Hi,I showed up late to the party and only now watched all five seasons. I tried to pace myself because I wanted to savour it, but the show is ridiculous in the best way and I ended up ploughing through the whole thing in about three weeks. I kept telling myself I would stop after one episode, then suddenly it was two in the morning and Gary Oldman was shouting at someone again.
The writing is top tier, the acting is mostly brilliant, I say mostly because seasons four and five start drifting into slightly cartoonish goon territory, but the rest is so good that I forgave it. Gary Oldman, good lord. The man could read a takeaway menu and I would still lean forward. What I love is that the show uses him perfectly. He is there, he dominates every frame he steps into, yet the whole thing never collapses into a one man circus. Everyone else gets enough oxygen to grow.
The look of the show, the atmosphere, the pacing, all of it feels like people who really know what they are doing. Honestly, I finished season five and felt a bit sad that I now have to wait a year like everyone else.
But there's a thing that keeps poking me in the ribs.For all the buildup, the villains or antagonists, call them whatever you like, never land with the weight the story gives them. Every season starts like it is about to change my blood pressure. You get the tension, the clever misdirection, the political scheming, all of Lamb’s muttering, and it feels as if something massive is about to drop. Then the ending arrives and the whole thing softens. Not in a terrible way, more in a politely disappointing way.
And no matter what the bad guys do over the season, it always comes back to something personal and, compared with what we were led to expect, rather anticlimactic. I am not saying their motivation needs to be larger than life like a Bond climax, but when you break it down season by season, the pattern is hard to miss.
Season one sets up an alt right nightmare and ends with one angry bloke having a meltdown. Season two surrounds itself with Cold War atmosphere, sleepers waking up, Russians shifting pieces, MI5 falling over its own feet, and for a while you think something serious is about to happen. Then you discover it is a heist. Russian Die Hard with diamonds. Season three gives us a villain more sympathetic than half the official good guys and ends with an MI5 bloodbath that barely registers. Season four goes full Bond villain with super soldiers he bred. Season five builds a terror plot and finishes yet again with money, while trying very hard to explain itself politely so nobody gets offended, which is strange considering how freely the show went after Russia in season two.
I am not asking by any means for Bond style finales, but take season one as an example. You have an alt right group kidnapping someone, preparing a staged execution, feeding their message to the media, referring to a wider network that supports or disapproves of their actions. Yet they never interact with this supposed network and the whole thing ends with one man who pushed it further than the rest. The story treats the wider threat as if it simply vanished once he was gone, even though everything we saw suggests the danger came from a much broader place.
Even when the immediate threat is dealt with, it came from a world where many similar figures exist, but the show never acknowledges that. So you reach the end with the sense that the journey was better than the anticlamtic destination.
Curious if anyone else felt the same, or if I am the only one shouting at my TV like Lamb shouting at River.
Edit : Reddit, you did not disappoint. Almost no one opened the door for an actual conversation, barely anyone read the comments, and the few who did still dismissed it because it didn’t fit the herd. And of course, the downvotes. Like in most subs about TV shows, people enjoy their own echo chamber.