r/PoliticalDebate • • Apr 12 '24

Debate POTUS forgiving the debts of young voters is the same as purchasing votes and should not be legal

0 Upvotes

There’s no procedural oversight, Biden is making these proclamations unilaterally, and the results most definitely benefit him personally and directly.


r/PoliticalDebate • • Dec 17 '23

Debate Israel is an Apartheid State

13 Upvotes

Israel is an apartheid state. Their goal is to set populations apart. Israel proponents who argue otherwise state that Israel has 2 million Palestinian citizens; these were called a "demographic threat" by Netanyahu in 2002, before it was considered politically incorrect; there were laws against interracial marriage, and in 2018 a symbolic law declaring that only Jews have the right of self determination in Israel was passed. As of today it's nearly impossible for Palestinians to migrate to Israel and become legal citizens.

Beyond this argument, Israel has roughly 4 million non-citizens under the control of their field military. Some populations in the West Bank have been ruled by the military police for almost 70 years. Furthermore, Israel continues to abuse the UN's lack of enforcement to surround them with settlements in what looks like a clear goal of ethnic replacement.

One could argue that those are just foreign nationals and talk about a "two state solution"; that was also the strategy in South African apartheid, to create fragmented states, displace the natives there, and call them foreign nationals. And just like in South Africa, Israel stops a single entity from controlling both the West Bank and Gaza and even goes as far as to do assassinations or fund Hamas to do so, in order to keep the natives fragmented. Furthermore, recently Netanyahu has stated that he's the candidate that will stop the consolidation of a Palestinian state, considering Israelis don't want them to have vote rights in the actual governing structure, it means the goal here is precisely Bantustan.

Israel has no intent of giving the people of Gaza equal rights and citizenship, they seek to conquer it to establish a military rule. This is at odds with almost every claim of land on the planet, for instance, If Venezuela were to take part of Guyana, they'd have to grant citizenship to the people living there and treat them as equal citizens, Israel conquers and surrounds people to do the opposite.

Hezbollah and Iran's position is that Israeli apartheid does not have the right to exist, and that Palestine should be ruled by both Palestinian muslims AND jews; in the UN, the Israeli ambassador to advocate for Israel stated that "the Palestinians do not want a Jewish state", as in, Israel's official position is that they require a state of ethno supremacy, a "jewish state". This is further supported by their propaganda efforts such as "the jewish state has the right to exist", as well as the position of their religious fanatical Zionist movements.

There's no doubt in my mind that Israel, and more specifically Zionism, is by definition a violent apartheid movement.


r/PoliticalDebate • • Mar 19 '24

Discussion Voting for Biden is (one of) the best things you can do for the Palestinians

0 Upvotes

Obviously we know what's going on in regards to Palestine, however I don't think it's unfair to point out that Biden can't do anything consequential towards Israel without risk of losing the election due to the commonly held opinion in the US that Israel is in the right to defend itself and deserves to exist the way it does. And if he does lose the election, Trump will undoubtably do far more to worsen the conflict.

From everything that has come out, I think it's likely that Biden recognizes the situation is untenable and wants Netanyahu to stand down, and is even willing to call for a ceasefire and provide humanitarian aid logistics. With that in mind, I think it's possible that once Biden is allowed another four years, without the concern of needing to be re-elected, he will able to exert far more pressure with less political consequence.

While I do think this is the case, I think that it is imperative that we continue to pressure our politicians as well as his administration to end this genocide. (EDIT: As well as spreading the word of Israel’s actions and debating effectively against its supporters to turn the tide of public opinion).

But as far as taking actions that allow Trump in office, that should be completely off the table.

Thoughts?


r/PoliticalDebate • • Jun 18 '25

Debate Israel-Iran, surely we’re not this cooked.

0 Upvotes

Hamas, in reaction to the Israeli occupation, attacked Israel on Oct. 7th. Israel used this as a justification to start committing genocide on the Palestinian people. Since then, Israel has gone rogue and expended their attacks to the West Bank, then Lebanon, and now at war with Iran; all of whom Israel has been the aggressor.

What I find incredibly astonishing, is that many are claiming Iran is the aggressor in this, despite Israel, who is in the midst of committing genocide and is engaging in a multi-front war, attacking them first on a baseless claim that Iran is building a nuclear weapon (there’s no evidence of this).

Trump’s “negotiations” were obviously flawed as well. He purposely proposed a deal to Iran that he knew Iran couldn’t accept. For those who don’t know, Trump’s deal was for Iran to give up all enrichment of uranium, even for power for their power grid and scientific research (which they have a right to do under international law). Trump knew Iran wouldn’t accept this, which in turn he could use to say “see, the Iranian’s are unwilling to negotiate” which then led to Israel using that as a justification to offensively attack Iran.

Surely, there’s no way we as a people are about to fall for the same baseless lies and playbook that got us into Iraq and Afghanistan, right? And if so, I’d like to hear the pro-Iran war position and what good are you thinking will come out of this.


r/PoliticalDebate • • Sep 22 '25

Debate The rights response to Kirks unfortunate assassination is proof of white authoritarian nationalism

0 Upvotes

I want everyone to recognize not just recent times, but this entire decade: all the way back to the race for the 2016 election. Recognize how much political violence happened since then. Anti LGBTQ rhetoric going into hyperdrive with the legalization of gay marriage in 2016, then the substantial hate crimes LGBTQ people had to face because of that. The countless amount of black people murdered in droves by police brutality which led to BLM and of course the Floyd protests. The Jan 6 insurrectionists who eventually got pardoned even though they chanted "hang mike pence", assaulted police officers and led to the death of a politician. The murder of trans people and LGBTQ allies including Nex Benidict and Laura Ann Carleton. Of course, the brutal murder of the Hortmans in their own home and the glorification of Alligator Alcatraz, which had to be shut down because it's literally a concentration camp.

And of course, most brutally of all, the genocide in the middle east that isn't justified no matter what HAMAS has done.

In every one of these instances, the Right fuels and jokes about it, or turns a blind eye, hell some of them celebrates it with open arms.

Yet, after a decade of minorities facing brutal torture and fighting tooth and nail since Trump first went into office, the right starts showing passion when ONE, just ONE of their people gets assassinated.

Conservatives of this sub, is this a joke? How disgusting can you be to openly not give a fuck about brutal violence for decades, only to blow up when ONE of your people gets shot? Do you realize that all this does is proves the fact that you only care about a specific demographic with a certain religion and lighter skin? Where has this passion been for all these years, and how do you sleep at night KNOWING full well that you never gave a shit about political violence until now?

This specifically reminds me of the celestial dragons from one piece. They can do whatever the fuck they want to minorities, yet when one person so much as touches them, the government sends an entire army and it makes national headlines. The only difference is we're not in the direct violence stage yet (at least directly from political pundits like Kirk, but I think these people know their words fuel it), but considering the fact that the right is using this as a justification to commit even more violence then they already have, I think we're pretty close: and I want answers.


r/PoliticalDebate • • Apr 08 '24

Discussion How close is the US really to fascism if Trump gets elected?

0 Upvotes

There has been some coverage recently of efforts like Project 2025 outlining what kinds of authoritarian changes could be coming to US government should Trump win the election in November.

I have plenty of reasons for opposing Trump, and don't want him to win. But I have trouble imagining that he of all people would be able to really carry out fascism in the US, or even anything approaching it.

I can imagine Trump trying to carry out a few authoritarian actions, especially in trying to prevent accountability for his own alleged crimes. But even if Trump wins, he will not have a majority of the popular vote, and will be starkly opposed on day one by a majority of Americans. It is easy to imagine a lot of people protesting, resigning rather than carry out orders, ruling against him, going on strike, etc. And if he tries to go around all of that through crushing dissent...again, how many people are really on Trump's side for going much further than he has already gone?

So how will Trump's authoritarian tendencies most likely play out should he win the election, and what are the best ways to make sure they are stopped? Or - do you really think the US system as we know it is over once Trump takes power again, and what makes you feel that way?


r/PoliticalDebate • • Mar 27 '24

Other I prefer the class struggle. It's healthy.

0 Upvotes

Perhaps and unpopular view for Reddit:

So much dialog lately coming from the socialist, communist camp about workers not reaping the fruits of their labor. Being exploited. That's false. The fruits of their labor is called wages. Equity SHOULD enjoy the lion's share of profit as they are the risk takers, entrepreneurs, innovators and visionaries. Their is no justice in diluting equity's rewards.

The wealthy haven't gotten there by magic. It takes effort (perhaps not the kind that produces perspiration) and often risk.

Even in my case, to buy my first business at 50+ years old, I liquidated a large portion of my retirement savings, and used my home as collateral to finance the business purchase (I was betting on me). My employee's haven't risked anything. They're renumerated by being paid for their labor. I am rewarded with every dollar of profit the business makes.

Labor is a necessary evil. It's a cost of business. The Balance Sheet doesn't list your work-force under Assets. They're NOT an asset. I cannot sell them, nor can I depreciate them. The workforce part of the cost of goods and services. An operating EXPENSE.

I'm certainly NOT arguing that people are equivalent to a my liability insurance policy. Mostly because it's much easier to replace my insurance than my manager. Your workforce should be treated as the valuable part of your product delivery that they are. The COST of finding and training new people adds to the COGS. Business owners try to reduce costs: yes for their own benefit - but also for the benefit of their customers.

The argument that I should 'share' my rewards with my workforce is absurd. If they want a share of profit, they should get their own business. It was actually easier than I imagined. The SBA (Small Business Administration) is ready with lending.

So, in conclusion, I like the class struggle. Workers should aspire to be business owners and not bemoan their station. The working class want freedom from risk while reaping the rewards of others' risks. If my business fails, my workers will walk away relatively unscathed. My life would be in financial ruins (for a while). It is a symbiotic relationship, but we are NOT the same.


r/PoliticalDebate • • Mar 08 '24

Political Theory Capitalism is everything it claims it isn't.

10 Upvotes

I know this might get me killed but here's what I've noticed in my life regarding whatever "Capitalism" is in the States.

  1. It aims to pay workers a poverty wage while giving all the profits to owners.

The propaganda says that bother governments want to pay everyone the same. Which of course kills incentives and that capitalism is about people earning their worth in society.

What see are non capitalists calling for a livable wage for workers to thrive and everyone to get paid more for working more. While capitalists work to pay workers, from janitors to workers, as little as possible while paying owners and share holders as much money as possible.

2. Fiscal responsibility. When Capitalists run the government they "borrow our way out of debt" by cutting taxes for owners and the wealthy and paying for the deficit with debt. Claiming people will make more money to pay more in taxes which never happens. We see them raising taxes on the poor if anything.

All while non capitalists try to remove tax write offs and loopholes, lower taxes for the poor, raise taxes on the wealthy and luxury spending.

3. They claim privatization is better than publicly regulated and governed.

We hear about the free market and how it's supposed to be a kind of economic democracy where the people decide through money but they complain about any kind of accountability by the people and are even trying to install a president to be above the law.

We're told you can't trust the government but should trust corporations as they continue to buy up land and resources and control our lives without the ability to own anything through pay or legal rights as companies lobby to control the laws.

This constant push to establish ownership over people is the very opposite of democracy or freedom that they claim to champion.

So there you have what I can figure. I've been trying to tackle the definition of capitalism from what people know and what we see and this seems to be the three points to summerize what we get with it.

Slavery for the masses with just enough people paid enough to buffer the wealthy against the poor.


r/PoliticalDebate • • Nov 24 '24

Discussion If children really are unable to meaningfully comprehend gender identity, then wouldn’t the logical conclusion be that everyone should start genderless until they can meaningfully articulate their gender?

4 Upvotes

This is a very abstract concept that just came to mind, which even now is difficult for me to properly articulate, and i already know it’ll be an extremely controversial take.

I always hear the argument about how “they’re still children, they don’t even understand emotions yet” and thus the idea of gender diversity should be off limits until they’re fully developed, but isn’t this in itself a double standard? If children really are too young to comprehend gender, then how does it make sense to assign them one over the other without ever having their input?

What do you think about this concept? I assume the biggest division between people’s thoughts will work off of if you believe sex and gender are two separate concept, or if you think they’re the same thing. But I’m curious to hear perspectives from both beliefs of this concept.

Essentially what i’m questioning here is why the gender that corresponds with a child’s biology at birth is more natural / justified than anything else, including neutrality. If you think that gender shouldn’t be conceptualized until people grow up, then shouldn’t that principle extend to everyone?

And of course since this is a politically centered forum i’m trying to tie it back not just to the philosophical narrative, but also socially and politically. Thank you for your thoughts!


r/PoliticalDebate • • Jul 05 '24

Question Help me understand the strategy behind still supporting Biden at this late stage?

0 Upvotes

In the recent presidential debate, Joe Biden showed clear signs of mental deterioration. There was attempts by the Biden team to play it off as a 'once off' flub, however this has been an ongoing criticism for Biden prior to him even announcing he would run in the previous 2020 election. After many televised gaffs, videos of him being shown how to walk off stage, and speculation he might have dementia, there is now widespread calls for Biden to withdraw his 2024 candidacy.

While recent head to head polling since the debate shows Biden trailing Trump by less than 10 points, the same polling shows majority (close to 80%) Independents and Democrats now believe Biden is too old to govern. Various media democratic talking heads (Maddow, WP & NYT columnists, Podcasts, etc), even Nancy Pelosis re-animated corpse has made an appearance to call for Biden to pass the torch. There is talk donors are pulling the plug also. While they raise concerns about Biden being unable to win the upcoming election, the unspoken concern is that Biden is unfit to govern right now. A dementia addled President puts the country at risk.

Now I can comprehend[speculate] the motivations of Biden, the Biden team, and Bidens family rallying around him and backing him to stay in the race. Similar to what we have seen previously with RBG, Pelosi, even Trump, ego, personal gain, and a careerist focus are powerful motivators that can steer your mindset away from whats "good for the country". This is of course the election where "democracy is on the ballot", as we have heard so many times the danger a Trump victory and the introduction of Project 2025 will bring. But I think it goes without saying that if the incumbent President is trailing in polls to the guy he voted in to replace, its not a good sign.

The Trump team of course is more than happy to keep Biden in the race, viewing him as a weak candidate, releasing the following statement:

"Every Democrat who is calling on Crooked Joe Biden to quit was once a supporter of Biden and his failed policies that lead to extreme inflation, an open border, and chaos at home and abroad. Make no mistake that Democrats, the main stream media, and the swamp colluded to hide the truth from the American public - Joe Biden is weak, failed, dishonest, and not fit for the White House. Every one of them has lied about Joe Biden’s cognitive state and supported his disastrous policies over the past four years, especially Cackling Copilot Kamala Harris..."

The criticism here is pretty easy to read through the Trumpisms, and will effect down ballot voting, because it rings true. Even from the start of his 2020 campaign Biden was visibly a shell of the man who trounced Paul Ryan in the VP debates. His campaign was criticised for "hiding" the aged gaff prone Biden during the primaries, relying on his Obama era name recognition to carry him through. The 2020 primary race also saw democrats 'carry' him through, as all likeminded candidates dropped out to endorse him after receiving a call from Obama. Likewise the common defence spouted 'Biden handily won the 2024 primary' does nothing but raise the question 'is the DNC primary process woefully unfit for task?', not being able to filter out a clearly declining senior to a stronger candidate.

Saying all this I can comprehend[speculate] the logic of establishment, media, & liberals backing Biden up to this point, there has been a clear desire to block progressives from elected office and maintain neoliberal policies despite their declining popularity with the public. However what I don't understand is objection to the choice currently presented: replace Biden with another neo-liberal centrist, a carbon copy, with no pushback from the left coalition. Neo-liberal centrist policies would continue, progressive talking heads are even openly saying they would take Hillary over Biden right now, because at least her brain works.

So why am I seeing armchair liberals still ardently supporting Biden?

I am calling on Liberals, Democrats, Neo-liberals, anyone who is still backing Biden to help me understand your mindset/strategy/goals here. Everyone on the left is of the agreement Trump + Project 2025 is bad, but the current criticism of Bidens team is they are trying to run out the clock till there is no option to switch him out, effectively handing the Presidency to Trump.

Help me understand the strategy at play, what is going on here?

EDIT** Here is a video of the former DNC executive chair discussing the process, and how a change of nominee could play out for the Democratic party. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Vu39seLqIo&ab_channel=DemocracyNow%21


r/PoliticalDebate • • Apr 23 '24

Question Is Hitler really a socialist?

0 Upvotes

I was PM'd by a person' a few weeks ago, after a page had banned him on Facebook. His claims are

"Hitler is a socialist".

This is one of the Hitler quotes he uses to promote that Hitler is a socialist.

Hitler on German Socialism

“Is there a nobler or more excellent kind of Socialism and is there a truer form of Democracy than this National Socialism which is so organized that through it each one among the millions of German boys is given the possibility of finding his way to the highest office in the nation, should it please Providence to come to his aid?” – January 30, 1937, On National Socialism and World Relations speech in the German Reichstag"

He had several other quotes on Hitler and him claiming he is a socialist, but historians are saying otherwise that I have read so far.

This man who DM'd me, had stated that he is someone who has been studying Fascism since 2016, and that if I use historians, and deny his claims, I'm admitting a fallacy as he claims.

It seems contradictictory to claim I'm committing the Appeal to Authority fallacy, when they themselves claim themselves as an expert?

To not get off topic, he also posted this...

"What must fundamentally distinguish the populist world-concept [Nazi worldview] from the Marxist one is the fact that it recognizes not only the value of race, but the importance of the personality, and thus makes these the pillars of its whole structure…If the National Socialist movement were not to understand the fundamental significance of this basic realization, and instead were superficially to patch up the present State, or actually to regard the mass standpoint as its own [i.e. Democratic Socialism, which was a major party in Germany at the time], it would really be only a party competing with Marxism.”- Adolf Hitler, Mein Kampf (New York: Stackpole Sons Publishers, 1939), 434-435"

So, the question is, is Hitler a socialist, what was he?


r/PoliticalDebate • • Feb 25 '25

Question Conservatives, what is your opinion on equity and why are DEI hires so upsetting to you.

2 Upvotes

For example, in education:

-Equality would mean giving every student the same textbook.

-Equity would mean providing additional support (like tutoring or accommodations) to students who need it to succeed at the same level as others.

Equity recognizes that people start from different places and aims to level the playing field, while equality treats everyone the same, which may not always lead to fairness.

Do you really not feel like it is in the best interest of the American people to insure that people have the ability to learn regardless of their disabilities?

Also, with DEI, the way that it works is that if two people are equality qualified and are trying to get the same position, if there is a lack of diversity in that industry they try to go with the minority person so that they can have representation in a field. They aren't just hiring unqualified people because they are a minority, it's basically a tie breaker. I know this because I have worked in industries that make these decisions. If you disagree with DEI, what is your proposal to fix the issues that minorities are still not given the same opportunities in many respects? Before you say that isn't true, look into it.


r/PoliticalDebate • • Aug 02 '24

Debate I believe that bidens college forgiveness plan is a mistake.

0 Upvotes

While it is a novel mission, I do not believe that it is a sustainable practice without hurting the average American financially.

forgiving 69.2 billion dollars is admirable, yet pales in comparison to the total debt and does not solve the real problem,

**28% of bachelor's degrees and 41% of master's degrees do not increase the incomes of students enough to justify the cost of tuition.-**FREOPP

I firmly believe that the proper way we need to take care of this issue is stopping colleges from charging what they want carte blanche and promoting trade schools more.

The average cost of tuition currently is nearly 30k per year. meaning a bachelors degree would end up costing over 120k. That is not factoring in anything other than tuition, room and board averages $12,770 per year. After fees that 30k jumps to nearly double.

If America was to successfully limit loan providers from writing blank checks to colleges by government intervention we could see a substantial decrease in cost for everyone. I have met many people whos families made too much, but had no money to send a kid to school or outright refused to support them.

Imagine how many more people could go to college if it was 30k for the entire degree, I did an Exceltrack degree for my bachelors. cost me 11k total. (did 4 years of college in 6 months completing a minimum of 2 classes per day and thinking of getting my masters through the same program.)

Would absolutely love to see more low income Americans being introduced to the trades as well. Typically shorter, cheaper, and in high demand especially in low income areas and are able to give back to their neighbors through service more than any degree can. Would also help boost up the community when there's a new generation of young welders, plumbers, HVAC and electricians being able to fix the issues in their community.

If you have any counter points or corrections I would love to discuss them.


r/PoliticalDebate • • Jun 19 '25

Israel is committing a genocide in Gaza.

10 Upvotes

The 1948 Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide defines genocide in this way:

"Genocide means any of the following acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such:

(a) Killing members of the group;
(b) Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group;
(c) Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part;
(d) Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group;
(e) Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group."

The hardest thing to discuss and prove is intent. I believe the Israeli government deliberately targets civilians and civilian infrastructure with the goal of achieving at least one of the five acts described in the convention. Here is my proof:

Genocidal hate speech is omnipresent in the Israeli society (here, here), in Israeli media (here, here), and obviously the Israeli government itself (here).

"Words accompany actions – they prepare and explain them." (here)

Israel is a country based on apartheid and systemic oppression of Palestinians.

Thus, I believe Israel's society, media and government actively intend committing genocide.

The second step is proving one of the five possible ways in which a genocide can be committed.

A/ Killing members of the group : ranges go from 55 000 to 180 000. Hamas "only" has 20 000 active members, and even Israel admits the number of civilian casualties are "far higher than reported".

B/ Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group : "four out of five children in Gaza say they are living with depression, grief and fear" (source dates before start of genocide). Also here, here and here.

C/ Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part : this definition is perfect, especially thanks to the mention of "calculated" : "IDF dieticians calculated the calorie intake needed to keep the average Gazan just above the malnutrition threshold: 2,279 calories per person per day. Based on this estimate, the general staff determined that 131 trucks would be authorized to enter Gaza every day." (source)

D/ Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group. The harsh situation is IMO enough as proof but I don't have detailed statistics

E/ Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group. I don't believe this has happened in Gaza.

Thus, I believe Israel is deliberately enacting at least three of the actions that define genocide. Reminder : only one of those actions being committed can define a genocide.

edit : following the many comments in this post, I want to remind everyone of a few things :

- None of those things I mentioned are invented by me on the spot, especially the definition for genocide. this is why i don't bother answering people who believe "my" definition is flawed, as it has been created by a literal holocaust survivor.
- I am open to debate. however, i respectfully invite people who don't know the matter to please think twice before answering. I think it's an amazing subject and you'll find lots of resources to educate yourself. In the meanwhile, i will abstain from answering to people who don't know well the situation.


r/PoliticalDebate • • Nov 07 '25

Is right-wing politics political infantilism?

0 Upvotes

Could we say that right-wing politics is a form of infantilism or underdevelopment in the advancement of political consciousness, and therefore right-wing politics is a drag?


r/PoliticalDebate • • Dec 11 '23

Discussion Housing should be a public welfare right, homelessness shouldn't be a designed reality

0 Upvotes

Decommodified public housing and right to shelter would be cheaper long term, would allow for the construction of better designed communities, end homelessness. There is no need for Faircloth limits unless we want people to suffer by design. When we house people, they are more likely to work, seek healthcare treatment, purchase normal and luxury goods, etc. There is no reason for thousands to die annually while homeless in America each year. 300 people die in my neighborhood annually while homeless. I've been homeless twice. Rather than sit and complain about it on reddit though, I'm using reddit to rehouse people. If you need help with accessing public housing please join my support reddit r/section8listshoppers as I want to help you get access to welfare services too. I want everyone who can qualify for them to get them. And if I could change anything about the system, I would fix welfare so everyone could qualify and access it.

Direct action from anarchists and communists will solve this crisis faster than any the bureaucratic capitalists who have intentionally created homelessness by design to maintain a lumpen class to exploit and strike fear into the proletariats that if they don't stay wise and be exploited, they will be lumpen too. I'd like to hear a capitalist actually explain to me their plans to end homelessness because I never have once heard it. So I'm going to do what I can to house a few with my little power until we can end the faircloth limits and we can actually have effective socialized housing. I'm putting all your democrats and republicans on alert I am on a mission to end homelessness, and I will use all of your actions that designed it against you. It might take me a few years. But I'm going to take you down.

Best,

Alex Casper
Inspector of Elections - Philadelphia Inspector of Elections (Green Party) Ward 47 Division 14
Reimagine Philadelphia Committee Member - Philadelphia Department of Planning and Development
Member Secretary - Green Party of Philadelphia
State Committee Delegate - Green Party of Pennsylvania
Also my day job is a sign people up for food stamps, and public healthcare. So if you are a fascist, I am here to ruin your day by continuing to do the work to help our communities access welfare to spite you.


r/PoliticalDebate • • Feb 09 '24

Discussion Large scale immigration to the U.S. is driving some native-born people out of the workforce, increasing homelessness and people needing public assistance.

0 Upvotes

There is truth to the fact that immigrants entering the workforce displace some workers, especially dysfunctional workers. Historically almost all societies had low level jobs like school janitors, dishwashers, street sweepers, parks gardener that were mostly filled with people with alcohol issues or mental limitations. Often middle-aged men held the jobs. Everyone understood the social contract:

This is undesirable, minimal skill work, but it has to be done. We have people with limited work capabilities and they will be routed in these jobs. If they don't work that hard due to their limitations, that's OK -- they are doing the best they can. We pay them so they have support. They contribute to society, as everyone should, even if in a limited way. The work generally gets done. A win-win.

Granted, this often did not work well for restaurants--they depend on dishwashers to show up and be sober--but the system worked passably for centuries. In the U.S. this was upended in the 1980s, when Hispanic immigrants who historically favored agriculture work opted for city jobs instead. There were also more immigrants every year, propelled by progressive policies eroding border controls. Many sober, hard working 20 to 40-year-old immigrants, predominantly Hispanic, entering the U.S. each year, willing to do this work.

These immigrants displaced those native-born workers in short order. A new status quo across the U.S. That is why the progressive narrative of homeless men, age 35 - 50-plus with 10-15 years of addiction being "rehabilitated and reintegrated" in the workforce is mostly wishful thinking. Immigrants easily outcompete these people on the job. Now anyone with marginal work skills is at risk of becoming homeless and needing the Dole.


r/PoliticalDebate • • Aug 25 '24

Question Is it only a matter of time until free speech is dead in the West?

0 Upvotes

In the US, TikTok is going to be banned unless it is sold.

In France, they just arrested the founder and CEO of Telegram.

In Brazil, X is closing down it's regional office because they will not comply with government orders to remove content from their platform.

Increasingly governments have realized that online platforms have vast control over the narrative and now they seek to use the legal system as a means of undermining them.

How long until the Western Internet is indistinguishable from the Chinese Internet with it's Great Firewall? I think the sad truth is that it's going to be sooner rather than later.


r/PoliticalDebate • • Nov 11 '24

Discussion Claims that the Democratic Party isn't progressive enough are out of touch with reality

21 Upvotes

Kamala Harris is the second-most liberal senator to have ever served in the Senate. Her 2020 positions, especially on the border, proved so unpopular that she had to actively walk back many of them during her campaign.

Progressives didn't significantly influence this election either. Jill Stein, who attracted the progressive and protest vote, saw her support plummet from 1.5M in 2016 to 600k in 2024, and it is now at a decade-low. Despite the Gaza non-committed campaign, she even lost both her vote share and raw count in Michigan—from 51K votes (1.07%) in 2016, to 45K (0.79%) in 2024.

What poses a real threat to the Democratic party is the erosion of support among minority youth, especially Latino and Black voters. This demographic is more conservative than their parents and much more conservative than their white college-educated peers. In fact, ideologically, they are increasingly resembling white conservatives. America is not unique here, and similar patterns are observed across the Atlantic.

According to FT analysis, while White Democrats have moved significantly left over the past 20 years, ethnic minorities remained moderate. Similarly, about 50% of Latinos and Blacks support stronger border enforcement, compared with 15% of White progressives. The ideological gulf between ethnic minority voters and White progressives spans numerous issues, including small-state government, meritocracy, gender, LGBTQ, the "American dream", and even perspectives on racism.

What prevented the trend from manifesting before is that, since the civil rights era, there has been a stigma associated with non-white Republican voters. As FT points out,

Racially homogenous social groups suppress support for Republicans among non-white conservatives. [However,] as the US becomes less racially segregated, the frictions preventing non-white conservatives from voting Republic diminish. And this is a self-perpetuating process, [and could give rise to] a "preference cascade". [...] Strong community norms have kept them in the blue column, but those forces are weakening. The surprise is not so much that these voters are now shifting their support to align with their preferences, but that it took so long.

While the economy is important, cultural issues could be even more influential than economic ones. Uniquely, Americans’ economic perceptions are increasingly disconnected from actual conditions. Since 2010, the economic sentiment index shows a widening gap in satisfaction depending on whether the party that they ideologically align with holds power. A post-election poll released by a Democratic polling firm also shows that for many swing voters, cultural issues ranked even slightly higher than inflation.

EDIT: The FT articles are paywalled, but here are some useful charts.


r/PoliticalDebate • • Apr 07 '25

Other John Oliver's segment on trans athletes is a banger

32 Upvotes

Link here -> https://youtu.be/flSS1tjoxf0?si=luOq8ANHB75KwPI5

I think as political talking heads go John Oliver is one of the best in the biz and this segment is an example of this. I'd like to hear how people who care so deeply about the "threat" of trans athletes (truly an incredibly small amount of people) that it'd sway them on who they vote for think about this.

Tldr: there are some genuine nuances to trans people in sports but the research on this is so scarce and with such small sample sizes it's hard to say anything definitive, the "900 medals" point transphobes like to make is bullshit, a lot of the former college athletes who made careers "speaking out" about trans women in sports are just sore losers, and the point of banning trans kids from sports is somehow "protecting children" is just bullshit.

EDIT: I've never seen so many people so triggered by the suggestion that a small and vulnerable group of people deserves dignity and respect. Some of you are genuinely vile and hateful people. I hope it feels good to hate people who have never done anything to you. I don't know what other benefit it could possibly bring.


r/PoliticalDebate • • Oct 29 '25

Political Theory Europe should give up on the idea of ethnic nationalism and embrace multiculturalism instead

0 Upvotes

POV: I have had many European friends & acquaintances. The perspective that I get is that a lot of then don't consider their people of foreign backgrounds as the same of their own, despite many of them being second, third and sometimes even fourth generation citizens residing in those countries. The identity is highly tied to the ethnic/ancestry affiliation. This is hurtful in so many ways, because I feel like it prevents assimilation, and trust within society. I have met tons of Europeans who really dislike immigrants and could never accept them as "German", "English, "Belgian", etc, and even think they (immigrants of third or fourth generation) should be deported. In contrast, in the USA, even hardline Trump supporters would consider "minorities" (such as Blacks and Native American) as American as they are and support for deportations is only reserved for very fringe Neo-Nazi groups (I exclude illegal immigrants of course, as there's quite a difference between an illegal immigrant to a legal fourth generation civilian with a foreign background).

I don't see why multiculturalis and shifting nationality towards a civic one couldn't work in Europe. It worked in the USA, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, etc. I myself am from Israel, and we originate from 100+ different countries, yet there's very little racism between us (in comparison from what I have observed of my European friends). My grandparents arrived to Israel from Yemen during the 1940's; their arrival was financed by the government (airplane), and they received free land and housing and never held negative attitudes towards the government and saw themselves as proud Israelis. Why couldn't it work elsewhere?

Some may suggest to just limit immigration, but Europe NEEDS immigrants; its native population's birth rates are falling off the charts dramatically, well below replacement levels. Someone needs to pay for the pensions, the government debts, the aging population, etc. Also, Europe needs to fill the low-paying work positions (construction, infrastructure, agriculture, manufacturing, mining, cleaning, retailing, food service, hospitality, healthcare, etc). Yes, natives could do those jobs but that would require paying living wages (often doubling or tripling the wages), which would significantly raise the cost of them to other Europeans, making everyone worse off. Same for high-paying jobs (doctors or tech workers) which are in high demand, and could raise the cost of healthcare or limit the industry's growth (in the case of tech).

Some would compare Europe to East Asian countries, but I think the comparison is unfair, because their economies don't rely (for the most part) on "slave workers" in construction, agriculture, food service, etc, and the natives are willing to do them themselves. Also, Europe already has a huge population with foreign background, so the genie is already out of the bottle, and those "guest workers" aren't going away anytime soon.

I think the failure of assimilation is in Europe's hands; the preservation of racist ethnic nationalism, discrimination against immigrants, and hostile attitudes (placement in ghettos, discrimination in the job market, hostility by government officials, etc).

td;lr Europe's economy is structured on immigrants filling low-paying jobs to sustain themselves. Europe's failure to adopt civic nationalism in favour of ethnic nationalism does more harn than good, and risk leading to failure in the assimilation of immigrating population, which would inevitablly lead to a growing number of second-class citizens who fail to see themselves as part of their respective nations.


r/PoliticalDebate • • Apr 22 '25

META If you downvote a post in a DEBATE subreddit because you disagree with the premise…you are part of the problem.

3 Upvotes

Why are you here? What is the point of even being here?

If there is a post you disagree with and you downvote it early on, it quickly becomes invisible. OP probably gets salty and doubles down on their opinion and sees the opposing side as unreasonable. Which, in this instance, they actually are!

If there is a post you disagree with and you UPVOTE IT, the person who posted it might encounter viewpoints they wouldn’t normally encounter and even change their mind.

If you don’t care about that, why are you even here?


r/PoliticalDebate • • Dec 27 '23

Current Events Should Biden be receiving more scrutiny for his use of alias email addresses?

0 Upvotes

Republicans are claiming Biden used aliases to hide his communications with Hunter to discuss business. Aliases aren't named in FOIA requests, so are hidden from outside scrutiny.

Would Biden's supporters feel similarly if Trump were caught using aliases for the same reason?

https://thefederalist.com/2023/11/16/vp-biden-followed-advice-hunter-sent-to-his-champ4-burner-email/


r/PoliticalDebate • • Oct 14 '26

Discussion It's Time To Drop The Identity Politics

8 Upvotes

I am generally pretty left-wing progressive (those are NOT the same thing!), but with a notable libertarian streak. Universal healthcare, free college, government investment in mass transit and nuclear power, support for co-ops and labor unions; I support all of this.

Unfortunately, the proponents of those policies bring with them other policies, many of which are specifically aimed against my own best interest. Absurd gun laws, DEI, social programs that only benefit minorities or women, censorship of speech and press they dislike, "Green" policies which are actually worse for the environment, etc.

Not that I have any issue with minorities or women, but most of the people I know are poor, rural whites; why are we being asked to pay more and accept oppression on the justification that those groups had little money and were oppressed in the past? What kind of sense does that make? "Two wrongs make a right?"

Moreover, how do you expect these people to actively vote against their own best interests? Forget ethics for a minute and look at sheer pragmatism: The white working class consists of 100 million Americans, the single largest voting bloc there is, whom it is simply impossible to form a majority position in government without.

That means that the policies they are proposing will never happen... and they know it.

Do you want to help minorities and women? Start by helping everyone.


r/PoliticalDebate • • Apr 13 '24

Question Why is the far left dishonest about democracy?

6 Upvotes

I keep seeing MLs and anarchists say they are for democracy but not "bourgeois democracy" but for "radical" democracy which for them entails banning opposition liberal/conservative parties and forcing the population to choose between a flavor of socialism. In my opinion this isn't democracy, they use it in an orwellian way, true democracy means offering real alternative to the population, i have problems with aspects of liberal democracy too but what the far left offers seems a downgrade and dishonest. For how bad the far right is, they are at least honest with their disdain for democracy and letting the people have a voice.