I'm in shock and there's so much to say. PubTips helped me so much in my journey so I wanted to share all the stats, setbacks and wins with you all.
PART 1 - Getting an agent. Stats + Query Letter
Wow, getting an agent was definitely the longest and most difficult part of the process for me. A query tracker subscription should come with a free therapist!
Number of books failed before querying this one: 1
Agents submitted to: 63
Full requests: 6
Offers: 2
Tools used: PubTips for learning about query letters, Manuscript Wish List, Publishers Marketplace, and Query Tracker
Let me tell you, this time was BRUTAL. Every day for months I was absolutely tortured by my email inbox, looking out for rejections and requests. At one point I was starting every morning with 2-3 passes and absolutely dying inside. I got an agent just as I was starting to give up on it entirely.
Ultimately my two offers came from 1: the typical query manager experience of submitting to an agent through there, and 2: sending the query package to an agency that wanted manuscripts sent to the agency as a whole rather than individual agents. I didn't end up doing much of the typical nudging and getting offers post offer of rep, as I only had it out with around 4 agents at the time I got my offer, and the agent who first offered was an absolute dream!
QUERY LETTER
I had two query letters that were largely the same except for some tweaks. Here is one of them I think is slightly better. Honestly though, I don't know if it was even that strong (and my full request rate probably reflects that)! I thought the 'What does it matter if' lines were good at the time, now I can see that they are a bit cliche after reading hundreds of letters in PubTips. I'm realising there's no greater sin than being cliche if you want to stand out (or have high quality prose in general).
Anyway I know you love your query letters so here it is in full:
I am seeking representation for my novel, THE FINAL BOSS, a zany, gamified adventure through the horrors of late-stage capitalism best described as READY PLAYER ONE meets SEVERANCE (tv). THE FINAL BOSS is a standalone novel complete at 91,000 words, sitting across Science Fiction, Fantasy, and GameLit genres.
***
This morning, Sarah was just another depressed millennial trying to survive in corporate for the next 50 years.
Now, she'll be lucky to survive the day.
Sarah's living the dream. Not only is she employed, but she works for the world's biggest gaming company. Literally millions of people would kill to be where she is. What does it matter if she hates the endless meetings, brutal competitiveness, and daily encounters with tech-sector douchebags? All she has to do is keep smiling, claw her way up the performance rankings, and get a promotion. Then she'll be winning at life.
It's all going to plan until Sarah sets off a chain of events that ends in disaster—a bungled tech launch transforms her entire nine-floor office into a nine-level videogame. Between violent office printers, merciless managers, and a sadistic AI hellbent on killing everyone off, Sarah's going to have to try harder than ever to stay alive.
But as Sarah fights increasingly more ridiculous game designs based on her office, the absurdity of it all begins to shatter the illusions she's built her whole life around. To truly have a hope of winning the game, she's going to have to figure out how to survive a far more nightmarish, life-threatening place—the real world she is trying to get back to.
***
THE FINAL BOSS is a wacky yet heartfelt take on modern corporate life. It will suit fans of the quirky, office-based humour of Natalie Sue's I HOPE THIS FINDS YOU WELL, the wild but emotional journey of EVERYTHING EVERYWHERE ALL AT ONCE, and the satirical, game-inspired spectacle of Matt Dinniman's DUNGEON CRAWLER CARL. Packed full of videogame and office culture easter eggs, it will appeal to gamers and corporate employees alike.
With close to a decade of experience working in corporate and a lifetime of playing videogames, THE FINAL BOSS is the inevitable lovechild of two of the most significant influences in my life. When I'm not working, gaming, or writing, I am enjoying the beautiful city of Melbourne, Australia. THE FINAL BOSS would be my debut novel.
Thank you so much for your consideration.
Emma Holden
PART 2 - The Book Deals
After I got my agent in Australia, we worked on an edit while my agent recruited help from all around the world to be partner agents in their home territories. Once my US agent came on board, they had ideas for edits too so I think in the end it was three rounds of edits before we were comfortable submitting. The word count blew up to 99k over this time!
Going on submission initially felt even worse than looking for an agent. With agents, you feel like there's still always something in your power to keep trying, more agents to send to, more query letters to experiment with, or more edits to make to the manuscript for as long as you're willing to do it. But on submission, it felt like my dreams could actually just die. I was terrified!
In the end, it has been amazing. Once the first offers came in for Australia (my home territory), that got the ball rolling in all of the other countries. We sold in Australia, the US, and the UK at three different auctions, all to Big 5 imprints. The Publishers Marketplace announcement went up just a couple of days ago! There's also more movement happening in the translations rights space but I can't announce those just yet.
I couldn't believe how different submission was to querying. There was SO MUCH EDITOR INTEREST and it was totally unbelievable considering how hard querying had been. Definitely this is all because of how amazing my agent is, and also the snowball effect of when one editor is interested, they all speed up their reading times to meet deadlines set for offers. It was all quite quick (it's a blur but I believe it was only a couple of months or less from submission to first offer).
OTHER TIDBITS
Social media - I just wanted to reassure everyone that I do not have ANY social media following nor was it considered at all necessary to have one. I have some author pages set up now (please follow me on Instagram, ya girl is struggling, look for emma holden author) but I had nothing at all to show when publishers were asking about my social media presence and this was never an issue.
Timing - They say publishing takes a long time and they are not joking. It took me five years to work on my first novel that failed, another year to write this one, a year to get an agent, months editing, months on submission and now 1.5 years until publication day. And that's considered super fast.
Surviving the process - Gosh I don't have as many tips here because I just limped my way through everything, but I'd say a relentless passion for your own story is essential. You really have to keep believing in it to what feels like a delusional level just to survive the feelings of rejection and get through the waiting time.
That's all I can think of for now, but please ask anything you like in the comments or send me a DM, I'm so happy to help, and I'm desperate to make writer friends!