r/Pathfinder2e • • Apr 24 '24

Tian Xia, real world parallels, and a serious moment.

71 Upvotes

The Tian Xia World Guide is now officially available for purchase!

With this book’s release and the discourse surrounding it, we need to make clear the subreddit’s rules and principles to make sure that the community is safe from harm. Especially recently, the subreddit has seen too many arguments that show how poorly people understand the severe prevalence of racism against Asian people, a phenomenon so deep-rooted that people simply do not notice its presence. It isn't as simple as someone saying a slur or judging based on skin colour—it’s easy to be confident in one’s ability to spot commonly-taught and overt racist tropes—but beyond that surface level, there are worlds of nuance and harms that many don’t know how to see or understand. ​

In the early 2000s, a book called Oriental Adventures was rewritten and expanded for D&D 3e. It is one of WotC's best-selling books of all time. It is also one of the most concentrated collections of Asian-based racist tropes in TTRPG space at the wide reach that Wizards has in the hobby. Paizo is no stranger to bigoted tropes either, found throughout PF1e books such as the Jade Regent AP and still carrying into PF2e in the monk class, which boxes Asians into the “Magical Asian” stereotype: rather than representing the fact that Asian fighters or Asian clerics exist (because Asian people are people), this racially-coded class stifles Asian representation into a caricature of 1970s kung fu exploitation movies. While we can move forward and learn from the past if we recognise the need to confront it, nothing will be accomplished if the reaction to that need is defensiveness or denial. Taking responsibility and taking real steps to improve is the entire philosophy of the Tian Xia World Guide: Paizo has given the reins to Asian authors who have made this book an honest conversation that addresses past mistakes and respects Tian Xia not as an exoticised locale, but as a legitimate, lived-in home.

Stereotypes and biases influence the ways that a book is written, the ways that a movie is edited, the ways that we speak to each person we meet in a day, and even unconsciously influence the ways that we think. Media exposes us to ideas that can normalise distorted perceptions and draw lines that make minorities “othered”, portraying them as if they’re different from “normal” people. AAPI activist Jenn Fang writes on how biases and norms feed into orientalism, making it all too easy to treat the stereotypical “West” as “normal” while a fantasised “East” is filtered through stereotypes:

Orientalism… draws upon exaggerations of both Occidental and Oriental traits in order to create an Orientalist fantasy that is a fictional recapitulation of both East and West. Western men are reimagined as universally Godly, good, moral, virile, and powerful — but ultimately innately human. By contrast, those traits that best serve as a counter-point to the Occidental West are emphasised in the West’s imagined construct of the East: strange religions and martial arts, bright colours and barbaric practices, unusual foods and incomprehensible languages, mysticism and magic, ninjas and kung fu. Asia becomes innately unusual, alien, and beastly. In Orientalism, Asia is not defined by what Asia is; rather, Asia becomes an “Otherized” fiction of everything the West is not, and one that primarily serves to reinforce the West’s own moral conception of itself.

Some fans often talk about wanting a dedicated “ninja” or “samurai” character option. However common these tropes have been, they’re a very blurry subject because of the exclusive focus on Japanese media stereotypes fueled by anime and samurai movies being the main exposure to Asian culture that westerners ever have. It goes beyond just "liking something" or "just a fantasy". Putting stereotypes on a pedestal excludes the hundreds of ethnic groups that exist in Asia and tells them that, when Asians get represented, they just get homogenised into a Japanese person—this is racism through exclusion towards Asian people who aren’t specifically Japanese. It’s the overwriting and exclusion of ethnicities that falls into the racist stereotyping of “you all look the same”. It creates a racist trope where Asian people are either the “karate master” or “honourable samurai warrior”, defined by the history of Japanese imperialism that billions of people in Asia are still grappling with. In the words of the Tian Xia World Guide:

“Tian Xia can’t be summed up in a single book; no land can. The following pages offer an outline of the cities, cultures, peoples, places, creatures, flora, and history of what can be found here. It might seem different, but no more different than the nations of the Inner Sea are from one another. Look with a willingness to learn, and you might find as many things in common as there are differences.”

Moving forward, we will do our best to improve our understanding of these harmful stereotypes and how to address them. We will always strictly enforce Rule #1, as we want everyone to feel safe and respected in this space, and we thank you for your understanding and care in making this a more accepting community for all Pathfinders.

- r/Pathfinder2e mod team

If you would like to learn more, we recommend Jenn Fang's introduction on orientalism as well as a few more sources:


r/Pathfinder2e • • Feb 20 '23

Discussion Petition to make AI Art Against Rules Regardless of Context

130 Upvotes

I know I'm not alone in my extreme dislike of AI "art". The DnD subreddit has already banned those posts, as have others unrelated to the TTRPG sphere. These posts do nothing to enhance the discussion around here and certainly do nothing to support the creators these AI are stealing from. They aren't the most prevalent posts, but they are on the rise, and I would rather not wait around until they're out of control. Mods, please take a stand now.

EDIT: I should have worded the above to say "ANY AI generated content including AI generated art, ChatGPT generated text, etc."

EDIT 2: WHAT are you people talking about? I don't care if it's legal or art or anything like that. I don't want to see this subreddit choked with more art spam than there already is, and with AI drawing everything, this will be an "AI Art and Sometimes Pathfinder2e if There's Time" subreddit.


r/Pathfinder2e • • Nov 04 '25 Polished Gold Turd Bless Up

Advice Tarondor's Guides

0 Upvotes

I want you all to know that I received a form message saying that my "art submission" (e.g., my 366-page Guide to Clerics with one piece of art on the first page) was removed because I was "unkind or disrespectful". Evidently, the attack on me and my guide wasn't disrespectful, but saying I couldn't care less about people's opinion on AI art was.

I have never been rude to anyone on this subreddit and literally anyone who's ever read my posts know that I always try to be polite, even when people commenting on my guides are occasionally quite unkind. Each of you knows the allegation of disrespect is just false.

The original posts pointing out the AI image were so peremptory and rude that I chose not to explain. I'm rather tired, both on this reddit and in our national discourse, of people assuming that because they feel something strongly everyone must immediately and unthinkingly fall in line and kowtow to the new thinking or be declared the enemy. That sort of childish demand that everything be the way you like it is the most un-American attitude I can imagine. Shame on all of us for continuing to think our neighbors and friends must either join the utterly new orthodoxy or be outcast.

I'm going to explain a few things about art, both in general and my art in particular. First of all, I chose a picture I liked and used it. I had no idea it was AI-generated and still don't care now that I know. If there had been an equally apt piece of art available that was not AI-generated, I would have used that with equal satisfaction. Second, if I -had- chosen a piece of art created by a human, I would have been obligated to figure out who made it and ask their permission, even though I give these guides to you, the Pathfinder community free of charge. I don't know how I would have managed to figure out the owner or how long it would have taken to get a response, but it sure as hell would have been longer than the two minutes I spent to try to give you all a nice-looking piece of splash art on the cover of my guide.

And art? MY art is the guides I've been giving this community free of charge for many years now. I don't ask how you use it. I don't tell you how what to do with it. I listen patiently when you tell me how you don't agree with me. I often change my views after hearing yours. In short, I have been a contributing member of the Pathfinder community since before this reddit began. Hell, I've been a contributing member of the RPG community since before most of you were born.

So, once again, learn some damn manners! And that goes not just for you few who demand obedience to your arbitrary orthodoxy but to you moderators who took this action without even consulting me. Had even ONE moderator contacted me in the comments and politely asked me to remove the AI art, I would have done so without hesitation. I'm not saying I'm special - I'm saying all of us deserve better than a bot message.

So. I'm taking a little break here. If the moderators would like to contact me like actual human beings, I'm listening.

- Tarondor

_____________________________________________________________________________________

EDIT: I responded to the moderator's post below, but it'll be lost in the tumult, so here's what I wrote:

Thank you for taking the time to post a detailed response. I appreciate it.

I regret not having waited for your response to my message. I have personally apologized to you for that and now I do so publicly.

I also regret violating a forum rule (even though I didn't know I was doing it at the time.) I absolutely think it's a bad rule, but I respect that the forum has rules and, should I post here again, I intend to follow them.

Thank you to the many forum members who had something nice to say here and in personal notes. I love role-playing games. I love Pathfinder 2e.

I don't regret giving and expecting politeness. It's a virtue all too often forgotten on the Internet.

- Tarondor


r/Pathfinder2e • • May 28 '26

Content VTT module maps suck

Thumbnail
gallery
17 Upvotes

Just got hellbreakers and ... damn man. For a hundo?

The adventure looks great, the automation is very comprehensive. Everything written or coded for the VTT module looks great.

The actual looks are absolutely miserable quality though. I get that we've given up on expecting quality from the maps Paizo publishes in PDFs, but the maps being "Completely remade" and "Highly detailed" is literally a major advertising point for the VTT modules, they even name drop the studio.

These two are the Paizo and "completely remade, high detail" maps for the first encounter. Can you even guess which is which?

If selling APs is how Paizo stays afloat - why dont they present them competently?


r/Pathfinder2e • • Jul 03 '26 Bravo

Discussion On Liches: Why the soul cage change didn't go far enough

35 Upvotes

tl;dr- Back in around 2021, Paizo changed the name of the things liches keep their souls in to soul cages to avoid the potentially antisemitic connotations of the word "phylactery", but I recently noticed that Monster Core actually keeps in the main detail that led to the controversy in the first place - their physical description.

Also, credit to prokopetz on Tumblr. I've supplemented his post with some of my own research, like the Jack Vance connection or the explanation of the etymology, but this is really building off that post.


To start off, I need to talk about the etymology of the word "phylactery" itself. Basically, because of things like Hellenistic Judaism and the Septuagint, we wound up with Greek translations of various terms for things in Judaism. For example, a synagōgḗ could mean a gathering of people or a place where they gather... or it could specifically mean a Jewish synagogue. Pentēkostḗ could just be the word for "fiftieth"... or it could mean the holiday of Shavuot, which is celebrated on the 50th day of Passover. Or, in this case, a phylactḗrion could mean a protective amulet... or it could mean a tefillah. And in part because of the cultural influence of Greece (and Rome), a lot of these words went to have both Jewish and non-Jewish meanings. For example, Pentecost can either be an older name for Shavuot or the Christian holiday descended from it, or a phylactery can either be one of those small, "travel-sized" reliquaries... or a tefillah.

Meanwhile, in AD&D 1e, Gygax introduced the concept of a lich as a spellcaster who tucks their soul away in a... something for safekeeping. They aren't really described, and there isn't even a consistent word for them. For example, they even get called jars in a few places. However, they do get called phylacteries in a few places. And if I'm being completely honest, I'm comfortable asserting it was a thesaurusism for "amulet". I can even find instances of Jack Vance using the word in that sense, and if there are two things Gygax was known for, they're borrowing from Jack Vance and using thesaurusisms.

By AD&D 2e, the description stabilizes. They're called phylacteries, and they're just objects of great value. This is the version that everyone remembers. This is the version that probably inspired horcruxes in the transphobic wizard series. This is the version that D&D-adjacent media like OOTS uses, where Xykon keeps his soul in Redcloak's amulet. This is even the version that adventure-writers use, like how in Strength of Thousands, the very adventure path where Paizo announced the change, Dwandek's soul cage is described as an extra page tucked in a grimoire. If you were shocked to hear that there even was a controversy with liches and antisemitism, it's probably because you're imagining this version of a whatever you want to call them, and assuming the only controversy is with the name.

However. There are also a few stock magic items that have existed in D&D across editions and which even found their way into Golarion, like the phylactery of faithfulness or the cursed phylactery of monster attraction. And these are very specifically using phylactery closer to the Jewish sense, like how the AD&D 1e DMG describes the phylactery of monster attraction as a cursed armband. They're still ecumenicized, similarly to the semantic shift with paladins, and are for any clerics. But there is also a history in D&D and related games of using "phylactery" to refer to things based on tefillin. So plausibly in part because of that, there was a shift in around the 90s in how those things liches have were described. Starting with Van Richten's Guide to the Lich in last 2e and being promoted to the Monster Manual in 3e, the book very clearly describes tefillin. For example, this is the 3e Monster Manual's description:

The most common form of phylactery is a sealed metal box containing strips of parchment on which magical phrases have been transcribed. This typically has a leather strap so that the owner can wear it on the forearm or head.

Or this is the corresponding text in the PF 1e Bestiary:

The most common form of phylactery is a sealed metal box containing strips of parchment on which magical phrases have been transcribed. The box is Tiny and has 40 hit points, hardness 20, and a break DC of 40.

For comparison, tefillin are actually made of *leather, but they're otherwise sealed boxes containing strips of paper on which Torah verses have been transcribed, with a leather strap to that the owner can wear it on the forearm or head. Yeah. There's normally some sort of clause in there to grandfather in the 2e-style soul cages. But the usual form of a phylactery (soul cage) according to D&D 3e, D&D 5.0, PF 1e, and PF 2e is a phylactery (tefillah).

In other words, liches have existed in this weird middle state, where the common understanding of what a soul cage is doesn't sound all that antisemitic apart from the dubious name, but where if you actually look them up in the Monster Manual / Bestiary, you'll probably be shocked to see the entry namechecking Jewish religious objects.

And, well... that's where we get to the issue I discovered with the current depiction. I'll give Paizo credit for (as far as I'm aware) leading the effort to rename soul cages. But while they thankfully at least ignore their own lore and refuse to give any liches soul cages that directly resemble tefillin, that's still how they're described in Monster Core.

The standard soul cage is a sealed metal box containing strips of parchment inscribed with magical phrases. This box has Hardness 9 and 36 HP, but some liches devise more durable or difficult-to-obtain soul cages. A soul cage might also come in the form of a ring, an amulet, or a similar item; the specifics are up to the creator.

(Basically, just focus on the "the specifics are up to the creator" part and remove the bit about the standard soul cage being a box with magical phrases inside)


EDIT: It's been pointed out that Book of the Dead features, not just the updated name, but also an updated description. So this might even be a case of just copying the description from the Bestiary without thinking about it, as opposed to updating the description like in BotD


r/Pathfinder2e • • Oct 28 '24

ORC / OGL I've fallen out of love with Pathfinder 2E because of the remaster.

125 Upvotes

First off, I'm not here to say that Pathfinder 2E is a bad game or that the remaster is a poor iteration—not at all. I just feel like I need to voice some concerns that have led me to lose interest in GM’ing Pathfinder 2E.

My group and I started with Pathfinder 2E four years ago, as we were looking for something beyond what D&D 5E offered. We had previously played Pathfinder 1E, Starfinder, and D&D 3.5 (essentially Pathfinder 1E). The action economy in 2E immediately caught our interest.

Let me tell you, over the years, we had so much fun I’ve collected many books I could easily open up and use to run a session. My group and I also developed a deep appreciation for Paizo as a developer. We felt they were customer-focused and committed to quality—and to some extent, they still are.

However, after the OGL incident and the remaster announcement, some members of my group and I were on the fence about how it would turn out, especially when we were told we’d "barely notice any difference" and would only need minor adjustments if we chose to use the remaster rules. Well, that didn't turn out to be the case—at least not in our experience. We had a new player join the group, we had not bothered reading up on the remaster changes, and the new player brought along their player core book, which we thought would be fine. Since, the changes would be so small.

The remaster brought more substantial changes than expected, including reworks to classes, monsters, the removal of some monsters, and other game mechanics.

Here are some notable changes we've noticed:

  • Classes in the remaster have undergone significant alterations, including (but not limited to) changes in how certain class feats and abilities work. For example, using the original core rulebook alongside the remaster could lead to conflicts in interpreting certain class abilities.

  • Many terms were changed to distance Paizo from OGL content (understandably so), including spell names, conditions, and some feat names.

  • The remaster adds and rebalances many feats, particularly for multiclassing and archetypes.

  • Certain items and magical equipment now have different mechanics, such as the apex items and updated talismans.

  • Changes to spellcasting make the original core rulebook difficult to use alongside the remaster.

  • Adjustments to skill proficiencies and options, including refined or renamed feats, complicate tracking and awarding skill-based checks between the remaster and original core rulebooks.

I want to keep supporting Paizo, and I want to purchase new book releases for Pathfinder 2E. But I cannot for the life of me want to sit down and learn the remastered rules, especially with all the books that I own!

Edit: I forgot to add that, along with this feeling of not wanting to learn the remaster, I've also lost the desire to continue playing 2E. Yes, we can easily bring up the legacy rules on Nethys if we want to (we try to refrain from using digital tools when playing), but I just can't find the motivation to play the game anymore.


r/Pathfinder2e • • Feb 10 '26

Advice [Rant] Giant Instict Barbarian makes me want to quit GMing

0 Upvotes

Yeah, it's an old topic from what I gather, but I really need to vent.

After GMing for over 3 years and finishing two 1-20th lvl campaings I must say, Giant Instict Barbarian (GIB) is the first and only character that made me question the system design. Maybe I relied too much on XP budget and bounded accuracy. It just worked smoothly every time and I could trust the process of building encounters and running pre-written adventures.

But now, with about 10 sessions of running a campaign for a party with GIB, I give up and just roll with it. This beast is a One Punch Man of PF2 for me. He has single-handedly killed the last 5 bosses with a single hit each time. He easily does more damage from a single hit than the average HP of their appropriate enemies, including bosses. And the party caught onto it, so now they simply pre-buff the GIB and throw him in to auto-win anything.

Yeah, I know that adding difficult terrain, forcing Reflex saves and unreachable ranged enemies can help, but I hate how I never had to adjust my approach to encounters for any other PC ever. This is the first and only case. I simply wanted to run a campaign as written, but now I find myself rewriting every single encounter, redrawing every map, or just throwing out certain NPCs simply because they don't work in a game with GIB. They simply don't mathematically and practically. So I just end up making a homebrew campaign from scratch, centered around the abilities of the single PC instead of focusing on the party at whole.

I've seen a take that GIB trades their huge damage for a clumsy debuff, but it hasn't impacted my games yet. I've also seen an opinion that his damage is balanced by his lack of out-of-combat abilities, so it should have a field for others to play, right? Well, in that case, what are the rest of PCs supposed to do in combat? Stick to their phones and wait for GIB to solo the dungeon? Because he literally can. We tested it on a short pre-written dungeon-crawl with Low-to-Severe encounters.

I'm really confused with this specific issue in an otherwise well-working system (at least for me so far). Am I doing something wrong? Should I just roll with it as it is designed and let the party enjoy easy walkthrough? Should I re-write the entire adventure to suit GIB's abilities?

UPDATE: Context and examples

I owe you all an apology for speaking half-truths out of frustration and bias.

We are at low levels (1-4) and the party faces with bosses (whom I consider the named NPCs at the end of each dungeon in the AP) who are usually PL+1. They had two separate encounters with PL+2 enemies at level 2, namely, an Owlbear, and a Cursed Guardian.

The party's composition besides GIB is a flurry ranger, a battlemage wizard, a warpriest cleric and a sorcerer (I forget which bloodline, but it's a healing one). I do adjust XP budget for 5-PC party.

My main lie is that the boss kills usually happened in one turn, not in one hit, and included the GIB being in Bless aura, and sometimes with Runic Weapon too. And it always included at least one of those hits being a crit.

The first defeated boss was a level 2 melee martial one (PL+1, AC 18, 48 HP). Sudden Charge with nat20 Strike, and then a hit with ordinary Strike.

On level 2 there was a level 2 melee martial with ranged minions (PL+0, AC 17, HP 32).

The latest one was a level 3 mounted mitflit chief NPC (level 3 after Elite adjustment, PL+0, AC 20, HP 50), and it was a nat20 with exactly 50 damage.

Currently at level 3 his attack bonus is +10 after Bless, Runic Weapon and Clumsy 1, with damage 2d12+10.

I use trips, difficult terrain and Reflex-based hazards to slow him down. And also more low-level minions as meat shields, because buffing the boss to PL+2 or PL+3 becomes an issue for the rest of the group (namely, the sorcerer with 18 max HP at level 2 got critted by a level 4 Cursed Guardian for exactly 36 damage). One of the latest encounters had six simplified tripping snares (Reflex DC 19, fall prone on a failure), but they all rolled high that night.


r/Pathfinder2e • • Dec 14 '23

Discussion MCDM's "no attack rolls"-philosophy is misguided, and PF2e proves it

0 Upvotes

So, as many of you know, MCDM is currently crowdfunding their new RPG (name pending). I have zero doubt that the game will rock - they're the closest the RPG industry has to a spec ops team, and their latest outings (Flee, Mortals!, The Talent, The Illrigger) have all been peerless.

However, there is one core philosophy to their new RPG that doesn't quite sit right with me - the notion that attack rolls are superfluous. Matt Colville has mentioned the idea that attack rolls are a relic of wargames of yore, but whereas in a wargame you may roll a dozen attacks, one for every model, modern TTRPGs only have you roll one or two attacks per turn. Thus, missed attacks feel bad, and we should strive to make every attack impactful. The MCDM RPG aims to fix this by only having damage rolls - every attack has some impact.

I've seen this sentiment since the D&D Next playtest, where the designers said that, in order for actions to feel satisfying, characters should succeed about 60% of the time, and constructed 5e's math around that assumption. I disagree with it; it sounds like pop-psychology to me, and results in very deterministic combat scenarios. Derik from KoLC had a neat analogy for it - hit points are a clock. When that clock ticks down too predictably, the tension curve of combat encounters tends to be a downward slope. I believe this is why 5e encounters feel sloggy or have long mop-up phases.

Let's see how PF2e does it better:

When PF2e characters find themselves in a position to reliably hit an enemy, that enemy will probably go down in 2-3 good hits, or 1-2 crits - combat tends to resolve quite quickly from then on. The challenge lies in getting into the position of hitting reliably.

In my experience, PF2e combats tend to follow a pattern - at the end of the first round, the party generally hasn't accomplished much; they have weapons to draw, prey to hunt, courage to inspire, rages to enter, and places to move to, but the few attacks they do get throw this round tend to bounce off in a worrying way. A sliver of panic is setting in. They're encountering resistances, strong saves, etc. Meanwhile, enemies have no trouble applying pressure due to their higher stats.

Only in round 2 do things start to shift - Recall Knowledges succeed, weaknesses are revealed, buffs and debuffs start landing in order to set up the next round of attacks, etc. The players have solved the combat puzzle - they just need to coordinate on the execution, and now they need to do this while spinning a few more plates (at this point, someone is probably down or dangerously low, so they need to think about defense/healing as well). This results in rising tension over the course of the encounter.

Now, for a more extreme example (and I'm cognizant this doesn't play well to modern audiences - simulationist games aren't in vogue any more), let's look at GURPS. The average hit chance in GURPS is around 25%, because the attacker needs to succeed on their attack roll and the defender needs to fail on their defense roll. However, even one good hit can cause someone to go down, and the combatants have plenty of ways to mess with each other's attacks and defenses. Some of the most nail-biting RPG combats I've ever seen consisted of nothing but whiffs for 5-6 rounds, as the fighters jockeyed for positioning, tested each other's guards, set up Ripostes and Counterattacks to try and get the upper hand, before a single well-placed stab took home the prize.

In light of those examples, I'm just not convinced that whiffing is as big of a problem as MCDM makes it out to be. Miss chance is a tactical riddle - you're meant to solve it using the tools the game gives you. I find it misguided, and a tiny bit patronizing, to claim that players would rather consistently deal consolation-prize-amounts of damage every turn.

I have confidence that the MCDM team will find other ways to make their game tactical, but this specific attitude is somewhat worrying to me.


r/Pathfinder2e • • Feb 19 '26

Promotion PSA: Grab 26 Pathfinder 2E book and supplements for just $14.99 - save 10% with our exclusive code!

5 Upvotes

Hey everyone, thank you to the mods for giving us the green light for this!

We're delighted to present our Introduction to Pathfinder 2E RPG Book Bundle, available now on our site!

We've built a collection of 26 adventure books, core supplements, and more across three tiers for your perusal. Tier 1 is a great starting point for beginners, including the Beginner's Box, GM Screen, and an adventure book for just $1, whilst Tier 2 and Tier 3 include more adventure books and supplements to enhance your Pathfinder games.

Oh, and we have an exclusive discount for members of r/Pathfinder2e, so you can also get 10% off if you use the code "REDFV10 " at the checkout.

Interested? You can take a look at the bundle ▶ HERE

Thank you, and we hope you have a great day!


r/Pathfinder2e • • Feb 23 '24

Discussion Wouldn't It be cool if more classes were like the kineticist?

6 Upvotes

Like, i think the vancian system sucks and that the best way to evolve would be focus points+at Will stuff like the kineticist has.

The remastered already buffed focus points and medicine in general takes away the use of hp as a resource (since, by level 4, you'll be full health at the beginning of every fight if no problems concur); martials, unlike 5e, have no long rest stuff and "short rests" are refocus or medicine checks (so, half an hour to an hour at worse).

So, the kineticist Is Dope and everyone liked It, we already have a ton of traditional casters, why not more stuff like the kineticist

PS: It Is interesting how the upvotes on this post worked tho, they went up then down then up a Lil then down again


r/Pathfinder2e • • Apr 04 '22

Discussion Pathfinder ruins roleplaying.

5 Upvotes

After tonight’s game (Abomination Vaults) we had a bit of a discussion about how the game is going. The players are all new to pathfinder and are only level 2 (almost 3). They all seem to be enjoying the game and are getting better at the more tactical cooperative play that Pathfinder encourages.

However one comment that caught me off guard was that the players feel more restricted in roleplaying their character because “Rather than doing what I think my character would do, I do what is most tactical advantageous.”

Another player commented that “It feels more like being a general controlling a soldier than playing as the character.”

I feel that these comments are fairly accurate, but hadn’t thought of it that way as I generally always experience the game that way being the DM.

They did say that they were enjoying the game and learning a new system so this isn’t a criticism. Also sorry for the title, it was just so catchy, I couldn’t resist 🙂

===update===

Thanks for all the feedback, this post had a lot more responses than I expected so I gave up on responding to individual posts as it was starting to get repetitive. I read everything and got quite a bit out of the discussion.

A couple of points of clarification.

I actually like Pathfinder and am enjoying the experience of DMing Abomination Vaults. Although it has been challenging running a new system with new players.

I asked my players if they wanted me to adjust the difficulty level and they said that they would prefer me to run it as written. So I think they are also enjoying the game even if they are finding it challenging.

This post wasn’t meant meant to be critical of Pathfinder or the AP. I just thought it was interesting the way the mechanics seemed to be effecting role play.


r/Pathfinder2e • • Dec 17 '24

Discussion What’s the wizard’s point now?

2 Upvotes

So with the rise of of the remastered imperial sorcerer and the necromancer (and online whispers of people wanting more classes, devoted to one school of magic, like a battle mage or an illusionist), what is the point of the wizard? I know people talk about a wizard’s versatility but I feel like that becomes an excuse. Like why would I ever play a wizard or a witch, excluding flavor.


r/Pathfinder2e • • Dec 24 '23

Discussion In your opinion, Is this sub (or the community for that matter) an Echo Chamber?

5 Upvotes

Been in the community for a while and noticed that basically every discussion in this subreddit boils down to a "faction" war where no One listens the point of the other One

Class discussion It's basically non exhistent, builds are Just the same thing over and over (in my opinion, due to how the system works) and the few actual alive posts are all about praising paizo.


r/Pathfinder2e • • Mar 20 '24

Discussion Barbarian, level 11, so squishy

3 Upvotes

EDIT TWO:

Thanks for the comments guys. And all the down votes. Rules Lawyer got a ton Afaik, so I'm in good company. :-)

First takeaway is that default Amiri build sucks. I'm going to rebuild her with double slice and Bastion for double shield block. Need to juggle the dedications. Also heavy armour feat. Will roughly double her durability vs weapon attacks, with minimal impact on her dpr. It might even increase. I think she'll lose every barbarian feat to do it, but no great loss.

Also, looking to post some dpr and tanking calcs. I'll do level 1 first, and expand to include monk with tower shield plus Drake mutagen and other fun stuff.

Edit 3. Some good comments. Firstly, deny advantage helps her a lot here, reducing gap to 3 ac.

Also, is only 35% extra damage, not the usual 50%. I'd expect for +3ac difference as the monsters are spanking her on 3+, making it further away from the middle of the expected to hit ranges.

The 83% only going to be vs single monsters hitting fighter on 10+, her on 5+.* *I'll check precise % later.


MAIN POST.

Running Kingmaker and party is level 11.

Amiri has joined the party for her companion quest.

She sees a bunch of undead and runs in. And gets wrecked...

195hp, plus 15 temp, so 210 hp.

She ended up taking roughly 170 damage in a round.

First thing. I forgot about deny advantage. I'll downgrade 2 crits to hits. Gives her back roughly 30hp. So she's gone from 210 to 70hp in a round. Vs 4 level 10 mooks.

Guess barbarian shouldn't charge in. Even though that's how Amiri is described as acting.

Fine. She's only ac 27 after all.

Looking at fighter ac. 32.

32.

5 higher ac. Wtaf?

Simple. Fighter gets armour expert 2 levels before barb. Also, heavy vs medium armour. No Rage. No clumsy.

That's roughly 83% more incoming damage taken by the barb vs the fighter.

What about raging resistance? Enemies slashing. It ain't doing jack.

Also, fighters have slash resist 3, adding insult to injury. Afaik, barbs never get armour spec.

Wow, just wow. Blown away at the ac difference between 2 martials of the same level.

Edit, thanks for the info on meaning of circa. I've edited my post. :-)


r/Pathfinder2e • • Nov 19 '23

Table Talk Why isn't Free Archetype a core rule?

1 Upvotes

With the insane level of popularity of FA in PF2 I started to wonder why this rule was not a core mechanic of PF2. This wasn't even changed in the remaster. There doesn't feel like much of an impact on how this impacts the flow or power of the game, and players build characters based on the assumption that FA will be allowed.

So, in the long run, just a really simple question. Why isn't FA considered a core mechanic instead of an optional one?

EDIT: Just having a thought on this particularly popular rule this morning, and felt like trying to spark a conversation. However, I feel like I may have instead slaughtered a pig in a public square. I would happily drop this one if people just don't want to talk about it.

EDIT 2: Thank you to any that got involved in this conversation. I really appreciate, and enjoyed, the various responses. They were all so well thought out and give me a lot to consider.


r/Pathfinder2e • • Jul 25 '24

Discussion Is the Tailwind (Longstrider) Wand Banworthy?

4 Upvotes

In my nearly complete 1st to 11th level campaign, my players have elected to all buy 2nd rank Wands of Tailwind. For those not in the know, here is what a 2nd rank Wand of Tailwind does:

  • As a 2nd rank wand, it costs you 160gp, which is very likely pocket money for a PC of 5th+ level

  • When cast at second rank, Tailwind gives the caster a +10 status bonus to speed for 8 hours

  • The target MUST be self

  • Per the rules of wand spellcasting, you must have either Primal or Arcane casting to use a Tailwind Wand. So you will either have to take a multiclass feat in a spellcasting class of one of these traditions, or you must use Trick Magic Item to use the wand

So for a minimal investment in gold and (maybe) a minimal investment in feats/skills, EVERY SINGLE CHARACTER IN YOUR PARTY can get a +10 status bonus to their speeds for the majority of the adventuring day. Now I wouldn't normally mind this, but it kind of steps on the toes of class features and feats from the Barbarian, Monk, Ranger, Scout Dedication, and many others where you can get either a permanent or temporary status bonus to your speed or bestow a speed bonus to an ally.

I have my issues with a select number of spells/feats maybe being a little too powerful (looking at you Dirge of Doom and Synesthesia), but the fact that this single 160gp common magic item can completely invalidate a surprising number of class/feat choices is where I am inclined to take action.

So this brings me to my question. Would you:

  • Ban the spell completely?

  • Ban just the wand?

  • Let the Tailwind bonuses stack with class features/feats that give status bonuses to speed?

  • Or do nothing at all?


r/Pathfinder2e • • Nov 21 '24

Discussion It's me or Class Archetypes needs some Playtesting?

2 Upvotes

So after reading the new class archetypes I got say they didn't leave a good impression on me, though they are creative I see a lot of problems with then like the Vindicator tripping himself because he doesn't have enough actions, Bloodrager missing most of his spell attacks through his carrier to say at least and Battle Herald core feature is 1° levels Ranks Spells that do not heighten.

I know Paizo once said that they wouldn't release a play test for class archetypes because otherwise they would launch to feel and it would take a lot of time, but after seeing the results... I think they should... they look half baked to say at least and to niche.


r/Pathfinder2e • • May 08 '25

Discussion For PF3e, maybe we're ready to no longer have a Martial/Caster role divide?

0 Upvotes

I know 3e is going to be a long way still, and PF2e still has a lot to offer in the future, this is just some speculation for a theoretical Pathfinder 3rd Edition whenever that comes out.

In a lot of other modern TTRPGs that I've played, everyone can be as much martial or caster as they want, since they use smaller, more specific 'classes' rather than the big, broad class system that RPGs were known for (in PF2e's case, Fighter, Wizard, Rogue, Cleric, etc.). Things like Lancer, Gubat Banwa, Fabula Ultima, with their archetypes that function more like mini-classes. With each having a specific mechanical (and narrative) identity, but without a big overarching gameplay element like spell slots.

Spellslots

Part of the question is 'are we ready to leave daily spell slots behind?' That seems wild as a question, spell slots could be considered a part of Pathfinder's identity, and D&D too, which PF1e was designed and inspired off of their 3.5e, but even as we look at the more recent and incoming classes for PF2e, Paizo seems to be leaning more to alternative resource usage. Exemplar, Kineticist, Commander, Runesmith. Even the incoming caster, Necromancer has an alternate resource to slots, and focus points with their in-combat Thrall count. Animist is pretty much the only exception where it plays much more like a caster in the past with daily spell slots and focus spells.

If the rumors were true that Paizo only included Vancian prep and spontaneous casting into PF2e for legacy purposes, then they may have already had the idea to ditch daily spells a while ago. Potentially why they gave casters Focus Points so they'd have a semi-renewable encounter-based resource rather than needing to fully rely on only daily spells or cantrips when running out.

To be clear, I'm not saying spells as a whole would be deleted, just their 1/day component, then rebalanced for their new resource cost.

Classes

Another question is 'are we ready to leave classes behind for something more flexible?' While the previous question, I'm personally ready to leave daily resources behind in favor of /encounter, /round, action-based resources, I'm a lot less so for the big overarching classes that we have like Wizards and Fighters. The games I used as examples above all use smaller templates and chassis, but are very easy to mix-n-match. Lancer has mechs that you can load up with any weapon or system from other mech licenses, Gubat Banwa has disciplines where you can poach techniques and moves from other disciplines, Fabula Ultima has classes, but your character cannot even start off with only a single class. All of them have restrictions to things you can and can't take, a Lancer mech can't take the traits of another Lancer mech, a Gubat Banwa discipline also each have individual traits, and you can only have the traits from one discipline that you've chosen.

While every mech, discipline, and class has its own identity, none of them have the umbrella mechanic that's only supposed to go to one side of the class categories, they can all take from each other. But that's how it works there, I don't think I or we would want that to be adapted for Pathfinder. Fighter is its own broad identity, that can branch from that starting point, rather than starting with the smaller branches and adding up things to it.

Imagine taking Fighter and only getting accurate weapons, and one other feature, while you have to build it out from there with other abilities and features as you level up. I don't know if it'd work for Pathfinder and still feel like Pathfinder. It would be interesting but it would be pretty far from PF2e and PF1e at that point.

Annother interesting way the devs could take it is if broader classes still exist in the same way, but they can all take from a pool of feats and features, spells included. But if only the Wizard archetype could take the spells from that pool, then we're back to having a martial/caster divide. So the class systems might have to also get an overhaul too anyway.

--

That's if they'd even try to get rid of the martial/caster role categories, they're a team of people, and designers that have done this way longer, so maybe they can actually make an overhauled system that keeps the divide, but makes both categories undebatably feel good to play, at least relatively.

Because no matter how balanced or weak you think martials or casters are in the current edition (mostly casters), you can't deny that you continue to get into arguments and debates with others that think they're stronger or weaker than you do.


r/Pathfinder2e • • Jul 21 '23

Discussion Kineticist "Timber Sentinel" feat is in my opinion Overpowered and will affect balance of the game.

0 Upvotes

Feat: https://imgur.com/2MemxQa

So this Level 1 (!) feat "Timber Sentinel" allows you to summon Protector Tree spell that automatically scales to half your level (so as your normal spell slots!) and you can use it INFINITE amount of times. Not only it means you get basically infinite amount of highest level spell slots (even if just for that one, very very good primal spell), but it also means that you can literally keep spamming frontline with Protector Trees and they provide pretty much infinite amount of damage reduction. One tree dies- summon next one. No cost. There are also world-building implications here as Kin with this feat can just make a whole forest by himself in couple of weeks, making infinite amount of trees. A Druid of level 10 can only summon 3x 5th level Protector Trees IF he will put it on all his 5th level slot. Any character that archetype into Kin and take his level 1 feat can do it INFINITE amount of times. This steps hard on toes of primal casters too. It's one of their better spells and now level 1 feat can spam it for free with autoscale!

The biggest impact is that every single class can archetype just for it. All martials/tanks will love it. At level 7 that's 40 free hit Points to aborb, no cost, no cooldown, nothing. A Hasted martial upfront can just use 2 actions for new tree, 2 actions for two Strikes and tree will just eat damage for him. And in next turn Tree will combine with martial Raise Shield/Block, self-heals, high AC, WoB/LoH etc. All casters can just spam new protector trees next to frontline without touching their precious slots for suppport. Someone moved? So what? Summon new Tree. Trees everywhere! Free 80 HP per Tree at level 15? Who will say no? It doesn't even cost Focus Points! It's has no limits, none. And martials have quite a lot of adjecent grids around them! Imagine Large or Huge Character. That's a lot of adjecent grids for Trees!

Also think about Monk with Kineticist, Protector Tree->Flurry.

Everyone can take archetype just for that and at start of combat summon his own Protector Tree and then whole combat map is full of Trees that can provide pretty much infinite damage reduction. Sure, maybe not optimal to do it all in turn 1, but the potentical and low cost, high reward is here. It's infinite spell.

I think this one slipped through the balancing pass. As dirty optimizer I will take hard advantage of that feat, but that also means, I view it as Overpowered feat.

This needs hard cooldown, like 1/hour, maybe probably something else as infinite highest spell slot spell for free is just too strong. It will still be one of best things for everyone in party to dip in. Paizo needs to look at this one, fast.


r/Pathfinder2e • • Nov 10 '22

Discussion Pathfinder representation, All inclusive or a bit one sided?

5 Upvotes

I've been thinking about making a post like this for quite some time. As a long-time player of Pathfinder, the inclusive nature of the game has always been something I've not only enjoyed but been proud to express. Pathfinder is a game that allows someone to not only play anyone you want, but to see people like you as characters in the stories and adventures you’re a part of. Except if you’re gay. How many main characters in Pathfinder (iconics, inner sea gods, primary NPCs in Adventure Paths) are gay? Specifically homosexual male? I can't think of any. No inner sea god, no iconic, and very few characters in main line Adventure Paths. On the flip side, I can think of many lesbian characters and relationships. Three Inner Sea gods (Sheyln, Sarenrae, and Desna), two iconics, and many characters from the many AP's (Irabeth & Anevia being probably the most well-known and topical currently).

This is not to say that inclusion and representing these groups is a bad thing- of course it's not. I love the relation Kyra & Merisiel have, as well as all of the other LGBTQIA+ characters in Pathfinder but the one-sided nature of this representation is a bit strange. Why does this specific group have such a disproportionate presence? It feels at best lazy and a bit strange, at worst objectifying. My concern is two-fold; that in the best of cases the lack of prominent gay characters and relationships is disappointing to see in a game I've always been happy to call inclusive, and in the worst that this pattern shows a continuation of a long-standing trope in media, that lesbian relationships are more "acceptable" than gay ones. This notion is categorically and factually untrue, but it is present due to the way that sexual minorities exist in contrast to the predominate heterosexual population. This pattern reinforces this notion even if it’s unintentional- if this is not the case this discrepancy in representation, not only for gay relationships, but for all other sexual minorities deserves some thought and examination.

To be clear, I am not saying that we should limit lesbian representation and make more gay/bisexual characters. Representation is not a zero-sum game, nor is it a quota. Characters depicting marginalized peoples should be neither curtailed as to not have "too many", nor be forced to meet some shallow quota. I want Pathfinder to be a game where any person, no matter who they are, can feel included and see people like them in their favorite stories. Right now, it's hard to say that’s true.

Addendum: This post focuses on gay (homosexual male) representation mostly. This is not to say this pattern is not also seen for many other sexual minorities. Primarily, I chose to focus on this group simply because I'm a part of it, and due to that it was a pattern I noticed as I played Pathfinder, between playing through Adventure Paths, reading about the iconics, and reading through the Lost Omens books and many splat books of 1e. I will say, however, that at least in those cases we have an iconic that belongs to those groups. Merisiel is bisexual and the shaman iconic from 1e is transgender, as well as the new thaumaturge iconic being non-binary. I hope we can get a canonically gay iconic soon. It seems very odd that we haven’t had one in the 10+ years of Paizo publishing.

Edit: A lot of comments are posts bring examples and of "this gay char here check them out" I really appreciate it and seeing these examples is great but I just wanted to clarify. The post was not about doing a numbers game, saying oh there's x many lesbian characters and y many gay characters this is unfair. Its about a general trend not just in pathfinder but in media overall I just wanted to bring some attention too. I love seeing more and more examples it helps to show more about people and groups I didn't know about! But the trend with major characters, people everyone who plays an AP, reads the lost omen guides or reads about an iconic their playing will see its a bit upsetting so see a lack of rep in places like that.


r/Pathfinder2e • • Aug 13 '23

Discussion Everytime I miss a spellstrike...

0 Upvotes

Everytime I miss a spellstrike I'm like:

"Good thing I have a martial accuracy and runes, so I only have 4 spell slots, have an action tax to recharge my damage source, don't get to do half damage on a miss unless I take a very specific level 2 feat which isn't as good in most situations. Wish regular casters could have same accuracy but sacrifice nothing for it, it for sure won't make my class redundant."

My thoughts every time, fr.

Edit: I LOVE magus, I know it's a strong class. This post is more of a sarcasm toward guys who want to simply give runes to regular casters, taking nothing in return while magus gave a lot for his capabilities.


r/Pathfinder2e • • Jul 13 '23

Discussion Tuesday shutdowns seem petty.

88 Upvotes

Genuine question:

Do people see these Tuesday blackouts as helpful or meaningful in any regard? I'm not trying to be rude or insensitive, but I'm not really seeing a benefit to them outside of an ego boost to the sub moderation. I understand how they came about, and the turmoil surrounding the reddit debacle; but they feel hollow and token considering the sub comes back the other 6 days a week. If anything it's only hurting the users looking for historical information or rule clarifications on their Tuesday games (admittedly I'm one of those people, so I have a biased impression).

I'd like to hear other people's opinions (constructive only please).


r/Pathfinder2e • • Oct 20 '24

Discussion Several Mythic Feats, as well as every single Mythic Calling, are either nigh useless or trap options

20 Upvotes

Every single mythic character gets the ability Rewrite Fate, which allows you to (as a free action) reroll a check by spending a Mythic Point and rolling it a second time at mythic proficiency. It's basically a souped up Hero Points since Mythic Points replace Hero Points. It's a really cool and awesome ability, and totally not the problem here, but its existence means that a great many mythic feats, as well as one of the main features of every single Mythic Calling, are nearly entirely useless and redundant.

Every single Mythic Calling has three parts: Its edicts & anathema, its way to restore Mythic Points, and its ability to let you roll a skill check at mythic proficiency using Mythic Points. The Artisan's Calling, for example, lets you spend a Mythic Point to roll a Craft or Repair check at mythic proficiency. The Acrobat's Calling lets you do the same with Balance, Maneuver in Flight, Tumble Through, and Long Jump. Every single Mythic Calling has a set of skill checks it lets you spend a Mythic Point on to roll at mythic proficiency. Cool, right?

And a bunch of the lower level mythic feats are stuff like "Arms that Cut the Waves", which lets you spend a Mythic Point to attempt a Swim check at mythic proficiency, or "Hands that Unweave Disaster", which lets you do the same to Grab a Ledge or Disable a Device, or "Ears that Hear the Truth" for Sense Motive and rolling Perception for Initiative. Also all really cool, right?

Not really. See, why would you ever spend a Mythic Point to roll a single time at mythic proficiency when you could roll normally and if you fail use Rewrite Fate to roll again at mythic proficiency anyways? You wouldn't. It’s a trap to spend a Mythic Point to roll a single time at mythic when you could instead spend that same point to roll normally and with mythic? Those feats/callings, or parts of those feats/callings for those that have other effects as well, are just a waste of text that encourage you to use your Mythic Points in almost an objectively worse way than just using the automatic feature you get just for existing as a mythic character. By my estimation, along with all 11 Mythic Callings, about 11 Mythic feats and 1 Mythic spell are in some way, shape, or form affected by this.

That said, there are two edge cases to not using Rewrite Fate: The first is that like using a Hero Point, Rewrite Fate has the fortune trait and as such can’t be used with anything with the fortune trait that affects skill checks. However, fortune on skill checks is a surprisingly rare effect and usually locked behind archetypes, consumable talismans, or focus spells. The other edge case is that you bypass all proficiency requirements when using mythic proficiency, allowing you to Treat Wounds at a higher DC or Disable a Device you require a certain proficiency for. However, that is once again a fairly rare scenario and only applies to a select few skills and certainly does not cover the entire gamut like Swim, Grab a Ledge, Tumble Through, Recall Knowledge, and more.

To re-iterate, I think the problem isn’t Rewrite fate, it’s a wonderful ability and a natural upgrade of the hero point (even if you lose the ability to reroll attack rolls). The problem is all these skills that are made redundant by Rewrite Fate, and in my opinion rather need a complete rework to function the way I imagine they are supposed to.


r/Pathfinder2e • • May 03 '22

Discussion Anyone Else Think This Sub Is Insanely Toxic To 5E?

0 Upvotes

Whenever anyone mentions 5E on this sub, people act like it's the worst thing on the planet, and that it's players are, to quote someone from the "What're Your Homebrew Rules to Make 5E Crunchier" post, "The unclean masses who haven't been made aware of the glory of the glorious light that is PF2". I have seen people actively deny that PF2 is more complex and dense than 5E just to be able to say "It's just as simple, and pretty much objectively better".