The motives and morals of a rhetorician can vary; however, the overwhelming number of negative uses is prevailing in societies across the globe. Even when truth and goodness are the goal of the writing, “The honest rhetorician has no separate name to distinguish him from the dishonest.” (Honeycutt)
The art of persuasion and manipulation in certain circumstances has been considered criminal. In the instance of Charles Manson, a man convicted of seven counts of murder and conspiracy to commit murder, without ever pulling a trigger, used persuasion and rhetorical methods to have his deeds of malicious violence carried out. (Bardsley) Adolph Hitler was also known for his ability to persuade the masses into doing things that would now be considered a violation of good practice in any moral sense. In the wrong hands, the art of the used car salesman will inevitably be responsible for the fall of man in structured societies.
Marketing and advertising use persuasion methods that we all know are immoral. I was watching daytime T.V. and saw a commercial that made me question the tactics used in persuading the consumers of advertising. It was an Everest College advertisement, with a man that talks down to the viewer for not taking action and going to college. At the end of the message he swooshes his hand towards the viewer, turning his back as if he was disgusted with the inaction of the couch potato. The way it was worded was so convincing that I felt as if I wasn’t doing enough with my life, and I better get a move on. Quickly, I remember this paper is part of my 12 credit hour load for the semester.
It is iniquitous that people educated in the art of rhetoric, will manipulate words to take advantage of people in any mind state, turning written and spoken word into gospel. Rhetoric has been used through time to, “get what you want;” push people to see things your way and back up that information so it can’t be contested. If it is these writing practices that are considered correct, then there will be no hope for proper information ever reaching the mind; it is all still opinion, even when supported by facts. If what I say is true, then this paper itself is a part of the madness of writing that will cause the fall of man through the infinity of case arguments; this is nothing more than words organized in such a way that when the message is read, an opinion will form. The perpetual motion of rhetoric, and the back and forth sway, gives the reason for its discredit. The need for Winston Churchill to use rhetoric to have allies put an end to Hitler’s wrong doings is a double standard; had rhetoric not developed, the need for a counterargument wouldn’t have either.
Religion is not to be excluded when looking at rhetoric as a form of manipulation. The majority of people have a desire to believe in a higher power, making them very susceptible to take written and spoken word as an absolute truth. As one absorbs information about religion from birth on, there becomes little room for personal beliefs; it creates a lack in individuality among the populace. Some religions baptize as young as eight years old, others from birth. The United Methodist Church answers the question, “What is the appropriate age for baptism?” “As soon as possible and practical.” (Burton-Edwards) The problem with this attitude is opinions are forced into beliefs at an age where the individual hasn’t developed the proper ways of thinking to analyze and critique the information with a non-biased view. Unfortunately, we must learn the practice of questioning material, due to the amount of inadvertent conditioning that takes place in the developing mind of a child.
One way that we can take care of the problem that rhetoric has put on our front door is to educate listeners and readers to the idea of critical thinking. Implementing critical thinking/analysis classes as a requirement in public school systems, as a graduation requirement, will ensure that those who make it through school understand the concepts of speaking and writing using persuasion. As observers of language, questioning the rhetorician is a must. The driving force used in the writing may be to fulfill an assignment, encourage an opinion, or to gain control over peoples thoughts, ideas, and beliefs. It is the responsibility of everyone who receives information to question the meaning behind it and the aim at which the creator of the gathered facts of a subject took. If it is these practices that become correct, then a reasoning society would emerge, rather than the assured destruction of a controlled public. Instead of trying to eliminate a problem that has no solution, one must educate the public to its presence.
To finish, vigilance should be practiced when listening and reading, due to the dangers of an author and his or her possible intentions. No matter what the message is, it’s constructed of organized words with distinct meanings, and a distinct direction. Whether or not it is taken as fruit from the tree of knowledge is up to the individual.
Work Cited
Bardsley, Marilyn. "Charles Manson." Charles Manson. 2007. Courtroom Television Network. 26 Feb2007 http://www.crimelibrary.com/features/clickBack.asp?tempV=227589&urlP=/serial_killers/notorious/manson/16.html> Chapters 1, 16, 19
Burton-Edwards, Rev. Taylor. "What is the appropriate age for baptism?." Our World. unknown. The people of The United Methodist Church. 26 Mar 2007 http://archives.umc.org/interior.asp?ptid=1&mid=3196.
Honeycutt, Lee. "Index to Book 1." Aristotle's Rhetoric. 16MAR2004. 26 Feb 2007 http://www.public.iastate.edu/~honeyl/Rhetoric/oneindex.html.