r/Spinoza • • Jan 06 '26

Revealing Spinoza’s God/Substance

0 Upvotes

We all would have seen this line of Spinoza that “God, or substance consisting of infinite attributes, each of which expresses eternal and infinite essence, necessarily exists.””

I am here to make you experience this “substance”. The direct experience of this substance is stillness one experiences especially at night. There is also a medical diagnosis called “tinnitus” where people describe hearing a constant ringing sound. That is what is the substance which is the source of everything.

Now don’t ask me questions. Research on it yourself and see if what I said is true or not. If it turns out to be false, you know what to do.


r/Spinoza • • Jul 15 '25

The Unity of Caution and Care: A Synthesis of Spinoza's Caute as the Foundation of Ethical Understanding

0 Upvotes

The Unity of Caution and Care: A Synthesis of Spinoza's Caute as the Foundation of Ethical Understanding

In the context of Baruch Spinoza's philosophy, particularly as outlined in his On the Improvement of the Understanding, his personal seal bore the Latin word Caute—meaning "Caution" or "Beware"—accompanied by the image of a rose. Far from signaling a defensive withdrawal from human connection, this motto expresses the essential intellectual discipline that makes authentic care possible. Through philosophical and etymological analysis, we can understand how Spinoza's caute is not opposed to care, but rather its necessary foundation: the rigorous practice of epistemological vigilance that enables the highest form of ethical life—helping oneself and others attain freedom through understanding.

I. Etymological Convergence: The Hidden Unity of Attention

The apparent opposition between "caution" and "care" dissolves when we examine their etymological roots. Caute derives from the Latin cavere—to be on guard, to take heed—while "care" traces back through Old English caru and Proto-Germanic karō, originally connoting sorrow or concern. Despite their different historical trajectories, both terms share a central preoccupation: focused attention—the deliberate orientation of the mind toward reality.

This linguistic kinship reveals a deeper philosophical relationship. Whether guarding oneself from illusion (caute) or tending to another's well-being (care), both involve intentional, thoughtful engagement with the world. In Spinoza's system, where the quality of one's ideas determines the quality of one's life, this shared attentiveness becomes the bridge between what initially appear to be contrasting postures: withdrawal and compassion.

II. Epistemological Vigilance: Caute as Methodological Precision

In On the Improvement of the Understanding, Spinoza presents caute not as fearful hesitation but as methodological precision—what might be called "epistemological vigilance." He argues that human suffering stems primarily from inadequate ideas—confused notions about ourselves, others, and the world.

His method calls for the intellectual honesty to perceive reality as it is, not as we imagine or desire it to be. This caution undergirds his ethical aim: liberation through knowledge. The geometric structure of the Ethics—its deliberate, stepwise clarity—exemplifies this: every proposition must serve both logical coherence and the broader goal of human emancipation.

Thus, caute is more than a warning; it is therapeutic caution: the diagnostic care required to distinguish truth from illusion, clarity from confusion, and freedom from bondage. It is not the caution of timidity, but of the physician who must first diagnose precisely before prescribing help.

III. The Transformation of Emotion: From Passive Affects to Active Understanding

Central to Spinoza's project is his radical theory of emotion: affects are themselves modes of thought—passive when based on inadequate ideas, active when grounded in adequate understanding. The practice of caute demands that we examine our emotional responses, understand their origins, and gradually transform them from reactive passions into empowering insights.

This requires what Spinoza calls fortitudo—fortitude or moral strength—the capacity to interrogate our desires, fears, and attachments without distortion. This inquiry is at once an act of caution (guarding against self-deception) and care (aimed at greater joy and autonomy).

One still dominated by passive emotions—envy, fear, pity, confused desire—cannot offer genuine care to others. Their help will be reactive, distorted by projection or unconscious need. What often passes for care may be dependency, moral vanity, or the weak passion of pity: the sharing of another's sadness without increasing their power to act.

IV. The Social Dimension: Civic Virtue and Collective Liberation

Spinoza's political philosophy shows how personal caution translates into public care. In both the Theological-Political Treatise and the Political Treatise, he argues that flourishing societies require citizens capable of rational deliberation, not those driven by fear, superstition, or unexamined passion.

The cautious citizen—one who thinks clearly, examines evidence, and resists ideological manipulation—advances not just their own freedom, but the stability of the state. In this sense, caute becomes a civic virtue: an intellectual form of care for the community, safeguarding the shared conditions of collective flourishing.

Spinoza's ultimate aim is not personal salvation but mutual empowerment. A person governed by reason, he writes in the Ethics, "desires for others the same good he seeks for himself." Thus, ethical caution becomes the condition for universalizable care.

V. Authentic Care as Rational Empowerment

In Spinoza's framework, authentic care is not sentimental sympathy or self-sacrificing altruism. It is the rational act of guiding others toward their own empowerment. To help someone increase their understanding is the highest ethical act—an offering of the greatest good one can give: freedom.

But such care requires prior mastery of the self. Without caute, the would-be caregiver may act from anxiety, confusion, or pride. Through caute, one becomes capable of clear-sighted assistance—able to help others not by feeling their pain, but by helping them transcend it.

The highest form of this rational care is the intellectual love of God (amor Dei intellectualis): not an emotional attachment to a supernatural being, but a joyful, clear-eyed understanding of the necessary order of nature. To wish this insight for others—to help them develop their own caute—is to offer the most profound care of all.

VI. The Rose and the Thorn: Integrating Symbol and Meaning

The rose that accompanies caute on Spinoza's seal adds symbolic depth. On one level, it may reference sub rosa (secrecy), a nod to the dangerous political climate for unorthodox thinkers. But it also gestures to a deeper metaphor: the rose as flourishing life, cultivated through discernment.

Just as the rose grows among thorns, true care must be protected by caution. The thorn does not destroy the rose; it guards its possibility. Likewise, caute does not hinder care—it enables it, ensuring that what we offer others grows from strength, not sentiment; from clarity, not confusion.

VII. The Paradox Resolved: Caution as Love's Foundation

The apparent contradiction between caution and care resolves when we recognize that to care well, one must proceed cautiously—not from fear, but from commitment to truth. Caute is the caution of the lover who refuses to idealize the beloved, seeking instead to understand them truly. It is the loving attention that aims not to possess, but to empower.

In Spinoza's system, method and goal converge: caute is the disciplined path that makes ethical love—cura—possible. As understanding grows, so too does joy, and with it, the capacity to offer others the only real gift: the means to become free.

Conclusion: Caute as Ethical Attunement

Spinoza's Caute is not a defensive motto but a therapeutic stance—a lifelong commitment to truth through disciplined understanding. It is the sober, exacting orientation that allows the soul to ascend from confusion to clarity, from passion to reason, from reactive suffering to active love.

We might say: Caution is the care we show toward truth. Care is the truth we offer to others.

This synthesis captures the heart of Spinoza's vision: not a denial of emotion, but its transformation through reason into something enduring, liberating, and deeply loving. Caute prepares the ground in which authentic care can flourish. It is the intellectual soil from which both individual blessedness and collective joy may grow.

The rose on Spinoza's seal thus symbolises not withdrawal from the world, but the full flowering of human potential—a flourishing made possible only when caution and care unite in the service of understanding.

ENDNOTE: This is an AI-generated doc that I made for myself to better understand the contours of a Spinoza Legend I thought I had read but that apparently I made up in a chat with an AI about AI Safety. The Legend -- which I probably read somewhere at some point -- was that Spinoza had the word care in latin tattoo'd around his ring finger as his pact with divinity. The AI clearly understood what I meant by my fictive Spinoza legend and offered a reply I saw as interesting jumping off point for another essay so I had to research the origins of my (maybe) Spinoza fiction. After determining that I somehow appropriated or misread the word Caute w/ rose on his signet as meaning care. To better understand my (perhaps) modern Spinoza Legend, I asked the machine to help me better understand was my mistake implied in Spinozan terms. I thought the machines did a great job and really enjoyed reading what it wrote for me and I hope you do too.


r/Spinoza • • Jul 31 '26

A free interactive companion for a more visual reading of Spinoza’s Ethics

12 Upvotes

For anyone who wants a more visual way into Spinoza’s Ethics — not only the words on the page, but the geometric order that binds them — there is a free online companion here:

https://www.spinoza-ethica.com

It is built to help you:

  • Read the text with followable citations

  • See how propositions depend on earlier material (proof graph)

  • Follow short guided paths through the lattice

  • Map central concepts across the five parts

  • Explore the affects and how they relate

The aim is a study desk beside the book: browse, trace proofs, and discover relations in an interactive way. Part I is the fullest stretch; later parts are curated and still expanding.

Still work in progress. Feedback welcome — especially from readers and teachers who work with the Ethics in class or on their own.


r/Spinoza • • Oct 08 '26

Life Outside The Cage

0 Upvotes

Life Inside The Cage

Escaping the cage, one photon at a time

Growing Up Inside The Cage

When we are young we either have unrealistic expectations put on us, or we are told we are too

much: too loud, too opinionated, too sensitive. This naturally makes us feel we are not enough, or

too much, which leads us to not be our authentic selves.

When you are not your authentic self, a voice in your head can start to become loud.

It says negative things that destroy your self-esteem and keep you stunted. This sadly works well

for the system, because a kid who hates themselves can be easily kept in the cage that was

designed by past psychopaths, for future psychopaths, to be the elites in society.

The system doesn't want you to have self-compassion. It wants you to be emotional, because it

feeds off strong emotions: anger, hate, ignorance, sadness, self-doubt. It can handle you being

angry at it, but it doesn't like being laughed at.

This is one of the ways to start escaping the cage, because the cage is just an illusion. A shitty

magic trick by a very low-level magician, definitely no Dynamo-level magic. When you pull back

the curtain that is barely even a curtain, you see the emperor has no clothes on. You can laugh at

the absurdity, and use discernment, because discernment is something it can't feed off.

They use your strong emotions as a way to control you and brainwash you into becoming a

low-level member of their cult. When you realise all the elites around the world are in the same

cult, and you are just an expendable to help them jockey for a higher position between the leaders,

that's when the penny drops. There are no sides, no countries, just expendables.

They want soldiers to believe they are fighting for a country, for a purpose, for a marketing slogan,

but they are only fighting for their deranged cult leader's self-interest, to try to take another cult

leader's spot higher up the cult pyramid.

They want people in prison, as they are then another part of the system. They want you to drive a

car because it fuels their wars. They want you to be in large amounts of debt so you have no

space in your mind for critical thinking. They want you stuck in consumerism to keep you broke

and filling a bottomless pit of resentment. They want you to put a mask on for 8 hours a day and

be someone other than your authentic self at a job you hate. They want you to doom-scroll and

watch the media to create anxiety and wreck your nervous system. They want you comparing

yourself to others on social media. Be bullied on there, or be a bully, either works for them. They

want you to spend money playing status games on social media, keeping you broke and

miserable.

They want you to have the illusion of owning a home they can make you a slave to the banks for,

then put up rates and squeeze you to keep you in survival mode. They want you to fight with your

spouse over financial issues, so if you divorce you have less money. They want outrage. They

want you drunk or on drugs, eating poisonous food, taking pharmaceuticals. Anything but you

seeing their game inside the game. Are you getting the picture? Distractions.

Life Inside The Cage · Page 2 of 9

They stand outside the cage and they despise the people in the cage. Psychopaths think they're a

superior species and that we normal people are here to be gaslit and manipulated to push them up

the cult pyramid. Their shitty magic trick is based on one thing: the willingness of us to participate.

Once you see that, you can't unsee it, and it's very annoying, because it's so simple.

If you don't pick up a gun and go to war, nothing happens. If you opt out of consumerism, it stops

feeding the beast. If you don't buy petrol for the car cult and ride a Lime bike or catch an electric

train instead, there's no funding for wars. You are brainwashed by cult leaders, and the exit is

simply withdrawing your participation.

The Way Out

So the depressing part is out of the way. Here is the positive part.

You are enough. You don't need to be anything but your authentic self. You are made of

supernovae, from selfless stars that exploded, that gave everything for you to be here. You are

made of star stuff, as Carl Sagan once said. The atoms in your body came from an exploded star. I

recommend you look at how beautiful and interesting the pictures of supernovae are.

You are a photon of light, and yes, these cult leaders are the darkness, but darkness is boring and

light is interesting.

They don't realise that they are made of the same supernova atoms as well. But they are hoarding

instead of giving, which creates darkness, because that's not the ingredients of supernovae. That's

why it feels good when you give, and it's unfulfilling when you collect things for yourself. You can

collect things your entire life, only to realise you can't take anything with you when you return to

the Universe when you die. It's a trap.

Darkness might despise the photon, but the photon shines anyway. If you can learn to use

discernment and be giving, darkness can't get rid of light, there is always light. The trick is to be

completely like a photon: you don't care that darkness hates you, you just shine anyway.

The elites become so dark that's when the depravity starts rising, and we have all seen that

happening. American Psycho is a film that points it out clearly. But here's the thing: that's on them.

They think there are no consequences, but maybe the Universe decides where it puts them when

they go. Maybe to the Bootes Void. It does have a sense of humour.

The Universe is constantly creating and dissolving, and we will dissolve back into it. We are all

homeward bound. Evil may win the day, it always has, but what matters is that we don't become it.

We act with decency not because it's rewarded, but because it's right. There's no old man in the

sky judging us. That's from another cult, with a guy in a stupid hat speaking down to you from a

window in a square. The one with good marketing and two thousand years of whoopsies swept

under their expensive rugs. The one that needs you to walk into an old building each Sunday, give

money, and ask for forgiveness.

Life Inside The Cage · Page 3 of 9

The Universe is all around us.

What Else Can Us Photons Do To Escape The Cage?

Think of some yourself as well, but my trap escapes are:

Giving, simplicity, calmness, self-compassion, compassion for other photons, self-respect,

self-belief, acceptance of all others, health, playing to your strengths, not being attached to

outcomes, gratefulness for the gift of the supernovae (it's rude not to be), awareness, love,

discernment, comedy, not clinging to things. Enough is everything, no hoarding. Cheap clothes,

good food, train rides. Be present.

And strangely, your life gets better.

I'm not riddled with anxiety anymore. I don't self-harm anymore. I feel like I'm enough. I lean into

my neurodivergence as a way to have a different perspective, I see it as a superpower. I don't try

to commit suicide anymore. I don't drink and do drugs anymore. I don't compare myself to others

anymore. I don't hoard crap anymore. I've cut toxic people out of my life. I'm living in the now. I

have no fear anymore. I don't avoid pain anymore. I laugh at the absurdity rather than rage against

the machine, discernment against the machine. My relationship with my wife is better. I lost 30kg. I

have slow-dopamine hobbies: writing, NRL, meditation, nature walks, dog walks, Lime bike rides

through Sydney, philosophy (Spinoza is a huge influence), comedy, and more.

You can start to see the difference in someone outside the cage, after they realised you can

actually just walk out of it. I have compassion for you all still inside it. I don't look down on you like

the elites do. They think you're stupid for being in the cage and not just walking out of it. They think

they're above you. I see you as the same photon as me. I'm not above you, I'm not below you,

you're just the same supernova star stuff as me. I opted out of the cult, and so can you!

Admiration Is An Expensive Currency

Be very careful who you choose to give admiration to. Find substance and consistency in

someone if you are going to give any admiration, but also remember they are just a fellow traveller

on this journey in life. They are not to be put on a pedestal, as it lowers your self-worth. We are all

flawed human beings, every one of us.

Some examples of fellow cosmic travellers I like: Greg Inglis, Brian Cox, Yongey Mingyur

Rinpoche, Baruch Spinoza, George Carlin, Tim Dillon, The Elephant Graveyard guy, Stavros

Halkias, Carl Sagan, Dan Tapiero, Banksy, Dynamo, Nter, Anthony Bourdain. These people were

and are their unapologetic authentic selves, and a lot of them have had deep pain to go through,

which leads me onto my next part.

The Two Sequences

Life Inside The Cage · Page 4 of 9

A lot of people live in fear, but once you let go of fear the whole world opens up. There are two

sequences people run, a right one and a wrong one.

Correct sequence: Fear, Courage, Sit with pain, Freedom, Peace.

Wrong sequence: Fear, Avoidance, Fake peace, Emotional prison.

See, the only difference is avoidance. Avoidance feels like peace, but it isn't. It's an anaesthetic

with interest. Every time you dodge the thing, the dodge gets easier and the thing gets bigger. You

drink past it, scroll past it, work past it, buy past it, and the fear is still inside, just renamed. Now it's

called "busy" or "fine" or "that's just how life is." Fake peace never holds, that's the tell. Fake peace

needs the storm in your mind to stay away forever, and the storm never agrees to that. The cage

doesn't hold you with locks. It holds you with the wrong sequence, repeated daily.

Burt Munro, The World's Fastest Indian, with Sir Anthony Hopkins. Burt walked through his fear

with courage. He was told he was too poor, too stupid, and was laughed at. He sat with his pain,

his failures, his setbacks, and ended up breaking the land speed record on his old Indian

Motorcycle on the Bonneville Salt Flats in Utah. This led to freedom and peace back in Invercargill,

NZ.

Sir Anthony Hopkins, in his own life, has discussed his past issues with alcoholism. He said he

was ashamed of his drunk driving, as he could have killed someone, but if he killed himself, he

didn't much care. That's the beast talking right there, isn't it? The fear of hurting others barely

registers, because the self has already been written off. Just a bloke who was drunk and

ashamed, drinking himself towards the edge, and he sat with the pain instead of drowning in it, did

the hard thing, and came out the other end as a highly respected man.

• Fear first: the shame, the self-hatred

• Courage: facing it instead of drinking past it

• Sat with the pain: the sobriety, the honest reckoning

• Freedom and peace: and now the man spends time painting, making music, and being at

peace in his 80's

I can relate to this, being a recovering alcoholic who is ashamed of when I drove drunk, and who

also didn't care what happened to me. I had written myself off at 13 years old.

There are smaller examples too. I had a huntsman spider living in our house named Peter, whom I

had been avoiding. The other day I walked through my strong fear of spiders with courage, put a

glass over him and a bit of paper underneath, took him outside and released him in the garden. He

was free, I was free, we were both at peace again.

The good news? The sequence can be swapped. The bad news: if you have a lot of pain, it may

take years of sitting with your pain before you reach peace and freedom. But the suffering is worth

the reward, and remember: your suffering is shared. Everyone has pain, and knowing it's shared

Life Inside The Cage · Page 5 of 9

lightens the load. I hope this message reaches young people before they fall off the cliff, as it's a

long, painful climb back up.

Learn to understand pain rather than fight it. Then you can see other people's bad behaviour as

their pain leaking out of them. It doesn't make their bad behaviour right, but it explains it, and it

doesn't mean they get access to your life.

A Shortcut To Financial Freedom

This leads me onto young people, and how to attempt to gain financial freedom. It took me 41

years of pain and being broke. I want to create a shortcut for you, so you can avoid being forged in

hell first.

Toss your past, don't live in it. Just take the lessons, move on, and be present, that's where the

real magic lives. Don't worry about the future either; that's a trap. You can make up horror movies

that might happen, and then they don't eventuate. So what, a waste of time. Close the horror

movie set and live in the now.

Here is the shortcut. It still takes hard work and risk, there's no avoiding that, sorry. The idea is to

lower the risk as much as possible and be right more times than you are wrong. You don't need

insider knowledge or celebrity investors to do this. You need a few boring rules, held for years:

• No leverage. Only buy what you can afford to buy outright.

• Buy and sit. Don't get into the trading trap. Whatever assets you buy, hold them. Time in, not

timing.

• Use an ethical bank. They're all far from perfect, but choose one that doesn't invest in

weapons manufacturing or fossil fuels, and don't let them gaslight you, ever. If they do, just

leave. (Look up the HSBC whoopsie, when they got caught money laundering for the Mexican

cartels.)

• Don't buy what they're selling. When the cult leaders flog you a product, that's the distraction.

Watch what they do, not what they advertise, and mostly, just keep it simple and boring.

• Invest ethically. There will be some investments you shouldn't make because you have a soul:

drug dealers, weapons, surveillance. Use your common sense. Common sense is your most

important asset. I lived with a PhD neuroscientist who burnt her toast every morning and I had

to tell her how to make mashed potatoes. Play to your strengths.

• Stay frugal. Keep your needs small and your surplus large, then you have something to give.

• Don't panic when they shake the tree. When the cult leaders shake the tree to see who loses

their nerve when the price plummets, stay in the tree with them. You'll notice they never leave

the tree. In fact, they buy the fear at a cheap price.

Life Inside The Cage · Page 6 of 9

You don't need to copy anyone's portfolio. The strong core above is the whole game: keep it

simple, keep it ethical, keep it boring, and let time do the work. Don't fall for the fear-peddling trap.

Don't fall for the status trap, the debt trap, or the leverage trap either.

A Word On Generational Advice

One trap worth naming, but let's name it fairly: don't dismiss advice just because of who is giving it,

and don't swallow it just because of who is giving it either. Some older people did pull the ladder

up behind them and say "too bad, got mine." Some generations did have it easier, and it's fair to

acknowledge that. But the test for any advice, from a Boomer, a Gen Z, or anyone in between, is

the same test you use for admiration: substance and consistency. Judge the advice by its

substance, not by the age of the speaker. You'll find wisdom in unexpected places, and nonsense

in expected ones. Your common sense is the filter, not their birth year.

That said, one generational note stands: there's not much juice left in the property lemon. It's been

squeezed all out and passed to you as a carcass. A house should be a sanctuary anyway, not a

profit maker. Banks make record profits off mortgages and are not to be trusted. Use an ethical

one, and only if you must.

Staying Humble

Don't get a big head if you start doing well. Anthony Bourdain said, "the more I think I know, the

more I know nothing at all." Don't let pride come along and then turn into greed. Same when you

think you have the world figured out. Once you think you have arrived, you have already left. Stay

humble, stay frugal, keep growing, and give any excess away to ethical charities outside the

system, like the Goanna Academy. Don't tell anyone you're giving, either, or it becomes a

transaction. Do it anonymously, without the need for validation.

Work And Purpose

You don't need to be an academic to do well in life. You will need a job to make money to put into

your ethical investments, so if you hate your job, start finding ways to leave. It's never too late to

start a new career.

If you are a young person, think hard. Remembering you're not in the status game anymore: you

have read this far, so you are opting out. If you are not innovating something or starting a business

(which can also be a trap, don't let it become your identity), a trade is a great place to start.

Plumbers, builders, electricians, welders, all earn six figures once qualified, and are not riddled

with student debt. Plenty of money for you to invest each week. It beats sitting behind a screen

designed by cult leaders in a cubicle with a mask on.

The honest caveat: it only works if the trade suits you. Play to your strengths, not to the list. If you

decide you don't like it, stick with it for 10 years, that will go fast! Wait until your investments take

Life Inside The Cage · Page 7 of 9

off, then think of something else, but you must have purpose.

You can find purpose from your hobbies. Some of mine are astronomy, writing, reading

philosophy, and helping youth. You can find jobs from your hobbies. Maybe be a youth mentor, for

example. Help stop the kids from falling off the cliff. Teach them not to hate themselves, and to opt

out of the cult.

Life Inside The Cage · Page 8 of 9

Fear, Courage, Sit with pain, Freedom, Peace.

The cage was never locked. Walk out, shine anyway, and give the light away.


r/Spinoza • • Aug 31 '25

What are the biggest obstacles a "beginner" would face on Spinoza’s path to wisdom? (And how does the Ethics address them?)

3 Upvotes

Assuming one takes Spinoza’s Ethics as a guide to becoming wiser (or more perfect or free from passions), what are the practical difficulties an "ignorant" reader (i.e., someone dominated by imagination/passions) would encounter—and how does Spinoza acknowledge or address these challenges?

Texts I’m wrestling with:

  • Ethics II, Prop. 49, sc. (full peacefullness)

  • Ethics V, Prop. 42, sc. (the "arduous" path)

Subsidiary question: can we say there are there "stages" in Spinoza’s path? (E.g. after the 3 knowledge types: first reducing imagination, then improve reason, then master intuition?)


r/Spinoza • • Apr 06 '25

Spinoza and Descartes Mind-Body Problem

4 Upvotes

I need critiques for Spinoza's solution to Descartes mind-body problem. They have to be extremely logical and well-supported arguments. Cannot be throw away statements and have to be reasoned well. Will appreciate any help, I really need an A on this paper:)))


r/Spinoza • • Mar 25 '26

If God is Nature, why does Spinoza give ontological arguments?

4 Upvotes

Why not just dispense with all that God talk? Since Nature is self evident, he doesn’t need to argue for its existence.


r/Spinoza • • Nov 29 '25

Metaphysics

5 Upvotes

What is the underlying dilemma in treating non-divine subjects as their own substances? In other words, how did he convert them only to modes of substance, which essentially reverts all subjects of existence into modes of the only substance ‘god,’ making them a sort of reflected agents of it? How did Spinoza resolve it?


r/Spinoza • • Jan 29 '26

My Paper on Deleuze: Spinoza, a Practical Philosophy

Thumbnail
open.substack.com
7 Upvotes

I recently published an analysis of Gilles Deleuze's book on Spinoza. If you want to check it out, I'd really appreciate your support and any constructive feedback.


r/Spinoza • • Sep 02 '25

Can Spinoza’s Ethics itself be considered the "path" to greater perfection or beatitude? If so, how?

8 Upvotes

The hypothesis I would like to test here is that the Ethics is not just a theoretical treatise, but also a practical guide—a structured itinerary for the reader to follow in order to achieve his own greater intellectual and ethical perfection.

My question: To what extent is it accurate (or textually supported) to claim that the Ethics itself—its structure, method, content, and progression—constitutes the "way" (via) to beatitude? In other words, does Spinoza intend the book to function as the very path he describes (e.g., in V, Prop. 42, sc., "If the way which I have pointed out […] seems exceedingly hard, it may nevertheless be discovered.")?

Key points I can see to supporting this hypothesis:

  • The geometric method as a pedagogical tool: Does the step-by-step demonstration mirror the reader’s own progression toward adequate knowledge?

  • The order of the books: Does moving from metaphysics (I) to human bondage (IV) to freedom (V) reflect a deliberate spiritual or intellectual ascent?

  • Scolia and "digressions": Do passages like II, Prop. 11, sc. ("Here […] readers will come to a stand […]; I therefore beg them to accompany me slowly, step by step") or V, Prop. 42, sc. suggest that reading the Ethics is part of the ethical work?

  • Historical context: Were early Spinozists (or Spinoza himself) known to treat the Ethics as a manual for self-transformation?

Last question: Are there secondary sources (articles, books) that address this idea of the Ethics as a practical path?


r/Spinoza • • Apr 16 '25

Question about Determinism

10 Upvotes

This question might sound stupid since I am new to Spinoza but I was wondering what his stance on "self improvement" was.

If all our actions are already predetermined doesn't that mean that we are incapable of changing ourselves? Of course we can change as a human but it never is our own decision and just a result of all the causes that have impacted us.

Connected to this is the question of why some people have to live such a shitty life. If the purpose of life is to become a free person then what about people who never had a chance at it. There's tons of people that die early before being able to form any philosophical thoughts, are they just determined to die early?

Once again, sorry if any of this sounds stupid. Correct me about any wrong assumptions I've made.


r/Spinoza • • Jul 29 '25

Spinoza's Ethics Explained: The Path to Supreme and Unending Joy — An online lecture & discussion series starting Monday August 4, open to all

Thumbnail
reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/Spinoza • • Apr 27 '25

Does anyone have a primer?

5 Upvotes

I'm new to his thought and could use a brief rundown of his ideas and works


r/Spinoza • • Mar 22 '25

Revisiting Spinoza

5 Upvotes

I found spinoza during my bachelor's and never really dug deep into it. I always meant to come back to read Spinoza: On God but it was left out with time and everything happening. Now I am considering to do another Masters, quite clueless about life and all the decisions I've made so far. Adulting is Clueless for most part and I've been digging into my old list of books I've always stacked away to read later on.

I want to dig right in reading Spinoza but wanted some heads up of where should I begin.

I want to read the primary text so I can try to grasp on my own interpretations. Thanks


r/Spinoza • • Mar 27 '25

Spinoza was right in saying that God is the cause of all things within the framework of his philosophy. It is we who have understood him in an inappropriate sense.

9 Upvotes

I believe that this statement by Spinoza has been misunderstood and misinterpreted.

Given the monism between the world and God in Spinoza’s thought, any object in the real world belongs to one of the alternative and infinite forms of divine being. Thus, the law of causality to which our mind refers plays its role insofar as it is subject to time and space, which are merely facets of the world but are transcended by God. However, God cannot be subjected to the law of causality due to His immensity. Moreover, God does not cause anything; causality is merely a limited form of the manifestation of His existence.

In other words, God is the cause of each object in the same way that a mathematical function f(x) relate to all its possible values. Many people interpret the idea that God is the cause of everything that exists as if 4, 6, 8… exist because x = 2, 4, 6 in the function f(x) = x + 2, believing that 2, 4, and 6 are the causes and that God is 2, 4, and 6. In reality, Spinoza’s statement is more metaphysical: God is nothing other than the function f(x) itself. God is the very notion of cause, regardless of the values; those values do not stem from Him but from us.


r/Spinoza • • 9d ago

New Spinoza Podcast!

32 Upvotes

Hello everyone!

I'm Michah Gottlieb, and I've been teaching Spinoza at NYU for two decades. Together with Clare Carlisle, a leading Spinoza scholar, I've started a podcast called Spinoza Unravelled, in which we read and unpack Spinoza's writings line by line.

Our aim is to make Spinoza's philosophy accessible and engaging while taking his arguments seriously. We're particularly interested in what Spinoza can teach us about living a good life.

We've released nine episodes so far. Episodes 1–6 explore an early work in which the young Spinoza describes how he came to devote himself to philosophy. In episodes 7–9, we've begun working through the Ethics itself.

Each episode runs about 25–35 minutes, and we release a new episode weekly. So this is a particularly good time to join us as we begin exploring the Ethics!

We'd especially welcome questions, comments, and disagreements. There's a place on our website to submit questions, and we'd love to hear what you think and what you'd like us to explore.

You can find us at spinozaunravelled.com, or listen on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.

Hope you enjoy it. We'd love to have you join the conversation!


r/Spinoza • • Mar 06 '25

Spinoza and Suicide

7 Upvotes

My copy of the ethics is a little dusty. I remember that Spinoza addresses it, but it didn't feel very satisfying.

How do we reconcile the possibility of suicide as that action which most radically forecloses my capacity to act.

My first thought is that Spinoza would say that it's not actually me doing it, but maybe some part within me, the same way we'd understand a cancer, but this feels pretty unsatisfying. Spinoza for sure has to foreclose the possibility of rational suicide.

Anyway, this seems like a big hole in Spinoza.

(Generally love Spinoza. He's my favorite modern)


r/Spinoza • • Aug 09 '25

Ethics, A Convenient Version (All Free)!

Thumbnail readphilosophy.org
12 Upvotes

This is a restyled version of Spinoza's Ethics with pop-ups to quickly read the references to other axioms, definitions, propositions ect.

Let me know what you think!


r/Spinoza • • Dec 19 '25

Spinoza translations, guides, & commentaries?

7 Upvotes

Hello, I don’t read much philosophy but I have a great interest in reading Spinoza’s Ethics quite extensively & would appreciate recommendations. I can read English, French, Spanish, & German, so anything in those languages are welcome. Thank you


r/Spinoza • • Jan 28 '26

What kind of Infinity is Spinoza referring to? And what "reality"?

Thumbnail reddit.com
5 Upvotes

r/Spinoza • • Apr 12 '25

His “ethics”

4 Upvotes

Hello everyone, I have been studying philosophy for a year and a half and am willing to put in the effort, would you consider his “ethics” easy to read or would you recommend it in general? Thanks


r/Spinoza • • Feb 19 '26

Spinoza and Natalism

3 Upvotes

Needing to parse out my thoughts on this subject in a casual way, with the aims of creating some discussion in the comments. I don’t think anything I am articulating here is final, but this will be a good way to get started.

Spinoza is pretty quiet on the subject of child-rearing. Of course, in The Ethics, there is no conception of duty or obligation; to the intellect, claims of the existence of commandments are likely to be followed by the inquiry: “from whom does this commandment come?”. God/Nature wills everything from absolute necessity, and in Nature there is neither an implication that humans should nor should not procreate. The only significant reference is in part IV when Spinoza mentions how marriage should be undertaken for the sake of freedom of the spirit and the desire to rear children rightly (or something like that—I’m paraphrasing). For two passive individuals, child-rearing is likely understood as a determinate event following the inability of each individual to remove the trace effects which external bodies had upon them. I don’t think that it would be viewed as something affirmative within the intellect in The Ethics then.

What about “active” individuals then? Spinoza supposed that the following are adequate ideas: 1. The endeavor to persist in our own being is our very essence; 2. That no individual strives to persist for the sake of something else.

What Spinoza’s metaphysics lack, I think, in order to perform a more affirmative take on procreation, is an organic phenomenology. In certain ways, having been conditioned by Judaic ideas, and being reared in an urban environment, I see Spinoza’s metaphysical take on the world to lack earthliness. He converts virtue from a supernatural lens into an intellectual one, but the rays of his seeing never descend from the mind down to the heart, gut, groin, grass, family, and other individuals. Man is always for himself, by himself; and despite Spinoza’s ability to recognize the radical interrelation of all things, he goes lengths to protect the individuality of the human being. But is it because our individuality is an immutable metaphysical fact, or because Spinoza himself was affected by determinate emotions and desires according to which a committed bond of love (marriage), and thus child-rearing, were not in accordance with his nature?

Take the second idea in my third paragraph for instance (it comes from E4P25): despite Spinoza’s emphasis on the indivisibility of substance, he restricts the totality of our striving essentially down to “our own sake”, as if we are not already always absorbed in desires which are unified with distinct activities/traditions/potentialities within the world into which we have been thrown. Is child-rearing not merely an extension of the self, according to which our conatus finds its fulfillment? Sure, maybe procreation is not a prioritized mode of Nature (which is non-hierarchical in my reading of Spinoza) but is it not possible that the essences of many humans are organized in such a way that responding affirmatively to the organic capacity to rear children is a prioritized power?

Maybe I’m just curious how others intend to rationalize the will to rear children or not to.


r/Spinoza • • Jan 02 '26

Timelines and Train Times: Finding Freedom In Necessity

Thumbnail
open.substack.com
4 Upvotes

r/Spinoza • • Mar 30 '25

Spinoza’s TTP and TP thesis

4 Upvotes

Hi all, I’m writing my Ba thesis on social contract theory in Spinoza’s TTP and TP. Basically I want to investigate whether Spinoza’s departure from demonstrating the origin of societal institutions in contractarian terms in the TP is a genuine break with the social contract theory he explicitly endorses in the TTP. Does anybody have any recommendations of literature that has been written on this topic in Spinoza’s political philosophy specifically? I already came across some of Alexandre Matheron’s papers which are a great starting point but would appreciate some more background literature:)


r/Spinoza • • Dec 27 '25

My New Article On Ethics

4 Upvotes

Guys, as I mentioned in the past, I’ve finally written this piece after reading the book for a second time. To my fellow Spinoza readers feel free to roast me. Hahaha. Any form of feedback is appreciated, as I’m not shy about harsh remarks, so don't hold back. Here:

Link