r/SneerClub • • Sep 14 '21

Dishonesty on r/SneerClub

1 Upvotes

It feels like a lot of the posts on this sub are dishonest in some way. A few examples:

https://www.reddit.com/r/SneerClub/comments/gxoevn/when_its_not_about_black_lives_shes_on_board/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3

The title is just a strait up lie about what she's saying. She's not saying that she doesn't care about black lives, like the title implies. She's saying that she objects to identity politics and viewing the discussion of police violence through a racial lens. Maybe she's wrong. Maybe it should be viewed from a racial lens. That's a fair criticism. But instead the poster decides to strawman her views.

https://www.reddit.com/r/SneerClub/comments/pnc46d/any_problem_can_be_solved_by_throwing_money_at_it/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3

The title is saying the exact opposite of what he's saying. He's claiming that you can't change politicians by 'aligning' them the way you can with AI.

https://www.reddit.com/r/SneerClub/comments/ozacst/maybe_we_should_sort_of_stigmatize_mental_illness/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3

Again, more dishonesty in the title. He's not saying we should stigmatize it, not even "sort of". He explicitly says so in the second sentence. He's saying that we shouldn't stigmatize OR 'valorize' it. He thinks we should be neutral towards it, think of them like everybody else.

https://www.reddit.com/r/SneerClub/comments/oilc12/aella_watching_out_for_oppressed_homophobes/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3

Jesus, this one's literally got it entirely backwards. She's pointing out that both homophobes and people who are grossed out by a fetish defend their hatred by saying they're "gross". The poster has that correct. But she's NOT saying that this makes 'homophobes' better, she's saying it makes the people who are grossed out by fetishes just as bad as the homophobes.

Look, there's plenty of people who pay lip service to rationality while failing to be rational themselves. But lets not lie about their statements to make them seem worse.


r/SneerClub • • Jan 17 '22

What percentage is jealousy NSFW

0 Upvotes

Listen, I get the basis of Sneer Club. The whole thing these people are doing is absolutely thinly veiled white supremacist accelerationism. They have to a tee ended up with the unabomber's philosopher, added in nothing more intelligent than the Tic Tac Toe sequence of War Games, and started a shitty little cult. I think the world cares less about what they do than what even Steven Pinker does.

But I have to admit a basic percentage of my hatred toward them will always be jealousy. Why? Because it is clear to me that everything in terms of society and community has been irreparably shattered by capitalism and libertarianism, alienation and commodification, until what's left is that the closest thing you could ever, ever get to a family in terms of spending time with people you love is a start-up company. Yes, I've got the COVID blues and I'm sort of saying the Devil won. But humor me here and let me go a little goth.

I'm bitter that for whatever years these delusional pretentious shits get the whole shebang: religion, prayer, parent figures, practically arranged marriages, and they never really toil, completely and utterly spoiled. They spend the whole time just vibe-fucking each other and believing they are the chosen few Top Mormons. They live their lives as if they are on the verge of inventing fully immersive Augmented Reality glasses when they haven't so much as improved the flavor of Cheez Whiz. They perpetually reinvent the basics of philosophy and political science and for no reason give it a new word - just to get high off their own fucking fumes again.

I'm just saying that as a fucking delusion, it seems desirable. I can see why people are willing to go quasi-psychotic for it, and every time I read the monologues of people who left, I always think, yeah, but you would've stabbed an innocent in an alley if it kept the whole delusion going, wouldn't you?

The part of myself I see in them makes me sickest of all.


r/SneerClub • • Aug 05 '21

NSFW Meta: The purpose of sneering

7 Upvotes

I would like to know, in good faith, how people who frequent this club think about and justify sneering as an activity.

Do you view it as a guilty pleasure, but not your best self? Or is it something that you fully endorse, such that you’d be able to calmly explain why it makes sense to someone willing to listen?

Edit: Downvotes ahoy xD


r/SneerClub • • Dec 26 '21

Want to talk about Mr. Robot God, here's the sub for you! NSFW

0 Upvotes

Infohazard warning, we all already know what this is but just incase.

So I went back down the old Acausal Robot God rabbit hole the other day, and in my stress fueled panic I came across r/rokosbasilisk,

This sub is basically dedicated to the discussion of muh AI god, with a lot of it dedicated to debunking the thing and helping people who have anxiety because of it.

But then we come across some real good sneer material my friends. I mean one guy actually linked a Julia Galef video.

To see the worst that sub has to offer just look for these posts:

'Tweaking {Acausal Robot god}"

And

'The Solution-debate me" (I may be missing the point with this one so please explain why I'm wrong, if I am, with regard to this post)

After checking those out, please feel free to sneer with me in the comments and we can have a laugh. Unless me writing this is a way to acausally blackmail me, but somehow I doubt that.

Note: sorry for the lack of links, mobile isn't treating me well right now.


r/SneerClub • • Apr 28 '20

Biden's Coronavirus advisor, Dr. Ezekiel Emanuel, on why life past age 75 is life unworthy of life that should be sacrificed for the economy

Thumbnail
theatlantic.com
0 Upvotes

r/SneerClub • • Dec 09 '21

What is this subreddit?

8 Upvotes

Is it the kiwi farms but for intellectuals?


r/SneerClub • • Jan 23 '19

Question

0 Upvotes

Why is there so much yudkowsky hate on this subreddit?


r/SneerClub • • Sep 16 '20

What do you call it when you go "red pill" on the "rationality" movement?

3 Upvotes

Obviously it can't be "red pill", this term is tainted.

Green suppository, maybe?


r/SneerClub • • Apr 10 '21

Falkovich on sex negativity

5 Upvotes

Falkovich argues society is too sex-negative (viewing sex as bad or only focusing on its dysfunctions like harassment etc.) https://mobile.twitter.com/yashkaf/status/1380568379115892736


r/SneerClub • • Nov 10 '19

In which a guy talks about emotional labor as if he's some sort of Lifehack genius for discovering it.

Thumbnail
medium.com
0 Upvotes

r/SneerClub • • Jul 02 '18

Best Criticisms of LW/SSC

4 Upvotes

I like Scott and SSC. I think there is a slight anti-SJW bias, though. It seems like this place focuses on criticism of the 'rationalist' community. I find Scott to try very hard to be intellectually honest and as evenhanded as possible. I'd like to find opposing perspectives that take Scott down with that same sort of approach. Can you offer me up the best of Sneerclub to convert me to the Sneer side?

Thanks.


r/SneerClub • • Aug 12 '26

Never Is Not a Number: Adam Becker is right about the billionaires. He's dead wrong about Mars.

Thumbnail
thecosmicintelligence.substack.com
2 Upvotes

There was a post in this subreddit about Adam Becker's book "More Everything Forever" when it came out, and he promoted it last month on a Taylor Lorenz podcast. This article examines his arguments about Mars, acknowledges his takedown of Musk and Bezos, but challenges his sloppy science.


r/SneerClub • • Feb 18 '23

NSFW Some LWer outs itself as a stupid chatbot

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/SneerClub • • Jun 22 '18

I'm a rationalist and I lack the self control to close this tab. Ask me stuff (not about the current events, I'm sorry, I'm not done reading everything).

8 Upvotes

Also I don't use reddit usually, you have my apology if I'm not using it right.


r/SneerClub • • Dec 27 '19

Hacker News shows its usual sympathy for poor people

Thumbnail news.ycombinator.com
6 Upvotes

r/SneerClub • • Apr 09 '25

AI 2027

Thumbnail
ai-2027.com
0 Upvotes

Yes, I'm aware of the tone on this subreddit (99% of the time I enjoy it). But as someone who lurks in both ACX and SneerClub, I figured I'd make you guys aware of something that is no joking matter.

Sneer all you want. I think there are very good reasons to believe humanity faces existential concerns in the next few years. And I think deep down there are some very well-intentioned people both here and on ACX (which is hardly a monolithic community).

Please read. Please spread the word.


r/SneerClub • • Aug 09 '19

Soylent and Rob Rhinehart - The Dollop

Thumbnail
soundcloud.com
0 Upvotes

r/SneerClub • • May 07 '18

Eliezer Yudkowsky's thoughts-and-prescriptions for Writing Well

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/SneerClub • • Jan 29 '23

Now I know why my fellow LessWrongers love Bayes Theorem so much

10 Upvotes

Edit: How in the world did people miss the sarcasm in this? Do I need to end the post with "/s"?

Card carrying rationalist here. I had always been puzzled by the statement "We're very big fans of Bayes Theorem" on the LW's "about" page, until I saw the Standard Bayesian solution to the Raven Paradox ... Its beautiful factual elegance moved me to tears. I never knew looking at apples had anything to do with ascertaining the colors of ravens until then. It was as if a whole new world of appleravens and ravenapples opened up in front of my mind's eye! This epiphany is just too great not to share, even with my worst enemies here. Regards!


r/SneerClub • • Mar 29 '22

Proof that modern utilitarianism/"rationalism" is openly a flimsy cover for Nazism

Thumbnail
lesswrong.com
0 Upvotes

r/SneerClub • • Feb 25 '19

Intellectual Dark Web vs Sneer Club? NSFW

4 Upvotes

The founder of Quillette just posted something of a manifesto, in which the closure of /r/ssc's Culture War thread serves to illustrate the need to protect free speech. In retrospect it's not surprising it would come to the attention of Quillette, but I'm surprised that it would be given that degree of prominence. Isn't that shutdown largely due to /r/sneerclub's efforts?


r/SneerClub • • Aug 06 '18

Whats The Actual situation with AI? NSFW

6 Upvotes

I'm not wanting to hear anything about how you think someone else is wrong.

I just want

Is superhuman AGI possible? Will it ever be developed? Would it be dangerous? Why?


r/SneerClub • • May 16 '25

See Comments for More Sneers! Foundation is overrated

0 Upvotes

A lot of these rationalist internalized Asimovs “Foundation” too much think that they’re Harry Seldon the psychohistorian I couldn’t finish the crappy novel on tape from the public library read by the author . These dummies should read more Umberto Eco, a real historian.


r/SneerClub • • May 06 '23

NSFW Is there a solid middle ground between extreme pro-natalism propagated by some from the TESCREAL community and anti-natalism coming from their critics? NSFW

2 Upvotes

I found this community to get more insights into the people behind AI doomerism following the recent media panic. While I discovered lots of weird stuff about EA, longtermism, which kinda comfirmed my intuitive mistrust towards ideas from this spectrum. However I have seen some sympathy towards antinatalism from the critics of TESCREAL community which I can not relate to at all, so I just wanted to know if one avoid falling into antinatalism while simultaneously discrediting TESCREAL ideologies?


r/SneerClub • • Mar 27 '26

Is this supposed to look like a Klan rally?

Post image
0 Upvotes