r/PoliticalDebate • • 9h ago

Discussion All American state legislatures should be unicameral.

10 Upvotes

For the federal government, the Senate and the House represent two different things. The Senate represents each state on equal footing with the other states, regardless of population. The house by contrast represents the roughly equal populations of each congressional district.

Though many object to the Senate, the logic makes sense. However, 49 state legislatures also use a bicamerial legislature. However, unlike the United States Senate, which does represent a geographic region/political entity, state legislatures are legally obligated to allocate seats for both chambers of the legislature based on population. (See Reynolds v. Sims and similar supreme Court rulings).

Subsequently, I feel the upper house of a state legislature has become superfluous, and that state-level upper houses should be abolished in favor of more seats in state legislatures.


r/PoliticalDebate • • 11h ago

Discussion What will be the effects of the DSA's platform on the US economy?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/PoliticalDebate • • 13h ago

Debate $40 trillion in debt: Republican policy is bad for the economy and working people. Here are the sourced receipts

19 Upvotes

I keep seeing "both parties spend or the republicans are better on the economy" every time the debt comes up. So I went through the actual bills. Who wrote them, whether there was an emergency, and whether anyone paid for them.

My rule: emergency spending counts as emergency spending, no matter which party passed it. Take that out and see what's left.

What Republicans passed with no emergency and no way to pay for it

  • The Bush tax cuts (2001, 2003) plus Trump's 2017 tax cuts: about $10 trillion added to the debt through 2023. That includes the 2012 extension, more on that below.

  • Iraq and Afghanistan: trillions, almost all borrowed. No war tax. Korea and Vietnam both came with tax increases to help pay for them. These didn't.

  • Medicare Part D (2003): GOP Congress, Bush signed it, never paid for.

  • The 2025 "Big Beautiful Bill": CBO says $4.7 trillion more through 2035. CBO also says it raises interest rates enough that it costs more than the sticker price. It doesn't pay for itself.

None of these were forced by a crisis. Somebody chose them.

One stat from the Center for American Progress: if you take out the one-time costs of COVID and the 2008 recession, the Bush and Trump tax cuts are more than 90% of the rise in debt as a share of the economy since 2001.

The 2008 crash

The commission Congress set up to investigate the crash pointed to two big things: mortgage standards falling apart and Wall Street derivatives with no oversight.

Derivatives: in 2000 Phil Gramm (R-TX) stuck the Commodity Futures Modernization Act into a huge spending bill. It basically took derivatives out from under any regulator. The commission called it a key turning point on the way to the crisis. Clinton's Treasury backed it and Clinton signed it, so Democrats don't get a pass. But Republicans wrote it.

Mortgages: by 2004 more than 30 states had passed laws against predatory lending. Bush's bank regulators overrode them and exempted national banks. Researchers found that kicked off a race to the bottom in lending.

Then it all blew up. Tax revenue cratered, unemployment went through the roof, and the debt went with it.

What Democrats passed

  • Recovery Act (2009): about $830 billion. That was the response to the worst crash since the Depression.

  • Affordable Care Act (2010): CBO has always scored it as reducing the deficit.

  • American Rescue Plan (2021): $2.1 trillion. Pandemic.

  • Inflation Reduction Act (2022): CBO said it cuts the deficit by $238 billion.

So the big Democratic bills that added debt were emergency responses, and their two biggest non-emergency laws cut the deficit.

Trump's COVID money: where did it go?

COVID was a real emergency, I'm not knocking that. But look at where the business money ended up.

PPP was sold as saving paychecks. An MIT study (David Autor and others) found only 23 to 34 percent of it went to workers whose jobs were actually saved. The rest went to owners and shareholders. About three quarters of the benefit went to the top 20% of households.

Then Congress let businesses deduct the expenses PPP had already covered. That cost about $100 billion and some companies ended up with a negative tax rate.

The stimulus checks and the extra unemployment did the opposite. Most of that money reached the bottom 80%. The parts aimed at regular people helped regular people. The parts aimed at owners helped owners.

TARP

The bank bailout passed with votes from both parties and ended up costing about $33 billion net. The bailout wasn't what hurt the budget. The crash was.

"But Republicans are better for the economy"

The record says otherwise. Two Princeton economists, Alan Blinder and Mark Watson, looked at every president from Truman through Obama's first term:

  • GDP grew 4.3% a year under Democrats vs 2.5% under Republicans.

  • Unemployment fell 0.8 points on average under Democrats and rose 1.1 points under Republicans.

  • 10 of the 11 recessions between 1953 and 2020 started under Republican presidents.

To be fair, Blinder and Watson say a lot of that gap comes down to luck, like oil shocks and productivity swings, and presidents don't control the economy by themselves. I'm not claiming Democrats magically create growth. But if Republicans were really better for the economy, you'd expect it to show up somewhere in 70 years of data. It doesn't.

Where Democrats share the blame

I'm not going to pretend they're clean.

In 2012 Obama signed the deal that made 82% of the Bush tax cuts permanent. The Senate passed it 89 to 8.

How he got there matters though. In 2010 Republicans blocked legislation until the Bush tax cuts got extended, and Obama traded a two year extension for unemployment benefits. In 2011 they held the debt ceiling hostage and he signed automatic spending cuts to avoid a default. By the end of 2012 both of those deadlines landed at the same time, the "fiscal cliff," and CBO was projecting another recession if nothing passed. He kept the cuts for the middle class and got the top rate back up to 39.6% on income over $400K.

Add Clinton signing the derivatives law, and plenty of Democrats voting for the Iraq war. Republicans wrote the tax cuts and drove the deregulation. Democrats went along more than they should have.

Then there's interest

We're now paying over $1 trillion a year in interest. Only Social Security costs more. Every tax cut nobody paid for and every war on credit keeps costing us interest every single year.

Bottom line

Take out the emergencies and what's left is tax cuts tilted to the top, Part D, wars nobody paid for, and a crash that deregulation helped cause. We don't have a spending problem so much as a revenue problem with a war bill, a crash bill and an interest bill stacked on top.

So next time somebody says "both parties spend" or "Republicans are better for the economy," you've got the receipts that show otherwise.


Sources:


r/PoliticalDebate • • 15h ago

The cost of inaction. Pay more - get Less. Politics in the US

3 Upvotes

Regardless of if your support skews to the right or the left the red or the blue, our nations politics are costing you.

No matter who you voted for .20 Cents out of every dollar you pay in taxes goes just to paying interest. And its going to get worse much more quickly than it has in the past.

Everybody loves Pizza! Between Taxes and Inflation at its current trajectory we will soon no longer be able to afford Pizza!


r/PoliticalDebate • • 19h ago

Question Abortion

3 Upvotes

From what I've observed, for the most part there is a bipartisan agreement that abortion is an acceptable option in cases where the medical well-being of the mother is in question. So my question is three-parts.

  1. Do you believe in mental health issues?

  2. Why would the physical health of the mother be a valid reason for an abortion, but not the status of her mental health?

  3. Who would be more qualified to assess the mental health of the mother than the mother herself? In other words, if she's saying she's not mentally ready or fit, who is anybody to argue with that assessment of herself?


r/PoliticalDebate • • 1d ago

Question Why are Republicans still called the Party of big business, when Big businesses are run by Democrats?

0 Upvotes

GOP is still being called the party of big businesses, yet when you look at many of America's largest companies, you find that they are either run by registered Democrats, or donate millions, even billions into the Democratic Party. California is the best example for this. A giant cabal of corporate overlords, some facilitated by the Democrats themselves. Democrats have run Cali for generations, made one of the most anti competitive and hostile surroundings for small businesses, let Big tech implement some of the scummiest and most predatory schemes(such as online gambling in Video games, which democrats also defend), but somehow republicans are to blame for all of this?


r/PoliticalDebate • • 1d ago

Debate The assumption that political compromise is inherently virtuous ignores how often it produces worse outcomes than deadlock

7 Upvotes

Every major reform that actually stuck, from the New Deal to the Civil Rights Act, came from one side building enough power to override the other, not from both sides meeting in the middle. The middle ground on climate policy in 2010 was cap and trade. We got neither that nor anything else. The middle ground on healthcare in 1993 was the Republican alternative that became Romneycare. That failed too, and we got another 17 years of rising costs before a more partisan bill passed.

Compromise is treated as an end in itself in political discourse, as if the act of both parties signing somehow validates the result. But the historical record suggests that durable change tends to come through dominance, not splitting the difference. Splitting the difference on slavery produced the Missouri Compromise, the Compromise of 1850, and Kansas-Nebraska. Each temporarily stabilized things and each made the final conflict worse.

I am not claiming partisanship is always good or that cooperation never works. But the automatic assumption that gridlock is failure and compromise is success deserves more scrutiny than it gets. Sometimes deadlock preserves bad systems, but sometimes it prevents the entrenchment of halfway measures that foreclose better options later.


r/PoliticalDebate • • 1d ago

Why is it impossible to respect each other?

0 Upvotes

I am a conservative Christian woman (20) and I can not comprehend why everyone in today’s world has to be one of two sides or they are wrong. I don’t agree with liberal democratic values or views. I am very much pro gun, pro life, pro Christianity and pro America. Do I get why these views aren’t more widely accepted no. But I don’t hate anyone for not getting why I think that. Part of being pro America is not only wanting the best for our country but supporting the right to having different opinions. At the end of the day I fail to understand why if your opinion is not the same as the opposite side you deserve horrible things. We are all humans and regardless if you think someone else’s views support human rights or not you shouldn’t be hateful. You can disagree but also be able to agree no one deserves to be treated as less than because if values and views. I truly think the hate and intolerance in America is so sad and is damaging us more and more.


r/PoliticalDebate • • 1d ago

This is what fascism is - for all of those who throw the word around as if it means nothing

6 Upvotes

To define fascism is not just as easy as going through a list of actions that may be perceived as authoritarian or a breach of democratic values. People often throw the word around on all sides of the aisle without fully grasping what the ideology entails. For example, a common misconception that I hear often on platforms like these is that fascism can seemingly only be identified when it accurately mimics or reflects the actions of the most notable fascist regimes historically speaking. That being the NSDAP in Germany and the NFP in Italy. Other misconceptions also exist in political discourse regarding this topic. To help define and explain what fascism really is and how it can be represented in today's political environment, I have come up with three central questions that must be asked when arguing about whether a regime can be depicted as "fascist", or at least as representing fascist tendencies. The questions are as follows: 

Question One – What distinguishes fascism from ordinary nationalism, conservatism, authoritarianism and right-wing populism? 

Question Two – What ideological commitments, political behaviours, organisational characteristics, and historical processes can be used to identify a fascist movement? 

Question Three – How can these characteristics be used to identify possible fascist regimes or movements, and how can we do this without overreliance on superficial historical comparisons? 

 

Umberto Eco, Ur-Fascism (1995) *1 

Robert O. Paxton, The Five Stages of Fascism (1998) *2 

Robert O. Paxton, The Anatomy of Fascism (2004) *3 

Roger Griffin and Constantin Iordachi, Fascism (2018) *4 

These will be the four foundational texts I will refer to throughout this in-depth guide to fascism. The following questions are drawn from these pieces of literature, and the conclusions drawn from each will then aid in answering the three questions above.

*1 – What are the recurring patterns of thinking and behaviour that provide an indication towards fascist tendencies within a movement? 

*2 – How does fascism shift as it progresses through different political stages? 

*3 – How do fascist movements emerge, acquire power, and govern? 

*4 – What is it about fascism that distinguishes the ideology from other political movements? 

Let us answer these important questions one at a time to provide the necessary context and explanation for what I believe fascism to mean and to consist of.

*1 – What are the recurring patterns of thinking and behaviour that provide an indication towards fascist tendencies within a movement? 

This question is in relation to the argument put forward by Umberto Eco in his piece titled "Ur-Fascism", which specifically outlines 14 distinct characteristics of what defines a fascist movement and argues that since historical fascist regimes were not necessarily ideologically consistent and thus modern movements need not resemble historical ones, how, as observers, can we then identify fascism in practice when operating within a different political environment. This leads us nicely into what Eco describes as "ur-fascism" or "eternal fascism", which, instead of focusing on the recognition of fascism as exclusively historical symbols, institutions or an internally consistent ideological doctrine, identifies fascism as a recurring pattern of thought, emotion, culture and the relationship that exists with authority. Eco understands that, due to the existence of overlapping characteristics within fascist movements, there are also key differences concerning religion or cultural practice that distinguish fascist movements from each other and even expose how, internally, fascist movements such as that of the Italian Fascist Front contradict themselves. Essentially, the key takeaway here is that defining fascism as one consistent doctrinal body can inevitably obscure similarities of movements that are operating within different historical/political contexts and Eco's own term of what is known as "Family-Resemblance" makes the case that movements that seemingly appear different share the most important characteristics that enable them to be both categorised in the same way despite their external differences. So, when labelling modern political movements as fascist, one should take this into account.   

Ur-Fascism - The 14 characteristics of "Ur-fascism" can be read from pp. 11- 16 

We can now construct a response to the fundamental question that Umberto's work can now answer: Recurring patterns of thinking and behaviour in fascist movements typically organise around three relationships that hold Eco's 14 points together. That is the suppression of independent political judgement, the creation of an exclusive collective identity, and the concentration and legitimation of authority.  

I will also point out that Eco's list of traits attributed to fascism does not constitute a checklist with a numerical threshold. That would misrepresent what he is alluding towards.  

*2 – How does fascism shift as it progresses through different political stages? 

This question relates to the work of Robert Paxton, who outlines the 5 major transitions that occur within fascist movements. Paxton identifies 5 stages that fascist movements tend to progress through as they develop themselves. The five stages are as follows: The establishment/creation of a new political worldview that seeks to dismantle and contradict the existing world order from which those ideas have emerged; the next stage concerns the transformation of previously ideological radical ideas into the mainstream political environment and establishment before proceeding to the next stage involving the acquisition of power itself by establishing governance. Stage four is the exercising of power once gained, generating friction between established institutions and the fascist movement; this conflict is how political authority transforms.  The ultimate stage of fascism, however, is whether the movement pursues further radicalisation or its power decays, otherwise known as entropy. The question is whether the movement will intensify in its ambitions or lose momentum. These are the two long-term results of fascism that Paxton outlines. The overarching conclusion Paxton draws from his work is that fascism is a political phenomenon that should be assessed in relation to how it has developed and the existing political conditions/situation it has emerged from. 

Two important clarifications must be made, however. Firstly, Paxton does not claim in his work that these five stages are to be perceived as a checklist. Much like Umberto Eco's eternal fascism and the characteristics he outlines, Paxton makes clear that the stages he envisions should not be treated as events that happen smoothly, but rather as what we should look out for when distinguishing a potential movement that encompasses fascism. Secondly, seven recurring passions in fascist movements help mobilise and rally support for their ultimate cause.  

001_Paxton_Five Stages of Fascism - The seven "passions" Paxton outlines can be read from pg6-7  

We can now construct a response to the fundamental question Paxton's work can now answer: Fascism develops beginning as a fringe political movement that seeks to pursue national transformation, morphing into an established political organisation that then adapts to the practical realities it exists within so the movement can acquire, maintain and exercise its newfound political power. How the movement thrives may differ depending on the conditions it faces, how it manoeuvres at a political level and how the methodology of its actions may shift to accompany its desire for ever more centralisation of power under its own national ideology. The commitments to national unity, collective strength, purification and the opposition to framed "national decline" will persist as the core pillars of their governance despite adaptation, a quite astute reflection of its reactionary tendencies.  

*3 – How do fascist movements emerge, acquire power, and govern? 

This question relates to Paxton's argument again. However, in this piece he explains how fascism develops through interaction between nationalist movements, political and social crises, established political elites, and existing institutions within the state. Fascism is not a sudden burst of energy that takes over the system like a cancerous tumour. Instead, individuals within the movement seek to exploit the opportunities presented to them to harness even more power, in an attempt to reinforce the movement's development. Reliance on the choices made by existing state institutions also allows for further development and the mass mobilisation of the people to help radicalise the electorate and swing their favour towards the movement in its developmental phase. Competing pressures shape how fascist movements grow over time. This can prompt political infighting, which can lead to its demise, or propel radicalisation even further. The relationships that emerge among figures within the movement, and how the movement builds relationships with outside bureaucratic elites, define its trajectory. By looking at history, Paxton examines how crises such as the Great War produced the material conditions that bred anti-liberal and radical nationalist ideas, which were then formulated into organised political movements. Public dissatisfaction with the consequences of these crises alienated those who felt established ideological positions had failed them, leading to disillusionment with the establishment. Fascist movements presented themselves as the sound political alternative, opposing socialism and communism as well as liberal parliamentarianism and seeking to restore national unity. Through political activism and the tolerance of political violence, fascist movements grew into what they eventually will become. Paxton makes the point that fascism appeals to many social groups and classes within society, usually united in their hostility towards establishment politics and the acceptance of violence. Paxton, referring to examples such as the NSDAP during the Great Depression, explains how not all fascist movements gain influence during crises, since those that present themselves to be the true representatives of social grievances will be the movements that gain the most support. Political crises are fundamental to fascist success and, therefore, to their influence. This also contributes to the acquisition of power; however, contrary to what many would perceive, fascism does not rely solely on popular support to gain power; cooperation between the movement and the elite class is also vital in the acquisition phase. Fascist movements specifically require cooperation from conservative elites, as those among them perceive the fascist movement to characterise the solution in restoring political order and winning the fight against the threat of the left. The process of power acquisition once the established fascist regime is in charge will involve weakening political opposition, restricting civil liberties and expanding executive power and increasingly subordinating independent institutions to the regime. The governance of fascists operates within a "dual state" framework. This is often cited in reference to the Nazi regime and how Hitler operated. Two separate state entities exist in this format. The normative state includes the existing administration and bureaucracy, while the prerogative state is the political organisation exercising its authority and discretionary power, violating legal constraints. This friction results in an administration in which some established institutions remain, while political decisions increasingly erode the boundaries of established laws.  

We can now construct a response to the fundamental question Paxton's work can answer: fascist movements emerge from political and social crises that create disillusionment with established institutions and ideologies. They gain power through mass mobilisation, political violence, and cooperation with conservative elites who see them as a solution to instability. Once in government, fascists consolidate power by weakening opposition, restricting liberties, and subordinating institutions to the regime while increasingly exercising authority beyond legal constraints. 

Anatomy of Fascism

 *4 – What is it about fascism that distinguishes the ideology from other political movements? 

This question relates to the argument put forward by both Roger Griffin and Constantin Iordachi. The central argument is that a unique form of ultranationalism distinguishes fascism, centred on the belief that a nation experiencing profound decline must undergo national rebirth. The problem with defining such an ideology, and why it stands out against other ideological movements, is that, unlike other political ideologies such as liberalism, fascism did not emerge from an established philosophical tradition that establishes a clear and coherent set of founding texts that define such tradition; thus, fascism has always been a volatile subject when discussed in modern-day politics. Instead, the argument put forward in this piece is that fascism developed through a web of political and intellectual external influences, ranging from radical nationalism and revolutionary syndicalism to anti-liberalism and a reactionary approach to the political and social crises that plunged the world into chaos during the 20th century. They also point out that the fascist movement manifested differently in different countries, depending on how it adapted to their political and social surroundings. The core concept, of course, is what is known as the "fascist minimum". Here, the authors challenge the previously accepted view that fascism is an outgrowth of the capitalist system and an expression of reactionary class interest, united in what it opposed. However, the fascist minimum presents a different answer, which is that fascists should be treated as ideological characters who are motivated by their own political ambition and belief system.  Griffin and Lordachi identify what fascists want to create: a belief that the nation, understood as an organic collective community, must be regenerated after a period of perceived decline and existential danger. Internally or externally. This links to Griffin's concept of palingenetic ultranationalism, defined as a rebirth myth and a sense of a unified, pure collective national society.  Ultranationalism prioritises the nation as an overriding political community whose collective destiny takes precedence over competing interests. The authors go on to explain the mythic core in fascism, which refers to an emotionally compelling narrative that fuels the movement and provides its conception of history, collective identity and purpose in relation to politics.  Five major components overall define fascism's ideological core. 

Roger_Griffin_Constantin_Iordachi_Fascis (1).pdf - read on pg. 556 for the five major components of the ideological core of fascism 

The key distinction between fascism and other right-wing movements lies in its ideological core: the idea of national rebirth, more specifically the concept of palingenetic ultranationalism. Fascists, unlike those who seek to restore order, want to implement a new kind of national community. Therefore, a potential contradiction arises. Whilst Fascism can glorify an idealised national past, it can also seek revolutionary change. Furthermore, fascism typically involves the identification of enemies on the grounds of differing political views, ethnicity or other demographics that the movement may perceive as a threat to its own national rebirth. As seen in historical examples, violence and oppression often go hand in hand with fascist ideals as the ideological core drives its followers to extreme lengths.  

A key clarification, however, is needed. Both Griffin and Iordachi acknowledge the limits of the fascist minimum and express that analysis must be supplemented by historical case studies, comparative research, investigation of social constituencies, and examination of political development. 

We can now construct a response to the fundamental question Paxton's work can now answer: Fascism is distinct from other right-wing political movements, specifically in its unique form of palingenetic ultranationalism, centred on the belief that a nation experiencing decline, humiliation, or crisis is obligated to pursue a process of national collective rebirth. The ideological core conceives the nation as an organic community whose regeneration must be fulfilled through political activism and the establishment of a new political order characterised by collective unity, renewed vitality, and the perceived idea of national greatness. 

Now, after answering these fundamental questions and analysing these 4 foundational works, we can answer the three central questions proposed at the start of this post. 

Question One – What Distinguishes fascism from ordinary nationalism, conservatism, authoritarianism and right-wing populism?

As detailed in work by Griffin and Lordachi, including the fascist minimum, the core distinction is ideological. Fascist movements have a distinct belief in palingenetic ultranationalism, which should be achieved through fundamental change, typically resorting to political violence and the purging of perceived enemies of the state, such as individuals who share different political beliefs, or, if categorised based on demographics, there is an abundance of discrimination based on demographic characteristics.  Nationalism can coexist and operate within a constitutional or liberal democracy whilst holding popular sovereignty and pluralism. The separating feature is that fascism is a unique project organised around an idealised national rebirth. Conservative ideology stems from the conservation of the old and rejection of what is new. Whilst fascism plays into this nostalgic feeling for a nation's past glory and idealises that past, it is an effort to seek a new historical era. Authoritarian governments often seek to preserve established social arrangements and maintain a politically passive population; however, fascists like to actively mobilise and rile up the electorate in an effort to bring about national rehabilitation and revival after perceived decline. Fascists seek to penetrate and reorganise social life, whilst authoritarian regimes are more likely to leave societal practices under the authority of state institutions such as the church or economic associations.  

When comparing fascism to right-wing populism, we can introduce Umberto Eco's work. One of Eco's 14 points is what is known as selective populism, which conceives of the people as a unified political entity whose authentic leader somehow personally embodies their interests as a whole; this differs from democratic pluralism, where citizens have their own preferences and political disagreement exists and is tolerated. This is not to say populist movements cannot be fascist, but to be characterised as such, a right-wing populist movement would have to aspire to the ideological ideals of fascism and demonstrate that through its development.  

Question Two – What ideological commitments, political behaviours, organisational characteristics, and historical processes can be used to identify a fascist movement? 

Ideological Characteristic Explanation 
National rebirth  The belief that the nation must overcome its decline through regeneration at a fundamental level 
Organic nationalism The nation is organised as a unified collective community whose destiny is greater than individual interest 
National victimhood The nation is understood to have suffered through humiliation or victimisation at the hands of external or internal malicious forces 
National unity and purification Political divisions and enemies of the movement are only obstacles to the ultimate goal 
Rejection of liberal pluralism Individual rights and liberties, independent judgement and political discourse must be subordinated to collective national goals 
Transformative political ambition The fascist movement seeks to fundamentally change the existing order and establish a new political and social order that reflects its own vision of greatness.  

 

Political Behaviour Explanation 
Delegitimisation of opposition Opponents to the movement/regime are seen as enemies of the state rather than simple political competitors.  
Acceptance of political violence Political violence or coercion is typically justified as necessary in the pursuit of destroying any perceived enemies 
Subordination of democratic liberties Law, the constitution, and the rights of the people are treated as obstacles to overcome, which the national objective overrides.  
Conspiratorial political explanations Conspiracy theories are used to blame economic and social woes on perceived enemies of the fascist movement 
Leader-centred political authority Authority circulates a leader that presents and embodies the national community's destiny 
Mobilisation through political conflict Confrontation becomes a means of reinforcing collective identity and commitment to the greater cause 

 

Organisational characteristic Explanation 
Mass political mobilisation The fascist movement seeks active participation and public enthusiasm as opposed to passive public obedience in a way of demonstrating loyalty to the regime 
Charismatic leader/vanguard A leader or committed vanguard who manipulates the electorate into their ideas so they can fulfil their goals of national rebirth 
Militant movement organisations Activists committed to the cause may establish institutions in which the political authority of the fascist leader(s) is then exercised on a broad scale 
Collaboration with established elites The movement develops relationships with conservative elites or other powerful institutions to propel its own political momentum 
The "dual state" Once in government, fascist movement organisations compete with established institutions of state authority 
Expansion of political control over society Political organisations may penetrate social institutions to enhance political authority over the population and to control people's private lives 

 In relation to historical processes, we can look at what has already been discussed - 001_Paxton_Five Stages of Fascism

Question Three – How can these characteristics be used to identify possible fascist regimes or movements, and how can we do this without overreliance on superficial historical comparisons? 

To apply which characteristics can be used to identify possible fascist regimes or movements, the theoretical aspects of what defines fascism proposed by Eco, Paxton, Griffin, and Lordachi can be examined to determine whether the ideology, behaviour, organisation and historical development correspond to the defining features of fascism established in their respective works. To accurately identify such a movement, an all-encompassing definition of fascism must be formulated as a reference point for what the term means when describing a movement or a regime as fascist. A clear definition, accounting for all that has been researched throughout the analysis of what defines fascism overall, is the following: 

"Fascism is a revolutionary form of ultranationalist politics organised around the belief that a nation experiencing profound decline or humiliation must undergo collective regeneration. It seeks to mobilise the national community around an ideal of unity, strength and renewal, while challenging liberal pluralism and subordinating competing political interests to the perceived destiny of the nation. Historically, fascist movements have pursued these objectives through mass mobilisation, militant political organisation, charismatic leadership, cooperation with established elites and, where they have acquired power, attempts to transform state authority and national society. Their political programmes, alliances and governing practices can change considerably during this development."  

This definition synthesises everything covered throughout this post.  

Furthermore, to establish the fascist minimum, the movements' or regimes' ideological core must reflect the fundamental thinking behind fascism, as well as examining the political conduct independent of political rhetoric. Investigating action as well as rhetoric and treating both as separate categories allows for examination of the suspected fascist regime when it deals with political opposition, crises or competing centres of authority – in other words, how the movement/regime adapts to the political environment it is surrounded by. By using the five stages of fascism as outlined by Robert Paxton, analysing the historical development of the movement is vital in determining if it should be considered fascist or not, thus enabling the term to be used without relying on independent outliers who happen to demonstrate extremist views and behaviour whilst not fully representing the movement itself.  

If historical comparisons are to be identified, these comparisons must not deviate from the core distinctive characteristics of fascism. Symbols, rhetoric, or political aesthetics do not establish fascism; rather, political behaviour and action do, or similarities in each movement's historical development.

Thank you for your time and attention to this post.


r/PoliticalDebate • • 1d ago

Question I want to become more politically informed. Where do I start?

10 Upvotes

I've always been interested in politics, and I genuinely want to develop a deeper understanding of how the political world works. I want to be someone who can engage in meaningful political discussions, understand different ideologies and keep up with what's happening around the world.

My biggest problem is knowing where to get reliable information and where to start.

Between work, school and other responsibilities, I don't have much time to spend searching for resources. So I'm looking for recommendations.

What books should I read? Which podcasts, YouTube channels, journalists or news platforms should I follow? Are there any Reddit communities you'd recommend?

I'm particularly interested in international relations, African politics, political philosophy and global affairs.

I'd appreciate any advice, especially from people who have been interested in politics for years. What resources have helped you become more knowledgeable?


r/PoliticalDebate • • 1d ago

Discussion Did anyone read The Mediocracy by Alain Deneault?

5 Upvotes

The book really shocked me, it revealed a very unapologetic view of socio economic, and political reality of neoliberal society.

It was quite painful since it discussed how academia has been like, and I am planning to work in it (Political Science Major).


r/PoliticalDebate • • 1d ago

Discussion Why do liberals not talk about currency erosion?

0 Upvotes

I just never hear liberals talk about it. Do liberals understand what currency erosion is? The devaluing of the currency? Any attempt to control inflation should probably involve doing something about currency erosion.

Why not align the value of the currency with something finite like a precious metal? Right now the price of silver is 48.63 per ounce and is usually stable. Currency erosion is a subject that should not be a left v right issue. Doing something about It can improve the cost of living.


r/PoliticalDebate • • 1d ago

Discussion I’m trying to build a rough scoring framework for rating countries based on Maslow’s hierarchy of needs.

3 Upvotes

Lots of composite indexes already exist to measure national development, like the Human Development Index (HDI), the Measure of Domestic Progress (MDP), and the World Happiness Report. But none of them sit right with me. I think we need a better scoring model for evaluating governments and states themselves. I’m a big supporter of Maslow’s theory, and I believe meeting the tiers of Maslow’s needs works better for judging a regime than vague abstract ideas. That’s why I’ve put this index together.

It’s only a first draft, so plenty still needs tweaking. I’d welcome discussion and criticism from everyone.

  1. Tier1: whether the government secures its people’s basic human needs including food, clothing and basic public order. Weighting: 30%.

    • food supply: 10%

    • housing security: 6%

    • fuel or cooling access: 4%

    • public safety: 10%

  2. Tier2: whether the government delivers basic healthcare, basic education and access to public goods. Weighting: 25%.

    • infrastructure: 10%

    • healthcare cover: 7.5%

    • basic education: 5%

    • core government functions: 2.5%

  3. Tier3: whether the government supports steady employment, higher education, sustainable industrial growth and economic security. Weighting: 20%.

    • employment: 7%

    • higher education and research: 5%

    • economic and financial stability: 5%

    • political stability and government credibility: 3%

  4. Tier4: whether the government upholds fairness, welfare, labour rights and safety-net support to protect people’s dignity. Weighting: 15%.

    • workers’ rights: 6%

    • social security: 4%

    • judicial fairness: 3%

    • trust in security forces and the sense of safety they provide: 2%

  5. Tier5: whether the government safeguards people’s freedoms, expression, electoral rights and full political rights. Weighting: 10%.

    • protection from political persecution: 4%

    • freedom of speech: 3%

    • democratic rights: 3%

This lines up broadly with the five tiers of Maslow’s hierarchy of needs.

All feedback and corrections are welcome. You can point out any flaws in the sub-items of this index, though I’m keeping the rule that the weighting falls from tier one to tier five. You can also critique my underlying ideology itself.


r/PoliticalDebate • • 2d ago

Politics is Downstream from Culture

0 Upvotes

Legislation and even SCOTUS decisions tend to be lagging indicators of social attitudes. There is a whole book on this topic as related to the Civil Rights era, ripe with data, called the Hollow Hope. It shows that SCOTUS decisions followed public opinion in the south, and when it got too far out in front of public opinion, they were simply ignored (Brown v. Board wasn't implemented, and Brown v. Board II was essentially a finger wag "we really mean it").

Some other areas. Gay rights in the united states reached a tipping point in public opinion polls before SCOTUS ruled it was legal. And historically, you have the 2nd Great Awakening, a democratization of religious/social institutions, a couple decades before Jacksonian era democracy that oversaw the virtual elimination of property right requirements for voting.

What does this mean? Government often places its stamp of approval in the form of laws/rulings on matters that have already been settled in the public arena Far from politicians being 'leaders' they simply give their assent to matters that have already been settled socially. Given this reality, we should be placing far more focus on our culture and even 'pop-culture' than political offices and laws (which are again just a lagging indicator of the former).


r/PoliticalDebate • • 2d ago

Discussion Most online political discourse treats policy complexity as a conspiracy against plain common sense

2 Upvotes

Every time a debate touches on healthcare, immigration, or trade, the same pattern appears. Someone cites a 2000 page bill and gets met with: this is intentionally obscure to hide the real agenda. The counter never addresses whether complex systems might genuinely require complex implementation.

This framing is pervasive across left and right. Climate policy gets dismissed as technocratic overreach. Tax code critiques assume malice in every loophole. Immigration systems are read as deliberate chaos rather than accumulated compromises.

The assumption that simplicity equals honesty and complexity equals deception has become its own barrier to good faith engagement. It lets participants avoid engaging with mechanisms while posturing as the only ones seeing clearly.

Anyone else noticed this becoming the default rhetorical move? Not asking for examples of complex bad policy, but whether the complexity itself is treated as automatic evidence of bad faith.


r/PoliticalDebate • • 2d ago

Political Theory An unpopular opinion on a radically restructured society: Meritocratic classes, equalized wages, epistocracy, and shared luxury.

0 Upvotes

An unpopular opinion on a radically restructured society: Meritocratic classes, equalized wages, epistocracy, and shared luxury.

"I believe that social classes should exist — specifically divided into academic citizens and non-academic citizens. However, wages should be equal or very close for everyone: doctors, lawyers, entrepreneurs, plumbers, farmers, footballers, singers, actors, influencers, etc.

Companies and corporations should be managed by educated groups of people, who would earn the same or approximately the same as the physical workers.

Elections would be democratic, but everyone who votes must pass certain IQ tests in order to be eligible. Instead of a single president, a council of multiple chairpersons would be elected; they could serve an unlimited number of terms, but each term lasts for only one year. All chairpersons of the country earn equal wages.

As for luxury cars, penthouses, and yachts — they should not be privately owned for hoarding wealth, but rather reserved for renting. Anyone can rent them."


r/PoliticalDebate • • 2d ago

Debate The idea that “culture is downstream of race” is nonsense, change my mind

2 Upvotes

Before anyone jumps in, let me say what I mean, because this topic goes off the rails when people talk past each other.

By culture I mean learned, socially transmitted stuff: language, religion, norms, family structure, how much people trust strangers or institutions. By race I mean the broad ancestry-based groupings people use in everyday life. By "downstream of race" I mean race is the cause, so inherited biology produces the cultural differences we see between groups. That's different from saying ancestry and culture are correlated, which of course they are, since families hand down what they know and tend to live in the same places.

So I'm not claiming culture is flimsy or that history doesn't matter. My claim is that race isn't what's driving it. Here's my case.

Adoption is the cleanest test we have. A Korean kid adopted into a family in Minnesota or Sweden grows up speaking the local language natively, with the local religion (or lack of one), the local humor, the local norms. Same ancestry, completely different culture. If race were upstream of culture, this is where you'd expect it to show up, and it basically doesn't.

Culture also changes way faster than anything genetic could. Ireland went from a church-dominated, high-fertility country to legalizing same-sex marriage in 2015 and abortion in 2018 by popular vote. Japan went from feudal to industrial power within a few decades after Meiji. Nobody's gene pool shifted in that time.

Then there are natural experiments. North and South Korea are one population, split for 75 years, and the gap in values and outcomes is enormous. East and West Germans had measurably different attitudes toward the state after 40 years apart, and those started converging after reunification. People of Chinese ancestry in Singapore, Taiwan, Hong Kong and the mainland live in very different cultural and institutional worlds. Mainland China itself was poor and badly governed for most of the last 150 years, which is awkward if Chinese ancestry is supposed to carry some built-in cultural advantage.

The categories themselves are shaky too. A century ago Irish and Italian immigrants in the US were treated as racially inferior groups, and today nobody thinks that. Brazil, the US and South Africa all draw racial lines in different places. Most human genetic variation sits within populations rather than between them, so the traits we use to define race are a small and unrepresentative slice of the genome. A causal variable should be sturdier than that.

On immigrants, there's an NBER paper by Giavazzi, Petkov and Schiantarelli that tracks attitudes across four generations of European immigrants to the US. Once you look past the second generation, attitudes persist less than earlier work suggested, and how fast they converge varies by trait and by country of origin. That pattern fits social transmission. I don't see how a single racial mechanism would produce it.

I'll give the other side its best card. Garett Jones, in The Culture Transplant, cites data showing differences in trust persisting even to the fourth generation, and that's real evidence for persistence. But it's persistence of origin-country culture, and the same ancestry can end up in very different places depending on where people land. Italian immigrants to the US moved into the middle class. Italian immigrants to Argentina did comparatively poorly. That looks like an environment effect to me.

Finally, parsimony. Institutions, geography, contact between groups, incentives and plain historical accident already explain a huge amount. If you think race explains some leftover chunk, show me a case where ancestry predicts cultural traits after controlling for those things.

What would change my mind: evidence that ancestry-linked cultural traits survive controls for institutions and history, groups that diverge from host cultures in the same direction across very different environments, or an actual mechanism running from genotype to cultural practice instead of a correlation between group labels and outcomes.


r/PoliticalDebate • • 3d ago

Discussion The reason Conservatives tend to be hostile toward social minorities is by no means because they are “Racists” or “Discriminators” (though some certainly are)

0 Upvotes

Conservatives view their own society as the norm and feel anxious about people who might significantly challenge that norm. That is why I believe they tend to be hostile toward social minorities.

However, as conservative tendencies become more pronounced, there is a tendency to unjustly exclude or discriminate against social minorities. I believe that constitutes racism and discrimination.


r/PoliticalDebate • • 3d ago

Debate As a European , would you like a swiss type of direct democracy system for the EU ?

Thumbnail reddit.com
6 Upvotes

r/PoliticalDebate • • 3d ago

Question If a society can produce abundance without requiring most people to labor, does that abundance still belong to those who happen to own the means of production?

5 Upvotes

Automation has been reshaping work for decades, and AI seems poised to accelerate this. Productivity keeps rising while labor force participation in certain sectors falls. This raises a structural question about economic systems: when the link between work contribution and total output weakens, what justifies the existing distribution of that output?

I see two broad responses in political discourse. One treats this as a problem of retraining and transition: people will find new roles, markets will adapt, ownership structures need not change. The other treats it as a systemic threshold: past a certain point of automation, market mechanisms based on labor contribution lose their moral and practical coherence.

What I am trying to understand: is there a coherent framework for thinking about economic rights or entitlements that does not depend on labor contribution, yet still respects individual autonomy and avoids the pitfalls of centralized planning? Universal basic income is often proposed, but the debates I see rarely engage with how ownership of automated systems would work, how prices would function, or what political accountability would look like in such a system.

I am interested in whether there are developed theoretical responses to this, or whether most political frameworks assume labor will remain central enough that this question can be deferred.


r/PoliticalDebate • • 3d ago

Discussion Perversion of the 2nd Ammendment

0 Upvotes

As a reminder ~ "A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed."

It makes me viscerally upset how smug some people sound as they say "if you want guns so bad for protection, why not just join the militia."

Who in their right mind thinks that if the government goes tyrannical, the State National Guard would be any different? Its the same political parties pulling the strings.

Not to mention, for my everyday personal safety, I cant count on the police coming in time to protect my family - and Im supposed to trust the Army?

Matter of fact, Im in the Army - its not like I can walk in the armory and grab a weapon to go defend my community or family anytime. Im beholden to State laws that make as difficult as possible to carry for self defense. And those politicians say "only the military should have ___ type guns". Its neverending.


r/PoliticalDebate • • 3d ago

China is an example of how market liberalization lifts people out of poverty

0 Upvotes

In Mao's China, nearly 90% of people lived in what the World Bank would classify as "extreme poverty." In addition to human rights abuses on par with Hitler and Stalin, China was deeply poor. In the late 1970s, market liberalization began. Within some limited context, businesses were allowed to operate and property rights replaced communal farms. By 1990, extreme poverty was cut by more than 50%. The point of decline coincides perfectly with market liberalization, and the decline in poverty is exactly what we would expect moving away from a command economy. This trend continues today.

So is the answer China-style lite-command economies with constrained markets? Probably not. The GDP per capita in the US is 85k. In China is around 14k. China's massive population is the source of it's total GDP. It's higher GDP growth rates are a product of diminishing marginal return (your 1st point of growth is easier to get than you 1,000th). Given economies of scale, China should be the wealthiest nation in the world. However, its economy is strangled by its government. The liberalizations helped to reduce the absolute level of devastation brought by Mao and his command economy, but the lack of continued market liberalization has trapped it in the 2nd world.


r/PoliticalDebate • • 3d ago

Question Why do political coalitions that champion local control consistently support federal preemption when it serves their policy goals?

2 Upvotes

Looking at recent legislative patterns across several states, there is a recurring tension in how parties invoke principles of governance. The same factions that frame education, zoning, or public health as matters best decided by communities or individuals frequently support federal constraints on state experimentation when the policy area shifts. This is not unique to one side; the pattern inverts depending on whether the issue is labor law, environmental permitting, or firearms regulation.

I am trying to understand whether this is understood as a pragmatic exception to a genuine principle, or if the principle itself is primarily instrumental. Do proponents see these as distinct categories where local control does not apply, or is the rhetoric of decentralization mainly useful for opposing policies one dislikes rather than a coherent theory of government?

What frameworks help make sense of when decentralization is treated as overriding versus disposable? I am less interested in identifying hypocrisy than in understanding how practitioners reconcile or navigate these moves.


r/PoliticalDebate • • 3d ago

A picture is worth 1,000 words: How to fix a broken system that rewards the next election over the future of our country.

9 Upvotes

Its so very easy to become distraught over the state of our country - no matter which side of the political spectrum you support - there is always someone to blame. And thats by design. Our current political system allows politicians to stay in power while our country continues to decline. Congress has an average reelection rate in the 80-95% range, despite an approval rating that runs between 15-25%.
America recently celebrated its 250th birthday and if we want to continue - change is needed. Change can be a scary word - if it was easy everyone would do it. But when you take a step back and see the alternative - it becomes an easier choice.

Our country and indeed many businesses have faced similar choices of change and become stronger and better as a result.
Likely if you support one side of the political spectrum over another - you may be saying. If only my party could stay in power - or have control over the executive and both sides of the legislative - then we would see change. The challenge in that is it has been done - multiple times. And as easy would be to blame the politicians - the system incentivizes a focus on the next election over the future of our country.

To be fair - who wouldnt want to leave office? The Median personal income for a US Citizen is $47,000 - while the salary alone of a politician is $174,000 - and includes a federal pension (on average 40-60,000 a year in retirement) and access to some of the best health coverage available. Change is hard and most countries fail from stagnation. When the personal benefits of being in office outweigh driving change - change is likely to take a back seat, it is human nature.
Fortunately, our founding fathers foresaw something like this happening one day and gave us the ability to drive the needed change for the future of our country.

Which idea is ultimately selected matters less than the action that we the people - and yes the few politicians who have it within themselves to advocate for whats best for the nation over the current stagnent system that allows them to stay in power for decades.

In the words of JFK "Ask not what your country can do for you - but what you can do for your country".

The goal is to put accountability into our government in a way that prepares us for a better future without unduly burdening any part of our nation.

A patient comes in to see his doctor after living a very rough and unhealthy lifestyle. The doctor says "you have two choices, you can keep living the way you have and will die within the next few years - or you can make lifestyle changes and live a long and prosperous life. The choice is up to you."
We are one of the youngest nations in the world. We have the ability to change the direction of our country - one of the few that can honestly say that. That requires dialog, that requires action. There are countless examples in our history of doing this and emerging stronger as a result. It starts with you.

If you agree with the general premise (not every detail, just the idea) - share this on social media. Communicate and discuss this as it is your tomorrow.

If you disagree with the general premise (not every detail, just the idea) - lets discuss. Its part of what makes this nation what it is.


r/PoliticalDebate • • 3d ago

How does the politics of Earth translate into space exploration?

2 Upvotes

What would be the difference in approaches when it comes to the identification of extraterrestrial intelligent life, resources not native to Earth or other discoveries that would become points of contention if treated as a political issue (most likely would become a question of politics)

Would we see a "space race" become the next phase in human history? Modern colonisation? Interplanetary warfare?

I concede, I am thinking, most likely, centuries into the future of our civilisation; however, I am interested to see how others would go about answering these questions and what their general approach would be. If even having one at all.

I also presume that many would argue that this is not a priority and rather a distraction from the issues that we already currently face; however, I think there is definitely room to debate here, especially on something that is more theoretical and what I believe to give an opportunity for a more exciting discussion to take place. Considering most political discourse is strictly focused on the issues that affect us tomorrow or next week rather than years upon years into the future of humanity.