r/RedditCritiques • • Aug 23 '16

"Welcome to Reddit 5.0: "We're infested with Nazis now.""

0 Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/pics/comments/4z8i1n/nordic_genes/

"We're infested with Nazis now"? They always were..... and yes, the OP is a very unpleasant person. Evidently sees Marxists, feminists, and people of color as behind all the world's troubles. Posts heavily on r/The_Donald. Why isn't he banned?

https://www.reddit.com/user/BlondWhiteMale


r/RedditCritiques • • Mar 16 '18

VICE's Motherboard has article on r/drama video of man committing suicide that was linked to the subreddit FOR NINE HOURS, which broke Reddit's own rules on graphic content.

0 Upvotes

VICE's article here.

The video itself was taken from a YouTube livestream where the man (name unknown, "Robot" is an alleged handle) at one point held up a piece of paper "calling out" the 4chan board /r9k/ before he killed himself with a shot to the head by shotgun. The video vanished off YouTube, was mirrored, and the link was only yanked when Motherboard ran the story.

A r/drama thread of charming responses to the entire incident is here. And here's the kinda-original thread with the Sendvid mirror of the original.

Some thread quotes from the one about VICE's article:

Velvet_Llama 14 points 11 hours ago

OH SHIT HIDE YOUR WAIFUS THE NORMIES ARE COMING.

COINTELPROxShareBlue 4 points 10 hours ago

more like the admins. This is not good publicity for us lol

voicelesshoodwinker 21 points 12 hours ago*

Well, it was nice knowing ya all. We got negative mainstream press, which means - we're probably fucked.

I just wanted to thank r/drama mod team, Toasty Ed, The_Rachel, other dramanauts ( even Zachums, because his pug is cute!) and fine users of r/drama chat for everything. 😘

https://lh5.googleusercontent.com/-ws2DvaB1tLc/TtjBdgViNuI/AAAAAAAAYAI/EnLbjx1ThI0/s0/igloo17.jpg

Also, WatchPeopleDie is a more mainstream sub than us, write about then, you Vice idiots.

gilmore606 2 points 5 hours ago

me too thanks :(


r/RedditCritiques • • May 09 '15

If you like to see real-time Reddit shitstorms, go to r/subredditdrama.

2 Upvotes

r/subredditdrama

(Just don't post a link to this subreddit there, because it will be deleted. Happened once before already. Apparently they don't want serious analysis of Reddit issues, they just want to gawk at crazy shit.)


r/RedditCritiques • • Aug 04 '21

r/MGTOW goes poof (instead of "its own way")

1 Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/SubredditDrama/comments/ox8h0u/rmgtow_has_been_banned/

r/MGTOW2 was apparently similar and got the same nuking.

Daily Dot article

Part of the ā€œMen Go Their Own Way" (MGTOW) movement, the r/MGTOW subreddit was run by advocates of male separatism or the belief that men must distance themselves from women and society. The subreddit, according to a January 2020 report from a team of computer scientists, had been linked to numerous instances of ā€œonline harassment and real-world violence.ā€

It linked to the original MIT Technology Review report. https://www.technologyreview.com/2020/02/07/349052/the-manosphere-is-getting-more-toxic-as-angry-men-join-the-incels/

Which linked to this paper, dated April 2021 but appearing to be older. https://arxiv.org/pdf/2001.07600.pdf

Looks as if it took Reddit management a while to act on this "bad news". Typical.


r/RedditCritiques • • Aug 27 '18

David Katz, aka u/ravenchamps

0 Upvotes

Something little noted in the media about Katz, the Madden 19 tournament shooter; he was a Reddit regular.

https://www.reddit.com/user/ravenchamps

His history was being discussed in various parts of 4chan. (Predictably there was considerable "oh, a filthy Jew" bullshitting. Those little bastards will never ever grow up.) Katz also used the name "bread" on gaming forums.

In case Katz's account "mysteriously disappears", I copy-pasted his last 20 or so messages. Final one was 12 days ago, someone asked him what he was playing recently and he answered "Madden 19". Which would tend to verify his identity. Otherwise....christ what an arrogant snotty little twat. And there are indications he used to go into t_d and fight with the Trumpies.


ravenchamps commented on What PC Game have you been playing a lot lately?Discussion •r/pcmasterrace•Posted byu/cyrptonaut ravenchamps 1 point Ā· 12 days ago Madden 19

ravenchamps commented on Is it worth it to upgrade the CPU on this build?Question •r/pcmasterrace•Posted byu/ZMoney187 ravenchamps 5 points Ā· 12 days ago I'd wait to upgrade to a new board. That CPU should still hold up and do fine.

ravenchamps commented on Josh Norman a step late on a pick today. Teammates response: "It ain't Kirk throwing the ball no more, JNo! He gone!" twitter.com/Kenned... •r/nfl•Posted byu/DMVBornDMVRaised SackRVC17 4 points Ā· 1 month ago NOW HERE’S A GUY

ravenchamps 3 points Ā· 1 month ago That can't play receiver

ravenchamps commented on Flacco throws 5 TDs in the first half against the Bucs, including a 56 yarder to SSSr. •r/ravens•Posted byu/Watawkichaw ravenchamps 1 point Ā· 1 month ago Boy was I happy when it was my quarterbacks bye week in fantasy and I said Fuck it let's see what Flacco does.

ravenchamps commented on Any good games?Discussion •r/pcmasterrace•Posted byu/YDontUGitGudM8 ravenchamps 2 points Ā· 1 month ago What genre

ravenchamps commented on Need advice with a new GPUDiscussion •r/pcmasterrace•Posted byu/Blackfries ravenchamps 1 point Ā· 1 month ago For $500 look for a 1080 that could go on sale or go with a 1070ti.

ravenchamps commented on 8 Years in my Anxious life - SSRI's, Benzos and Blood Pressure [OC]OC i.redd.it/t7hofy... •r/dataisbeautiful•Posted byu/Caiobrz Caiobrz 0 points Ā· 1 month ago I don't know if keeping the records help me, in fact I started feeling it didn't (talk about that in a moment), but they give me an important sense that I am not abusing the substance and that therefore it is ok to use them when needed. I had some problem earlier in the treatment because I kept having panic attacks or let a normal anxiety escalate to very uncomfortable because I feared that I was taking too much, or that I should only take the meds after I was anxious, so my doctor told me that, if I was that worried, I could keep these records to show myself (because I was always honest with her, thus she knew I was ok) I was well below the 1.5mg average that is considered the danger line to habit making. see more

ravenchamps 1 point Ā· 1 month ago Pathetic

ravenchamps commented on Rate my setupBattlestation i.redd.it/4v9qvj... •r/pcmasterrace•Posted byu/SIMMETIK Get_Back_To_Work_Now 33 points Ā· 1 month ago It appears to be a computer

ravenchamps 3 points Ā· 1 month ago Big if true

ravenchamps commented on 200k on the Xbox edition!Screenshot i.redd.it/wt27vh... •r/CitiesSkylines•Posted byu/Jmonch70 Caiobrz -10 points Ā· 1 month ago 200k on Xbox is probably using 100% CPU nonstop.

see more ravenchamps 2 points Ā· 1 month ago Aren't you an idiot who doesn't know how modern technology works.

Caiobrz 0 points Ā· 1 month ago Hei stupid, they have a sub for you: /r/woosh

ravenchamps 3 points Ā· 1 month ago Youre probably great at party's.

ravenchamps commented on do not plan interchanges after not sleepingScreenshot i.redd.it/sbnuve... •r/CitiesSkylines•Posted byu/RagingAcid ravenchamps 1 point Ā· 1 month ago Need more curves

ravenchamps commented on Dual 4k monitors or dual 144hz?Discussion •r/pcmasterrace•Posted byu/Cross_Beaulieu AsusFanBoyyy -1 points Ā· 2 months ago Why you have a good grammar?

ravenchamps 1 point Ā· 2 months ago Stay in school

ravenchamps commented on Rx 580 cf vs gtx 1070Build •r/pcmasterrace•Posted byu/muddieboi ravenchamps 0 points Ā· 2 months ago I'm sorry, but your friend doesn't have a clue of what he's talking about.

muddieboi 1 point Ā· 2 months ago I mean he does know a bit, but probably not as much as I thought.

ravenchamps 2 points Ā· 2 months ago You don't need 32 gb of ram for gaming at all. You can get a 16gb kit and put that money towards a 1080ti. Don't crossfire as less and less games support it and that'll continue going forward. Seriously, your buddys suggestions are really bad. ravenchamps commented on I love the colour blue. Can you tell? i.redd.it/qldagm...

•r/battlestations•Posted byu/DBSs- DBSs- 1 point Ā· 2 months ago and water bottle :)

ravenchamps 1 point Ā· 2 months ago Can clearly see all of that /s

DBSs- 1 point Ā· 2 months ago Im sorry but what is /s?

ravenchamps 1 point Ā· 2 months ago Sarcasm

ravenchamps commented on What plan backfired spectacularly? •r/AskReddit•Posted byu/acrowsmurder Elranzer -21 points Ā· 2 months ago Ā· edited 2 months ago EDIT: Guess not.

ravenchamps 0 points Ā· 2 months ago .....stay in history class

ravenchamps commented on The ā€œI’ll Delete My Account Ifā€ Post •r/nba•Posted byu/pierce_brady_ortiz [deleted] 3.1k points Ā· 2 months ago Kawhi signs with the Spurs this offseason or I'll delete my account.

ravenchamps 2 points Ā· 2 months ago Dead

ravenchamps commented on I want to build my first pc •r/pcmasterrace•Posted byu/Rafiki55 ravenchamps 0 points Ā· 2 months ago r/buildapc

ravenchamps commented on Sorry, but I'm leavingStory •r/pcmasterrace•Posted byu/xacrimon ravenchamps 2 points Ā· 2 months ago Bye bitch

ravenchamps commented on Next upgrade choice?Hardware •r/pcmasterrace•Posted byu/575mewtwo ravenchamps 1 point Ā· 2 months ago A gpu


r/RedditCritiques • • Mar 29 '15

How Reddit Became a Worse Black Hole of Violent Racism than Stormfront (Gawker lists loads of anti-Black subreddits)

Thumbnail
gawker.com
4 Upvotes

r/RedditCritiques • • Aug 07 '19

Chapo Trap House subreddit quarantined for shakey reasons

Thumbnail old.reddit.com
5 Upvotes

r/RedditCritiques • • Jul 05 '15

Big news: Victoria Taylor used to edit Wikipedia for PAY. Thus violating a major WP policy.

11 Upvotes

Because Examiner links are "eeevil" on Reddit, do a web search for the title "Unmasking Victoria Taylor as a Wikipedian".

Note:

"So, we know that "AnnBLea" took a great deal of interest in creating and carefully maintaining Wikipedia's article about ID PR, at the same time that Victoria Taylor worked at ID PR. Thanks to the share-and-share-alike ethos of Wikimedia Commons, we also know that a Wikipedian was identified as "AnnBLea" in a photograph taken June 25, 2011 by Max Klein. We also can see that two days later, the LA Weekly published a photo of what appears to be the same "AnnBLea". Finally, we can follow ID PR's Twitter feed to see that when Victoria Taylor went over to Reddit, the person they identified photographically looks an awful lot like "AnnBLea". It's not rocket science to put it all together, that Victoria Taylor worked for ID public relations, then used a Wikipedia User account chosen to read nothing like her own name to author the Wikipedia article about ID public relations and many of their clients."

Also:

"As if that weren't enough, if you take a look at the Wikipedia editor who created Victoria Taylor's own Wikipedia biography yesterday, that's one Mr. Lane Rasberry. He is officially paid by Consumer Reports to cram Wikipedia full of references to Consumer Reports. You'd think that would be a practice that is frowned upon, but since he's a friend of various Wikipedia insiders (including paid editor Max Klein, who took Taylor's photo in the park that summer day in 2011), everyone looks the other way as he shills for Consumer Reports. If you want to see how Rasberry skews Wikipedia's content for Consumer Reports, just go take a look at Wikipedia's article about "toaster" and see if you notice anything odd about footnote #12."


r/RedditCritiques • • Jun 18 '20

No one's bothering or restricting "boogaloo" related subreddits

1 Upvotes

r/boogaloo is invitation only, but

r/boogalooinc r/weekendgunnit

are still wide open (and fuck are they STUPID places).


r/RedditCritiques • • Nov 12 '18

Clearest proof that Reddit is not a "news site", it is a nerd ghetto

1 Upvotes

Right now the top front-page items on Reddit are NOT anything in top headlines at major newspapers, CNN, USA Today, etc. It is something really important to comic-book worshipping basement dwellers.

https://www.reddit.com/r/news/comments/9wgrdf/report_stan_lee_dead_at_95_story/ https://www.reddit.com/r/OldSchoolCool/comments/9wh0zx/stan_lee_at_the_1975_comiccon_rip/

Numerous subreddits also have Stan's death as the top-voted story; r/television, r/movies, r/comics, r/books, on and on. The only word I can think of is "embarrassing".


r/RedditCritiques • • Jun 21 '19

r/frenworld is kicked

1 Upvotes

Just happened today. Why?

https://www.reddit.com/r/TopMindsOfReddit/comments/c2yrky/rfrenworld_has_been_banned/ https://www.reddit.com/r/AgainstHateSubreddits/comments/c0kisd/behold_how_far_right_ethnonationalists_are_now/

Those are pretty good reasons.

But r/clownworldwar is still there, and so is r/honkler, and others....what fucking idiots. Can't stop socking and creating sock subreddits. Never get the idea: the rest of Reddit wants them gone.

There is even an anti-frenworld sub: https://www.reddit.com/r/antifafrenworld/


r/RedditCritiques • • Jul 06 '15

Ellen Pao apologizes

Thumbnail
reddit.com
5 Upvotes

r/RedditCritiques • • Nov 09 '25

partisan downvotes by Reddit mob?

2 Upvotes

I’ve noticed that whenever I engage or comment on anything even that may be construed as remotely political and it’s not in full alignment with the extreme-left consensus it gets buried in downvotes.

It honestly feels like there are downvote mobs ready to crush any thought that doesn’t perfectly match their worldview, regardless of whether your point is logical or sourced. We all have bias but there is also the pursuit of truth so don’t you want to know the other side?

I’ve had well-reasoned, factual comments disappear while emotional, zero logic comments rack up +50 upvotes.

I hadn’t even realized how much my karma dropped until I tried to make a post in a personal finance sub and my post was not allowed.

I’m not someone who needs validation or internet points I just genuinely wonder if others have noticed how Reddit is one big left political echo chamber?


r/RedditCritiques • • Dec 17 '19

Think t/d is the worst of Reddit?

2 Upvotes

Have I got a moronic (and popular) subreddit for you:

r/weekendgunnit/

Mentioned because there's a front-page thread expressing concern about their apparent desire to have a "Virginia luau", since Virginia is considering a number of new gun-control laws. So a bunch of stupid incels are gonna go to Virginia in January and have a violent "boogaloo"?

If you're looking for a subreddit to ban, there ya go.


r/RedditCritiques • • Apr 26 '19

r/cringeanarchy was banned at 5:07 PM EST today

2 Upvotes

That subreddit was one of those "hey let's repost the cringy things said on leftwing subreddits we don't like!" subs that over time took in all the people from the banned subreddits like the one for Million Dollar Extreme, the long-banned r/coontown, etc. Because Reddit allows sockpuppets, we have no idea who was involved with what, but a good number of the CringeAnarchy crowd were probably r/The_Donald users came from places more extreme than r/The_Donald. What I can say is that r/cringeanarchy was banned for not keeping their hordes in line (doxxing, personal threats, calls for ethnic cleansing, other rule breaking are claimed as reasons.)

Thread on Subreddit Drama on the subject, listing a lot of what happened.

Previous thread on SD three days ago listing more stuff; the sub had been quarantined since 2018.

"The final warning" modmail thread between Reddit HQ and the CringeAnarchy moderators

Chapo Trap House had two threads on the banning, this is one of them.

This entire event has been seen by the far-right "shitposting" community as a massive betrayal of Reddit's "free speech" policies, forgetting that Reddit is a private company and almost every company backtracks when their policies begin to cut into their profits or their ability to sell themselves to future users, and as this subreddit has reported, the history of Reddit is full of nastiness.

(BTW, we need to start a list of banned subreddits, or find a bunch of smaller lists and copypaste them into a huge one.)


r/RedditCritiques • • Jun 15 '23

Hey reddit u/spez save reddit block all moderators on strike name new ones

0 Upvotes

As this, no way communities still hostage from few "moderators" and super-moderators , most people if not all their communities content doesn't belong them but to the bunch of people collaborating.

An gruesome example is r/Synology, by long Time founder moderators was MIA by no specific reason we respect, then he/she appears and start a process to select new moderators, and that was the last time community has an opinion on that sub, new moderators suspiciously are aligned with Synology on hiding community resources to circumvent blatlant annoying restrictions at their products, and everyone criticism on this get banned, criticism on joining this strike was punished with a 30 day ban, as every time I criticize lack of action about a thread catalog to share all the good resources on solving issues or circumvent restrictions on our devices I got blatant warnings.

IMHO all 4 moderators at r/Synology is the same person on different aliases.

He/she is blatlantly aligned with Apollo, and ignore his community don't belong (neither she created it) her.

IMHO u/spez should ban all moderators on strike or at least deranged them and open the communities and create a tool to select new moderators not aligned with external agendas .


r/RedditCritiques • • Aug 22 '18

Who is Stefan Karl Steffanson?

2 Upvotes

r/RedditCritiques • • Sep 29 '18

The quarantine system was revised--a number of provocative subreddits were locked down

2 Upvotes

From the announcements section: https://www.reddit.com/r/announcements/comments/9jf8nh/revamping_the_quarantine_function/

It covered some racist sections, assorted political extremism (left and right), and just plain disgusting things like r/watchpeopledie, which numerous users have complained about for years. All are still accessible but you must be logged in and punch a button.

Daily Beast article https://www.thedailybeast.com/reddit-quarantines-white-nationalist-subreddits

Verge https://www.theverge.com/2018/9/28/17914240/reddit-update-quarantine-policy-appeals-process

"Quarantined subreddits are still held to the same content policy that governs the rest of Reddit. But if that’s true, and the content that’s posted in these forums is vile enough for site admins to consider it toxic to the rest of the site, then why not just ban the offending subreddits entirely?"

Uh, yeah. Gooooood question.


r/RedditCritiques • • Feb 10 '18

Palmer Luckey, cofounder of Oculus and a notorious right-wing dudebro, is made a moderator of r/oculus. It ends up at the top of r/subredditdrama.

Thumbnail
reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/RedditCritiques • • Mar 06 '18

Someone points out that t_d might be tolerated because Josh Kushner is a major stakeholder in Reddit. The comment is swiftly deleted--but others keep the thread going, so it was pointless.

3 Upvotes

https://np.reddit.com/r/announcements/comments/827zqc/in_response_to_recent_reports_about_the_integrity/dv8lk7y/?context=3

[–]JoshKushnerOwnsYou 1219 points 11 hours ago* [removed]

[–]thisisthewell 136 points 9 hours ago Can you clarify the $50m figure? I don't see that on your Crunchbase link (I assume it requires signing up for an account), but Business Insider and Recode both say that $50m was the total from the investment round, not from only Thrive Capital.

[–]BiBiBicycle 156 points 10 hours ago Oh shit, I had no idea about this. Do you have an article I can read or anything?

[–]JoshKushnerOwnsYou 158 points 10 hours ago https://www.crunchbase.com/funding_round/reddit-series-b--662ba273/investors/investors_list#section-investors

ĀÆ\(惄)/ĀÆ


r/RedditCritiques • • Jan 22 '22

R/antiwork was overwhelmed with misogyny today

3 Upvotes

A woman posted a Tiktok video of her office (tech industry i guess) and people piled onto her, claiming she was a whore, got her job thru sex, made threats etc. the usual childish boy shit. The thread was eventually deleted, but someone else posted this criticism. It was HEAVILY upvoted. And many women chimed in with their own terrible stories. But the original post is still gone.

https://www.reddit.com/r/antiwork/comments/s9iviz/the_misogyny_in_this_sub_is_so_gross_everyone/

Example

As a SW and someone who was in the targets of every single incel from both Reddit AND 4Chan at the same time, I can seriously say that Reddit is by far the worst of the two.

Redditors are self-righteous. They're the ones that doxxed me, sent me non-stop death threats, approached me IRL, and had mods refuse to remove my private information on a sub with millions of people (r/greentext). You know it's fucked up when /b was even like "whoa, okay, maybe this has gone a little too far".


r/RedditCritiques • • Jun 05 '23

"WAHHHHH we're not happy, GONNA SHUT DOWN SUBREDDITS"

3 Upvotes

https://www.theverge.com/2023/6/5/23749188/reddit-subreddit-private-protest-api-changes-apollo-charges

https://www.engadget.com/reddit-communities-are-going-dark-to-protest-changes-that-would-hurt-third-party-apps-154133342.html

Bloody fools should have done this 10 years ago.

As social media developed, it became clear that tinpot dictatorships would be tolerated by the stupid/self-obsessed userbase. Feed their dopamine secretions and you can be Zucc or Jack Dorsey. It cannot be denied anymore: Huffman wants to have himself a little tin pot.

He's tired of giving the people what they want. He learned NOTHING from the failures of Livejournal, Myspace, and Digg, plus a hundred stillborn social sites that no one's ever heard of. Also learned nothing from watching Lord Elon screw Twitter into the ground.

Wonder how many popular subreddits will be banned and how many 'unruly' moderators will be kicked off the platform permanently. They've done it before.

Also wonder how long this thread will last

https://www.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/141borj/major_reddit_communities_will_go_dark_to_protest/

Have a nice day, suckers, and jam a Vision Pro headset up your collective asses


r/RedditCritiques • • Dec 03 '20

An excellent example of the Reddit incel/manboy culture

3 Upvotes

Someone posts a photo of an abandoned house in South Dakota. And hundreds of Redditors show up to post Courage The Cowardly Dog comments (despite the house looking nothing like Courage's house). Is this site full of people who stopped developing at age 12?

https://www.reddit.com/r/pics/comments/k5a0b8/mammatus_clouds_over_an_abandoned_house_in_south/

The house from the actual cartoon is totally different--apart from being run-down: https://tvseriesfinale.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/11/courage-the-cowardly-dog-590x307.jpeg


r/RedditCritiques • • Jun 27 '19

After calling for violence against Oregon police and politicians, subreddit The_Donald was quarantined, knocking it off the front page.

4 Upvotes

This was noticed by Media Matters on Monday, that r/The_Donald was hyperventilating about 11 GOP state senators in Oregon who left the state to not vote on a cap and trade bill. Of course the rhetoric spiraled out of control, so we had u/john_denvers_dick writing "4th generation Oregonian here, I have seen my beloved state turn into North California. The only way to get it back is to burn Portland and Eugene to the ground.šŸ”„šŸ”„šŸ”„." The ranting turned into a froth as u/PsychicRussianSpy wrote "Rifles are the only way we're going to get any peace in our lives ever again these people will not stop because they're got crazy people energy crazy people energy you know what that is they don't have a life so it's just this bullshit it's either war and we get rid of these guys or a lifetime of listening to this shit over and over again start getting yourself ready I think this should happen cuz I want some fucking piece from these people[.]"

After nearly two days of this, Reddit made the decision to quarantine the subreddit about seven hours ago, in a moderator message on The_Donald that was yanked. Here is The Verge's take.


r/RedditCritiques • • Jan 06 '15

This is terrible information

4 Upvotes

Are you working to keep posting more such bad stories? How many are there to talk about?