r/SneerClub • u/dgerard • 22h ago
Yes, we have noticed the slop
r/SneerClub • u/ApothaneinThello • 4d ago
r/SneerClub • u/Icy-Recognition-7453 • 8d ago
Thank me later.
Who is Andy Ngo? He's a Trump-side pundit who first came to prominence when he showed up at an Antifa vs Proud Boys "protest" (read: street brawl) and Antifa beat him to a jelly. He also wrote a book about it, and appeared in the early Trump 2nd term at the committee hearings about Antifa-led violence. As some of you may know, he's now written a book about the Zizians, the trans vegan death cult who spun off from the Bay Area Rationalist and EA community. The Zizians are directly implicated in the deaths of six people and indirectly implicated in a bunch of others.
Some of you may have thought about buying the book, but held back: didn't want to give Andy Ngo your money, didn't have time to read it, whatever. Luckily for you, I had a mates-rates deal on a copy and I was on a long flight so I read it and took notes. In the twin spirits of public service and Ed Zitron, I've now written a lengthy essay about it; what was good, what wasn't, and what interested me in reading it.
BAD: Andy Ngo is to transgender people what Jerry Falwell was to gays
Most of you would have seen that coming. Throughout the book, Ngo flatly refuses to use anyone's chosen name, except in quotations where those names are used. If you don't like that, you'll hate this book. Unfortunately, this prejudice then colours the actual investigatory work. Ngo views the trans movement as the driving force behind the Zizians. While that argument seemingly has some merit on the face of it - the Zizians were all trans and all went crazy - it ignores not only the reality of the Rationalist/EA community, but the reality Ngo actually lays out early in the book. Which is a shame, because...
GOOD: The Rationalists/EAs get absolutely dragged
Ngo correctly identifies (but doesn't capitalise upon) the connection and pipeline between the Rationalists and the Zizians. He interviewed people on all sides - Rationalists, EAs, Zizian-adjacents - to draw up a picture of Rationalism as a cult. He clearly views the Rationalist/EA ethos as a load of slop, and he makes no attempt to hide this.
One thing he does particularly well is describe the pipeline that created the Zizians. The early life cycle of a Zizian is/was:
be from middle-class family, often in parents in tech
be on the autism specturm
do well in math/CS/something similar in school
excel - lots of Zizians got internships with major tech firms (Ziz's was with NASA)
get exposed to Yud-think, EA and LessWrong at a young age, usually early in college
decide AI "alignment", so-called, is the greatest challenge of the age
move to the Bay Area to pursue a career down those lines
What usually happened at that stage was a clash with reality. Then as now, in the early Ziz offing, Bay Area housing was unaffordable. This created the circumstances where the proto-Zizians, and other Rationalists/EAs, got cooped together in cramped group houses with a bunch of like-minded individuals. They then lived, worked and dated within these communities, all while steeping in Rationalist thought.
If that sounds familiar, it'll be because that's the same witches' brew that created the workforces of OpenAI, Google DeepMind and Anthropic. In fact, Ngo nails Amodei directly for being an AI alarmist and a prominent EA. For the first 25% of the book, Ngo lays out a character case against LessWrong and Yudkowsky in particular which is scorching. He treats the Bay Area Rationalist cult as predators who prey on the minds of young, vulnerable, autistic people, usually separated from their families for the first time in their lives. They then funnel into AI labs to further the aims, and lines the coffers of, the Yudkowskian complex. I agree with this framing, but even so, I tend to think he fleshes that out quite well. These are properly villanous people - callous, cynical, cruel and creepy. Prize "altruistic" moves allegedly included trying to convince people to have their life insurance pay out to MIRI and then kill themselves, as well as coercing teenage CFAR conference attendees into sex.
This leads me onto another failing, though.
BAD: Too much about the Zizians, not enough about who made them
This is my own bias showing through, but it is fair to ask. Mentions in the book:
Thiel: twice
Amodei: twice, both on the same page
Epstein: four times
Altman, Bostrom: never (!)
Tallinn, Buterin, Open Philanthropy: once each
This book would have been a lot better if Ngo had interrogated the Bay Area TECSREALists a bit harder. He establishes they are to blame, but then doesn't blame them. On the one hand, the book is presented as a true-crime piece about the Zizians. On the other, he discards his own findings to pick away at the Antifa/transgenderism scab a bit more.
BAD: Ngo's politics ruin the conclusions
Full disclosure: I'm not transgender, and I have absolutely no issue with transgender people. It's not my gender identity that's up for discussion. If you're transgender, I wish you a happy and full life in the skin of your choosing - you'll not hear a peep out of me to the contrary.
As alluded to above, Ngo spends the second-last chapter of the book slagging transgender people in quite some detail. This is doubly disappointing.
Firstly, the case he raised against Yudkowsky et al gets tossed away. In that case, he reveals the schism event. The Zizians were disavowed from the Rationalists in 2019/20. This was presented later as a principled stand by leading Rationalists. In fact, this was immediately after the Zizians tried to bum-rush a CFAR conference at Westminster Woods. The object was to accuse Yudkowsky of being a child sex fiend. To be fair to the Zizians, Yudkowsky didn't exactly cover himself in glory in that regard. To wit, when accused of sleeping with a 16-year-old:
"To the best of my knowledge, I have never in my life had sex with anyone under the age of 18... I think laws against older people having sex with 17-year-olds, are relatively okay laws. I have obeyed those laws.”
(Editor's note: Bruh)
Having established Yudkowsky as human vermin, Ngo then flatly ignores him in the conclusions.
He focusses more on the transgender lobby, which he sees as a shady force pulling the string. He is right, in some respects: he establishes that the pro-trans lobby of the Bay Area does have transhuman and TECSREAL connections, particularly in the form of people like Martine Rothblatt. The Zizian view on transgenderism (heavily TECSREAL influenced) treats it as variously as a superpower or as a problem to be surpassed using ASI.
Later, however, his Trumpism compliance chip kicks back in. He seems to ascribe transgender mass shooters as a phenomenon to be a creation of the transgender community, rather than the Zizians who usually directly inspired them. He also ignores that transgender people existed long before San Francisco, much less the TECSREAL lobby.
Even earlier in the book, Ngo can't bring himself to attack the Republicans in detail. He points out that SBF donated heavily to the Democrats, but there was no evidence to say SBF donated heavily to the Republicans. The first is true, but the second point misleads; SBF barely gave the GOP a penny but his offsider Ryan Salame gave plenty of FTX's money to the GOP. That point didn't make it through. He takes a lengthy detour to dunk on Ziz's father for being a Democrat, including finding people from his local community who are willing to talk shit about him. Another crying shame, because the story didn't need it.
GOOD: The book is actually pretty well written
Ngo does cherry-pick sources, but the book has an extensive bibliography, and all of it seems to actually exist. His prose style is pretty good; I breezed through the 321-page book within a 12-hour flight with several breaks. Even at that pace, he actually goes through the evolution of individual Ziz cultists in depth. Although he slags transgender people as a whole continuously, he does look upon the Zizians with pity and even compassion at times. While they were certainly no saints, even Ziz was not created in a vacuum. He shows more compassion to the victims than has otherwise been shown at times elsewhere in the media.
Moreover, it's a pretty damning indictment of Silicon Valley as a whole. Ngo describes and supports a case against the Valley where it is complicit in the crimes of Yudkowsky and his acolytes, if not in deed then certainly by omission. Viewing the Zizian life cycle as a whole, you start to see the seeds. Jacob Coxon, for instance, could have been a Zizian factory blueprint. Whether he got out early or if his brain really is cooked, we may never know. Certainly, there's plenty of other brain-fried Rationalists and EAs in San Francisco. If only Ngo had interrogated it more.
Wat do?
Should the average reader of r/BetterOffline or r/SneerClub bother with this book? Surprisingly - yes, but not at the current price point. Borrow a copy from your librul-hatin' uncle if you're keen. Or find it on the internet somewhere.
I think people should actually consider this book. I wouldn't go so far as calling it an important book, or even say you read it in full and agree with any of it, but it is a counter-perspective. In recent times, the TECSREAL community has gotten off scot-free. While Ngo attacks them only from the right, at least someone on the Right with any audience does. The next mass-market treatment of this issue will most likely be the movie "Artificial". By stark contrast, "Artificial" looks like it will view the issue from the left, make Sam Altman look like a villain - not that he needed a hand in that respect - and treat the Rationalists/EAs like brave heroes who stood up to him and lost.
Gather the facts and make up your own mind. Thank you for reading this far if you made it.
TL;DR - this book is a transgender-hating screed, but it does raise very salient points around the issues we face now with regards Silicon Valley. Some of it is complete junk, some of it is actually worth considering.
r/SneerClub • u/Better_Permit2885 • 18d ago
r/SneerClub • u/[deleted] • 19d ago
r/SneerClub • u/outer_spec • 25d ago
They seem interesting to me, and I want to learn more about them, but every time I try, I get very confused.
They seem to be interested in the same sort of concepts that Rationalists are interested in, technology, philosophy, accelerationism, crazy sci-fi worldbuilding exercises, etc. However the communities seem to have been created independently, CCRU was started in the 90s in the UK, Rationalism was started in the 2000s around yud’s blogs, and afaik neither of them were influenced by each other.
Also, Rationalists try to pretend that their ideas aren’t batshit insane, but the CCRU doesn’t seem to be doing that, if anything they’re proud of being batshit insane lol.
anyway i’m interested in hearing what you guys think about them, and learning more about them in general.
r/SneerClub • u/wnpwnp • 26d ago
To some, it is a problem that AI safety’s most influential voices can’t stop hosting orgies for each other. They think it cheapens what is, let’s be clear, quite a consequential debate. How, they ask, can we expect politicians and bureaucrats to take a bunch of Bay Area perverts seriously?
To which I say: how will they take them seriously when they wear such stupid hats?
r/SneerClub • u/ApothaneinThello • 29d ago
r/SneerClub • u/RJamieLanga • Oct 15 '26
r/SneerClub • u/dgerard • Oct 07 '26
I’m in a pile of excellent people opposed to the TESCREALists at this trying time in history. We need a name.
We have a list of possibles, but it’s actually hard to pick a nice name that doesn’t sound like an EA front group!
An initialism for S.N.E.E.R. probably won’t be the sort of thing we’re after lol.
What’s a name that’s (a) nice and polite sounding (b) says at least a bit what it actually is (c) doesn’t sound like an EA front group?
r/SneerClub • u/nokom • Oct 06 '26
I can’t figure out why the batshit insane cultishness of these CEOs isn’t on front pages everywhere. They’re literally like a cargo cult burning money to their god and promising that he will show up if we just burn a little more, BUT also he will destroy everything when he does. I guess billionaires pay to keep it quiet, but we need to shout it from the rooftops: these people are in a delusional cult, and they have dangerous amounts of power.
r/SneerClub • u/Well_Socialized • Oct 01 '26
r/SneerClub • u/ApothaneinThello • Oct 01 '26
r/SneerClub • u/ArpegiusDoll • Sep 30 '26
It feels effective-altruism adjacent, but different from rationality and AI doomerism, it's focused on how to find a fullfulling career.
Anyone heard the podcast / read the book / is familiar enough with this org to tell me if their advice is worth listening to?
r/SneerClub
•
u/spagornasm
•
Sep 30 '26
If Joyce Carol Oates ever talked about me this way I would turn into a pile of dust like Thanos had just snapped.
r/SneerClub • u/p0lari • Sep 27 '26