r/Psychiatry • • 11h ago

For those hoping to do pretty low-key CL work, or CL-adjacent work, how necessary is a CL fellowship at the current time?

13 Upvotes

Resident considering my options. I am hoping to be a primarily outpatient doc, but also interested in collaborative care and emergency psychiatry (which often uses a consult model). However, given my Frankensteinian interested, I may think to round out my schedule with a CL shift here and there if necessary. For this kind of setup, is fellowship actually necessary? Some of the older attending at my program think it would be necessary and increasingly so, though lots of younger attendings disagree and I know at least 2-3 who pick up CL shifts that did not do CL fellowship. I am curious to hear more about other perspectives/experiences. Primarily in the New England area, but not just Boston/Providence.

Alternatively, how hard is it to go back to CL fellowship after a few years as an attending? Obviously not great from a financial standpoint, but am curious to hear about all potential pathways if plan A doesn’t work out.


r/Psychiatry • • 18h ago

Choice of antidepressant in treating Major Depressive Disorder?

12 Upvotes

During my psych rotation, I observed one of the attendings putting every MDD patient on Sertraline as their first med with CBT recommendation. I now wonder why Sertraline is always the first choice. Why was it not other SSRIs or even SNRIs, depending on the most troubling symptoms? It never occurred to me then, and so I couldn't ask.

Is there any general algorithm for treating MDD or does it vary across clinicians? If there are multiple algorithms, is there one that is more effacacious than the other? How do you approach in treating MDD?

Also, regarding determining partial response, is it always about checking lists on some scale (even if the patient can't meaningfully tell whether there has been any improvement)? Are there specific interviewing skills that bring out the information?


r/Psychiatry • • 19h ago

When joining a private practice as a 1099 what is a reasonable split?

7 Upvotes

They provide a full schedule(patients with commercial insurance), malpractice, phone, scheduling, credentialing, billing, prior authorization support. In previous discussions I have seen everything from 60/40 to 85/15. Just wanted to see what everyone’s experience was.


r/Psychiatry • • 21h ago

How to deal with shame? Vent

0 Upvotes

How to deal with the shame that am a psychiatrist but cant figure how to feel toward mother , family as a youngest daughter , how to heal from the so called abuse , mainly emotional abuse or negligence, idk how am supposed to sit and listen to my patient , help them if I myself cant tell if i was really neglected or am just being emotional, idk if am making sense but its so hard, and i cant bring myself to ask for help cuz derp down am overreacting , even tho am prescribing meds for people with the same complaints, cuz how much they suffer and am truly sorry for them , and i can spot the suffering in my patient but I dont know what to do with my feeling ? My trauma with having a mom that doesn’t love me apparently
Idk what to do ? Should I seek therapy or read some books or what ? I tend to do SH when I get overwhelmed with something related to mom


r/Psychiatry • • 1d ago

Is the US really the worst country to have a severe mental illness?

Post image
199 Upvotes

There's been a bit of a debate online about whether the US is genuinely the worst country to have a severe mental illness, following comments made by psychiatrist Dr. Allen Frances, who pretty much doubled down on his position when argued against

I know there's been research suggesting that people with schizophrenia in some developing countries have historically had better outcomes, I believe mainly due to stronger community and family support.

But IDK , I find it hard to believe that the US is the ABSOLUTE worst country in the world for people with SMI also don't think you can claim that after only visiting 60 counties

I fully admit Dr. Frances has far more experience in psychiatry than I do and I'm just a naive med student. so I'm open to being completely wrong lol

I'm curious what everyone here thinks. Agree or disagree?

I'd especially be interested in hearing from people who've worked in mental healthcare systems outside the US.


r/Psychiatry • • 1d ago

Attention residents - use of AI during training

176 Upvotes

I’ve developed some growing concern about use of AI in training for writing your notes. While I do believe it is important to learn these tools, please do not completely forgo writing atleast SOME of your notes without it.

Writing your note manually - specifically and most importantly your impression/formulation yourself is important for your learning. If you let a program fully do this for you, I worry that you wont be thinking indepth about patients you see early in your career. Learning to formulate cases is one of the skills you learn in residency that takes the most time and practice and writing your notes helps you think critically about that as you write it.

Basic reporting of history sure use it…HPI/interval history etc., there’s not much thinking involved here beyond how you decide to elicit information, its largely just scribing for that data. But the impression/formulation is different and essentially you synthesizing all the data yourself to come up with a plan and give a patient an accurate diagnosis.

I’m just an old man yelling at kids to get off my lawn, but I felt this was important to say - take it or leave it and good luck in your training.


r/Psychiatry • • 2d ago

Does anyone here have experience dealing with a non-compete?

25 Upvotes

I work for a big Telehealth company with a ridiculous non-compete clause. I am interested in leaving. I spoke with an attorney who basically told me that the non-compete was probably unenforceable as written, and that he couldn't find a case where the courts enforced a non-compete like this, but if they wanted to try to enforce it for some reason it would cost me a lot in attorneys fees and time to fight it. He told me I essentially have 2 options:

  1. Attempt to negotiate a waiver with them: Essentially I write an email saying that I spoke with a lawyer and we think it is non-enforceable and it doesn't make sense and see if they will waive it. He described this as legally the safest route, but obviously they can say no and in that case they would know im planning to leave. Upside is even if they don't agree to waive it completely they might waive some of it.

  2. Just resign, do what I want and kinda dare them to try to enforce it. I got the sense that he was probably leaning toward this option, because Im essentially a cog in the machine, there are plenty of psychiatrist and patients that this company probably won't be hurt by me leaving and that there are serious issues with the non-compete that make its enforceability questionable. Downside is that if they send me a cease and desist it will probably use language just as broad as in the contract itself, which to fight would be expensive at that point.

Im leaning more toward option 2, but just wanted to see if anyone here has any experience with dealing with this. I'm in NY for reference. And yes, use this as an example of why you should never sign a contract with a non-compete clause(even if it means turning down/changing jobs).


r/Psychiatry • • 2d ago

What Can Video Games Teach Us About Attention, Motivation, and Reward Processing?

0 Upvotes

With the attention surrounding GTA 6, I've been thinking about a question that I believe has interesting implications for psychiatry.

Why can someone struggle to concentrate on homework for 20 minutes yet remain absorbed in a video game for six hours?

And why might someone who avoids challenging tasks in everyday life repeatedly attempt a difficult game mission until they succeed?

After more than 40 years in clinical psychiatry, I find this contrast particularly interesting.

My working hypothesis is that video games can create environments that satisfy important psychological needs more consistently and immediately than many everyday activities.

What changes is not necessarily the brain's capacity for attention, but the motivational and environmental conditions under which attention operates.

I think there are seven mechanisms worth considering.

1. Autonomy and perceived control

Self-determination theory identifies autonomy, competence, and relatedness as important psychological needs.

Video games frequently provide opportunities for all three.

In open-world games such as GTA, players can explore, experiment, and make decisions with fewer real-world constraints.

The appeal of simulated criminal behavior may therefore involve perceived autonomy, novelty, and freedom from consequences rather than any actual desire to engage in criminal activity.

Of course, the autonomy is ultimately constrained by the game's design. Nevertheless, the subjective experience of control can be powerful.

2. Competence and immediate feedback

In clinical practice, we frequently encounter patients who struggle with motivation when rewards are delayed, uncertain, or difficult to recognize.

Video games often provide the opposite experience.

Goals are explicit. Progress is measurable. Feedback is immediate.

Successful actions produce visible results, while unsuccessful attempts frequently provide information that helps improve subsequent performance.

This structure can reinforce persistence.

It also raises an interesting question: Could some principles of game design improve adherence to behavioral interventions, rehabilitation programs, or educational activities?

3. Dopamine, reward prediction, and motivation

Popular discussions frequently reduce gaming to dopamine release.

That explanation is incomplete.

Dopaminergic systems participate in reward prediction, reinforcement learning, motivation, and effort allocation.

Games can combine anticipated rewards, uncertain outcomes, repeated attempts, and rapid feedback.

These features may encourage continued engagement.

However, it would be inaccurate to assume that all video games operate through identical reinforcement mechanisms or that dopamine alone explains prolonged gaming.

The distinction between intrinsic motivation, reinforcement learning, and potentially maladaptive reward-seeking deserves particular attention.

4. Identity experimentation and psychological escape

Video games allow players to assume identities and capabilities that may be unavailable in everyday life.

Someone who feels powerless, socially inhibited, or physically limited may experience competence, leadership, or freedom within a virtual environment.

These experiences are not necessarily pathological.

They may support imagination, self-expression, emotional regulation, and social participation.

But clinically, I wonder whether the function of gaming matters more than the amount of gaming.

Is the individual using gaming for recreation and enrichment, or increasingly relying on it to avoid distress, responsibilities, and difficult interpersonal experiences?

The same behavior may serve very different psychological functions.

5. Social belonging and interpersonal reinforcement

Multiplayer gaming can provide cooperation, competition, social recognition, and meaningful relationships.

For individuals experiencing social anxiety or interpersonal difficulties, these environments may offer more predictable opportunities for interaction.

Online relationships can be genuine and supportive.

At the same time, gaming environments may not require the same interpersonal skills as face-to-face interactions.

The clinical issue is not whether virtual relationships are inherently inferior, but whether the individual's social functioning and overall quality of life are improving or deteriorating.

6. Flow and sustained attention

This is perhaps the most interesting mechanism.

In his 1990 book Flow: The Psychology of Optimal Experience, Hungarian-American psychologist Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi described a state of deep absorption characterized by focused attention, reduced awareness of distractions, and altered subjective perception of time.

Flow is often facilitated by clear goals, immediate feedback, and a balance between challenge and skill.

Video games can be particularly effective at providing these conditions.

A task that is too easy becomes boring.

A task that is excessively difficult becomes frustrating.

A challenging but manageable task may sustain intense engagement.

This brings us back to the original paradox.

Why can someone who struggles with sustained attention in one environment demonstrate remarkable concentration in another?

From a psychiatric perspective, this is especially relevant to ADHD.

The ability to maintain attention during a highly engaging activity does not exclude ADHD. Nor does prolonged gaming establish that someone has the disorder.

Rather, it illustrates how strongly attention regulation can depend on task characteristics, motivation, reinforcement, and environmental structure.

I wonder whether our understanding of flow could contribute to more effective approaches to behavioral activation, executive-function interventions, and treatment engagement.

7. Simulated danger, arousal, and risk-taking

Games such as GTA allow players to experience simulated aggression, danger, and rule-breaking without the immediate physical consequences of comparable real-world behavior.

This may appeal to sensation-seeking, novelty-seeking, emotional arousal, and the desire to experiment with situations that would otherwise be inaccessible.

The attraction resembles, in some respects, the enjoyment of horror films, roller coasters, or competitive sports.

Importantly, enjoying simulated violence should not automatically be interpreted as evidence of violent intent.

The literature on violent video games and aggression remains contested, particularly regarding effect sizes, measurement, and the distinction between laboratory measures of aggression and serious real-world violence.

An evolutionary hypothesis

I'd also like to raise a more speculative possibility.

Throughout much of human evolutionary history, survival involved exploration, competition, cooperation, resource acquisition, risk assessment, and the development of practical skills.

Many video games reproduce aspects of these activities in highly structured environments.

Could gaming engage motivational systems that evolved in response to these ancestral challenges?

I find the possibility intriguing, although I would emphasize that this is an evolutionary interpretation rather than an established causal explanation.

When does engagement become pathology?

The WHO recognizes gaming disorder in ICD-11.

The diagnostic framework emphasizes impaired control, increasing priority given to gaming over other activities, and continuation or escalation despite negative consequences, with significant functional impairment.

This distinction is important.

High engagement is not synonymous with addiction.

Hours played may be relevant, but they are insufficient by themselves to establish a disorder.

Clinically, I would be more interested in impaired control, functional deterioration, sleep disruption, interpersonal consequences, and the individual's ability to experience satisfaction outside gaming.

I would also consider the possibility that excessive gaming may sometimes be secondary to depression, anxiety, ADHD, loneliness, or other difficulties rather than an independent disorder.

The broader psychiatric question

Are video games satisfying psychological needs that are insufficiently met in everyday life?

Or can repeated exposure to highly structured, immediately rewarding environments make ordinary activities with delayed rewards increasingly difficult to sustain?

These possibilities are not mutually exclusive, and the relationship is unlikely to be identical across individuals.

But perhaps the more clinically useful question is this:

What can we learn from the motivational structure of video games that might improve psychiatric treatment?

Could elements of game design help us create more engaging behavioral interventions for ADHD, depression, anhedonia, or rehabilitation?

And how do we distinguish adaptive immersion from avoidance and pathological engagement?

I'd be particularly interested in hearing how colleagues approach these questions clinically and whether they have found the concept of flow useful in understanding patients' attention and motivation.

Selected references

  1. Csikszentmihalyi M. Flow: The Psychology of Optimal Experience. Harper & Row; 1990.

  2. Ryan RM, Rigby CS, Przybylski A. The motivational pull of video games: A self-determination theory approach. Motivation and Emotion. 2006;30:344–360.

  3. Przybylski AK, Rigby CS, Ryan RM. A motivational model of video game engagement. Review of General Psychology. 2010;14(2):154–166.

  4. World Health Organization. ICD-11, Gaming Disorder (6C51).


r/Psychiatry • • 2d ago

Psychiatry/psychology books in german

6 Upvotes

Hi! I'm a first year resident in psychiatry and I am also learning german. I'm looking for German books on psychiatry or psychology, something more clinical but especially modern than Freud and company. Thank you so much to who'll answer!


r/Psychiatry • • 2d ago

New outpatient attending struggling with efficiency

70 Upvotes

I’m a new attending in a busy community outpatient setting. I work 10-hour days, 4 days a week, including a lunch hour and 1 hour of admin time. I have 2–4 intakes on 3 of those days, with a mix of my own patients and cross-coverage. Because of frequent no-shows, I usually see 13-16 patients/day ( one day I saw 20 but its an outlier so far), although some days I see as few as 9. We also have an overflow list, so open slots can be filled with patients who aren’t assigned to a clinician.

I’m struggling a lot with efficiency and balancing work with my life. We have the standard is 1 hour for intakes and 30 minutes for follow-ups, but even on a day when I see only 9 patients, I can end up leaving at 8:30 PM. I use Doximity Scribe, which has helped tremendously with saving my sanity. Before using it, I was staying until 11 PM finishing notes and carrying encounters over to the next day.

also have elderly patients who need written instructions and extra time to go through their medications, and I don’t want to compromise their care just to be faster.

I’m not sure where I’m losing so much time. Am I too chatty, Do I over explain, should I be more concrete and not explore so far from make chief complaint. It’s hard to say that but Should I care less , I am thinking maybe my inquisitive and empathetic nature is costing my time and mental health. My goal is to complete the note and close the encounter during the visit, with everything closed by 7 PM.

I’ve become so overwhelmed that I’ve even wondered whether inattention could be contributing, and I’ve considered Concerta, although I’m not sure that’s actually the issue.

During these four workdays, my entire life basically stops. I often don’t even take my lunch break or eat properly—sometimes it’s just coffee and toast.

I’m looking for practical advice on how to improve my efficiency and balance my life while doing this job. Thank you


r/Psychiatry • • 3d ago

Former colleague died

13 Upvotes

Any one here from UNMC Psychiatry? Just learned that a fellow psychiatrist has died at 64


r/Psychiatry • • 3d ago

Attending outpatients, please share info!

14 Upvotes

Graduating PGY4, leaving research career track to do full time clinical (outpatient) work. I have two questions: 1)What on earth is a reasonable number of RVUs to generate in a year with 60 min intake & 30 min follow up? 2) the second question is more existential— is it really survivable to do 100% clinical for the next 30years? When I tell researchers I’m going clinical they tell me I’ll burn out in no time. But people work full time busy jobs all the time — is it really that bad?? Would love to hear your experiences!


r/Psychiatry • • 3d ago

The Pharmacotherapeutic Alliance

Thumbnail doi.org
39 Upvotes

The views in the linked paper represent a perspective from the Psychopharmacology Committee at GAP. The more provocative views expressed below are mine. What do YOU think this means for the system of psychiatric care that we have created (or has been created for us by the businesses that shape medicine)?

Ask a psychiatrist whether they prescribe according to the evidence and the answer will almost certainly be yes. Ask what that means, and the reply usually focuses on evidence-based matching of medications with defined DSM categories. In this month's American Journal of Psychiatry, The Psychopharmacology Committee of the Group for the Advancement of Psychiatry argues that optimal prescribing requires attention to all of our evidence bases, particularly those pertaining to the prescribing relationship.

That literature is more substantial than many of us were taught. Placebo effects, which produce real and often lasting biomedical changes, contribute at least as much to psychiatric pharmacotherapy outcomes as the medications themselves. In the NIMH TDCRP Study, alliance effects were equivalent in antidepressant pharmacotherapy and psychotherapy, accounting for more outcome variance than the purported active treatment. Meta-analytic data suggests that the effect size of the pharmacotherapeutic alliance (0.3) is on par with the effect size of our most prescribed medications.

The pharmacotherapeutic alliance offers a modifiable and evidence-based point of intervention to optimize treatment benefits. These effects may be particularly potent in psychiatry, where a majority of patients have histories of early adversity that may have undermined trust in caregiving. Meta-analytic data shows a nearly 1-point drop in the HAM-D with every additional appointment in the initiation phase of antidepressant treatment… a potent relational effect that is essentially ignored in clinical practice where patients are often seen less than monthly.  Clinician warmth also reduces side-effects, improves follow-up, and corrects for the relational cost of briefer visits. Attending to patient preferences for treatment when weighting psychotherapy vs pharmacotherapy for depression can potentially boost treatment response 6-fold. Engaging with the patient rather than the EMR can triple the likelihood of the patient returning for a follow-up visit after intake. Countless other data on the effective prescribing process suggest, as did Michael Balint in his seminal 1957 text, that our most potent drug is the one called… “doctor.”

Not even counting vast private industry funding, over 6 billion dollars in federal funding goes into psychiatric research every year, which, as former NIMH director Tom Insel noted, noted, “has barely moved the needle” on psychiatric outcomes. Someday, we can hope that there will be big payoffs, but, in the meantime, countless patient suffer with recalcitrant mental illness. Given RDOC criteria, almost all of this funding focuses on neurobiological mechanisms rather than psychosocial aspects of psychiatric care. Given the substantial impacts of psychosocial factors on pharmacologic treatment outcomes, it seems likely that alliance research and dissemination of these findings could substantially improve psychiatric outcomes, could do it next year, and could do it at a fraction of the cost of the development of novel biomedical approaches.

In a culture and environment that overvalues medications and undervalues the power of the psychiatrist-patient relationship, the whole field has moved towards brief visits, often monthly or less.  Strikingly, there is essentially no research on how this shift has impacted treatment outcomes or contributes to the problem of psychiatric treatment-resistance. When we do consider how much non-pharmacologic factors contribute to treatment outcomes, it raises serious questions about whether we have created a system of care delivery that is costing our patients more than we know.

Given that psychosocial factors often shape treatment outcomes as much as (or more than) the medications themselves, it is reasonable to ask whether a psychiatrist ignoring these evidence bases is really practicing evidence-based psychiatry. The potency of the pharmacotherapeutic alliance and other psychosocial factors shaping pharmacotherapy outcomes suggests that alliance-enhancing interventions should have better representation in our research agenda, our treatment algorithms, and our residency training. It could even be argued that, if half of pharmacotherapy outcome is shaped by nonpharmacologic factors, many of which are modifiable, should a commensurate amount of psychopharmacology training in residency focus not on what to prescribe, but, rather, the evidence addressing how to prescribe?

This is a crucial issue for our patients.  It is also an existential issue for psychiatry. If we continue to neglect the impact of the doctor-patient relationship in shaping positive outcomes and treat psychiatry as if competence boils down simply to algorithmic matching of diagnoses and symptoms, our corporate overlords will soon succeed in their efforts to replace us with prescribing bots, and it will take a generation of patient suffering before we realize the disastrous folly of our biomedical reductionism. Psychiatry as a human endeavor cannot survive unless we recognize that our traditional expertise in the doctor-patient relationship is not a relic of a psychodynamic past but is essential to the effective treatment of our most troubled patients.


r/Psychiatry • • 3d ago

What special tricks of the trade make psychiatry so interesting for you even after years of practice?

59 Upvotes

I am a med student planning to choose psychiatry as my specialisation. I am fascinated by how much people's lives can change through proper interventions (as I have seen during my rotation).

I would love to hear about your personal tricks of the trade that you have learned through your years of practice, ranging from interview to intervention (meds or otherwise), . Be it from clinical experience or evidence based or combined.


r/Psychiatry • • 4d ago

Recent interesting research articles in adult psycho-pharmaco-therpay

6 Upvotes

Hello, maybe the headline sounds a bit cheesy, but I decided to give it a shot anyways after scrolling for few days all possible journals and not stumbling upon an interesting article in the mentioned area. I really need to present something in my department and can't find anything "significantly" interesting and relevant. I mainly scrolled through JAMA and American Journal of Psychiatry.

Thank you!


r/Psychiatry • • 4d ago

How much better is private practice?

33 Upvotes

Hi all. Just hoping to get some perspectives on others experience with private practice (and I mean real private practice where you are the one managing referrals/all business, maybe with a biller but not with one of these services that you’re really an employee of - either your own or as part of a small group).

I’ve been at the VA for a few years as my first job out of residency and the caseload/bureaucracy/severity of illness of cases is starting to burn me out. We’ve had multiple providers leave in the past year and needed to absorb their caseload. I respond to 40+ patient portal messages a week and am forced into overbooking my schedule due to acuity of illness. My panel is probably over 500 people at this point.

I’ve got other things to consider as well like healthcare benefits for my family, a few more years to be vested in my pension and PSLF for >250k in federal student loans (dont have any private ones thank god). The jump in income would need to be pretty large to make it financially worth it, probably >100k getting close to the 400s.

Idk I’m just getting to a point in my career where I’d like a smaller panel, less medically complex/elderly, less acute, be able to do more therapy. Taking the plunge into private practice might not be reasonable currently, but I really feel I cant do this job forver.


r/Psychiatry • • 4d ago

Stay at home or leave for research track?

6 Upvotes

Hi r/psychiatry! I'm an MD/PhD student applying to psychiatry this cycle. I'm struggling with how to think through my rank list and would appreciate perspectives from residents, faculty, and especially physician-scientists.

My home institution has a strong reputation, and I've spent my entire academic career here (including undergrad). I have an established research trajectory and hope to pursue a career as an independent physician-scientist. However, despite my research background, my home program offered me an interview only for the categorical residency program, not the research track.

Meanwhile, I've received research-track interview invitations from several top academic psychiatry programs, some of which have expressed considerable enthusiasm about supporting my research interests and long-term career development beyond residency.

Complicating matters, my longstanding research mentors at my home institution are no longer available. If I stayed, I'm genuinely unsure who would serve as my primary research mentor or how I would continue developing my research program. Although some faculty have expressed interest in supporting me, their research expertise doesn't closely align with my own, making it difficult to identify an appropriate primary mentor. Moreover, there is no clearly defined pathway for pursuing my research goals, particularly outside a formal research track.

The biggest reason to stay is family. I've lived in the area for most of my life, have a close relationship with my family, and have older relatives for whom being nearby is increasingly important. Leaving would mean moving away for the first time. There is no partner in the picture to complicate this decision (one rare perk of being single).

I'm trying to separate the emotional difficulty of leaving a familiar institution from the actual career implications of staying.

For those who have been through this:

  1. How much weight would you place on a formal research track versus a categorical program?

  2. Is the lack of a research-track invitation from my home institution something I should take seriously when evaluating how much they would support me as a physician-scientist?

  3. How important is having an established mentor when ranking a residency program?

  4. For those who moved away from family for residency, was the career benefit worth it?

In particular, I'd like to know whether anyone regrets staying at their home institution for reasons I mentioned, or conversely, regrets leaving a supportive personal environment for a more promising academic opportunity.

Thank you so much for your insights!


r/Psychiatry • • 4d ago

Please advise on the assessment of pathological jealousy

13 Upvotes

Jealousy is a natural and complex emotion, especially in romantic and committed relationships. Extreme / delusional jealousy, and ego dystonic obsessional jealousy, are relatively easier to recognise. Requesting your inputs on how you assess and decide about overvalued jealous suspicions (versus plausible doubts of partner fidelity) especially in this digital age. Evaluating the minutiae of specific incidents also takes a lot of time + active peacekeeping during the session (when the couple consult together), would like to know how practitioners are approaching the evaluation.


r/Psychiatry • • 5d ago

Boards this week?

14 Upvotes

Anybody hear anything about boards results? Last year it looks like they were released 10 weeks after which would be this week


r/Psychiatry • • 5d ago

Rural FM vs Psych in mental health care

29 Upvotes

I'm a med student who's been pretty interested in both FM and psych, but tbh I'm leaning more toward psych because I really like it and I feel I'm willing to lose FM and delve deeper into psych then lose psych expertise but be a fm

Although I've seen some rural FM docs argue that they can manage pretty much any outpatient psych condition, including schizophrenia and bipolar disorder, and that outside of ECT, ketamine, and therapy, there isn't much a psychiatrist can do that a rural FM can't.

I pushed back but was kinda dragged a bit lol. Id imagine four years of psych residency would give you a lot more experience with complex diagnoses, treatment-resistant cases, psychopharmacology, etc. But ig not?

Obviously, I get that rural FM docs have to manage a lot of these patients because access to psychiatry is limited, and I'm not saying they should refer anything that isnt mild MDD or GAD

I guess I just found the whole discussion a little discouraging. Part of why I'm leaning toward psych is because I want that deeper knowledge that comes with it. so the idea that four years of residency might not amount to much outside of inpatient psych, procedures, and therapy is a bit disappointing. I also seldom see this attitude in reverse when I've met psychiatrist who treat some general medical conditions because their patients can't get in with a pcp

I'm curious what psychiatrists here think, especially those who've worked with rural FM docs. Is there really that much overlap in outpatient practice? Where do you feel your additional training makes the biggest difference in outpatient


r/Psychiatry • • 5d ago

Cobenfy, muscarinic drugs, and the "awakening" phenomenon—what are you seeing in practice?

75 Upvotes

 I've been following the rollout of Cobenfy and the broader shift toward muscarinic targeting with interest.

I'm curious about two things

1. The "awakening" phenomenon. I've seen case reports and some inpatient observations describing a rapid, almost qualitative shift in patients with prominent negative symptoms—emergence from withdrawal, spontaneous social engagement, future-oriented thinking—sometimes within 48 to 96 hours of initiation . The Halassa case series is the most detailed example I've come across. For those who have used it: are you actually seeing this? Is it distinct from what we'd expect from better positive symptom control, or is it something else?

2. The bigger picture. Cobenfy's approval is notable less for its efficacy data (moderate effect sizes, GI tolerability issues, twice-daily dosing, cost) and more for what it represents mechanistically—a non-D2 path after decades of dopamine-centric development . There are M4-selective compounds in the pipeline aiming to reduce the peripheral cholinergic baggage . Do you see muscarinic modulation becoming a mainstream second pathway, or a niche option for patients who can't tolerate D2 blockade

I'm less interested in rehashing the EMERGENT trials and more in what early clinical experience is actually telling us.


r/Psychiatry • • 6d ago

Antidepressants for persistent depressive disorder

67 Upvotes

I had an interesting conversation with a fellow psychotherapist recently that left me scratching my head. He contends that for persistent depressive disorder/dysthymia, particularly if the patient has a history of developmental trauma, antidepressants just aren't effective. I can believe that antidepressants would be less effective with this population, and most certainly that addressing the trauma in psychotherapy would do more to get to the root of the problem, but it seems like a stretch to me to say that antidepressants aren't even worth a try for these patients. My colleague says he has reached this conclusion in consultation with prescribers, but I've worked closely with a number of different prescribers over the course of a long career and have never heard this opinion expressed.

Is there something I'm missing, or is this just this one clinician's idiosyncratic belief?


r/Psychiatry • • 6d ago

For those who take Medicare, how often do you bill a G2211?

10 Upvotes

Following up on my last post, just a question about this. I know it's being replaced by B1, but it's the same criteria. Based on what I could find, you should really be billing this for almost every regularly scheduled patient. I see patients typically every month to three months and most tend to be regularly complex. There is no limit on frequency. Seems to have been created as an incentive for psychiatric care. Doesn't seem to be able to be used if you need to see a patient for an urgent appointment, but rather if you're seeing them for regular longitudinal care, and you're the main provider managing their psychiatric care, which as the psychiatrist, you should be. How often are people using it?


r/Psychiatry • • 7d ago

Do psychiatrists have a spider-sense? Clinical impressions as violations of interpersonal Bayesian expectation

Thumbnail academic.oup.com
154 Upvotes

Sharing a fun article to end the week. Special shout out to the acronym VIBE (Violation of Interpersonal Bayesian Expectation). Quoting directly from Dr Michael Okun because he's thought about this a lot better than I have:

Do psychiatrists have a spider-sense? Can your doctor really sense when something is not right? A fascinating new review published in Brainby Amad and colleagues explores something many experienced clinicians recognize but rarely discuss: the intuition that something is not quite right with a patient, even before we can identify a specific symptom. The authors call this phenomenon VIBE (Violation of Interpersonal Bayesian Expectation), proposing that our brains continuously predict how people should communicate and interact, detecting subtle mismatches in eye contact, facial expressions, voice, emotional responses, and conversational timing. When these expectations are violated, clinicians may experience a gut feeling that something is wrong. The concept builds on the historical praecox feeling, described in schizophrenia, but potentially extends to autism, mood disorders, and other neurological and psychiatric conditions. What resonates with me after decades of examining patients with Parkinson's disease and other neurological disorders is that clinical medicine is about much more than checking boxes, reviewing scans, or ordering laboratory tests. Sometimes the way a person walks into the room, speaks, moves, or interacts tells us something important before we can articulate precisely what it is. The caution is that intuition is not a diagnosis, and this proposed framework still requires scientific validation. Our impressions can also be wrong or biased. The art of medicine is learning to recognize these subtle signals, testing them against objective evidence, and never losing sight of the person sitting across from us. Perhaps the best physicians are not those with a supernatural spider-sense, but those who have learned how to listen, observe, question, and remain curious.

Have a lovely weekend guys.


r/Psychiatry • • 7d ago

Teen psych

105 Upvotes

Looking for some perspective from psych who deal with this way more than I do.

My partner and I are both in cardiology (I’m a 3rd-year fellow, he’s an attending) with no bio kids.

Last year, during my 2nd year of fellowship, I was consulted on a teen psych patient to check her QT intervals and rhythm because shes on heavy meds. Staff on the psych floor warned me shes aggressive. We ended up having a great rapport, and she asked me if she could come home with me. I responded by saying something like "They're going to find a wonderful home for you because you're a wonderful person, and I'm so happy I get to be your doctor."

This month I ran into her again, this time down in the ED, and she is not doing well (overdose/SI). One of the nurses mentioned to me that she still hasn't had a stable placement and has just been bouncing around the system.

I went home, told my partner everything, and said I want to bring her home by becoming a foster parent. We have the finances and stability.

For those of you on the psych side who see kids in the system or work with complex placements, thoughts on this?

It hurts my heart to see her in so much pain and without a stable home.