Before reading on, make sure you've read the main guide for QC posting, otherwise this won't make much sense to you. Done? Let's go.
This specific guide is intended to be a visual supplement: showing you exactly what to look for when you complete your QC templates. For obvious reasons, this guide will skip parts that aren't visual.
I've used pictures that mostly come from this subreddit. If anyone is uncomfortable, DM me and I'll replace the picture.
With that in mind, let's begin.
Index Alignment
Here, you are expected to assess how well the index markers on your watch are aligned. You can use the index alignment tool to assist you in this regard. An example of good index alignment is this:
Index misalignment, on the other hand, looks like this:
Or this:
Now that you have an idea of what to look out for, what should you be writing in the template?
You need to describe any misalignment you see in detail. Statements like "6 is off" or "3 is kinda wonky" or "not sure about 1, help please" arenot acceptable. This is because unless the misalignment is immediately obvious (and in most cases, it is not), users will not know what you are talking about. You may not get the help you want as a result. Be specific, like the following examples:
"The 7 marker does not seem to fit into the slot nicely. It is rotated towards the right and looks like it is dancing around."
"The 6 marker does not seem to line up straight with the crown in between swiss made. Based on what I can see, it appears to be slightly tilted to the left."
A caveat here: Just because there may be some misalignment does not necessarily mean you should definitely RL the watch. As the main guide points out, all reps are subject to a level of inaccuracy. It would be entirely unrealistic to expect gen standards for index alignment. Further, different reps are subject to different standards: a XF Pelagos, for instance, is known for having problematic indices - so much so that even if you RL, you are unlikely to get anything better. Conversely, CF Explorers are now getting so good that even slight misalignment would not be par for the course.
A good guide would be to assess your watch based on proportion. One slightly misaligned index is not a problem. But one majorly misaligned index or many misaligned indices on a single dial could justify RL.
Just for illustration, this is misalignment that I would RL for:
That deals with index alignment. Let's move on.
Date Wheel Alignment
This applies to watches which display the date. If your watch does not display a date, there is no need to consider this. You will look silly if you say that the date wheel alignment is good when your watch is a no-date Sub, for example.
Here, you are tasked to consider if the date is properly displayed in the date window. Often times, this is a question of how well-centered the date is. A good example of date wheel alignment is this:
An example of misalignment is this:
Sometimes, the misalignment can also be as to the date numbers themselves:
Uncommonly and in the alternative, the issue may be with the Cyclops itself (the magnifier that covers the date window):
Now that you know what to look for, let's discuss what to write.
As with index alignment, unless the issues are immediately obvious (and most of the time, they are not), you need to be very specific. Comments like "the date seems off", "2 in 25 is kinda off", "date looks weird" are not acceptable. They do not tell readers what you are looking for. You'll get faster and better results if you identify the issues for your reader. For example:
"The date seems misaligned towards the left. Part of it is touching the left border of the date window."
"The 5 in the date appears to be slightly higher than the 2 next to it."
"The Cyclops does not seem to be straight. It looks like it is slanted towards the left?"
As with index alignment, please note that not all misalignment will justify RL, especially for date wheels. All rep date wheels come with varying degrees of misalignment. A few misaligned dates are usually not enough for RL, unless the date is clearly cropped out of the date window or touching the rim. A little misalignment towards either side of the date window is also generally more than okay; a good way to gauge is to zoom out to the actual size of the watch and see if the misalignment is still immediately visible. If not, you're likely to be good to go.
Here is an example of misalignment I would nevertheless GL:
On to the next topic.
Bezel
There are two main things to look out for: First, whether the "pip" (usually a lumed marker at the 12 position) is centered. Second, the quality of any engraving.
This section would also cover any possible damage to the bezel or anything else unusual, including any misalignment.
Example of a good bezel:
An example of misalignment:
Generally speaking, most problems that surface nowadays have to do with the pip - even then, these are not entirely common. Engravings and alignment are usually not an issue with higher level reps. With this in mind, what do we write?
As with the other sections, you are going to need to be specific. "Bezel looks off", "pip looks kinda off", "I don't know about the bezel, seems weird to me" are phrases that we see everyday in this subreddit. But none of these phrases are acceptable; they do not direct the reader to what OP is seeing. Details are king - and if you are going to pluck the crown, you're going to have to write like this:
"The pip at 12 is not centered. It seems to touch the right side of the triangle."
"The printing on the bezel at 3 seems to be angled down. It does not match the index on the dial."
The key is to visually direct your reader to the exact point that you say is a problem. The word "off" on its own says nothing to that effect.
On to the next point.
Solid End Links (SELs)
Possibly the least understood of all sections as a lot of newbies do not really know what they are looking for.
The ultimate guide to this is here. But for convenience, I'm going to summarise several key points about SELs.
SELs refer to the final links between the watch case and the bracelet. I've highlighted it below:
Not all watches have SELs. Only watches which have that portion as highlighted above - and for QC purposes, the SEL section really only applies to Rolex reps. Tudors have SELs (which can also be QC-ed to some extent), but SELs on a Tudor are not held to the same standard as SELs on a Rolex.
Now, what are we looking for when we assess SELs? We are looking for gaps between the lugs and the SELs themselves. I've indicated this below:
An SEL gap appears when there is separation between the SEL and the lug. But what is a gap?
A gap appears when you can see through the space between the SEL and the lug. There is no gap when all you can see is a black line. There may be some variation in how thick the black line is, but for QC purposes there is nothing to be worried about until and unless you can actually see what's behind the watch.
This is generally not a problem on higher level reps (and by now, pretty rare). I will, however, show you an example of something that may be an actionable gap:
What does this mean? If all you see is a black line, even if it is slightly thicker than another SEL on the same watch, there should be no actionable gap. I am going to highlight the last few QC templates submitted where the user said there was a gap - but there really wasn't (to me, at least):
If, after going through all the examples above, you still feel that there is a gap, highlight it in the template by identifying which part of the watch you are looking at; there are really only four options: top left, top right, bottom left, bottom right. Doing so helps users zoom in directly on your issue and saves time.
To the last segment.
Dial Printing
Here, you are tasked to check if the printing on the dial has been poorly done. By this, we mean defects in the workmanship of the printing; printing which differs from gen (such as the infamous "floating r") would not be a QC defect per se.
An example of dial printing with no issues:
And now for examples of dial printing with issues:
Sometimes, the print can be misapplied across the entire dial:
With the above in mind, let's turn to what you should write. Again and at the risk of sounding like a broken record, do not simply write things like: "Dial seems off" or "Print seems off. letters kind of wonky?" If anything, dial printing is usually very, very small - unless you point a reader to the exact part which has an issue, chances are it won't be seen. Make certain that you provide the reader with specific directions:
"Appears to be some bleeding at the top of VI. Thoughts?"
"R in Submariner looks like only half of it was printed. Am I seeing things?"
Important note: again, just because the dial printing on your watch may have some issues, this does not necessarily equate to RL. As stated, dial print is almost microscopic - no human being is going to be able to see slight bleeding on any print when you have the watch on wrist. Feel free to point out issues that you see, but remain realistic about your expectations.
And with that, I come to the end of this guide.
Conclusion
QC-ing reps is a difficult task - which everyone in this subreddit does for free. You can help out immensely by simply being precise and detailed in your observations. The more effort you put into your template, the easier it is for members to help you - they can zoom in directly to the things that concern you.
I hope this helps you. I've tried to detail some common factors, but it would be impossible for me to catch them all. The rest is up to you - and your diligence.
If your template uses a NEW "yupoo" or a "mega" type of link, please note that, at the time of this typing, the automod here removes them immediately from view i.e. no QC help. We are addressing it, but....
So, what to do?
Although somewhat cumbersome for the OP, you can upload the QC packet to an Imgur account. Our automod 'likes' Imgur...and the post will show promptly. Just do NOT do it from a mobile because the mobile app loses resolution and crappy pics don't provide any benefit to anyone. Yea, yea...I know, the file compression software isn't supposed to lose quality, but it certainly does.
To add, post your complete QC album inclusive of the timing info. Do not, for the sake of your convenience, omit items. If you're bright enough to determine what is needed and what can be removed, that's great! Then, it's reasonable to conclude that you really don't need help. Simply, post it all.
If you have to wait for substantive additional info from the Seller e.g. timing data, then delay posting until you have a complete QC packet. Incomplete packages will trigger a removal of the post. Plus, it will require a return visit of anyone that commented on the incomplete post which shouldn't be required. One visit is all that it should take to QC most watches. Most won't return to a post anyway. They'll just go to the next one. The members are quite busy here. Yea, it can get crazy.
Finally, since you're a newbie, as a vote of appreciation for those members that help you, please upvote their comments. It's a nice gesture from you to them for the assist...and, it's free.
One final note, we've updated the main rules for posting. Refer to this link for info QC Must Read for New Members
Welcome to the hobby and the sub. Best wishes
Edit addition: March 2nd, 2024 - ReptimeQC member, u/EveningVariation8236 , has provided an updated version of the original QC alignment verification tool. https://watchqc.github.io/ . Thank you.
Edit addition: Jan 9th, 2024 - ReptimeQC member, u/Ro1hype has provided this for tool for alignment verification. https://qcwatch.com/ Thank you.
Edit addition: 8/8/2025 - Reptime QC member, u/jrverdes . has provided this version of the alignment tool to assist those that need additional help verifying the dial/bezel alignments on their watch. https://jrverdes.github.io/watch-qc-jr/ The adjustment resolutions are much finer in this app comparative to the other available apps which can be a benefit to some that need such. Check it out...Thank you.
Index alignment: looks solid, as can be seen in the attached image
Dial Printing: Prints all look sharp and well aligned. No obvious mistakes or outliers. Logo at the bottom of the dial seems to be ever so slightly off center, but that's like fractions of a millimeter.
Date Wheel alignment/printing: Seems to be slightly off-center to the bottom, but that could just be the perspective of the close-up photo as it looks fine in the video (see album).
Finally pulled the trigger on an IWC with Steve (who has been great as expected).
My first effort at a QC so let me know if I'm missing something:
1.Dealer name: Theonewatches (Steve)
2. Factory name: A7F
3. Model name (& version number): IWC Pilot’s Watch Mark XX Blue Dial on Bracelet (IW328204)
4. Price Paid: $488 ($493 after 5% discount and shipping)
5. Album Links: Attached instead
6. Index alignment: Good — printed numerals and outer minute markers align cleanly, and the 12 triangle/dots sit straight and centered under the 12 marker.
7. Dial Printing: Crisp and level across "IWC", "MARK XX AUTOMATIC", and "SWISS MADE" with no bleeding. "SCHAFFHAUSEN" font looks a tiny bit thin (have read about this for A7F). Very small lint fiber near the 1 marker in the first photo is gone in the angled shot (outer crystal lint).
8. Date Wheel alignment/printing: Very slight upward bias on the 8 in the straight-on photo, though nothing is clipped and it looks more balanced at an angle (within acceptable tolerance).
9. Hand Alignment: Aligned and good lume fill. Date flips cleanly.
10. Bezel: Smooth polished bezel with no visible dings, scratches, or defects.
11. Solid End Links (SELs): Tight and flush all around. I thought the bottom right might have been slightly sunken but it looks fine on the edge on shot.
13. Anything else you notice: Clasp brushing, IWC engraving, and inner deployant hinge join all look good for A7F, and the crown screws down smoothly in the video.
Thinking GL despite the tiny upward date bias, open to any second opinions.
**Overall Impression:** Everything looks okay apart from rolex logo on the dial which is left shifted (not tilted). But I am not sure if I'm right about that.
My first rep, it's been an interesting experience! I chose this reference, showed it to my wife who also was into it (which was a nice surprise) and here we are.
Paid on Oct 26th, 2026.
14 days later, November 9th, Andiot themselves emailed and said the first watch they received didn't pass their internal QC - "REASON FAILED:AE183128 – Movement issue." Reassuring that they caught it and informed me.
11 days later, November 20th, received QC images for this unit.
Dealer name: Andiot
Factory name: ORF
Model name(& version number): Seamaster 300M Diver Titanium/Bronze Gold ORF 1:1 Green Dial On Titanium Mesh Bracelet Asian Super Clone 8806(Free Rubber Strap)Free Sprung (210.90.42.20.10.001)
Price Paid: $583 USD ($545 + $38 USPS shipping)
Album Links: Uploaded directly to Reddit.
Index alignment: 6 o'clock looks a little wonky. I'm in my mid-40s and my eyes are crap anyway, so I'm inclined to GL regardless.
Dial Printing: Looks clear.
Date Wheel alignment/printing: N/A
Hand Alignment: Not a ton of pictures to help with this
Anything else you notice: The only other thing I spotted, and I feel silly for even mentioning it, was that the red 'OMEGA MASTER CO-AXIAL 8806' text on the rotor is wonky - it's not centered to the ring. Obviously not a big deal because I'm never really going to look at it.
As I said, I'm inclined to GL, but obviously would appreciate any other sets of eyes. Unfortunately most of the photos of the dial aren't really in focus - I sympathize as I'd imagine they've got lots of these QC's to do - would it be worth asking for any more in focus dial images? There are a couple of videos which I couldn't upload, winding the watch etc. I can upload elsewhere if they're deemed crucial.
Thanks in advance, excited to get an early Christmas present!
G'day all. First Qc and first rep. After spending a heap of time here I decided to go with the rich batgirl as my first rep. Chose steve as I've been impressed with the quality of other QC posts from him.
Dealer name: theonewateches (steve)
Factory name: rich
Model name (& version number): GMT Master II Batgirl Jub JH3285 free sprung
Index alignment: Looks aligned for each hour. The triangle at 12 maybe slightly not centred? The 4, 5, 7 and 8 marker look a little messy? the black circle isnt perfect on them.
Dial Printing: looks good
Date Wheel alignment/printing: i think it looks good and printing is aligned
Hand Alignment: Looks fine.
Bezel: no issues
Solid End Links (SELs): cant see any major gaps
Timegrapher numbers: 0sd 282 degrees 0.0ms error
Anything else you notice: Ive never had a jubilee bracelet, is it meant to be see through as seen in the images.
Dealer name: Steve – TheOneWatches Factory name: AF Model name (& version number): Cartier Tank Must Large, WSTA0041 (25.5 × 33.7 mm), Quartz Price Paid: $228 USD Album Links: dis not get album link this time but high resolution images in my email. Index alignment: I don’t see any obvious misalignment or dial rotation, but I’d really appreciate a second opinion from more experienced eyes. This is my first rep ever, so I’m trying to make sure everything looks good before giving it the GL. Dial Printing: This was probably my main concern. Last one has dial printing mistakes like specs, and stains. This one imo looks crisp, but. Set of pro eyes could help more. Date Wheel alignment/printing: N/A Hand Alignment: Nothing obviously wrong to my eyes. Bezel: No obvious issues that I can spot. Solid End Links (SELs): N/A Timegrapher numbers: N/A – Quartz Anything else you notice: The cabochon looks fine to me overall. I’ve noticed that newer Cartier Tanks seem to have a slightly pointier cabochon compared to the rounder ones on vintage models, so that doesn’t particularly bother me. I’m mostly concerned about the dial printing and whether there’s anything else I’m overlooking. Since this is my first rep, I’d really appreciate any feedback from people who are more familiar with AF Tanks. Just want to make sure I’m not missing any QC issues before approving it. Thanks in advance!
Anything else you notice: I didn’t see the 3285 movement photos, and I’m requesting Jacky for it. I’ve also asked for a video on the crown positions, and how these move the hands at positions 1, 2 and 3.
Appreciate extra set of eyes and feedback from everyone. Thanks.
Anything else you notice: It looks perfect from my POV, it's just that recent days phoenix seems to have questionable things going on so I want a sanity check
Hello guys, if I could ask for your opinion on this QC please, it’s my first one in a long time. I think overall it looks good, 8 looks a little off but not sure if it’s enough for a RL?
Dealer name: Ficotime
Factory name: VSF
Model name (& version number): Oyster Perpetual 36mm Green 126000
Dealer Name: Andiot Factory name: BVF • Model name (& version number): Cartier Santos Green Dial 40mm Automatic • Price Paid: 441 USD • Album Links: https://andiotwatches.x.yupoo.com/albums/263702773?uid=1 • Index alignment: N/A, after reading some other Santos forums, alignment doesn't apply to printed dials. Dial Printing: Looks good to me, no obvious flaws. Date Wheel alignment/printing: Can't tell if its off center or if the 1 is supposed to be that close to the left? • Hand Alignment: Looks fine • Bezel: Looks fine • Solid End Links (SELs): N.A • Timegrapher numbers: All numbers seem to be within range.
This is my second purchase ever, any help would be greatly appreciated! Thank you all
Index alignment: New to all of this, so not sure what to look for, but should the minute markers on the bezel line up with the corresponding hour markers on the dial?
Dial Printing: The Seamaster red printing looks dark to me but could be the lighting?
Date Wheel alignment/printing: N/A
Hand Alignment: Looks okay to me
Bezel: Comparing to gen, looks like the numbers are filled in properly (not flush with surface)
Solid End Links (SELs): N/A? This has a unique titanium mesh bracelet with a clasp system (feed)
Anything else you notice: Again, first rep purchase and first QC, so not sure what to look for. Only thing that caught my eye was the dark red print (Seamaster) and the alignment of the minute markers on the bezel not lining up with the markers on the dial.
Date Wheel alignment/printing:Looks aligned based on lines
Hand Alignment: looks centered for the most part
Bezel: outer bezel look misalligned
Solid End Links (SELs): straight forward dial
Timegrapher numbers: -2 s/d; Amplitude: 264-2; Acceptable Beat Error: 52 . He didn't have a picture of it, he has it part of a video where the result is at the end in the album
Anything else you notice: bezel looks scuffed is that normal? or is it over plastic? and the tachymeter , should i request it be redone? Any other indices looks ok? anything else I should look out for this model?
Dealer name: TheOneWatches (Steve) Factory name: RCF Model name: Day Date 40, 228236 Ice Blue, Weighted Approx. 210g, VR3255 Price paid: $858 Album links: Photos attached Index alignment: Concerned the 11 marker is slightly crooked. Other markers look good. Dial printing: Looks clean. Date wheel alignment/printing: Day and date look centered. Hand alignment: Looks fine. Bezel: Looks good. Solid End Links (SELs): No obvious gaps. Timegrapher numbers: +4 s/d, 310° amplitude, 0.2 ms beat error. Anything else you notice: First time QCing this model. The 11 marker is my main concern. Would you GL or RL based on these photos? Appreciate any feedback!
Picked up an OP36 from JTime, my fourth rep from them. Leaning GL but want extra eyes on index alignment and anything I missed.
Dealer name: JTime
Factory name: VSF
Model name (& version number): Rolex Oyster Perpetual 36 126000, black dial [version if known]
Price Paid: $498
Album Links:
Index alignment: Checked with the WatchQC ruler and a second independent overlay. All markers within ~1 degree; the worst readings (~1-1.5 degrees around 3/4/10) track the camera tilt in the photo rather than a real offset.
Dial Printing: Crisp and even. Coronet centered at 12.
Date Wheel alignment/printing: N/A (no-date model)
Hand Alignment: Hands sit consistent across shots at ~10:08, but no hands-at-12:00 photo was provided, so hand alignment is not fully verified. Requested one from the dealer.
Bezel: Smooth polished bezel, even all the way around.
Solid End Links (SELs): Look flush with no visible gaps from the angles provided.
Timegrapher numbers: 0 s/d, 286 amplitude, 0.0 ms beat error, 28,800 bph, one position (Weishi video in album).
Anything else you notice: Clasp engravings clean and legible (ROLEX/GENEVA/SWISS MADE, STEELINOX, U7T date code, ROLEXSA oval). Caseback clean with the 36 sticker. Protective film still on, so the finish underneath can't be judged yet. No lume shot in the set. Order ref 000060637.
Model name (& version number): Navitimer B01 RG 43mm BLS 1:1 Best Edition Green Dial Black Subdial On RG Bracelet A7750 (not actually on the website)
Price Paid: $430 including shipping
Album Links: QC photos attached
Index alignment: Looks aligned to me, but would appreciate a second opinion, since there is a lot of opportunity for things other be misaligned on the face of this model
Dial Printing: looks solid to me.
Date Wheel alignment/printing: These are know to be a little "sunk" on this model, but this looks maybe a tad off-centered towards the top? Input would be appreciated, could just be the angle and the wheel being sunk.
Hand Alignment: Looks good
Bezel: good
Solid End Links (SELs): Will likely be swapping out to a leather band, but ELs appear okay from what I can tell.
Timegrapher numbers: Timegrapher: +1 s/d, 244° amplitude, 0.0ms beat error, 52° lift angle. I don't 100% understand these measurements yet, but from what I (think I) understand is these are good to go.
Anything else you notice: First time buying a rep, any input/opinions are appreciated!
Index alignment: Indices look straight overall. The 7 marker sits slightly to the left of its minute marker, but it is minor.
Dial Printing: Appears clean, crisp and centered.
Date Wheel alignment/printing: N/A – no date.
Hand Alignment: Hands look reasonably aligned by eye, but when I check with alignment tools, they don’t seem particularly good. Am I wrong, or is this because the watch isn’t perfectly straight in the photos? (Please find the photos attached. Apologies for the screenshots. I couldn’t figure out how to download the photos properly after using the alignment tool, so I feel like a boomer right now. Please bear with me)
Bezel:
Solid End Links (SELs): They seem reasonably tight. If anything, the top right one (red circle) might be slightly off, but I don’t see light through it.
Timegrapher numbers: Dial up, fully wound: rate -3 s/d, amplitude 278° at 59° lift angle (approx. 250-258° if normalized to 55°), beat error 0.1 ms, 28,800 bph. Video attached.
Anything else you notice: First time purchasing a watch. Any feedback is helpful! Would really appreciate a second opinion on the overall QC, especially any flaws or details I might have overlooked. Thanks in advance!
This is my first QC (and most likely my only watch), so I’m excited, but also a bit cautious!
I’ve been learning a lot from reading other people’s QC posts, but I still find it difficult to spot all the little details that the more experienced members seem to notice immediately.
So I’d be incredibly grateful if you could take a close look at this watch and help me identify anything that seems off, particularly anything that could be an obvious callout.
I’d really appreciate your help and patience with a first-timer. Thank you so much!
Index alignment: 12 o'clock, shifted down to the right?
Dial Printing: fine
Date Wheel alignment/printing: N/A
Hand Alignment: fine
Bezel: fine
Solid End Links (SELs): fine
Timegrapher numbers: fine
Anything else you notice:
I wonder how easy it is to shift the marker if I GL the watch? I am handy all around and not afraid to try. I am also considering to ask the factory to throw in a better QC dial and swap it myself.
Model name: Cartier Panthère de Cartier Small, Stainless Steel, White Dial (22mm × 30mm) — NOT Mini
Price paid: $288 USD total ($238 watch + $50 shipping)
Album links: QC photos attached; album link pending
Index alignment: N/A — Printed Roman numerals
Dial printing: I believe the entire dial may be rotated slightly counterclockwise relative to the case. It's particularly noticeable around the lower Roman numerals and SWISS MADE printing. I'm unsure whether this is actual dial rotation or camera perspective. Would appreciate additional opinions.
Date Wheel alignment/printing: N/A
Hand alignment: Blue hands appear fine from the photos.
Bezel: Polished case and bezel appear clean, with no obvious major defects.
Solid End Links (SELs): N/A
Timegrapher numbers: N/A — Quartz movement
Anything else you notice: This watch is for my wife. My primary concern is the possible counterclockwise dial rotation. I'd appreciate feedback on whether it's within acceptable tolerances or worth requesting another watch. I also want to confirm that this is the Small 22mm model, not the Mini.
Hi guys, my first rep and a go at QC, any pointers from the pros is appreciated! (Also where I can find a alignment tool I see knocking around here for future QC’s)
Dealer name: Ethan Watches
Factory name: Clean Plus
Model name (& version number): Yacht Master Titanium 226627
Price Paid: £404
Album Links:
Index alignment: from the image I think it looks great, I don’t have one of those index alignment tools I see knocking around here. Maybe a slight twist on the 6 o’clock, could just be due to the hand covering it.
Dial Printing: seems good
Date Wheel alignment/printing: again solid & centred to my eye, maybe a tad low, don’t think it’s an issue
Hand Alignment: seems great here
Bezel: looks good to me
Solid End Links (SELs): solid, no obvious gaps that I can see
Timegrapher numbers: maybe a little low amp but in the acceptable range
Anything else you notice: nothing major to my untrained eye! If the pros can cast an eye over I appreciate any feedback while I get experience in this hobby!