I want to be abundantly clear: I like Jewel Staite. I loved her as Kaylee in Firefly. I have no issues with her performance.
It's the writing.
And I also want to be abundantly clear before the angry man babies jump in (they will anyway and my rule is that I will not respond to them or anyone trying to be malicious), I love Stargate. I love SG-1, SGA, I even like parts of Universe even if I think it flopped as a whole.
This being said: the show has trouble writing women characters.
"But Sam!" You cry "But Janet!"
Those two are semi-exceptions. Sam and Janet are great... most of the time. I won't get into it too much but Sam's romance life is so weird. They either die or disappear, I believe even Amanda Tapping referred to it as a curse or something.
Not to mention that replicator bad guy with the mommy complex, ew.
My only problem is Janet is that we don't have more of her :'(
Now let's get into the problems: Vala, Teyla, Elizabeth, and Jennifer -- I am NOT getting into the Universe characters. If they're not Ming-Na Wen's character, they were written very very badly.
Again, to be clear, I love Vala. She's one of my favourite characters. The writers treat her AWFUL. It's Deeana Troi all over again (for non Star Trek watchers, Troi is a decent character but her focus episodes tend to be rape-y).
Vala gets mystical pregnancied, she gets tortured, she watches her kid die and has to participate in that, Daniel treats her like shit and then they get together.
Like, what. Also, they make her kind of kid like with a bunch of trauma and a leather fetish, all because of sexualization and not to examine where any of that comes from.
Again, I love Vala. I just hate the way they write her.
Teyla. Unfortunately she falls under what is called the "noble savage" trope. Where the non-white character is primitive but noble and stoic.
https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/NobleSavage
It's actually a very problematic trope but I'm not going to get into it so please see the above link.
Also, sorry, but Teyla is often boring. The problem is I want to like her but they don't give her a lot to do. Oh yeah, and they make her run around in these impractical skimpy little outfits which makes no sense because over sexualization.
Also they made her pregnancy special for no reason. They couldn't just had her have a regular pregnancy and kid but noooo.
Elizabeth... I might be a little in love with her, she gives me Janeway vibes (Star Trek character). But if I'm in love with her, what's the problem? Weeeelll the way they wrote her off was freaking weird. I understand that actors leave shows but the choices they made, with the many recasts and the replicator people thing. Strange. Weird. Did not like. Uncomfortable.
I also won't go into the over sexualization of the one off (or reoccurring) women folk characters that show up in episodes. Like Anise. The fuck did they make her wear.
Okay I got carried away. I wanted to talk about Jennifer.
I don't think she's a character. I think she's literally just a love interest for Rodney. And such a boring one too.
She doesn't really have a personality. She's nice, I guess, she's pretty, but she's really only there to turn down Ronan and go for Rodney even though it doesn't really give any reason why. It's not like she hangs out a bunch with Rodney and shares interests with him.
It's kind of like when they try to write John/Teyla. No chemistry.
They respect each other, sure, they are even friends, but they don't seem to spend all that much time together if they don't have to.
The people that spend the most off time together are John and Rodney. They're constantly racing their cars or playing their games. Those two have more chemistry than Rodney/Jennifer ever did.
Anyway, to sum up, I hope if they make more Stangate content in the future that they do better with their women characters (and non white characters and queer characters and so on and so forth).
Again, I am going to reiterate, people who respond with attacks or blatant misogyny/bigotry in general, will not be responded to.