r/QuantumPhysics • • Feb 13 '25

Why are the mods selectively removing comments and then deciding what’s correct or incorrect?

0 Upvotes

In this post: https://www.reddit.com/r/QuantumPhysics/s/98kFhN4JDa, the top comment (rightfully) said we don’t know. The mod instead gets an (unjustified) ego trip, declares the top comment to be wrong, and then removes it at his own discretion. The person who commented it is an avid user of this sub as well. Is this normal for this sub?


r/QuantumPhysics • • Sep 22 '23

Could Quantum Mechanics account for f r e e w i l l?

0 Upvotes

[Before it’s suggested that this post is off-topic, consider there there is NO CONSENSUS on why the wave function collapses upon measurement. While my question might ‘seem’ too ‘mystical’ or ‘dualistic’ or whatever other adjective you like, I truly mean to cut right to the heart of one the deepest mysteries in quantum theory]

Most arguments against free will rely on the notion that free will is incompatible with causal determinism—the view that every event in the universe is an effect of physical causes which precede it. However, as is well established in quantum theory, the universe at the fundamental level is inherently NOT deterministic. Specifically, the act of measurement collapses the wave function in a non-deterministic manner.

So my question is whether the non determinism of QM provides a substrate for free choices to truly exist in our universe—which are not effects of any prior causes. The Free Will theorem by Conway and Kochen seems to argue along these lines.

To my mind there are two things in the universe we understand to be ‘free’ or nondeterministic: 1) quantum mechanical systems (upon measurement), and 2) ourselves.

Have any prominent physicists commented on this question?

We are made of matter, and matter is quantum mechanical on the most fundamental level. Is it really so radical to suppose our best theory of physics accounts for everyday experience as well as particle-collider experiments?


r/QuantumPhysics • • Dec 17 '23

How photons know that someone is observing and why would it care during Double slit experiment ?

0 Upvotes

I’ve been thinkinng about double slit experiment from few days and i am unable to understand how photons know that someone is observing the experiment ? All these particles are not concious like human beings then how such human like behaviour is observed in photons during double slit experiment ?


r/QuantumPhysics • • Oct 30 '25

Quantum mechanics isn’t really that strange

0 Upvotes

I’m talking in particular about superposition and quantum entanglement.

It’s not strange if you consider the fact that a measuring device can affect the outcome of an experiment.

Imagine for example that you measured the velocity of a ball by bouncing another ball off it. You would affect the velocity of the ball by bouncing another ball off of it. On a microscopic scale this is more pronounced, because what is observable to the human eye is a lot larger than what is not.


r/QuantumPhysics • • Jul 08 '24

Does Einstein's "God doesn't play dice" hold in light of success of A-bomb?

0 Upvotes

(I'm a complete beginner, so feel free to correct me - I will not take any offense)

From what I understand, it seems from QM's findings that there is a real element of randomness in the universe. I've heard that Einstein didn't like that conclusion, because he wouldn't accept the implication that "God plays dice with the universe".

That being said, quantum theory was utilized in the creation of a practical weapon. That means that it's not just theory, but it actually works in practice. If so, wouldn't Einstein be forced to admit that QM is real and correct, ergo that God does play dice with the universe???

Thank you very much


r/QuantumPhysics • • Jul 03 '24

Question about what exactly we know about the quantum realm

1 Upvotes

I'm just a creative writer who's listened to a few podcasts on quantum things, so bear with me:

From what I've remembered, we found that the quantum realm or state is between material and immaterial (nothingness) and we managed to find a way to interact with that piece of reality by supercooling everything and making sure gravity doesn't affect the motions of atoms in that quantum lab in space.

My question is, does the quantum state of things move faster than atoms, and will it lead into research on Faster Than Light phenomena, or something close to reaching the speed of time?

I know it's not as easy as describing magic, but I want to know if that's where we're headed to when it comes down to Quantum studies, or if I'm just wrong and I just don't know the minute details of what the quantum realm does in its existence as part of our universe.


r/QuantumPhysics • • Dec 22 '24

Has quantum mechanics and general relativity been unified? If so, what do they collectively imply about the structure of reality?

0 Upvotes

I do not know the deep technicals behind quantum mechanics. But I am still curious about the relevance of quantum mechanics on cosmological forces, and if its potential influence is at all relevant on a macrocosmic scale. Or do we not entirely know yet. If we don’t know yet, how can we get closer to knowing definitively?


r/QuantumPhysics • • Jun 12 '26

Quantum physics theories

0 Upvotes

Hi all,

I very recently got interested in quantum physics, its mechanics, and whether multiversal travel is possible.

I want to start trying to crack this little conundrum to see if we can travel between multiverses, but I have no idea what theories or math equations I need to focus on to make this happen.

Any suggestions on where to start?


r/QuantumPhysics • • Jun 07 '24

Are we Real?

11 Upvotes

I Learned this in physics class today

IF MASS CAN BE DESTROYED INTO ENERGY THEN THAT MEANS ENERGY CAN BE CREATED INTO MASS, THUS EVERYTHING(mass) IN THE UNIVERSE IS MADE OF ENERGY.
ENERGY CREATES MASS AND MASS CREATES (destroyed into) ENERGY THIS IS REVOLUTIONARY.
Energy is "The Ability to do work"
Does that mean then everything is made of the ability to do work.
WHICH MAKES NO SENSE. Because its essentially saying we are made of a concept.
But Lo and Behold of this discovery.
Energy is supposed to be a concept to explain how stuff exists ie movement.
So we are made of this very concept is crazy to me.
Mass creates energy. Energy creates mass.
Hence everything (elementary particles) is just energy / made from energy 😵.

pls correct me if anything I said was incorrect.

Edit: thanks to everyone who answered and helped me understand this through. I read a lot of good explanations to this and I hadn't realized E = mc2 talks about this. And my question is absurd under a false premise of what reality is supposed to be. I was just on a rabbit hole of if mass is tangible and energy isn't then by everything being made of energy, the tangible(mass) is made by the non tangible if that makes sense. But either way comments pointed out the flaw in my premise


r/QuantumPhysics • • Sep 02 '24

What to do if I have… theories…

4 Upvotes

I have contacted a university and they ignored me…


r/QuantumPhysics • • 22d ago

Hey I have a question. Can we actually harvest energy from blackholes like building a large dyson sphere?

0 Upvotes

r/QuantumPhysics • • Dec 15 '24

So yea... Energy can't be created or destroyed.

0 Upvotes

All those quantum fluctuations are just particles constantly changing form.


r/QuantumPhysics • • Jan 17 '25

Time travel and quantum randomness

0 Upvotes

So I'm not an expert but in a discussion about time travel this doubt appeared to me and it's killing me, basically my question is if quantum mechanics are truly random would that mean that everytime you travel to the past the next events would be different independently of you interacting with them or not since the mechanics behind them are random?

Sorry for grammar errors I'm not good with english.


r/QuantumPhysics • • May 18 '26 All Seeing Upvote

What is a wave function? A wave of what? What is a particle? An excitation of what? What I'd a quantum feild?

0 Upvotes

and why are people so mean to me when I ask?


r/QuantumPhysics • • Dec 30 '25

What is the biggest flaw in quantum mechanics?

2 Upvotes

One problem with it is the measurement problem and what I’d like to call the “observer problem” and what I mean by this is that we’re all just a bunch of observers carrying information and there doesn’t seem to be a unifying sense of being. I listened to a podcast with Slavoj Zizek and Sean Carrol about this where Slavoj discussed how quantum mechanics introduces ontological incompleteness.


r/QuantumPhysics • • Sep 07 '23

Theory of the meaning of the results of the double slit experiment - why particles behave differently when observed vs not observed (simulation theory)

1 Upvotes

This one guy on YouTube who I sadly forget who and can’t find the video, gave me this idea and ever since hearing it I can’t think of it meaning any other way and can’t think of the universe being anything but a simulation. So as we know, the double slit experiment showed that particles when observed behave as particles but behave as waves when not observed. The theory is that why this happens is it’s a power/storage saving feature of the simulation, similar to how video games are coded- objects in a video game world that are too far away to have to appear don’t exist until they are meant to be able to be observed, this being a power/storage saving feature of the game. You gotta admit, that is a perfect explanation for why particles behave differently when not observed. This also I guess could tie into why we cannot both measure the position and size/velocity/other measurements of a particle at the same time, some sort of power/storage issue, idk that’s just a guess on that one. I am certainly not an expert on quantum mechanics but this theory does make so much sense to me it’s insane. Simulation theory makes a lot of sense in many ways. I believe in demons and magick and skinwalkers and such, and honestly, it makes no sense how those things could exist- I feel like there has to be some sort of mechanism / process that allows everything to happen, and magick and such just can’t be explained by any mechanisms, other than it being coded into a simulation. Anyways, let me know what you think thanks


r/QuantumPhysics • • May 06 '23

life equation

0 Upvotes

not really a quantum physics question but, does anyone think there's an equation that describes how life (maybe how life interacts with other life, when they've evolved from the same starting point, (all life on earth))? and I'd imagine this equation or series of equations is like statistical mechanics where its only true when you look at the entire scope of probabilities, or like quantum mechanics equation with the way they relate to probabilities. I feel like there has to be an equation(s) given that life must obey laws of physics as well. And I was thinking that since so much of physics parallels other theories of physics, maybe life is analogous (looking at it from a stastical mechanics lense or something like that) to something we already understand in the world of physics or math. Just like gravity interaction and point-charge interaction are so similar in form, mathematically. maybe life-interaction is similar to something else in this way. This post is mostly just to provoke thought and start interesting conversation, I'm not a physicist but I did some physics in college so I've learned a little)

stay curious!


r/QuantumPhysics • • Oct 06 '23

Biocentrism and Afterlife

0 Upvotes

Edit: I guess people dont understand how I am wording this to say that its essentially bullshit to claim quantum theory provides evidence of an afterlife.

When I mentioned that neuroscience indicates consciousness is linked to brain activity, someone countered with quantum theory, asserting consciousness can exist independently of the brain. They insisted I "do my homework," so I delved into two articles, and my findings so far have me dissatisfied. I will research more, but the articles I read don't seem efficient to claim consciousness exists beyond death. The initial article merely made a promising title without delivering an explanation. The second article relied on the double slit experiment, suggesting that death must be an illusion. However, it seemed overly audacious to draw such a profound conclusion based solely on one specific controlled experiment, which examines particle behavior when observed. This prompts the question: can we extrapolate the nature of reality entirely from the double slit experiment alone, as biocentrism does? Shouldn't we conduct various other experiments to establish conclusive evidence? Are there any other experiments demonstrating how our observation can alter aspects of reality beyond particle behavior? How does any of this provide evidence that consciousness persists after death, and where can I read about further evidence? Was it just a coincidence that the articles I read did not provide enough information? Claim that Quantum Theory has found evidence of life after death


r/QuantumPhysics • • Jan 18 '24

Determinism helps me to accept my genetic disease. Please help me reconcile it with QM.

0 Upvotes

Hi,

I suffer from a genetic disease that could have been cured if diagnosed early but was missed by the doctors.

I've read works from deterministic physicians and biologists such as David J. Gross or Robert Sapolsky, which conclude that human mind is fully deterministic. This helped me to forgive the doctors who missed it. However, I still have hard time accepting that I received the particular gene at conception.

Even deterministic scientists believe that, outside of human mind, world can be indeterministic. One area where mainstream scientists believe that the laws of probability apply is genetics. My disease had approximately 60-70 chance of being transferred and 30-40 chance of not being transferred. It is difficult for me to accept that, if the time went back and the moment of conception happened again, I could be healthy.

I know there are many deterministic interpretations of QM, such as Broglie-Bohm, Many worlds, Hidden variable theory or superdeterminism. However, these are often frowned upon in a scientific community.

Is there a way for me to believe that the gene had to be transferred and it couldn't have happened any other way, and not fool myself with irrational unscientific thinking?

Thank you.


r/QuantumPhysics • • Aug 19 '24

Misleading Title Do Not Study Quantum Mechanics – Nobel Physics Laureate Tony Leggett's Controversial Warning

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/QuantumPhysics • • Jul 09 '24

why can't entanglement be explained by the particles observing each other?

0 Upvotes

why aren't we considering the process of entanglement a mutual observation that collapses the wave function at the moment of entanglement and we just have two particles in opposite states from then on? have we ever performed experiments on entangled particles that verify they behave like a wave before measuring them?


r/QuantumPhysics • • Mar 20 '26

Can We Measure Electrons Without Disturbing Them?

0 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

I am a high school student interested in quantum physics, and I’ve been thinking a lot about the quantum measurement problem. I would love feedback from anyone who thinks critically about the foundations of quantum mechanics.

Here are my main ideas and questions:

Electrons are extremely sensitive

  • Any small interaction with a measurement device can disturb their state.

  • Current experiments inevitably interact with electrons, which may affect the results we see.

  • I wonder if some of the “weird” behavior attributed to quantum mechanics is partly due to limitations of our measurement tools.

Observer vs device

  • I think it is misleading to say the electron “knows” it is being observed.

  • The effect is caused by physical interaction with devices, not by human observation.

  • Postulates should consider that we may not yet have a way to measure quantum systems without affecting them.

Superposition and reality

  • I feel that a quantum system has definite properties before measurement, even if we don’t know them.

  • I’m aware that experiments like Bell’s theorem challenge this, but I am interested in exploring non-local hidden variable theories or weak measurements to understand the system’s real state.

I would greatly appreciate feedback, references, or suggestions for simulations, experiments, or readings that could help me explore these ideas further.

Thank you for your time and insight!

Notice: I am not trying to attack or reject quantum foundations and I don't have strong background in the field of quantum mechanics.


r/QuantumPhysics • • Sep 02 '26

Guys. Is there's any connection between quantum phy or philosophy?? Because what i believe is the more you dive into quantum phy you'll find the philosophical concepts in it.

0 Upvotes

r/QuantumPhysics • • Apr 24 '21

Noob here

15 Upvotes

For all the smart people out there, can you explain in simple terms the basics of wanting mechanics and how it’s useful to science.