r/Psychiatry • • Sep 20 '24

Stopping stimulants in retired/chronic unemployed population

0 Upvotes

In outpatient practice I inherit or get a lot of new patients that were on stimulants for reported ADHD that are either retired or chronically unemployed their adult lives (many on disability for one reason or another, sometimes questionably). Obviously, many are resistant to coming off stimulants. In these scenarios I try my best to assess any ongoing necessity for this - for instance people getting in MVAs because their ADHD is do bad when unmedicated. The people I'm speaking up mostly sit at home watching TV and aren't doing anything cognitively demanding. They'll often complain of "poor motivation" even with stimulants. I also discuss diet, exercise, sleep schedule, and try to maximally treat psychiatric comorbidities. In my mind, potentially forgetting to finish the laundry or run an errands isn't worth the risks of taking a stimulant in perpetuity. How do you all handle this discussion? I try to give everybody a fair shake, but I'm sure my skepticism shows through in this paragraph.

I could get on my soap box about overdiagnisis and oversaturation of ADHD in the clinic setting, but I'll leave that for another time.

Edit: By chronically unemployed I mean people that don't work, don't want to work, never will work.

Overall, I'm talking about people not having anything in their life that's cognitively demanding. This has nothing to do with "earning their meds" by contributing to society. I'm talking about necessity and risk/benefit balance. If they do still need it, cool. If not, even better. Lowest medication burden is ideal, without under-treating.


r/Psychiatry • • May 30 '25

I'm sick of psychiatrists bagging on PMHNPs

0 Upvotes

So I'm going to go on a bit of a rant here in hopes that it will open a productive discussion. I am really getting sick of the attitude that many psychiatrists have towards PMHNPs. I'm sure that we have all had the experience of seeing a patient, or many patients, on the wrong medication from a PMHNP. I've certainly seen plenty of patients on bizarre and completely inappropriate or even dangerous combinations of medications. I've also seen plenty of patients who have been completely misdiagnosed. But I've also seen a bunch of those patients who were misdiagnosed or mistreated by a psychiatrist, and I've seen plenty of patients who have received wonderful treatment from PMHNPs. The thing that really bothers me the most about it is that we NEED PMHNPs. We have a massive shortage of psychiatrists in this country, and there is no way that we are going to address the problem by graduating more psychiatrists. This means that we MUST find a way to increase the reach of each psychiatrist, and right now PMHNPs are by far the best solution we have available to do that. PMHNPs are not the problem. I agree that PMHNP programs by and large do not educate them enough. But the solution is not to crap on PMHNPs. Instead, why don't we work to create collaborative practices where they can practice within their strengths and have the support they need for the more challenging patients. At the same time we should be pushing to reform training requirements and offering to precept PMHNP students so that we can be part of the solution instead of referees blowing our whistles and never getting in the game!


r/Psychiatry • • Apr 20 '24

Down with DSM: From Over-Diagnosing and Over-Prescribing to Advancing Self-Exploration and Balance

5 Upvotes

“Instead of trying to define what’s wrong with us, we should try to explore what’s uniquely beautiful about us.”

In my psychiatric training, I was taught to screen for symptoms, assign a diagnosis, and then choose a medication or treatment option that fits that diagnosis. This is our medical standard of care. Unfortunately, this model limits our ability to help resolve the core issues affecting our mental and emotional health, often perpetuating the internal conflict that caused our symptoms.

The Diagnostic and Statistic Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM) is the standard assessment tool in mental health. The categorized cluster of symptoms are formed by 160 mental health professionals and experts. There is nothing wrong with this book. It is our best attempt to adhere to the medical standard of diagnostic care. However, it is largely shaped by societal standards and can over-simplify very complicated human emotions, thoughts, and behaviors.

In the past, we used to have some embarrassing and even offensive DSM disorders. In 1973, they removed the mental disorder of homosexuality. Seven years later, it was reinserted as ego-dystonic homosexuality. The previously diagnosed gender identity disorder was recently updated to gender incongruence. As a psychiatrist, there is no blood test or imaging I can order to confirm these disorders. I have to rely on subjective data coming from our patients, who like all of us, don’t fully understand what they’re feeling and may have a hard time articulating their emotions.

Even in recent times, these subjective diagnoses can often add a layer of stigma. Labeling people by a mental illness can feel cold, clinical, and even judgmental. Our diagnosis can become a crutch, enabling unhealthy behaviors. “Sorry I was a jerk; that’s just my bipolar.” Depression is the number one leading cause of disability in the nation. If instead of telling our patients they suffer from major depression, perhaps we can help heal emotional conflicts, inspire passion and purpose, and help reframe negative thoughts patterns. Without the invisible shackles of a depression diagnosis, maybe we can see start to see the value we’re able to offer the world and the fulfillment in being of service to others.

Because we’re so focused on what mental illness to diagnose, we often overlook that perhaps we’re not actually ill. Perhaps we’re just going through normal human experiences. Instead of exploring what’s contributed to the way we’re feeling, psychiatric providers have been trained and conditioned to think of which medication fits this current presentation. We lose insight into the dynamic nature of our thoughts, feelings, and behaviors.

The way we should approach mental health is rooted in self-awareness and self-exploration. Right now, we ask about symptoms. We should be exploring pervasive thought patterns, past traumas, emotional conflicts, acute stressors, workplace happiness, daily routines, relationship dynamics, and perspectives of life and death. A more nurturing and educational approach could improve self-awareness and inspire change without shame, blame, or judgment.

We need to evolve the standard of care in mental health. Instead of trying to define a mental illness, let’s advance our exploration of the mind. The great news is there are tools available to us. Our industry is rapidly evolving. Diagnostic agnostic tools include magnetic stimulation to improve neuronal activity, hyperbaric treatment to improve oxygenation of the brain, and psychedelic therapy to expand our minds and increase neuroplasticity. These are all brain enhancements to help us remove emotional barriers and mental mountains and improve our self-clarity, love, and empathy.

The brain is the only organ in the body you can think your way into changing. Thus, perception is the most powerful prescription. Instead of taking a pill once a day, if we improved our thought patterns, laughed more, played more, and loved more, our chemicals would align towards homeostasis. The body is designed to find balance. Let’s remove the barriers and toxins to allow our bodies to heal, grow, and transcend beyond our mislabeled limitations.


r/Psychiatry • • Dec 28 '23

Should we create an ask psychiatry thread for NP to MD/DO/MBBS?

25 Upvotes

The recent lamotrigine thread about how to manage the medication created a pretty polarizing response amongst us. Wondering what the community thinks about creating another subreddit where NP can ask other NP or MD/DO/MBBS psychiatrists more basic questions. Kind of like an “askpsychiatry” but for mid levels. This may help to attract only those physicians who are open to providing advice rather than fueling a polarizing discussion where every physician is labeled as arrogant.

Alternatively, but less preferred by me, a different flair within this subreddit that designates an NP ask from the community.

Ready to get downvoted to oblivion by NPs and called arrogant over and over but also curious what my physician colleagues on here think as the quality of posts on this subreddit are so mixed. Perhaps the NPs may appreciate this too as it may attract less “backlash” for asking what physicians may consider inappropriate questions?


r/Psychiatry • • Feb 27 '24

What if happens if eating disorders are actually not Psychiatric disorders?

177 Upvotes

I have an MD/PhD and worked in the field of eating disorders since leaving Residency. Spent many years in Academia identifying the genetic factors that cause eating disorders. I left Academia in 2016, because well Academia sucks, but I always missed the work which I found interesting. So a couple of years ago I went back and started working on the genetics of eating disorders again in my spare time as a hobby. Just finished up most of the work this past weekend and released my results.

Binge eating and Bulimia are clearly not psychiatric disorders. The top 4 pathways (Melanocortin, Incretin hormone, Neuropetide processing, and Cannabinoid) would all be better classified as Endocrine (except maybe cannabinoid which we don't really target). Anorexia is mostly due to mutations in genes that were called 'Inborn Errors of Metabolism' when I was in medical school. The most common pathway is importing long-chain fatty acids into the mitochondria and the second most common pathway is breakdown of essential amino acids. These pathways are clearly not classically 'Psychiatric'. I now think of the eating disorders more as metabolic/endocrine disorders that also cause intense psychiatric symptoms.

I'm not sure what it means for the future of treating eating disorders. Most Psychiatrists already don't like managing eating disorder patients, I can't imagine they want to learn about Krebs Cycle again. At the same time, I don't see Endocrinologists or Internists taking over. I can't recall a time in medicine where one disease was actually found to be better treated by another specialty. Any thoughts on who should manage these disorders?


r/Psychiatry • • Apr 16 '24

Florida anti trans laws

2 Upvotes

Hello, does anyone know the law on issues pertaining to youths and pronouns? If the parents state “you must refer to my child as their birth name and pronouns” does the law bind you into misgendering the child? Even when it is demonstrably damaging to their mental health? How are other providers handling this increasingly common scenario? What, if any, resources can be supplied to families whose political or religious views do not align to support their children’s identity or orientation? I feel very worried, and honestly distressed, for my pediatric patients in this position. Thanks all.


r/Psychiatry • • Apr 03 '20

Lockdown advice from the Royal College Of Psychiatrists

Thumbnail
pbs.twimg.com
0 Upvotes

r/Psychiatry • • Sep 06 '26

Colleagues Recommending Certain Treatments

0 Upvotes

Just some thoughts I had when responding to another comment, where certain therapeutic modalities were being recommended for a specific patient population.

I have seen very strong responses here when non-prescribing psych-based practitioners (ie: psychologists, therapists, LCSWs) make med suggestions (specific meds to stop/start/try, changes to dosing schedule) for their patients to discuss with their psychiatrist/prescriber.

How do you feel that is so different than psychiatrists who recommend specific therapeutic modalities to their patients?

In case anyone is wondering, the suggestion was for patients with PTSD/CPTSD diagnosis to do CBT as their initial therapeutic intervention. And thats, in fact, a terrible suggestion.


r/Psychiatry • • May 15 '26

Why isn't residency for NPs more common?

4 Upvotes

I have been recently started working with a PMHNP who completed a 1 year residency in psychosomatic medicine and I'm honestly impressed with their knowledge and clinical competence. Documentation and clinical decision-making couldn't be better. However, this doesn't seem very common of a career path. Why don't we have these programs more available? What's the obstacle to making this more common?


r/Psychiatry • • Oct 23 '24

Threshold to call CPS?

0 Upvotes

At inpatient child psych right now and my patient said their parents threatened to kill them and physically attacked them. I have a slight suspicion patient is making it up, but my attending says we have a duty to report this to CPS - “our job is to report, not to determine veracity.”

I totally get this point (and this being my attending I don’t argue), but I also wonder if other psychiatrists practice differently.

Do y’all:

  1. Do as my attending does at the of risk inflicting significant psychosocial stressors to families, knowing full well some children may not recognize the effects of their lying

  2. Interrogate the child further at the risk of making them feel unheard and recant what otherwise was a true story

  3. Some other combination of 1 or 2 or something altogether

MD/DO only please

Edit: people so mad being asked not to participate because not MD/DO. Just go to med school if you crave validation that much.


r/Psychiatry • • Apr 27 '25

When charting today, I came across this little gem: patient claims hx of GAD w panic attacks; bad smells make her ‘irrationally angry’.

1 Upvotes

Gimme your best side gem.


r/Psychiatry • • Jun 05 '26

how concerned do we actually need to be about mid level creep?

8 Upvotes

I’m a current resident but keep seeing all this propaganda about mid level creep. while I have see the effects of mid levels practicing during my own training (making more than residents despite taking lighter patient loads etc), how worried do we actually need to be for job prospects (specifically in a few years when I graduate)? I’ll be doing child psychiatry but am curious what all the hoopla is about


r/Psychiatry • • Jan 16 '24

Can psychiatrists train to do DBS?

0 Upvotes

After looking into all the interventional psychiatry programs, whenever DBS is mentioned as part of training, the psychiatrist’s role has just been to identify, screen, and clear patients for the procedure leaving the actual surgery to NSGY.

Is it a very complicated procedure? Are there workshops / training courses to learn it?

How feasible is it for a psychiatrist to learn to do the DBS procedure?

Edit: damn, y’all have zero chill. I hope you don’t treat your med students like this when they ask - what I realize now is - a stupid question. Thanks u/PokeTheVeil for actually answering my question.


r/Psychiatry • • Jan 28 '24

Psychiatrist- money advice

7 Upvotes

Fellow psychiatrists: PGY-2 here, hoping to maximize income when I graduate to work as hard as I can for my first few years out. Are there any types of practice settings or fellowships that can help me maximize income potential?


r/Psychiatry • • Aug 07 '20

How can someone have both ADHD and autism? -from a neurologist in training (long post, tldr at bottom)

10 Upvotes

EDIT: After reading some and considering what you guys are telling me, it seems ASD tends to be more pervasive than ADHD and affect more domains. So ASD isn't just about attention, and may not even include that domain, but there are many other domains that together would fit a diagnosis of ASD while other behaviors and issues from those behaviors would also fit an ADHD diagnosis, hence these can be co-morbid.

Hi everyone,

I've been studying neuro-cognitive disorders lately, and it struck me that adhd and autism seem like polar opposites in many ways.

Those with autism like things predictable, similar to every other experience, order, and often experience distress when things occur out of order. They have restricted or narrow interests and often focus on small parts of objects, such as the wheels on toy cars. They process information differently than "neurotypicals," often absorbing much more information at one time than others. They tend to be overwhelmed by this information and thus appear "sensitive" to various tactile, visual and auditory stimuli. It's also thought this is part of the reason they avoid eye contact, because the expression of the eyes convey a ton of information. There are some studies showing that (neurotypical) children who don't make as much eye contact with a teacher when thinking about the answer to a question the teacher asked are more likely to answer correctly. The thought was that those who answered incorrectly were unable to process the question as much because they were processing the teacher's emotions conveyed through the eyes.

Those with AD/HD either live like they're driven by a motor from a dragster, but also sometimes like their head is "in the clouds." This of course refers to the hyperactive and inattentive forms of the disorder which are not mutually exclusive. Central to most cases of AD/HD is a dysfunction of attention, most often this is described colloquially as a "short attention span." This underlies many of the behaviors those with ADHD have, such as missing important information stated during classes, not noticing events occurring that neurotypicals do, and taking a long time to read books. The way I think of it, the person's attention span is shorter than others' and moves onto different things, leading to either delays in finishing reading a book due to frequent "obligatory" distractions, or not paying attention to a situation, person etc. long enough to notice particular occurrences. ADHD can actually be objectively diagnosed with continuous performance tests, such as the Test of Variables of Attention and Conners Continuous Performance Test. I think these tests also measure particular types of fidgeting as a way to assess hyperactivity, but the most eloquent aspect is in its measurements of inattention and impulsivity using errors of omission and commission as surrogate markers, respectively. Unfortunately, these eloquent and objective tests for the controversial disorder ADHD seems seldom used in favor of surveys and interviews, which while important in assessing the patient as a whole and putting the test results in context don't really serve the same capacity as said CPTs.

Anyway, as you can see, autism spectrum disorders and ADHD appear to emerge from very different mechanisms. ASD seems almost to represent an excessively long attention span and dislike of spontaneity, whereas ADHD represents short attention spans and thriving on spontaneity. Both have social deficits, but such deficits seem to emerge from the respective mechanisms underlying each disorder and don't necessarily reflect a connection. I.e., kid A is "bad at reading people" because his or her attention is on one of a million different places it goes throughout the day, and happens not to include one person's facial expression, mostly due to inattention and sometimes impulsivity. Kid B is "bad at reading people" because he or she is excessively occupied with a single, narrow task for many hours and avoids faces because they contain a very large amount of dynamic information and overloads the kid's ability to process this information, making them emotionally upset. Both kids have social problems particularly with noticing people's expressions but these problems arise from very different etiologies. It's like saying anemia of chronic disease and iron deficiency anemia are similar disorders because both show a decline in hemoglobin.

Tl;dr ADHD and ASD are very different disorders with some mutually exclusive characteristics but people are often diagnosed with both. This reflects a lack of understanding, objective testing, or both.


r/Psychiatry • • Mar 19 '24

Any Physician Assistants?

8 Upvotes

I’ve noticed that a majority of what I see in the psychiatric field are either nurse practitioners or physicians. As a physician assistant, what would you say are the pros and cons of your title specifically in the realm of psychiatry?


r/Psychiatry • • Oct 24 '25

On the struggle bus. (NP)

6 Upvotes

Hey all. I work for a rather decent size psych group. We are ~40 of us and a mix between MD’s and PA’s and NP’s. I’m struggling because I’m finding that I’ll spend a ton of time, 3-4 months with a patient who’s just unable to climb out of a depressed state, trialed all meds known to man, prior to me, we’ve done ketamine, all the things, gone through prior authorizations, etc. And then they just demand a different provider and get it without question. Often it’s an MD. Then the MD starts a Prozac or something they’ve been on before.. and then they’re just back in the same routine.

I’m just wondering if this is common everywhere because it makes me feel like all my efforts are in vain for the previous time spent. A second opinion is always appropriate but I’m frustrated that it seems to happen almost behind my back. Bizarre feeling. Are there any policies out there for your employment in outpatient settings for switching providers? Like in my view ideally give us a chance of 6 months. If after 6 months you’re still miserable then ok.. but I guess if I’m in the patient’s view, they’re miserable.

It’s a microwave generation and unfortunately in psychiatry, things don’t generally happen in light speed. /insecurerant


r/Psychiatry • • Nov 10 '21

PMHNP Collaborative Agreement Troubles

5 Upvotes

I am a PMHNP with both inpatient and academic experience. Over the course of the last year and a half I have had so much trouble obtaining and or maintaining a collaborator. Doctors are extremely hesitant to partner with me.

I have a great reputation and have never had issue in any areas of my practice. I also attended a highly respected university.

I am mandated to have this partnership in writing but no one is willing. If they are they are charging unreasonable amounts of money for this relationship. I’m at my whits end, I love what I do but can’t seem to find support.

Please help, any and all advise welcome.


r/Psychiatry • • Feb 13 '26

Using at-home cognitive testing in your practice

1 Upvotes

I get a lot of patients complaining of mental fog, memory issues, poor attention, etc. and want to start offering at home cognitive testing instead of referring to neuropsychological testing which hardly ever gets done. Can anyone share their experience with providers like CANTAB, CNS Vital Signs, or others? Have you found it useful? Use one-time or longitudinal testing?


r/Psychiatry • • Jun 09 '26

DSM quasi-science < Neuroscience

18 Upvotes

I'm going to say what a lot of us think but don't say out loud: the DSM, as a diagnostic framework, is holding psychiatry back.

MDD has 227 possible symptom combinations that all get the same diagnosis. Two patients can share ONE overlapping symptom and both carry the label "MDD." And the timelines are completely arbitrary. A patient with clear signs of depression (5/8 DSM criteria) on day 13 doesn't have MDD, but magically does on day 14? What changed in the brain overnight? Nothing. The threshold is administrative, not biological.

And let's be real. In the age of AI, a diagnostic system built entirely on self-reported behavioral checklists is increasingly gameable. Someone can literally ask ChatGPT how to present to get a specific diagnosis and medication. The DSM has no defense against this because it was never designed around objective pathophysiology.
Even the NIMH recognized this. That's why they launched RDoC, explicitly because DSM categories are heterogeneous syndromes, not diseases, and decades of research failed to find reliable biomarkers tied to DSM diagnoses.

So what should we be talking about instead? The actual neuroscience. The stuff that made me love psychiatry in the first place. Serotonin isn't just "chemical imbalance." There are 14+ receptor subtypes with distinct & sometimes opposing roles. Presynaptic 5-HT1A autoreceptors in the raphe actually REDUCE serotonergic output when SSRIs flood the synapse, which is why they take weeks to work (autoreceptor desensitization). Postsynaptic 5-HT1A activation in corticolimbic areas is what's actually therapeutic. That pre vs. post-synaptic distinction is why we now have drugs like vilazodone, vortioxetine, and gepirone targeting specific receptor profiles rather than just blocking SERT and hoping for the best.

MRS studies show reduced prefrontal GABA in MDD patients, even in remission. Ketamine works through NMDA blockade on GABA interneurons → glutamate surge → AMPA activation → BDNF release → mTOR-mediated synaptogenesis. Antidepressant effects in HOURS. Makes the 14-day DSM criterion look even more ridiculous.

Elevated CRH, cortisol non-suppression on dex testing, and failure of HPA normalization predicting relapse. Offspring of depressed parents show elevated basal cortisol before they ever develop symptoms. This is a heritable vulnerability marker, not just a consequence of illness. None of this is captured by a DSM checklist.

I'm not saying phenomenology doesn't matter. But when IM attendings grill us on pathophysiology and mechanism of action and we can only point to a behavioral checklist, we're undermining our own credibility as a medical specialty. We should be able to discuss 5-HT receptor subtypes and glutamatergic synaptogenesis with the same fluency when teaching med students and residents.

I wish my attending recommended me to read these below rather than pointing to the DSM-V, such an annoying book!

Neuropsychopharmacology (ACNP journal)
Biological Psychiatry
Molecular Psychiatry
CNS Drugs (great receptor pharmacology reviews)
Current Neuropharmacology (HPA axis, neurosteroids, novel targets)

The DSM is a communication and billing tool. It should never be mistaken for the science itself. To be honest, I hate it! It labels without discussing neuroscience & that’s annoying the crap out of me as an incoming psychiatry resident.

Why do some psychiatrists get boxed by a DSM while what they studied is medicine? The behavioral manifestation isn’t what we should be talking about as researchers, why aren’t we spending time teaching students, residents - the basics ~ the pathophysiology? Anyone even midlevels can memorize the DSM pretty easily!


r/Psychiatry • • Jun 29 '24

Does psychiatry have an inherent politics?

0 Upvotes

https://x.com/SameiHuda/status/1806944531721416912?t=5NyZxYTvjsv-AdjJneLdCg&s=08

While attending a conference last year, i was noticing how psychiatry is essentially a conservative project, given its focus on fitting in, personal effort, responsibility and community.

Of course we might see these as more enlightenment values or liberal ideology than strictly being on the conservative right. But it's definitely in opposition to the left and dialectic materialism?

Two other streams are certainly on the left though. One is the public health apparatus in psychiatry... In my part of the world it's also referred to as social psychiatry which is all about structural factors and determinants that are often unmodifiable.

The other strain is of rogers and client centred therapy, which also discounts agency?

I'm not trying to make an activisty statement about the right and wrong of this, nor am I saying that things are black and white. Rogers obviously influences our practice as much as beck or linehan .

Just wanted to convey my growing awareness of this subliminal aspect, and the sense that maybe it's something that creates dissonances in the papers we read And the things we do.

Thoughts?


r/Psychiatry • • Mar 08 '24

Stimulant Rx rationale

26 Upvotes

How do clinicians here approach patients who are on chronic stimulant therapy but do not have functional improvement in their lives? I've seen some primary care patients diagnosed with ADHD, consistently being prescribed stimulants by psych MDs and PMHNPs, yet these patients exhibit minimal to no improvement in their functional abilities. For instance, I observed patients who are chronically homeless, lacking employment history, never attending school, while being prescribed these medications. What is the justification for prescribing these drugs in such cases? Are some providers primarily relying on symptom reports and disregarding whether these drugs are actually improving the patients' functional outcomes?

Also, how do clinicians here approach patients who keep returning for ADHD psych appts, but repeatedly no-show to their important primary care or specialist appointments?


r/Psychiatry • • Oct 07 '26

Malingering: Are We Sometimes So Afraid of the Label That We Fail to Document What We Actually Think?

20 Upvotes

After more than four decades in psychiatry, I have become increasingly interested in a peculiar problem with the word malingering.

It is a diagnosis—or perhaps more accurately, a clinical formulation—that can cause harm when used carelessly.

But avoiding it can also cause harm.

Malingering is not simply having something to gain from being ill. Our patients frequently have secondary gains associated with illness: shelter, disability benefits, medications, avoidance of responsibilities, hospitalization, attention from family, or protection from an intolerable environment.

None of that establishes malingering.

The critical element is intentional production or substantial exaggeration of symptoms for an external incentive.

And there lies the difficulty: intention is one of the hardest things in medicine to establish.

We cannot measure malingering with a blood test. We cannot look inside another person's mind and directly observe intent. Even substantial discrepancies between reported symptoms and observed behavior do not, by themselves, prove deliberate deception.

This makes caution appropriate.

But I wonder whether our profession sometimes moves from appropriate caution to something else: we recognize the possibility of malingering clinically but become reluctant to document it.

An experienced psychiatrist may notice that the history changes depending upon who is interviewing the patient. Reported symptoms may be inconsistent with prolonged observation. A symptom may appear or disappear when disposition is discussed. Collateral information may directly contradict important parts of the history. Reported psychotic experiences may be phenomenologically unusual. There may also be a clearly identifiable external incentive.

The psychiatrist thinks: There is a significant possibility that some of these symptoms are being intentionally produced or exaggerated.

The team may even discuss precisely that possibility.

And then the medical record says almost nothing about it.

The next psychiatrist encounters the patient and essentially starts from zero.

That creates another kind of risk.

A patient may undergo repeated hospitalization, medication changes, escalating doses, unnecessary testing, or increasingly complicated diagnoses because previous clinicians were uncomfortable documenting what they had actually observed.

There is another complication that I think is particularly important:

Malingering and genuine psychiatric illness are not mutually exclusive.

A person with schizophrenia can exaggerate hallucinations.

A person with PTSD can fabricate a particular symptom.

A person with substance-use disorder can report suicidality for admission while simultaneously having substantial genuine psychiatric illness.

The discovery of deception does not magically make everything else about the patient false.

Perhaps, therefore, our choice should not be between:

“This patient is malingering.”

and

saying nothing at all.

There is a third possibility: document the evidence.

Instead of writing simply “malingering,” we can describe the discrepancies we observed, relevant collateral information, changes in presentation, possible external incentives, and—most importantly—our degree of certainty.

For example:

“There is concern for possible intentional exaggeration of reported symptoms because of X, Y and Z. An external incentive is present. However, genuine psychiatric illness remains present/has not been excluded.”

That gives the next clinician information rather than merely a label.

It also leaves room for us to be wrong.

I am curious how colleagues approach this.

How much evidence do you require before you actually document malingering? Do you use the term itself, document “concern for malingering,” or avoid it and describe only the observed inconsistencies? And have you seen cases in which reluctance to document the concern resulted in unnecessary admissions or treatment later?


r/Psychiatry • • Jul 17 '24

How to manage suspected malingering in psychiatry

41 Upvotes

Hi all, I’m a PA practicing at an outpatient psychiatric clinic. I have one patient in particular I am thinking of when I write this that I will use as an example, but I can think of a handful of patients who fit this description.

I have been having regular (every 2-4 week) appointments with this patient pretty much since I began practicing 1 year ago. They have been unemployed since I began seeing them, and their disability hearing is coming up soon. They are very dysthymic, with PHQ scores persistently in the 20s. Lonnnnnng list of psychiatric medication trials and failures. You name it, they've tried it. Most of the medications we have trialed have not been tolerated, but they seem to be tolerating their current regimen of venlafaxine, bupropion, Vraylar, and clonazepam (1mg TID- from a previous prescriber). They are relatively pleasant on exam and their affect has definitely seemed more "upbeat" since initiation of Wellbutrin, but self-reported symptoms are the same with no reduction in PHQ scores. Yes, they've had some family estrangement, financial concerns, and other situational factors that can contribute, and of course I don't know the full picture, however I just feel that their symptoms are out of proportion to their affect (and perhaps their situation?). I don't really see evidence of a personality disorder that may explain it, and regular therapy sessions have yielded little to no benefit as well. I've suggested Spravato therapy as we offer it in our clinic, and patient refused. I don't really know where to turn with their care.

I don't like to throw the word around, but I can't get out of my head that this patient might be malingering to receive disability benefits. I definitely feel exasperated by this patient's care and just want to make sure I'm not missing anything important that may help them progress. Any advice is welcome!


r/Psychiatry • • Oct 24 '23

Can any psychs in here explain to me what is the Orgone school of thought?

1 Upvotes

Specifically the American College of Orgonomy? There’s so little info from what I can find. Is it just a way to approach things holistically, but then why are so few psychs in this group? TY