r/Star_wars_Rogue_One • • Jan 28 '17

Why do they even NEED a Death Star?

0 Upvotes

When an x-wing going faster than the speed of light slamming into a planet would have the same kind of effect? Quick way to kill the death star too. I wish they'd kinda just dealt with this glaring what-if with a line or two of dialogue so it doesn't sit like a gaping wound.


r/Star_wars_Rogue_One • • Dec 18 '16

What happens when you watch the movie without watching the trailers [SPOILERS]

0 Upvotes

Soo.... i just came back from the cinema, and i fell so weird. As the movie started, i got introduced to another strong main female character "Jyn Erso" and it was weird (nothing bad about another female characters but we already got Rey, i didn't know how it is going to be when those 2 meet). Then we get the news about another big weapon, i was hoping it was not another death star, we already got one if the last one.... and what do i get a friking DEATH STAR. But what can you, at list it may do more then the last. As the things progressed i started seeing more and more similarities, but i was sure that this movie it will continue story from "Force Awakens" and it bother me that they didn't came up whit something new. When we saw Vader i thou't they created a clone of him or something and as thing went on i was going crazy. I liked the move but nothing fit, i saw so many similar characters and things didn't add up, new death star, same way of destroying it, it was around that time that i realized that this is a prequel to New hope, and then we saw princes Leia and i was sure. As i realized that i started to look around seeing the reactions of other people watching the movie, but noting was going on. I couldn't wait for me to come home and see how other people online reacted.... as it turns out people know that it was a prequel.

It was not the best idea to watch it when you don't know any thing about the movie and staff like this happens (prequel in the middle of trilogy), BUT it was also awesome xD, and i cant wait to watch it again and be able to focus on all little things that i missed the first time. And also i thing i should say that i really liked the movie and it is way better the the Force Awakens, the story telling, action scenes, every thing was better, also cant wait to see more of the Rey and Luke when the next movie comes, if it is not another prequel xD.

(sorry about the grammar, i do expect that i have butchered it, as you guest english is not my main language)


r/Star_wars_Rogue_One • • Dec 04 '16

Ruining Rogue One with Racial Politics...Great, just what I wanted.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/Star_wars_Rogue_One • • Dec 22 '16

(SPOILERS) Did any Bothans die getting that information??

2 Upvotes

I LOVED this movie - but thought there would be an appearance by some Bothans - or at least maybe a strike force called the Bothans. Am I alone? Did I miss something?! :o


r/Star_wars_Rogue_One • • Dec 31 '16

ELI5: [SPOILER] How are they going to build the 2nd Death Star?

3 Upvotes

If all of the engineers (including the lead) who worked on the original are dead, and the only plans that existed were thought to be blown up on Scarith, how and why are we to believe that the Empire can just build another Death Star, ESPECIALLY when they don't know the first ones weakness?

EDIT: Additionally, why is the Empire so gung-ho about building another one, when they essentially laughed at and criticized Krennic until the test shot was fired - to only have that very weapon be blown to pieces shortly after (in A New Hope) due to a seemingly large flaw in something they are saw as flawed?


r/Star_wars_Rogue_One • • Jan 15 '17

Rogue one movie title in after effects

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/Star_wars_Rogue_One • • Dec 31 '16

Where is Princess Leia's place in the Rebel hierarchy?

6 Upvotes

In 4,5 &6, it seems clear that the princess is in charge of the Rebel Alliance. However in R1, Mon Monthma is the leader and the princess just happened to be at the right place and the right time to receive the DS plans. So who reported to who and when did that change exactly?


r/Star_wars_Rogue_One • • Jan 04 '17

Subtle but hilarious stormtrooper moment in Rogue One..

4 Upvotes

The stormtroopers in this movie were the dumbest I've ever seen them. They were getting recked the whole damn movie! One moment made me LOL. When Jyn is being transported at the imperial labor camp and is saved by Andor and a group of rebels, when the troopers realized they stoped one thought it was " maybe another pick up or something" one turns curiously toward the rear door, then.. BOOM! Classic stormtroop death! Hahah who else remembers that part? I wish there was a gif of it!


r/Star_wars_Rogue_One • • Dec 16 '16

Just got back from Rouge One, are we really just going to let Hollywood whitewash the sacrifices the Bothans made for the rebellion?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
4 Upvotes

r/Star_wars_Rogue_One • • Mar 30 '17

Rogue One Ending Issue

7 Upvotes

In the end of the Darth Vader scene, the Tantive IV undocks from the Profundity, and Darth Vader steps out into the space where it was docked. There is no way that the rebels could have made it onto the ship because they entered from the back, but there were the engines in the way. Can someone explain this for me?


r/Star_wars_Rogue_One • • Dec 15 '16

Spoiler alert

Thumbnail
i.reddituploads.com
11 Upvotes

r/Star_wars_Rogue_One • • Jun 04 '22

Rogue One original ending ultimate thread.

2 Upvotes

I know that it is not exactly a new question but what have we learned. I know the famous running with the stolen drive and facing of against a Tie Fighter but is there some sort of original leaked script.

Also, it was reported that the movie went through reshoots, any idea about these?


r/Star_wars_Rogue_One • • Dec 23 '16

(Spoilers) With Raddus resembling Churchill, does Jyn represent Reagan?

3 Upvotes

Reagan's "Time for Choosing" speech was one of several historical speeches that resonate with me and her speech at the Senate hearing struck me as being inspired from this speech directly. The excerpt I'm referring to is found here:

https://youtu.be/tpH5L8zCtSk?t=156

Background to the speech was that it was done at the 64' RNC (Reagan was not President yet and was giving the speech for a senator) and was directed at the advance of Communism:

Jyn's Dialogue: "You give in to an empire this evil, and you condemn the entire galaxy to an eternity of darkness"

RR: "We'll preserve for our children this, the last best hope of man on earth, or we'll sentence them to take the last step into a thousand years of darkness."

The darkness hook was what got me. Other excerpts from the TFC speech that could be warcry's for the Rebel Alliance could be:

"You and I have the courage to say to our enemies, “There is a price we will not pay.” “There is a point beyond which they must not advance.”

RR also drew and quoted from Churchill (Raddus) who valiantly sacrificed a portion of the fleet to get those plans:

“There’s something going on in time and space, and beyond time and space, which, whether we like it or not, spells duty.”

Another excerpt is here:

"Admittedly, there’s a risk in any course we follow other than this, but every lesson of history tells us that the greater risk lies in appeasement, and this is the specter our well-meaning liberal friends refuse to face—that their policy of accommodation is appeasement, and it gives no choice between peace and war, only between fight or surrender. If we continue to accommodate, continue to back and retreat, eventually we have to face the final demand—the ultimatum."

Would you guys agree that Jyn represent Reagan or at least Edwards was inspired by Reagan? Would like to see if anyone also can come up with any resemblances of speeches and themes to any great historical figures.


r/Star_wars_Rogue_One • • Dec 17 '16

SPOILER- why is the empire so weak?-

3 Upvotes

I hate how the empire is defeated so easily, I mean even in rogue one where the empire is supposed to win, they struggled like if facing a real army, they received tremendous damage from the rebel, I almost walked off the theatre because at one point. I was expecting/hoping a movie where the empire is strong and evil killing rebels by dozens crushing them like the scum they are. the last minute of the movie is what It should have been the empire killing the hell out of the rebels while they struggle to try and take the plans


r/Star_wars_Rogue_One • • Dec 29 '16

Rogue One Oscars Nom Pool

3 Upvotes

Wow! What a movie right? So I just saw it for third time with my girl and it converted her to star wars (maximum firepower indeed).

Anyway, we all know a December release was strategic release designed to use maximum impact on the judge's minds going into the Oscars. So I'd love to hear everyone's category picks.

For me, I feel confident they're going to steal the tech noms with the CGI, where do you think R1 has a good chance?


r/Star_wars_Rogue_One • • Jan 10 '17

Just another reason to love the film...

Post image
16 Upvotes

r/Star_wars_Rogue_One • • Dec 22 '16

[Very Minor Spoilers] I felt the first 5% of the movie made the rest of the movie difficult to follow at times.

12 Upvotes
  • No main anthem, when I see a Star Wars movie, I want my theme music. When what was played, was played, I said to my friend "I don't know what that was supposed to be, but I hate it".

  • No scrolling text. A bit of info about maybe who is looking for who, and the names spelled out clearly so I don't think the main characters name is Jim for almost the whole movie until I clearly hear someone say Jin.

  • Jumping from planet to planet so quickly gave the movie a very rushed pace for the first little bit. It only added to the confusion.

  • No real explanation of the time jump, at least I don't recall seeing one saying how much time had passed or anything like that. It wasn't until later that a character mentions the temporal gap between what we saw at the beginning and current events.


r/Star_wars_Rogue_One • • Dec 20 '16

Rogue One Review - I have high hopes for the future Anthology Movies

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/Star_wars_Rogue_One • • Dec 20 '16

The next Star Wars story

0 Upvotes

Well it's seems Disney will most likely push this new sub series to the limit but the real question is , will they fill all the gaps George Lucas left? I would definitely like to see the clone wars being told as between Star Wars 2-3 it wasn't really told only in Wikis. Do you think this sub series will be mostly rebels or do you think they will fill gaps?


r/Star_wars_Rogue_One • • Dec 15 '16

Non-spoiler thoughts on the film

0 Upvotes

So I went to see the first screening in Budapest last night and here's what I have to say:

At this point, this entry is more of a commercial move than anything else. There's no real progression in the story line whatsoever. It wouldn't really matter if this movie didn't come out at all.

But it's an entertaining sci-fi movie to say the least. It's Star Wars-y with different alien types doing alien things, space ship battles and stormtroopers being stormtroopers.


r/Star_wars_Rogue_One • • Dec 27 '16

the explosion conspiracy Rogue One (spoilers)

4 Upvotes

----- spoilers ------

in the third act of the new Rogue One movie, we see many tragic deaths. most notable are the deaths of the entire Rouge One crew. What seems odd is that, for the 5 human crew members, all of the deaths are from explosions. not a single one of them is killed by a simple blaster shot except for K2-SO, a droid. Imwe is killed when the master switch is blown up, Baze and Bohdi are killed by grenades, and Jyn and Cassian get caught in the explosion from the death star blast. none of the main crew go out in a platoon shoot out, dropping to their knees fighting until they get shot to death. it just weirdly intentional. Maybe Disney just wanted to make the deaths cinematic, or maybe they had something else planned. keep in mind that we've seen a man dipped in lava with his arms and legs cut off be "saved." It could be possible that while Darth Vader goes to chase down the plans for the death star another crew goes and retrieve the corpses of the rouge one crew and brings them back Darth Vader style as cyborg solders or the Knights of Ren. regardless of whether you think the Rouge One crew are the knights of Ren, having all of the crew die by explosion seems like a very odd choice that I think Disney did on purpose.


r/Star_wars_Rogue_One • • Mar 19 '17

Turns out there was an opening crawl for Rogue One! But, it wasn't needed. Here's why...

Thumbnail
slashfilm.com
4 Upvotes

r/Star_wars_Rogue_One • • Dec 26 '16

I had one complaint about the new Star Wars movie Rogue One (Spoilers)

5 Upvotes

Major spoilers in this so I highly recommend you stop reading now if you have not seen the movie.

The movie was amazing. I feel like it was a masterpiece in every respect but one.

Hollywood is not used to stories like this and you can clearly see it in how they treat death of main characters. This movie basically EVERYONE DIES, not most of the characters like most movies. This movie was a relentless butchering of main characters in ways I think are unprecedented in content of its paradigm.

This wasn't regular death scenes followed by remorse either. It was death followed by marching on of the story with absolutely no time to pay respects to ANYONE in any way. Hollywood is not used to this kind of movie in any way shape or form. Especially noticeable at the very end of the movie you get to see a massacre take place at Darth Vader's personal hands in a brutal death march not even seen to the likes of Friday the 13nth Jason Voorhees with a glowing blade and throat crushing telekinesis. Could the guy stuck to the fucking ceiling even BREATH while he felt Vader cut him in half like a Mortal Kombat finishing move?

Two of the characters were killed by annoying grenade mechanics. Basically one of the most annoying ways to die in a video game and you get to see it take place not once but twice with lasting impact on the story.

The movie then ends suddenly with "A new hope" .. Then plays super up beat Star Wars music.

Think we could have at least got a fucking ceremony or SOMETHING? Think they could have at least played sad music at the end showing pictures of the characters like a memorial? How about a scene showing their graves or symbolic caskets being shot out into space. SOMETHING.. Nope, they just plodded along with the usual song and dance like it was any of the other Star Wars films. Imagine if they treated Spock this way?

"Oh no! the Romulans randomly dropped a grenade and Spock was blown apart from the explosion! Lets just continue the movie like he never existed! Bones died because he fell down some stairs! The story must go on!"

Hell what if they treated Han or Obi-Wan this way?

Then to top that off, the first Star Wars movie they failed to actually blow the damn death star up anyway. So not only were they all basically lost in time forever with zero condolences they didn't accomplish their goal. I wasn't feeling this hope they talked about at all. It was more like massacre of Rogue one that accomplished almost nothing at all.

If that was what the movie was supposed to be then fine. But at least be a little more considerate and self aware about it. Don't parade a bunch of amazing characters then pull them apart in front of me like a machine churning out meaningless charred bodies.


r/Star_wars_Rogue_One • • Dec 16 '16

The one that says it... Rogue One sucked. Sucked bad!

56 Upvotes

So many things wrong... music, story, "lets make Darth Vader bad ass" ... 2 hours i left im still up set with it.

(update) I was born when the first movie came out but when I was old enough my father would show me the movies. I feel in love with the franchise. I did not wall for the special effects or space ships nor the characters. It was the story and how that story was told. It became, what will happen in the story vs what will happen to the characters. That is the core of my review of this movie. The reason I got see a movie is like reading a book or a comic. To get lost in a story.

Rogue One sucked.

Why? How can a powerful franchise like Star Wars make a horrible movie? Has any movie made after for first 3 made any good reviews?

Force Awakens was literally the remake of New Hope. What they did in Rogue One was just abomination of trying to create the Star Wars magic by trying something different. They tried to tell 5 stories at the same time vs Originals had 3 at max with the third one just popping in and out through the series.

Most of the movie seems geared toward selling toys and super fans that want to see Darth Vader in action, which in my opinion was weak as hell. Darth Vader scenes were so over the top they almost made me laugh and one scene I did, which was post to be serious.

Music was horrible and someone should be told this personally. One scene when main character is trying to get something the music is so bad and so off that I was totally pulled away from the movie and came realize that I was watching something horrible. Even a amature film maker can say “oh thats bad.”

The story it self got lost halfway through and seemed like “hey this movie sucked how can we make it more epic.” At one point of time it looked the scriptwriter had a writer's block and the studio say “Blow something up.” and bam. Story moved along. The word hope is said so much I do not want to hear it for 3 months. Yes, this is the movie before “New Hope” which was makes the movie little more interesting. This movie was easily a 30 TV show at best not a 2 hour movie. If they wanted to tell a star wars movie. The should have told a movie that does not involve any characters from the originals.

Top it off the story had so many logical loopholes and can not even phantom to write them all down. Why does the control room for the data bank have a large 5ft thick blast door but to access the data bank has a small 3 man wide door that is 2 inches thick?

All I want is a story to be told. Stop trying to push an agenda and selling more toys. Toys will sell. Focus on the story and how the characters deal with the story vs characters creating the story.


r/Star_wars_Rogue_One • • Dec 17 '16

[SPOILERS] First thoughts on Rogue One

6 Upvotes

First off, I'm not a critic. I normally don't post reviews online but my god this film has compelled me to. Im just a massive Star Wars fan who loves discussing it (as are we all I'm assuming).

Ive only seen it once so i cant remember everything, but based on my first viewing i can safely say this is, in my opinion, the greatest StarWars movie since Empire. It may even top it, and thats really saying something as the original trilogy is held so dear to my heart, Empire of course being the pinical.

Its absolutely incredible. It perfectly and effortlessly paves the way for episode IV in a way that i really was not expecting. The tone is reminiscent of the great war films, which makes sense as its a war film first, sci-fi second. Its so gritty in a way not yet seen in live action Star Wars .

The characters are amazing. K-2SO is the stand out for me, and possibly my new favourite character. I haven't felt that emotional over a robots death since the Iron Giant. I mean i knew none if them were going to make it but I was so engrossed it just came in an unexpected way. All the characters looked awesome, even the background characters. I felt that Cassian, Jyn, Baze, Iwit and the rest (again, only seen it once so cant remember all the names) had the best amount of screen tine and development needed for each person. DARTH VADER HOLY SHIT. In this one stand alone film they made him more menacing then the entire original trilogy. They completely eradicated the soggy emotional sack they made Anakin/Vader into in the prequels. Gareth Edwards finally gave us the Vader we always heard about. Menacing, Merciless, unstoppable. And the cameos of CG carrie fisher, Peter Cushing as Tarkin (incredible CG tho im not sure with his amount of screen time and plot intrlegrity its a mere cameo) plus all the little nods to Bail Organa, the 'im wanted in 12 star systems' guys from mos eisley cantina were done so well it was almost unnoticeable.

Speaking of cameos/easter eggs, omg its an easter egg kessel mine. The little things; blue milk, black scout trooper helmet, a lassat in the jedi temple on jetta, the Hammerhead Corvets (which im pretty sure is a reference to rebels as thats now canon but in hoping its a KOTOR reference too), just too many to remember in a first viewing. They were subtle but insane.

The battle scenes were the most jaw dropping I've seen in recent years, truly had me on the edge of my seat and actually shouting at the screen, in a good way. Really got a reaction out of me. I could watch all the battle scenes in that film till i die and be happy. Very similar to ROTJ with the space, ground guerrilla battle and main platform battle. Just spectacular.

Final thoughts are that its the best addition to the star wars franchise since Empire and it truly kept to the original trilogy Lore and skin and truly a rollercoaster ride of emotions. 10/10, best film if 2016.

TL:DR The Film is amazing, everything a Star Wars fan wants, go see it a thousand times.