I’ve decided to quit dick-picking around and work on a divorce, but before I go, have yet another advice post.
For the fellas replying:
I have given up hope that I can convince men who do not fit the description of what a woman is looking for not to respond anyway. But, if I can get even a couple of you to listen, it’s worth the time it took to repeat it.
For those of you who are here acting in good faith, or as close an approximation as one can find while seeking infidelity, do not forget that it’s an actual human being on the other side of the screen. If she’s naughty af in her post, it’s fair to respond in kind. If she’s asked for a slow burn, something more long-term, or to really get to know you, don’t get pissed if she’s not ready for your dick pics on day three, or perhaps even day ten. She’s probably still reading the hundreds of replies she’s gotten, at least 50% from people she’s explicitly NOT looking for.
If she’s bothering to talk to you at all, you are winning. Don’t get greedy, or pushy and blow it. Some dude once said “Well, if you’re cool sending nudes to other people, I don’t understand why I’m not getting them?” I responded, “So, does that mean that if I’m having sex with someone, or have in the past, I’ve consented to fucking anyone who asks?” Blocked, mercifully.
Commenting publicly on the post is equivalent to a public marriage proposal, to a woman probably here looking for someone discreet. It put me off instantly, unless they were replying to drag the first dude who did it.
For the fellas posting:
Have you ever noticed how so many of the F4M posts ask you to perform a small feat, or follow directions to check you were paying attention? I suggest you do the same, but ffs, do not make it something like “send me your measurements.” The best I ever saw asked me to demonstrate that I knew how to correctly use a semicolon in a sentence. That guy got 12 replies, which to my understanding is pretty extraordinary for an M4F. We’re all here looking for some form of validation or another. If you’re starting the conversation by telling a woman how you also love the three favorite movies you’ve asked her to tell you about, or that the joke you asked her to tell is hilarious, things will probably develop much more organically. Give the conversation somewhere to go, and also give yourself a polite out if she’s not what you’re looking for. “It sounds like we might not be a great fit, but you have great taste in movies. Thanks for your reply.” is way better for your karma, on Reddit or otherwise, than “Not into it.”
Don’t post every other day, and clear your profile history of anything you don’t want her to judge you for.
For fellas in either category:
If the conversation lags at any point, rather than sending her the written equivalent of an elbow nudge, tell her a story or say something interesting.
Why do I still have to say this? Do not send unsolicited dick pics. Pictures of your dick obscured only by a sock or a cup are still dick pics.
If you are lucky enough to receive photos or any other form of kompromat, do not violate that very generous woman’s trust by saving or sharing them without her express consent.
Really think about what you are looking for in an AP. Consider that when you say you aren’t looking to change anyone’s situation that things like requiring exclusivity might make it more difficult for your AP to keep things in perspective. I’m not saying you shouldn’t, I’m just saying that this is something that is best negotiated with the best interests and goals of both parties in mind.
If she’s asking for more conversation and you just want nudes, you could save yourselves both plenty of grief, and support economic recovery by patronizing online sex-workers, who are just as deserving of respect and kindness as chat partners, but who are willing to skip the formalities for the right price.
For the ladies:
Please be careful. There are so many wonderful people here. There are also so many predatory assholes. Anonymity has its risks, so does the loss of that anonymity. Know your worth. You do not have to tolerate bad behavior.
For everyone:
Keep an open mind about what you’re looking for. I might not be riding off into the sunset with anyone (because that was never my intention), but I’ve made some dear, dear friends with occasional benefits. None of us are all one thing. Feelings are real, and very complex. Appreciate one another for who and what you are, and be kind. BE KIND.
Thanks for the great ride! 😘