[Before it’s suggested that this post is off-topic, consider there there is NO CONSENSUS on why the wave function collapses upon measurement. While my question might ‘seem’ too ‘mystical’ or ‘dualistic’ or whatever other adjective you like, I truly mean to cut right to the heart of one the deepest mysteries in quantum theory]
Most arguments against free will rely on the notion that free will is incompatible with causal determinism—the view that every event in the universe is an effect of physical causes which precede it. However, as is well established in quantum theory, the universe at the fundamental level is inherently NOT deterministic. Specifically, the act of measurement collapses the wave function in a non-deterministic manner.
So my question is whether the non determinism of QM provides a substrate for free choices to truly exist in our universe—which are not effects of any prior causes. The Free Will theorem by Conway and Kochen seems to argue along these lines.
To my mind there are two things in the universe we understand to be ‘free’ or nondeterministic: 1) quantum mechanical systems (upon measurement), and 2) ourselves.
Have any prominent physicists commented on this question?
We are made of matter, and matter is quantum mechanical on the most fundamental level. Is it really so radical to suppose our best theory of physics accounts for everyday experience as well as particle-collider experiments?