r/RomanceBooks • • 17h ago

Community Management Book Request Cooldown is now in effect!

156 Upvotes

In case you missed it

We are trialing a frequency limit for book requests. Book requests will be limited to 3 posts per user per week.

Please do not try to repost under other flairs, these will be removed and persistent attempts may result in a temporary ban.

If you have exceeded that limit, our Simple/Quick Request Post is still up and running as usual, or you can repost next week.

In the meantime, we hope you enjoy the reviews, gushes, discussions, and games, or even consider posting your own! For more information about what we are doing, and why, see this post.

Thank you!


r/RomanceBooks • • 1m ago

Book Request Spicy recs about Santa NSFW

1 Upvotes

I read a book about a FMC and Santa and now I need more.

Not role playing as Santa or a MMC dressed up as Santa. I mean SANTA. đŸŽ…đŸ»đŸŽ…đŸ»đŸŽ…đŸ»

Something cute and smutty. No dark romance. Any trope at all except accidental pregnancy. Novellas preferably but anything is fine.


r/RomanceBooks • • 2h ago

Discussion What are your favourite books?

20 Upvotes

I would love to get to know some more books but I want it verified that they are good😂 So my question to you: What are your favourite books?

No restrictions. Share you top 3 or however many books you love. Be it because you have reread it the most, just because it was that good or maybe your favourite book(s) of the year. I would love to know which books are loved by you!

(This is brought to you by a minor book slump😅)

Edit: I forgot to add mine, lol

Atm I would say my favourites bc of the number of Times I have reread them are
{Wait for it by Mariana Zapata}
{Protecting whats Mine by Lucy Score}
{outlier by Susie Tate}


r/RomanceBooks • • 2h ago

What was that book called...? [WWTBC] Historical Western with Outlaw MMC

4 Upvotes

I read a historical western where Im pretty sure the mmcs name was Sims? Callaghan? I think? And the fmc was an aspiring lawyer and he had a brother that ran off that was supposed to marry her or something? I could be getting 2 books mixed up tbh but im almost certain his name was Sims or something close to it


r/RomanceBooks • • 4h ago

Quick Question Please spoil part of Undone by Peyton Corrine for me

5 Upvotes

Hi all. Literally just started {undone by Peyton Corrine} and I just need to know if Toren becomes friends with Rhys (and the other guys I guess) at all. I want them to so bad and I just need this tiny bit spoiled LOL thanks so much


r/RomanceBooks • • 5h ago

Discussion Which characters are your favorites, and what is it about them that makes you want them to be together?

15 Upvotes

What makes you like the main characters and want them to be together?

If you end up reading this long post and want to give examples of characters from books or book recs, I'd love that.

Sometimes when I pick up a book, they fall too fast and easily into instalove with eachother and I just don't really buy into their romance. I don't even care if they end up together. It's weird because some books a large part of the book is the tension of them getting together, but if they get together too soon I sometimes lose interest. Other books I've read and loved, the entire book is about them being in a relationship and I eat it up. I can only think that maybe the book just wasn't for me. Or the writing wasn't executed as well? But it's just an odd thing I've noticed.

I don't really enjoy the misunderstanding/miscommunication trope, a lot would be solved if they just talked and told each other how they felt. I get why they don't, because it would open themselves up to some severe heartbreak or make them incredibly vulnerable when they're not even certain of the other person's feelings. But I feel like I want their conflict to be bigger than them. Something that couldn't simply be solved by an open conversation.

How does an mmc endear himself to you? Does he have to be a perfect green flag character? Do you ever like to read books when he's turned into a really bad guy? I love an entirely good and wholesome mmc, but I also like it when the mmc experiences a fall from grace. Maybe he wasn't so bad to begin with, but you see and understand why he took the path he did? Or does this only work with a redepmtion arc? But sometimes grovel in redemption arcs feels like too much or not enough.

What makes you like an fmc? what personality traits do you think she has to have? Or what kind of background does she need to have? Do you like it when she's more independent? rebellious? is plucky and has a sense of humor? or she's very kind? or some combination of all of them?


r/RomanceBooks • • 6h ago

Book Request Pregnancy/ or Single Parent: Low Spice

9 Upvotes

I would love to learn about more books that feature a pregnancy or single parent trope with LOW Spice.

2 or 3 on the romance.io scale is preferred ♡

Indie author recommendations are welcome as well.

Some I have recently enjoyed:

{The Off-Limits Rule by Sarah Adams} (& I have already requested the next book from Libby!)

{Ready or Not by Cara Bastone}

{Better than a Duke by Suzanne Enoch}

Thank you! ♡


r/RomanceBooks • • 8h ago

Book Request Dark romance enemies to lovers book where Mmc saves fmc from something that triggers her past trauma.;

7 Upvotes

Hi! I'm looking for a enemies to lovers, dark romance where Mmc hates fmc but saves her from something that's related to past trauma she has, for example saves her from getting raped, and fmc has past trauma (getting raped/almost raped in the past) or saves her from drowning in a pool of water body and fmc has bad memories related to water or drowning, or any other similar situation. So even after getting saved she has like a breakdown of sorts and the Mmc calms her down.

Even if the saves her actively from something aspect isn't there, maybe something triggered her and she had a panic attack/hyperventilated or just fainted and the Mmc takes care of her while she's unconscious.

I still want it to be a proper enemies to lovers, where the Mmc genuinely can't stand the fmc at first, and not just light banter for one chapter.

Bonus points if it's a bully romance or has hate sex!

Thank you!


r/RomanceBooks • • 9h ago

Book Request Marriage of convenience but the MMC keeps pushing off the divorce deadline

55 Upvotes

I want the book to be set during their marriage, preferably if they’ve already been married for a while. I want them to be married for ‘reasons’ (an old relative wants to see one of them married, only they lied about being sick and they’ve been married for years now, bonus points if the mmc makes sure they’re going to the doctor constantly to stay healthy). I’m not looking for serious, believable excuses to stay married, they can be extremely ridiculous, I just want the mmc pulling all the strings possible to stay married to her and make her fall in love.

Bonus points for OM drama, she can be in love with someone else, or he thinks she’s in love with someone else, or just a guy causing drama.

- No cheating of any kind
- no OW drama (the mmc must be fully devoted to the fmc)
- no reverse harem
- no historical romance, looking for contemporary
- dual pov, or only the mmc’s pov, I want to see him pinning
- preferably audiobooks


r/RomanceBooks • • 9h ago

Book Request Favorite authors NOT on Amazon?

31 Upvotes

One of my favorite authors, Skye Kilaen, seems to have cut off sales on Amazon altogether. I'd love to find more authors that have made this tough call and support them. Any recs?


r/RomanceBooks • • 11h ago

Monday Miscellany 📖 Monday Miscellany

16 Upvotes

Hi RomanceBooks, and welcome back to another wonderful week of romance chat!

If you're new here, check out our RomanceBooks 101 guide for a quick intro to our community.

***

Feel free to ask any questions about the subreddit, our rules, or just the general vibes here. If you have any comments or suggestions, this is the place for them! Thinking of a post and want feedback / brainstorming / peanut gallery support to hype you up? Comment it here!

Looking forward to another great week with you all 💛


r/RomanceBooks • • 11h ago

New Releases What New Releases Are You Looking Forward to This Week? 16 Nov 📚

11 Upvotes

Hi r/RomanceBooks - bad news, it's Monday again. Good news - there are new romances being released!

It's hard to capture all the upcoming releases, but here are a few good roundups to browse through and see what's coming up:

What are you most excited about this week?


r/RomanceBooks • • 13h ago

Book Request "Oh no! My best friend is hot!" Platonic friends who are TERRIFIED to realize their best friend is attractive

119 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I'm looking for friends-to-lovers arc, where the leads start off as actual solid, supportive friends, with neither lead secretly pining for the other.

Then, there is some event that makes one of the leads realize that:

  1. their friend is attractive,

  2. they are attracted to them, and

  3. they are terrified of their attraction messing up their friendship.

Basically, I want the lead to be absolutely petrified with fear that if they make a move, they are going to blow up a friendship that is tremendously important to them.

This is kind of the opposite of the guy or girl who has been pining for their best friend their whole lives. I want someone who is suddenly pining, and doesn't know how to handle it. Maybe it's a guy who is freaking out because he has just realized his girl best friend really is not "just one of the guys", or a girl who has just realized she doesn't love her best friend like a sister, actually, and is scared of coming out to her.

I prefer CR, HR and other low-violence genres. Fantasy and PNR are okay if there's not a lot of murdering getting in the way of the kissing.

MF, FF, and MM pairings are all fine, as are nonbinary leads!

My only constraint is that if the rec is for an MF pairing with a bi awakening (i.e., a gay or lesbian lead realizes they are actually bi for their opposite-sex best friend), I would really prefer that the author is queer themselves.


r/RomanceBooks • • 17h ago

Book Request MF romance, where the main characters are stranded on an deserted island?

17 Upvotes

I was wondering if there are any steamy romance books, where the MMC and MFC are stranded on a deserted island together.

Some things I would like in the book:

- MF only please (no harems, reverse harems, ménage or other man or woman drama).

- No alien or monster romance (I’m just not the biggest fan), I would like both characters to be human or human looking most of the time (I’m fine with vampires, werewolves or considering the setting I want mermaid or merman).

- No non-con or dub-con please.

- No enemies-to-lovers, though I’m completely fine if they don’t get along all the time, as they’re in a stressful situation.

Any recommendations you can give me will be greatly appreciated.


r/RomanceBooks • • 18h ago

Fan Art Art of ~Mayhem Manuscripts Season Two: Cryptids Series~ Pt. 2 NSFW

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

r/RomanceBooks • • 18h ago

Book Request Any books with an MC struggling with self-compassion?

20 Upvotes

Hello, are there any books where the MC is working on sef-compassion or experiencing low self-worth?

P.S: I do not like age gap like dad's best friend saw you grow up vibes

It can be fantasy or sci fi as long as its helpful. I love a series to dive into. Bonus if its an audio book because I am working two jobs and I can sneak and keep diving into the book


r/RomanceBooks • • 22h ago

Quick Question Has anyone listened to the audiobook version of the Harrow Faire series by Kathryn Ann Kingsley?

4 Upvotes

I loved this series when I read it a couple of years ago - was wondering if it’s good for a reread via audiobook!

Thanks! â˜ș


r/RomanceBooks • • 1d ago

Gush/Rave 😍 The Dragon Kin Series and The Scarred Earth Saga by G. A. Aiken. Two Sides of the Same World. They're a Treat.

Post image
74 Upvotes

The Dragon Kin Series and it's spinoff/continuation The Scarred Earth Saga take place on opposite sides of the same high fantasy, two sun world.

I've been suggesting these books recently, and decided to just post about them.

Filled with devoted family (found and blood), detailed world building, political intrigue, war, bloody battles, manipulative Gods, adult competent women, lovely devoted romances, and good doses of humor and snark, it's a universe that deserves more attention it the Romantasy-sphere IMHO. Shelly Laurenston (G. A. Aiken is her pseudonym for high fantasy) has been writing immersive universe series with fun snark for 20 years.

Kensington Publishing has re-released the Dragon Kin paperbacks with new covers. The OGs had clinch half-naked warriors (still showing on Audible). No retro editing of the books, which I appreciate.

Dragon Kin is a multigenerational tale of Anwyll the Bloody's human Court at GarbhĂĄn Isle and the dragon shifter Court of Queen Rhiannon at Devenallt Mountain.

{Dragon Kin Series by G.A. Aiken}

First few books,

{Dragon Actually by G.A. Aiken} Book 1

MMC dragon Fearghus the Destroyer, heir to his Queen mother, finds FMC Annwyl the Bloody and her faction in battle against her brother's soldiers. He saves and returns with her to his den, deciding to train her to be a better warrior. Included with this book is the wonderful prequel Chains & Flames novella, Fearghus' parents' story.

{About a Dragon by G. A. Aiken} Book 2

Nolwenn witch Talaith, a sleeper assassin who's being used and blackamiled by the Goddess Arzhela) enters the story. She has a noose around her neck and is about to swing in front of a crowd of mad villagers being egged on by her husband. Briec the Mighty flies in to the rescue.

{What a Dragon Should Know by G. A. Aiken} Book 3

Gwenvael runs into Dagmar Reinholdt The Beast of the North A perfect sunshine MMC/grumpy FMC pairing. Just read the blurb. â˜ș

{The Scarred Earth Saga by G.A. Aiken}

Takes place on the other side of the world from Dragon Kin. Eventually, Anwyll from Dragon Kin crosses the mountains with the dragons and forms an alliance with Queen Keeley in the war against the bitch Beatrix and the demon God Athanagild .

{The Blacksmith Queen by G. A. Aiken} Book 1

A prophesy that a queen will ascend to the throne of the Black Hills brings war once the old king dies. The Amichai Centaur warriors, Red-Eyed Demon Wolves, and others rally to fight in support of Keeley the blacksmith's claim to the throne.

{The Princess Knight by G. A. Aiken}

Keeley's sister, Gemma, was believed by the family to have left home to join a sect of nuns to one of the peaceful gods Instead, she returns as a powerful and feared War Monk to become her sister's champion.

{The Heritic Royal by G. A. Aiken}

Master archer Ainsley has entered the fray in support of her sister Queen Keeley. Their fight is against a forth sister, the ruthless Beatrix, who has ripped apart the kingdom and plunged it into civil war.

{The Farmer Knight by G. A. Aiken} Book 4 will be pubished in 2027.

Currently re-listening to Dragon Kin. I had completely forgotten how nicely spicy đŸŒ¶đŸŒ¶đŸŒ¶đŸŒ¶ it is, including the matriarch dragon Queen and her consort's zesty BDSM power exchange dynamic .

Have you read any of Shelly Laurenston/G. A. Aiken books?

FYI, The Dragon Kin Series is available on KU ATM and Hoopla. Scarred Earth is on Hoopla.

*The term Romantasy was only coined around 2020, and became popular in '23-'24. There are tons of books categorized as paranormal romance that today would be called Romantasy. So, don't pass them up.*

Image is a photoshopped collage of the updated Dragon Kin book covers. Nine books, Dragon Actually, About a Dragon, What a Dragon Should Know, Last Dragon Standing, The Dragon Who Loved Me, How to Drive a Dragon Crazy, Light My Fire, Feel the Burn, Bring the Heat. Three novellas, Dragon on Top, Tale of Two Dragons, Can't Get Enough.


r/RomanceBooks • • 1d ago

Critique The writing in puck yes by Lauren blakely is so bad it’s painful to read

Post image
170 Upvotes

I said it, sorry. I’ve seen people recommend this book and I just don’t get it. Some people say it’s secretly good. I guess it’s still a secret to me.

Maybe I’m judging too hard, because I haven’t even gotten half way yet. But as soon as I opened the book, even the ‘about the book,’ part was hard to read.

I’m not sure if it’s just me, but I feel like her sentences are always too long and lack any rhythm or flow. And reading them just feels like reading ai slop. Like genuine word soup masquerading as a book.

The writing lacks tact, and I find it’s often over descriptive junk jam packed into what should’ve been a simple sentence.

I know it’s a hockey romance but goddamnnn.
I really want to like this book.
Does it get any better?


r/RomanceBooks • • 1d ago

Critique {Merry Flipping Christmas by Holly June Smith} + the perils of an MMC with too many green flags

103 Upvotes

This is a Christmas novella about a recently divorced Mum of two (38) and a younger single Dad (28). The FMCs kids are 10, the MMCs daughter is 12. They match on a dating app, having already met once or twice because he is her kids skateboarding coach.

Conveniently, her kids go to Lapland for a week, so she has plenty of time to have sex with the hot younger man. The premise was fine for a smutty novella, unfortunately the MMC, Hardie, was a bit of a walking green flag - but not in a good way.

Don't get me wrong, I generally love green flag characters. Generally I find it very off-putting when someone doesn't treat their love interest, or other people, with a reasonable level of decency and kindness. However, this guy was a green flag
 and nothing else. Almost everything that came out of his mouth was an affirmation or a comment about how women should be treated.

For example, during their first sexual encounter:

“There’s nothing wrong with you, do you hear me?” Her mouth falls open. “You’re a grown-ass woman who made two brilliant kids. Your body did an incredible thing, and it’s gorgeous. Thank you for sharing it with me. For letting me do this.”

That's a nice sentiment, but it feels so rehearsed and too perfect. He sounds like a motivational poster and it gets a bit old when he talks like that all the time. It felt like the author had googled “what are divorced women insecure about” and then tried to address every single one within a novella.

Obviously her ex is awful, never touched her, made constant comments about how her body was ruined by childbirth and never went down on her. So the MMC seems even more perfect in comparison.

Maybe I'm not the target audience for this book, as I'm not a divorced single parent. But I don't usually believe that books should only be for people who can see themselves in the characters.


r/RomanceBooks • • 1d ago

Discussion I canceled my Kindle+ membership, and now I'm slowly dying from withdrawal

536 Upvotes

Y'all. I did nothing but read romance every single day for a year. Then I started thinking about how many unread non-romances I have on my actual bookshelves, and decided it was time to get back to some other reading.

I canceled Kindle+ about two weeks ago, and I don't know how much longer I can take it before I cave. I love reading other genres, and I'm enjoying what I'm reading, but I miss knocking out a kindle book every day or two. I miss aliens. I miss gay dudes longing for each other. I miss gay dudes and aliens longing for each other.

Okay, let's say I finish three books from my physical bookshelf, and then I can have my K+ back. That's reasonable, right?

Edit: I have a library card, people! The problem isn't access to books, it's that when I have access to romance on an e-reader, I read that compulsively instead of getting to all the other books I want to enjoy. Sometimes a girl's got to make space for other things in life.


r/RomanceBooks • • 1d ago

Discussion Times when the author got TOO specific with a description and it fully took you out

104 Upvotes

In The Fall Risk by Abby Jimenez:

“He looked like a brown-eyed Brandon Sklenar. Tan, tall. Strong. But funny and self-deprecating.“

Well now I have to Google that name and then I see it’s the evil husband from The Housemaid who is sadly not attractive to me but more importantly, all I can see is his raging, bloody, toothless face from the end of the movie which does not go well with a cute romance novel. Also the “but funny and self-deprecating” line just made the whole description feel so lazy! Boooo


r/RomanceBooks • • 1d ago

Gush/Rave 😍 Appreciation post for the humor and flaws shown in Jennifer Crusie’s sex scenes NSFW

133 Upvotes

Jennifer Crusie is the author that never missed for me, with most of hers still on my reread shelf. That she stopped writing standalone novels is a tragedy of epic proportions in my mind, but I have her past written books for comfort. I’ve tried a couple of her co-written books, but they don’t hit the same for me. I think because the sex is more glossed over, and it was a part of her writing I loved most.

I thought I’d post an exploration of my top books with some quotes of the dialogue or inner thoughts around the sex scenes that just make me appreciate how real she is while still being funny.

{Bet Me by Jennifer Crusie} – There’s only one sex scene in this one because the FMC has been fat-shamed her whole life and really has to trust someone before being that vulnerable with them. There’s a bet (or is there a bet) that the MMC supposedly makes with her ex about having sex with her in a month, and it leads to all sorts of antics because both MCs are so drawn to each other but fighting it. Cal is one of my favorite MMCs, and despite how the plot sounds, he is not a jerk.

“There’s something else I have to tell you. The thing is, I’m going to spread. Hips, thighs—”

“Not until nine-thirty.”

“—waist. What? Nine-thirty? Not till my forties, probably, I think I can fight it off that long, but then—”

“What?”

“I’m going to get fat. Er. I’m going to get fatter. What did you think I meant?”

“For future reference, if you’re sitting half naked on my lap and you tell me you’re going to spread—”

{Crazy For You by Jennifer Crusie} – This one is best friends to lovers but with the twist that her best friend is her older sister’s ex-husband. All the FMC wants is to adopt a dog, but her life unravels because of it, but really it’s just becoming the life she’s always wanted. She breaks up with her “nice guy” boyfriend who spirals into an abusive stalker, and her best friend is there to help her, just like she’s always been there for him. They’ve loved each other forever, but neither thought it was sexual, and I enjoyed how real the FMC’s thoughts were when wrapping her head around having sex with her best friend.

Inner Dialogue Examples

*Oh, hell, we’re naked.* *Wait, this is Nick.* *Is this something I’ll regret?*

*I think I’m off a beat, if he’d slow down, I could catch up, it’s sort of a rumba.*

“I’m going to go now, but I have to tell you, your finish needs work.”

“Hey, you came.”

“I was being polite.”

“You remember coming your brains out even while you fought it, which for the life of me, I still don’t get. The next time we do it, you cooperate.”

{Faking It by Jennifer Crusie} – This was actually my first read of hers, and the first ever where the sex between the main couple was really bad at first. It’s a trust thing for the FMC, and they had just met. She has so many secrets that she has to keep control at all times or everything will unravel, so losing herself in sex is a no go. They don’t figure things out until she trusts him completely. The zany side characters are amazing in this book.

Again, the inner dialogue is so real.

*You don’t want me to hold my thought. You want me to hold the one you’re having.*

*If I say no, he’ll stop, and then we’ll have to talk about it, and that’ll be terrible.*

*It didn’t hurt—there’s a recommendation for you, it didn’t hurt.*

Pippy Shannon sang “I Pretend” on the jukebox. *Our song.*

“So what was that? A fake or a forgery?”

“Hey.”

“You’re a terrible actress.”

“Your foreplay was okay. You’re afterplay sucks.”

“Sorry.”

“Well, gee, I can’t thank you enough. What a good time.”

“Good night. I’ll see you in the morning,” and then he turned back and said, “Look, don’t fake. It’s lousy for everybody.”

“You sounded like you were having a pretty good time.”

{Welcome to Temptation by Jennifer Crusie} – Small town antics when the FMC and her sister decide to record a female-gazed porno. Their father was a deadbeat grifter and the FMC had to pretty much raise her siblings and is burnt out. The MMC is the town mayor but doesn’t want to be. It has a really great discussion between the women about terrible first times. The romance isn’t my favorite of hers because the MMC is a jerk sometimes, but he also says some great things around sexy times and it has some of the best quotes.

“Depends on the version of real life you’re using.”

“Well, in my version, you have to be careful all the time and you get nothing for free. Especially orgasms.”

“Then you need another version. Come here and let me give you an orgasm you don’t have to work for.”

“You want sensitive and understanding, stick with the therapist. You want great, headbanging sex, get off the fucking phone and come with me.”

“Remind me never to get involved with you.”

“So you’re not getting involved?”

“No, I’m just going to have cheap sex with you and then run like hell.”

“Chicken.”

“You bet.”

“You’re not even close, are you?”

“What?”

“Hi, I’m Phin Tucker, and I’m inside you. I know how these things slip your mind.”

“I’m sorry. Maybe we should just call it a night.”

“Maybe we should give it another shot.”

After he realizes she has a discovery fantasy and throws something against the wall to bring attention to them so she gets off.

“I don’t believe you did that!”

“I don’t believe you’re not grateful.”

“Grateful?”

“Did you come?”

“Yes.”

“Did you like it?”

“Yes.”

“Say, ‘Thank you, Phin.’”

“Oh, please.”

“Say, ‘Thank you very much, Phin.’”

“I don’t think so.”

“Say, ‘You are a great lover, Phin.’”

“I’m out of here.”

He felt good, solid against her back, and she had to concentrate to remember she was annoyed with him for making her come.

*That couldn’t be right.*

She has more books I enjoyed, but those are my top ones.

If there are other authors who tackle sex with a similar zany humor combined with the reality of things not always working but them eventually getting it right, I can't think of them.

Business or Pleasure by Rachel Lynn Solomon is the closest I can think of, and I really enjoyed it, but it’s not the same level of humor.


r/RomanceBooks • • 1d ago

Gush/Rave 😍 Dig Two Graves by K.A. Merikan - Emotionally packed gritty western M/M duology

30 Upvotes

I read the {Dig Two Graves by K.A. Merikan} series at the beginning of the year and I still think about it. I've already gushed about it in the r/MM_romancebooks and in the r/HistoricalRomance reddits and I thought I would use the no request day to gush about it here and now.

This is a M/M Western (1880-1887) with morally gray characters and a strong “touch them and die
 for real” energy. There are lots of classic western action scenes with horses, trains, robbery and so on but it is an angsty, violent, grim and gritty story.

The first book, {The Man Who Loved Cole Flores by K.A. Merikan}, is told from Ned’s POV. His family was destroyed by some gang members 10 years ago. Now, Ned has the opportunity to infiltrate that gang and bring them to justice. This mission doesn’t take into account Cole Flores, a man Ned is drawn to without realising why.

This book was equally beautiful, with Ned and Cole forming a strong friendship that evolves into something more, and equally brutal. The Western Frontier and gang life is full of violence, death, judgement and immoral/despicable characters. Let’s not forget the betrayal that was bound to happen and the devastation it would bring on their relationship.

The second book of the duology {The Man Who Hated Ned O’Leary by K.A. Merikan} takes place 7 years later and is told from Cole's POV. It is slightly less gritty and violent. The themes of the book are more about forgiveness, letting go of the past, second chance and healing in general. There were some very emotional moments, some great care taking scenes.

If you are good with numerous trigger warnings (murder, violence, mention of rape, mention of cannibalism, alcoholism, past child abuse, homophobia), I highly recommend this duology.

Gay awakening, secret relationship, Western, angst, second chance, touch them and die.


r/RomanceBooks • • 1d ago

Gush/Rave 😍 Protective MMCs: A ranking

121 Upvotes

I'm down bad for a protective MMC.

I will admit I have a specific type: physically imposing, confident MMCs who treat the opportunity to stand up for FMC as a privilege. They're not controlling or excessively violent; they just want FMC to feel safe and do whatever she wants.

It's the MMC who says, "wear whatever you want. I can fight."

Here is my ranking. I welcome corrections and nominations, so that I can do more "research" and collect more medalists:

đŸ„‡Gold Medal (2 way tie)đŸ„‡

{Blue Eyed Devil by Lisa Kleypas} Hardy Cates

Hardy is the man. When he first encounters Haven (FMC)'s abusive ex, even without knowing the backstory, he can instantly tell FMC is uncomfortable. It's a beautiful moment of a strong, protective, brilliantly assessing MMC who subtly asserts his dominance over weak assholes. Here's FMC's perspective of the two meeting:

I felt a strange mixture of emotions . . . a knee-jerk uneasiness at the sight of Nick’s anger . . . a twinge of annoyance at Hardy . . . but mostly a sense of triumph, knowing that no matter how badly Nick wanted to punish me, he couldn’t. And although I had never especially liked the fact that Hardy was so physically imposing, I relished it at that moment.

Because there was only one thing a bully like Nick respected, and that was a bigger bully.

{After Hours by Cara McKenna} Kelly Robak

Kelly is confidence personified. At first glance, you'd dismiss him as an outright misogynist. He's got four rules for how a real man treats a woman: he can fix her car, make her a steak, kick the ass of anyone who makes her cry, and fucks her good. But through the book, you realize he just wants FMC to be taken care of - he's happy to submit to her, but no one else. When he runs into the man who gave FMC a black eye, he's positively giddy to be able to show FMC he can look after her.

“That’s him, huh?” Kelly didn’t look up from his chore, just hoisted my car another inch with each crank on the jack’s lever. When I didn’t answer, he jerked his chin up and stared me dead in the face. “That’s him? The one who gave you a black eye?”

đŸ„ˆSilver Medalist đŸ„ˆ

{Rock Hard by Nalini Singh} - Gabriel Bishop

Gabriel has a single objective: to get the FMC, Charlotte, to feel comfortable around him. He's a massive ex-rugby player, and he's more than a little bit aggressive. She's nervous. He treats her like she's his doctoral thesis - he studies everything she likes, everything that scares her, all to make her comfortable.

And when it becomes clear that there is a man who might hurt FMC, a man from her past, Gabriel is practically chomping at the bit to get to him.

He gets silver because he's a little too eager. He has no chill when it comes to Charlotte, and it borders on a touch controlling at times. That said, he loves when she pushes back. In fact, I think he kind of gets off on it.

His beatdown of her ex-torturer is *chef's kiss*:

The next thing she heard was a roar of sound, and then Richard was flying back to slam into the wall, his nose crooked and gushing blood. Gabriel’s second punch took him to the floor, the knife in Richard’s hand dropping soundlessly to the carpet.

đŸ„‰Bronze MedalistđŸ„‰

{Bride by Ali Hazelwood} Lowe Moreland

A slightly controversial choice, maybe, but he fits my arbitrary rules description to a T. Lowe is the personification of "quiet competence." Like a bodyguard, he's constantly looking out for FMC in ways so subtle, she doesn't even quite catch onto them. It might be a little too subtle at times, which is why he's at 3rd place, but they are no less impactful once you realize what he's doing.

From the day they're married, he's looking out for her. There isn't one moment exactly that sticks out to me, but more so a series of small ones. Big moments, like stopping assassins out to get her with his bare hands, and little ones, like ensuring her bodyguards know they're there to protect her, not restrict her. Here's a snippet:

...he’s making it abundantly clear: his hand lingers possessively on the curve of my lower back, and I know enough about self-defense to understand that he positioned himself strategically, and that he plans to shove me behind himself at the slightest sign of intimidation. There’s no way Emery’s guards—all eight of them, evenly split between wolf and Human form—cannot see that. Judging from their tense expressions, they seem to believe that Lowe offers a considerable threat, even this starkly outnumbered.

Honorable Mentions:

  • {Hello Stranger by Lisa Kleypas} Ethan Ransom is a gem. Frankly, about 80% of Lisa Kleypas' MMCs could be on this list, but I had to get a little choosy. But my god he's a perfect protector - confident, smooth, shows up just when FMC needs him but not a minute before, since she's capable and strong and he wants her to live her life.

  • {After the Shut Up Ring by Cate Wells} there's a beautiful little monologue from MMC's POV about how he wants her to stay "soft" - it's his job to make sure she's able to be sensitive and vulnerable and deal with all the hard stuff so that she can remain an idealist. His tough-guy beatdown of her angry/asshole ex is a work of art.

  • {Fangirl Down by Tessa Bailey} I love Tessa Bailey's MMCs. Rarely does she create a plot "villain" in her books: the protection from harm is more imagined than real. But oh, man, Wells Whitaker has no limit when it comes to the FMC. He would pretty much do anything, including to fistfight Type 1 Diabetes for her, if he could. He's deeply invested in letting FMC do whatever the fuck she wants, as long as he gets to be next to her and fight any battle for her.

  • {Nickel's Story by Cate Wells} OK, Nickel fits maybe 40% of the definition I gave above, because, like Gabriel Bishop, he has NO chill when it comes to Story. He's her rabid dog; he's not calm or controlled, but he's the furthest thing from controlling.

Anyway. I welcome disagreements and appeals, especially if you come with receipts.