r/Spinoza • u/Redzinho0107 • Oct 22 '25
I would like to present the spinoza system in a visual way.
Image taken from: https://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/articles/13964-Spinoza-baruch-benedict-de-spinoza
The second image is better.
r/Spinoza • u/Redzinho0107 • Oct 22 '25
Image taken from: https://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/articles/13964-Spinoza-baruch-benedict-de-spinoza
The second image is better.
r/Spinoza • u/Party-Judge8037 • 3d ago
Hello everyone!
I'm Michah Gottlieb, and I've been teaching Spinoza at NYU for two decades. Together with Clare Carlisle, a leading Spinoza scholar, I've started a podcast called Spinoza Unravelled, in which we read and unpack Spinoza's writings line by line.
Our aim is to make Spinoza's philosophy accessible and engaging while taking his arguments seriously. We're particularly interested in what Spinoza can teach us about living a good life.
We've released nine episodes so far. Episodes 1–6 explore an early work in which the young Spinoza describes how he came to devote himself to philosophy. In episodes 7–9, we've begun working through the Ethics itself.
Each episode runs about 25–35 minutes, and we release a new episode weekly. So this is a particularly good time to join us as we begin exploring the Ethics!
We'd especially welcome questions, comments, and disagreements. There's a place on our website to submit questions, and we'd love to hear what you think and what you'd like us to explore.
You can find us at spinozaunravelled.com, or listen on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.
Hope you enjoy it. We'd love to have you join the conversation!
r/Spinoza • u/CarrotMonster157 • Dec 04 '25
Am I weird or is Spinoza, in his way, kind of funny? I often find myself laughing when reading some of his more sardonic and colorful comments. For example, when he writes that if a stone had conciousness it would think itself free, that if triangles could speak they would say that God is eminently triangular, that a fool is no more bound by the dictates of reason than a cat is bound to live by the laws of the nature of a lion.
It's not an extremely important question, but I'm just curious to know if others have the same experience.
r/Spinoza • u/staygoldd • Jun 09 '25
Hi everyone! I am so excited to have found this community. :)
I've been obsessed with Spinoza for the last few months. His ideas have completely reshaped how I view the world. I even made a camping zine inspired by his philosophy.
I recently watched an episode of Van Der Velt that was unexpectedly Spinoza-themed and it inspired me to build a Spinoza website.
Anyway, I am a teacher who likes to build educational apps, and my latest project is called Ethica. It breaks down Spinoza's ideas into small understandable pieces. There are some interactive simulations, reflection prompts, and a "SpinozaBot" that you can chat with.
It is still a work in progress, but I'm looking for other Spinoza lovers who would like to try it out & provide feedback. You can try it here: https://tethica.replit.app/
r/Spinoza • u/PTwolfy • Oct 20 '24
One of the greatest philosophers of all time, and this community has 50 members and 2 posts. (Now 3).
r/Spinoza • u/Much-Flamingo-9424 • Oct 29 '25
What I appreciate about Spinoza's philosophy and worldview is that the Ethics is a viable ontology (explanation for the nature of being). According to Spinoza, God is the natural world, and he even uses "Nature" as a substitute for "God" to strip away the theological baggage associated with the Primary Creative Force of the universe.
I came to learn of Spinoza after having a disagreement with a mechanical engineering studying vacuums, when I observed that a pure vacuum could not possibly exist, and by extension, that also means "nothingness" cannot exist in the physical universe, and thereby there is no boundary to the universe at which point the physical universe buts up against nothingness.
Spinoza's worldview reconciles a lot of what I have learned about physics, quantum phenomena, and spacetime. If Nature is emergent and if Nature is physically infinite, than everything is possible and is happening everywhere all at once.
Spinoza's worldview also reconciles human agency with free will—because everything is happening all at once, humans are made of the creative force of the universe and are thus embodying the free will inherent in the creative force of the universe they are a constituent part of. This idea is also explored at a fundamental level in the Hindu Upanishads (Atman is in Brahman and Brahman is in Atman, that is, what is true for the individual self is also true for the entirety of existence; the divine essence is both within and is the foundation of everything.)
Where I want to go deeper is to understand how quantum physics and different theories thereof, can best describe the mechanics of an infinite universe. For a classic example of how the Primary Creative Force of the universe works, look to the wavefunction (as demonstrated in the double slit experiment): particles like electrons behave as waves (showing interference) when unobserved, but act like particles (no interference pattern) when a measurement is made to detect which slit they pass through
My life goal is to fully reconcile Spinoza's worldview with quantum physics as the most accurate reflection of the reality of our observable universe, and then find a persuasive way to bring this worldview to popular culture, as tool to divest large parts of the world from religious dogma, and instead invest into education rooted in learning about the observable natural world.
I want to shift power away from the far right and archconservatives—of the ilk of the Koch brothers (whose father's money came from selling refinery technology to Hitler and Stalin, and whereby they continue to perpetuate their worldview of self-interest and white supremacy) and DeVos family (who seek to privatize K-12 education and indoctrinate children into Christian Nationalist ideology)—to move societies towards a social democratic model that dramatically reduces inequality and yields the best generational outcomes for the largest percentage of the population possible.
Spinoza's worldview is deeply compassionate and rooted in curiosity and respect and verifiable agreement of reality based on the scientific method. Religious doctrines are based on shame and a foundation of submission, which impugns self-respect and open-mindedness.
r/Spinoza • u/Unusual_Ad_8364 • May 20 '24
r/Spinoza • u/Ok_Improvement_3949 • Jul 31 '26
For anyone who wants a more visual way into Spinoza’s Ethics — not only the words on the page, but the geometric order that binds them — there is a free online companion here:
https://www.spinoza-ethica.com
It is built to help you:
Read the text with followable citations
See how propositions depend on earlier material (proof graph)
Follow short guided paths through the lattice
Map central concepts across the five parts
Explore the affects and how they relate
The aim is a study desk beside the book: browse, trace proofs, and discover relations in an interactive way. Part I is the fullest stretch; later parts are curated and still expanding.
Still work in progress. Feedback welcome — especially from readers and teachers who work with the Ethics in class or on their own.
r/Spinoza • u/fluxofstarss • Aug 25 '25
I love Spinoza, especially his notion of God & Nature, but find him pretty inaccessible. I only read books about him, and never him in the text. Would anyone recommend a good book on him/ by him to start diving deeper into his ideas?
r/Spinoza • u/VariationEuphoric319 • Aug 09 '25
This is a restyled version of Spinoza's Ethics with pop-ups to quickly read the references to other axioms, definitions, propositions ect.
Let me know what you think!
r/Spinoza • u/BlueBitProductions • May 21 '26
r/Spinoza • u/vishvabindlish • May 17 '25
r/Spinoza • u/atomx14 • Apr 16 '25
This question might sound stupid since I am new to Spinoza but I was wondering what his stance on "self improvement" was.
If all our actions are already predetermined doesn't that mean that we are incapable of changing ourselves? Of course we can change as a human but it never is our own decision and just a result of all the causes that have impacted us.
Connected to this is the question of why some people have to live such a shitty life. If the purpose of life is to become a free person then what about people who never had a chance at it. There's tons of people that die early before being able to form any philosophical thoughts, are they just determined to die early?
Once again, sorry if any of this sounds stupid. Correct me about any wrong assumptions I've made.
r/Spinoza • u/Both-Sock2244 • Jul 29 '26
A while ago, I published an analysis of Gilles Deleuze's book on Spinoza. If you want to check it out, I'd really appreciate your support and any constructive feedback.
r/Spinoza • u/distropika • May 10 '26
r/Spinoza • u/thirddegreebirds • Mar 17 '26
I'm reading the Theological-Political treatise, currently on chapter 15, and I'm pretty confused about something.
In chapter 6, Spinoza dismantles the idea of miracles. For him, there are no such thing as miracles, and the "miracles" that we see in the Bible are nothing other than orderly acts of nature which the people in those times did not have the scientific knowledge to comprehend. The "supernatural" or "preternatural" is a logical impossibility.
But in chapter 15, where he aims to firmly separate theology and philosophy into two distinct realms, he asks on what basis we should even believe in scripture and the prophets anyway. He notes that the authority of the prophets traditionally rested on 3 factors:
A distinct and vivid imagination
A sign
A heart turned toward what is right and good
He dismisses the first factor, since imagination is a personal quality depending on the individual mind of a specific prophet (which he discusses more at length in chapters 1 and 2). He therefore concludes that "we ... must accept only this reason for believing in Scripture – that is, in the prophets – namely, their teaching confirmed by signs." He then goes on to stress the importance of signs as confirming the divine source of the prophets' moral teachings.
Either Spinoza just did a total 180 and contradicted his whole argument against miracles here (which I find hard to believe), or he is drawing a distinction between miracles and signs – although I can't seem to find anywhere else in the Treatise where he explains such a distinction. Am I being too charitable to him here, or was it common knowledge in his day that there was a difference between a miracle and a sign? Is it that a "miracle" is something which is believed to contradict nature's laws, whereas a sign is closer to what we might call a synchronicity?
r/Spinoza • u/No_Art_1810 • Mar 27 '25
I believe that this statement by Spinoza has been misunderstood and misinterpreted.
Given the monism between the world and God in Spinoza’s thought, any object in the real world belongs to one of the alternative and infinite forms of divine being. Thus, the law of causality to which our mind refers plays its role insofar as it is subject to time and space, which are merely facets of the world but are transcended by God. However, God cannot be subjected to the law of causality due to His immensity. Moreover, God does not cause anything; causality is merely a limited form of the manifestation of His existence.
In other words, God is the cause of each object in the same way that a mathematical function f(x) relate to all its possible values. Many people interpret the idea that God is the cause of everything that exists as if 4, 6, 8… exist because x = 2, 4, 6 in the function f(x) = x + 2, believing that 2, 4, and 6 are the causes and that God is 2, 4, and 6. In reality, Spinoza’s statement is more metaphysical: God is nothing other than the function f(x) itself. God is the very notion of cause, regardless of the values; those values do not stem from Him but from us.
r/Spinoza • u/TakeMeInYourArmy • Nov 24 '25
I've just recently started trying to get into Spinoza by reading some basic stuff about his conception of God and noticed something that seemed interesting to me: in his conception of God as one infinite substance with attributes and modes and that there cannot be another substance besides it, it seems like Spinoza very casually acknowledges the issue of "a set of sets that don't contain themselves" and applies a kind of axiom of separation to get around it.
Spinoza suggests that there can only be one unique and unchanging substance because if there were another, it would necessarily be identical to the other substance and thus both contradict each other's defined uniqueness, thus negating each other's implicit existence. This, to my understanding, would necessarily be because in being the one unique, unchanging cause from which all causes stem from, Substance necessarily contains all cause. Substance would necessarily have to include Substance, but nothing can contain Substance as it is limitless, infinite, and unique. Substance would be subject to its own rules and necessarily have to contain itself, which would be a contradiction because it would thus make it a contingent existence and thus not the unique and unchanging self-caused Substance.
Because everything is dependent on Substance, everything is necessarily limited by it and cannot contain or limit Substance. They can be contained within Substance, but they cannot contain Substance themselves. So, in a sense, Spinoza recognises that Substance as a category has to be distinct from that which is within it. He needs a way to "separate" Substance from what is contingent on Substance in order to avoid creating a contradiction in which Substance can exist within itself or affect itself, and he does this by making distinctions between God's attributes and God's modes.
God's attributes are infinite and eternal and self-caused, whereas God' modes are finite and determined and contingent on a previous cause. Because attributes are infinite and unique, they are incompatible and cannot interact with each other. Modes, however, are finite and determined and contingent on the same causes/within the same Classes, and thus are compatible and therefore can interact with each other. In a sense, God's attributes are akin to Classes in Set Theory, his modes Sets, and God/Substance himself the Universal Class. This allows things that exist within Substance to exist within it without being Substance itself, and without contradicting the uniqueness of Substance so that it defies its nature and breaks the fundamental rules of logic and nature.
By defining God in this way and granting these distinctions between God's infinite attributes and his finite modes, Spinoza basically acknowledges the contradictory existence of a "Set of Sets That Don't Contain Themselves" and creates a system in which such a Set could not exist, instead being simply a "Class" or "Attribute". He basically realised back then that the idea of a totally unrestricted Set simply couldn't work, it needed to be restricted with Classes/Attributes which do not interact with each other due to their being incompatible.
Am I on to something, or do I have a fundamental misunderstanding on how either or both of these ideas/theories work? I will admit that I am not qualified in anything, either Philosophy, Maths, Theology, etc., so this is all based on limited knowledge I gained through independent reading and study.
r/Spinoza • u/strangewondermag • Nov 19 '25
Hey everyone, I have a substack where I frequently write about Spinoza. I thought folks here might enjoy: matthewgindin.substack.com. Here's one to get you started: https://open.substack.com/pub/matthewgindin/p/spinozas-recapitulation-of-parmenides?r=1nffy&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=false
r/Spinoza • u/New_Pin_9768 • Sep 02 '25
The hypothesis I would like to test here is that the Ethics is not just a theoretical treatise, but also a practical guide—a structured itinerary for the reader to follow in order to achieve his own greater intellectual and ethical perfection.
My question: To what extent is it accurate (or textually supported) to claim that the Ethics itself—its structure, method, content, and progression—constitutes the "way" (via) to beatitude? In other words, does Spinoza intend the book to function as the very path he describes (e.g., in V, Prop. 42, sc., "If the way which I have pointed out […] seems exceedingly hard, it may nevertheless be discovered.")?
Key points I can see to supporting this hypothesis:
The geometric method as a pedagogical tool: Does the step-by-step demonstration mirror the reader’s own progression toward adequate knowledge?
The order of the books: Does moving from metaphysics (I) to human bondage (IV) to freedom (V) reflect a deliberate spiritual or intellectual ascent?
Scolia and "digressions": Do passages like II, Prop. 11, sc. ("Here […] readers will come to a stand […]; I therefore beg them to accompany me slowly, step by step") or V, Prop. 42, sc. suggest that reading the Ethics is part of the ethical work?
Historical context: Were early Spinozists (or Spinoza himself) known to treat the Ethics as a manual for self-transformation?
Last question: Are there secondary sources (articles, books) that address this idea of the Ethics as a practical path?
r/Spinoza • u/Hal__Incadenza • 9d ago
I’m not new to philosophy (fair share of German Idealism, postmodernism, ancient philosophy and Analytical philosophy, mostly Wittgenstein though), but I haven’t read Spinoza yet. Usually I start with the main work of an author and if I like I read the rest.
So I’m not looking for a classical „first Spinoza“ book, but more for his main-work, most holistic perspective of his metaphysical claims.
Happy for any recommendations!
r/Spinoza • u/kevin_v • Feb 02 '26
Spinoza in is preface to the Ethics part Three puts the analogy right out there: considering human emotions "as if the surfaces of lines, planes or solids", but further than this, the entire Ethics is conducted more geometrico. Its a reasoning analogy based on geometric mathematics, yet (according to Letter 12) the status of mathematics itself is merely that of a "product" and an "aid" to the imagination. So what Spinoza is analogizing from is really something anchored in the Imagination. At the very least Spinoza is fairly inconsistent as to the status of mathematics and number throughout his writings, oscillating towards the Imaginary and then towards number being ens rationis (yet never ens reale). But, no matter what their status (and there is lots of debate about it, because he's inconsistent), I believe there is no real getting around the analogical nature of the Ethics itself, an analogy he even starkly asserts. Analogy and metaphor holding camp with at least one foot in the Imaginary. There are under emphasized aspects in Spinoza's philosophy which supersede (or alternately, underwrite) rationality, this being one of them.
r/Spinoza • u/Both-Sock2244 • Jan 29 '26
I recently published an analysis of Gilles Deleuze's book on Spinoza. If you want to check it out, I'd really appreciate your support and any constructive feedback.