r/Shouldihaveanother • • Jun 11 '21

Reflections I had that other child. This is what you should know before making that decision:

301 Upvotes

For a long time we thought we were one and done. Then our little one started asking for a sibling. A lot. So we decided we’d leave it to chance. I doubted I could actually have a second because of multiple miscarriages and because of how hard getting pregnant the first time around was. But it did happen, and this is what you should know if you decide to go down that route.

If you thought the first was hard, raise that by a factor of ten. Having one child means the ratio of parent to offspring is in your favour. Any more and kiss any time to yourselves goodbye. I cannot stress enough how much harder it is, how much more there is to do, how it’s entirely possible to clean and cook and care for children non-stop and still get nothing done. We are both working but I’m not convinced it’d be any easier if one of us wasn’t. It can be hard enough asking a friend or relative for a favour to look after one child if you want a break once a blue moon. But with two it’s a considerably greater ask. My husband and I have only been out once by ourselves over the past year for a grand total of 90 minutes. And it was the most enjoyable 90 minutes of the past year.

When I went back to work after our first I was able to actually get a better job and do some of the best work of my career. With the two of them I feel like I’m failing every single day. I get zero sleep, zero rest, and have zero space in my mind for work.

You are going to have half the resources available for your children. I have a good salary but if I’m to pay for childcare for the two of them over the summer I will have zero money left.

No matter how much your eldest likes their sibling, they will still feel jealous and they’ll still be horrible to them on occasion.

Having said all the above, I’m right in the middle of the worst of it, the baby is a terrible sleeper and we did have it in the middle of a pandemic.

Also worth saying that the siblings do really love each other. Of course, there is no guarantee that this won’t change in the future.

Had I been able to glimpse at our lives with two, I don’t think I’d have ever made the choice to have a second.

And yet we do love the baby to bits.

All I’m saying is, if you’re having second thoughts, if you’re feeling you’ve just got parts of your lives back since having your first, perhaps you should keep things as they are... I currently feel there is none of the things I used to associate with the core of who I am left in my life. It’s not a decision you should leave to chance or take lightly.


r/Shouldihaveanother • • Jun 23 '22

Happy I had a second, and am so happy about it!

200 Upvotes

I wasn't sure about having a second originally, so I used to stalk this subreddit. I wanted to give an update, since I always wanted to see them.

TLDR: I was one and done, very concerned about having another. Now I do, and am very happy.

I'll try to keep this concise, but it will be long. Having my first child tested me. I had multiple near-breakdowns, and really struggled with the challenges. As far as babies/toddlers go, I know I didn't have the most challenging child, but I felt very challenged because of my stress tolerance, anxiety, and trouble handling big emotions. In particular, at the toddler age (2 especially), he seemed to be much more challenging than others his age because none of the parenting books and many parents online didn't seem to experience the long, intense, unstoppable tantrums I did.

For a while, my spouse and I were very one and done. It wasn't just the challenges our kid gave us. It seemed like there were a million reasons. Saving money. Ease of doing all the things we enjoyed: getting out of the house, eating out, traveling, etc. Not having to go through pregnancy and the looong recovery again. Not having to go through the newborn stage again. Not having to go back to monitoring their every movement now that we have some independence. And so on.

And yet, we did think about having another from time to time. But we would always come to the same conclusion: no way, never again. One day, I talked to my grandma, and got a different perspective. She's in her 90s, and talking to family on the phone was her whole life, now that she can't get around well anymore. I realized I was looking at the short-term perspective rather than long-term. In the long-term, I would like a bigger family. But the short-term is still daunting.

Ultimately, that realization motivated us to try again and get pregnant. But even making the choice didn't make us confident about it. We both felt waves of intense anxiety about it, and thinking, "what did we do?" My spouse was particularly concerned about losing the ability to be able to do the things he enjoyed: his sports teams and getting out with friends.

I won't lie, pregnancy sucked. I had a difficult pregnancy, and even if you don't, it's so much harder being pregnant with a toddler vs being pregnant with no kids and being able to relax whenever you want. But pregnancy is only temporary (despite seeming endless), and eventually we had our baby.

Our baby is 3 months now, and our older child is nearly 4. It took some adjusting (funny how you forget a lot of the baby stuff even just a few years later), but we're in a pretty good rhythm now.

One thing I was concerned about was the temperament of our new baby. It's such a gamble, and you have zero control over it. They could be an easy kid, they could be super colicy, or anywhere in between, and you won't know until they're here. I was hoping we'd have an easier child, because our first was challenging, and I'd heard that kids tend to be opposite (not always, but anecdotally, I'd heard several stories of easy first kid, challenging 2nd, or vice versa).

We lucked out! Obviously we won't completely know until our baby's older, but so far, her temperament's been great. She is more of a fusser than a crier, and I'll take fussing any day over crying (crying really triggers me). She is very smiley and sweet. She's not a super easy baby (for a while she had long witching hours every evening), but she's easier than our first, so I really appreciate that.

My husband and I both noticed how much easier things feel the second time around, and more confident we feel as parents. There was such a sharp learning curve the first time around, and so much researching needed, and figuring out the best ways to do things. This time, we already know that stuff, so the mindset was more "no big deal" than "omg, what do we do?" Also, the stereotypes are so true of wanting to do everything perfectly the first time, and the second time around having more of a "they'll be fine" mindset.

I did start an antidepressant during pregnancy thus time (never used one before) for my anxiety and have stayed on it postpartum, so that may be helping me be more relaxed in my parenting. But my husband, who's also pretty anxious, isn't on anything and he's more relaxed too. I remember with my first, I was so focused on wake windows, and having naps be perfect, etc, and now I wonder why I put myself through that. But at the time, I guess I felt like this was the only way that would help.

Some things that have made this experience easier than it could be: being more financially secure, having 2 sets of parents neatby willing to help, having parents watch our oldest for a week when the baby was born so we could adjust, starting formula feeding sooner so we could share feeding responsibilities & get out easier, and, most significantly, having longer parental leave times than the first time around (12 weeks vs 2 for my husband and 5 months vs 2.5 for me). It's been so much better having the longer time to adjust, and being able to do it together this time around.

Another major thing that has made this easier is the age gap between our kids. They are about 3.5 years apart, and it's perfect. Everything I heard about smaller age gaps sounded miserable. And if we went through this when our first was 2 and having those horrible meltdowns all the time...I shudder at the thought. My oldest is at an age where he's fairly independent, loves helping, and is old enough to not see his sister as competition or be jealous of her. He loves her! He's old enough to know to be gentle with her.

We can still give him tons of attention because she's a baby and can just be "along for the ride." Our oldest is mostly potty trained and sleeps through the night, so we're only balancing one baby at a time, not 2. And we're lucky enough to be able to afford him staying in daycare while we're on parentsl leave, so we can have one:one time with our baby. Don't get me wrong, we still are dealing with his threenager stage and he's testing us constantly, but I'd rather deal with that than his out of control violent meltdowns, plus when he's not testing us, he's super sweet and generally happier than when he was 2.

A few things that have made this harder: the main one is having pets, and also getting sick all the time with a kid in daycare. As for the pets, we have 3, and if I could go back in time (we got all of them pre-kids), I would have stopped myself from having so many. They are all now 10 years+, and all struggling with senior animal issues (mostly incontinence, among other ailments). Taking care of 3 senior pets, with all their issues and meds, in addition to 2 kids is just too much. I love them, but it's hard, and I worry about how hard it will be when the baby can crawl.

Nothing is perfect, but all in all, we're happy we had a second (but 100% sure no more kids). I hope this eases some people's concerns.


r/Shouldihaveanother • • Sep 07 '21

"Having another child is like having more money"... Bare with me here... My analogy for why I've decided not to have another. Maybe it will help someone out there?!

162 Upvotes

Having another child is like having more money. I love money. I'd love more money. There's nothing bad about more money. It's desirable. It's fun. It's great. It's amazing! It makes you feel good.

But... There IS a reason I don't have more money.

I don't want to work any more than I already do. I could work more and get more money. I could take weekend shifts and get more money. I could work 7 days a week, 24 hours a day and have looooooads of money. But I'll be tired. Exhausted. Grumpy. Stretched. I'd have no time for myself. I'd have no time for my husband. And... I may not even get the chance enjoy the money I already had plus the extra money, because I'd have less time.

So. While I'd always love more money, I'm happy with the money I've got and the balance I have in my life to enjoy all the things that aren't just about... Making more money.


r/Shouldihaveanother • • Mar 29 '26

I was on the fence for a second, and here is my experience from the other side with baby 2.

145 Upvotes

We were one and done forever, until my son turned 4 and started school. He was a hardddd newborn and baby, he was an okay toddler and then when he hit 4 I started to wonder/panic if we should have a second. It was eating me alive. 1 year + 2 miscarriages later I found myself finally pregnant with #2. I’m sad to admit that there were times I regretted it at first. After a few scares it took a few months to actually connect with the pregnancy. Toward the end I had so much fear that I was making a mistake. The emotions were so crazy and I didn’t stop worrying.

I’m here writing to you that my newborn is currently one week old, and this had absolutely been the best experience of my entire life. The labour was a million times better, he is absolutely the sweetest soul, and a much easier newborn than my first.(which i admit makes me so sad because I don’t think my first got the best version of me at that time)

I’m rested, I’ve decided to formula feed for my mental health, and I still feel guilt, it has changed my life.

Seeing the 2 interact together has been so healing, and it’s something I never knew I needed.

If you’re on the fence, or you’re pregnant and scared, I hope this maybe can bring you some comfort. I am so thankful to myself for having baby 2, my entire life feels so beyond complete and I could not be happier.


r/Shouldihaveanother • • Nov 17 '22

Reflections It’s more important for your child to have stable, nurturing parents than a sibling

144 Upvotes

Bit of a hot take here, but I think it makes sense. If bringing another kid into the family comes at the price of the mental or physical health of the parents, then this will likely have a greater impact on your child than the positives of having a sibling.

I’m certainly not saying there is a right size for any family but I think this is something to mull over when considering having another.


r/Shouldihaveanother • • Oct 12 '25

Reflections I’m outta here…

136 Upvotes

While I wasn’t very active in this space, the posts were so helpful and insightful and comforting.

A couple weeks ago I scheduled an appointment with my reproductive endocrinologist to discuss the second and last embryo transfer. This is a doctor that I absolutely love because she was so great at a balance between positivity and hope but reality.

The appointment was not what I was expecting. Her tone was quite different and more on the reality side. She carefully explained how difficult my first pregnancy was and how much high risk across the board this second time would be. While not directly telling me it was a bad idea, she made it pretty clear that it was not safe. And this time around there was so much more to consider. Plus the second embryo had half the chance of pregnancy, less for live birth.

By the time our appointment was over, it was clear I couldn’t/shouldn’t put my life on the line for this attempt. As formative as my childhood with siblings was, that’s simply not something I could give my kid. And that’s ok. I’m feeling very much at peace and so grateful for science, compassionate medical care and my life in general. Now I can focus on my cute little family and making the best life for my kid.

So thanks folks for sharing your thoughts, feelings and consideration. It was so nice to know I was not alone in this struggle.


r/Shouldihaveanother • • Jun 05 '24

We had another

128 Upvotes

And could not be more full of joy.

I came to this sub as a long time member just to share our decision and how it’s going. We had our first daughter in April of 2020 and it was so insanely challenging. Pandemic, career changes, becoming first time parents, etc. We really struggled and had a hard time. We, for over two years, were 100% certain we would be one and done. We absolutely could not imagine going through life with another child and doing those early years again. But when our daughter turned three, we had realized how much we had grown as individuals, how our marriage had grown, the confidence we had gained in parenting, and we truly felt that our family would feel complete with another. Our second daughter was just born last week and it has been amazing. It’s crazy how different this time around is in these newborn days compared to our first and we do not regret it for a second! This of course is my own anecdote, but wanted to post as someone that was absolutely never going to have another, to a fence-sitter, to a second time mom, and it’s better than I could have ever imagined.


r/Shouldihaveanother • • Mar 04 '23

Did having a second child increase your happiness?

114 Upvotes

A question to those with more than one child...

Did having a second child increase your happiness?

Edit... not sure why this is being down voted. I've been told offline that if I am happy having a child, than my happiness will double with a second. I'm looking for confirmation or differing opinions.


r/Shouldihaveanother • • Sep 18 '25

Two and through We decided not to have a third, and I want to validate anyone else who’s leaning that way, too.

111 Upvotes

Hi all. I’ve been sitting with this decision for a long time, over a year, actually, and after so many hours of talking, circling, doubting, re-evaluating, my husband and I have finally decided: we’re not having a third child.

We’re done.

We have two beautiful, healthy daughters. We’re deeply grateful. We are in such a great balance. And we’ve spent the last year living in that debilitating space of “should we or shouldn’t we?” We talked about the age gaps, our energy levels, finances, our careers, what pregnancy and postpartum would mean again, the impact on our marriage, and most of all, the kids we already have. We talked about it nearly everyday and it consumed us. We decided yes, then no, then yes, then no x 100. We were waiting for a gut pull, something undeniable to nudge us in either direction. And what we realized was: the pull was toward peace. Toward the life we already have. Toward being present.

We tried the exercise where you "make" the decision for 2 weeks and see how you feel. Then you make the other decision and see how you feel. Conclusion? For us, decided "we're having a third" felt exciting but very anxiety inducing. "We stop at 2 kids"? Sad, but huge relief.

It’s not that we couldn’t have another. It’s that we’re choosing not to. And that decision feels radical, sometimes sad but deeply right. It’s about honoring our capacity, emotionally, physically, mentally. It’s about being the best parents we can be to the two kids already here, instead of stretching ourselves thinner.

And to be honest, it was hard to come to this without guilt or second-guessing. Because so many stories here on Reddit end with “we took the leap and it was the best thing we ever did.” That’s beautiful, and I honor that for people who go that route. But I wanted to offer a counter-story, just in case someone out there is searching for permission to not expand.

To say “this is enough.” To feel validated in choosing depth over more.

I want to hear from others who’ve made this choice to stay two and through, or are considering it. What helped you feel peace with the decision? And if you’re still unsure, I’m happy to be a voice on the “no more” side of the spectrum, without judgment.

I do feel like I have to mourn the baby stage, the newborn smell, the cuddles, the firsts. But I do still have a 2.5 year old, who is still my baby, they both always will be.

But now is the time to finally put myself first. Not "hide" my needs behind another human being's. And that's scary. (Working on that in therapy!).

I'm sending love to anyone walking through this tender decision. It’s not easy, but it’s yours to make.

-

(formatted with GPT but all thoughts are mine).


r/Shouldihaveanother • • Jan 02 '22

Update on “I had that other child, this is what you should know”

102 Upvotes

A couple of people asked me to do an update post I had that other child

It’s now been 8 months since I made that post and things have changed a lot. The most important change is sleep! With our first, we were both firmly against sleep training so we were very sleep deprived until she was a year and a half. But with the second waking up every twenty minutes (whether on our bed or his) and having a second child to care for, we soon decided sleep training was a much better option than collectively losing our minds. It only took a couple of months for it to work. The toddler now sleeps a solid twelve hours overnight. In fact, he’s a much better sleeper than his older sister which says a lot about the sleep training approach.

What is also amazing is that the toddler and five year old really get along. They play together all the time and he chases her around for cuddles all day. They’re adorable together.

It’s impossible to think of our lives without him now. Having said that, our finances continue to be much worse and the logistics of negotiating school and childminder pick ups and drop offs, after school activities and caring for the two of them whilst having two full-time jobs (even though they’re home based) are incredibly complicated and stressful.

So all in all, I’d say it can get much better but it really does depend. I have colleagues and friends whose two children never got along or who never recovered their sleep. In the end, I’ve not changed my mind in saying that it’s not the sort of decision to be taken lightly or left to chance - like we did. But I’m very glad we have the little guy.


r/Shouldihaveanother • • Feb 13 '26

Update: went for baby #2 with no regrets

97 Upvotes

My husband and I had “decided” we were one and done even while I was pregnant with our first kid. Newborn period and postpartum was really hard on me the last time and I didn’t think I had it in me to do it again. Fast forward to when our daughter turned 3, I felt something shifting like our family was incomplete and we should try for baby #2. My husband came around after a few days of discussing. Got pregnant pretty quickly after trying

We have a 4.5 year old and 4 month old now (they are just over 4 years apart) and we are so happy with our decision! Life has definitely gotten a lot more difficult logistically, but we all love our new little addition. Postpartum was night and day difference this time and I’ve had very little PPA like I did first time around. My husband and I have very little free time right now but I know that will change once baby is older. We’ve been savoring up this baby stage so much as I know it goes by so fast. Big sister is also so obsessed with baby brother and we know this was the right choice for our family :)


r/Shouldihaveanother • • Jun 03 '23

6 weeks into 2nd kid

90 Upvotes

We spent a lot of time debating on having a second kid, so I just wanted to give an update. Although we're only 6 weeks in, I can easily say that it was a very good decision for us.

We have a 2 year and 9 month age gap. Our son has been very sweet and excited about his baby sister. Of course, we didn't have another kid for him, but it's pretty amazing when he calls her his best friend.

A lot of my hesitation came from how hard the newborn experience was the first time around. My son didn't sleep, always cried, and was just a really challenging infant. I stressed a lot over every little thing. He has made up for this by being a pretty phenomenal toddler.

This time everything has been astronomically easier. I think my daughter is an easier baby, however so much of it is knowing what we are doing. We're so much more relaxed as parents and can enjoy everything way more. Even when she's being difficult, I know everything is temporary. I don't panic every time she cries and question if I am a terrible mother. Also I'm on zoloft this time around which is a big help.

I'm a SAHM, and I was really nervous to have both kids by myself. I'm still not overly confident taking both out in public alone, but I'm not afraid to be left alone with both the way I was when we first took her home. I am very lucky to have a lot of help. My parents live 5 mins from us, and my husband works from home.

I hope this is at least a little bit helpful to someone else trying to make the decision. We are so incredibly happy with our family of four, and can confidently say that we are done having kids.


r/Shouldihaveanother • • Feb 13 '26

7-year age gap - our lived experience

88 Upvotes

Dear community,

I have been reading along here for about two years, thinking about whether we want to have another child. Until my daughter was five, we were OAD, but suddenly that changed. The desire was no longer there. So I read a lot here on Reddit about the general decision to have another child and about siblings with a larger age gap. I found the exchange helpful, especially when people reported on decisions they had made. That's why I would like to share our experience.

After two years of consideration, we decided to try for another child. We set ourselves a limit of one year. It took six months, then I was pregnant. Until then, I had been ambivalent about each new cycle. I was disappointed and relieved at the same time when the test was negative. But I didn't want to stop trying. The morning I tested positive, a deep calm came over me. “Okay, so this is how our life will be now” was my first thought. That inner calm and peace remained. Today, our son is three months old and our daughter is seven years old. They are the lights of our lives, and every day I am happy and grateful that we decided to have another baby. Of course, it's more exhausting than before. But this time, we know how short this period is when they are so small and needy. Our nights will eventually become more restful again, and we will have more time for ourselves. We are enjoying this time so much.

P.S. Since many people from the US are reading this: we are German and live in Germany. We have a good social security system and decent living conditions for families. Plus, we don't have a crazy president. As Americans, we might have decided differently!


r/Shouldihaveanother • • Sep 21 '26

“Omg you would be starting overrrr.”

86 Upvotes

So, I’ve been on the fence for the last couple of years now, but I think I’m finally settled with wanting to have another. My son is almost 5 now and life has gotten SO MUCH EASIER. He’s in school, he’s pretty independent and the physical demands are so minor now.

That breathing room has given me space to seriously consider one more. What I’ve been so annoyed by as of late is people saying “omg you’d be starting all over again.” Which I guess in part is true, but what I think people don’t understand is some of us aren’t cut out to be dealing with a second while still in the trenches. I knew 2 under 2 was not my calling immediately. I was never going to be that mom.

What I am comforted by is the fact that my kid is emotionally regulated, pretty independent, sleeps through the night and doesn’t require all of my energy, attention, and effort 100% of the time. Those are the only conditions where having a second seems logistically possible FOR ME. Even traveling—which we do lots of, makes more sense because it’s not double the diapers, or pack n plays, etc.

We’ll be trying in the next few months, but I’m just so glad that the first time around I listened to what I wanted and the (possible) second time around, I’ll be doing the same.

If you’re asking yourself “should I have another,” the answer is “when and if you’re ready.l” don’t pay attention to others’ made up timelines. Do what’s best for your mental, physical, and emotional health; what works for your family, marriage and logistical life.


r/Shouldihaveanother • • Nov 05 '20

I've graduated from "should I have another" because life found a way... but I may have found a way to help you answer the SIHA question.

86 Upvotes

Tl;dr: Close your eyes. Breath deep. Imagine thinking you're pregnant. Visualize two different testing sessions. One positive, one negative. Imagine your reaction. How do you feel? May help you understand if you should have another.

I knew when I charted my days in September that something was off. I didn't feel myself. I'm very in tune with my body, and I usually "feel" ovulation when it happens because I have ovarian cysts that can make it somewhat painful. I chalked up that "off" feeling to dealing with the stress of my daughter's one-year-post-surgery cancer scans to see if she was still clear. We had spent a few days locked up in a hotel room under isolation, attending appointments alone because of COVID--so no help from Daddy when LO woke up screaming, crying, and drugged from her procedures.

We got home, finally got our housesitter cleared out, got LO down for a nap, and finally had some "us" time.

A couple of weeks pass, and I start to feel... off... again. I couldn't quite place it. So I bought a pregnancy test. Negative. I was 9 days out from my period. Three days later, took another. Negative. At this point though, I felt like I was only taking tests continuously until I got a positive, not to confirm that it was negative.

The next day... positive.

And we. ARE. STOKED. I feel like if we kept having the "when?" or "should we?" conversation, we never would have had another child. I'm glad this was our unplanned baby. Unplanned doesn't mean unloved or unwanted.

So, try this. Close your eyes. Visualize that god-awful 5-minute wait for the pregnancy test. Are you scared? Excited? Now visualize it positive. How do you feel? Now visualize it negative. Same question... how do you feel? Maybe, just maybe, you might get a hint of whether or not you should have another. This could help you realize whether or not you should... or whether or not you're ready.


r/Shouldihaveanother • • Aug 11 '20

Does it count as OAD "by choice" if you'd like to be able to handle two, but know you probably can't?

86 Upvotes

I've said this umpteen times and seen it said as many: If I could skip the first few years, I'd happily have more kids.

My kid isn't 3 yet so maybe I'm wrong. Maybe I'll find the older years just as hard. (You know, there are loads of jobs where you can shadow before you decide to commit yourself, and I wish there were a parenting equivalent. Can I live in a household with two young kids for a week and just watch...?)

In any case, if I'm perfectly honest with myself I know I'm putting myself and my relationship with my husband at big risk of crumbling if we have a second. The responsible thing to do is to just not have another one. But if I could wave a magic wand and make us the kind of people who can shake off the difficulties more easily and be happy being "busy" all the time and generally get us through the early years with a second, I'd absolutely do it.

That's the problem, really. It doesn't feel like a choice.


r/Shouldihaveanother • • Aug 07 '26

I had a second child and I’m 4 months in- here’s my experience (I love it)

85 Upvotes

Quick back story; So I stalked this group when trying to decide if I should have a second child. My first was just about 4 at this time. The first 3.5 years of his life were HARD. He was a hard baby, he was a good toddler with health problems, and the health issues continued until we mostly sorted it out around 4. At this point, I started questioning the “One and done” so much. At this age he really looked like a big kid to me, he seemed a little bored and I just knew in my heart he would love to be a brother. I would never a make decision on that alone, but he is so sweet we just had a feeling this would be the right call.

—After a year of TTC, multiple miscarriages etc we
finally had our second son (this is another story but I love having 2 boys after slight gender disappointment) in March of this year. Pretty much an exact 5 year age gap between the two, and it’s honestly been a dream.

*-*the baby has really fit into our family perfectly. We were scared of our lives changing, and it really hasn’t! He’s easy going, and most of all he LOVES his big brother, so much that I can’t believe I almost didn’t get to experience this relationship. And…. My oldest adores him. I was worried about how my
Oldests life would change, how he would react not getting 1000% attention etc and guess what- he’s literally fine. He’s a sensitive guy and this has been so good for him. He’s learnt some patience, but overall no huge changes for him!

-every worry we had pretty much has meant nothing at this point. Nothings really changed except we’re just navigating naps again and trying to keep a routine, which is harder in the summer than during the school year but I wouldn’t trade it for the world. I love being a mom of 2 boys and I just feel finally our family is so complete, and I never have to wonder what would be.

I do not envy anyone in the deciding limbo, it was so stressful and I cried a lot trying to figure out what we wanted. I will even admit when I was pregnant I was afraid. I wish I could hug that version of myself and show her a glimpse of how sweet life is with baby 2. I wish someone told me the good things when I was making the decision.


r/Shouldihaveanother • • Sep 07 '24

I think it’s time to say goodbye to this sub.

85 Upvotes

It’s been great, but i think it’s time for me to go! Just got a positive pregnancy test yesterday. My partner and I have been talking about adding a second to the family for a while, just happened sooner than we expected! Wish you all the best with whichever choice you decide is good for you and your family :)


r/Shouldihaveanother • • Feb 10 '21

Fencesitting COVID made me change my mind

85 Upvotes

I have always been convinced of being one and done. Kids need a lot of energy and commitment, and I wanted to leave some "me" time. But I guess COVID changed my mind.

Over Christmas 2020 we were not able to gather with the extended family as we usually do, so each family stayed at her "own" place, amongst "themselves". It made me understand that at the end of the day, when problems arise, close family is what matters.

Extended family is nice but cousins will never be able to replace siblings. Friends can be there but often they have their own things going on.

Being an only myself, I do not want my kid to be alone in the future. As a kid I always felt a special bond with my cousins but I guess it was one way as they were siblings. I was always the one reaching out, I was the outsider.

So after all I think I would like to have my own large family, the one I never had, to give my kid the opportunity to have a sibling and even if I am really scared of what it entails logistically and financially I hope that I will be able to make it work .

I think I would regret more not having another than having one.


r/Shouldihaveanother • • Jul 12 '25

Advice I can’t be the only mother in the US scared to have another baby, right?

83 Upvotes

Trump and his entire cabinet is making me anxious to have another. All of this is happening right when my family (wlw and 3yo) are thinking of having a second baby. I am fearful that this administration will target a family like mine and other families for their differences.

If I could wave a magic wand and see into the future for America, that would help me decide so much.

I don’t want to get into political discussions, so if America is heading in the right direction for you and your family, just don’t reply.

What do we do with this uncertainty?


r/Shouldihaveanother • • May 26 '26

Happy I was on the fence about a second, here’s how it’s going now that he’s here

81 Upvotes

I read a ton of posts on here when I was fencesitting myself, so I figured I’d share the experience of going from solidly one and done, to debating a second, to having a second.

My oldest is 4.5 years old. He was colicky from the start, and even as a toddler was very clingy and fussy. I also had really bad PPA that was probably made worse by me constantly googling to try and figure out why my baby was so damn angry all the time. Up till 3 years old I was 100% one and done. I even got rid of all our baby stuff(whoops). But at 3 and a half, my husband asked if I would think about having a second. My first thought was no way. Thinking about the newborn days filled me with fear. But I wanted to be fair to my husband and give his idea a chance. So I just started imagining what it would be like to have a second, the good and the bad. And it made me realize that we were very different people than we had been when we first began our parenting journey. We had learned to communicate our needs better and work together to tackle the hard days. I had also learned to recognize the anxious thought patterns I’d had with my first, and was much better at handling my anxiety. So even if my second was just as difficult I thought we would handle it a lot better. Once I let go of all the fear I realized I did want another baby. I didn’t want to be totally done with the baby/toddler stage just yet.

So now I have a 4.5 year old and a 9 month old. And I won’t lie it has had its difficulties. My baby didn’t sleep more than two hours at a time once for the first 7 weeks. But I’m actually enjoying my time with him so much, rather than constantly being worried. The sweet baby cuddles hit differently when you have a four year old and you‘ve seen how fast they grow and change. It also helps that parenting is kind of second nature at this point. I’m not googling why he’s having blowouts or how to give him a bath because I remember from the first time. And I know this isn’t guaranteed for all the fence sitters out there but my second is such an easy baby, other than not sleeping for long stretches. He’s one of those who can actually be put down drowsy but awake and just go to sleep. And he’s almost never fussy.

I also was worried that I wouldn’t be able to give my oldest enough attention after having a baby. And while it has been a balancing act, I think that it‘s going really well. We have a routine of quick things I‘ll do with him to connect, like playing Legos, reading a book, or watching a movie together. I also think it’s helped him to mature in some ways. Before this kid was like a ping pong ball, constantly bumping into us, knocking things over etc. He‘s diagnosed adhd so that’s not a surprise. What has been surprising has been how much self control he’s developed around the baby. He moves at top speed 24/7, but hasn’t had an issue walking carefully around the baby or moving to a different area of the room to get his gymnastics moves out.

I spent many years working retail so I’d describe the difficulty levels like this- two parents one kids is like your average day working retail. Some difficulty, some slow moments of downtime. Two parents two kids, is like working a weekend. Busy, but doable if you work together. One parent two kids is like working black friday. Sometimes a little chaotic, sometimes a lot, and you have to plan really well if everyone’s going to get their lunch break. The chaos can be kind of fun though.


r/Shouldihaveanother • • Feb 07 '24

I took the plunge and am pregnant with my second child

80 Upvotes

After three years of being very sure I’ll be OAD by choice, I am now 7 months pregnant with my second. I have a few reasons for this.

  1. the culture I live in doesn’t understand the concept of OAD, and I realised it would be very hard on my son growing up as an only when everyone around him will have at least one other sibling around.

  2. my husband really wanted another, and at some point I felt I was emotionally capable to stop denying him that.

  3. this is maybe my biggest reason- I started to see the loneliness in my son that he would not have anyone to share his childhood with. As an only myself, I have no idea what it means to share parents etc, so I don’t know if it’ll really improve his life or not, but I know that when we go to play areas and I see kids playing with their siblings, I felt like something might be missing in his life if he doesn’t have a sibling, and I hope he’ll be happier for it.

  4. I felt ready to take the plunge again.

I’m not posting this because I want to convince anyone of anything, this was entirely my personal choice for my family. I have been following this sub since my son was born and you have all helped me so much in getting my mental health to a better place during my son’s early years. So I wanted to say thank you for everything, and although I might not fit here anymore, I would still love to follow the community as it has had such an impact in my life.


r/Shouldihaveanother • • Jan 30 '24

Fencesitting In our best moments, it feels like someone’s missing. In our worst, everything feels so overwhelming.

80 Upvotes

As the title said. We are deciding on having a second.

When things are good, they’re great, and I can’t help but picture our family with another and it feels so right! But husband isn’t convinced because when we have bad days, everything is overwhelming and neither of us have energy.

our daughter is 2.5 years old. She’s perfect.

But it just feels like there’s someone else that should be in our family. I can’t shake the feeling.

I just don’t know what to do!!!


r/Shouldihaveanother • • Jan 26 '26

What happened to a 3-3.5 year age gap?

76 Upvotes

This is really just a rant/looking for thoughts and solidarity.

My child is almost two, and everyone I know (and see online) is pregnant, trying, or got pregnant at this stage and has 2u2, 2, 2.5 yr gap. I don't know why but I feel like something is wrong with me for not feeling ready. I feel like maybe I'm just weaker than others? 0-1 rocked my world. My husband and I both wfh and watch our toddler, so I do have help (and he is extremely involved) but it's a lot. I just feel like 3+ year gaps used to be more common and now I rarely run into anyone with that gap. I had PPD bad and a pretty standard pregnancy, but I'm still scarred from how awful those first few months were.

I'm in therapy and honestly so happy now. Truly fulfilled. So it feels counterintuitive to rock the boat, especially while still nursing my 2 yo. How did you know you wanted another? Why are we seeing a rise in these small age gaps (2U2, 2 yr etc)?


r/Shouldihaveanother • • Mar 05 '25

Fencesitting I want another two year old, not another baby

71 Upvotes

I actually don’t even have one two year old. My first baby is almost 1 now and while still challenging at times, it’s def getting easier and more fun over time, and I think I’m absolutely gonna love the 2ish stage. I’ve always wanted two kids, but now that I have one, I’m not sure anymore. My baby isn’t even a hard baby, I would say she’s fairly easy, she does sleep through the night most nights and is happy and healthy.

Still, the first year of her life has been exhausting. I didn’t mind being pregnant, birth was fine too, didn’t have ppd, but the sleep deprivation the first few months was rough, and also the extreme fussiness that started around 3-4 months. Also, my baby still hates the car seat and the stroller, which has made leaving the house challenging at times.

Honestly, the thought of having another baby scares me and I’m not sure if I’ll be able to cope. I’m scared of losing myself. Of my life just revolving around parenting (I do work and have a career though).

I would still love a second child, and I think I might regret it if I don’t, but I wish I could just have a two year old, not a baby. Anyone feel the same? What’s the best thing to do in this situation? Thanks.