r/Pathfinder2e • u/Glad-Tomatillo-4563 • 8h ago
Table Talk My character drank a Greater Elixir of Gender Transformation as a joke.
Something that happened on my latest Pathfinder 2e session that I wanted to share. Just as a heads up, I'm not mad about it, I just didn't know how to react for a while, but everything's fine.
Just for context: I'm playing in a Westmarch type server, and the one-shot was about fighting against a dragon, with a Level 6 party. I was playing my tanuki Thaumaturge (Mid-forties man, wife and kids, took up adventuring to pay the bills) and one of the party members (A Plant Yaoguai reskinned as a forest nymph Druid with an Alchemist Dedication) was handing out mutagens and potions for the fight.
Near the end, the player asks me in character something like "Do you trust me?" and I go "Sure, we've been in other missions before and you've always been a great help" so I drink the potion without thinking about it. In that moment, they reveal the trick and I'll admit that at first I didn't knew how to react but I just rolled with it, and we agreed that we would address the effects of the potion on written RP later.
Even then, the elixir's effects take a really long time to appear and time is a curious thing when you're not keeping track of days, weeks and months in-game so I guess we'll see what happens...
I did tell the player as a warning that they shouldn't make those kinds of jokes lighty in the future, as things like gender and how you present yourself are heavy topics for a lot of people, and even if I don't really mind, other players might find a lot of issue with it.
Edit: Just to clarify some things, the potion was crafted so it wouldn't lose its potency after a day, and like I said at the beginning, I'm really not mad about the whole issue myself and just see it like a curious opportunity for RP, even if I would have preferred to be asked instead of just springing that on me out of nowhere. Also me and the other player are on good terms right now.