r/SneerClub • u/[deleted] • Sep 14 '21
Dishonesty on r/SneerClub
It feels like a lot of the posts on this sub are dishonest in some way. A few examples:
The title is just a strait up lie about what she's saying. She's not saying that she doesn't care about black lives, like the title implies. She's saying that she objects to identity politics and viewing the discussion of police violence through a racial lens. Maybe she's wrong. Maybe it should be viewed from a racial lens. That's a fair criticism. But instead the poster decides to strawman her views.
The title is saying the exact opposite of what he's saying. He's claiming that you can't change politicians by 'aligning' them the way you can with AI.
Again, more dishonesty in the title. He's not saying we should stigmatize it, not even "sort of". He explicitly says so in the second sentence. He's saying that we shouldn't stigmatize OR 'valorize' it. He thinks we should be neutral towards it, think of them like everybody else.
Jesus, this one's literally got it entirely backwards. She's pointing out that both homophobes and people who are grossed out by a fetish defend their hatred by saying they're "gross". The poster has that correct. But she's NOT saying that this makes 'homophobes' better, she's saying it makes the people who are grossed out by fetishes just as bad as the homophobes.
Look, there's plenty of people who pay lip service to rationality while failing to be rational themselves. But lets not lie about their statements to make them seem worse.