r/RedditCritiques • u/powersynth102 • Nov 24 '16
r/RedditCritiques • u/Met2000 • Oct 23 '21
Some possible early sockpuppet used by Steve Huffman and Alexis Ohanian to generate Reddit "traffic"
As every Reddit history I've ever seen has stated: Reddit's founders started it in 2005, created sock accounts, and started posting "content" to the main page. To make Reddit look more popular than it actually was. No one knows if other Reddit founders like Aaron Swartz were involved in this charming little deception.
The earliest Reddit capture I can find was taken in 25 July 2005. The majority of the posts to the front page were by u/bugbear, who disappeared in 2006. Also on the front page repeatedly: spez/Huffman himself, plus some accounts that also stopped posting long ago, especially u/rtm. u/Meegan might be an actual early user as the account was still posting a year ago.
You could ask Reddit's management about this. I will be amazed if you get a straight answer.
r/RedditCritiques • u/StanleyKubrick62 • Aug 06 '22
The most amazing AMA ever....
This is Johnny Nguyen, the smoke shop owner in Las Vegas who nearly stabbed a would-be thief to death on August 3. This thread has been yanked by r/robbersgettingfucked, probably for the following exchanges:
Nguyen: I am the shopkeeper xD, but the potential criminal charges aren't really too concerning for me. I know I was in the right. They didn't have to rob me, I gave them an option to leave but they escalated the situation.
User 1: just replying here because it needs to be said.. Also, I'm not a lawyer, but, this advice is worth taking- and is being given from experience.
Delete this thread. Anything that you say here, can and will be used against you when the guy you stabbed sues you in civil court.
User 3: But in nearly all states, you can't generally use deadly force merely to defend your property. (Texas appears to be an exception, allowing use of deadly force when there's no other way to protect or recapture property even in situations involving simple theft or criminal mischief, though only at night, Tex. Penal Code § 9.42; see, e.g., McFadden v. State (Tex. Ct. App. 2018).) That's where we get the conventional formulation that you can't use deadly force just to defend property.
[2.] This conventional formulation, though, omits an important limitation: In basically all states, you can use nondeadly force to defend your property—and if the thief or vandal responds by threatening you with death or great bodily harm, you can then protect yourself with deadly force. So in practice, you can use deadly force to protect property after all, if you're willing to use nondeadly force first and expose yourself to increased risk.
You are so screwed lol
User 5: Holy fuck you’re dumb lol. You’re for sure gonna go to jail my dude. You better delete this post quick. Your life was never in danger, the guy never brandished a weapon, you did not have to stab the guy to defend yourself. He literally never even attempted to attack you. Your ass is getting locked up for sure especially if his lawyers find your post 😂
*****
And it goes on like this. Nguyen claims "his lawyer" said it was fine to go on Reddit to discuss what is an open investigation and the majority of commenters saying "delete this now", "get a new lawyer", etc.
https://www.icloud.com/photos/#01dU--6zN2JSu-XBtmujecpQA <---- His AMA "proof" of identity.
r/RedditCritiques • u/powersynth102 • Jul 03 '15
The u/chooter termination
2 July: Victoria "chooter" Taylor, the Reddit employee responsible for running the popular section r/IamA and originally hired in 2013, was suddenly let go for unexplained reasons. Indirect evidence suggests this happened due to an IamA thread featuring the Rev. Jesse Jackson. The result was a massive protest by hundreds of non-employee Reddit moderators, many of whom made their sections private in protest, including r/IamA itself.
https://www.reddit.com/r/Drama/comments/3bw66c/admin_chooter_aka_victoria_has_been_let_go_from/
https://www.reddit.com/r/pics/comments/3bwev7/i_had_the_pleasure_of_meeting_uchooter_in_person/]
Bloggers at ''Gawker'' and ''The Register'' were "amused".
http://gizmodo.com/reddit-is-tearing-itself-apart-1715545184
http://gawker.com/reddit-in-chaos-after-allegedly-firing-ama-coordinator-1715556970
r/RedditCritiques • u/Met2000 • Nov 13 '22
Marty Stratton vs Mick Gordon, one of the most evil tricks ever pulled on Reddit
Read this. It's long and will enrage any sane human being. Stratton, after years of screwing Gordon over financially and harassing him to work harder and faster on the soundtrack for DOOM Eternal, used a Reddit thread to stab Gordon in the back. And DOOM fanboys helped him by making hysterical death threats against Gordon AND his family. Two years later, Gordon posted this long statement proving that Stratton and id Software had cheated him AND tried to ruin his life. NOW the Redditors are going "oops, that's terrible, I guess I was wrong". Idiots.
https://medium.com/@mickgordon/my-full-statement-regarding-doom-eternal-5f98266b27ce#7f12
r/RedditCritiques • u/Heywood12 • Mar 31 '15
"Fat Hate" is actually a thing on Reddit....
I've been on Reddit for three years and I didn't find out about this idiocy until yesterday. By which I mean actual subreddits full of people calling themselves "shitlords" mocking fat people they run across, or pro-fat websites, et cetera ad nauseam.
List of anti-fat subs:
/r/talesoffathate (from sidebar: WE ARE A BMI OF 24.9 AND UNDER SUB. IF YOU ARE OVER THAT (UNLESS YOU'RE SWOLE) KINDLY GTFO) [Subreddit is now private.]
/r/fatsoshop (Photoshopping fat people skinny)
/r/choosingbeggars (mocking picky fat people on dating websites)
They also have an IRC channel at #fatpeoplehate
And they carry on over at the Blue Bird of 140 characters: https://twitter.com/rfatpeoplehate
Daily Dot did a story on these subreddits back in 2013, it seems the mentality of the Fat Hate people came with it in the comments:
Ray Montane Oct 17, 2014 LOL, you're probably a hamplanet yourself.
Anastasia Dreizin Nov 27, 2014 "Condishun" is referring to a faux medical ailment that hamplanets have invented so as to justify their incredibly poor eating habits.
Also, you sound fat; try not to let the fat-logic pull you into its Cheetos-powdered, ham-fisted grasp.
r/RedditCritiques • u/Met2000 • Jan 06 '23
The recent r/art moderator-abuse explosion
Oh, this is a hot one. Happened several days ago but just made the front page. The mods ALMOST got away with it.
https://nichegamer.com/art-subreddit-bans-artist-style-ai/
https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/chrisstokelwalker/art-subreddit-illustrator-ai-art-controversy
https://www.vice.com/en/article/y3p9yg/artist-banned-from-art-reddit
https://www.reddit.com/r/Artists/comments/103mja9/art_is_being_censored_on_reddit_the_mods_of_that/
Checking r/art, sure enough, the mods are carefully obliterating ANY criticisms or mentions of the artist, his art, or the controversy. They made the whole subreddit private for a time, complaining they were being "brigaded". It appears that r/art mods are a very arrogant bunch. Classic Reddit mod power trip and very similar to Wikipedia admin dirty tricks. Giving smug childish nerds any power over others, it's a bad idea.
The painting was reposted here. Doesn't look like "AI art" to me. And he's not getting banned.
https://www.reddit.com/r/drawing/comments/ztbtw9/a_muse_in_the_warzone/
He commented on his Deviant Art page:
https://www.deviantart.com/benmoranartist/status-update/AI-art-the-revolution-942653422
Good comment on Niche Gamer:
Most mods on Reddit are dumpster fire people. I've seen how stupid they get first hand. The Magic the Gathering subreddit basically had a full on revolt against a specific mod until they were finally able to oust him because he was banning people left and right over any tiny, tiny, tiny miniscule thing he could find.
r/RedditCritiques • u/powersynth102 • Jul 05 '15
Big news: Victoria Taylor used to edit Wikipedia for PAY. Thus violating a major WP policy.
Because Examiner links are "eeevil" on Reddit, do a web search for the title "Unmasking Victoria Taylor as a Wikipedian".
Note:
"So, we know that "AnnBLea" took a great deal of interest in creating and carefully maintaining Wikipedia's article about ID PR, at the same time that Victoria Taylor worked at ID PR. Thanks to the share-and-share-alike ethos of Wikimedia Commons, we also know that a Wikipedian was identified as "AnnBLea" in a photograph taken June 25, 2011 by Max Klein. We also can see that two days later, the LA Weekly published a photo of what appears to be the same "AnnBLea". Finally, we can follow ID PR's Twitter feed to see that when Victoria Taylor went over to Reddit, the person they identified photographically looks an awful lot like "AnnBLea". It's not rocket science to put it all together, that Victoria Taylor worked for ID public relations, then used a Wikipedia User account chosen to read nothing like her own name to author the Wikipedia article about ID public relations and many of their clients."
Also:
"As if that weren't enough, if you take a look at the Wikipedia editor who created Victoria Taylor's own Wikipedia biography yesterday, that's one Mr. Lane Rasberry. He is officially paid by Consumer Reports to cram Wikipedia full of references to Consumer Reports. You'd think that would be a practice that is frowned upon, but since he's a friend of various Wikipedia insiders (including paid editor Max Klein, who took Taylor's photo in the park that summer day in 2011), everyone looks the other way as he shills for Consumer Reports. If you want to see how Rasberry skews Wikipedia's content for Consumer Reports, just go take a look at Wikipedia's article about "toaster" and see if you notice anything odd about footnote #12."
r/RedditCritiques • u/GhostofHeywood12 • Jul 03 '24
The former operator of the "CoonTown" subreddit has been found.
The website that tracked down who StoneToss (aka Red Panels) is is now going through all the people involved with the Nationalist Coalition, a neo-Nazi group built from the ruins of the failed National Justice Party. One of them turns out to be "former" Reddit user u/GreatApeNiggy, founder/operation of the long-banned r/coontown subreddit, who in the great Reddit tradition had a large number of sockpuppets on multiple websites. He also ran a huge number of now-banned subreddits like r/altright, r/whitebeauty, r/Chimpout, etc. You might have run across him as George Arthur, Great Ape Nifty, Atomic Liberty, Real Sven Laden, etc. He's actually Micheal Anthony George, and he was at the "Unite the Right" rally holding a tiki torch the night of August 11, 2017. Interestingly enough, at r/coontown he worked alongside Joshua Ryne Goldberg, one of the greatest trolls on the internet, using his u/Europe88 handle. Goldberg later wasted a decade in jail for his Australi Witness Twitter persona, who claimed to be an Islamic State operative from Australia, and tried to set up terror attacks using that account. Just before he left prison Goldberg started a Medium site, at which he has recently accused Steve Albini of being a promoter and lover of child pornography (in fact, he did it the day after Albini died, because that's how trolls operate.)
But back to Micheal Anthony George; he is heavily involved in neo-Nazism online and at actual in-person events. He showed up at "TRSLMania" in Houston, Texas in 2017. This was a gathering of listeners/fans of The Right Stuff podcast where he got on the microphone and preached "White Sharia" (that is a concept too nasty to discuss here.) He also showed up to protest a drag brunch in Cookville, Tennessee last year. He was able to get people from the then-operating National Justice Party, Patriot Front, Tennessee Active Club, and Vinland Rebels to do a neo-Nazi street protest down the street. Like many of the movers and shakers of the neo-Nazi movement, he is involved with numerous groups using multiple handles (he has at least five handles under the name George Anthony using The Office's Kevin Malone character as an avatar on Facebook.) He tries to front as a sports dad and small time landlord, but his actual personality as a Nazi just keeps shining through.
r/RedditCritiques • u/Met2000 • Jun 02 '23
The Apollo/Christian Selig hellstorm
Obviously spez and his minions saw Musk try to price Twitter API access into low earth orbit, and said, "We hate these smartphone app developers anyway, how dare ANYONE make money off OUR badly-organized website, so yeah let's do it too!" So they tried it on Imgur first. Traffic declined drastically and complaints were made, but it did not die. So they implemented it on Reddit.
And now it's exploding in their stupid little millennial faces.https://www.cnn.com/2023/06/01/tech/reddit-outrage-data-access-charge/index.html
https://www.theverge.com/2023/5/31/23743993/reddit-apollo-client-api-cost
https://www.macrumors.com/2023/05/31/reddit-api-changes-pricing-apollo/
So....how is Reddit itself handling this? You WILL NOT find anything on the front page, in r/all, or on r/news. I can find nothing in other popular sections. Look at the comments in r/apolloapp/ for some examples. They are trying to censor it and badly. For example:
https://www.reddit.com/r/apolloapp/comments/13yivot/i_asked_the_person_to_show_a_screenshot_that_he/
This is at the top of r/technology today:
https://www.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/13yc62g/reddit_sparks_outrage_after_a_popular_app/
Oh, btw, it appears the Reddit management is now censoring the hell out of r/shitredditsays, one of the few subreddits where open criticism of Reddit was tolerated. It's almost dead. Good luck with that IPO, you little shits!
https://techcrunch.com/2023/06/01/fidelity-reddit-valuation/
r/RedditCritiques • u/Met2000 • Jul 29 '23
"Will Reddit get quality replacements? "Not a snowball's chance in hell.""
Child porn, dying animals, dying children, brutal 3rd world scenes of horror, and quite a lot of literal poop. So if anyone was bothered by graphic images, they should stay well away...And because your Reddit account can be permabanned at any time by Reddit's Anti-Evil Operations bot with a modest amount of reporting from a number of sockpuppet accounts, you're not able to tell these people to fuck off and go to hell when they inevitably ask why you're discriminating against them and their sickening photos.You have to maintain a veneer of pleasantness for even the most vile photos and the most abusive Redditors because those are the people that can and will get you banned in retaliation.
I don't doubt this kind of thing happens on Reddit routinely. However....speaking personally, the only interactions I've had with subreddit moderators usually ended with abuse from them, because I posted text or a link they didn't like on "their" subreddit. It was usually personal and petty.
Either you can be abused by random basement-neckbeard volunteer mods, or by mods installed by Reddit management. Hell of a "choice".
r/RedditCritiques • u/Met2000 • Jul 21 '23
r/malefashionadvice was seized in a very Wikipedian manner
At the time, the moderators expected to be removed after receiving a message from a Reddit admin (employee), ModCodeofConduct, telling them they would be replaced if they didn’t reopen......Now, the community’s modlist currently has just one moderator: ModCodeofConduct.
Similar things have happened on Reddit before, and it's a daily routine for Wikipedia admins. History keeps repeating itself and idiots with "special rights" on websites never remember it. Repression seems to be the default mode for social media.
r/RedditCritiques • u/Met2000 • Jun 17 '23
It's Saturday, have another report about Shutdown Madness
https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2023/06/the-reddit-protests-are-winding-down-so-whats-next/
I still suspect the management (however rotten) is right, this will eventually fade away and Reddit will continue as a dopamine factory and nerd trap. Hopefully with far less traffic and fewer willing advertisers. Check back in several months. ¯_(ツ)_/¯
Also: remember my mention of jimmyr.com yesterday? Shortly after my post, they drastically revamped their front page. Adding things like Hacker News, TechCrunch, and the Onion (?!) as "news sources for aggregation" as well as refocusing on the major subreddits that remained open. For the past week its front page was almost blank AND in a different format.
Plus don't be too surprised if r/ModCoord suddenly vanishes with no warning. Because people are using it to criticize Reddit management. They've disappeared subs like this before and they'll do it again.
r/RedditCritiques • u/Met2000 • Jun 16 '23
"Reddit Threatens to Remove Moderators From Subreddits Continuing Apollo-Related Blackouts"
COME ON, you all KNEW they would do this.
https://www.macrumors.com/2023/06/15/reddit-threatens-to-remove-subreddit-moderators/
r/RedditCritiques • u/Met2000 • Jun 13 '23
"Huffman says the blackout hasn’t had “significant revenue impact” and that the company anticipates that many of the subreddits will come back online by Wednesday."
https://www.theverge.com/2023/6/13/23759559/reddit-internal-memo-api-pricing-changes-steve-huffman
He may be right. Reddit is clearly a "false ochlocracy" little different from Wikipedia--just far less transparent and more paranoid. Now he wants to "top-down" it and push out the ochlocrats. And there's every indication he will pull it off.
Also: WHAT REVENUE?
r/RedditCritiques • u/bbb23sucks • Sep 23 '23
Fascist subreddits are still kept open by Reddit despite reports
There are many Fascist and neo-Fascist subreddits that despite numerous reports, have been kept open by Reddit. Examples include: r/truefascism r/FascismReclaimed
Amazing how they rush to ban Leftist subreddits and subreddits with slightly different views on certain social issues, yet they leave these ones open.
r/RedditCritiques • u/Met2000 • Sep 04 '23
"Reddit faces content quality concerns"
https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2023/09/are-reddits-replacement-mods-fit-to-fight-misinformation/
The dangers of food canning were explained to me clearly, succinctly, and with cited sources by Brad Barclay and someone going by Dromio05 on Reddit (who asked to withhold their real name for privacy reasons). Both were recently moderators on the r/canning subreddit and hold science-related master's degrees.
Yet Reddit removed both moderators from their positions this summer because Reddit said they violated its Moderator Code of Conduct. Mods had refused to end r/canning's protest against Reddit and its new API fees; the protest had made the entire subreddit "read only." Now, the ousted mods fear that r/canning could become subject to unsafe advice that goes unnoticed by new moderators. "My biggest fear with all this is that someone will follow an unsafe recipe posted on the sub and get badly sick or killed by it," Dromio05 told me.
We will never know how many people died because of stupid things they were told to do online. I bet the number of deaths from Tiktok "challenges" is considerable. But all that has to be kept quiet. Social media really doesn't tolerate "bad news".
Reddit is set up to INSURE silence and censorship. While also posing as a place full of "experts". Especially after dumping "uncooperative" subreddit moderators. I foresee big problems for Reddit management in the near future.
r/RedditCritiques • u/Met2000 • Jul 15 '23
If you thought Reddit Gold was bullshit, don't worry
They're ditching it. Along with paid subscriptions that avoid ads. Ha ha ha.
Dude, Twitter makes/used to recently make $30 per month in ads per user. It is galling how much more profitable ads are for apps and websites compared to subscription revenue.
https://www.reddit.com/r/reddit/comments/14ytp7s/reworking_awarding_changes_to_awards_coins_and/
https://www.theverge.com/2023/7/13/23794403/reddit-gold-awards-coins-sunset
https://techcrunch.com/2023/07/14/reddit-is-killing-its-gold-awards-system/
They're gonna SATURATE this site with advertising. Actually surprised they didn't do it before.
Barely noticed during the protests: the obliteration of user PM and chat histories.
https://mashable.com/article/reddit-removes-live-chat-archives-messages
r/RedditCritiques • u/Met2000 • Jul 08 '23
"Reddit mods fear spam overload as BotDefense leaves “antagonistic” Reddit"
FYI no one really seems to know how many moderation bots are being used on Reddit. Like Wikipedia many people write their own, and never declare them. If the front page fills with blatant spamming and phishing, you will know why.
And at the top of my front-page feed right now:
https://www.theverge.com/2023/7/6/23786474/reddit-nsfw-moderator-protest-final-warning
"Going NSFW puts up an age gate and means that the subreddit is not eligible for advertising, creating friction for users, and potentially affecting Reddit’s ability to monetize the channel."
Ahhhh. Inevitably money was involved.
r/RedditCritiques • u/Met2000 • Jun 15 '23
15 june: 5146 subreddits still dark
I can only imagine the hellstorms within the Reddit moderation "community" this week. As if they were an actual community, and not a random mob of basement nerds fighting over subreddit powerz. Dozens of high-ranking subs have either reopened or opened in a restricted manner.
and posted today:
https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2023/06/reddit-blackout/
YOU SHITHEAD. It already WAS crap. The majority of such online communities are cooked up with the seeds of their own self-destruction baked in. Furthermore, only a fool would take Cory Doctorow's "business advice". He is not an expert on internet business, he is a nerd who writes horrible trendy hipster-slanted novels.
r/RedditCritiques • u/GhostofHeywood12 • May 07 '23
"Reddit killed Pushshift, all Reddit threads and comments after 1 May 2023 no longer get archived, remember to archive anything *important* that you see."
From here: https://www.reddit.com/r/stupidpol/comments/13aaacn/psa_reddit_killed_pushshift_all_reddit_threads/
Quote:
The title is self-explanatory, Reddit ended the ability for pushshift to archive posts and comments of the whole site on 1 May, as a result, sites like unddit et all no longer contain posts and comments made after 1 May, so once they are gone, they are gone for good unless someone archived them previously.
In case there is anything noteworthy on this sub or any other sub in general you like, archive them in any way you see possible, especially with these:
However, from what I see these sites do not archive literally all of the discussions, you can do it the old-fashioned way by just simply showing all comments, copy and pasting all of them on a text file, or the classic method of just taking a screenshot of the whole page, it is a rough way to archive, but this can at least save these long schizoposts, so that they will survive for future generations to read them in some way.
r/RedditCritiques • u/Met2000 • Feb 03 '23
Still firing people.....badly
That narrative has not changed. Even as Reddit has cut staff, the company has said repeatedly it's not conducting layoffs like other tech companies, telling Insider (and its own employees) that staffers were let go in January strictly based on performance in the normal course of business and that it planned to rehire for most roles. Reddit has over 1,800 employees, the spokesperson said.
But insiders said Reddit's insistence that it was simply cutting low performers has sparked anger. The Reddit spokesperson declined to elaborate on how performance was assessed for these cuts.
So they lie to everyone about everything, including their own employees. Classic Silly Valley tricks--probably dumping older employees, because they "cost more to keep on staff". Last more than 10 or 15 years and they WILL toss you. And replace you with someone younger, dumber and easier to exploit on the job.
This time, it WAS posted on Reddit, in r/technology. And people changed the subject to Google layoffs. At least, some other commenters had similar stories in the tech business, so it's not an isolated instance.
https://www.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/10s1nbf/reddit_staffers_who_lost_jobs_livid_at_being/
r/RedditCritiques • u/Mrindalpandey • Jan 04 '23
"r/all is now basically Facebook"
in this thread: https://www.reddit.com/r/nextfuckinglevel/comments/1034zlj/weightlessness_during_freefall/
Reddit's r/all is now basically Facebook. Random pictures of women 'muh wife is smiling' or sob stories 'It's been 1024 years, but I finally feel good' with a picture of them in a basic hoodie, or another sob story 'I just beat cancer' or 'cancer just killed me, whoo!'
That, or pictures of cats and 'muh furbaby is 12 years old tuhday!'
Basically, the boomers have found Reddit.
r/RedditCritiques • u/richards1052 • Feb 07 '22
Reddit permanent ban removed
Thanks for u/heywood12 for posting here about my recent permanent ban by an apparent pro-Israel Reddit admin who has been targeting me over the past few weeks with temporary suspensions and then a permanent ban.
I've appealed them all and every one I appealed was lifted. But clearly this admin will continue to target me. And you may/probably will find me in the dog house with this admin in future. There doesn't seem any way to communicate with senior admins about the abuse of admins such as this one of their privileges and role. Which is a major flaw in the system here.
FOr a more comprehensive account of my recent trials and tribulations which puts my personal situation in a broader context of social media censorship of progressive voices, including on Reddit, pls read my blog post: https://www.richardsilverstein.com/2022/02/05/reddit-and-digital-censorship/
I will also be publishing an article on this at The New Arab soon and will link to it here. Thanks again to all who offered support.