r/ProgressionFantasy • • Jan 09 '26

Meme/Shitpost Gentlemen i may have a brain but i don't have standards

Post image
4.1k Upvotes

r/ProgressionFantasy • • Jan 11 '26

Meme/Shitpost Ah yes, of course I am impressed by S rank since I surely won't see it as step 1 of the story.

Post image
3.9k Upvotes

Want to make the top dogs scary? Easy. Don't glaze them, don't hype them, slowly but surely describe how the very bottom of the foodchain is like and let the narrative focus on the bottom. Let the reader speculate just what kind of monster the top dogs are.

Or that's at least how I like my progression fantasies and games to be like.


r/ProgressionFantasy • • Mar 05 '26

Meme/Shitpost Switch up so crazy even the devil may cry

Post image
3.8k Upvotes

Mfs switch to a completely different person all of a sudden. I promise you if you put this much effort on earth you’d be a billionaire instead of a bum😭🙏


r/ProgressionFantasy • • Mar 08 '26

Meme/Shitpost The forerunners always get left in the dust

Post image
3.4k Upvotes

r/ProgressionFantasy • • Feb 06 '26

Meme/Shitpost Wish fulfillment to the extreme

Post image
3.3k Upvotes

Why are they always complete losers.


r/ProgressionFantasy • • Mar 06 '26

Meme/Shitpost Asspull central

Post image
2.8k Upvotes

r/ProgressionFantasy • • Sep 06 '25

Meme/Shitpost The objectively best premise

Post image
2.7k Upvotes

r/ProgressionFantasy • • Mar 02 '26

Meme/Shitpost I have a love hate relationship with OP bloodlines.

Post image
2.6k Upvotes

I don't mind the mc having a crazy power or bloodline but just acknowledge that the MC didn't entirely earn his power. I kind of hate it when the MC beats down random people who had none of his advantages and acts so smug with himself.


r/ProgressionFantasy • • Dec 12 '25

Meta Baited.

Post image
2.4k Upvotes

Then again, maybe it's just me?


r/ProgressionFantasy • • May 08 '26

Meme/Shitpost CEO death eaters 💀 VS CEO heaven & earth great love alliance🥰

Post image
2.2k Upvotes

Left = Lord Voldemort

Right = Fang Yuan


r/ProgressionFantasy • • Mar 01 '22

Xianxia Unsouled - I made some Cradle fanart, I hope you like it!

Post image
2.1k Upvotes

r/ProgressionFantasy • • May 26 '24 Galaxy Brain Heart of Silver Bravo

Review I Went Through My Own Training Montage and Analyzed Every Tier List on the Progression Fantasy Subreddit

2.1k Upvotes

After all the tier list discussion over the last week, I was compelled by forces beyond my control to try to see what information we could gleam from them as a collective. To do this, I examined every tier list I could find on this subreddit, made a very long spreadsheet, and tried to do a little bit of data analysis on it. Not to get all clickbait article-y on it, but some of the results were pretty surprising (and some were extremely expected).

1. THE TIER LISTS

Using the very bad reddit search function, I pulled every tier list that could be found on the subreddit. I excluded any meme or meta tier lists for obvious reasons. This left me with a total of 34 lists. I did exclude any books that were Light Novels, Novel Translations, Manga/Manhwa/Manhua, traditionally published books, or books in the DNF tier, (there were also under 5 books that I couldn't identify from the tier list image), mainly to make creating the spreadsheet a little more manageable. The average user ranked 33.9 books, with the lowest ranking only 8 books and the highest ranking 107 books.

2. A BRIEF SECTION ON DATA

Because there were so many different ranking scales (SSS-F, S-D, S-F, etc), I normalized the data where 1 meant the ranker placed the book in the top tier and 0 meant they placed it in the bottom tier. In a S/A/B/C/F scale S=1 A=0.75 B=0.5 C=0.25 F=0. Okay lets get to the fun part.

3. THE BOOKS

There was a total of 469 different instances of books on the tier lists. Of these, only 187 of them were ranked 2 or more times, 52 were ranked 5 or more times, and 20 were ranked 10 or more times.

4. THE 10 MOST RANKED BOOKS

The 10 most ranked were:

  • Cradle by Will Wight - 29 ranks (not surprising anyone)

  • He Who Fights with Monsters by Shirtaloon - 24 ranks

  • Mother of Learning by Domagoj Kurmaic aka Nobody103 - 22 ranks

  • Defiance of the Fall by J F Brinks - 21ranks

  • Primal Hunter by Zogarth - 19 ranks

  • Mark of the Fool by J M Clark aka U Juggernaut - 18 ranks

  • Dungeon Crawler Carl by Matt Dinniman - 17 ranks

  • Mage Errant by John Bierce - 16 ranks

  • Warformed: Stormweaver by Bryce O’Connor - 16 ranks

  • Azarinth Healer by Rhaegar - 15 ranks

5. MOST CONSISTENT HIGHLY RANKED BOOKS

The books had 3 or more ranks and placed most in the top quartile (top 25%) of the tier lists.

  1. A Summoner Awakens by Kerberos - 4 ranks - 100% in the top quartile

  2. Worm by John McCrae aka Windbow - 3 ranks - 100% in the top quartile

  3. The Wandering Inn by Pirateaba - 8 ranks - 87.5% in the top quartile

  4. Super Powered by Drew Hayes - 6 ranks - 83% in the top quartile

  5. Cradle by Will Wight - 29 ranks - 75% in the top quartile

  6. The Stargazers War by J P Valentine - 4 ranks - 75% in the top quartile

6. BOOKS WITH THE HIGHEST AVERAGE RANK

These were the books that were ranked 5 or times and had the highest average ranks. Scores closer to 1 mean they were placed near the top tier in all tier lists they appeared in.

  1. Super Powered by Drew Hayes - 0.86

  2. The Wandering Inn by Pirateaba - 0.85

  3. Cradle by Will Wight - 0.80

  4. Super Supportive by Sleyca - 0.79

  5. Mother of Learning by Domagoj Kurmaic aka Nobody103 - 0.78

  6. Millennial Mage by JLMullins - 0.778

  7. Blood and Fur by Maxime J Durand aka Void Herald - 0.776

  8. Reborn as a Demonic Tree by XKARNARION - 0.71

  9. Worth the Candle by Alexander Wales - 0.668

  10. Chrysalis by RinoZ - 0.665

7. MOST POLARIZING BOOKS

These were the books with 5 or more ranks that were the most polarizing. There was the largest difference in number of times they were placed in the top quartile of the lists and the bottom quartile of lists.

  1. Speedrunning the Multiverse by adastra339 (40% top/40% bottom)

  2. Unbound by Nicoli Gonnella (35.7% top/35.7% bottom)

  3. Dungeon Crawler Carl by Matt Dinniman (58.8% top/23.5% bottom)

  4. He Who Fights with Monsters by Shirtaloon (37.5% top/29.1% bottom)

  5. The Perfect Run by Maxime J Durand aka Void Herald (53.8% top/23% bottom)

8. HIDDEN GEMS

I'm classifying hidden gems as books that only appeared in a single tier list but were placed in the highest tier. A good percentage of these books were pulled from a single tier list that included a lot of harem fics so just be wary of that if that's not really your thing.

  • Artorian Archives by Dennis Vanderkerken and Dakota Krout

  • Blue Core by InadvisablyCompelled #harem

  • Dinosaur Dungeon by Alex Raizman

  • Dream of Wings and Flame by Cale Plamann

  • Eve of Destruction by Benjamin Medrano #harem

  • Godclads by OstensibleMammal

  • Grey Mantle Chronicles by J David Baxter

  • Guardians of Asterfall by David North

  • Hero of the Valley by Gary Spechko

  • Saving Super Villains by Bruce Sentar #harem

  • Spell Heart by Marvin Whiteknight #harem

  • The Jester of the Apocalypse by Robert Blaise

  • World Keeper by Justin Miller

9. STATISTICAL RECOMMENDATIONS

I haven't done any stats since university but I remember just enough to run some simple tests with quite a bit of googling. Looking at books that were ranked 5 or more times, these books had a correlation between the ranks. If you enjoyed one of these you may enjoy the other. The sample size definitely wasn't large enough to make any definitive statements but I thought it was interesting.

  • All the Skills by HonourRae and Speedrunning the Multiverse by adastra339

  • Sylver Seeker by Kennit Kenway and Blessed Time by Cale Plamann aka Cocop

  • Blood and Fur by Maxime J Durand aka Void Herald and Jackal Among Snakes by Nemorosus

  • Defiance of the Fall by J F Brinks and Primal Hunter by Zogarth (is this one surprising at all?)

  • Everybody Loves large Chests by Exterminatus and Salvos by V A Lewis

  • Full Murder Hobo by Dakota Krout and Portal to Nova Roma by J R Mathews

  • Paranoid Mage by InadvisablyCompelled and Salvos by V A Lewis

  • Speedrunning the Multiverse by adastra339 and Threads of Fate by Michael Head

  • Sufficiently Advanced Magic by Andrew Rowe and The Divine Dungeon by Dakota Krout

10. STATISTICAL AVOIDANCES

In opposition to the statistical recommendations, these, books ranked 5 or more times, had a negative correlation between the scores, although the thresh hold was even lower because there were no strong negative correlations in the dataset. If you enjoyed one of these books, you're less likely to enjoy the other one.

  • Chrysalis by RinoZ and The Immortal Great Souls by Phil Tucker

  • Cradle by Will Wight and Mayor of Noodtown by Ryan Rimmel

  • Dungeon Crawler Carl by Matt Dinniman and Millennial Mage by JLMullins

  • Virtuous Sons by Y B Striker aka Ya Boy and Primal Hunter by Zogarth

11. CONCLUSION AND FINAL THOUGHTS

One interesting tidbit was that everyone who rated Cradle in bottom half of their lists had read a lot of novel translations, even though I didn't collect data on them to make any real statement.

After a lot of discussion on people upset that tier lists rehashing the same books over and over again, I wasn't expecting to have different 469 books and 282 only being ranked a single time. There were quite a few books that were definitely consistent on the tier lists but a vast majority of them I had no idea existed or had no discussion about them.

I would like to try to do another of these in the future, I already have a list of tier lists from the LitRPG subreddit, but entering the data on the spreadsheet took me 15 hours so it may be a while before that. I think it would be interesting to do some more statistical test on the books but I would need a much larger data set.

I have now become an expert of identifying books from poorly cropped, bad quality pictures.

If you're interested in the dataset you can find a link to the Google Sheets [HERE](https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1GCrITClb-CduFGpSTD4yVh3GCRXIsWNTH9mqzm5wfd8/edit?usp=sharing), scrubbed of analysis and PII (links to the tier lists). Remember that scores of 1 mean they were placed on in the top tier and 0 means they were placed in the bottom tier.


r/ProgressionFantasy • • Aug 10 '25

Meme/Shitpost What series is this?

Post image
2.1k Upvotes

r/ProgressionFantasy • • Sep 09 '25

Meme/Shitpost Uh oh!

Post image
2.1k Upvotes

r/ProgressionFantasy • • Feb 26 '26

Discussion I hate it when authors make this kind of reference... which then ages like milk

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

Elon Musk is one of those examples of a celebrity who was highly hyped in real life between 2010 and 2019 as the "Real-Life Iron Man." This guy was highly hyped on Reddit, Twitter, Facebook, YouTube, and had all sorts of paid cameos to insert himself into all kinds of media like the MCU/Simpsons/The Big Bang Theory/Star Trek as a "billionaire genius."

With a great PR team carefully controlling his image to maintain this hype, until Elon Musk finally exposed himself as a huge jerk in the children's cave incident, starting the erosion of his image to the total garbage it is today.

Making references to real-life celebrities in works of fiction is a huge risk, as their images are carefully constructed and maintained by a PR team, and we only see what they want us to see... until a slip-up reveals everything.

That's why authors should only reference dead people; there's almost zero chance of it going wrong... unless the name of the deceased celebrity or famous person is on something like the Epstein Files. Like Stephen Hawking.


r/ProgressionFantasy • • Apr 20 '21

Me when my Dad tells me how far he is in Mother of Learning, "I'm at the part where his little sister jumps on him and runs into the bathroom!"

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

r/ProgressionFantasy • • Oct 31 '25

Meme/Shitpost Why is it always dragons

Post image
1.9k Upvotes

r/ProgressionFantasy • • Feb 02 '26

Meme/Shitpost The Dreaded Question

Post image
1.9k Upvotes

r/ProgressionFantasy • • Feb 13 '26

Meme/Shitpost "Gun's Don't Work Anymore"

Post image
1.9k Upvotes

r/ProgressionFantasy • • Mar 01 '21

The Very Hungry Caterpillar is Progression Fantasy

1.9k Upvotes

If you're not familiar with the classic picture book, The Very Hungry Caterpillar by Eric Carle, it's a children's book designed to teach children the words for basic foodstuffs. And, it is a Progression Fantasy novel; here's why. Spoilers for The Very Hungry Caterpillar.

The very hungry caterpillar begins the book as an egg on a leaf. One Sunday, the caterpillar emerged from his egg as a very hungry and very "tiny" caterpillar. The caterpillar, wishing to sate his hunger and grow stronger, ate a hole through 1 apple on Monday. But it wasn't enough, so on Tuesday, the caterpillar ate a hole through 2 pears. The caterpillar effectively doubled his eating power!

On Wednesday, the caterpillar ate through 3 plums, which is a 50% increase. This implies the cultivation system of The Very Hungry Caterpillar has diminishing returns, but the caterpillar was still growing his personal eating power. On Thursday, the caterpillar ate a hole through 4 strawberries. And 5 oranges on Friday. On Saturday, the caterpillar ate through 10 different types of foods (1 one of each.) Saturday marked an incredibly increase in the caterpillar's power, compared to the measly 1 apple on Monday.

And indeed, the caterpillar was now a "big, fat" caterpillar. The caterpillar had reached the height of the caterpillar cultivation stage. To reach the next step, the caterpillar had to undergo a traditional ritual. The caterpillar ate no more food, and instead ate one green leaf. The caterpillar used this to build a cocoon around himself, which he stayed in for two weeks. And finally, the caterpillar broke through! Reaching the next cultivation stage, the caterpillar became a beautiful butterfly.

The very hungry caterpillar is a classic example of Progression Fantasy. The entire book revolves around the caterpillar training and cultivating his body to eat greater and greater levels of food. At the end of the book, the caterpillar breaks through to a literal new level of power. Although not explored in the book, the caterpillar turned butterfly likely gains powers of flight due to his advancement. If The Very Hungry Caterpillar isn't Progression Fantasy, then really, what is?

Why is this interesting and why did I make you read a dry description of The Very Hungry Caterpillar that is probably longer than the actual book? Mostly because it amuses me. But also, The Very Hungry Caterpillar has sold over 50 million copies since its 1929 publication. Which means not only is the book Progression Fantasy, but also, it is in all likelihood (by a considerable margin) the most popular book in the genre.


r/ProgressionFantasy • • Sep 07 '22

Meme/Shitpost Writing tip: "it is unreasonable to assume a character knows what genre they're in"

Post image
1.8k Upvotes

r/ProgressionFantasy • • Feb 21 '26

Meme/Shitpost Isekai protagonist

Post image
1.8k Upvotes

r/ProgressionFantasy • • Jan 05 '26

Meme/Shitpost Average "genius" protagonist

Post image
1.8k Upvotes

r/ProgressionFantasy • • May 05 '25

Meme/Shitpost PF: “We are not just a male power fantasy” Also PF:

Post image
1.8k Upvotes

I know the Reddit community is leagues better, but we can’t deny this continually happens. Especially in more mainstream PF like Solo Leveling/Greatest Estate Developer.

I get it. It’s a reflection of what’s in demand, but it just feels like being served fast food only.