r/Rhetoric • u/[deleted] • Sep 14 '25
r/Rhetoric • u/MoreWretchThanSage • Aug 30 '25
The Rhetoric of Far Right
I recently tested how self-identified right-wing voters respond when asked if they consider themselves “Far Right” and what their definition of the term is. Out of 500+ replies, almost all fell into just a few predictable patterns:
Semantic Deflection – avoiding the issue by demanding definitions (“What’s your definition?”) instead of engaging with substance.
Thought-Terminating Clichés – shutting down discussion with lines like “Just common sense” or “Not Far Right, just RIGHT!”
Ad Hominem / Disdain for Intellectuals – dismissing definitions as inventions of “leftist academics” or “elites.”
Semantic Denial – claiming words like Far Right or Homophobic have lost all meaning, denying shared definitions.
Reductio ad Absurdum – taking definitions to extremes (“If not wanting kids abused is Far Right, then I guess I am”).
The most striking finding was how common Semantic Denial was — suggesting a trend of “vocabulary nihilism,” where people reject the idea that words can have fixed meanings. That breakdown in shared language makes political debate itself harder and feeds polarisation.
r/Rhetoric • u/Realistic-Plant3957 • Sep 16 '25
25 Wild Things Charlie Kirk Has Actually Said..
r/Rhetoric • u/poetic_fart • Sep 18 '25
The political affiliation of the Kirk shooter doesn’t matter - but the rhetoric of leadership does
I will start off by saying the shooting of Charlie Kirk is a tragedy, and should have never occurred. This is not a post condoning or celebrating his death. This is also not a post celebrating the views he promoted during his life.
The online sphere is currently hyperfixated on whether or not the shooter was a left wing or right wing individual. I am here to say that it DOES NOT MATTER what his political affiliation is. Why not? Because until today, Tyler Robinson was a completely unknown individual in the political landscapes of both demographics. Tyler Robinson is not a democratic thought leader, nor is he a republican thought leader. This individual was an extremist, and by definition, extremists do not represent the majority of the people on their side of the aisle. The idea that all liberals automatically claim him if he was trans-friendly, or that all conservatives automatically claim him if he was a groyper, is an absurdity. The discussion around which side of the aisle he lived on is solely destructive in nature, and should not be the core of our discourse.
(I say the above while fully knowing that statistically, the vast majority of recent political violence has been performed by right-wing provocateurs.... and it technically of course matters, to a degree… but just stay with me for a second...)
Do you all want to know what does matter? The real world responses to this tragedy by the thought leaders on both sides of the aisle. A quick Google search can show you the difference here, and it is stark.
Leftist thought leaders - ranging from “my deepest condolences” to “this is a tragedy, but the guy was a bad person.” I know there are randoms genuinely celebrating his death, but I have yet to see any leaders doing so… and if there are, they are few and far between.
Right thought leaders - very widely calling for a fucking civil war, death penalty, punish-the-left focused, aggressive and inflammatory comments, mixed in of course with condolences mourning the loss.
Rhetoric matters. Rhetoric coming from leadership matters even more. This is an actual problem - look at the differences in these reactions. Moving forward from today, which of these do you think is more likely to spark future political violence? Which is more likely to guide more lost souls down the path of extremism? Which style of rhetoric do you think has led us to more past violence?
I have literally seen people in my personal sphere, from my hometown, already posting on Facebook that THIS MEANS WAR - exclusively conservative individuals. Where do you think they get the signals that this sort of thinking is acceptable? I have seen no such calls for violence from the left; despite how incompassionate it may be to say "I didnt really care about that person / I'm glad he's gone", that is nowhere near as violent as comments such as "this means war". The real world repercussions of these world views are drastically different.
TLDR; the political leanings of an extremist - on either side - do not represent the majority, and thus should not be the focus of our concern. The rhetoric coming from individuals who do represent the majority of a particular side, however, matters immensely.
TLDR2; by engaging in arguments over which side this guy was on, we are implicitly accepting that he could be on my side. We should not even be engaging in these arguments, because even if he was technically on the extreme end of “my” political leaning, I do not accept him.
(To get ahead of some inevitable critiques, I had typed this in my notes before any solid info on his leanings had been released. This is not a “well he’s a lefty so now the left claims it doesn’t matter” post, as I’m sure some will claim. Regardless of my poor post timing, the point stands)
r/Rhetoric • u/NeatConclusion7157 • Oct 12 '25
Good faith US discussion
From what I’ve been able to observe, conservative-ruled states in the US have (per capita) more violent crimes, less literacy, poorer education, more poverty, more homelessness, higher divorce rates, less contribution to the national GDP, less contribution to federal taxes. They cause a LOT of problems, and I don’t see them offering ANY solutions, even by their own metrics.
I’d appreciate any good faith arguments that demonstrate that US conservatism has a valid logical reason to exist, other than just saying that some people don’t have access to or reject education. I’d like to truly understand the “other side,” so that we can hopefully bridge the gap…
r/Rhetoric • u/ZippyDan • Dec 04 '25
I propose a new category of argumentative fallacy: damnum per curam
As no one could specifically identify the behavior I described in a previous post, I've decided to propose a new class of ad hominem argument, and I propose to name it:
damnum per curam
(Latin for "loss by caring")
Description
The fallacious argument wherein the speaker attacks the other person in the argument for caring too much about the argument, and implies that by caring too much, the other person loses the argument.
This is a fallacy because - like all ad hominem arguments - it completely sidesteps the content of the argument itself, and its validity or logic, and focuses instead on the state or quality of the person making the argument. In this specific category of ad hominem, the criticism focuses on the emotional investment or time investment of the target person, or - in other words - the level of care they have demonstrated or the amount of effort they have put into winning the argument.
This fallacy is strongly correlated with the bullshit asymmetry principle, as refuting incorrect statements throughly and comprehensively often takes much more time and effort than the original inaccurate or dishonest statement. Argumenters that rely on this strategy then pursue a multi-pronged approach to "winning":
Either no one responds to their inaccuracy, and they "win" by default, or...
Someone responds to the inaccuracy, but in an incomplete way, allowing the original claimant to still claim "victory" on a technicality, or...
Anyone who takes the time to thoroughly refute their inaccuracy must spend more time and effort in a refutation that covers all angles. The speaker will then pivot away from the content of their argument to focus on this disparity of time and effort, and will try to frame that additional effort as the behavior of a "loser".
This kind of argumentation thus presents as a trap - or "no-win scenario" - by the claimant - sometimes intentionally, and sometimes as a subconscious fallback defense mechanism used by those whose ego feels threatened. If no one challenges their bullshit, they win. If someone does take the time to refute their bullshit, their "winning" argument makes them a "loser" because they cared enough to refute their statement.
There are only two approaches to defeat this strategy:
Ignore the original comment and move on. In other words, "the only winning move is not to play". This may be a viable strategy for some, but it still feels like a "win" for the "bad guys" to me because you are allowing inaccurate information to stand unchallenged - inaccurate information which can mislead and misinform any number of other anonymous viewers who may in turn propagate the misinformation.
Correctly identify the disingenuous use of this strategy and call it out. It's with that counter-strategy in mind that I choose to name this rhetorical tactic: damnum per curam.
Example 1:
Person 1 makes a short remark that is blatantly wrong.
Person 2 throughly analyzes why this remark is so wrong, with logic and evidence.
Person 1 claims they weren't serious about their original statement, and that Person 2 is a "loser" for taking it so seriously or for taking the time at all to refute the original "offhand" remark.
Example 2:
Person 1 makes a longer argument that contains multiple fundamental errors.
Person 2 throughly dissects the argument point by point, with logic and evidence.
Person 1, likely not expecting that anyone would actually take the time to deconstruct their longer argument, and miffed at being thoroughly contradicted, refuses to respond to the content of the longer refutation, and instead falls back on the "Wow, you really wrote an essay in response to my comment? What a loser." argument.
In both cases, the common behavior is a refusal to admit that their argument has been proven wrong and a refusal to respond to the contradictory arguments or evidence.
Clarifications
As some people seem to be confused, this fallacy is not an accusation of bias or loss of perspective. There is no second-order accusation here. The insult is simply that by pursuing a continued discussion / debate / argument, you care too much, and you thus lose.
It's not "you care too much about this topic, and therefore are biased and cannot be trusted / taken seriously, therefore you lose", which can sometimes be a valid accusation; it's a much simpler, and more obligatorily fallacious / more illogical / less defensible conclusion: "you care too much about this discussion, therefore you lose."There are various ways that damnum per curam can be implied rather than explicit.
Alternatives
I also considered damnum per investmentum ("loss by investment") as an alternate name for this fallacy, referring to the perceived or actual investment of time, energy, effort, and/or emotions in the discussion.
Several people have suggested other alternate names:
Drop damnum, and just use per curam or per investmentum.
The full name could then be ad hominem per curam or ad hominem per investmentum.
As damnum carries several related English meanings beyond "loss", including "hurt", "damage" or the cognate "damned", these English equivalents could also work:
Damned for caring
Loss by caring
Hurt by caring
Damaged by caring
r/Rhetoric • u/Bakari2Sense • Jun 29 '26
What's the most underrated skill in argumentation? I'll go first.
What's the most underrated argumentation skill nobody talks about?
I'll go first: Responsiveness.
Most people think debate is about making your point better than the other person. But the real skill is engaging what they ACTUALLY said, not the version you wish they said.
I see it constantly in online discourse. Someone makes a strong point and the response ignores it entirely and just restates the original position louder.
What do you think is the most neglected skill in public argumentation?
r/Rhetoric • u/Maleficent_Quail_913 • Aug 10 '25
Is “Trump Derangement Syndrome” an example of a thought-terminating Cliché?
Some examples
r/Rhetoric • u/ampersand117 • Oct 27 '16
Rhetoric Reading List
This post is adapted from the original, which has since been deleted.
Feel free to add more books or topics in the comments. I'll then add it to the list. For edited volumes, I've just placed "by authorx", you can work it out. Obviously this is a work in progress.
Classical Rhetoric
Plato (Gorgias, Phaedrus)
Aristotle (Organon, Rhetoric, Poetics).
Isocrates (get his works from Loeb Classical library collection).
Demosthenes (Loeb classical library collection).
Dionysius of Halicarnassus (Loeb)
Quintilian (Institutio Oratoria).
Cicero (works).
Works by Unknown Authors
Rhetorica ad Herennium
Dissoi logoi
Rhetorica ad alexandrum
Books about Classical rhetoric
Ancient Rhetorics for Contemporary Students by Crowley & Hawhee.
Blackwell Companion to Greek Rhetoric by Worthington.
Blackwell Companion to Roman Rhetoric by Dominik & Hall.
Greek Political Oratory by Saunders (Penguin classics collection of political speeches).
Classical Rhetoric for the Modern Student by Corbett.
Medieval Rhetoric
Medieval Rhetoric: A Casebook by Troyan.
Contemporary Rhetoric
The Philosophy of Rhetoric by I.A. Richards
New/American Rhetoric
A rhetoric of motives by Kenneth Burke
Burke (most books)
Bitzer (on rhetorical situation)
Vatz (same as bitzer)
Booth (Rhetoric of fiction, rhetoric of rhetoric for example)
McGee (on the ideographs),
Jarrat (Rereading the sophists)
Vickers (Rhetoric revalued, In defence of rhetoric)
Weaver (Ethics of rhetoric),
Black (Rhetorical criticism)
Fahnestock (Rhetorical figures in science)
Continental
Valesio (Novantiqua), Grassi (Rhetoric as philosophy)
Cassin (L'effet sophistique, How to do things with doxa)
Barthes (L'ancienne rhetorique don't know if there's an english translation).
Religious and Political Rhetoric
Political
Cold Warriors : Manliness On Trial in the Rhetoric of the West by Clark (manliness in post-WW2 rhetoric and literature).
The Reagan Persuasion by James Humes (former Presidential speech writer).
Terror and its Discontents: Suspect Words in Revolutionary France by Weber.
The Languages of Edison's Light by Bazerman (how Edison used rhetoric to spread electric light).
Religious
Divine Rhetoric: The Sermon on the Mount as Message and as a Model in Augustine, Chrysostom, and Luther by Pelikan (the uses of the Sermon on the Mount by religious orators).
Sanctified Aggression: Legacies of Biblical and Post-Biblical Vocabularies of Violence by Bekkencamp and Sherwood (essays on the interplay between religious texts and religious violence).
Christianity & the Rhetoric of Empire by Cameron (the discourse of Early Christianity, and how it spread by preaching).
Arguing the Apocalypse: A Theory of Millennial Rhetoric by O'Leary (the rhetoric of apocalyptic religion).
The Book of Jerry Falwell: Fundamentalist Language and Politics by Harding (the rhetoric of Christian Fundamentalism).
Rhetorical Theory, Popular accounts, and General books
Thank You For Arguing by Heinrichs.
Saving Persuasion: A Defense of Rhetoric and Judgment by Garsten (argues against the idea that rhetoric is superficial).
Rhetoric & Science
The Rhetoric of Empiricism: Language and Perception from Locke to I. A. Richards by Law.
The Literary Structure of Scientific Argument: Historical Studies by Dear.
Science in Action by Bruno Latour (reason why Latour and Kuhn were added).
Structure of Scientific Revolutions by Thomas Kuhn.
Communicating Science by Alan Gross.
The Social Misconstruction of Reality: Validity and Verification in the Scholarly Community by Hamilton (how mistakes in scholarship originate, and propagate).
Guardians of Science: Fairness and Reliability of Peer Review by Daniel (sociological study of the peer review process).
Shaping Written Knowledge: The Genre and Activity of the Experimental Article in Science (1988) by Charles Bazerman
Science of Persuasion
The Art of Self-Persuasion by Boudon (how people come to believe falsehoods).
Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion by Cialdini.
Thought Reform and the Psychology of Totalism: A Study of Brainwashing in China by Lifton.
Science of Coercion: Communication Research and Psychological Warfare, 1945-1960 by Simpson.
Obedience to Authority by Milgram.
The Psychology of Attitude Change and Social Influence by Zimbardo.
Arguing and Thinking: A Rhetorical Approach to Social Psychology by Billig.
Gaslighting, the Double Whammy, Interrogation, and Other Methods of Covert Control in Psychotherapy and Analysis by Dorpat.
Visual Rhetoric
Edward Tufte (works, his books are concerned with how to visualize information).
Rhetorics of Display by Lawrence Prelli
Rhetoric of Humor
Toward a Rhetoric of Insult by Conley.
Melville and Repose: The Rhetoric of Humor in the American Renaissance by Bryant.
Making Mockery: The Poetics of Ancient Satire by Rosen.
Laughter and Ridicule: Towards a Social Critique of Humour by Billig.
The Genius of Parody: Originality and Imitation in Seventeenth and Eighteenth-Century Literature by Mack.
Hyperbole in English: A Corpus-Based Study in Exaggeration by Claridge.
On the Discourse of Satire: Towards a Stylistic model of Satirical Humor by Simpson.
Greek Laughter: A Study of Cultural Psychology from Homer to Early Christianity by Halliwell.
Viva La Repartee: Clever Comebacks & Witty Retorts From History's Great Wits & Wordsmiths by Grothe.
Wicked Words by Rawson.
Social Engineering (The use of rhetoric in computer hacking)
Social Engineering: The Art of Human Hacking by Hadnagy. *The Art of Deception: Controlling the Human Element of Security by Mitnick. *No Tech Hacking: A Guide to Social Engineering, Dumpster Diving, and Shoulder Surfing by Long.
Women & Rhetoric
Reclaiming Rhetorica: Women In The Rhetorical Tradition by Lunsford.
Available Means: An Anthology of Women's Rhetoric(s) by Ritchie & Ronald.
Rhetoric Retold: Regendering the Tradition from Antiquity Through the Renaissance by Glenn.
Non-Western Rhetoric
Rhetoric before and beyond the Greeks by Lipson & Binkley.
Rhetorical Genre Theory
Genre as Social Action by Carolyn Miller
Writing Genres by Amy J. Devitt
Genre and the invention of the writer by Anis Bawarshi
Genre: An Introduction to History, Theory, Research, and Pedagogy by Anis Bawarshi and Mary Jo Reiff
Reasoning & Argument
Overviews:
Logic: A Very Short Introduction by Graham Priest.
Elementary lessons in logic: deductive and inductive by Jevons (available here).
Informal logic (critical reasoning, fallacies)
A Rulebook for Arguments by Weston.
All of Douglas Walton's works (start with Informal Logic or Argument Structure, then move onto the specific fallacy-based books).
Some of Stephen Toulmin's works (especially The Uses of Argument, and An Introduction to Reasoning).
Analyzing Informal Fallacies by Engel (practice book that contains a ton of arguments to analyze).
The New Rhetoric by Chaim Perelman & Lucie Olbrechts-Tyteca
Formal Logic (deductive)
Logic with Trees by Colin Howson. Covers propositional (P) and predicate logic (Q).
Readings for Logical Analysis by Hicks & Kelley (good book that has a ton of short essays to practice logical analysis on, includes readings that allow informal, formal, and inductive thinking. Differs from other books in that it includes good examples of arguments for analysis, not just bad examples).
An Introduction to Non-Classical Logic: From If to Is by Graham Priest (covers extensions of P & Q. Covers modal logic, many-valued logics, fuzzy logics, etc).
Logic (inductive)
An Introduction to Probability and Inductive Logic by Hacking.
Probability Theory: The Logic of Science by Jaynes.
Scientific Reasoning: The Bayesian Approach by Colin Howson (the inductive sister book of the deductive book above).
How to Lie with Statistics by Huff.
Statistics as Principled Argument by Abelson (how to tie together arguments with statistics).
r/Rhetoric • u/ZippyDan • Nov 30 '25
Is there a more specific term for the strategy of dismissing an argument because of the "tone" or "attitude" of the messenger, as an excuse for dismissing an argument you never intended to entertain in the first place?
At its core this seems to be an ad hominem argument, but I wonder if there is a more specific label for this strategy of focusing on "tone" and "attitude" specifically. The listener then takes (or feigns) offense at the "rudeness" of the messenger, and often implies they might have accepted the message but now they won't just because of "the way" it was delivered.
Of course this is irrational, because if the message is valid and logical, then this should be of greater importance than the manner in which the human vessel presents it.
(And often times, the messenger isn't even rude - they're just passionate - or they are justifiably "rude", because they are speaking out about gross injustices or inequalities that deserve an angry response.)
r/Rhetoric • u/stresstwig • Jul 14 '26
What fallacy is this?
There was an argument my dad's wife made to me years and years ago that I know is bad. It's wrong, it's illogical, it's nonsensical. But I can't identify what the fallacy--if there is a fallacy--it uses would be, and it's bugging me even though ultimately it doesn't matter. It's only coming up in my life because I'm finally starting to unpack all of the shit from her in therapy.
Context is that we were arguing about faith and religion. I said something about how I didn't have faith (in the sense of religion) and she argued back that "Everyone has faith. You have faith the chair will hold you when you sit down in it." I didn't have a good answer back then besides the knee-jerk of "that's utterly stupid and wrong, I know the chair will hold me because physics, not because God."
Is that a false equivalence? Equivocation? I've been going through lists of fallacies and bad-faith argument types trying to figure it out and they're all starting to look like word soup now. I know my brain isn't going to rest on this 'til it gets an answer.
r/Rhetoric • u/Tylos_Of_Attica • Feb 03 '26
How do you counter an opponent firehosing the debate with falsehoods?
I have seen online that some people fill the debate with a line of irrelevant information or lies whenever whenever they are backed into a corner. What can people do to fight against these?
Thank you for your time.
r/Rhetoric • u/Korenaut • Aug 13 '25
“Thank you for your attention to this matter…”
New member, longtime constitutive rhetoric nerd - I have been spending a lot of time thinking about how this phrase works to assume authority and commander / control attention - I’m curious if any other folks doing rhetoric have any thoughts on how often POTUS uses and what it does rhetorically?
r/Rhetoric • u/traanquil • Sep 14 '25
What do you call this form of demagogic rhetoric and how do you critique it?
To avoid triggering Reddit filters, I'll speak in hypotheticals here.
Let's say a speaker wishes to demagogue about a target racial / ethnic group -- let's call them Plutonians.
The speaker says something like this: "Plutonians commit crime and violence, threatening the stability of our society."
In response to critiques that this is racist, the speaker retorts: "I wasn't talking about ALL PLUTONIANS, I was merely pointing out a fact -- the fact that there are a significant number of Plutonians committing crime."
In other words, while the original statement is suggestive of falsely vilifying the totality, the speaker retreats into a more limited interpretation -- that, no, the statement was merely talking about a subset of the Plutonians. He can now claim that he was making a value-neutral statement of literal fact, and thus it cannot be racist.
My question is: Are there any technical terms in rhetoric -- or case studies from rhetoric -- to describe what is happening here? How could we use our knowledge of rhetoric to critique these kinds of statements?
r/Rhetoric • u/ironicart • Sep 12 '19
Been fascinated by the way people communicated so eloquently in late 1800s and early 1900s; my current theory is Rhetoric was much more at the heart of English teaching then... picked up these books from 1800s to see what teaching back then on the subject was like.
r/Rhetoric • u/The_Rhetorician_redd • Jul 08 '25
So, I started a newsletter on Rhetoric
My job requires me to "influence without authority", so I went down the rabbit hole of the whole art of persuasion and influence. Started with sales, eventually stumbled onto Aristotle's Rhetoric.
Was completely mind blown. What a book. Changed the way I look at human interactions and persuasion.
Although I found it to be much more info-dense than your average book these days... so I started a newsletter to keep track of what I'm learning, and keep sharing it along the way.
If you're into it, check it out - therhetorician.co
Thanks!
r/Rhetoric • u/halapert • Dec 08 '25
What fallacy is this?
“I’m a good person, and Z is against me, so Z is a bad person.” I know there’s a name for it but it’s slipping my mind. ———— Another one: “I’ve come up with plan Q, which would result in people not suffering. If you’re against my Plan Q, you must just want people to suffer.” (Like, if Politician A said ‘we should kill Caesar so Rome won’t suffer’ and Politician B said ‘no let’s not do that’ and Politician A says ‘Politician B wants Rome to suffer!’) what’s the word for these? Thank you!!
r/Rhetoric • u/Apart-Double3901 • Mar 03 '26
How did you train yourself to identify fallacies and counter them in real time?
I understand the theory — I know what straw man, ad hominem, false dichotomy, etc. look like on paper. But in actual debates or arguments, recognizing them quickly enough to respond effectively is a completely different skill.
What I've tried: reading logic textbooks and watching debate breakdowns. Good for learning, not great for building reflexes.
What I want: drills, habits, or training methods that actually build the real-time recognition and response skill — not just theoretical knowledge.
What worked for you? Especially interested in anything that felt like deliberate practice rather than just more reading.
r/Rhetoric • u/Comfortable_Tutor_43 • Nov 21 '25
Conservative writer claims wokeness is largely the feminization of the workplace
reddit.comr/Rhetoric • u/Resident-Guide-440 • Aug 31 '25
What is this fallacy?
Not sure if it’s a fallacy, but whatever it is it must have a name. Here’s an example:
In high school, we were about to vote on prom king and queen. A (really dumb) girl said choosing the king and queen should not be a popularity contest. It should go to the most qualified for the job. That’s laugh-out-loud funny, of course, but we can see her mistake. She was repeating a cliche (more common in the 1980s) used by voters who wanted to emphasize their independence of mind, that they were not unthinking partisans.
Because the two scenarios (a political contest and choosing prom royalty) have at least one thing in common (voting), she dragged an idea from one to the other, where it didn’t belong.
This example is extremely silly, but I hear other examples all the time.
There must be a name for it. Conceptual drift? Bleed?
I’d like to know the name so that I can spot them more easily. That’s the Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis. (Actually, it’s not, but that may be taken as another example of the phenomenon!)
r/Rhetoric • u/Cavalir • 4d ago
“Pick another protein? I’d rather pick another senator”
Can anyone please tell me the name of the rhetorical device used in Scott Colom’s senate ad?
I know it’s not Epistrophe or chiasmus.
I appreciate the help!
r/Rhetoric • u/JayHeinrichs • Jul 15 '25
I'm Jay Heinrichs, bestselling author of THANK YOU FOR ARGUING, and my latest book ARISTOTLE'S GUIDE TO SELF-PERSUASION. Ask me anything on Thursday, July 17 about rhetoric, persuading yourself to achieve your goals, and how you can win every argument
Hey there! I'm Jay, a bestselling author of books on rhetoric, the ancient (and very modern!) art of persuasion. I get hired by the likes of Ivy League universities, tech companies, and NASA engineers to change people’s minds and their actions. I also write a weekly Substack that show how rhetoric works in the real world—like the critical persuasive tool missing from self-help books, or how introverts can benefit the most from rhetorical tools.So ask me anything—from what trope wins elections to what tense you should use to get yourself out of trouble.Thanks and looking forward to getting these conversations going

r/Rhetoric • u/ZippyDan • Mar 26 '25
Rhetorical strategy where "caring too much" or taking an argument "too seriously" makes you the "loser"?
Is there a name for this? It's so often been used against me here on Reddit.
Step 1: Person A makes a wild claim or accusation, often in a short format.
Step 2: Person B provides a long and detailed refutation of said claim or accusation, many times with supporting sources.
Final strategy: Person A refuses to actually engage with the arguments or evidence that Person B presented, and instead frames the time spent or the volume of words written as evidence that Person B "cares too much" about the discussion / debate / argument and optionally that their initial claim or accusation wasn't "that serious", and therefore not worthy of such an exhaustive response - without actually admitting that they were completely wrong. Their reply becomes a criticism of Person B for being stupid enough to actually invest effort in disproving their claim.
It seems to me this must be some variation of ad hominem because it is shifting the discussion from the topic at hand to the mental state of the person making the counter-argument.
It often reminds me of this quote from Jean-Paul Sartre:
[Italics Mine]
Never believe that anti-Semites are completely unaware of the absurdity of their replies. They know that their remarks are frivolous, open to challenge. But they are amusing themselves, for it is their adversary who is obliged to use words responsibly, since he believes in words. The anti-Semites have the right to play. They even like to play with discourse for, by giving ridiculous reasons, they discredit the seriousness of their interlocutors. They delight in acting in bad faith, since they seek not to persuade by sound argument but to intimidate and disconcert. If you press them too closely, they will abruptly fall silent, loftily indicating by some phrase that the time for argument is past.
This seems to describe a very similar situation, where they make faulty, erroneous arguments that seem to be presented seriously, but when you challenge them they accuse you of taking the arguments "too seriously", and that in so doing you have "lost".
It furthermore seems very easy to fall into this "trap" considering the "bullshit asymmetry principle", as it often takes a lot more time and words to comprehensively debunk even the seemingly simplest of claims or accusations. And yet, leaving wildly inaccurate statements unchallenged also carries big risks in public discourse.
Is there a name for this strategy?
UPDATE: Absent any compelling specific responses, I decided to attempt to name this behavior myself.
r/Rhetoric • u/seventhsela • Aug 07 '25
Rhetorical device invoking unknown fear
Hi rhetoricians, I’ve been staring at this bag from the grocery store I brought home, fascinated by how it works rhetorically. Although it seems to be a positive message, it operates by invoking an unstated fear of “bad” things that the audience supplies with their own imagination (pesticides, artificial dyes, microplastics…basically all the bad things we read about in the news daily). Seems like a very common and effective rhetorical strategy these days, for a world made anxious by so much pervading doom.
Interested in if any of y’all can think of classical terms to describe this strategy!