r/RomanceBooks • • 27d ago Bravo

Critique Down with Downvotes on Art Posts!

0 Upvotes

This is a critique of some very off-putting downvoting I've seen.

Don't downvote a fanart post. Someone is sharing their art with the sub because they enjoy making or sharing art for a favorite book or couple. It's great to see what people create.

This is a reader-focused sub. Some readers enjoy making art - drawings, needlepoint, stickers, pins, whatever. And they share art of books and couples here for the rest of us to also enjoy.

This is not an art-focused sub. If they were looking for feedback on their art, they'd post in an art-focused sub. They are not. Nobody needs to provide a downvote as feedback.

If you don't enjoy the art, you can scroll right past or click the three dots -> hide post. It takes the same level of effort as a downvote.

This isn't "toxic positivity" or whatever argument someone is going to try to make. This is "don't be an ass for no reason." There's no reason to downvote someone's art.


r/RomanceBooks • • Jan 27 '24

Discussion Why do people downvote posts?

11 Upvotes

I just posted this looking for book requests also TW of the post mentions of rape and sexual assault in the title of post

https://www.reddit.com/r/RomanceBooks/s/iqIvVbiTnF

And it’s actually pretty disheartening that 50% of people have downvoted my post. If this isn’t the type of trope or whatever you’re interested in then skip it. Downvoting just hurts these type of posts especially book request post to get less visibility. This kind of judgement just perpetuates the stigma of romance book readers.

Edit: I think there are a lot of reasons folks downvote posts that are against this community’s guidelines. My intention to post this was to raise the visibility on the impact downvoting has on posts/comments just because you disagree with something. It’s not a dislike function like social media but meant to be used if something goes against community guidelines or offensive. Another Redditor helped me realize that the mention of rape/sexual assault in the title can actually be quite triggering. That was definitely not my intention but I agree would be a legitimate reason to downvote. So thank you for helping me realize that.


r/RomanceBooks • • Feb 28 '24

Discussion Is "clean" romance books not welcome here?

0 Upvotes

Just saw a post about an author saying she'll be doing "clean" romances from now on and many comments seemed to be mocking her for that decision.

If this subreddit is strictly just for "spicy" books then?

Are books where no sexual explicit scenes not welcomed?

Don't get me wrong, I love "spicy" books.

But someone doesn't want to read "spicy" books all time or even write it, then they should be allow to without judgment, correct?


r/RomanceBooks • • Feb 03 '26

Book Request MMC gets turned on by the thought of watching fat FMC eat. NSFW

8 Upvotes

I know by now not to get too shy with things I’m interested in with this sub. But still, sometimes I have to fight through the initial “should I ask this” squeamishness. This is something I’ve always been waiting to encounter in a book and I never have so hopefully some kind soul can help. Do you guys know of any books where the FMC is insecure about her weight and so she refuses to eat anything (and I mean anything, not even small meals) in front of the MMC for fear of appearing gluttonous? The MMC notices this and gets extremely angry that she refuses to relax with him and translates that to feeling like she doesn’t trust him. What I really want is for him to be turned on by the thought of watching her eat a hearty meal with him, like a burger and fries or a pizza. He vividly fantasizes about watching her mouth and throat and loves the idea of her being satisfied by this food.

✅Bonus if he gets so hot thinking about it, he has to self soothe 😉.

✅Extra Bonus if he catches her eating with a male friend/OM and gets seething jealous.


r/RomanceBooks • • Jun 23 '25

Book Request Single dad MMC chooses the FMC over his daughter

0 Upvotes

Okay, hear me out.

I know this makes me sound like a total bitch, but I just re-read {Best of Me by Maya Alden} and I kept wanting the MMC to choose the FMC over his bratty daughter.

WHY OH WHY DID I RE-READ THIS, IT JUST PISSED ME OFF

I want a SINGLE DAD MMC who prioritizes the FMC over their own child. The child/teen doesn't have to be bratty towards the FMC, but I guess it makes it more palatable if they are.

Angst is welcome, even preferred. Maya Alden hits all the right spots for me, angst-wise. But she never gives me a satisfying redemption/grovel.

All tropes/genres are fine with me but not RH.

Thank you in advance! (And I hope you don't judge me hehe)


r/RomanceBooks • • Mar 25 '26

Discussion HEA in Romance Books: Do you expect one?

0 Upvotes

How do you feel about the rare occasion in books listed as a "romance book", and you're gobsmacked when the FMC or MMC dies?

Update/Edit: My understanding has always been that romance books have an HEA, which is why I am confused when there are books marketed as romances that clearly don't have an HEA. Example: {Under Your Scars by Ariel N. Anderson} is a romance, but the description of the book has the warning: "This book does not have an HEA."

*Major book spoiler ahead:**I generally go for Jade West's books expecting intense spice, and in some cases outright depravity. I went into {Hello Stranger by Jade West}, marketed as contemporary romance, with this expectation. Instead, it was heartache heaped upon a plate of tragedy. I found no hint that this was to be expected in the book summary. I am not a big crier in books, but this one made me feel sickeningly sad. At the very end, you learn the MMC has been hiding a terminal illness. I hoped beyond hope that in the epilogue you learn that he fought the cancer, and lives a long life. Nope. He and the FMC have a few years together and then he dies. EDIT: Please note, that this book was well written. Great character development, just not an HEA, and thus not a romance IMHO.


r/RomanceBooks • • Oct 18 '25

Other Romance.io steam 🔥 ratings on Goodreads

0 Upvotes

TLDR: I created a userscript to get romance.io steam ratings on goodreads directly.

Hi all,

While trying to search for details about romance books I found that I had to always visit both goodreads.com as well as romance.io The former to read/post reviews/ratings and the latter to check for steam ratings.

Romance.io itself is a great website and I wish it had all the ratings/reviews there in goodreads so that I wouldnt have to visit both the sites for each and every book but 🤷‍♀️

I got tired of essentially searching the same book in two different places so I created a script which would run on goodreads and display the steam rating directly there, if, the said book exists on romance.io.

The script grabs the book title and author from goodreads book page, searches it on romance.io in the background and then parses the steam rating which it displays back on the Goodreads page.

If you're lazy like me and would like to try out the script, the steps are explained in here. You can try it on incognito mode, or a non-logged-in goodreads book page, if you're (rightfully) wary of running random scripts off the internet.

If you do end up trying, let me know your feedback/comments/critique.

EDIT: Updated the script to now include a link to the romance.io book url.


r/RomanceBooks • • Sep 03 '26

Critique Tired of "because I'm a woman"

0 Upvotes

As a woman with a job in a "traditional man's club job" I totally get what that can be like, like with less pay compared to what male counter parts make and fighting for what your worth, BUT I have also found a lot of success being a "woman" in a male's world with most people not even viewing me as a gender but just another human who rocks at her job.

I bring this up because I feel like there have been one too many books recently I've read where it instantly goes to the FMC being like "ohhh it's so hard to be a female in a man's working world" or "oh they hate me and are against me cause I'm a female" along with some really sexist men to drive the point home and only the MMC treats her right and I just feel like this is getting to be an easy/lazy writer workaround for conflict for the book. I get that this really does happen to women (and it totally shouldn't!) And it's not that I don't want light brought to the problem, but I just don't see it as realistic and an easy copout. Like can't the FMC face any other conflict or problems in her life other than having a vagina in a "man's world"

I don't know maybe I'm lucky I have great bosses and coworkers where this isn't really the case, but I just get tired of reading the same issues and same ways they overcome. Like, come on, women are complex, we have more issues and problems than just that fact that we are female that could be covered for conflict for a romance book.

Let me know if I'm going crazy here and maybe it's just the recent run of books I've read. Let me know if anyone else has noticed this pattern as well.

Edit mass reply:
Thank y'all for everyone who commented. For anyone still going through sexism at work I am so sorry and it is not right at all. I realized I am blessed to be in a field I am working for a company that does not seem to have as obvious issues. I also agree with it being a systemic issue and perhaps that's part of my issue with the "trope" when it comes across as more an individual issue that is nicely solved by books end. I'll take y'all's advice and put off some of the work place romance books and switch to something else on my tbr list till I get that itch again. Y'all are the best community and to anyone facing sexism irl all i can say is --- kick their ass and show them who the real boss is!!


r/RomanceBooks • • Apr 24 '25

Discussion Slap Shot / Chelsea Curto - yeah, cooking 3 meals a day is exhausting ??

0 Upvotes

I'm about 25 % in and if I have to read one more time about how exhausting and busy life is as a live in professional cook to a single athlete and being a single mother I will DNF.

Despite the nicely edited and smooth writing, engaging premise and slow burn.

I mean seriously ? During the holidays I cook 3 meals a day and work full time and do the shopp and wash for a family of 5 and come on, all she's doing is the cooking and after school parenting ??

And the MMC is a professional hockey player with 14h days and he talks about how much she works and how she never has time for herself or to unwind? Or what about the scene where's she exhausted because she had to stay up late working on the meal plan?

I don't know if the author is a rich single and kid less but waaaay out of touch... to the point that it's grating to read.


r/RomanceBooks • • Feb 10 '23

Discussion The saying is “another THINK coming”…..grrr.

11 Upvotes

Does this bother anyone else? So many authors say “If they think that, then they have another THING coming”.

I actually find myself getting pulled out of the story every time now, even when it’s correct, because it has become such a annoyance to me!


r/RomanceBooks • • Mar 30 '25

Banter/Fun petition to stop making romance books over 400 pages

314 Upvotes

so many are like 500 pages now 😭 lucy score’s new book is beautiful but she writes such long books lmao.

(I’m talking about contemporary romance btw)


r/RomanceBooks • • Mar 15 '26

Banter/Fun Books vs Mini Series adaptation and I think I am a little slow…..talking Julia Quinn and the Bridgertons possible spoiler Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I read Julia Quinn books quite some time ago, and have just recently watched the Netflix series. The last season had me flummoxed a bit because the history of Francesca did not feel exactly right. I remember it being one of my favourite of all of the Bridgertons, but something was different. I went down to the basement to see if I could find the book (alas it was not still in my collection) and yesterday I broke down and bought it on Apple Books.

I read the book, and was still so confused. Where was Michael Stirling? Part of the magic of this particular book is the friendship between Michael and Francesca. How are they going to dub him in, with their history. What about Francesca’s driving desire to have a child of her own?

Suddenly, POSSIBLE SPOILER, something occurred to me. My iPad never lets me blank out a comment so only read on if you don’t mind seeing a spoiler…

Dearest Reader, is it possible that the producer is going to really shake up the storyline and the part of Michael sterling will be shocking to us, as they are already in The storyline? Michael Sterling in the book was the cousin of John…..but in the series…. It’s not a man who plays the cousin…..

Is this obvious to everyone and I am just slow on the uptake? Or am I completely off base?


r/RomanceBooks • • Oct 30 '25

Critique Frustrated with romance

0 Upvotes

I apologize in advance but I need to rant. And I gotta do it here cause I have no one IRL I can talk about this with, but…When did romance books become like reading porn??? Seriously makes me wanna cry because reading is the only thing I enjoy, and romance is my absolute favorite genre, but I am SICK of pages and pages and whole chapters of the same repetitive sex in minute detail!!! I’m so burned out on it and I’m resenting the fact that it’s taking the enjoyment out of reading romance for me. It doesn’t add anything to the story just cheapens the romance for me.💔

I got nothing against porn and enjoy it occasionally; but it has taken over my books now too??? Why are authors doing this?? Most of the books recommended on here (by myself included) are at least ‘explicit open door’ on romance.io which really means the story will revolve around sex, whole chapters of it. Pages and pages. It never ends even after orgasm. It starts all over again and we gotta be there for every minute detail, every single time. Which is every other chapter. FML! 😫

I’m too OCD to skip the sex scenes cause I fear I’ll miss something important. Some of my favorite tropes are the worst offenders; reverse age gap, reverse-harem, mafia…authors treat them like sexual fetishes…and that’s not romantic to me, but I got no choice but to wade through the oceans of sex to get a bit of love. Too much like real life right now.

The overabundance and frequency, and length of sex scenes in books are starting to feel like those commercials that you can’t skip, on YouTube, only longer and more frequent. I don’t even get turned on anymore. Not that that was ever my goal when I pick up a book, but I guess that’s the authors’ goal…and it’s backfiring.

Trying to limit myself to open door only ratings will restrict my options to a pitiful selection. Why can’t we just have like, one sex scene, like the first time they do it or something and then the rest could be fade to black? Or when it’s actually important to the plot? That would be glorious! Why must it take over the story once the couple becomes physical? Do I have to restrict myself to “Christian” romance only? I’d rather stop reading romance altogether and that will break my heart.

I’m not even gonna start on about the insta-lust problem in romance right now cause this post is already way too long and I’m just making myself angrier. lol

Thanks for letting me rave. And I’d like to make it clear that I’m in no way judging others’ taste in books. I understand and acknowledge that my taste and opinions are unique to me only and I respect all readers and their choices. So this is no judgement on what others enjoy. I just wish I didn’t feel alienated by romance authors nowadays. 😞

Edit: Wow! It’s been a couple weeks I think since I posted this, and I feel like an infamous celebrity. My most popular post yet! And no I’m not trolling when I say it’s harder and harder to find romance books without an overabundance of smut. Especially when you read as much as I do.

First off, I’d like to thank the peeps that offered constructive, non-judgmental advice for my dilemma. Good to know I’m not alone, even though we usually stay quiet.

To the others, there is too much I could say but I don’t have the time. As someone who reads an average of 4 (mostly some subgenre of romance) books a week, for a large chunk of my life, I’m too busy looking for good books, to care about defending myself. And if you can’t see what else besides sex could be in an age gap or poly relationship, and that I’m looking for in my books, it’s a moot point anyway.


r/RomanceBooks • • Oct 27 '24

Critique I read Cruel Prince - Holly Black Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I hated The Cruel Prince. Everything, from the writing style to the characters and the way places were described geographically, just didn’t work for me. I wish I hadn’t wasted my time reading it, and I even skipped many pages. After reading Throne of Glass, Blood and Ash, and many others like them, The Cruel Prince feels like a poorly written Wattpad story.

Also, does Cardan ever tell her he loves her? Did I skip over it, or is it because he can’t lie and never really loved her?

If you’re trying to decide whether or not to read it, I’ll save you the trouble—don’t bother.


r/RomanceBooks • • Aug 13 '24

Discussion Blurb is not enough - I need tropes

5 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

So I noticed, that I find it hard to decide whether to read a book or not only by reading the blurb. I always have to look up what tropes are in the book, most of the time I use romance.io. Even if I go into a book store and I find some interesting books, I need to know what tropes there are. So I was wondering if you guys feel the same?


r/RomanceBooks • • Sep 12 '25

Book Request Books where the MMC gives the trans FMC/NBMC a blowjob and she/they asks him to get her/them pregnant while they’re having anal sex. NSFW

2 Upvotes

Looking for books with a trans MC who’s either early in the process or knows bottom surgery isn’t a want or necessity for them. Bonus if it’s his first time with a penis other than his own, and/or he is a caretaker after top surgery.


r/RomanceBooks • • May 12 '24

Quick Question Why was Goodreads bot replaced my romance.io bot?

6 Upvotes

I think GR bot is better because one can read the reviews as well as see the stars. One cannot do that in latter.


r/RomanceBooks • • Aug 23 '24

Discussion What’s with hyper-specific book requests?

0 Upvotes

I saw a post on r/fantasy wondering why book requests these days are so specific and realized I see the same trend in romance communities? For example, “I want enemies to lovers historical but the MMC MUST be aggressive and the FMC MUST be submissive but both of them should be titled and also they should have sex on a horse at some point”

Do people actually like being surprised by their romances? Why are book requests so specific these days?


r/RomanceBooks • • Feb 21 '26

Discussion “it’s not a slow burn if it’s a standalone”: agree or disagree

2 Upvotes

I personally disagree but I can see where the opposite standpoint is coming from.


r/RomanceBooks • • Sep 04 '25

Book Request Seeking romance books with cannibalism.

18 Upvotes

Kind of just what it says on the tin.

Fall is coming, and I yearn for books with cannibalism. Intentional cannibalism preferably, but I'll take what I can get (yes I've read Butcher & Blackbird, no this does not satiate my yearning). I'm not typically a super dark romance girlie, but I know anything with cannibalism is going to probably skew that way.

I've also looked at some stuff with vore, and while that's not exactly what I'm looking for, I'll accept that as well I suppose.

Edit: give me cannibalism as a metaphor for all consuming desire and intimacy. But also, cannibalism in a horror sense. Either is fine.


r/RomanceBooks • • Jun 09 '26

Discussion Silly question: why the hate for reverse harem?

0 Upvotes

Obviously I get it not being everyone's cup of tea!! I'm asking more like.... why does it get treated as a tabboo trope? Compared to other common tabboos (age gap, noncon, incest) it's like, not..... actually bad? lol.

Maybe I know too many polyamorous people irl o get it, lol.


r/RomanceBooks • • Sep 22 '25

Critique Age-Gap Romance and 18-Year-Old FMCs

108 Upvotes

Guys! What issue do authors have with 18-year-old heroines in age-gap relationships? Do we change completely the moment we turn 18? We don't become more mature the second we turn 18.

I've noticed that authors like to add drama, traumatic events to the backstory of FMCs to make them seem more mature than their peers. As a woman who has been through those ages and unfortunately dated older men, it makes me uncomfortable knowing that books like this exist and promote that.

Essentially, a 17-year-old and an 18-year-old are the same. Why is it okay for an 18-year-old (A TEENAGER) to be in a relationship with someone in their thirties or forties? I know it adds to the taboo category, but this kind of age gaps shouldn't even exist in my opinion.

P.S. The universal age of majority should be 21 or 22.


r/RomanceBooks • • Mar 01 '25

Discussion Thoughts on building an organized resource list of authors with problematic content (racist, transphobic etc) with receipts?

68 Upvotes

Hello! This post on a racist comment in Sophia Lark’s upcoming book made me realize how disorganized /ad hoc my keeping track of authors with content I’d find problematic!

I wanted to ask a question to the mods and the community about the possibility of creating a megathread or resource for identifying authors who have written racist, transphobic, or otherwise problematic content (both in their books and/or on their socials). The idea would be for readers to have a space to assess whether they’d like to support these authors or not—kind of a community-driven way to provide transparency and encourage opportunities to hold authors accountable.

For me, I try to be an ethical consumer and to be consistent in my values and approach to this kind of stuff. So for me Sophia Lark being so callous and racist in an upcoming book - especially when undocumented immigrants in the United States are being deported and in an extremely hostile climate - is a hard no for me. And a resource like this would help me be better and more consistent as I try to do this. This isn’t a means to force people to do the same but making the information more accessible for those who do want to.

For example, I remember an author with a sci-fi book who had an alien name that sounded a lot like a racial slur. Once readers pointed it out, the author took it seriously, apologized, and changed the name. They explained that English wasn’t their first language, and it was an honest mistake. That’s an example of an author growing and making amends. (If anyone remembers which post this was I’d love to link it here - couldn’t find it when I searched)

However, there are also authors who, despite being called out multiple times (like Danielle Lori), don’t seem to make an effort to change or improve. Personally, I find it hard to support an author who is actively harmful, especially when I have many other options.

Would anyone be interested in something like this? A thread where we can post authors’ names, the problematic content they’ve written or posted, and the receipts to back it up, so people can decide for themselves if they want to support them? I’ve seen so many recommendations from authors that I would no longer support after learning about certain behaviors or writing in their books.

I’ve been keeping my own list of “problematic authors” in my notes and on a “do not read/problematic author” shelf on my Goodreads, but I think it would be really helpful to have a community-driven space to share and discuss. Thoughts?

Someone pointed out that this could be potential defamation so I wonder if there are ways to state here is a post or clip of this author in this book or platform that some would construe as racist or something.

I also realize there have been several posts over the years but I would want this to be in the romance book wiki / resource section so that there is some organisation and uniformity to it.

It’s in the similar vein of how this sub no longer allows any links to twitter /X, Facebook, instagram etc which I completely agree with.

EDIT with updated thoughts after reading through the discussion:

You’ve all made some really strong points, and after thinking about it more, I agree that creating an “official” list or resource like this would be a difficult and potentially harmful undertaking. As some of you mentioned, context is crucial, and it’s incredibly hard to assess what’s truly problematic, especially when people have differing views on what crosses the line. In the past, efforts like these have been weaponized against marginalized authors, with cherry-picked quotes or misrepresentations circulating, which only causes more harm than good. It also can encourage virtue signalling and create more toxic and harmful environments.

There’s also the issue of the sheer labor involved. As you pointed out, maintaining an accurate and ethical list would require a lot of work, and the potential for manipulation or misinformation is high, especially when so many people bring their own biases and lack of media literacy to the table.

I think the tumblr fiasco as mentioned below is a good example of this.

With all that in mind, I don’t think creating a centralized resource is the way to go. But I do believe it’s incredibly important for us as a community to continue these discussions and share our experiences when we come across problematic content or authors. I think it’s about fostering conversations, where readers can weigh these concerns for themselves and make informed decisions. Some books & authors are recommended all the time but have also been flagged for some content that some would find problematic, offensive, and/or triggering - I would want us to be able to identify that but that doesn’t mean it’s a “don’t read this book bc of that” or “you’re not allowed to enjoy this book bc of that” but rather as an fyi that there are some who have noted this.

For example, if I come across something problematic in a book, I’d love to discuss it openly, without fear of being downvoted or shut down, especially in spaces where others are sharing their love for that book. I think we can still be open and critical without creating a space that doesn’t allow for people to still read that book or enjoy it regardless.

In the end, I think ethical consumption does require personal responsibility and while I think we should be doing our own research, I still think it’s important to keep the lines of communication about authors open and part of the discussion as they are recommended or spoken about and to encourage readers to decide for themselves.

Thank you all again for the thoughtful responses—it’s clear this is a nuanced issue, and I appreciate everyone’s perspective on it.

UPDATE 2: And just to say the whole point of this post was to have a discussion on this and it is currently at “0” downvotes. I mean how do you even have discussions without basically being told not to raise issue and be quiet ? Bc that’s what the downvoting means to me.


r/RomanceBooks • • Oct 31 '25

Book Request Sex between fat rolls (non fetish) NSFW

3 Upvotes

I saw a short video of an amateur couple where the guy stroked his penis in the space between her leg and stomach roll and it was really hot. So now I'm wondering if there are any scenes like this in romance books.

I searched and found a few posts about intercrural (between the thighs) sex but would like to know of any specificly between fat rolls or in the leg crease under the belly roll.

I'd also accept recommendations for under breasts.

I'll read any era and monster or fantasy is fine too. Basically go ahead and recommend any that fit and I'll check out the romance.io tags before reading so don't worry about any TW or CW limits (but feel free to mention them in your comment for anyone reading).

Really the only thing I DON'T want recommendations for is anything that is fat fetish/feederism.


r/RomanceBooks • • Apr 23 '24

Critique soulless by Gail Carriger is totally overrated

4 Upvotes

The author is trying to do too many things at once: it's a romance, but also fantasy, with supernatural creatures like vampire and werewolves, it's steampunk, but also set in victorian times, it's a comedy of manner like Jane Austen, but also feels like Twilight. And even then, it seems like not much happens, besides the 2 mc getting together.
It's not a recent book, but it's still one of these books where i'm at loss as to why so many people claim it's great, when it reads like fanfiction. I don't find the main characters likeable, eventhough they're memorable because they're both annoying and bossy to the point you're like "i wish i never come accross someone like this".