r/PBtA • u/straight_out_lie • 1d ago
First session of Masks down.
Earlier this week I ran Masks for my group. This is everyone's, including myself, first foray into PBTA. Everyone has 10-20 years of experience in various other systems (DnD likes, Delta Green, etc), so it felt like there were some growing pains. Despite that, I would say the session went rather smoothly, I'm just looking for more specific advice on how to improve.
* There were a few times the players wanted to do a simultaneous attack on the villain, which I wasn't exactly sure how to run. I could resolve Directly Engage a Threat individually for each player, or they could use team pool to assist each other.
* The Villain had a macguffin he was trying to steal, and the delinquent wanted to quickly teleport behind him, snatch, and teleport out of him. I said to roll Directly Engage a Threat, which they very briefly argued it would be instant and he wouldn't get a chance to react, but we went with the move anyway which I think was the correct way to play it out. (The player rolled a miss and the villain predicted when and where they were going to teleport catching them out). However this leads me to wonder when and when not to use the move. Obviously some weaker antagonists can be dismantled with little effort, but I suppose some stronger villains could be so powerful that they can't be directly engaged without some kind of advantage.
* I was having a tough time thinking of what GM Moves to use when the players rolled misses on Assess the Situation. The first time a player did it I said they were overwhelmed and gave them a condition, but more misses I used things like having the villain taunt them from where he was hiding, reveal some trapped civilians, stuff that helped move the scene forward which I think is really required at a time the players are looking for things to do
* The villain set off poison gas on his belt, putting two players in danger as they were right next to him. I asked the two players how they respond, when a third player, The Brain in power armour, said he wants to dive in and helpfully throw his team mates out of danger, which seemed like a perfect opportunity for Defend which I didn't think of. I suppose I should be more open ended when asking what the players want to do.
We had to wrap up on a cliffhanger as we were running overtime, but next session right after the villain fight wraps up I want to focus on some more personal relations, and will be leading into a corruption plot line. Hoping all goes well!