First off, I'm not a critic. I normally don't post reviews online but my god this film has compelled me to. Im just a massive Star Wars fan who loves discussing it (as are we all I'm assuming).
Ive only seen it once so i cant remember everything, but based on my first viewing i can safely say this is, in my opinion, the greatest StarWars movie since Empire. It may even top it, and thats really saying something as the original trilogy is held so dear to my heart, Empire of course being the pinical.
Its absolutely incredible. It perfectly and effortlessly paves the way for episode IV in a way that i really was not expecting. The tone is reminiscent of the great war films, which makes sense as its a war film first, sci-fi second. Its so gritty in a way not yet seen in live action Star Wars .
The characters are amazing. K-2SO is the stand out for me, and possibly my new favourite character. I haven't felt that emotional over a robots death since the Iron Giant. I mean i knew none if them were going to make it but I was so engrossed it just came in an unexpected way. All the characters looked awesome, even the background characters. I felt that Cassian, Jyn, Baze, Iwit and the rest (again, only seen it once so cant remember all the names) had the best amount of screen tine and development needed for each person. DARTH VADER HOLY SHIT. In this one stand alone film they made him more menacing then the entire original trilogy. They completely eradicated the soggy emotional sack they made Anakin/Vader into in the prequels. Gareth Edwards finally gave us the Vader we always heard about. Menacing, Merciless, unstoppable. And the cameos of CG carrie fisher, Peter Cushing as Tarkin (incredible CG tho im not sure with his amount of screen time and plot intrlegrity its a mere cameo) plus all the little nods to Bail Organa, the 'im wanted in 12 star systems' guys from mos eisley cantina were done so well it was almost unnoticeable.
Speaking of cameos/easter eggs, omg its an easter egg kessel mine. The little things; blue milk, black scout trooper helmet, a lassat in the jedi temple on jetta, the Hammerhead Corvets (which im pretty sure is a reference to rebels as thats now canon but in hoping its a KOTOR reference too), just too many to remember in a first viewing. They were subtle but insane.
The battle scenes were the most jaw dropping I've seen in recent years, truly had me on the edge of my seat and actually shouting at the screen, in a good way. Really got a reaction out of me. I could watch all the battle scenes in that film till i die and be happy. Very similar to ROTJ with the space, ground guerrilla battle and main platform battle. Just spectacular.
Final thoughts are that its the best addition to the star wars franchise since Empire and it truly kept to the original trilogy Lore and skin and truly a rollercoaster ride of emotions. 10/10, best film if 2016.
TL:DR The Film is amazing, everything a Star Wars fan wants, go see it a thousand times.