This might be a bit of a weird post, it would probably make more sense as a blog post or reviews. But since I'm more of a redditor than a content creator I figured I'd write it here. Also, I don't spend as much time reading reviews and first impressions as much as I should so my apologies if I'm repeating stuff that have been said too often already. In any cases, feel free to tell me how I'm wrong, tell me how I'm right, tell me which games made you feel similar things, which other games I should avoid because of similarities, etc. . I'm not sure what the point of this post is exactly so comment with anything that's on your mind I guess.
I have a huge issue with both Blades in the Dark and Rhapsody of Blood that makes both of them completely unenjoyable for me. And that issue, I believe, is not a question of having had bad MCs or a question of perspective, I believe that issue is downright a fact and it just happens that it doesn't align with what I'm looking for in RPGs or specifically PbtAs. If you're afraid that my point of view might reveal something you'll never be able to unsee and you'll never be able to enjoy those games again, you should stop reading. I know how arrogant this seems, but I don't believe anyone will ba able to debate me on said issue, feel free to try but the hard truth I'm about to drop is , as far as I'm concerned, COLD HARD FACTSTM . You can say the issue doesn't bother you of course and that the games never set to not have that issue, but good luck convincing me that this issue doesn't exist. And while I didn't research this nor can I speak from experience, I would expect what I'm about to say to also apply to Forged in the Dark games, other Worlds of Legacy hacks and Legacy:Life Among the Ruins so if you feel I might tarnish your enjoyment of those too, stop now, last warning.
Those games are not about playing through a story and telling it collectively. Those games are about playing through and telling a very focused part of a bigger story.
Let's take Blades first. Blades is played in two-phases, the heist and the down-time between heists. I'm not going to talk against the Heist part, it does an incredible job of recreating heist tropes and the feeling you get from heist movies. However, when it comes to the down time, this isn't an RPG or storytelling game anymore, it's just some kind of boardgame that serves as a prompt for the next heist.
In storytelling, writers will often be told to "show, don't tell" and I think this could be translated to "play through, don't tell" when it comes to RPGs. I don't think "telling" is inherently bad but in the case of Blades it leaves a very bad taste in my mouth. Think of the movies that end with a freeze frame of every main character and then text or narration would tell you how the following years affected them. The downtime part of BitD feels like that to me. You do a heist, freeze frame and get a little epilogue "The 4th street gang would use that money on cheap booze and gambling. They also used the prestige to intimidate local thugs and extend their control all the way to the 6th street. Jerry bought a wagon with his share. But little did they know their score hurt the Red Sashes in a big way, Bob's brother was found beaten and left for dead in a garbage can next to their hide-out". As an epilogue to a movie or as a closing statement for the end of a campaign it wouldn't bother me, but in the context that there's another session/episode coming up it infuriates me. It feels like I'm binging a show on netflix but skipping the last 10 minutes of every episode.
Even from the very start, before the very first heist, it's already a bit of an issue. When creating your gang, it's decided that to cut out your little corner of the big pie you stepped on someone else's toes. One of the gang is chosen and you have to decide if you paid a coin for the damages or didn't pay a coin and pissed them off. It's very abstracted. I remember me and my friends being real angry at the Red Sashes because they are pieces of shit and it was out of the question we would pay their price. Problem is, how did they ask for that cash? Did they even ask for it? Who our gang could have been very different depending on how it happened. If we heard that the Red Sashes weren't too happy and we just didn't care enough to get in touch, it's pretty neutral. If they had sent a high ranking member to congratulate us on making it into the big leagues but kindly asked for payment to smooth things out and keep future collaborations possible... but we decided to spit in their face, beat 'em up and throw them in front of a Red Sashes hang out... then we're pretty much jerks. If they sent a handful of goons to trash our hideout and intimidate us... they'd be the jerk. And not knowing doesn't stop the game from progressing, the game is perfectly fine with leaving that as an undefined part of the story.
I've discussed it with friends and I've heard the argument that the game doesn't stop the player from roleplaying the downtime. And it is true, but the game doesn't really support it. It's a bunch of multiple choice questions, you roll some dice and get information on how the gang situation changes in the city. The game doesn't tell you not to roleplay that part, or not to flesh it out, but it is perfectly happy to let you roll dice, not flesh out anything and then move on. And this is something that can happens in traditional RPGs quite easily. My gripe with DnD is that too often I've spent a few sessions in a campaign and then realized no story had happened. We killed some baddies, got some treasures, saved some folk but it was all very shallow and hardly worth remembering. And what I like about PbtAs is that in a single evening you can create a few good scenes and moments worth telling and remembering, and the games will push players towards that. I'm hesitant to play traditional RPGs because players en GMs are left to their own devices, free to just push numbers around without story ever emerging because there is no guidance. And I like PbtAs because there is guidance helping us not waste our time, and then I realize 25% of Blades in the Dark is exactly that.
My gripe with Rhapsody of Blood is almost the same but a bit different. If you've played World Wide Wrestling or Monster of the Week (and probably most PbtAs), the character relation questions when first creating them can have a bit of a similar feel. You're not playing through that part of the story, you're telling it. This however doesn't bother me because it gives you a great start to interact with the other players in the kind of way you want to right away. Instead of having a few awkward sessions where the characters are trying to find ways to relate to one another and build tension, you skip that and it's done. To use a TV show analogy, you start on season 2 of the show basically. And it's a bit of a shame never playing through those events, but the payoff of is more than worth it.
(Before going on, a basic idea of what Rhapsody is might help you. It's basically the Castlevania series of video game adapted to PbtA, not a single game but the series with sequels and all. Each player plays a bloodline/secret organization and every generation an evil mystical place (could be a castle, could be an island, could be a mansion with accompanying forest, etc.) manifest itself with its inhabitants to accomplish a dark and evil ritual. Each players plays a representative of their bloodline and they venture together into this "dungeon". When they finish the dungeon(either by winning or losing) after a few session, or even a single one, the characters are retired, the bloodlines may advances and new characters are generated).
Every time you generate new characters for a new generation in Rhapsody, you go through that kind of process. You define the time skip, how bloodlines have acted towards each others, how the characters know one another from before evil manifested itself. Two players might decide their character grew up together, grew apart because of a disagreement and then during the dungeon crawl they'll explore how they deal with this forced reunion. Two other players might decide one of them has weird dreams and they spent the last five years trying to understand them, and now that they are in the dungeon they can start to use those dreams for guidance. The game really encourages the players to interact between themselves during the dungeon crawl and explore those relationships and the resulting dungeon crawl is very different from a regular DnD dungeon crawl. But the focus of the game is entirely based on the dungeon crawl.
And some of you might say that all that stuff between generation is also the focus of the game and to that I'll say that it's not really because it's not playing. It's a very nice writing tool for building intertwined backgrounds. It can be fun to write a common history with other people with each person having a character to focus on, but it's background writing. Some people love writing 20 pages of background for a character in an RPG, and it can be fun, and for a long time I enjoyed that kind of activity. And doing is as a group can be great fun like two authors writing a novel together. But it is not "playing an RPG", it's collective storytelling, it's creative but it's not what I make time for and it's not what I expect from something called an RPG.
In short, it's not an RPG where you play through stories of evil coming back every generation with brave heroes rising up to the challenge even if it might look like it. It's an RPG about doing a dungeon crawl. That part where your character has to come to terms with having a destiny and responsability toward a cycle of evil coming back time after time... you might talk about it but you won't play it. That part where you have to come back and tell your ally's family that they didn't make it, never going to play through that either. Again and again you will vaguely define Act 1 of your character, play through the second act, maybe play throught the third act if they never come back from the dungeon but probably only define it with time skip mechanics. And a big difference with WWW and MotW is that the character creation questions feel like what happened is the same kind of things that will happen during play, you missed the first few episodes but play each episodes completely after that. Meanwhile, Rhapsody makes you not-play the beginning and end of each episode.
In short, I'm not saying those games are bad but I'm saying they are not about playing through a story or stories. They are exclusively focused on the action and climax of those stories. BitD is not a game about the criminal underbelly of a city, it's not The Godfather, it's a darn good heist sequence generator. And Rhapsody isn't a grand saga, it's an exceptional psychological dungeon crawler with intro and outro text-scrolls. They have huge gaps when it comes to playing the full scope of their genre, and I would enjoy them if they each had 20 extra moves to play through the parts between the action sequences. Or if someone built companion games, let's call them Shady Meetings in the Dark meant to flesh out the politics portion of BitD, and Overture and Curtain Call of a Rhapsody.
BUT. THEY. DON'T. and I don't enjoy them and I'm pissed at them, pissed at the situation and pissed at myself. Because they are good games, but I can only see them as incomplete. And I needed to rant about it because I can't be the only one seeing it this way and maybe someone can tell me I'm not crazy.