r/Outlander • u/Longjumping-Swan4873 • 1d ago
Spoilers All Time loop? Spoiler
Okay finally finished my first watch through and... Huh? What? Que?
My original thought was just, I wish they had set up a big bad foe for season 8 other than fate, but I get it. Nature of the show and all. But still a through line bad guy would have been great in the place of the pontificating and proclamating and discussions of off screen conversations with children we didn't see
But the part, where Jamie is the man outside Claire's window, young Jamie not old Jamie. Huh
Yea they said if he died he would come back (ghost him) and check on her. So he..peeps on her younger version before they met instead of older her who would undoubtedly bw missing him
Or that doesn't matter cause he is brought back to life anyway so why in that brief moment of death would he go back to a version of her he didn't know
Except he did know and thats young him not the one that died and this isn't star wars where anikins ghost self is the version if him before Darth Vader (not so niche reference)..so one can presume and he set the whole chain of events off and played dumb the whole time and could pass through the stones and thata why he asked her if he wished she'd never found the flowers
Or maybe ghost him briefly visited a version of her he didn't know to set off a chain of events with the flowers that grew? To put Claire in a time loop so that she would always have to come through the stones
It's all so convoluted
My head hurts
Honestly asking for an explanation of something I am missing in the meaning of all of this
13
u/CathyAnnWingsFan
1d ago
•
I don’t overthink it and don’t take how they present the supernatural too literally. No matter how long he lives, Jamie has been long dead in 1945. His ghost can appear to be any age he likes; it doesn’t necessarily have anything to do with how old he is when he dies. And time and space have no meaning for ghosts; they can appear when and where they like after the person has died. Personally, I think Jamie’s ghost has been watching over Claire since she was born; the night before Beltane was just a time when he was visible to someone else (Frank). And none of that requires any sort of a time loop.
0
u/ContactNeither7319 1d ago
But Claire went back and stayed. She's going to die in the past. Why would Jamie bother watching baby Claire all the way to adult Claire when he could be with spirit Claire for all of eternity in a Nirvana? And a spirit Claire that looks like she's 20 if I might add. 😉
I agree on everything thing else though. 🙂
11
u/CathyAnnWingsFan 1d ago
It’s a part of her life he missed. Why wouldn’t he want to see her then?
-1
u/ContactNeither7319 1d ago edited 15h ago
That's true. And I love the idea that he would do that.
But then I started to wonder why he would do that. Because I would think spirit Claire would be with spirit Jamie when they die. She's one of those paradoxical people that will die before their born.
What I mean is (and this would only pertain to the show) when Jamie died on Kings Mountain he was a ghost. He was in the spirit world for about 12 hours or so in the living world time. While he was a ghost he visited Claire and planted the flowers. And then Claire brought him back to the living world. He will go on living until he finally really dies and is buried. Hopefully he will be really old and Claire will be with him. Claire is never going back to her time. She will die in the past. Hopefully they will die together. When they do die they will be together in the spirit world.
The only time that I can think of that he would visit Claire when she was born is maybe when he died on Kings Mountain and was the ghost that visits her in 1945. Maybe he visits her in 1918 when she's born before going to 1945. The only other time he might have the opportunity to do this would be if he dies before Claire. He would be in the sprit world before her and is waiting for her to join him. But he might just watch over her until she passes.
That's all I was getting at. I do admit describing things as spirit Jamie and baby Claire was silly but honestly I couldn't think of a different way to label them.
Edited for clarity. It was way past my bed time when I originally wrote it. My brain was nuts and it made sense at the time. Not so much in the morning.
1
u/CathyAnnWingsFan 5h ago
You're assuming he was a ghost during that time. We don't know that. I don't think he was. But the showrunners left it open to interpretation, so people can think what they want.
1
u/ContactNeither7319 5h ago
I know. It's left open to our own interpretation. I was just hypothesizing. I really liked your thoughts about Jamie's ghost visiting Claire when she born.
0
u/qwnofeverything 8h ago
We don’t know she’s going to die in the past. At the end, they both gasped, so it up to you whether they lived or died. In any case, she’s still born in the future. The ghost was watching over her. He knew it time to come to him and he set the scene for her to find him.
1
u/ContactNeither7319 6h ago
That's true. We are left to for ourselves to decide what happens after they open their eyes and gasp.
We don't know if she goes back to the future or stays. What's in the future for her to go back to?
0
u/qwnofeverything 6h ago
Maybe nothing. But if he does before she does or if she gets sick or a million other things. What if Brianna and Roger go back? We just don’t know. At least in the show. As yet we don’t know outside the show either.
8
u/liyufx 1d ago edited 1d ago
I do think and like that it is a time loop. But my read is that a ghost is not bound by a certain time or appearance, it is just Jamie’s ghost. I don’t even believe Jamie ever died on King’s Mountain, it was just a near death experience but Claire preserved his life. The notion that he died for a little while, turned into ghost and in that little time found young Claire and planted the forget me not, then get back in time to be revived by Claire, is just that people always try to hold on to linear time. They had to put the ghost scene and King’s mountain together because it was the last episode of the show and both have to go into the last episode of the show, but it does not follow that the ghost was the ghost of Jamie from King’s Mountain. For all I know, Jamie would eventually die , hopefully of old age, in peace, surrounded by the people who loved him, and he could turn into a ghost and find Claire and nudge her to take her fateful journey through the stones, so the cycle restarts. It doesn’t matter which version of Jamie the ghost appears, there is no science that explains how ghost should look like or behave anyway.
2
u/ContactNeither7319 1d ago edited 1d ago
Well see Jamie is a ghost when he sees Claire in the window in 1945. For a brief time he was dead on that mountain. He was in the spirit world and Claire was not. So goes to 1945 and does his thing. Now it's often said your ghost will take the form you see yourself as. Think Neo from the Matrix. When in the Matrix Neo is badass looking. When in the real world he looks like shit. That's why Jamie looks young.
At some point Jamie will really die and be buried. And so will Claire. Hopefully they die together. The way I see it they will be together in like Nirvana. Forever. 🙂
0
u/Slow-Weakness8511 1d ago
That bit was actually one of my favorite parts of the last episode/season. Jamie caused it all with that little blip back in time. He made the flowers and made Frank jealous, not worth going back to when Claire had the chance.
0
0
u/Crystalraf 9h ago
I don’t know about the ghost of Jamie. My thought was he had clairvoyance or something in the spiritual form, and time traveling is just part of the experience.
I still think he died though. The ending was weird, even for a show about time travel. I think they woke up in heaven or something. Or she resurrected him and they both lived. He was definitely time traveling in his dreams and checking up on his loved ones before he died.
I don’t really think the show ending was important. It was up to the viewer to interpret what was shown. I think the flashbacks were non-diegetic, meaning the audience saw them, but the characters did not, or they were just thinking about their lives in their minds. What was important was that Clair started writing about her story.
•
u/AutoModerator 1d ago
Mark me,
Something in your post matches a discussion I have seen here before…
If this is your first time in this fair subreddit, you would do well to peruse this introductory page.
Are you asking about the ghost that bore an uncanny resemblance to my friend James?
These threads may have the answer you seek.
If this resolves your question, be so kind as to delete your OP. This assists my subjects in keeping my dominion tidy.
Your prince thanks you for your sacrifice. When my father assumes his rightful throne, mark me, it will not be forgotten!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.