TLDR: Ariens chewed two belts, pulley came loose, carbs fucked, governor failed and made piston soup. Under warranty repair and out of commission until May. Bought a Toro 824 out of frustration. It's aight.
I would like to preface that my experience does not lower Ariens in my regards at all. I love them, and when my unit worked properly, I loved it as well. Lemons happen, and unfortunately mine has left me needing a second snowblower in interrim.
As a recent homeowner, snow removal looms in the back of our minds as the colder weather sets in. Being of the mindset of "buy once, cry once", I had my heart set on an Ariens for my snow removal needs, as living out in the sticks with a 24 car driveway, meant reliability and adequate performance would be paramount. In my part of Canada, there isn't an incredible amount of authorized dealers, most being 45- 80 minutes away, making the convenient option being a chain store. Initially wanting a Toro Powermax 824OE because the Home Depot was 15 minutes away, I saw that a Rona depot had a deluxe left in inventory, and was 40 minutes away.
Driving off with newfound sense of determination and slight smugness would soon be met with slight disappointment. Upon arrival, the manager informed me the last deluxe was just sold, and that Rona would no longer be selling anymore Ariens.
Bummer.
Not one to waste a trip, I noticed there was a 24" Classic for sale for 1599$. As I inspected it, it became apparent this model has been used prior; dings and paint chips in the bucket and chute, small surface rust on the exhaust, and a small tear in the handle foam on the underside. This didn't bother me and I shot my shot with the store manager.
"This unit has been clearly used. I would be interested in purchasing it but not at advertised price. Can we work something out?"
"Let me know what you have in mind and I'll ask my supervisor "
"1050 plus tax".
And before I knew it, I was hauling off my new to me Ariens into my truck for the modest Canadian sum of 1200 odd dollars.
And so the waiting game begins.
First snow fall arrived in mid November, and it may as well have been Christmas for me. Loving anything with an engine and tires, I relished in the fact I was to conquer mother nature with a carefully crafted blend of steel, aluminum, and petroleum byproducts.
First use left me underwhelmed. It was a modest snowfall, and I recall a modest 8 or so inches. "It was wet, obviously it wouldn't throw as far as advertised" I told myself with a mild feeling of regret. The engine would belch black smoke on full choke and backfire, and stumble slightly at idle, and surge ever so slightly under load.
Odd. A new machine shouldn't need a carb cleaning. I figured a bit of seafoam should straighten the old gal out.
It did not.
Not one to take less than optimal performance for an answer, I tore into the carburetor as well as installed an impeller kit. As I tore the carburetor apart, 2 things came to mind; That the engineering while simple, was moderately frustrating to take a part and some parts could have been better thought out. The belt cover needing to be squeezed in behind the chute, as well as how the fuel line cover held in place made me question how many times it would hold up to reassembly long term. I noticed that the wiring for the ignition key showed signs of fraying, most likely to vibration causing it to rub somewhere it should not. Whatever. It will be a problem when it will be a problem.
The carburetor was astonishingly clean. Admittedly having ran 500ml of seafoam over the span of several uses, this could be expected. For good measure, I meticulously cleaned everything, and blew compreased air in the fuel line in case there was anything gumming up or restricting flow.
The following snowfall was slightly more demanding. We were looking at approximately 12 inches in the span of a fortnight, and eager to test my newly redone machine, went to work at the crack of dawn.
Disaster struck. Reaching the end of my driveway to plow the bank at the entrance, the auger completely stopped. I inspected the bucket, thinking it would have been jammed up, but was clear.
"This must be those famous shear pins that have finally gave" I told myself. I pushed the orange unit into my garage, ready to install the new pins I had ordered preemptively only to be met with two intact shear pins, openly mocking my theory.
That's when I noticed the belt cover had a perfectly round hole, as if someone were to have taken a holesaw to it and drill it out.
Welp. Removing the belt cover revealed that the pulley holding the drive and auger belts in place had come loose, sliding forward, cutting into the belt cover, and shredding both belts. While extremely frustrating, I was able to justify to myself that large scale manufacturing can leave to some faults and I just lost the luck of the draw. Daddy Ariens could do no wrong, they are the king of snow, afterall. The sticker included with my snowblower proudly attested to that as it laid on the front of my toolbox.
2 belts later and a peculiar mix of scotch, swearing, and more mild frustration left me with what would hopefully be a functional unit for long to come. Prior endeavor left me in the ideal position to recheck all bolts were snug, and figured I may as well rust proof it.
And for the better part of December and January, my snowblowing was uneventful. The new belts and carb cleaning left the machine feeling like it has a new take on life. While it still belched black smoke on full choke, the stumbling was gone, and it felt like it had more power, as it would bog down less on those nasty banks, and seemed to throw further.
As many people in north America dreaded this weekend's past storm, I could not have been more eager. "Finally a storm that could put my Ariens through its paces!" I thought to myself.
I had just finished stacking 5 cords of firewood, and refueling my inventory of gas cans and toys. I was ready for whatever mother nature had to throw at us.
We were left with about 15 inches of snow, and I could not have been happier. The Ariens was taking everything mother nature has thrown at it and demanded more. I made a path so my kids can walk to school, and finished blowing a circuit around my garage so my dog can run without being caught in deep snow. Navigating towards the driveway would be where my little classic would meet its untimely demise. As I had finished clearing the snowbank, I let go of the auger and drive lever to toss it in reverse and reposition myself. As I hit the auger lever, the engine surged with no slow down, and shut off.
"Oh. Oh no"
I went back to the garage with my unit, head hanging low as the pit in my stomach grew deeper. This is probably not something I can fix myself, and here.
I tear into the unit, belts are fine, carb looks fine, governor arms and springs are all in tact. Perhaps it lost index? The tightness of the bolt said otherwise. Low resistance of the governor arm leads me to believe the governor had failed and the engine subsequently created a delicacy known as piston rod soup.
Livid, and with snow still falling, I reached out to Rona, explaining the situation and how problematic this unit has been. Their return policy was only 90 days, and that it must be shipped off to the authorized dealer for repairs and left me with their contact information.
Calling them up, they said it will absolutely be passed on warranty, and I can expect to have my machine back in May.
May.
A lot of snow will fall between now and May, and my credit card company would not back me up for filing a dispute as the merchant is offering a solution, even though it isn't optimal.
I went out and bought that Toro I was initially looking at, and I do have a few key takeaways.
The engineering is nice behind the unit. Imperial sockets annoy the shit out of me, but everything was sturdy mechanically and made sense in terms of disassembly. The pulley for the belts are large. I made sure they were well torqued.
what a difference 50ccs make! This thing is angry. At first I thought the engine was perhaps broken or defective as it was much quieter than the Ariens (it was borderline deafening and I am already half deaf) at idle, but put it under load and it roars to life and just throws the snow without hesitation.
The joy stick is a gimmick. It's really cool, and is fun to play with, fulfilling my ambitions of taking off in a F14 Tomcat all from the comfort of my garage, however I felt more comfortable with the Ariens chute control.
I do not like the plastic. The dash, the joy stick, and even the bucket housing has a portion or plastic. I can't help but wonder how well it will hold up long term.
I will probably have to tear the carb a part. Idle pops and slightly surges, while under load it is fine.
This unit is man sized and a bit of a bear to handle. My biggest gripe with the Ariens Classic is it is small. I stand at a modest 6'2, 250lbs and operating the Ariens leaves me hunched over or arms straight down, not the most comfortable for long term use. The Toro Powermax handles are the perfect height, and those tires really dig in unlike the Ariens smaller ones.
At the end of the day I'm at a bit of a crossroads. I would love to own another Ariens in the future, but I'm thinking I would need a 252cc at minimum and perhaps even in the 300cc range. I enjoy simplicity, I don't want EFI, electric shoot controls, and I don't care for hand warmers. LED lighting is nice and for the cost of the Toro, it is insulting it doesn't have one. A 750$ power smart blower has 2 led lights.
One of these two blowers will be sold, and I'm probably leaning towards keeping the Toro, even though the king of snow continually beckons me.
Anyway, thanks for coming to my Ted talk.