Years ago, I did something I view as an act of sexual coercion. We were both 21. I am a male, she is a woman.
We were talking about things we might want to try sexually one day. I asked her if we might want to try fingering/oral one day. She said “yeah” and I asked if she was wanting to try it soon. She said “No, maybe later.“
I do not know to this day why it felt like there was still a chance of something happening. It felt like there was a moment of “opportunity.”
So I had a plan that if I did some things, she might be more likely to say yes.
I asked her “Can we take off our clothes for comfort?”
She said yes.
I asked her “Hey, is it okay if I look down there?”
She said yes.
I asked her, as if I just fell into the opportunity, “Is it okay if I try that fingering thing?”
She said yes.
I asked “Are you sure you want me to do this for you and not just because you think I want it?”
That is something I asked verbatim.
She said yes.
Halfway through, she asked me to stop, and so I did.
Down the line I asked her why and she said “Didn’t feel like the right time of day to do it.”
I asked her if she felt coerced a few weeks later. She said no. I asked her if she felt pressured. She said no.
Here’s some disclosure: I have OCD. So I will naturally be more obsessive over these things.
Throughout the years, I have read so many sources that rightfully point out that “maybe later” is to always be taken as a firm “no.” I have read so many sources that rightfully point out that asking after a firm no is always an attempt at coercion.
She always maintains it was fully consensual. Multiple therapists have stated that it doesn’t sound like coercion.
But there’s no way for that to be morally consistent, is there? I did something that was coercion where I just happened to get lucky that it wasn’t actually coercion, right?
A few weeks after the incident, I posted about it on Reddit, to a feminist sex subreddit. I was naturally torn apart for my misdeed. The opinions all stated that it was similar to coercion, some even stating that it was coercion, but my girlfriend just didn’t understand it.
My girlfriend was distraught that I was trusting Reddit over her view, but there’s no way this wasn’t, at least in practice, coercion, right?
My therapists have stated that it was probably online people with an axe to grind, but that seems like a more stereotypical understanding of the internet.
I did something to make a “no” a “yes.” I knew I was doing that. That is coercion, even if I got lucky nobody got hurt.
I’m 28 years old now, and this has haunted me since that initial Reddit thread. Me and her are still friends, but with the obvious boundary that I don’t bring this up again.
I am a bad person who got a second chance, but do I really deserve it? Or should I be treating myself like any other rapist?