r/Outlander • • 2d ago

Prequel Two Blood of My Blood S2E9 - Another Man’s Shadow

16 Upvotes

Colum experiences a tragedy, and Maura uses the opportunity to encourage Dougal to lead. Murtagh defends Grace from harm, with terrible ramifications for their relationship. Henry watches as a new and dangerous romance unfolds.

Written by Diana Gabaldon. Directed by Emer Conroy.

If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.

You’re free to mention:

  • all of the show canon (seasons 1-8 of Outlander)

  • any bits from the books that pertain to the characters from the prequel.

Bear in mind that we might have newcomers here so keep the talk about the characters’ future fates to a minimum and don’t reveal big spoilers from the original show if you don’t have to. You can use spoiler tags to be extra careful.

Keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.

What did you think of the episode? Vote in the poll above.

327 votes, 4d left
I loved it
I mostly liked it
It was OK
It disappointed me
I didn’t like it

r/Outlander • • 3h ago

Spoilers All Outlander in Concert: I wish I could go again! Spoiler

15 Upvotes

I saw the performance in San Diego and I'm kicking myself for not going again in Riverside or LA. If you have time for what's left, GO!


r/Outlander • • 3h ago

Spoilers All Plothole in the show Spoiler

0 Upvotes

How did Claire find Jamie's headstone in Scotland if they were in America at their time of death? Was that ever mentioned and I missed it?


r/Outlander • • 16h ago

Season One Is Outlander safe to watch on the living room TV? Is there any list of the nsfw scenes that I should fast forward. NSFW

0 Upvotes

Asking this ‘cause I came across the fact that this show has explicit scenes at some places.


r/Outlander • • 1d ago

Spoilers All BEST JAMIE SAYS GOODBYE SCENES Spoiler

10 Upvotes

Unlike Claire, whose most important goodbyes were to Jamie, I feel that Jamie had to say goodbye to a more varied crew. Here are my favorite goodbyes from Jamie:

5. Jamie says goodbye to Fergus right before the battle of Culloden. He gave Fergus a vital mission, and called him “mon fils”, believing that was the last time they would ever meet. Heart rending for Fergus and for me.

4. Jamie tells Lord John that they must sever relations. This was a complex scene, as both men struggled to adjust to the fact that they were on opposing sides of the looming Revolution. After their encounter, it was notable to see that Jamie had a strong visceral reaction to parting ways with his old friend (did not stop LJG later on from asking Claire to travel from Lallybroch to Philadelphia to operate on nephew Henry- quite an ask!)

3. Jamie saying his last words to his father at his graveside. Not a goodbye like the other goodbyes, but a cleansing moment for Jamie and a moment when everything in the universe is aligning just right for him—- not to last, however.

2. Jamie says goodbye to Murtaugh. Not only says goodbye but urges him to disappear, in order to escape Governor Tryon’s dragnet, and hopefully to avoid a pitched battle with the Regulators. I was not proud of Jamie in this sequence, as he released Murtaugh from his vow to protect Jamie, and asked him to go his way. That is to say, go AWAY. NOT Jamie’s proudest moment.

  1. What else? Jamie says goodbye to Claire at the stones. I’ve seen a focus on the “Lord, you gave me a rare woman…” line, but my favorite line from him came a bit later. After Claire says “I love you” he answers “And I you”. I found that line powerful in its simplicity and the contraction emphasized his depth of feeling

Y’all agree or have other thoughts ?


r/Outlander • • 1d ago

Spoilers All Time loop? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Okay finally finished my first watch through and... Huh? What? Que?

My original thought was just, I wish they had set up a big bad foe for season 8 other than fate, but I get it. Nature of the show and all. But still a through line bad guy would have been great in the place of the pontificating and proclamating and discussions of off screen conversations with children we didn't see

But the part, where Jamie is the man outside Claire's window, young Jamie not old Jamie. Huh

Yea they said if he died he would come back (ghost him) and check on her. So he..peeps on her younger version before they met instead of older her who would undoubtedly bw missing him

Or that doesn't matter cause he is brought back to life anyway so why in that brief moment of death would he go back to a version of her he didn't know

Except he did know and thats young him not the one that died and this isn't star wars where anikins ghost self is the version if him before Darth Vader (not so niche reference)..so one can presume and he set the whole chain of events off and played dumb the whole time and could pass through the stones and thata why he asked her if he wished she'd never found the flowers

Or maybe ghost him briefly visited a version of her he didn't know to set off a chain of events with the flowers that grew? To put Claire in a time loop so that she would always have to come through the stones

It's all so convoluted

My head hurts

Honestly asking for an explanation of something I am missing in the meaning of all of this


r/Outlander • • 1d ago

6 A Breath Of Snow And Ashes Question about Claire

11 Upvotes

Spoiler Ahead!

Hi all - long-time lurker, first-time poster. I am reading through the Outlander series for the first time and am currently on Breath of Snow and Ashes. I never finished the show (sorry! It didn't do it for me), so I don't know if this could be answered by someone only having watched the show.

Where I'm at in the book, Claire and Jamie were just taken from the Ridge over the death of Malva. Jamie asks Claire, "Have you never been tried before?" and Claire responds with "You know I haven't." Jamie proceeds to tell Claire about being tried and taken to Ardsmuir.

I'm 99% sure that in the show, there was a trial over Claire being a witch with Geillis. In the show, this is when Geillis unveils her mark of the beast/ smallpox scar to everyone. I remember the book and show differing at this point: in the book, the scar was something that Claire just noticed, not made into a dramatic flare for the crowd. However, I can't remember if Claire made it to trial in the book.

Can someone who remembers the details of book 1 help? My brain is confusing the show and the book, and it's driving me nuts that she made that comment haha!

Thank you!


r/Outlander • • 1d ago

Season Two First time watching thoughts and rant

13 Upvotes

I'm on season 2, episode 7. This has probably been said so many times before but I NEED to rant.

Jack Randall is literally the most evil character I have ever seen on screen, I hate him with a PASSION and I have never felt like this about any tv character ever, not even Jeoffrey from Game of Thrones. This man is pure disturbed evil and I can't WAIT for him to die!!!!! Like WHAT THE ACTUAL FUCK, I hated him enough after the ending of season 1 and I didn't think they could make me hate him more but then he goes and does THIS??!!! This show is going to kill me. I am so scared for Mary Hawkins I can't bear it, the scene where she was attacked had me bawling from horror and the fact that Randall will somehow get his hands on her makes me SICK. I can only hope that she turns out to be a villain too and they're somehow kindred spirits but I have a hard time imagining that.

I also can't help but wonder if it affects the actor to play such a disgusting character and having to play out the most evil actions. I can't imagine having to do that and it would be interesting to know if he ever spoke about it?

Also, I love the show so far and can't believe it took me this long to finally watch it. Jamie has me giggling and kicking my feet even though he has his flaws, and I love the way Claires character is written, that even though she comes from the future and could easily be portrayed as some evolved, all-knowing superwoman she is still human has to navigate issues that transcend time, such as relationships and morality and we see that she too has her flaws.

One thing I am torn about is that there are a lot of very disturbing rape scenes which I feel are starting to be used a bit gratuitously, something I have seen being critiqued quite a lot. After this episode it just felt like one too many in a very short span, so I hope this is the last one for a while cause otherwise it would really feel like they just add them for effect.

Also, mark me: Why is Dougal kindaaa.. 😏🤭


r/Outlander • • 2d ago

6 A Breath Of Snow And Ashes Does anyone have the full “It’s just a cat” passage from ABOSAA?

6 Upvotes

Anybody have this full exchange between Claire and Jamie from ABOSAA (when Claire says goodbye to Adso)? I can’t find it but could really use it right now! Thanks💕


r/Outlander • • 2d ago

Spoilers All Fergus Spoiler

12 Upvotes

I have nothing to say but 😭😭😭

Is it the same in the books?


r/Outlander • • 2d ago

3 Voyager The books are making me like Claire more

50 Upvotes

Don't get me wrong I love show Claire. She has been one of my favorite FMCs for a while now but book Claire? Obsessed. I love her so much. They are the same of course but also a little different at times and Caitriona was remarkable as Claire and brought her to life but the book makes me appreciate the character way more.


r/Outlander • • 2d ago

Season Seven Fun Speculation About Claire Spoiler

11 Upvotes

I love Claire as a character, and I’m entranced by her many traits (both good and bad but mostly wonderful), so I do sometimes wonder about how matters may have gone if the story plot had played out just a little bit differently. Let’s try this one. After learning Jamie has drowned, Claire marries LJG (the “why” of this can be argued, yes I know the standard reason that is given, or rather that LJG gives). Claire gives every indication of accommodating to her new life (even at the moment that Jamie appears she has agreed to more social engagements with LJG and acquaintances)- after all, accommodating to circumstances is one of her strengths. What if Jamie does not appear when he does? What if he arrives in town a month later? The British army is evacuating Philadelphia (both in the film and historically) and the Americans are moving in. My question is: does Claire, still ignorant of Jamie’s survival, leave Philadelphia and accompany LJG as his wife, or does she stay in town and go over to the Continental army to serve in their medical corps (and serve the Cause, as she told Ian she wanted to do) ?

The rendering of her departure with LJG would, IMO, add so much depth to the story: there would be a role reversal at the battle of Monmouth, where LJG battles the nefarious rebels, and although Claire is not a Loyalist, she would feel obligated to tend the wounded English. My imagination would have them go on to New York or even London, causing Jamie to search for many months before catching up with them. Thus, it would easily be a year since the star crossed lovers have seen each other. In the meanwhile, Claire has ripened in her role as Lady John Grey, with all that goes with being his wife. Don’t get me wrong—-Claire is crazy in love with Jamie and would cleave to him in that scenario, but the encounter would be fraught with so much more energy, difficulty, passion, and emotion. And, it would allow the relationship between Claire and LJG to develop more fully (in the show, it’s really a dead end - the whole affair only serves to anger Jamie and spotlight John’s adventures/escapes)

Thoughts?


r/Outlander • • 2d ago

Prequel Two Outlander: Blood of My Blood Season 2, Episode 9 Clip: Brian and Ellen Twelfth Night Invitation Spoiler

Thumbnail
tvline.com
11 Upvotes

Just in case anyone needs a reminder, we get a new episode at midnight. TV Line has a sneak peak for episode 9, Another Man's Shadow, written by Diana Gabaldon.

Thoughts, speculations?


r/Outlander • • 3d ago

Season Two I wonder… Was Dougal really that bad?

19 Upvotes

This post is meant only slightly tongue-in-cheek…Yes he was a nasty man at times, but were there redeeming acts and qualities? I’m keeping this question open ended to see what ya’ll think, but I do have to ask: Did he deserve his ignominious death? (PS: Jamie seemed to have matters well in hand, so why did Claire assist him in stabbing Dougal? Was she afraid that Dougal might somehow prevail despite his imminent demise, or did she simply want in on the action and repay Dougal for past misdeeds?)


r/Outlander • • 3d ago

4 Drums Of Autumn Brianna book vs show

83 Upvotes

Have watched the show through a few times. Currently watching season 2 with my husband. Just finished reading Drums of Autumn though, and I gotta say there is a marked difference between Brianna in the book and Brianna in the show. I have no hate for Brianna in the show, but I feel like they really toned her down from the book version. Why did we get a tiny skinny gal instead of the force of nature of a giantess described in the book?

In the show, she still seems more like a kid in season 4, not yet an adult. In the book she feels like a whole adult, fully realized who knew exactly what she was about. I dont feel she really came into her own in the show until almost season 7 or 8.

Finally, why the hell did they have show Brianna be so useless when she came through the stones? She is not wearing proper clothes for the cold, she immediately falls over and busts her ankle, she doesn't have enough food. If loagherie hadn't found, she probably would have frozen to death the first night. Im not sure I understand the choice there. In the book, she goes to Lallybroch on her own with no issues. She isn't a damsel in distress.

Idk it just sort of rubbed me the wrong way that the show seemed to take her power away? What are yall's thoughts?


r/Outlander • • 3d ago

7 An Echo In The Bone For people who read the books first…. Does the show get better?

16 Upvotes

Unpopular opinion possibly- but I’m listening to the audiobooks and really enjoying them. I also started watching season 1 and 2 of the show when I want the comfort of a tv show instead of listening to a new story. I put Echo In The Bone as the flair because that’s the book I’m on right now.

I’m just… disappointed. I don’t dislike it but I’m having trouble wanting to keep watching. There are just so many times the characters feel so flat compared to the books and while that’s totally normal just based on the type of medium, I find myself wondering if I should even bother with the show.

Do the later seasons improve and have more nuance?


r/Outlander • • 3d ago

Season Five season 5 finale ep 12, Lionel finding out Claire is Dr. Rawlings

9 Upvotes

DISCLAIMER: I love this show and everything that it is behind it: the actors, the storylines, the magic of the landscapes, the time travel...

That said, I can't wrap my head around how stupidly claire was identified as Dr. Rawlings by Lionel.

For those who don't recall: Lionel was having her wife checked by Claire in the infermery, and while waiting he was looking around, only to find the exact pen Claire was using to write the articles, with the plate "Dr. D. Rawlings" right beside it! Wasn't she supposed to keep it a secret?

I keep wondering how differently it would've gone. Sure, the Browns already held grudge over Jamie for turning them down and rejecting their invite to fight side by side, but still....it feels so stupid. Even for a tv show.


r/Outlander • • 4d ago

Spoilers All Marsali is my fav - does she have a big part in the books?

18 Upvotes

I’ve watched Outlander several times and oh how I love Marsali’s character. I want to start reading the books, does she play a role in them? As she does on the show?


r/Outlander • • 5d ago

Season Eight Just finished watching the show for the first time Spoiler

18 Upvotes

I loved it from start to finish, and I never had anything to complain about until the very end. I liked season 8, but does anybody else feel like it was a bit rushed? I definitely think this season needed 16 episodes, or at least 13. I hated how they deal with fergus’ death: Claire seemed not to care too much about it and the tribute jamie paid to him was not enough. And Lord, how I hated the fact they introduced Fanny’s character and did nothing with her. She was supposed to be so important to the plot: she was their granddaughter and on top of that they only introduced her being able to travel though time plot on episode 9 (I think?) in the last 2 minutes, when in was impossible to do anything with it anymore since episode 10 was going to be centered about the battle. And I also think they should’ve not announced Jamie’s death early on in episode 1; when he said Frank wrote he was going to die, that completely ruined it for me, and I was not really satisfied with his death.

Does anybody else feel the same?


r/Outlander • • 5d ago

Season Eight Sam Heughan celebrates Outlander’s legacy at BAFTA Scotland Awards

Thumbnail
scottishnews.com
264 Upvotes

Sam Heughan and Matthew B Roberts, along with Sophie Skelton and John Bell, were present to receive the Outstanding Contribution to Television Award from BAFTA Scotland. Congratulations!


r/Outlander • • 5d ago

Season Eight Outlander in Concert was fantastic!

Post image
183 Upvotes

All the musicians were precisely on point and sounded amazing, and this is coming from another musician. Loved seeing and hearing the bagpipes, penny whistle, bodhran, and other instruments in real life. There’s a merch table and a photo backdrop so make sure you have time to stop at those if you’re going to the show! We got a teddy bear to take with us on our Scotland trip next year!

This was the Mesa, AZ stop and Diana Gabaldon lives in a bordering town so I was hoping she might make an appearance, but alas.

ETA: Anyone who’s gone already or will go, did you get the link from the QR code for the show program that was part of the slide show before the concert started? They don’t have paper programs and I couldn’t get the QR code to work because of the angle I was at. If so I would love if someone could share it with me!


r/Outlander • • 5d ago

Prequel Two Song from BOMB S2 E4 Spoiler

3 Upvotes

Hello folks. Is there a recording or link to the song that the men are singing when they are sitting around the campfire late at night? I know it's called 'when cannons are roaring', but want to know if there's a recorded version from the show anywhere? It's quite catchy. Thanks!


r/Outlander • • 6d ago

Spoilers All Claire vs. Richardson on American Slavery Spoiler

2 Upvotes

I know we already got a bit of a conversation between Claire and Richardson in the Show, but their Show conversation seemed so hokey and unreal to me. Way too much of Show! Richardson being awestruck/amazed that Claire had tried twice! If he was given more than 2 seconds of freedom, he probably would have bowed at her feet!

I would LOVE for Book 10 to feature some deeper conversation between Claire and Richardson about Richardson's plan and the impacts of American slavery.

I'm aware that Hitler was apparently inspired to conduct the Holocaust based on American slavery and Jim Crowe laws. I think there was one specific book published about the conduct of American slavery that was found amongst Hitler's belongings.

Considering that Claire served as a nurse in WWII, I think it would be interesting for her to grapple with Richardson's idea of ending American slavery, as something that has global repercussions on the shape of the future, and more specifically, on the course of her own past.

Based on Claire's past thoughts/lectures on Slavery and Poverty in France, what do you think Book!Claire would say to Richardson IF she gets the chance to confront him/talk it over with Jamie afterward?


r/Outlander • • 6d ago

Season Eight I just wanted to say the only good man whom i think is sane and caring is Lord John.

65 Upvotes

I am on episode 7th of season 8. The scene how he tries to comfort Amaranthus just made me realize of what a good human being he is and how loving, considerate, logical and selfless he has been through the seasons.