trial court for a denial of a new Motion just like the CDs.

Same crap. Different month.


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Apr 30 '21

What I will be testing tonight.

0 Upvotes

I live on a very dark lonely dead end road. Thank goodness its not the last house on the left. I have a jeep comparable in size and height to a Rav4. In fact I think they are identical. I have a 6' husband if he is not willing. I can get the brother tomorrow or even find a bum some place. I went to party city getting a santa beard . I will have one of them couch down as I drive past. In a car and than a 4x4 to see what I can determine about the physical appearance and size of the person. As I approach the jeep I have to swerve to the side of the road maintain control and vision of said person. I will go better and get a neighbor to go behind the Jeep as if pushing it, than stand clear.

I am guessing my Zellner will yield nothing at 20-25 mph that speeding up to 35ish and swerving. Leaving me about 3 seconds of viewing time, not overly distracted.

Place your bets now. I'm also sorry can not record this. I will be doxing mail boxes, names and addresses, myself and family members.


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Aug 11 '16

FORMAL The bones from the quarry dirt pile

0 Upvotes

Avery supporters often cite the bones in the dirt pile as evidence that Halbach was burned elsewhere. Does the evidence support such though?

First of all what exactly was found in the dirt pile?

  • 13 burned bones

  • numerous unburned bones

2 of the unburned bones had cut marks while 8 of the burned bones had cut marks. These cut marks were clean cuts definitely made by a human using some sort of slicing or cutting instrument.

Many of the bones both burned and unburned were definitely animal bones. 3 of the burned bones could not be ruled out as being human- they could have been human or could have been animal bones. They were among the bones that were cut. They could potentially have been part of a human pelvis though it is just as possible they were not human.

Note that this dirt pile was not a burn site so they can't have been burned exactly where they were found. So the following conclusions can be drawn:

  • Someone cut up an animal and burned at least some of it

  • This person mixed up some of the burned bone with the unburned bone of the same animal or another animal

  • The person then dumped the mixture in a pile of dirt in the quarry

The above definitely occurred. We have no idea where the bone fragments from that pile that were burned were actually burned we only know it wasn't in the place where they were found.

Now comes the "what ifs". If the 3 pelvic fragments were from an animal then the above is the end of the matter and that's all that happened.

But if the 3 pelvic bone fragments were human then the following additional things happened:

Someone burned a human and at some stage cut up the pelvis. For some reason the person who did this took several pieces of the burned pelvis and relocated them to the dirt pile in the quarry. It could have been the same person who dumped the animal bones, the person could have mixed the animal bones in with the pelvic bones to try to help hide them, or it could have been a different person who came across the bones someone else left and thought it was a good place to conceal the 3 pelvic pieces.


Since there is a big IF as to whether the pelvic bones are human or animal they hold no real value or significance in this case.

But just to be complete and to deal with the wild conspiracies people love to toss around let's go the extra mile.

If the pelvic fragments were human and belonged to Halbach what would that mean occurred?

It would mean someone cut up Halbach's pelvis before or after burning her and took several portions of the pelvis and dumped it in the dirt pile in the quarry. The same person either mixed them with various animal bones they had cut up, some of which they burned, and dumped this mess together or simply came across a few bones laid there by someone else and decided to mix the pelvic fragments in with the already present bones.

If this happened would it in any way help suggest she wasn't burned in Avery's burn pit? No because all it proves is she was burned somewhere else and Avery's pit is somewhere else.

Let's go through the universe of possibilities if they were Halbach's bones:

  1. Halbach was burned in Avery's pit then some of her bones were added to the Janda burn barrel either on purpose or while moving something else to that barrel and they just so happened to be included and at some point cut the pelvic bone up and 3 of the pelvic bone fragments were dumped out in the quarry but most bones remained in the burn pit.

  2. Halbach was burned in Janda's burn barrel then most of her bones as well as the zipper and rivets from her jeans were added to the burn pit but several bone fragments were left behind in Janda's barrel and the person who burned her cut up the pelvic bone and 3 of the pelvic bone fragments were dumped out in the quarry.

  3. Halbach was burned somewhere other than Avery's pit or Janda's burn barrel and then someone moved most of the ash and bones to Avery's burn pit including all of the rivets and zipper from Halbach's jeans, moved several of the bones to Janda's burn barrel and cut up the pelvic bone then took 3 of the pelvic bone fragments and dumped them in the quarry.

Out of these 3 the most likely is the first. The last one makes no sense period. It doesn't make sense for Avery to do the last one nor would it make sense for someone else who is trying to frame Avery to do the last one. Why would someone who was trying to frame him dump some random bones in the Janda burn barrel and dump some pelvic bones in the quarry? You would dump them all in Avery's fire pit.

Even though the first one is the most likely out of these 3 it still seems odd that Avery would bother cutting her pelvis and taking a few pieces to dump in the quarry. The most likely scenario is that the pelvic bones were not human but rather animal and that the same person who cut the other bones also cut the pelvis and dumped random burned and unburned bones the person had no use for. There was a hunting area nearby after all.


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Jan 21 '19

I want a talking Trans Am so bad!

0 Upvotes

Apparently, the wrong people were called in to investigate Teresa's murder. David Boreanaz and Emily Deschanel, despite having played characters who caught murderers would have solved the murder and exonerate dAvery and Dassey in 47 minutes, before they were even suspected of a crime. You know, after David Caruso took his sunglasses off and put them back on multiple times before finding Avery's semen everywhere, but no matter the crime, the criminal always leaves semen everywhere. One can only dream that my car can turbo boost.


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Jul 25 '16

The George Zipperer Nonsense

0 Upvotes

The story goes that George Zipperer was home with his wife instead of at work. He saw Halbach on his property and decided to shoot first ask questions later so shot and killed her. Then he had his police friends help him plant evidence to frame Avery.

Days later the Calumet police call and even though he wants to not let anyone know he shot her he tells them that if she comes to his property he will shoot her. Yeah that makes lots of sense....


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Aug 30 '16

u/foghaze knows as much about cell phone technology as Hillary Clinton knows about email server technology

3 Upvotes

Month after month u/foghaze posts analysis about cell tower data that demonstrates he or she doesn't have the first clue how a cell phone works.

In post after post including this most recent one:

https://np.reddit.com/r/TickTockManitowoc/comments/50b4w7/the_revelation_of_the_tower_ping_at_241_proves_dp/

u/foghaze insists that Halbach's phone had to be right next to the last tower it pinged as if such tower has a range of only 1 mile.

  • A GSM tower has a maximum range of 19.7 miles. The exact range will vary from one moment to another depending on the exact conditions. A variety of factors affect range and there is no way for historical information to enable people to reconstruct the maximum range at some point in the past.

  • It used to be believed that a provider would connect to the cell tower that was the closest or that had the strongest signal. This had been thoroughly debunked. Also thoroughly debunked is the notion historical data from one point in time could be applied to a different point in time to know which tower has the strongest signal or the exact range. We now know that what what tower gives off the strongest signal chances moment to moment as does the range and provider switching equipment chooses towers in a way that can't be predicting with 100% accuracy and thus it is improper to jump to any conclusions about location based thereupon.

  • The only current scientifically accepted principle is that when a call pings a GSM tower that means the person had to be within the maximum effective range of the tower (19.7 miles).

  • To determined the maximum coverage area of a tower you measure 19.7 miles in all directions from the tower.

  • We don't know if the Whitelaw tower is the actual tower connected to at 2:41 we just know Zellner alleges it is.

  • If one uses a compass and map to map out the maximum coverage area of the Whitelaw Tower the Avery lot is squarely inside of the maximum coverage area. One doesn't even need to map it out since Zellner admits it is 13 miles away from the Avery lot. Obviously since the maximum coverage area is 19.7 miles away then 13 miles is inside the range.

  • Halbach's phone could have been anywhere inside this coverage area.

  • u/foghaze misrepresents that Halbach's phone had to be right by the tower as if the tower has only a 1 mile range instead of 19.7 mile range.

  • Using this false proposition u/foghaze then says this means she and her phone had to be 13 miles away from the Avery lot at 2:41 when the call was received. The truth is that Halbach could have been anywhere in the coverage area including at the Avery lot. The cell data is unable to pinpoint where within the coverage area she was.

  • The reality is that historical data can't be uses to accurately assess with any precision where within a coverage area one was when a call was received or made. Only in real-time while the call is taking place can the location of a phone be triangulated. It is called triangulation because multiple phone towers are being used. Once a call ends the only record that is retained is the last cell tower the phone connected to not any of the other towers and thus there is no way to attempt to triangulate a call once it is ended.


In conclusion if the Whitelaw tower was used it does not rule out Halbach being at the Avery lot at 2:41. She could have been there or anywhere else within the maximum coverage area. An eyewitness as well as circumstantial evidence supports that at 2:41 she was at the Avery lot.


It is bad enough that u/foghaze has so thoroughly misrepresented the cell tower data to pretend that it proves at 2:41 she was located within a mile of the tower that was pinged. But even worse u/foghaze makes other giant leaps from such error such as ridiculously claiming that because she was located 13 miles away at 2:41 this proves Dawn Plizska lied about speaking to Halbach at 2:27.

The call at 2:27 lasts 5 minutes too. Which would mean she would be at least 5 min from Avery's. She hangs up at 2:32. Now only 9 minutes to get back to this tower. From Avery's just to get close to the tower she pings at 2:41 it would take 16 minutes from Avery's. She has to get back to it by 2:41 and she only has 9 minutes after she hangs up with DP and she obviously not there because "she was on the phone with Dawn, on her way there". If she hasn't even arrived at Avery's and it takes 16 minutes to get back in this area that means that phone call did not happen. It was not Dawn which means it was someone else and they are covering it up. The most important call of the day. The last known contact anyone has with her and they COVERED IT UP! I've said it from the beginning and now we have proof.

One has to seriously wonder what planet u/foghaze is from. The phone records from Auto-trader prove Dawn called Halbach at 2:27. Halbach's phone records prove that Auto-trader called Halbach at 2:27. The claim that cell tower data can prove this call didn't happen is absurd.

*If in fact Halbach was within 1 mile of the Whitelaw tower at 2:41 all this would prove is that at 2:27 Halbach was no more than 14 minutes driving distance from the Whitelaw tower. That is the most such could prove. This would have no ability to prove the 2:27 call did not take place. Records prove the call did take place.

  • Even if Halbach were 16 minutes away from the Avery lot at 2:41 all this would prove is that she didn't arrive at the Avery lot until 2:57 or later. This would not in any way support that Halbach had already been to the Avery lot because there is no way she could have arrived at the Avery lot subsequent to 2:32, completed the assignment, left and be 13 miles away at 2:41.

*So even if we were to assume that Halbach were at the Whitelaw tower at 2:41 it would in no way help establish she left the Avery lot alive.

But the claim she had to be no more than a mile from the tower in order to be able to have received the 2:41 call is absurd she could have been up to 19.7 miles away.

Not to be outdone u/foghaze makes this ridiculous claim as well:

If she pings this same tower at 1:52 that means she was at Avery's about 2:12.

Once again u/foghaze is assuming at 1:52 Halbach had to be within 1 mile of this tower.

The distance from the tower to Zipperer is less than the time it would take to drive to Avery. Why could she not make it to the Zipperer neighborhood by 2:12 if she could make it to Avery (which is further away) by 2:12?

Nothing u/foghaze claims ever makes sense. He or she just makes up nonsense.

Links about how cell tower data has been incorrectly interpreted in the past and why courts are no longer being swayed by it including convictions that used such junk science being reversed:

These links are worth reading about the fallacy of cell tower data:

https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/experts-say-law-enforcements-use-of-cellphone-records-can-be-inaccurate/2014/06/27/028be93c-faf3-11e3-932c-0a55b81f48ce_story.html

http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/what-your-cell-phone-cant-tell-the-police

http://educatedevidence.com/Viewpoint_J-F.pdf

http://www.abajournal.com/magazine/article/prosecutors_use_of_mobile_phone_tracking_is_junk_science_critics_say/

https://www.fd.org/docs/training-materials/2013/MT2013/Law_Enforcement_Tracking.pdf


Edit u/foghaze

Asserted some new nonsense in the followup posts:

There are towers around here that are spaced about 3 miles apart.

In 2005 there were not towers every 3 miles and not all towers that exist are necessarily online. The claim the tower only would have a 3 mile coverage area is sheer nonsense.

Her cell would pick up the closest radio frequency. The only time you are routed to another tower is if it's full and congested. Routing happens in large cities not in rural areas on a normal day.

More nonsense. Cell towers have overlapping coverage. Routing is done by switching centers far away and will often have nothing to do with which tower has the strongest signal. This is exactly the kind of bunk that was rejected in the links I posted and which has resulted in convictions based on such false claim being overturned.


r/StevenAveryIsGuilty • • Feb 22 '19

To catch a muppet.....

4 Upvotes

Bait hook with something tasty, muppets are very keen on fantasy. Be sure the bait has zero credibility and would be dismissed immediately by a child of 5 years old.

Tangle said bait in a septic pool of dysfunctional deluded loners with a sick fantasy about incarcerated murderers..

Boom MUPPET ON A HOOK.

HMONG

HMONNNNNGGGG

bhaaaaaaaaaaaa