r/SSSC • • Mar 11 '16

17-1 Ruling on 17-1 TheSolomonCaine v. SolidOrangeGangsta II

9 Upvotes

This Court has reached a unanimous ruling in the case of TheSolomonCaine v. SolidOrangeGangsta II. The opinion can be found here.

In summary, the executive order was found to be constitutional as the order in question does not bear similarities to oppressive titles of nobility which were utilized to create extreme social stratification in Europe. Additionally, the state has a vested interest in honoring and awarding those who have contributed to the Southern State. Please read the full opinion for further details on how we came to this conclusion.


r/SSSC • • Oct 27 '16

Petition Accepted /u/PM_ME_YOUR_PANZER vs the State of Dixe

8 Upvotes

To the Honorable and Esteemed Justices of this Court, now comes the petitioner, /u/PM_me_your_Panzer, representing himself, who respectfully submits this petition to review the constitutionality of Southern State B.091, otherwise known as The Death Penalty Reaffirmation Act of 2016, signed into law today by acting Governor /u/CaptainClutchMuch. The petitioner respectfully asks the Honorable Court to find the law unconstitutional and strike it entirely. The law in question reads in pertinent part as follows:

Article 2 All currently scheduled Death Penalties will be carried out as planned in Dixie and prosecutors may seek the Death Penalty in all such cases that are appropriate according to Dixie statutes. The following question has been raised for review by the Court: Whether Section 1. and Section 2. of the above EO State Law are violations of Article VI, Clause 2 of the United States Constitution, otherwise known as the Supremacy Clause, by contradicting and impeding the Constitution of the United States. reddit Signing of Bill 91: Death Penalty Reaffirmation act • /r/ModelSo... I truly believe in states' rights and the process of the Dixie Supreme Court. With the support of the Dixie Assembly, I must sign this into...

Article 2 of B.091 would permit and mandate that the State of Dixie carry out executions of persons who have been tried as criminals and given the death penalty. The 29th Amendment to the United States Constitution states in Section 2 that "All jurisdictions shall be prohibited from enacting and maintaining laws that prescribe the death sentence as a permissible punishment". As Article VI holds the Constitution to be the supreme Law of the Land, the State of Dixie has no legal or constitutional recourse to begin executing persons.

Pursuant to this petition, the Petitioner respectfully and urgently submits a motion and a request for immediate injunctive relief in the form of a temporary restraining order preventing any and all executions pursuit to B.091 (The Death Penalty Reaffirmation Act of 2016). To wit, it is believed that this law will allow executions to occur immediately after enactment (and the meta timeframe issues regarding this require that this injunction be filed now - edited to reflect bill being signed). Petitioner has grave concerns that it will immediately cause the deaths of multiple citizens of the Southern State, a grave and irreparable danger. Therefore, given the potential harm to numerous citizens of this State, and certain nature of the contradiction of this law with the 29th Amendment to the Constitution of the United States, the petitioner urges the court to issue a temporary injunction preventing the implementation of this law. While typical Court rules may require harm to occur, Petitioner argues as follows:

  1. Harm has already occurred in violating the sanctity of the US Constitution. The actions of the legislature and Governor in claiming to be beyond the purview of its reach are an attempt to de-legitimize the Constitution of this nation and violate their respective oaths of office.

  2. To the extent this Court would have Petitioner wait for an unlawful execution to occur, the harm would be so great and irreparable that allowing the law to remain in force is utterly unconscionable. There are Dixie citizens on death row right now. It is foreseeable that under this law they will be executed in violation of clear constitutional directive. There is no justification to wait for a needless death to find that such an execution would be a clear violation of the constitution. To wit, the law directs all executions to proceed as normal.

  3. Further to point 2., the execution of Tommy Arthur is scheduled for one week from today.

Thank you.

Edit: Per order from the Court, this petition has been amended by the petitioner to reflect the rules of Court and changing events. This post should be labeled: In re: The Death Penalty Reaffirmation Act of 2016 (pursuant to Rule of Court Part 1 Section 4), given [Reddit] restrictions, this shall serve as an amendment thereto.


r/SSSC • • Jan 07 '16

16-1 Injunction Order

7 Upvotes

This Court has reached a decision on the maintenance of the injunction issued in 16-1.

We will be proceeding with the determination of the constitutionality of Executive Order 1 in accordance with this preliminary determination.

Plaintiff /u/coupdespace and Defendant /u/FeldmarschallRammel, /u/SolidOrangeGangsta have four (4) days remaining to submit briefs detailing the validity of Executive Order 1 as it conforms to our preliminary determination. After which, if the Court wishes, a time for oral arguments may be scheduled.

I thank both parties for their responsiveness and professionalism in the pleadings. We will be using this thread for the remaining arguments.


r/SSSC • • May 14 '21

21-5 Petition In re: Fair Work Ethic Act

6 Upvotes

May it please the Court:

Parties and Jurisdiction

Plaintiff is a managing general partner of CannibalHookers, a registered government relations firm based in Miami, DX. As part of its business, plaintiff employs lobbyists to develop long term relationships with public figures and/or their families.

Governor u/Tripplyons18 is the executive leader of the state of the firm’s incorporation and author of the law in question.

Plaintiff and defendant are subject to the general laws of the State of Dixie. This Court has general jurisdiction over this action pursuant to the Court Rules II and III.

Introduction

This action seeks declaratory judgment that certain provisions in the Dixie "Fair Work Ethic Act" ("FWEA"), recently passed by the Assembly and written by and signed by Governor u/Tripplyons18, are unconstitutional under multiple sections of the Dixie Constitution, both on their face and as applied.

For the first time in Southern history, the Assembly has empowered a politicized reliant agency to investigate workplaces and terminate employment contracts without an employer or employee’s assent, upon a mere allegation of workplace harassment or bullying. There is no right of appeal or of intervention. The board represents an undue and unauthorized state burden on the right to own and operate an enterprise unencumbered, and to execute employment contracts for benefit without unreasonable state interference. The manner in which the Assembly has granted investigative powers to the board also strongly implicates violations of the the Fourth Amendment and Dixie equivalent.

Though the Assembly recently adopted a new constitution that voluntarily eliminated the power of the Assembly to impose taxation, FWEA also creates a business tax to fund an expansion of paid spousal leave far beyond any other federal or state program. Mandated paid family leave is considered by the federal government and major accountancies as benefits subject to income tax treatment, to be reported by employees and employers and withheld by businesses as needed. For example, beneficiaries may withhold family leave taxes through the federal W4-V form.

Aside from Washington D.C., the current states that mandate PFL [like FWEA] require employees to pay into the fund. Deducting the employee’s portion before withholding taxes means their contributions are not taxable (e.g., pre-tax deduction). Deducting the employee’s portion after withholding taxes means their contributions are taxable (e.g., post-tax deduction). So, which is it? Are employee PFL contributions pre-tax or post-tax deductions? Employee PFL contributions are post-tax deductions, therefore their contributions are subject to taxes... Employee PFL benefits are subject to federal income tax (aside from the disability portion of Rhode Island’s program). However, PFL benefits are not subject to Social Security and Medicare taxes, or federal unemployment (FUTA) tax... When an employee receives PFL benefits, the payments come from the state. Employers do not withhold taxes on an employee’s PFL benefits because they are not included in payroll. State governments do not automatically withhold paid family leave federal tax from an employee’s PFL benefits. However, an employee can request to have income taxes withheld by filing Form W-4V, Voluntary Withholding Request. Mercer.

As designed, FWEA’s funding renders it a state-federal tax accountability and relief nightmare, but a nightmare requiring tax powers.

This unconstitutional law in addition to “separate but equal” requisite power granted by the people in the Dixie Bill of Rights cannot be enforced by the state.

General Allegations

FWEA, unless enjoined, violates several sections of the Dixie Constitution:

  • The power of the FWEA board to terminate private employees interferes with the “right to own and operate a business in the State of Dixie, in accordance with reasonable and applicable laws, [and] shall not be infringed.” Art. I.

  • As employment services are contracted for mutual material benefit, the board’s interference in employment agreements impairs “obligations stipulated under a binding contract agreed upon by all involved parties that does not violate any provisions of this Constitution or any law made by the Assembly,” and also because the “right to exchange goods and services for monetary profit, in accordance with reasonable and applicable laws, shall not be infringed.” Art. I.

  • FWEA implicates civil rights protections in both constitutions because the board’s civil search and seizure power actually implicates the Fourth Amendment according to federal precedent, and it also cannot be enforced by the Dixie Court, because a “person shall [not] have their persons, houses, papers, and otherwise personal property be unreasonably searched or seized without a warrant,” and “the Supreme Court or any other lower court shall not issue any warrant unless probable cause is presented, proven, or otherwise apparent.” Art. I.

  • The taxes imposed on businesses by FWEA are unconstitutional and unenforceable because the Assembly rejected the authority to issue state business taxes. Legislative Powers, Unitary Clause.

Analysis

An unreasonable state burden on business and against the contracts binding willing employees and employers is impermissible under the Constitution and this Court’s own doctrines, fundamentally destroying carefully guarded Court precedent.

The Dixie Courts “have long recognized the strongly embedded public policy favoring freedom of contract. And, absent a compelling reason, courts must respect and enforce the terms of a contract that the parties have freely and voluntarily made.” Bombardier Aerospace Corp. v. SPEP Aircraft Holdings, LLC, 572 S.W.3d 213, 230 (Tex. 2019); Endeavor Energy Res., L.P. v. Discovery Operating, Inc., 554 S.W.3d 586, 595 (Tex. 2018); Nafta Traders, Inc. v. Quinn, 339 S.W.3d 84, 95–96 (Tex. 2011).

Employment contracts, particularly those already in force willingly accepted by both employees and employers, are granted significant constitutional protections under Dixie law. These critical agreements power Southern enterprise, typically exchanging legal services for benefits such as pay or leave, and remedies outside litigation to address capricious or biased termination.

[I]f there is one thing which more than another public policy requires it is that men of full age and competent understanding shall have the utmost liberty of contracting, and that their contracts when entered into freely and voluntarily shall be held sacred and shall be enforced by Courts of justice. Therefore, you have this paramount public policy to consider—that you are not lightly to interfere with this freedom of contract.” *Wood Motor Co. v. Nebel, 238 S.W.2d 181, 185 (Tex. 1951); see also *St. Louis Sw. Ry. Co. of Tex. v. Griffin, 171 S.W. 703, 704 *(Tex. 1914) (“The citizen has the liberty of contract as a natural right which is beyond the power of the government to take from him. The liberty to make contracts includes the corresponding right to refuse to accept a contract or to assume such liability as may be proposed.”)

This Court does not recognize the ability of the Assembly to terminate or alter legal business contracts without overwhelming public interest. As an example of permitted regulation, at-will employees may be terminated for any legal reason or no reason at all, but Dixie still may penalize businesses in the appearance of biased termination. An employer that fires an employee based on mere allegations sent to a state agency subjects itself to costly civil liability issues at the state and federal levels.

“These [multiple U.S. state] courts have reasoned that a negligent-investigation claim would be inconsistent with, and would significantly alter, the at-will employment relationship.   We, too, believe that recognizing such a duty in this context would significantly damage the at-will employment relationship that Texas has so carefully guarded.   See City of Midland, 18 S.W.3d at 216. By definition, the employment-at-will doctrine does not require an employer to be reasonable, or even careful, in making its termination decisions... And creating an incentive for insurance companies to summarily dismiss their agents when misconduct is merely rumored is certainly not in the best interest of agents in Sears's position.” Texas Farm Bureau Insurance Companies v. Sears (Tex. 2002).

Plaintiff and other businessss agree that there exists a reasonable level of needed protection for employees in an at-will contract, such as racial or gender-motivated termination. The state cannot force employers take preemptive action and assume civil liability for firing the morally accused. The state also cannot force employees and employers to renegotiate private contracts whatsoever based on this executive board’s determinations. The Assembly has decided without foundational police power to render Dixie’s “carefully guarded” judicial protections void.

Dixie and federal constitutional precedent prohibit abusive and general administrative searches of the workplace.

Sweeping administrative search power by a state agency may be at times permitted. This is often employed in long-regulated industries like alcohol, radio, securities, and tobacco. Colonnade Catering Corp. v. United States, 397 U.S. 72 (1970). Firearms are also subject to warrantless search, because weapons were already “pervasively” regulated with an urgent need for investigative speed and surprise. Therefore, these business dealers already have little expectation of privacy. United States v. Biswell, 406 U.S. 311 (1972).

On the other hand, a scheme similar to FWEA was deemed unconstitutional. The Supreme Court rejected OSHA’s argument that warrantless searches of all businesses in its legislative purview without evidence was allowable. Because occupational inspections of every business serves little explicit government purpose, the administrative powers exercised were arbitrary. 436 U.S. 307 (1978).

The FWEA board offers businesses employing morally accused employees an unconstitutional bargain implicating the Fourth Amendment, Fifth Amendment and mirror texts of the Dixie Constiution. This is because a search of a business and its records, and seizure of material benefits to both employer and employee, is “equivalent [to] a compulsory production of a man's private papers.” Even with an arguable public purpose, such a demand is “an 'unreasonable search and seizure' within the meaning of the Fourth Amendment.” See Boyd v. United States, 116 U.S. 616 (1886) (state law allowing state and private agents to issue warrants to search business papers for the purpose of debt recovery is unconstitutional). This choice presents a further Dixie Constitution violation because of the absolute bar against self-incrimination in “any matter, civil and criminal.”

A politically appointed board with no independent arbiter is also suspect. United States v. U.S. Dist. Court for the E. Dist. of Mich., S. Div., 407 U.S. 297, 315 (1972). “Warrants provide the ‘detached scrutiny of a neutral magistrate, and thus ensur[e] an objective determination whether an intrusion is justified.’” Birchfield v. North Dakota, 136 S. Ct. 2160, 2187–88 (2016) (Sotomayor, J., concurring in part and dissenting in part) (quoting Skinner v. Ry. Labor Execs. Ass’n, 489 U.S. 602, 622 (1989)). Judicial warrants should always be sought, and therefore “give life to [the Court’s] instruction that the Fourth Amendment ‘is designed to prevent, not simply to redress, unlawful police action.’” Id. at 2188 (quoting* Steagald v. United States*, 451 U.S. 204, 215 (1981)).

The state cannot popularly reject state tax power in its Constitution months ago, and then mandate a sizable tax on all business operating in Dixie without amending its powers to fulfill such an agenda.

The Governor of Dixie may propose the amount of revenue required for the annual budget. Revenue includes anything from property and sales taxes (as in all other states), to intergovernmental transfers (such as through Dixie congressional advocacy), to government-run liquor stores, pension funds and public utilities (as under Dixie statutes). The assumption that raising revenue means issuing appropriations laws and tax powers would render both terms meaningless, when Texas and Florida each had separate executive, legislative and county Revenue and Taxation agencies previously.

The Assembly approves or rejects the suggestion that there could be an inherent tax power inline any other in the nation and reserved to the states if the opportunity is taken:

Section 1. All political power is inherent in and derived from the people, and all free governments are founded on their authority, and instituted for their benefit. The rights of the people shall not be denied or infringed upon.

Section 16. No person shall be deprived of the rights put forth by this Constitution without ample due process under letter of the law.

Section 5. All legislation enacted by the state of Texas prior to January 20, 2021 shall continue in effect upon adoption of this Constitution, except legislation which contradicts the provisions of this document.

Section 1. The Legislative power of this state shall be vested in a unicameral General Assembly consisting of 7 members.

Section 6. (a) The General Assembly may make no law except by bill. ... (c) No bill shall be so amended in it’s passage through the Legislature as to change its original purpose.

Section 7. Upon passage by the General Assembly, the bill shall be sent to the Governor. The Governor may sign the bill, at which point it shall become statutory law.

1. The General Assembly shall have the right to amend this Constitution by an absolute two-thirds majority of the sitting Assemblypeople in the affirmative.

Section 2. All amendments to this Constitution must either directly amend Articles I-V of this Constitution or add a new section to Article VI of this Constitution. No new Articles may be added to this document.

In A.001 (the proposed and adopted Constiution), the Assembly by and through the “supreme power” of the people, adopted language that did not intend and never did grant the Assembly the power to tax. The budget process is the Governor proposes adjustments to state revenue, and the Assembly retorts. That a governor both wrote his bill and signed it may in fact be a retort between branches, but the dilemma exceeds the timing issue.

The Assembly debated this arrangement and finally decided it would clearly adopt the Atlantic Constiution’s (and New York’s) approach that the Governor proposes revenue measures and the legislature accepts or rejects them upon presentation.

It is abundantly clear the amount of thought the Assembly placed into this process: Dixie citizens today must constitutionally address the Assembly in a non-gendered state title; Dixie governors constitutionally and uniquely may have executive orders directly vetoed by the Assembly; The Dixie Assembly expressly prohibits any citizen amendment in two instances: reproductive rights, or renumbering the Constitution; The Assembly moved itself from Florida to Texas while keeping Florida legal precedent; The Assembly allows a veto override without receiving a gubernatorial veto; It constitutionally prohibits independents to be appointed to a vacant Senate seat; it expanded Florida’s opinion capacity of the Attorney General to nearly any topic...

What the Assembly decided not to empower itself with is the burdensome tax process, a decision popular with the Dixie people and with business.

By the letter of the law, a look to neighboring states, and the historical debate record, the Assembly cannot now pass a bill taxing business for expanded spousal leave or any purpose. It would be unethical and unconstitutional for any other branch, serving as “checks on the other,” to empower another branch to do so for political purposes.

FWEA contains multiple revenue schemes, but its mandate that businesses provide 20 weeks of paid spousal sick and parental leave is “fairly possibly” construed as a tax benefitting Dixie, as Chief Justice Robert’s expressed in NFIB v. Sebelius interpreting the The Affordable Healthcare Act. FWEA’s mandate looks like an unconstitutional tax, not only because of its content, but because family leave deductions can be required by the state; the amount of tax is based on numerous factors in the bill; it mirrors IRS and other state reporting and withholding requirements; and the work and benefit is itself taxed and at times held held by the government.

Because the law deploys an unsupported legislative power to impose a mandate or tax with penalties for noncompliance, it should be struck.

Relief and Conclusion

Plaintiff CannibalHookers seeks declaratory relief clarifying the fundamental rights of CannibalHookers as a business operator and employer, and as a state taxpayer, pursuant to the FWEA and Dixie and U.S. Constitutions, chiefly on the issues of the regulatory reach of state agencies into corporate affairs and of the state’s constitutional capacity to legislate taxation on domestic and foreign business entities operating in-state.

Respectfully submitted to the Dixie State Court,

Hon. Carib Cannibette Biden, Jr., Esq.


r/SSSC • • Nov 29 '17

Petition Accepted In Re: B177 Dismemberment Abortion Ban Act

6 Upvotes

To the Honorable Justices of this Court, now comes /u/CuriositySMBC, representing the Petitioner /u/Gog3451, respectfully submitting this petition for a writ of certiorari to review the constitutionality of State Public Law 177 (henceforth “the Law”). Petitioner asks this Court to strike the unconstitutional section 3 from legal force. Petitioner holds standing as a Southern State Citizen.


First, the counsel for the Petitioner observes that this legislation is politically charged, put onto the docket after three rulings by the Supreme Court of the United States (In re. Midwestern Public Law B. 005.2, 100 M.S.Ct. 122 (2016), In re: State of Sacagawea Executive Order 007, 100 M.S.Ct 123, and In re: State of Sacagawea Public Law B060) challenged and struck anti-abortion provisions from various states' law.


Section 3 of the Law reads as follows:

(a) Dismemberment abortions shall be banned within the borders of Dixie at any point in a pregnancy in all cases.

(b) All abortions shall be considered banned after the 18 week point no matter the circumstances.

The following questions have been raised for review by the Court:

  1. Whether all provisions in Section 3 are unconstitutional given the clear disregard for the precedents set by the Supreme Court of the United States in Roe v. Wade, which were reaffirm Casey v. Planned Parenthood that the State does have power to restrict abortions after fetal viability “if the law contains exceptions for pregnancies which endanger the woman's life or health”. As Public Law 177 fails to provide any exceptions and in fact explicitly ensures there be no exceptions, it is unconstitutional.

  2. Whether all provisions in Section 3 are unconstitutional given the precedent set by the Supreme Court of the United State in Casey v. Planned Parenthood that established a standard of fetal viability (“We conclude the line should be drawn at viability, so that before that time the woman has a right to choose to terminate her pregnancy.” Casey 870) as the point of constitutional regulation for a fetus and abortion. It is with this standard of fetal viability in mind (defined by the Casey Court as 24 weeks, but tied to medical standard) that this section of the Law violates the Due Process Clause of the Constitution of the United States (“A woman's interest in having an abortion is a form of liberty protected by the Due Process Clause, but States may regulate abortion procedures in ways rationally related to a legitimate state interest.” Casey 966). The Casey Court notes that “States may regulate abortion procedures in ways rationally related to a legitimate state interest”. It is here ruled by the Casey Court that the States do not hold a legitimate state interest in those fetuses before the defined standard of viability (“...the attainment of viability may continue to serve as the critical fact…” Casey 860). As such is the case, Section 3(a), which makes illegal a type abortion at all points of a pregnancy even those before the point of fetal viability, is clearly unconstitutional. Furthermore, Section 3(b), which makes illegal all abortions post 18 weeks into a pregnancy, which is a point in time prior to a fetus being considered viable, is clearly unconstitutional.

Pursuant to this petition, the counsel for the Petitioner respectfully and urgently submits a motion and a request for immediate injunctive relief. While typically Court rules may require harm to occur, the counsel argues as follows: It is believed that this law will allow the prevention of possibly life saving medical procedures immediately after its enactment. Petitioner has grave concerns that it will immediately endanger the health and lives of multiple citizens of the Southern State, possibly causing irreparable danger. Therefore, given the potential harm to numerous citizens of this State, and certain nature of the contradiction of this law with numerous rulings of the Supreme Court of the United State, the counsel of the petitioner urges this court to issue a temporary injunction preventing the implementation of this law.

The counsel for the Petitioner claims that there is a substantial likelihood of the success of the merits of this case due to multiple precedents set down by the Supreme Court of the United State, especially in recent years, regarding abortion. Further, the people of the Southern State face imminent violations of liberty and safety through the continuation of this law.


r/SSSC • • Oct 28 '16

18-3 Hearing In re: Executive Order 014

6 Upvotes

Pursuant to the Rules of Court, a majority of the bench has voted to extend review on the constitutionality of Executive Order 014.

The Court finds that the Plaintiff has filed a complaint upon which relief may be provided.

The Plaintiff alleges that the Executive Order in question is a violation of the 4th amendment, the privileges and immunities clause, the supremacy clause, the 5th amendment, and the 14th amendment.

The Petition Reads


Honorable Court, before you comes the petitioner, /u/sviridovt to challenge the constitutionality of Executive Order 014: Additional Security Measures order. Given the urgency of this Executive Order we ask the court to grant a temporary immediate relief until such a time that this matter may be fully heard. Before you today stand the following questions:

  1. Did Governor /u/CaptainClutchMuch violate the 4th Amendment to the United States Constitution by ordering a search of peoples leaving and entering the state without probable cause as defined in Carroll v. United States?

  2. Did Governor /u/CaptainClutchMuch violate the United States Constitution Article IV, Section 2 Clause 1 (henceforth referred to as the 'Privileges and Immunities Clause') by setting up roadblocks with vague standards as to potentially violate law-abiding citizens rights to free travel as defined in Zobel v. Williams (1869)?

  3. Did Governor /u/CaptainClutchMuch violate the United States Constitution 5th Amendment and 14th Amendment by improperly holding them in custody without bringing charges forward?

  4. Did Governor /u/CaptainClutchMuch violate the United States Constitution Article VI, Clause 2 (henceforth referred to as 'supremacy clause') by violating the 4th amendment to the United States Constitution in accordance with points 1-3?

  5. Is Executive Order 014 (henceforth referred to as EO14) written in such a vague matter as to be rendered unconstitutional?


1. Did Governor /u/CaptainClutchMuch violate the 4th Amendment to the United States Constitution by ordering a search of peoples leaving and entering the state without probable cause as defined in Carroll v. United States?

On October 27th, 2016 the Governor of the Southern State /u/CaptainClutchMuch has issued EO14, establishing roadblocks on major entrances into the state. The Executive Order provides broad authority to State Law Enforcement to search any vehicle as part of Section 1 of EO14. We ask the court to find such a provision unconstitutional as decided previously in the Supreme Court Case Carroll v. United States where the court ruled the following:

[i]t would be intolerable and unreasonable if a prohibition agent were authorized to stop every automobile on the chance of finding liquor, and thus subject all persons lawfully using the highways to the inconvenience and indignity of such a search... . [T]hose lawfully within the country, entitled to use the public highways, have a right to free passage without interruption or search unless there is known to a competent official, authorized to search, probable cause for believing that their vehicles are carrying contraband or illegal merchandise.

By stopping and searching every vehicle that is entering the state, without prior probable cause, we believe that this Executive Order stands in direct violation of the United States Constitution, and is ought to be struck down. Because the Order provides no severance clause, the entire order shall be struck down as a result of this violation.


Did Governor /u/CaptainClutchMuch violate the United States Constitution Article IV, Section 2 Clause 1 (henceforth referred to as the 'Privileges and Immunities Clause') by setting up roadblocks with vague standards as to potentially violate law-abiding citizens rights to free travel as defined in Zobel v. Williams (1869)?

The Executive Order forces State Law Enforcement Agencies to set up roadblocks and stop all vehicles coming into the Dixie State. We urge the court to find this order in violation of the Privileges and Immunities Clause of the United States Constitution, as further confirmed in the precedent set by the United States Supreme Court Zobel v. Williams, which states the following:

Article IV's Privileges and Immunities Clause has enjoyed a long association with the rights to travel and migrate interstate. The Clause derives from Art. IV of the Articles of Confederation. The latter expressly recognized a right of "free ingress and regress to and from any other State," in addition to guaranteeing "the free inhabitants of each of these states . . . [the] privileges and immunities of free citizens in the several States." While the Framers of our Constitution omitted the reference to "free ingress and regress," they retained the general guaranty of "privileges and immunities." Charles Pinckney, who drafted the current version of Art. IV, told the Convention that this Article was "formed exactly upon the principles of the 4th article of the present Confederation." Commentators, therefore, have assumed that the Framers omitted the express guaranty merely because it was redundant, not because they wished to excise the right from the Constitution. Early opinions by the Justices of this Court also traced a right to travel or migrate interstate to Art. IV's Privileges and Immunities Clause....Similarly, in Paul v. Virginia, the Court found that one of the "undoubt[ed]" effects of the Clause was to give "the citizens of each State . . . the right of free ingress into other States, and egress from them...."

In the case, the court upheld the precedent set in Paul v. Virginia, ruling that the constitutional right of citizens to freely travel between states shall not be denied. Despite this, the Executive Order has ordered road blocks to be set up controlling entry into the state, subjecting citizens to vehicle searches, and making them subject to arrest based on vague criteria. We urge the court to find this act as an unconstitutional hindrance to the rights of United States Citizens to freely travel between states, and as such find this Executive Order unconstitutional.


Did Governor /u/CaptainClutchMuch violate the United States Constitution 5th Amendment and 14th Amendment by improperly holding them in custody without bringing charges forward?


The Executive Order in question gives broad authority to State Law Enforcement Agencies to arrest and detain any persons which in the officer's judgement posses a danger. In the Executive Order no provision of the law to allow this is mentioned. Here is the relevant excerpt:

Any vehicles that, in the judgement of the officer, may present a threat to the State of Dixie should be held for further processing by the Dixie State Guard.

No laws are provided under which these persons may be charged, as such, the orders allows for an undefined detention of individuals without charging them with any crime, thereby violating both the 5th and the 14th amendment to the United States Constitution, which reads that:

[N]or shall any person . . . be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law

We find that this Executive Order stands in direct violation of these fundamental amendments, and as such ought to be struck down.


Did Governor /u/CaptainClutchMuch violate the United States Constitution Article VI, Clause 2 (henceforth referred to as 'supremacy clause') by violating the 4th amendment to the United States Constitution in accordance with points 1-3?


We ask the court to find this act unconstitutional and in violation of the Supremacy Clause of the United States Constitution should this court find the Executive Order in question to be in violation of any of the previous points brought up before this court.


Is Executive Order 014 (henceforth referred to as EO14) written in such a vague matter as to be rendered unconstitutional?


Honorable Justices, perhaps the biggest violation of the Executive Order in question is the Vagueness of the order. As such, we ask you to rule this Executive Order to be so vague as to be void, thereby executing the Vagueness Doctrine. We believe that because of the vagueness of this Executive Order, it can easily lead to violations of other constitutional rights of citizens and ought to be struck down. The Vagueness Doctrine establishes that definitions of potentially vague terms are to be provided, however, the Executive Order sets up the following criteria which may lead to arrest of citizens:

Any vehicles that, in the judgement of the officer, may present a threat to the State of Dixie should be held for further processing by the Dixie State Guard.

We believe this to be unconstitutional, since no standard is provided for what may present a threat, or what provision of the law the persons ought to be charged with. We believe that this vagueness has the potential to lead to violations involving due process rights, civil rights amongst others and therefore ought to be struck down.


The Petitioner Additionally Included the Following


In the matter of plausible Plaintiff I would like to enter any citizen of the Southern State, who has been stopped and detained as a result of the Executive Order.

As far as a plausible scenario under which constitutional rights might have been violated, we need to talk about the thousands of people who would have been stopped and their vehicle searched as a direct result of this Executive Order, furthermore, an innocent person (perhaps members of certain minorities, since without a standard to follow, the discretion is left entirely to the officer of the law, which opens the doors to a whole range of biases) might easily be held without being charged with a crime, thereby violating his/her individual rights.


The Court shall continue to allow the State of Dixie to submit a motion to dismiss if they believe the petition to be invalid.

Oral arguments are in order at this time from the Plaintiff and the State of Dixie.

The Court shall open up this hearing to all parties with a vested interest in this case. Amicus Briefs are in order at this time.

Please keep all filings before this Court within the Rules of Court.


As our final order of business, this Court is issuing an emergency injunction against the enforcement of Executive Order 014. The Governor and his cabinet shall be permitted to continue exercising sections two and three of the order, however, no law enforcement agency or state militia force shall be allowed to impede the right of the people to travel freely as outlined by the Governor. This Court has reason to believe that this injunction is necessary to preserve the rights of the people of the United States. Due to the nature of this sim we are unable to determine the actions that law enforcement officers will take in response to Executive Order 014, but it is reasonable to conclude that officers may broadly apply this order to unjustly detain innocent citizens. The Court acknowledges that emergency response by officers to block roads may be warranted in extreme circumstances. The Court may hold an emergency hearing regarding this injunction if the State of Dixie can present extenuating circumstances that can reasonably explain why this order is necessary. Barring a serious emergency or crisis of the State of Dixie, this Court believes that the Executive Order in question has the potential to infringe on the rights of travelers and so any road blocks or inspection stations created by this order must immediately cease their operations.

It is so ordered.


r/SSSC • • Apr 08 '16

17-2 GenOfTheBuildArmy v. PM_ME_YOUR_PANZER Hearing

6 Upvotes

Pursuant to the Rules of Court, a majority of the bench has voted to extend review. We find that the Plaintiff, /u/GenOfTheBuildArmy, has submitted a complaint on which relief may be provided.

The complaint reads:


Comes the petitioner, /u/GenOfTheBuildArmy, Deputy Clerk of the Southern State. I would like to respectfully submit this petition for a writ of certiorari to review the constitutionality of the actions taken by Southern State Clerk /u/PM_ME_YOUR_PANZER.

On Monday April 4 of the year 2016, Southern State Clerk /u/PM_ME_YOUR_PANZER announced that /u/DrAlanGrantinathong had won the assembly seat in the Southern State to replace a vacancy. You can see the results here: https://www.reddit.com/r/ModelSouthernState/comments/4de9bx/seat_vote_2nd_seat_results/

6 votes were considered "invalid" by the state clerk due to the candidate not being submitted in time. You can see the clerk's response here: https://www.reddit.com/r/ModelSouthernState/comments/4de9bx/seat_vote_2nd_seat_results/d1q54ls

I submit this petition as the constitution of the Southern State outlines in section 5.2:

"Shall the Party fail to appoint a replacement within 7 days, the legislature shall elect a replacement by plurality vote. The same shall be the case if an independent resigns."

The constitution does not create any requirements for individuals to register to win the election nor does it ban the legislators from picking a candidate that has not registered.

As deputy clerk of the Southern State, I request that the court take the following action.

  1. Issue an emergency injunction barring /u/DrAlanGrantinathong from taking the oath of office and from participating in the legislative process in any way.

  2. Rule that the clerk took improper unilateral action in barring the state assembly from democratically electing the replacement legislator and requiring the State Clerk to amend the results to reflect the proper winner.


Review having been granted, the Court calls upon the Defendant, /u/PM_ME_YOUR_PANZER, to submit their answer to this allegation. They shall have five (5) days.

Additionally, an emergency injunction shall not be issued until Plaintiff, /u/GenOfTheBuildArmy, can respond to the following:

I ask the petitioner to establish three things in order to determine whether or not an emergency injunction is warranted in this matter. Number one, the applicant must show that they have established a prima facie case and that the claim is neither frivolous or vexatious. Secondly, the applicant must establish that there will be irreparable harm should the injunction be refused by this court. Third and last, the applicant must show there will be a greater harm from the refusal of the injunction, rather than the respondents will suffer from the granting of the injunction.

The granting of injunctions is always a matter of the court's discretion. As such, the court requests that these three things be established by the applicant before further consideration by the Justices of this court.

It is so ordered.


r/SSSC • • Mar 05 '16

Petition Accepted In re: Executive Order 004

6 Upvotes

To the Honorable Justices of this Court, the petitioner, /u/theSolomonCaine representing The American Media PAC, respectfully submits this petition for a writ of certiorari to review the constitutionality of Executive Order 004 of the Southern State, known for long title as Executive Order 004 - Establishing the Order of Cavaliers.

The following questions have been raised for review by the Court:

  1. Whether Executive Order 004 violates Article I, Section 10, ¶ 1 of the United States Constitution by granting titles of nobility to members inducted to the Order of the Cavaliers by the Governor of the Southern State.

  2. Whether Executive Order 004 violates Article I, Section 10, ¶ 1 of the United States Constitution by establishing an Order of Merit, which may be defined as a dynastic order which draws power from royal patronage, with the prerogative of transferring exclusive titles of nobility.


r/SSSC • • Feb 15 '16

Announcement My Resignation

6 Upvotes

I would like to thank this Court, especially those attorneys and Justices that I worked with, for the phenomenal proceedings I presided over. I look forward to the continued work of this Court, and to the nomination of the Chambers next Chief Justice. I'm positive they will shape the Court in ways I could never have conceived.

It is convenient that no cases are pending during this time, but should a case arise, I am more than confident in our two Justices to uphold justice in the Southern State.

May God bless you all, and may God bless the Southern State!

For the last time as your Chief Justice I now announce an occurrence of this Court. I do hereby resign my position as Chief Justice immediately.

Sincerely,

C.J. BSDDC


r/SSSC • • Jan 21 '16

16-3 Ruling on 16-3 TheSolomonCaine (for Rasheem Dubose) v. SolidOrangeGangsta

6 Upvotes

The Court has reached a decision on review of the execution of Rasheem Dubose. Our full opinion can be found here.

An excerpt from the decision follows:

In conclusion, because capital punishment, as prescribed by the laws of the Southern State, is compatible with the Constitution and that in the present case we find the punishment is justified by law, we find for the State.

The execution of Rasheem Dubose is to be carried out in accordance with the laws of the Southern State forthwith.

Appeal to the Supreme Court, if an appeal will happen in this matter, should be timely.

Should the Governor wish to issue clemency, we would also recommend haste.

Both parties are thanked for their professionalism during these very serious proceedings.

C.J. BSDDC


r/SSSC • • Jan 13 '16

Petition Accepted theSolomonCaine v. Southern State

6 Upvotes

To the Honorable Justices of this Court, the petitioner representing Rasheem Dubose, /u/theSolomonCaine, respectfully submits this petition for a writ of certiorari to review the constitutionality of Title XLVII, Chapter 921, Section 141 of the 2014 Florida Statutes and Title XLVII, Chapter 921, Section 142 of the 2014 Florida Statutes.


The Southern State, in its administration of the death penalty, has blatantly violated the Cruel and Unusual Punishment Clause of the 8th Amendment to the United States Constitution, stating:

nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted

The 8th Amendment to the United States Constitution was displayed as able to be applied to state law under U.S. Supreme Court ruling Robinson v. California, 370 U.S. 660 (1962). The punishment of certain death for the specific crimes indicated by the Florida Statutes has overstepped the boundaries of acceptable and fair punishment for crimes entailed, and therefore should be struck down by this Court.


[1] The Plaintiff has now been specified as Florida death row inmate Rasheem Dubose, convicted and sentenced to death in 2010 for a 1st Degree Murder charge occurring in 2006.


r/SSSC • • Dec 07 '15

Announcement Rule of Court

6 Upvotes

Part I. Initiation of an Action

§ 1. Any individual may file a petition for relief by creating a new post in the Court’s subreddit. The petition will, in short and plain terms,

  1. State a claim for which valid relief may be given and demonstrate a plausible plaintiff,

  2. Include the name of the opposing party or parties,

  3. Comply with all other applicable Rules of this Court.

§ 2. Failure to satisfy any of these requirement will result in a rejection of the petition. The Court shall rule on acceptance of a petition within forty-eight (48) hours.

§ 3. The individual petitioning the court shall be known as “Plaintiff” and the party responding shall be known as “Defendant” for the purposes of this Court.

§ 4. Should the petition allege a law or action is incompatible with the Constitution of the United States or the Constitution of the Southern State the matter will be designated as "In re: [Law/Action being challenged]." Parties with a vested interest will be invited to submit arguments in line with Part III of the Rules of Court. There will be no designated plaintiff or defendant in these proceedings.


Part II. Jurisdiction of the Court

§ 1. This Court shall be one of general jurisdiction.

§ 2. This Court shall have jurisdiction to hear cases arising under the Laws and Constitution of the Southern State and the Laws, Treaties, and Constitution of the United States. Actions arising from the laws of another state shall not be brought before this Court.

§ 3. This Court may not call another State or the United States to the jurisdiction of the Southern State as a defendant.


Part III. Pleadings and Arguments

§ 1. A petition being approved, the original petition shall be treated as the complaint and a new thread will be created for the remainder of the pleadings. Defendant shall have five (5) days to respond once the Court approves the petition and notifies the Defendant. Failure to do so will result in default judgement for Plaintiff.

§ 2. Following these initial pleadings both parties will be required to submit briefs detailing their main legal arguments within five (5) days of the Defendant's response and notice by the Court. These briefs shall not exceed one-thousand five-hundred (1,500) words. Failure to submit a brief will not result in penalties from the Court. The Court will be only able to rely on the initial pleadings of the failing party in reaching its decision.

§ 3. Following submission of the briefs, the Court may schedule a time for oral arguments at the Court’s discretion.

§ 4. No pleading or argument once submitted may be edited. Failure to comply with this rule may result in judgement against the offending party, or any other penalty the Court deems appropriate.

§ 5. Amicus Briefs are welcome, and must comport to the same deadlines and limits stated in Part III section 2. They may be posted in the case thread.


Part IV. Representation and Decorum of the Court

§ 1. Any party may designate anyone of their choosing to represent them during any and all of the proceedings before the Court. Failure of this representative to meet deadlines and requirements shall be a failing of the party they represent. This representative must be designated by a comment in the case’s individual thread or in the initial pleadings.

§ 2. Apart from the submission of Amicus Briefs, no non-party or representative will be allowed to comment in the case’s thread. Violating comments will be stricken. Sanctions of Court may be implemented for repeat offenses, and will be up to the discretion of the Court.

§ 3. All appearing before the Court will be held to the highest degree of decorum.


Part V. Decisions of the Court

§ 1. Approval of petitions, amendments to these rules, and final decisions in cases must be approved by a majority of the seats on the Court.

§ 2. Final decisions on pending cases will be released no later than ten (10) days following the deadline for submission of the briefs or close of arguments if applicable.


Amendment 1: Added Part I, Section 4. Amended Part II, Section 3 to prevent personal jurisdiction over the United States. 1/16/16.


r/SSSC • • Mar 31 '21

21-1 Petition Accepted In re: EO 007, Sensible Immigration Policies

5 Upvotes

Applicant seeks a ruling on the legality of EO 007: Sensible Immigration Policies, signed by Governor Tripplyons18 on 29 March 2021. Applicant claims that this executive order is illegal as an unconstitutional exercise of legislative power by the executive; in particular, with regards to the inclusion of undocumented immigrants in the Southern Health Service, as established by the Southern Health Service Act of 2021.

BACKGROUND

The executive order issued by Governor Tripplyons18 included provisions that “The state of Dixie shall offer undocumented immigrants access to the following welfare programs via state funds [...] Access to healthcare coverage under the provisions of B.001: Southern Health Service Act”. EO 007, section 4(1). Applicant claims that this expands the scope of the Act to undocumented immigrants, in an unconstitutional executive act of legislation.

THE SOUTHERN HEALTH SERVICE ACT LIMITS SERVICES TO CITIZENS

The Southern Health Service Act limits the scope of who is eligible to receive services under its provisions. In particular, title II prescribes the scope of the enrollment for the programme. “Every citizen of the Dixie State will be, at the age of 26 when they are ineligible to remain on their parents’s [sic] benefits, automatically enrolled in the Dixie Health Service.” Southern Health Service Act of 2021, section 203(a).

EXPANDING PROVISION TO NON-CITIZENS IS AN UNCONSTITUTIONAL EXERCISE OF LEGISLATIVE POWER

To be sure, undocumented immigrants are not citizens: this is true by definition. To expand the provision of the services of the Southern Health Service requires some other method of enrolling the undocumented immigrants who seek to access its services. No such method exists in law: the Southern Health Service Act does not include any provision that allows the Governor to enroll people in the service. Instead, it limits enrollment (done automatically) to every citizen aged twenty-six and over.

To permit the enrollment, then, of undocumented citizens would require the amendment of the Act. The Governor does not have the power to do so via Executive Order. That remains the sole prerogative of the legislature. “The Legislative power of this state shall be vested in a unicameral General Assembly”. Dixie Constitution, Article III, section I. The Act may not be amended save by another Act of the General Assembly. Governor Tripplyons18’s attempt at amending the terms of the Act are unconstitutional under the Dixie Constitution.

REMEDIES SOUGHT

That the court strike down the Executive Order.


Respectfully submitted,

lily-irl
Resident of the State of Dixie
Attorney at law


r/SSSC • • Apr 03 '20

20-5 Petition Granted In Re AB. 468 - Dixie Sexual Education Act of 2020

5 Upvotes

Your Honors,

Comes /u/dr0ne717, to petition the court on behalf of Mr. Frank Williams who has chosen me to represent him in these hearings pursuant to R. Ct. Part IV, § 1. I request the Honorable Judges of this Court to grant a writ of certiorari to review the Constitutionality of the Dixie Sexual Education Act of 2020. Plaintiff alleges it violates the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment and the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.

BACKGROUND

On March 19, 2020 Governor /u/BoredNerdyGamer signed AB.468 into law. The act mandates that all public high school students, without exception, are taught a sexual education curriculum that includes a number of contentious issues including birth control, homosexuality, and transexuality, among others.

The act does not include an excusual clause which would allow parents to excuse their child from content contradictory to their religious or moral beliefs. Rather it mandates, without exception, that “All students, however, must have been taught the above material by the 12th grade.”

Mr. Williams is a devout Catholic who currently has two high school aged children enrolled in a Dixie Public High School. Mr. Williams has attempted to raise his children in the Catholic tradition of sexual ethics. Under the act, his children will be forced to partake in sexual education lessons contradictory to their faith and may not be excused.

QUESTIONS

Does AB.468 (the Dixie Sexual Education Act of 2020) violate the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment by forcing students to participate in sexual education lessons contrary to their faith and the faith of their parents ? Does AB.468 violate the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment by denying parents the liberty to control the education and upbringing of their children?

ARGUMENT

The Act violates the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment as it forces the children of Mr. Williams, as well as all Dixie Public High School students, to participate in sexual education lessons that are in direct contradiction to their religion and his children will thus be inhibited in their practice of the Catholic faith. The plaintiff will also be inhibited in his right to educate his children in sexual ethics pursuant to his religious beliefs.

Other state courts have considered similar cases regarding the free exercise clause and sexual education (Medeiros v. Kiyosaki (1970) 52 Haw. 436, Parental Rights v. San Mateo County Board 51 Cal. App. 3rd 1, 124 Cal Rprt. 68 (1975 )). While the state courts in these cases upheld the laws in question, they did so due to the existence of an excusual clause which allowed parents to excuse their children from the sexual education lessons. No such clause exists in the Dixie Sexual Education Act. As stated previously, the Act requires, without exception or possibility of excusual, that all high school students participate in sexual education lessons. The Hawaii Supreme Court found in Medeiros that “in view of the fact that the program to which the plaintiffs now seek a permanent injunction is not compulsory, we fail to find any direct or substantial burden on their ‘free exercise’ of religion” and “Inasmuch as we have found no compulsion or coercion related to the educational Program in question, we find no violation of the First Amendment's Free Exercise of Religion Clause.”

The Supreme Court found in Troxel v. Granville, 530 U.S. 57 (2000) that parents have the right under the Fourteenth Amendment’s Due Process Clause to control the education and upbringing of their children: “In Meyer v. Nebraska, 262 U.S. 390, 399, 401 (1923), we held that the ‘liberty’ protected by the Due Process Clause includes the right of parents to ‘establish a home and bring up children’ and ‘to control the education of their own.” The Court also wrote in Troxel that “In a long line of cases, we have held that, in addition to the specific freedoms protected by the Bill of Rights, the ‘liberty’ specially protected by the Due Process Clause includes the righ[t] … to direct the education and upbringing of one’s children (citing Meyer and Pierce)). In light of this extensive precedent, it cannot now be doubted that the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment protects the fundamental right of parents to make decisions concerning the care, custody, and control of their children.” The Act prohibits Mr. Williams from controlling both the education and moral upbringing of his children, thus in violation of his Fourteenth Amendment Rights.

CONCLUSION

For the reasons stated above, I request the Court to grant this petition for review and declare the Dixie Sexual Education Act of 2020 unconstitutional.


r/SSSC • • Sep 27 '19

19-33 Default Judgement Department of the Environment in re: B.230: State Symbolism Act and B.273: Dixie Seal Act

5 Upvotes

PETITION FOR CERTIORARI

STATE OF DIXIE

DEPARTMENT OF THE ENVIRONMENT

IN RE:

B.230: STATE OF DIXIE SYMBOLISM ACT

AND

B.273: DIXIE STATE SEAL ACT

QUESTION PRESENTED

Whether the Assembly is improperly mandating that the Department of the Environment display on official documents state symbols based on invalid acts, that are contrary to the Dixie Constitution and the legislative prohibitions of the Flag and Seal Statutes?

Whether the Assembly is attempting to enforce laws that are improperly constructed according to the Dixie Constitution’s restrictions on logrolling of subjects and under misleading titles?

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES

Dixie State Constitution Art. XVI s. 12 (Amendment 4)

B.230: State of Dixie Symbolism Act

B.273: Dixie Seal Act

Brown v. Firestone, 382 So.2d 654 (1980)

Dixie States Chapter 15.03: State Seal

Dixie Statutes Chapter 256.05: Improper Use of State Flag

Dixie Statutes Chapter 256.06: Improper State Flag Mutilation and Prohibition on Display of Confederate Symbols

Dixie Statutes Chapter 256.07: Exceptions for Stationary

Dixie Statutes 256.015: Governor Determines State Flag Protocol for Display

Mandate by Assemblyman /u/MaiqKnowsMuch to the Secretary of Infrastructure /u/RobespierreBoi Cabinet re: Directive 48(2)

ISSUE ONE: UNCONSTITIONAL ACTS ADOPTED

GENERALLY

On September 25, the /u/Blockdenied Cabinet became aware of a legal demand by the Assembly that the State of Dixie shall employ a new flag for official use.

Assemblyman /u/MaiqKnowsMuch clarified that the Dixie Flag, referred to here as the “red flag”, was a foreign flag no longer in use by the state. The Assemblyman informed the Cabinet through officer /u/RobespierreBoi that official documents including directives should use the allegedly-valid replacement flag of Dixie after B.230, referred to as the “blue flag.”

It was also expressed that the state seal was replaced by B.273, allegedly replacing the Dixie seal, referred to as the “shield seal,” with what is referred to as a “blue seal.”

The Dixie red flag has been repeatedly objected to because it has a red pattern in the background. To the Assembly, this red background allegedly has an emotional or historical connection to Dixie’s confederate history, and was replaced by a completely altered blue flag instead.

THE ASSEMBLY CANNOT VALIDLY DEMAND A NEW STATE FLAG BY LEGISLATION AND INTERBRANCH DEMAND BECAUSE DIX. CONST. ART. XVI S. 12 DICTATES THE ACTUAL APPEARANCE, SUPERIOR TO THE LEGISLATURE

Amendment 4 (1966) garnered 80 percent of Southern votes and states in full:

Section 12. Seal of State of [Dixie]; State Flag. The present seal of the state shall remain the seal of the state of [Dixie]. The state flag shall conform with standard commercial sizes and be of the following proportions and description: The seal of the state, of diameter one-half the hoist, in the center of a white ground. Red bars in width one-fifth the hoist extending from each corner toward the center, to the outer rim of the seal. — Emphasis added

The Assembly has ignored the supremacy of constitutional procedure in Art. I and the ballots of our constituents, to express its odd demands on the people and their representatives in all three branches that red bars connecting to a central Dixie seal are representative of a racist historical or emotional pattern in Dixie.

This constitutional design most clearly reflects our existing red flag, and not the radically altered blue flag.

THE ASSEMBLY IGNORES ITS OWN FLAG STATUTE TO CLAIM AN INTEREST IN FLAG REFORM ANTI-DISCRIMINATION

The Assembly repeats time and again that the use of a “foreign” red flag by officials is a painful experience to Dixie constituents, despite the intent of these constituents by a 60 percent margin to keep a flag closest in appearance to the legitimate Dixie flag. The Dixie Government in all three branches has, allegedly, ignored our disposable and treasonous Confederate history.

Yet in D.S. 256.051, the Assembly has already prohibited the use of any Confederate symbology for private sale and advertising; for the defacement of symbols of the State, specifically the State red flag and shield seal; or for the mutilation of symbols of the country, except for decorative symbols.

On one hand, the state has explicitly applied penalties for the use of racist historical symbols on state and federal symbols, or as private means of intimidation. But on the other hand, the Assembly claims that putting a flag on a DDOE directive is “optional” and the Secretary could use any flag, even if nonsense.

If so, the Assembly seems to promote a theory that the use of the Dixie Flag on a document as official as a rail funding program could use the Confederate flag because it is merely decorative and not bound by the Statutes. The Assembly’s demands on the Cabinet are contrary to state law, and as applied, arbitrary and without reason.

THE GOVERNOR DICTATES THE DELEGATED POWER OF DISPLAYING DIXIE SYMBOLS, NOT THE ASSEMBLY

In the mandate and Acts, the Assembly appears to press upon Gov. /u/Blockdenied, Chief Justice /u/reagan0, and officials that it is the Assembly that dictates protocol for the display of the Dixie flag. This is contrary to the Flag Statute Chapter.

The Assembly’s intent over the entirety of Chapter 256 is to grant others the power to display state symbols and penalize those not in compliance. This includes the governor, who “may adopt, repeal, or modify any rule or custom as the Governor deems appropriate which pertains to the display of the state flag.” It explains that each courthouse, of which the State of Dixie maintains one managed by the Chief Justice and Associate Justice /u/FPSlover1, “shall display” state symbols including daily the American flag “when weather permits.” Each election supervisor must display a flag or an acceptable print each Election Day. Two sections explain that cabinet and judicial officers can expand funds from the Treasury to effect the protocols by the Governor.

The Assembly cannot demand of the Governor or Cabinet when and how to display the constitutional symbols of the state, because it has clearly delegated that authority to the Governor with the intent to fund activities across branches and punish those who act contrary to the protocols and laws dictates.

Even if the Assembly by some measure could enforce usage across the government, the government is exempt from such threats in the Exceptions subpart 7 of the chapter.

Assembly liaison /u/MariqKnowsMuch and bill authors /u/jarlfrosty and /u/Tajec misunderstand their authority and are acting on that mistake to enforce compliance on the executive and judiciary improperly.

THE ASSEMBLY UNCONSTITUTIONALLY ALTERED THE STATE SEAL, AND HAS IMPROPERLY IMPLEMENTED CONDITIONS ON ITS USE

As the Dixie Constitution demands that a red background element be affixed around the Dixie seal, similar to the proper Dixie flag, the issue of the state seal becomes important for this discussion. D.S. 15.03 in the Executive Branch Chapter states in part:

The great seal of the state shall be of the size of the American silver dollar, having in the center thereof a view of the sun’s rays over a highland in the distance, a sabal palmetto palm tree, a steamboat on water, and an Indian female scattering flowers in the foreground, encircled by the words “Great Seal of the State of [Dixie]: In God We Trust.”

The statute explains in several clauses that the Cabinet controls the usage of the Seal across the branches, and the Assembly authors then criminally penalize any entity that uses the Dixie seal improperly contrary to the Cabinet directive.

B.273 changes the seal design; creates a new state motto (contrary to the next statute in the chapter), confusingly creates an alternate seal; implement separate seals for all branches; and several seals for some but not all executive offices in the chain of succession, ceasing at the Attorney General.

The Act incorrectly assumes under the subsection “Great Seal” that changing the state seal motto also explicitly changes the state motto of Dixie: in fact, the motto on the Seal and the State Motto are separately defined in two statutes in two separate chapters. This is additionally all contrary to the rulemaking authority of Gov. /u/blockdenied, which implements his Art. II s. 4 powers on when, what, how, why, and the procedures for displaying the seal based on this delegated legislative power based on the constitutional provision that there is one Dixie seal. Now, there are at least two official state seals, three branch seals, and over three executive cabinet seals based on the singular constitutional quantity of “one.”

ISSUE TWO: UNCONSTITUTIONALLY CONSTRUCTED LAWS PASSED

Our constitution is common to that of at least 41 other states in its legal requirement that for constituent clarity, general readability, and to avoid hidden subclauses like the motto change above, the Assembly must pass laws with the simple judicial rule that:

Each bill generally contains one subject (subject rule)

Each bill generally depicts the content of the body in the title

Art. III s. 6, the Assembly’s own rules on itself, states in full:

Every law shall embrace but one subject and matter properly connected therewith, and the subject shall be briefly expressed in the title. No law shall be revised or amended by reference to its title only. Laws to revise or amend shall set out in full the revised or amended act, section, subsection or paragraph of a subsection. The enacting clause of every law shall read: “Be It Enacted by the Legislature of the State of [Dixie]:”.

In the seminal Dixie Court case Brown v. Firestone, 382 So.2d 654 (1980), for instance, this Court stated, "Were we to sanction a rule permitting an appropriations bill to change existing law, the legislature would in many instances be able to logroll, and in every instance the integrity of the legislative process would be compromised."

The effects of logrolling are apparent even in a case on state symbols. A law called the Dixie Seal Act based on the constitutional executive power of one seal creates eight seals, an alternate Dixie seal, and changes in a subpoint another Dixie law altering “In God We Trust,” existent since the mid-19th century, to an ethereal Latin motto affecting all uses from the Seal to the chambers of our courts and secretarial offices and use in public schools in a separate law.

Beyond the aforementioned reasons, the Act should be defeated for its unconstitutional construction according to the Dixie Constitution.

REMEDY

THEREFORE, petitioner a senior Executive offer of the State of Dixie prays for and Order of Declaratory and Permanent Injunctive relief from the unconstitutional legislative Acts aforementioned, and to enjoin further communicated demands and the usage of inappropriately adopted state symbols by the Dixie Assembly.

Respectfully submitted,

Secretary Carib

Dixie Department of the Environment


r/SSSC • • Sep 19 '19

19-29 Petition Granted Request for Judicial Discipline of Attorney General DeepFriedHookers

5 Upvotes

Relevant Facts

Throughout /u/deepfriedhookers's (hereinafter, "DFH") tenure as Attorney General of this state, he has engaged in a persistent course of aggressive, unprofessional conduct designed to intimidate and humiliate his opponents before this court and his political opponents elsewhere.

A. deepfriedhookers v. Cold B. Coffee

Complainant entered an appearance on behalf of defendant Cold B. Coffee above-mentioned matter. Upon Complainant's filing of a motion to dismiss, DFH immediately launched into a vicious personal attack upon Complainant. DFH began by suggesting that Complainant "has shown . . . an extension of the complete disrespect for this Court." DFH further accused Complainant of "perjury" and a "meaningful intention to mislead this Court, lie about plaintiff" and "insult[ ] this institution."

Furthermore, at no point during the process did DFH comply with requirements of service and provided no notice at all to Complainant regarding any of his filings with the Court.

B. In re: Department of Justice Directive 036

During consideration of the petition for writ of certiorari in In re: Department of Justice Directive 036, Case No. 19-26 (Sept. 2019), DFH made innumerable rude and offensive comments regarding counsel for petitioner, such as:

  • baselessly referring to the action as "yet another frivolous case of targeted harassment from Northern aggressors"

  • repeated and unsupported claims that counsel for Petitioner was making "false claims" to the Court

  • referring to counsel for petitioner as a "tourist litigator from the North" and "our tourist frivolous friend"

  • claiming that counsel for petitioner "unquestionably lacks the ability to cast judgment on the State’s objective, a state he only visits to file cases meant to waste time, effort, and harass his political opponents"

  • asserting that "Petitioner’s entire case is built in spite, assumptions, half-understandings of Dixie protocol, and fairytales" and that the action is a "waste of time"

  • claiming without basis that counsel for petitioner was "using this court as his playground for repeated frivolous cases and targeted harassment of his political opponents"

DFH's abuse continued undeterred once the supposedly "frivolous" petition was granted. DFH continued to insist that counsel for petitioner made "blatant and egregiously false claim[s]" to the court--still with no support. Furthermore, DFH yet again suggested that counsel for petitioner had a "flimsy understanding of precedent and a purposeful ignorance of other Department of Justice policies, procedures, or practices."

Legal Analysis

The Rules of this Court provide that "[a]ll appearing before the Court will be held to the highest degree of decorum." Likewise, Bar Rule 4-8.4(d) provides in relevant part that "[a] lawyer shall not engage in connection with the practice of law that is prejudicial to the administration of justice, including to knowingly, or through callous indifference, disparage, humiliate, or discriminate against litigants, jurors, witnesses, court personnel, or other lawyers." Violation of this rule can support the suspension of an attorney's ability to practice law. See, e.g., Florida Bar v. Norkin, No. SC11-1356 (Fl., Oct. 31, 2013) (suspending license of attorney due to rude and unprofessional behavior). Indeed, the Court has repeatedly ruled that unprofessional behavior is unacceptable. See generally Fla. Bar v. Ratiner, 46 So.3d 35 (Fla.2010); Fla. Bar v. Abramson, 3 So.3d 964 (Fla.2009); Fla. Bar v. Martocci, 791 So.2d 1074 (Fla.2001).

For example, in Florida Bar v. Ratiner, No. SC13-539 (Fl., Feb. 22, 2018) the Florida Supreme Court affirmed suspension of an attorney's license in part based on findings that "during the entire trial [the attorney] had been rude, overly aggressive, unprofessional and at times appeared to try to intimidate the witness" and that the attorney's behavior "had been totally disruptive [and] that he was a 'bully.'" In Ratiner, the sanctions imposed resulted from the attorney's conduct during a single legal case; here, Attorney General DeepFriedHookers has engaged in this conduct across every single case in which he has appeared before this Court.

Requested Sanctions

Complainant requests that Respondent be suspended from the practice of law before this Court for a period of sixty days. This sanction is warranted in light of Respondent's pattern of misconduct, multiple offenses, refusal to acknowledge the wrongful nature of his misconduct, and substantial nature of his misconduct. See Norkin, No. SC11-1356 (noting these among aggravating factors in considering severity of sanction).


r/SSSC • • Sep 09 '19

Opinion Ruling on 19-21, Robert Carey v. Dixie Inn

5 Upvotes

The court has issued a Split Decision in case 19-21, Robert Carey v. Dixie Inn. The full ruling can be read here:

https://www.reddit.com/r/SSSC/wiki/19-21

The court thanks all involved for their time, and hopes that such efforts will continue in the future.


r/SSSC • • Sep 10 '18

Petition Granted in re: B001, the Putting Dixie Businesses First Act

5 Upvotes

Your Honors,

At this link, please find a writ of certiorari seeking review of the Constitutionality of B001, aka the Putting Dixie Businesses First Act.

In the event the petition is granted, I also request an extension of argument in the form of a word count limit of 2000 words for the merit briefs stage, as we challenge the law on three different grounds and believe it would be virtually impossible to brief this Court on all three questions with a word count limit of 1500 without leaving out critical information and precedent. Obviously, the extension of the word count limit would apply to my friends on the other side as well. Thank you for your consideration.

Respectfully submitted,

SHOCKULAR, AG, Northeast State

TO: Chief Justice /u/FPSLover1, Associate Justice /u/chaosinsignia

CC: Governor /u/Reagan0, Attorney General /u/deepfriedhookers


r/SSSC • • Jun 21 '17

Petition Accepted Reagan0 v. DisguisedJet719

5 Upvotes

Comes the petitioner, /u/Reagan0. Greetings magistrates of the court. I come before you to submit this petition for writ of certiorari to determine the constitutionality of Directive 002: The Termination of School Vouchers. As signed by the Superintendent of Schools, /u/DisguisedJet719.

Here is a copy of the Executive Order:

As Superintendent of Schools of the State of Dixie, I hereby declare that using taxpayer dollars as a way to pay for attending private schools, otherwise known as school vouchers, shall be immediately terminated. No Dixie state, taxpayer, funding will be given to families of attendees for the purpose of paying a student’s tuition at a private school. This does not effect the funding and scholarships of dependents of an active-duty military member, nor students with mental or physical disabilities. This affects the non-public schooling tuition of approximately 41,200 students, including 31,000 in Florida alone, and will save the state approximately $250 million dollars a year. This money will be used to put back into the public school systems in the state.

It is my belief that this order violates the Constitution as seen in Article II Section 6 Subsection 2 of the Dixie Constitution, which reads:

No Executive Order may have the force of enacting a law; they may only facilitate or implement laws duly enacted by the State Assembly.

We may also find its apparent illegality in Article VI which reads:

All things not covered in this constitution shall be covered in the Florida Constitution.

Using this as a ground upon which to hold the Executive accountable we must look at Section 1 subsection (a) of the Florida Constitution which reads in part:

The supreme executive power shall be vested in a governor, who shall be commander-in-chief of all military forces of the state not in active service of the United States. The governor shall take care that the laws be faithfully executed ....

We may also look to Article IV Section 4 Subsection (a), which reads in part:

There shall be a cabinet composed of an attorney general, a chief financial officer, and a commissioner of agriculture. In addition to the powers and duties specified herein, they shall exercise such powers and perform such duties as may be prescribed by law ....

This constitutional duty to uphold the law would surely then apply to B.065 School Choice Act linked here. You will see its clear mandate for this vouchers.

And so, I ask that the court applies its judicial authority and strike down this order as a violation of the constitution and have the effects be nullified.


r/SSSC • • May 06 '17

Announcement My resignation

5 Upvotes

Gentlemen of this court, I have just been elected to the United States House of Representatives and been tasked with representing Dixie's 4th Congressional. My time here has brought me so close to the law and I wouldn't trade it for the world, but I am needed elsewhere and I am better abled to serve Dixie in DC. I hope we can work together again someday, God Bless.

              -Rep. Dobs (DX-4)

r/SSSC • • Oct 28 '16

18-2 Hearing in Re: Bill 091 Death Penalty Reaffirmation act

5 Upvotes

Pursuant to the Rules of Court, a majority of the bench has voted to extend review on the constitutionality of Bill 091 Death Penalty Reaffirmation Act.

The Court finds that the Plaintiff has filed a complaint upon which relief may be provided.

The Plaintiff alleges that the act in question is a violation of the supremacy clause of the United States Constitution.

The Petition Reads:


To the Honorable and Esteemed Justices of this Court, now comes the petitioner, /u/PM_me_your_Panzer, representing himself, who respectfully submits this petition to review the constitutionality of Southern State B.091, otherwise known as The Death Penalty Reaffirmation Act of 2016, signed into law today by acting Governor /u/CaptainClutchMuch. The petitioner respectfully asks the Honorable Court to find the law unconstitutional and strike it entirely. The law in question reads in pertinent part as follows:

Article 2 All currently scheduled Death Penalties will be carried out as planned in Dixie and prosecutors may seek the Death Penalty in all such cases that are appropriate according to Dixie statutes. The following question has been raised for review by the Court: Whether Section 1. and Section 2. of the above EO State Law are violations of Article VI, Clause 2 of the United States Constitution, otherwise known as the Supremacy Clause, by contradicting and impeding the Constitution of the United States. reddit Signing of Bill 91: Death Penalty Reaffirmation act • /r/ModelSo... I truly believe in states' rights and the process of the Dixie Supreme Court. With the support of the Dixie Assembly, I must sign this into...

Article 2 of B.091 would permit and mandate that the State of Dixie carry out executions of persons who have been tried as criminals and given the death penalty. The 29th Amendment to the United States Constitution states in Section 2 that "All jurisdictions shall be prohibited from enacting and maintaining laws that prescribe the death sentence as a permissible punishment". As Article VI holds the Constitution to be the supreme Law of the Land, the State of Dixie has no legal or constitutional recourse to begin executing persons.

Pursuant to this petition, the Petitioner respectfully and urgently submits a motion and a request for immediate injunctive relief in the form of a temporary restraining order preventing any and all executions pursuit to B.091 (The Death Penalty Reaffirmation Act of 2016). To wit, it is believed that this law will allow executions to occur immediately after enactment (and the meta timeframe issues regarding this require that this injunction be filed now - edited to reflect bill being signed). Petitioner has grave concerns that it will immediately cause the deaths of multiple citizens of the Southern State, a grave and irreparable danger. Therefore, given the potential harm to numerous citizens of this State, and certain nature of the contradiction of this law with the 29th Amendment to the Constitution of the United States, the petitioner urges the court to issue a temporary injunction preventing the implementation of this law. While typical Court rules may require harm to occur, Petitioner argues as follows:

  1. Harm has already occurred in violating the sanctity of the US Constitution. The actions of the legislature and Governor in claiming to be beyond the purview of its reach are an attempt to de-legitimize the Constitution of this nation and violate their respective oaths of office.

  2. To the extent this Court would have Petitioner wait for an unlawful execution to occur, the harm would be so great and irreparable that allowing the law to remain in force is utterly unconscionable. There are Dixie citizens on death row right now. It is foreseeable that under this law they will be executed in violation of clear constitutional directive. There is no justification to wait for a needless death to find that such an execution would be a clear violation of the constitution. To wit, the law directs all executions to proceed as normal.

  3. Further to point 2., the execution of Tommy Arthur is scheduled for one week from today.

Thank you.


The Court shall continue to allow the State of Dixie to submit a motion to dismiss if they believe the petition to be invalid.

Oral arguments are in order at this time from the Plaintiff and the State of Dixie.

The Court shall open up this hearing to all parties with a vested interest in this case. Amicus Briefs are in order at this time.

Please keep all filings before this Court within the Rules of Court.


Additionally this Court is issuing an emergency injunction against the enforcement of Bill 091. This act shall be considered wholly unenforceable. Any and all death sentences against those charged in the State of Dixie shall be stayed until the completion of this trial. It is abundantly clear to this Court that the enforcement of this act could lead to severe and irreparable harm to prisoners which is in direct violation of the most recent amendment to the Constitution of the United States.

It is so ordered.


r/SSSC • • Oct 27 '16

Petition Accepted In re: Executive Order 014

5 Upvotes

Honorable Court, before you comes the petitioner, /u/sviridovt to challenge the constitutionality of Executive Order 014: Additional Security Measures order. Given the urgency of this Executive Order we ask the court to grant a temporary immediate relief until such a time that this matter may be fully heard. Before you today stand the following questions:

  1. Did Governor /u/CaptainClutchMuch violate the 4th Amendment to the United States Constitution by ordering a search of peoples leaving and entering the state without probable cause as defined in Carroll v. United States?

  2. Did Governor /u/CaptainClutchMuch violate the United States Constitution Article IV, Section 2 Clause 1 (henceforth referred to as the 'Privileges and Immunities Clause') by setting up roadblocks with vague standards as to potentially violate law-abiding citizens rights to free travel as defined in Zobel v. Williams (1869)?

  3. Did Governor /u/CaptainClutchMuch violate the United States Constitution 5th Amendment and 14th Amendment by improperly holding them in custody without bringing charges forward?

  4. Did Governor /u/CaptainClutchMuch violate the United States Constitution Article VI, Clause 2 (henceforth referred to as 'supremacy clause') by violating the 4th amendment to the United States Constitution in accordance with points 1-3?

  5. Is Executive Order 014 (henceforth referred to as EO14) written in such a vague matter as to be rendered unconstitutional?


1. Did Governor /u/CaptainClutchMuch violate the 4th Amendment to the United States Constitution by ordering a search of peoples leaving and entering the state without probable cause as defined in Carroll v. United States?

On October 27th, 2016 the Governor of the Southern State /u/CaptainClutchMuch has issued EO14, establishing roadblocks on major entrances into the state. The Executive Order provides broad authority to State Law Enforcement to search any vehicle as part of Section 1 of EO14. We ask the court to find such a provision unconstitutional as decided previously in the Supreme Court Case Carroll v. United States where the court ruled the following:

[i]t would be intolerable and unreasonable if a prohibition agent were authorized to stop every automobile on the chance of finding liquor, and thus subject all persons lawfully using the highways to the inconvenience and indignity of such a search... . [T]hose lawfully within the country, entitled to use the public highways, have a right to free passage without interruption or search unless there is known to a competent official, authorized to search, probable cause for believing that their vehicles are carrying contraband or illegal merchandise.

By stopping and searching every vehicle that is entering the state, without prior probable cause, we believe that this Executive Order stands in direct violation of the United States Constitution, and is ought to be struck down. Because the Order provides no severance clause, the entire order shall be struck down as a result of this violation.


Did Governor /u/CaptainClutchMuch violate the United States Constitution Article IV, Section 2 Clause 1 (henceforth referred to as the 'Privileges and Immunities Clause') by setting up roadblocks with vague standards as to potentially violate law-abiding citizens rights to free travel as defined in Zobel v. Williams (1869)?

The Executive Order forces State Law Enforcement Agencies to set up roadblocks and stop all vehicles coming into the Dixie State. We urge the court to find this order in violation of the Privileges and Immunities Clause of the United States Constitution, as further confirmed in the precedent set by the United States Supreme Court Zobel v. Williams, which states the following:

Article IV's Privileges and Immunities Clause has enjoyed a long association with the rights to travel and migrate interstate. The Clause derives from Art. IV of the Articles of Confederation. The latter expressly recognized a right of "free ingress and regress to and from any other State," in addition to guaranteeing "the free inhabitants of each of these states . . . [the] privileges and immunities of free citizens in the several States." While the Framers of our Constitution omitted the reference to "free ingress and regress," they retained the general guaranty of "privileges and immunities." Charles Pinckney, who drafted the current version of Art. IV, told the Convention that this Article was "formed exactly upon the principles of the 4th article of the present Confederation." Commentators, therefore, have assumed that the Framers omitted the express guaranty merely because it was redundant, not because they wished to excise the right from the Constitution. Early opinions by the Justices of this Court also traced a right to travel or migrate interstate to Art. IV's Privileges and Immunities Clause....Similarly, in Paul v. Virginia, the Court found that one of the "undoubt[ed]" effects of the Clause was to give "the citizens of each State . . . the right of free ingress into other States, and egress from them...."

In the case, the court upheld the precedent set in Paul v. Virginia, ruling that the constitutional right of citizens to freely travel between states shall not be denied. Despite this, the Executive Order has ordered road blocks to be set up controlling entry into the state, subjecting citizens to vehicle searches, and making them subject to arrest based on vague criteria. We urge the court to find this act as an unconstitutional hindrance to the rights of United States Citizens to freely travel between states, and as such find this Executive Order unconstitutional.


Did Governor /u/CaptainClutchMuch violate the United States Constitution 5th Amendment and 14th Amendment by improperly holding them in custody without bringing charges forward?


The Executive Order in question gives broad authority to State Law Enforcement Agencies to arrest and detain any persons which in the officer's judgement posses a danger. In the Executive Order no provision of the law to allow this is mentioned. Here is the relevant excerpt:

Any vehicles that, in the judgement of the officer, may present a threat to the State of Dixie should be held for further processing by the Dixie State Guard.

No laws are provided under which these persons may be charged, as such, the orders allows for an undefined detention of individuals without charging them with any crime, thereby violating both the 5th and the 14th amendment to the United States Constitution, which reads that:

[N]or shall any person . . . be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law

We find that this Executive Order stands in direct violation of these fundamental amendments, and as such ought to be struck down.


Did Governor /u/CaptainClutchMuch violate the United States Constitution Article VI, Clause 2 (henceforth referred to as 'supremacy clause') by violating the 4th amendment to the United States Constitution in accordance with points 1-3?


We ask the court to find this act unconstitutional and in violation of the Supremacy Clause of the United States Constitution should this court find the Executive Order in question to be in violation of any of the previous points brought up before this court.


Is Executive Order 014 (henceforth referred to as EO14) written in such a vague matter as to be rendered unconstitutional?


Honorable Justices, perhaps the biggest violation of the Executive Order in question is the Vagueness of the order. As such, we ask you to rule this Executive Order to be so vague as to be void, thereby executing the Vagueness Doctrine. We believe that because of the vagueness of this Executive Order, it can easily lead to violations of other constitutional rights of citizens and ought to be struck down. The Vagueness Doctrine establishes that definitions of potentially vague terms are to be provided, however, the Executive Order sets up the following criteria which may lead to arrest of citizens:

Any vehicles that, in the judgement of the officer, may present a threat to the State of Dixie should be held for further processing by the Dixie State Guard.

We believe this to be unconstitutional, since no standard is provided for what may present a threat, or what provision of the law the persons ought to be charged with. We believe that this vagueness has the potential to lead to violations involving due process rights, civil rights amongst others and therefore ought to be struck down.



r/SSSC • • Oct 04 '16

18-1 Dismissal of Case 18-1 In re: B.083: Alcohol and Tobacco Tax Outlaw Act

5 Upvotes

Chief Justice dillon1228 joined by Associate Justice Lordfowl,

As the plaintiff has failed to appear for the hearing, this case is dismissed in accordance with Part III § 1 of the Rule of Court. Default judgement is passed. Writ of certiorari is denied and the injunction against enforcement of Bill 083 is lifted.

It is so ordered.


r/SSSC • • Sep 27 '16

18-1 In re: B.083: Alcohol and Tobacco Tax Outlaw Act.

5 Upvotes

Pursuant to the Rules of Court, a majority of the bench has voted to extend review on the constitutionality of In re: B.083: Alcohol and Tobacco Tax Outlaw Act.

The Court finds that the Plaintiff has filed a complaint upon which relief may be provided.

The Plaintiff alleges that Bill 083 is an unconstitutional violation of Article III, Section VI of the Constitution of the State of Florida as Bill 083 does not contain an enactment clause.

The Petition Reads:


Comes now the petitioner /u/Ramicus to petition the Court to find The Alcohol and Tobacco Tax Outlaw Act unconstitutional. I furthermore would like to petition the Court for immediate injunctive relief from the provisions of this legislation until the Court can come to a decision on this case.

The petitioner presents the following question before the Court:

Can legislation with no enacting clause take effect in the State of Dixie?

Although not expressly stated in our Constitution, the necessity of an enacting clause, traditionally written as, “Be it hereby enacted in the State of Dixie assembled,” is both traditional and logical.

Can a bill or resolution passed by the Dixie Assembly with no enacting clause change Dixie state law?

Section 6 of the Florida State Constitution reads as follows:

Every law shall embrace but one subject and matter properly connected therewith, and the subject shall be briefly expressed in the title. No law shall be revised or amended by reference to its title only. Laws to revise or amend shall set out in full the revised or amended act, section, subsection or paragraph of a subsection. The enacting clause of every law shall read: “Be It Enacted by the Legislature of the State of Florida:”.

This is further reinforced by Article VI, Section 2 of the Dixie Constitution, reading as follows:

All things not covered in this constitution shall be covered in the Florida Constitution.

The petitioner further presents the following question before the Court:

Can legislation not specifically referring to Dixie take effect in the State of Dixie?

Although legislation in our nation is frequently passed between states and altered to fit the needs of the respective assemblies, the Alcohol and Tobacco Tax Outlaw Act is notable for having been proposed only in the State of Dixie and not mentioning our state even once. Save its having been proposed and passed by the Dixie Assembly, there is nothing to tell us that this bill, written by a Southern Assemblyman and an Eastern Representative, was intended for our great state.

As the legislation includes no severability clause, it is necessary for it to be struck down in its entirety.


The Court shall continue to allow the State of Dixie to submit a motion to dismiss if they believe the petition to be invalid.

Oral arguments are in order at this time from the Plaintiff and the State of Dixie.

The Court shall open up this hearing to all parties with a vested interest in this case. Amicus Briefs are in order at this time.

Please keep all filings before this Court within the Rules of Court.


In addition, this Court is ordering an injunction against the enforcement of Bill 083. This Court finds that the end of the fiscal year is quickly approaching in less than one weeks time. Enforcement of this potentially unconstitutional law could illegally deprive the State of Dixie of millions of dollars in revenue. As such the State of Dixie MAY continue to collect the taxes made illegal by this act and this injunction shall remain in place until this case has been decided.

It is so ordered.


r/SSSC • • Mar 06 '16

17-1 In re: Executive Order 004 Hearing

5 Upvotes

Pursuant to the Rules of Court, the bench has unanimously voted to extend review. We find that the Plaintiff, /u/theSolomonCaine, has submitted a complaint on which relief may be provided.

The Complaint Reads:

To the Honorable Justices of this Court, the petitioner, /u/theSolomonCaine representing The American Media PAC, respectfully submits this petition for a writ of certiorari to review the constitutionality of Executive Order 004 of the Southern State, known for long title as Executive Order 004 - Establishing the Order of Cavaliers.

The following questions have been raised for review by the Court:

  1. Whether Executive Order 004 violates Article I, Section 10, ¶ 1 of the United States Constitution by granting titles of nobility to members inducted to the Order of the Cavaliers by the Governor of the Southern State. 2. Whether Executive Order 004 violates Article I, Section 10, ¶ 1 of the United States Constitution by establishing an Order of Merit, which may be defined as a dynastic order which draws power from royal patronage, with the prerogative of transferring exclusive titles of nobility.

The order in question can be found here: https://www.reddit.com/r/ModelSouthernState/comments/48ykua/executive_order_4_establishing_the_order_of_the/

The cited article of the constitution states:

No State shall enter into any Treaty, Alliance, or Confederation; grant Letters of Marque and Reprisal; coin Money; emit Bills of Credit; make any Thing but gold and silver Coin a Tender in Payment of Debts; pass any Bill of Attainder, ex post facto Law, or Law impairing the Obligation of Contracts, or grant any Title of Nobility.

This court shall now be open to all those with a vested interest in this case.

Amicus briefs are in order at this time.

Please keep all filings before this Court within the Rules of Court Part III and IV.

J. Dillon1228