r/ProgressionFantasy • • Sep 24 '24 Bravo

I Recommend This The Wandering Inn says Trans Rights! ❤ Spoiler

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/ProgressionFantasy • • May 24 '24 Take My Silver

Discussion Can we ban all tier lists?

77 Upvotes

I've never seen a tier list and been like, "wow, I'm really glad I got to see some random person's irrelevant opinion today," and I'm pretty sure no one else has either. They are by far the lowest, most braindead form of content for any kind of subreddit, and it makes r/progressionfantasy feel like it's dying. I'd rather read a hundred more "What are your least favorite trope" posts than see another shit-ass tier list.

Edit: If tier lists actually engendered discussion, it would be one thing, but I can guarantee that most of the comments will be either "you put Cradle in F-tier? kowtow three times and call me grandfather" or "I recommend Cradle/HWFWM/Primal Hunter."

Edit 2: It appears my opinion won’t be particularly appreciated until I rate tier lists at F-tier in my upcoming r/progressionfantasy posts tier list.


r/ProgressionFantasy • • Oct 01 '25

Question Transfem protagonists?

3 Upvotes

Hey, i still have a list of good books from you guys, but i just got done with stray cat strut 6 and while i wait for more there id like to see if theres any good stories with a transwoman protagonist, im trans myself and honestly i feel like this genre would be absolutely perfect for a trans character, the transition can literally be part of the progression! Are there any good ones you guys would say i should check out?


r/ProgressionFantasy • • Nov 17 '24

Self-Promotion The Worst Novel on RR.

8 Upvotes

The First Circle. I don't know if you read it, but man, do I have some opinions about this. Although the first couple of chapters drew me in with the immediate action, he had to ruin that by having the characters actually have a conversation. Like, come on, stop trying to tell a story and just give me the action.

That being said, the card power system is very cool. Has some depth and nice potential. It IS good enough to be on Rising Stars. Only 24 chapters out tho, so who knows? Maybe the author won't do anything cool despite the setup smh. Check it out Here, if you're interested I guess

~A Shameless Plug, The Author Himself


r/ProgressionFantasy • • Jun 07 '23

Updates AI Generated Content Ban

17 Upvotes

Hi everyone! We come bearing news of a small but important change happening in the r/ProgressionFantasy sub. After extended internal discussion, the moderators have made the decision that AI generated content of any kind, whether it be illustations, text, audio narration, or other forms, will no longer be welcome on r/ProgressionFantasy effective July 1st.

While we understand that are a variety of opinions on the matter, it is the belief of the moderators that AI-generated content in the state that it is right now allows for significantly more harm than good in creative spaces like ours.

There are consistent and explicit accusations of art theft happening every day, massive lawsuits underway that will hopefully shed some light on the processes and encourage regulation, and mounting evidence of loss of work opportunities for creators, such as the recent movement by some audiobook companies to move towards AI-reader instead of paid narrators. We have collectively decided that we do not want r/ProgressionFantasy to be a part of these potential problems, at least not until significant changes are made in how AI produces its materials, not to mention before we have an understanding of how it will affect the livelihoods of creators like writers and artists.

This is not, of course, a blanket judgement on AI and its users. We are not here to tell anyone what to do outside the subreddit, and even the most fervently Luddite and anti-AI of the mod team (u/JohnBierce, lol) recognizes that there are already some low-harm or even beneficial uses for AI. We just ask that you keep AI generated material off of this subreddit for the time being.

If you have any questions or concerns, you are of course welcome to ask in the comments, and we will do our best to answer them to the best of our ability and in a timely fashion!

Quick FAQ:

  • Does this ban discussion of AI?

    • No, not at all! Discussion of AI and AI related issues is totally fine. The only things banned are actual AI generated content.

    • Fictional AIs in human written stories are obviously not banned either.

  • What if my book has an AI cover?

    • Then you can't post it!

  • But I can't afford a cover by a human artist!

    • That's a legitimate struggle- but it's probably not true as you might think. We're planning to put together a thread of ways to find affordable, quality cover art for newer authors here soon. There are some really excellent options out there- pre-made covers, licensed art covers, budget cover art sites, etc, etc- and I'm sure a lot of the authors in this subreddit will have more options we don't even know about!

  • But what about promoting my book on the subreddit?

    • Do a text post, add a cat photo or something. No AI generated illustrations.

  • What if an image is wrongly reported as AI-generated?

    • We'll review quickly, and restore the post if we were wrong. The last thing we want to do is be a jerk to real artists- and we promise, we won't double down if called out. (That means Selkie Myth's artist is most definitely welcome here.)

  • What about AI writing tools like ProWritingAid, Hemingway, or the like?

    • That stuff's fine. While their technological backbones are similar in some ways to Large Language Models like ChatGPT or their image equivalents (MidJourney, etc), we're not crusading against machine learning/neural networks, here. They're 40 year old technologies, for crying out loud. Hell, AI as a blanket term for all these technologies is an almost incoherent usage at times. The problems are the mass theft of artwork and writing to train the models, and the potential job loss for creative workers just to make the rich richer.

  • What about AI translations?

    • So, little more complicated, but generally allowed for a couple reasons. First, because the writing was originally created by people. And second, because AI translations are absolutely terrible, and only get good after a ton of work by actual human translators. (Who totally rock- translating fiction is a hella tough job, mad respect for anyone who's good at it.)

  • What if someone sends AI art as reference material to an artist, then gets real art back?

    • Still some ethical concerns there, but they're far more minor. You're definitely free to post the real art here, just not the AI reference material.

  • What about AI art that a real artist has kicked into shape to make better? Fixing hands and such?

    • Still banned.

  • I'm not convinced on the ethical issues with AI.

    • If you haven't read them yet, Kotaku and the MIT Tech Review both have solid articles on the topic, and make solid starting points.

  • I'm familiar with the basic issues, and still not convinced.

    • Well, this thread is a reasonable place to discuss the matter.

  • Why the delay on the ban?

    • Sudden rule changes are no fun, for the mod team or y'all. We want to give the community more time to discuss the rule change, to raise any concerns about loopholes, overreach, etc. And, I guess, if you really want, post some AI crap- though if y'all flood the sub with it, we'll just activate the ban early.


r/ProgressionFantasy • • Sep 27 '26 Bravo

Request Trans Protagonists

7 Upvotes

My friend was asking me for some suggestions for progression fantasy with trans main characters. I suggested Tobias Begley's work but I realized I couldn't think of anything else. Does anyone know of some more works where the MC is trans so I can have a few more to give them?


r/ProgressionFantasy • • Dec 09 '23

Request Trans/LGBTQ mc?

9 Upvotes

Hi, I'm looking for recs with trans or gay mc. I would assume western novels have a higher chance of having a positive spin on it, as most eastern stories play it off as a joke as best. Thanks!


r/ProgressionFantasy • • Mar 03 '24

Discussion Unpopular Opinion: Punching is the worst form of combat

8 Upvotes

I know this sub likes its Azarinth healer and brawlers in general, but it’s the worst form of combat.

Ends of Magic at least justified in that the MC’s existence is antithetical to magic and magic weapons. So he has to punch things.

But most other characters don’t have that quirk. Any brawler would almost always be better served using either a weapon or spells. The only reason they function in the story is plot armor or their super special power.

Further, I think hand to hand combat is just boring to read, about as boring as melee weapons. Visually, it can be great - Geralt in The Witcher or Captain America v Bucky. But I don’t ever see that translated into text.

If anyone has recommendations with well written brawlers, let me know. AH is not one of them.


r/ProgressionFantasy • • Sep 02 '26 Heartwarming

Self-Promotion Moneymaker - From #1 on RS to Amazon KU!

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Hello everyone! Bertt here!

My 4th series, and easily my most popular one, is moving to Amazon KU today! Superhero action with a bit of romance never hurt anyone, right? Anyway, this book has been a lot of fun to write, and I hope it will be as fun to read!

Available now in Ebook/Paperback formats (paperback has illustrations!), with Audio coming in December!

Alright then. Blurb time!

Money is power. Too bad he's broke.

Nathan Brody was an average college student in New York until his death transports him into his favorite video game, My Superhero Life. Finding himself in the Ako Superhero Academy inside this romance/action visual novel world, he discovers himself growing stronger with each dollar, unlocking abilities in a strange "Power Shop" system. But his wallet isn't the only thing the ladies have their eye on.

What should be a dream come true evolves into a nightmare as the plot doesn't play out as it should. Main Characters are missing, heroes are siding with the villains, and Nathan's own memories are blocked by an unknown force. Enrolled into class 1-F, the class for misfits with the weakest powers, he meets Alicia Banava, a small-time antagonist from the game, and Vermillion Strike, a teacher at the very school he studies at.

A war is supposed to begin in three years, and yet now, there is nobody to stop it. Worst of all, there's a strange system window with a ticking clock, and achieving the "happy ending" might be a bit more than Nathan ever asked for.

Link: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0GX2XQQWX

COVER ARTIST: ZunoArt
AI USAGE: None!
Character artist: Argo


r/ProgressionFantasy • • Jul 01 '25

I Recommend This 1% lifesteal does not get enough love

2 Upvotes

Totally professionally written. Incredibly convincing character interactions that feel like they're actually happening, not a tedious sideshow between more fighting and levelups.

A main character that is often questioned by other characters and doesn't just immediately start winning at every aspect of life the moment he swings a sword better. It's really cool stuff.

There are also interesting ideas about what to do about problems at play that actually contradict each other, rather than the feeling that the author is simply talking to the reader in the same way with many different voices.

Perhaps most refreshingly, the hero worship is kept to a minimum and morality is complex (so far). MC hates society, but characters are annoyed with him for it.

He gets called edgy. Which he is! Loads of progression fantasy characters are. But this time people are like, "Well you got a better way to run a society, bub?"

It actually makes it feels like they live in the world and are a bit perturbed at this guy that just wants to burn it all.

Some actual decent skepticism and hestinacy to just deify MC.

Like "Are you sure you're qualified to be a god emperor Mr.?"

Too many books are just very small ponds that MC immediately starts winning over with occasional belated reminders of "Hey this character is deeefinitely stronger than MC. They could kill him ya know," to show other people are alive and doing things in the world, too.

This is also a rare author that attempts multiple perspectives at different points in the world.

By the standards of progression fantasy, this stuff is Lord of the Rings in my opinion.

Edit: Wow, there is some really heartfelt dislike for this series. To each their own, i suppose.

Edit: mhm m'kay. I get it. Thanks for this great interaction with your community.


r/ProgressionFantasy • • Jun 09 '26

Question Am I crazy or is this written by AI?

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/ProgressionFantasy • • Jan 13 '24

Request Socialist MC

0 Upvotes

Can anyone recommend me a story where the main character is a socialist, or a radical leftist in general. Bonus points of the MC is nurodivergent or queer and a magic user.


r/ProgressionFantasy • • Sep 10 '24

I Recommend This No One Is Talking About This -- What's Wrong With Y'all?

10 Upvotes

Hi!~

Okay, so I lurk here day and night (as in, on waking up and then when I go to bed. I'm an in-bed redditor, which is my excuse for why most of my posts here are incoherent) and I've noticed that no one is talking about Blood and Fur.

That's like, a crime. It's a Void Herald book, ffs, people should be gushing about this stuff non-stop. Is it the word fur in the title? There's no furry stuff in it, I swear!

Anyway, it's a weird Aztec dark fantasy progression story. The MC learns spells while visiting the underworld in his sleep. He's got like, a year to get his shit together before he's, as the youth say, unalived.

Book one just came out on Amazon, and if you don't read it I will think less of you!

Loud Linky link: https://www.audible.com/pd/The-Last-Emperor-Audiobook/B0D9MHBZRP

Wordy Linky Link: https://www.amazon.com/Last-Emperor-Progression-Fantasy-Blood-ebook/dp/B0D61473NG


r/ProgressionFantasy • • May 04 '25

Request Gay mc

9 Upvotes

Looking for well-written stories with gay cis male main characters with some amount of romance. To be clear, I mean gay cis male/gay cis male. I always struggle to find them on royal road and I've heard theres some history of LGBT stories having issues in that environment, so I don't mind reading other places.


r/ProgressionFantasy • • Jul 11 '26

Self-Promotion A no-ai fiction platform for readers, writers, artists and narrators

Post image
0 Upvotes

Ever since I started writing I've noticed how vocal this subreddit has been against the use of generative ai and Ive always really appreciated that.

A month ago, I volunteered to help grow a human only fiction platform called fictionite. It's still a baby, but its growing everyday. Fictionite is a place for authors, editors, artists and narrators to come together and form a sort of creative team around a story. We don't allow the use of generative ai for art, writing or narration, and we are serious about keeping slop out of our community.

But wait, I already don't support ai writing, why do I need a new platform for that?

Because sadly, most platforms aren't making sure ai stories are tagged.

Recently, someone made a filter for ao3 that exposed how many stories were definitively gen ai. And those were just the stories by authors silly enough to copy paste directly from Claude. It may come as a shock to some of you, but many ai stories aren't tagged or labeled that way. Almost none of them are, and platforms that rely on the honor system have essentially given up on doing anything about that.

For readers, that means odds are you're going to end up reading slop. For authors, that means your work is silently being drowned out.

But if you're rejecting ai stories, isn't that like...a witch hunt?

No. If a story is rejected from fictionite, nobody outside of the staff will know. We don't make a public spectacle of any of the ai stories that attempt to publish here. Those stories can find a home somewhere else.

How are you even figuring out which stories are ai?

Our methodology involves multiple stages, one of which is a manual review. None of the content posted on fictionite is used to train ai models by us or our detection partners. Fictionite has also taken steps to make scraping our website as difficult as possible.

For the part of our process that triggers our manual review, we've partnered with Pangram. Their detection rate is 99.98%, with a false positive rate of .005%. Those rates have been evaluated by third parties in multiple peer reviewed journals. One of those studies is linked here. That false positive rate is per 1000 words, meaning that in a 100,000 word manuscript, the odds of a false positive happening across every single chapter are extremely, extremely remote. We've set our thresholds in a way that ensures no story will be rejected due to a false positive. It's also effective against automatic-humanizers.

Our founder is a PhD in AI. We've run multiple benchmarks on Pangram's detection model. While I understand skepticism around AI-detection, it's only one part of our process to identify ai-generated writing and keep it off the platform. And there is always a human in the loop.

Look guys, I want to be as transparent as possible here. Even with Pangram and the other tools we have available to identify AI-writing, we're not going to stop all of it. Nobody can. Especially since we're erring on the side of caution during manual reviews. But we're going to stop a lot of it, especially the bulk-generated stories by authors churning out hundreds of novels per month. And not a single author is going to get hurt in the process. It's entirely confidential. Those ai-writers can go post their story anywhere else without fear of being persecuted or called out by us.

Nobody is witch hunting. The community is discouraged from reporting or making accusations about other fictions, and thus far nobody has. In fact, the website does not even have a report feature. The community is not expected to or encouraged to police each other, or the content published to fictionite. We don't want mob justice, and we actively discourage it from taking place.

Here's how we've made keeping slop off fictionite easier:

  1. The invite process eliminates bots

  2. Not allowing ai-generated covers discourages large scale slop farmers from publishing there, because they would need to commission human-made covers for dozens or in some cases hundreds of stories.

  3. Pangram and our own proprietary software flag suspicious writing, allowing us to privately reach out to authors to request proof-of-authorship.

I can tell you from experience on that last point, that AI-writers manuscripts look significantly different than human ones. I won't go into detail about how. but there are clear and obvious indications no matter what automated tools are used to attempt to scrub metadeta or hidden characters.

We're always open to feedback from the community on this, but actually putting effort into keeping ai-generated stories off the site is something that is desperately wanted by readers and authors out there. This isn't something nobody asked for. A lot of people are frustrated with platforms doing absolutely nothing about this problem. If you're upset that one platform out of hundreds is committed to making an effort, I'm sorry, but nobody is forcing you to publish here. There are plenty of spaces doing nothing to keep ai-content out, if that's what you're looking for.

But what if i just use ai for spelling or grammar

Fictionite is only against the use of generative ai, not spellcheck. We also can't control whether or not folks bounce questions or ideas off an llm... though you'd probably get better feedback from a person. Our complete ai policy is on the website for more info.

Aren't you kind of like, gate keeping?

Yes. Nobody is obligated to read something that no human took the time to write.

But, Isn't ai inevitable? Shouldn't we just accept that it's here to stay?

Sure, it can stay over there. We believe generative ai has no place in art, writing or music.

You can check the site out at fictionite.com and join the discord from there.


r/ProgressionFantasy • • Sep 15 '25

I Recommend This Mage Tank by Cornman has an openly trans character in the first book! So cool!

129 Upvotes

Edit: if this post bothers you so much that you feel the need to not only downvote it but go through all the comments and downvote all of them I don't even have words to describe how frankly pathetic that is.

It might sound silly to most people but like as a trans person it's really cool to see especially in my favorite genre. And I'll admit that I have a bit of an OCD thing where I don't want to support authors who are bigoted especially with the current political climate and some of the jokes earlier in the book left me somewhat worried about the author's political leanings, but this really clears up my compulsive worried and that you can relax and enjoy the book more.

I'm not saying every author has to include a to/ken trans character for my sake but it is really cool to see and it makes me really happy and I just want to express it. Queer characters in progression fantasy are surprisingly rare, especially any flavor of trans.


r/ProgressionFantasy • • Mar 09 '25

Request Can we revisit pride flag

0 Upvotes

Hello,

It has been 2 years. Can we revisit the pride flag? Point has well and truly been made and not seeing any bigotry, etc, here at all.

Would be cool to maybe run some kind of art competition in here and see what happens.

Worried I'll be attacked simply for suggesting the idea, but thought I'd throw it out there. The community needs to be inclusive and not to discriminate, 100%, and support the current imagery for a long time. But I think it has been a while and point is made, things seem well, would be good to reflect what the community is ultimately about in its imagery.

It's about progression fantasy literature, not about peoples sexual identity and preferences specifically.


r/ProgressionFantasy • • Sep 13 '23

Request Gay, LGBTQIA+ stories

11 Upvotes

I'm looking for some new litRPG or Progression stories who have gay characters. I'm looking for newer stuff as well.

Thanks for any suggestions!


r/ProgressionFantasy • • Jul 06 '26

Discussion Why does Solo Leveling get so much hate for "lack of depth" when 90% of this genre is just tropes?

0 Upvotes

I’ve only read the manhwa and watched the anime, but I really don't get the criticism.

People complain about SL having "no depth," but let's be real: this is Progression Fantasy. The whole genre is carried by hard power systems and constant tropes. Nobody is comparing it to Attack on Titan, but against the average PF story, SL actually delivers its premise with perfect pacing and momentum.

I know some will bring up ORV or similar titles as "actual good writing." Sure, they might be more original, but let's not ignore that those stories are stretched out forever just to milk readers for cash, completely ruining the pacing.

SL might be straightforward, but at least it doesn't drag. Is the hate genuine, or just hating on what's popular?


r/ProgressionFantasy • • 18d ago

Discussion Normal MC's are overrated.

8 Upvotes

I often hear that readers want MC's who are normal without any cheats to climb the ranks and become the strongest. Personally I would find it exhausting to follow a protagonist who has to struggle and suffer at every corner. I prefer a cheat, not only does it explain why the MC is able to grow faster than others and fight creatures above his level, but it avoids making the book a slog to get through.

The main character doesn't need to slap gods at chapter 1 (Although he will eventually), just a little cheat so that he doesn't start at the literal bottom is needed.

Primal hunter is a great example, Jake is Op because of his bloodline, but only in his Tier. He can still be beaten by numerous others above his grade.

In conclusion, Normal MC's aren't fun.


r/ProgressionFantasy • • Feb 20 '24

Request Bisexual Male protag

7 Upvotes

Seeking works that have openly bisexual male protagonists as part of a study


r/ProgressionFantasy • • Jan 17 '25

Question Gay leads?

21 Upvotes

Pretty much what it says in the title. I was wondering if there's any prog fantasy books with gay male leads to read. You see sapphic women on occasion but I've yet to find an MLM couple.


r/ProgressionFantasy • • Apr 14 '24

Discussion Gay mc this gay mc that, how about people list resources for queer stories.

0 Upvotes

List some spaces where people can post their own queer stories. God knows we need that. Royalroad has this tendency to be very homophobic when you don't prime their readerbase for a gay ship.

List some media with queer characters as the mc. And avoid f/f books unless you know they're written with a queer lens in mind. I don't have anything against f/f books, but those tend to be popular anyways.

Idk much about the first issue, but the for the second question, there is this one great book called Hope on royalroad. Fast progression, reincarnated mc, mage mc, and a pretty solid magic system. The mc is canonically asexual, which might not seem much but it's very explicit that he's asexual. It also has a bisexual side character for a solid portion of the story.


r/ProgressionFantasy • • Sep 02 '25

Question Can we have book where the MC isn't everything about the story and is definitely not brutally OP!?

3 Upvotes

I think we all know and if not then I would say many of the shounen/male targeted/progressive fantasies books consist a helplessly overpowering male character who just keeps getting limitlessly powerful by every two chapters.

Not only does he become unrealisticacally powerful, he even is the only thing we can learn about in the story.

Yes, It's understandae as he's the MAIN CHARACTER so obviously, main character energy but... At least something crucial to others as well. Give them some integral roles in the stories as well.

Where it does seem thaat if those characters aren't there, the story would not be able to continue (except for the antagonist as definitely the MC needs to beath the sheet out of someone).

Rant over. Thanks and apologies. :'D