r/Shouldihaveanother • • 13h ago

Advice Scared I will miss the fun stage with my first

7 Upvotes

My first child is almost 3 and I finally feel like things are getting much easier and we can start to do more fun things like go to the zoo or cafes, or swimming, or catch a train to the city, play at more playground etc, but at the same time I want another child, I just think the overall bigger family is nice and I want them to have each other in life. But I’m worried that as soon as I’ve gotten to the stage where I can really spend time with my first doing more interesting things like the above, if I go back to sleepless nights and breastfeeding I’ll just not have the ability to do anything else. My husband also gets overwhelmed easier than most people but he also wants a second but in the back of my mind I wonder if he could actually manage because everyone says it’s more than double the difficulty of having one. Would love to hear what others think overall. Thank you!


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 13h ago

Fencesitting Changing my mind on one and done (OAD)?

6 Upvotes

So in 2021 my husband (then fiancé) and I got pregnant with a surprise baby. We weren’t trying, I had an IUD, but turns out an IUD doesn’t work for my biology (this was discovered upon my pregnancy). It was still covid lockdown for us, but even though I was a high risk pregnancy due to my biology, I loved being pregnant. It was amazing. A great time. Birth was fantastic and easy as well (scheduled c-section - due to breech).

We were so caught up in the haze of it all, when she was about to turn 3 we realized “oh we should discuss if we want to do this again”. We both pretty quickly came to the OAD decision for many reasons. Partly finances - things weren’t wildly tight, we had some comfort but that comfort would be gone with another kid (we both work full time and daycare is about $1000/mo for each kid around here) We also enjoy our alone time and our daughter was starting to become more independent. But something has been nagging in the back of my head since then and I will go from being super happy with OAD to second guessing it.

Now our daughter is closing in on 5, I am 37 and our daughter has started asking about a sibling which I know is totally normal for her age and isn’t necessarily indicative of whether she actually wants or understands what having a sibling means. I asked her once why she wants a sibling and her answer was “I love you and daddy so much and you are great parents and I want to share that with someone”. 🥺 she has never asked because she wants a playmate. She wants to share her life with another kid.

Before when she asked for a sibling I would reflect on it and usually came out content in our decision. We can offer her more of ourselves, finances are not as tight, all the things. But the other day when she asked hit different. All day I wasn’t able to get the idea of another kid out of my head. My husband and I talked extensively and he has thought about it too and he is truly content whatever happens. Although he brought up a great point about already feeling exhausted and burnt out with one kid and feeling like he can’t catch up as it is. He is basically okay if it happens, but is not keen to try for it right now.

In the last few months my husband and I have both gotten relatively big work promotions. They also come with more flexible schedules in some ways. However my husband does go on week work trips throughout the year - gone for 2-3 weeks at a time about 5 times a year or so mostly in the summer - he has been doing that since our first kid was born so I am used to it. But I do have to consider “do I want to single parent 2 kids instead of 1 when he is gone?” But with these promotions, if we had a second kid we would be in a similar financial position to where we were before with 1 kid and our previous jobs. Which was not a bad place to be in.

We had been getting excited about the things we felt like we could do now with more income and our kid getting older - trips, savings, all the things. I have felt very locked down the last 4 years. Part of that was due to Covid in her first year or two of life, the other part was we were hustling and saving money to get ourselves to where we are. I am finally starting to feel like myself again. However because of these things (more income and feeling like myself again), the idea of a second child sounds more exciting than it ever has before. About a month ago we did family photos and I loved them, but I kind of felt like it would have been nice to have another kid in the picture. First time I have ever felt that.

Before I only thought about another kid when she was asleep or when I wasn’t momming. But the other day I thought about it while she was awake and I was conflicted over the thought of another kid being in the mix. It sounded both fun and also like something I don’t want. Our daughter is amazing with babies and adores them so much, she would be a great big sister. At the same time, multiple times this weekend I have been thankful for only one kid. All weekend I haven’t once wished we had another kid in the house. Well, maybe once, when my daughter said she was bored. But that can happen no matter how many kids there are.

So yeah, super lengthy post. I am struggling to unpack whether I feel this because I miss my daughter being in the younger years and I am feeling how fast she is growing up, or whether I do really want a second kid. I love being a mom. My husband is an amazing father. We have great friends and family support. Our daughter is our whole world.

I have a half sister who is 5 years older and we were never close until we both had kids. But that was more due to the fact that she was rarely around and we are WILDLY different people. I consider my raising more in the style of an only. It was a wonderful childhood and I have always had super close friends. But I always wished for a more traditional sibling relationship. My husband is the oldest of 3 and close with his siblings. The youngest is 6 years younger so he gets the age gap we are possibly facing.

I want the freedom and financial excitement we have been looking at but also with a second kid 😆 which I know is not how it works.

So yeah, no clue. I don’t totally feel content with being OAD but I don’t know what that means or why I feel this way.


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 8h ago

Anxious We set a time limit, now I feel guilty, like I failed

1 Upvotes

I'm sorry if I ramble or if the post is too long. I feel crazy. My husband and I always said we both wanted two. We have one right now. This past year has made us very well considering being one and done and I feel like I'm wrong for that. I'm always being told don't decide now, or he will need a sibling for his benefit.

I'm a SAHM, and my husband works most the week on nightshifts. We are financially stable, but times get tough as they do for most folks. We've realized that having a bigger age gap is something that could possibly be very bad for our mental health and that if we wanted baby #2 it would have to be soon. We don't want him be starting school then starting back to square one. We have talked about the obvious unplanned pregnancy before this, if it was a surprise pregnancy then its just ok we're having another one. It's not that we wouldn't want another child or anything but there's alot to consider and pros and cons to both sides. We set a time that if I'm not pregnant by then, we will be done (I'm aware we can always change our minds but I kinda doubt that). It's within the next year.

I feel very guilty I'm okay with this choice, happy even. I feel like I failed for some reason. Like for putting conditions in place and possibly changing my mind. I mean I know its a joint decision and my husband is supportive but still. We really do want 2 but despite being younger I have physical health issues and long story short I almost died giving birth and I'm genuinely terrified of being pregnant again. My husband is scared for me too. What if our son really does need a sibling for his development or when we're old and gone? What if I'm being selfish? Am I crazy for feeling this way? I feel so damn silly just making a post about it but oh well. Does anyone else have this feeling? Please tell me it goes away, it feels like it shouldn't be this difficult of a decision. Is it worth bringing this up to family for support? Or no, because it isn't their decision? Again, it should feel this overwhelming.


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 9h ago

Having a second child after first had autism/ADHD

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Shouldihaveanother • • 18h ago

Am I crazy?!

5 Upvotes

Pregnant with another baby and my boys will be 6 and 8 when she’s born. I’ve posted about my worries here before regarding age gap etc, but I’ve been feeling worse about it lately because of some people’s reactions. It seems like everyone thinks this baby is a surprise and some people have seemed really shocked. Is it really that crazy to start over when my son hits kindergarten? I know it seems like a big gap, but for me it feels like my kids were toddlers just yesterday.. time has really flown. If you were to hear your friend was pregnant and she had a 5 and newly 8 year old, would you think it was nuts? It’s all just making my insecurities about this whole thing worse and it doesn’t feel great to announce :/


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 16h ago

How do you know when you’re ‘done’ having babies?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Shouldihaveanother • • 1d ago

I want one more, but he is set on No more.

3 Upvotes

Me 31, and my husband 35 have 3 kids together.

He has 2 from a previous relationship and we share a child together.

I helped him raise my bonus kids for 11 years and have always wanted atleast 1 more together. He dead set on no.

my heart hurts because all the women around me are having their 2nd, 3rd, etc.

I feel upset and part of me feels like I will resent him later in our life because he doesn't want to have another baby with me. I feel incomplete and really sad about it.

Is there anyone else going through this, or am I alone?


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 1d ago

Why is this decision so fucking difficult?

7 Upvotes

I woke up today to hear my husband discussing that his old friend, who’s wedding we are attending later today, chose not to have kids because they would like more free time. And I felt jealous.

We currently have one child, who just turned 4, and I was by and large one and done until maybe 6 months ago when I began considering a second. We were just married this August.

My husband would love a second, third, I am sure fourth child. However, after my extremely isolating and difficult postpartum experience with PPD, birth trauma, ongoing depressive episodes and just general struggles, I am not sure I even want a second.

We’ve been discussing starting to try in a few months, and some days I find myself wanting to buy baby items in Walmart. Then the next day, the idea of having more kids seems like the worst thing I could do, and fills me with dread. Actual dread. I want to travel, write novels, experience more of the world, while my husband would be happy to stay home (we live rurally on a farm) a lot of the time. I love where we live, but I also love travelling.

We have no village except daycare and relatives that live two hours away that we can rely on if planned weeks ahead. Our one daughter is lovely and was an easy baby (except sleep.) But everything is so much more expensive now, and I feel like I am just getting back to becoming myself. I still get the sundown scaries a lot, I struggle with travelling because I feel like I don’t want to go back to my life after I’ve had a chance to be independent and free.

And most of all, I think I would be unhappy if I had a second child because I did what someone else wanted; but I would be unhappy if I didn’t because I would feel I would be letting down my husband and not providing my daughter with a sibling (which I know isn’t a requirement and doesn’t necessitate a “best friend for life.”)

I’m just so, so, SO weary of ruminating over this decision. I have discussed it at length with my therapist and have yet to come to a conclusion of any sort. It takes up so much of my mental capacity some days that I just want to cry. And I am 32 and my husband is 38, so while we aren’t very old, I don’t want to be having a child after 35.

Anyways. Just throwing this out there out of frustration because I know now I am going to be ruminating on this all day, again.


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 1d ago

Advice Plans switching to have 3?

0 Upvotes

My husband and I have a 4 year old and I’m pregnant with our second son due in April. We thought we’d for sure stop at two kids but now that it’s another boy I’m not sure about that decision. We both had some gender disappointment but more so me and that I’ll never get to have a daughter. We’re 25 and 24, financially stable and are open to having a third later in life but my husband wants to adjust to two first and wait on a decision. I was thinking when my first son is 10 and the second is 4/5 we could try again. I will be having another c section in April and I know I should take each pregnancy a step at a time before deciding and adjusting to a family of four first it’s just I can’t believe my mind is open/planning for three now. I’d be okay if the third is a boy I’ll just probably feel another wave of gender disappointment at first..

Thoughts?


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 2d ago

Partner wants a second, I'm not so sure

2 Upvotes

My partner and I have a 19 month old. I love her so much. She makes my heart sing. She makes me laugh. I love showing her the world.

And, being a parent has also been the hardest thing I have ever done. The sleep derivation, the minimal social life, not being able to engage in as many adult conversations, lack of time alone with my partner, very altered travel plans, tthe lack of freedom to do what I want... it is extremely hard.

I wouldn't trade it, like I said I love being a dad. But the thought of doing all this again in addition to having a toddler, i just can't phathom.

My partner wants another kid. She loves being a mom. I don't want to disappoint her, and I would like to give my daughter a sibling, but I have to make the decision for me and not because of trying to please others.

Another aspect is I am 35 and looking at going back to school next year for a 2 year program in a new field. Ive struggled to find what I want to do for a job for years and though I've been fortunate in running a successful business, the work isn't my calling.

My partner is almost 38 and wants to have another kid sooner than later and wouldnt want to wait til after the program. Understandable, but having another one right as im going into intensive full time school seems utterly absurd.

The thought of putting off the schooling when it's taken me this long to find it is gut wrenching.

I don't know what to do.

Any advice is appreciated.

What made you decide? Did any of you partially want another and then decide not to? Did your partner want another?


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 1d ago

Fencesitting Third? Or no?

0 Upvotes

Can’t decide if we should try to have a third child or not. Obviously my husband and I will make the decision that seems best for our family, but sometimes those outside of the situation can see things those inside can’t see well.

PROS: I have two absolutely wonderful children that I adore, and I would love to have more!

CONS: I would be at least 40YO, and the sleep depravation is getting harder. My first two deliveries did not go well. The first time I ended up in the ICU, and the second time my child ended up in the NICU. Neither circumstance is guaranteed to happen again, so there is a chance I could have a smooth delivery. The situation in the world seems unstable and being pregnant or having an infant is a more vulnerable position that older children.

Welcome comments from others who debated adding to their family and what they considered/how they decided!


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 1d ago

Fencesitting Try for a third child? Or no?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Shouldihaveanother • • 3d ago

Regret stopping at one

14 Upvotes

I have a 13 year old boy now. And if I am honest ... I have been so so sad, i cry a lot. most days:(
I had my boy at 43. But i was very very ill during pregnancy. sick a lot. migraines. heart palpitations. In and out of hospital having checks for worrisome symptoms. I knew when I was pregnant back then, that I would not do another pregnancy. I felt scared. Plus i have autoimmune disease (underactive thyroid) so i felt even worse with that. I then got pregnant at 45 and aborted the baby because at the time, i didn't feel i could cope with the pregnancy second time around plus 2 year old. i massively regret it now and for the last 10 whole years i have been miserable that i did this. so much regret. i could now be the mother of 2 beautiful children and not one. what shall i do. I also feel so selfish that I took a potential sibling away from my son. My son never has asked for a sibling btw. I am lucky. But I still feel bad that he could have had one. How do I stop beating myself up over this...


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 3d ago

Unexpected News of a Second Baby - How Did Y’all Feel?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/Shouldihaveanother • • 3d ago

I have a happy, financially stable life with one child. Am I selfish for not wanting a second?

21 Upvotes

I’m really struggling with whether to have a second child, and I’d love some perspectives, especially from parents who decided to stop at one or went on to have two.
My husband and I have a 16-month-old son whom we absolutely adore. We’re financially stable, have no mortgage or loans, travel internationally at least twice a year, and generally live a very comfortable life. My husband is incredibly responsible, supportive, and takes great care of both me and our son. I’m genuinely happy and satisfied with our life right now.
I’m also a scientist working on an immunotherapy project that, if successful, could potentially turn into a biotech startup. I’m very passionate about my career and excited about what the future might hold.
Here’s where I’m conflicted.
1. Quality of life vs. having another child
With one child, we can comfortably afford to send him to a prestigious private school from Pre-K through 12th grade, travel frequently, save for the future, and still have money to spend on ourselves.
With two children, we’d probably have to choose more affordable Catholic private schools for both, cut back on traveling, and make other lifestyle sacrifices.
I know plenty of children thrive without expensive private education, but I genuinely believe my son is very bright, and I want to give him every opportunity we can afford. Part of me wonders whether having another child would mean taking opportunities away from him.
2. Do I actually want a second child, or do I just want a daughter?
I love being a mom to my son, and I’ve always imagined having a daughter someday. But obviously, there’s no guarantee our second child would be a girl.
If we had another boy, would I still be equally excited about having a second child? I feel guilty even asking myself that question, but I think it’s something I need to be honest about before making such a big decision.
3. Fear of losing our only child, or leaving him alone someday
This is probably my biggest emotional struggle.
I’m terrified of the thought of losing my only child someday, especially when my husband and I are older. I also worry about what happens to him when we’re both gone. Will he feel lonely without siblings? Will he have anyone who understands his childhood and family the way a sibling might?
But I also realize that having a second child doesn’t guarantee they’ll be close, or that they’ll always be there for each other. And I know fear probably isn’t the best reason to bring another human being into the world.
4. Am I selfish for wanting to preserve the life we have?
I love traveling, having financial freedom, pursuing my career, and being able to give my son so much of our time, attention, and resources.
I know we could financially support two children, but doing so would mean compromising a lifestyle that we’ve worked hard for and genuinely enjoy.
Sometimes I feel selfish for thinking about the vacations, the private school, my career, and the things I want for myself. But another part of me wonders: if we’re already happy, why do we feel the need to change anything?
I guess the question I’m really asking is:
How do you distinguish genuinely wanting another child from wanting to protect your first child from loneliness, grief, or an uncertain future?
For those who were happy with one child but decided to have a second, did you ever regret the sacrifices? And for those who stopped at one, do you ever wonder if you made the wrong choice?
I’d really appreciate some honest perspectives, especially from people who have been in a similar position.


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 3d ago

Has anyone decided on cut off point for ttc 2nd child?

15 Upvotes

I have been going back and forth a bit on whether to ttc. My daughter has just turned 2 and I find day to day easier compared to 6 months ago but toddler stage can be a lot at times. However I do like long term picture of having two children.

I would prefer at least a 3 year age gap. Discussed with husband to ttc when daughter is age 2.5 I will then be approaching age 38. I am considering to only ttc until age 39 and then shut the door if nothing happens. First time it took us 16 months to ttc and I found the journey pretty emotionally draining so don't want a prolonged journey again. Also don't ideally want to be pregnant or still ttc as I approach age 40

Have any ladies aged late 30's felt similar and set a cut off point if decide to ttc?


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 3d ago

To the anxious parents: does it get better with the second (or worse)?

6 Upvotes

I can be a pretty anxious person, often considering all the ways something could go wrong. I try my best to not let it show too much in the way I parent but that in itself is tiring.

I don’t think the stuff I worry about is irrational, rather the usual things: my kid staying healthy, staying safe, having friends etc. at the same time, it doesn’t really feel like I’m getting more relaxed over time. So let’s say when my kid has a fever (which has happened many times in the last three years of daycare) the worrying bit just feels kinda all-consuming, every time.

So my question: does it get easier with the second or at least not worse (because you have experienced it all before)? I’m scared that I would simply be completely exhausted at some point of constantly worrying if it really is “twice as much”.


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 3d ago

Anxious Accidentally pregnant at 9 mo pp and want more kids but not now

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

i'm pregnant 9 months post partum by accident. it took us nearly a year to conceive before and i'm almost 36 so scared this could be my last chance (or i could totally get pregnant again, who knows!?). most importantly though: my son was born with a rare genetic mutation that we don't yet know enough about - docs say he could be fine and it could be benign, but he does have low muscle tone and requires physical therapy, but he seems mostly very typical. we'll know more when he's about 1.5 - 2 years old. there's a 50% chance of the mutation being passed down. we do want more kids but were gonna wait til he was about 1.5 to start trying (he's 9 months now) and we were gonna do IVF to screen for the mutation. i'm scared i'll regret my decision if we struggle to conceive later. but i'm also scared i'll potentially end up with two special needs kids - but also my son could be fine (that's the doc's operating theory and we just have to wait and see how he develops) and then if i struggle to conceive again, i'll have deprived him of a sibling.

i was in an insanely dark place earlier this year when post partum, dealing with the news about his genetics and all the unknowns, which we learned after he was born even though the pregnancy was normal. i was falling apart all over the place and had to go to an intensive 5 week outpatient program. getting back to work and to my routine and my job that i love has been so good for me and i'm finally feeling healthy and enjoying my lovely son and our life with him and his dad. and now this. also i'm terrified of what this would mean for my job - they obviously can't fire me for being pregnant again but i only just got back - and being away from work and my normal routine was just bad for my mental health. i want to be there and to earn the promo i'm up for in summer (which is super important because i'm the main breadwinner).

i need advice, compassion, support, anything. i'll take it. i have the medication to terminate the pregnancy but i just haven't decided yet. thoughts?


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 3d ago

We are financially stable we have everything for a second child

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Shouldihaveanother • • 3d ago

How to deicide whether to have a second kid

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Shouldihaveanother • • 4d ago

Complications

3 Upvotes

I’m 39, with a wonderful eight year old daughter. I had scoliosis surgery in my teens , with two rods and a degenerating L5. I also have a hole in my heart, and while I thought this wasn’t an issue the gynac suggests I need a cardio on board if I decide to go ahead with a second pregnancy. I have been wanting another child ever since I had my first but things with my back got really painful about two years after I had her and my plans got derailed. Now after finding a good PT, I’m finally better though not perfect . I’m worried about pregnancy with this body. Pregnancy with the risk of stroke ( the hole in the heart thing ) , pregnancy and childbirth at age 40 (just a few months away ) and just worried about the baby itself and the risks of having a child so late with a husband who is 45 . We love our lives as parents of one , we have a lot of time , money to spare, travel , etc. Our daughter has lots of cousins , friends and isn’t alone though she does sometimes wish she could have a sibling. It’s just me who keeps coming back to this burning question over and over for like 6 years now. I don’t know why , and I don’t know what I should do. Any advice from anyone who may have been wearing similar shoes ?


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 3d ago

Fencesitting Considering trying for a 3rd. How did you decide?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

Considering a 3rd child at 36. How did you decide?

I'm 36F. husband is 40M, 5yo daughter and 2yo son.

I thought we'd be done at 2, but lately both my husband and I have been feeling that maybe we'd like to try for a 3rd... im torn because:

  1. I'm just getting back into my career and finally feel like I'm finding my footing. I'm enjoying my role and am potentially up for a promotion. Having another baby would likely mean putting my career progression on hold just as things are starting to come together.

  2. we have international travel plans that we'd likely have to cancel or postpone. We're also finally getting to a stage where life feels a little easier, and I'm not sure I'm ready to go through the newborn phase, sleepless nights etc all over again.

  3. i also feel like everything is designed for a family of four. Cars, hotel rooms, vacation packages, family deals, etc. Being a family of five seems like it would make everyday life and travelling more complicated and expensive.

  4. At 36, I worry about age-related pregnancy risks and the possibility of long-term health issues for the baby. I also feel the pressure of having to make a decision sooner rather than later.

  5. I'm scared I won't have enough time and energy for my two kids, or that another child would affect my marriage and the time we have for each other.

...but despite all these concerns, I have this nagging feeling that I might regret not trying for a third. Almost like I'd be making a mistake by stopping at two, even though I can't fully explain why I feel this way.

For those who considered having a 3rd child, what helped you make your decision?

If you stopped at 2, did you struggle with the possibility of regretting not having another?

If you had a 3rd, was it harder than you anticipated? What sacrifices did you have to make? Are you happy with your decision?

I'd specially love to hear from women who had their third in their late 30s.

I know there's no perfect time or perfect answer, but I'd really appreciate hearing about your experiences. I'm feeling very torn...

Thanks in advance.


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 4d ago

Moms with one child- Did you see this phase?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Shouldihaveanother • • 4d ago

Family Close Adult Sibling Relationships

7 Upvotes

If you have a close relationship with your adult siblings (even better if you were also close as children), what are some (healthy- not trauma bonding) things that helped foster that relationship for you?

Please share how many siblings you have, which ones your close with and what your age gap is? We’re fencesittng and this is a big component to the discussion for us


r/Shouldihaveanother • • 4d ago

Age gaps Grieving the sibling age gap I dreamed of after two miscarriages.

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes