r/Stargate • • Jul 22 '25

Ask r/Stargate My SG1 hot take

6 Upvotes

Vala was a terrible addition to SG1 and served no purpose other than to be an attempt at comedic relief, which was often just sex jokes and knob gags.

Love Claudia Black, Ms Maldoran was not a bad side character, but shouldn't have been included as a permanent resident.


r/Stargate • • Jun 01 '24

What's up with the new sub icon?

0 Upvotes

It's ugly - what's up with it? Is it meant to be some weird lgbtq+ flag or similar? If so, aren't there any other ways to be supportive/aware of lgbtq+ issues (or whatever it's meant to reference) that doesn't require to vandalize the stargate? Like for example treating them like, you know, everyone else?


r/Stargate • • Nov 19 '23

SGU is a total drag

2 Upvotes

I am a big fan Stargate. I just recently rewatched Stargate SG-1 and Stargate Atlantis and am now watching Stargate Universe for the first time.

Is it just me or is SGU a total drag? I feel zero connection to any of the characters and have little to no interest in the plot line. It just falls so flat for me in terms of what Stargate is. I’m determined to watch both seasons but it’s been rough.


r/Stargate • • Aug 12 '25

Fan-Art Earth point of origin pixel art I did on wplace.live

Post image
134 Upvotes

r/Stargate • • Sep 22 '26

Discussion "The Asgard went too far in their cloning and couldn't reverse the process", I don't buy it.

0 Upvotes

The Asgard are, for lack of a better adjective, super smart.

I don't buy the fact that they couldn't just whip up a new body or make a flawless one from scratch. They could have even gone back in time 10 million years, grabbed a DNA sample and come back. For me, I feel like this is a major plot hole. Surely I can't be the only one?

Then there's the issue with the rapidly progressing disease. I'm unsure whether it was a body disease or one of the mind.

Like, you're really saying that the smartest race in the galaxy couldn't whip up a biological body? If I had to be charitable, I would say they had the technological means to do so but did not possess the ability of the mind, to do so. Almost like how in Doctor Who, Donna was able to do things the Doctor couldn't because of the "instinct" that comes with being a human.


r/Stargate • • Dec 09 '23

Discussion Bringing in Mitchell to lead SG1 was such a mistake. It should have been Sam.

0 Upvotes

I don't hate Mitchell or anything, or even really dislike him. But he always seemed kind of bland, and at the same time trying too hard.

The team never seemed to really accept him as the new leader in spirit, especially teal'c who would outright just often ignore his orders.

Bringing in a brand new character at this point just didn't seem necessary, although I'm glad we got Vala. But why wouldn't they pick Sam to lead SG1? I know in universe she was moving on to other things and wasn't interested, but I'm not sure if that's really consistent with her character.

IIRC the real reason was they were trying to inject new energy into the show and attract new viewers, but IMO this wasn't the way to do it. Sam absolutely should have been leading SG1 as the next most qualified and experienced after Jack.

Does anyone disagree?

Edit: It's funny how much people do seem to disagree, I guess Mitchell really grew on people. After searching a bit after making this post, I found some posts suggesting something similar which people largely agreed with, although they were much closer to when season 9 was new.


r/Stargate • • Sep 02 '26

I can’t watch universe

2 Upvotes

I have tried really hard to and have seen the amount of positive feedback that universe has gotten

However I can’t watch it due to the moving camera. I just can’t focus and it bothers me to the end is time the fact that every scene is like that bothers me. I can not get past it. I have tried to watch the series on multiple occasions. But I can’t get past the first episode.


r/Stargate • • Aug 07 '26

Toasting a fallen comrade with Coors light is poor form imo

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Stargate • • Aug 02 '24

Discussion probably a pretty popular opinion: Colonel young is the worst character in the entire stargate franchise Spoiler

0 Upvotes

So i’m watching SGU and I wouldn’t go as far to say Colonel Young is the cringiest character I’ve ever seen, but he’s definitely the cringiest character in Stargate. For one, he’s just an ass. He’s definitely not fit to lead the command and get anyone home. He doesn’t even try to work with anyone and when things don’t go his way just beats people up or tries to kill them, and these are people that he’s supposed to be getting along with. I think in one episode I saw him beat up 3 different people because he didn’t get his way. The only time i agreed with him was the Telford/Wife situation but other than that dudes a nut. I do not like this man. I made a post before about SGU portraying jack o neil with 2 Ls as kind of an asshole in this series & changing his character up but I understand why he was acting the way he was. He’s gotta deal with this ding dong.


r/Stargate • • Aug 22 '24

I don’t really like Ronan Dex.

6 Upvotes

He just comes off as such a jackass, and never really moves or grows past it. He’s got his moments, but it’s like they went too hard on the badass angle that Teyla already had covered to compensate, but forgot to make him a well-rounded person.

He shoots stuff; he’s blunt; he’s selfish; and he’s rude. And all of that keeps through to the end, which you can see when he throws himself at Keller just because Rodney and her had vibes going on between them. He’s a bully.

I dunno, I’m in the middle of a(nother) rewatch and it’s his second episode and I’m just over him already.


r/Stargate • • Mar 21 '26

Funny I couldn't unsee it, so I made a gif

0 Upvotes

"Since 1994" is a bonus


r/Stargate • • Dec 04 '24

Discussion Anyone else weirded out by the heavy Christian stuff in Stargate: Universe?

2 Upvotes

Don’t get me wrong, I’ve nothing against Christianity. But the references to God and Jesus in SGU seem a little over the top.

From the first couple episodes I thought it was just character building for Lt. Scott, but I’m on S1E15 and it almost seems like the entire series was written to proselytize Christianity. Virtually every episode there’s a sermon, sometimes subtle, often explicit. It’s as if a hardcore Catholic took control of the franchise and wanted to compensate for the agnostic/atheistic implications in the premise of the previous series’. Again? I’m not bothered by Christianity, and if this was a standalone TV series I wouldn’t give it a moment’s thought, but it feels really out of place for Stargate.

Also the entire series is just weird compared to SG:1 and Atlantis. Very different cinematography, much darker (figuratively and literally), feels too modern if that makes sense. But Lt. Scott is cute so I can’t complain.


r/Stargate • • Jan 10 '16

I just noticed that Baal had a little more than a normal goatee late in Season 8. Then I noticed the resemblance....

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/Stargate • • Jun 24 '26

This is how it went:

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Stargate • • Aug 15 '25

Am I the only one who really really wants to see a combat focused Stargate Spinoff?

2 Upvotes

There’s one episode in season 9 or 10 where SG-1 arrives from off world HEAVILY armed. Teal’c was carrying one of those death glider mounted heavy cannons and Mitchell (was S9 or 10) is carrying a M249.

I’ve thought ever since this episode aired that it would make an amazing spin off if they were to produce a show with nothing but one episode after another of just hard combat missions being run to enemy planets.

Think of the gritty, gnarly darkness of off world assaults on enemy territory and the storylines that could make for….

Weapons grade Naquadah raids gone wrong (like more detail on when Gen. Bauer came in and messed things up), assassination missions to nearby strongholds taking on low level Goa’uld warlords and their Jaffa, technology raids to seize weapons and

I always felt like the potential for deeper, longer combat missions with other non SG-1 teams could be amazing. I always wanted to see Carter or someone else with Naquadah in their system rip it up with a hand device on an open battlefield.


r/Stargate • • Oct 02 '23

Discussion I don't care for Jennifer

40 Upvotes

I want to be abundantly clear: I like Jewel Staite. I loved her as Kaylee in Firefly. I have no issues with her performance.

It's the writing.

And I also want to be abundantly clear before the angry man babies jump in (they will anyway and my rule is that I will not respond to them or anyone trying to be malicious), I love Stargate. I love SG-1, SGA, I even like parts of Universe even if I think it flopped as a whole.

This being said: the show has trouble writing women characters.

"But Sam!" You cry "But Janet!"

Those two are semi-exceptions. Sam and Janet are great... most of the time. I won't get into it too much but Sam's romance life is so weird. They either die or disappear, I believe even Amanda Tapping referred to it as a curse or something.

Not to mention that replicator bad guy with the mommy complex, ew.

My only problem is Janet is that we don't have more of her :'(

Now let's get into the problems: Vala, Teyla, Elizabeth, and Jennifer -- I am NOT getting into the Universe characters. If they're not Ming-Na Wen's character, they were written very very badly.

Again, to be clear, I love Vala. She's one of my favourite characters. The writers treat her AWFUL. It's Deeana Troi all over again (for non Star Trek watchers, Troi is a decent character but her focus episodes tend to be rape-y).

Vala gets mystical pregnancied, she gets tortured, she watches her kid die and has to participate in that, Daniel treats her like shit and then they get together.

Like, what. Also, they make her kind of kid like with a bunch of trauma and a leather fetish, all because of sexualization and not to examine where any of that comes from.

Again, I love Vala. I just hate the way they write her.

Teyla. Unfortunately she falls under what is called the "noble savage" trope. Where the non-white character is primitive but noble and stoic.

https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/NobleSavage

It's actually a very problematic trope but I'm not going to get into it so please see the above link.

Also, sorry, but Teyla is often boring. The problem is I want to like her but they don't give her a lot to do. Oh yeah, and they make her run around in these impractical skimpy little outfits which makes no sense because over sexualization.

Also they made her pregnancy special for no reason. They couldn't just had her have a regular pregnancy and kid but noooo.

Elizabeth... I might be a little in love with her, she gives me Janeway vibes (Star Trek character). But if I'm in love with her, what's the problem? Weeeelll the way they wrote her off was freaking weird. I understand that actors leave shows but the choices they made, with the many recasts and the replicator people thing. Strange. Weird. Did not like. Uncomfortable.

I also won't go into the over sexualization of the one off (or reoccurring) women folk characters that show up in episodes. Like Anise. The fuck did they make her wear.

Okay I got carried away. I wanted to talk about Jennifer.

I don't think she's a character. I think she's literally just a love interest for Rodney. And such a boring one too.

She doesn't really have a personality. She's nice, I guess, she's pretty, but she's really only there to turn down Ronan and go for Rodney even though it doesn't really give any reason why. It's not like she hangs out a bunch with Rodney and shares interests with him.

It's kind of like when they try to write John/Teyla. No chemistry.

They respect each other, sure, they are even friends, but they don't seem to spend all that much time together if they don't have to.

The people that spend the most off time together are John and Rodney. They're constantly racing their cars or playing their games. Those two have more chemistry than Rodney/Jennifer ever did.

Anyway, to sum up, I hope if they make more Stangate content in the future that they do better with their women characters (and non white characters and queer characters and so on and so forth).

Again, I am going to reiterate, people who respond with attacks or blatant misogyny/bigotry in general, will not be responded to.


r/Stargate • • Oct 23 '24

Funny How did they not see it?

0 Upvotes

r/Stargate • • May 06 '25

What the!? Elon is a Goa'uld! 😂 S5 E15

Post image
0 Upvotes

Makes sense. 😜


r/Stargate • • Aug 26 '26

REALLY not caring for Sheppard the 3rd time around. (And why was he such a dick to Hermiod?)

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I really liked him the first time I watched the series. Second watch, I thought he was a bit on the cocky side. Now I’m on my third watch and he’s even worse! He’s even more arrogant this time around and always has such an “I’m better than you” attitude. I felt this way for a while, but I just watched the scene where he sees Hermiod for the first time and that was the last straw - I had to vent. lol. He should be KISSING ASGARD FEET - not talking shit about them! Why was he so mean? I know they were probably going for an O’Neill vibe, as he always had his rough-around-the-edges moments, but he still always remained wholesome and humble somehow. Sheppard just can’t seem to pull that off IMO. 🤷🏻‍♀️

EDIT: him questioning the nakedness is not what I was referring to. That itself is not rude. It was just overall tone and the way he looked at him. He couldn’t at least fake a smile and say hello? Mean teenage girl vibes.


r/Stargate • • Jul 28 '22

Discussion Stargate: Universe is the best introduction for new fans.

1 Upvotes

In my opinion, SGU is the best and easiest way to introduce new people to the franchise.

Years ago I showed it to my dad. It sucked him right in. After he finished it, I had to get him the rest of the series (SG1, SGA) and all the movies, and gave him the proper timeline to watch everything. When he hit Universe a second time, it was like watching it all over again as everything tied together and made more sense. And this is a man who has never liked sci-fi, and always laughed at it and called it "stuff for nerds". His tune changed.

Now this year, I'm going through the same thing with one of my best friends. Same story, sci-fi is for nerds and a waste of time. Well he just got to the part in Season 2 where everyone realizes Rush broke the master code, and he is completely sucked in. He's already asking me to get the rest of the series ready for him for when he finishes Universe.

Why is this? I figure Universe is just more easy to approach from the outside, and less "campy" than the older series. Regardless, I strongly hold the opinion that SGU is the best introduction to the franchise for people who have not seen it before.


r/Stargate • • Sep 10 '25

I just realized the Ori Plage was supposed to be the same plage that finished the non-ascended Ancients?

1 Upvotes

Never made the conection until now :S


r/Stargate • • Dec 01 '14

Don't kill me.

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/Stargate • • Nov 24 '22

Does anyone else hate Prometheus?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Stargate • • Nov 22 '24

What was, to you, a dumb decision made by SG1?

3 Upvotes

To me, it was not allying with Euronda. Yeah, these guys' ethics suck, but humanity could essentially have exploited them for their technology. Like this was the perfect opportunity to get very advanced tech that was already made by humans for humans.