Watch: ZF Tudor Black Bay 58 GMT (A2836 GMT)
Dealer: MiroTime
Issue: Dead on arrival (DOA) – date driving wheel damaged/misassembled at factory, dealer refused repair coverage due to low price, then claimed "water damage"
Sharing a factual timeline with WhatsApp screenshots and watchmaker macro photos so other buyers have the full context.
1. What Happened Out of the Box:
After receiving the watch, I wound it, set the hands to 6:30, set the date to the 15th, and turned the hands clockwise past midnight to the 16th.
The next morning, the date had not changed to the 17th. Advancing the hands manually showed the date flipping around 3:14 instead of midnight, followed by a hard stop at the crown around 7:56 with the seconds hand stopped. I did not force the crown or open the caseback myself, and I sent a video to MiroTime showing the issue.
2. Watchmaker Inspection & Macro Photos:
MiroTime asked if I had a local watchmaker who could open the caseback and check the movement, noting they recommend resolving issues like this locally.
I brought the watch to a local watchmaker. After opening it and inspecting the date works, he reported that the date driving wheel was damaged / not assembled properly at the factory.
I sent the watchmaker's macro photos to MiroTime. In the photos, the movement is dry and clean with no visible signs of moisture or water damage.
3. MiroTime's Replies: Discount Excuse & "Water Damage" Claim:
After follow-ups, MiroTime stated that because I received the "lowest possible discounted price," (which was just their listed price, not on sale), they were "unable to cover any additional repair costs".
I pushed back—noting that a low price shouldn't excuse a watch that wasn't assembled properly out of the box and not functioning, mentioning the impact on repeat business (including a friend's orders), and asking them to make it right.
MiroTime then asked how the issue could exist if the watch worked during QC and added: "It was functioning properly before the water damage occurred."
I replied pointing out that the movement in the macro photos is dry with no water damage and asked for a replacement A2836 GMT movement.
Summary:
I followed MiroTime's suggestion to have a local watchmaker inspect the watch and shared macro photos of the assembly issue, only to be denied repair coverage over the low price and then told there was "water damage". Posting the screenshots and photos here for community visibility.