r/MurderAtTheCottage • • Sep 23 '22

The unusual death of Agneta Westlund

0 Upvotes

https://www.clermontsun.com/2021/01/20/marc-hoover-the-unusual-death-of-agneta-westlund

Sweden isn’t typically known for homicides or considered a dangerous place to live. So when a murder occurs, you can almost guarantee it’s going to get much publicity. For instance, take the strange case of Agneta and Ingemar Westlund, a couple who lived in the village of Loftahammar in Sweden. One day in September 2008, Agneta took her dog for a walk in the woods as she normally did. Unfortunately, she never returned. Afterward, Ingemar went out to find his wife. He found her battered body in the woods.

Ingemar called the authorities and led them to his wife’s body. In any homicide case, authorities usually try to clear the victim’s significant other first. Swedish police wondered who had a reason to kill Agneta Westlund? They didn’t think it likely a crazed killer lurked in the woods waiting for a victim. Authorities immediately suspected Ingemar.

They arrested and charged Ingemar with murdering his wife. He denied the charges and proclaimed his innocence. He spent ten days in jail before being released. Although he left jail, he remained a suspect for six months. Ingemar soon became an outcast in his community. No one wanted to associate with a man suspected of killing his wife.

The police eventually dropped all charges against Ingemar. However, the police neglected to tell Ingemar they had cleared him of killing his wife. If Ingemar didn’t kill his wife, then who did? The answer surprised everyone. Authorities blamed Agneta Westlund’s death on a drunken elk.

After Agneta’s body was recovered, authorities noticed fur on the body. Authorities incorrectly assumed it belonged to a dog. After studying Agneta’s wounds and doing genetic testing on recovered fur and saliva, authorities determined the genetic evidence belonged to a European Elk or what we Americans often call a moose. This enormous creature is common in Sweden. It’s not unusual for them to weigh in around 800 pounds. Although this creature typically avoids confrontations with humans, they have harmed people in the past.

Authorities believe that while walking her dog, Agneta Westlund came upon an elk eating fermented apples. After the elk ate the apples, it affected the creature similar to how alcohol affects a human. Most likely, the dog approached the drunken elk and antagonized it. The elk then attacked and killed Agneta. Unfortunately, Ingemar endured a horrific ordeal. He had told a media source about attending his wife’s funeral with his children. The 300 people who attended the funeral believed Ingemar had killed his wife.

I looked online for additional stories about drunken elks. One story involved a group of elks that gorged themselves on fermented apples. The elk then congregated around a senior citizen home. Authorities arrived to drive the creatures away. After police dogs didn’t intimidate the elk, hunters with guns arrived to scare away the enormous creatures.

After authorities exonerated Ingemar, he sued them for falsely accusing him of murder and then locking him up. Goran Ericsson, a university animal expert, said it’s easy to understand how police could mistake Agneta’s death for a homicide. Ericsson said it’s rare for an Elk to kill a person. Therefore, the police would assume another person killed Agneta. I remember reading about this story a few years ago. So what would have happened if this death would have occurred before technological advances in genetic testing? For instance, what if this would have happened in 1908 instead of 2008? I shudder to even think about it because a jury probably wouldn’t have believed an elk had killed Agneta Westlund. As for the killer drunken moose? Unless a wolf or a hunter has already killed it, then it’s still at large.

[Credit to DaBingeGirl for pointing out this article]

How about 1996 West Cork Ireland? A full 12 years before what happened Agneta Westlund!

Alternative horse kick equine caused fatality hypothesis for Sophie Toscan du Plantier crime

WARNING: Absolutely brutal horse attack that lasts for a minute.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=22ZxFif1PvA

Livestock Fatalities by Animal Type (HSA)2000-2010**MARE - 14 Fatalities54% of all fatalities are caused by a Mare.**More than Bulls, Cows, Cattle combined.

https://www.hsa.ie/eng/Publications_and_Forms/Publications/Agriculture_and_Forestry/Safe_Handling_of_Cattle_on_Farms.pdf

This hypothesis has nothing to do with a horse lifting a block. It is Sophie who lifts it in the hypothesis. Some people simply refuse to read this fully.

  1. The glaring problem is who goes to murder someone with a concrete block as the murder weapon in mind?

  2. Second, why is there a lack of intruder fingerprints and DNA?

  3. Third, if they have gloves on then how come Ian Bailey got scratched? You can't have it both ways.

  4. Fourth, the Irish Director of Public Prosecutions has said this case is a mess of contamination and badly managed.

Here is the bloody C shape on the 25kg concrete block STP had likely put up on the fence post in the first place.

There is no evidence the block was moved from another location ON THE SAME DAY. That block could have been used to prop back the fence from any number of days or weeks beforehand. Moss grows slowly.

The horse hypothesis is over 10 years old and was explained by locals who thought it was a horse attack. He might have some elements wrong in the video below because it was 10 years ago. However, the general hypothesis is there. So this is nothing new.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uOS1ALsW-08

Here is an aerial image where you can see horses there at the time. Top left.

Here is the list of counterpoints that don't work.

  • Women can't lift blocks (especially if they are already down on the ground with a block beside them).

  • The block was too heavy.

  • Her attack wounds.

  • Horses can't carry out that level of damage.

Maybe the best counterpoint -> Blood on a door handle (without accepting the crime scene was contaminated).

Farm animal attacks and fatalities were much higher than stranger homicides in the early 1990s Ireland and before.

The block is approx 25kg. This type of block is called a "Lightweight Hollow Cinder Block". You see them everywhere used to block gates from closing when open.

We actually don't know what her attack wounds are. There is no pathology report made public to back up how the block was used. We don't even know how many times it was dropped on her.

In short, this horse hypothesis is equally as valid as the intruder one or any homicide claim for that matter. There is no hard evidence we have been presented with that this a homicide.

If you have the autopsy report then we would like to read it. Again, we don't know how many times the block was used. We know nothing there actually.

If you watch the show again and pay attention to the claims made about the house and how she left the house, the horse kick fatality hypothesis works with all of it. It even explains it. She went out to investigate a commotion most likely.

Horse kicks evolved to be more powerful than a baseball bat strike. If you google images of horse kick injuries be warned. They are very graphic. Some look like shotgun blasts to the face. Others have a piece of skull missing. Jaws kicked clean off. Nose gone. They can be horrendous.

If the concrete block can be used as a murder weapon then there is no reason it can't have been used to try and hit a horse with it. If she was pinned against the fence after addressing a problem with horses stuck or in a panic then she could have grabbed anything to help her get out. If she was down on the ground she can still lift it up and put it before her. The kicks prior would have been near-fatal injuries as she made a last attempt to use the block next to her to knock the horse's back but already in a wounded state brought it up and maybe down on herself because of another kick.

I bet when her body was discovered that horses were out free and had to be put back into an enclosure. I think an expert in animal attacks, farm attacks, and equine attacks should be asked to review the pathology report.

Again, farm animal attacks and equine attacks are far more statistically likely than homicide, especially in 1990s Ireland and before. This isn't an owl hypothesis like the Staircase. These happen and they can be fatal if not life-changing forever.


r/MurderAtTheCottage • • Oct 19 '24

The murderer…

0 Upvotes

I’ll keep this short and simple If you really dive deep into this case you’ll come quickly to realise that the killer was one of the policeman at that time- it was never Ian Bailey If you really ask the people in west cork this question- they’ll look at you confused but it’s best not discussed as if they were to say anything they may also see the eyes of exactly what Sophie saw that night many years ago I’ll keep this here


r/MurderAtTheCottage • • Aug 15 '22

Thoughts about the Hellen’s possible involvement

0 Upvotes

r/MurderAtTheCottage • • Oct 07 '21

New Sophie murder vid on YouTube

0 Upvotes

Takes a good look at some of the recent developments https://youtu.be/6DfSUCfYJ5o


r/MurderAtTheCottage • • Jul 30 '21

Hot take on murder , I believe there was likely 2 ppl present

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/MurderAtTheCottage • • Jan 28 '22

My interview with Ian bailey check it out and subscribe.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/MurderAtTheCottage • • Jul 03 '22

Alternative horse kick equine caused fatality hypothesis for Sophie Toscan du Plantier crime

0 Upvotes

WARNING: Absolutely brutal horse attack that lasts for a minute.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p84R7gtfOKo

Livestock Fatalities by Animal Type (HSA)

2000-2010

MARE - 14 Fatalities

54% of all fatalities are caused by a Mare.

More than Bulls, Cows, Cattle combined.

https://www.hsa.ie/eng/Publications_and_Forms/Publications/Agriculture_and_Forestry/Safe_Handling_of_Cattle_on_Farms.pdf

First of all, take a depth breath, hold your preconceptions, remember that hardly any official documents have been made public, and consider this alternative that has been knocking around locally for at least 10 years.

Edit: This hypothesis has nothing to do with a horse lifting a block. It is Sophie who lifts it in the hypothesis. Some people simply refuse to read this fully.

  1. The glaring problem is who goes to murder someone with a concrete block as the murder weapon in mind?

  2. Second, why is there a lack of intruder fingerprints and DNA?

  3. Third, if they have gloves on then how come Ian Bailey got scratched? You can't have it both ways.

  4. Fourth, the Irish Director of Public Prosecutions has said this case is a mess of contamination and badly managed.

Here is the bloody C shape on the 10kg to 20kg concrete block STP had likely put up on the fence post in the first place.

The horse hypothesis is over 10 years old and was explained by locals who thought it was a horse attack. He might have some elements wrong in the video below because it was 10 years ago. However, the general hypothesis is there. So this is nothing new.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uOS1ALsW-08

Here is an aerial image where you can see horses there at the time. Top left.

Here is the list of counterpoints that don't work.

  • Women can't lift blocks.

  • The block was too heavy.

  • Her attack wounds.

  • Horses can't carry out that level of damage.

Maybe the best counterpoint -> Blood on a door handle (without accepting the crime scene was contaminated).

Farm animal attacks and fatalities were much higher than stranger homicides in the early 1990s Ireland and before.

The block looks like 10 to 20kg at the max and might even be less than 10kg. This type of block is called a "Lightweight Hollow Cinder Block". You see them everywhere used to block gates from closing when open.

We actually don't know what her attack wounds are. There is no pathology report made public to back up how the block was used. We don't even know how many times it was dropped on her.

In short, this horse hypothesis is equally as valid as the intruder one or any homicide claim for that matter. There is no hard evidence we have been presented with that this a homicide.

If you have the autopsy report then we would like to read it. Again, we don't know how many times the block was used. We know nothing there actually.

If you watch the show again and pay attention to the claims made about the house and how she left the house, the horse kick fatality hypothesis works with all of it. It even explains it. She went out to investigate a commotion most likely.

Horse kicks evolved to be more powerful than a baseball bat strike. If you google images of horse kick injuries be warned. They are very graphic. Some look like shotgun blasts to the face. Others have a piece of skull missing. Jaws kicked clean off. Nose gone. They can be horrendous.

If the concrete block can be used as a murder weapon then there is no reason it can't have been used to try and hit a horse with it. If she was pinned against the fence after addressing a problem with horses stuck or in a panic then she could have grabbed anything to help her get out. If she lifted the block up, she may have brought it down on her also (lifting from a crouched position is only a few feet). However, that block would not be a fatal injury. The kicks prior would have been near-fatal injuries as she made a last attempt to use the block next to her to knock the horse's back but already in a wounded state brought it up and maybe down on herself because of another kick.

I bet when her body was discovered that horses were out free and had to be put back into an enclosure. I think an expert in animal attacks, farm attacks, and equine attacks should be asked to review the pathology report.

Again, farm animal attacks and equine attacks are far more statistically likely than homicide, especially in 1990s Ireland and before. This isn't an owl hypothesis like the Staircase. These happen and they can be fatal if not life-changing forever.


r/MurderAtTheCottage • • Sep 06 '21

Missing gate

0 Upvotes

How on this earth have the guards gotten way with “ losing” an 8 foot gate?
I’m flabbergasted as to how the guards can explain how this gate went missing. Are the circumstances of this critical lost piece of evidence in any of the DPP reports? The blood smears on the gate hold the key to finding the perpetrator of this crime. I cannot believe that 25 years later it’s just accepted that the gate went missing and no questions asked, nobody held accountable for losing vital evidence.


r/MurderAtTheCottage • • Jun 04 '25

Not guilty

5 Upvotes

After watching both documentaries and various threads on this subreddit it is clear to me Bailey is not guilty by definition of beyond reasonable doubt. Do I think he did it though…. Probably.

It’s not what you know, it’s what you can prove.


r/MurderAtTheCottage • • Nov 16 '24

Cui bono?

2 Upvotes

Cui bono?

If this question was ever asked by the Gardai about the murder of Sophie, the finger of blame would surely point firmly in the direction of Daniel Toscan du Plantier, her then husband. It isn’t difficult to assume he was with his mistress (his next wife) when Sophie rang him on the night of her murder. He couldn’t take her call and had to ring back, with the reason given that he was in a work meeting. I think at that time of night it’s much more likely he was with Melita Nikolic. That in itself doesn’t point to his guilt but it could point to motive. Given Sophie and Daniel seemed to have an arrangement, it’s not a good motive in itself. The other motive he could have acted on was financial. Did he stand to benefit financially from Sophie’s death? Was Sophie really tolerant of Daniel’s promiscuity? Particularly if he was getting serious about Melita, perhaps Sophie was being difficult.

This is of course all supposition, albeit based on the facts of the case as I understand them, but the big problem was that Daniel was never investigated! Was he even questioned by the French police as a suspect? Is there any access to the French investigation? Or was it more convenient to let an unknown Englishman in Ireland take the blame? Daniel was actually a prime suspect but he was a big shot in France so how much was he deferred to? How can the guilt of any other suspect ever be decided (other than through forensic evidence) when there was this huge gap in the investigation?


r/MurderAtTheCottage • • Sep 23 '21

IB and MF, who's the bigger liar? A thread on the mysteries of the (now forgiven by IB) Marie Farrell, her mystery man and inexplicable and highly suspicious involvement in the case

Thumbnail
m.sundayworld.com
2 Upvotes

r/MurderAtTheCottage • • Oct 04 '22

Three new suspects

1 Upvotes

News report from one of the many newspapers on the Sky documentary stated :

“ The programme narrows it down to three different suspects, one of whom is Irish and who has moved to another part of the country, a second is French while the third is also a foreigner.”

The French suspect is the chap know to Sophies family.

Wonder who the other two are

'One of whom is Irish' ? (the peeping tom that was interviewd at the time maybe, if still alive?)

And another 'foreigner' ?


r/MurderAtTheCottage • • May 01 '22

Poll: Who’s your money on?

1 Upvotes

Curious to read what everyone’s verdict is. I think we all know what will poll highest, but the margins may well be interesting…..

79 votes, May 04 '22
31 Bailey, no doubt whatsoever!
15 Someone that Sophie was acquainted with (local or otherwise, but not IB)
5 The dead Guard
28 Not sure, keeping an open mind.

r/MurderAtTheCottage • • May 07 '25

Crime scene photos

0 Upvotes

Hey guys is there anywhere to access crime scene photos that have not been released publicly in order to do research. If anyone had these it wouod be appreciated thank you


r/MurderAtTheCottage • • Jul 03 '22

Can we get better photos of the crime scene area? I highlighted possible hoof prints. The bottom one is best but we need better detail of the path.

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/MurderAtTheCottage • • Jul 25 '21

Incredible documenty. If this

2 Upvotes

H Who killed her? Netflix documentary seemed to frame Ian Bailey. He the obvious guy? Most people think so. Problem is Ian isn't clearly psychopathic. He is not even weird or complex. I think his apparent confessions meaning nothing. He is a confident guy. He apparent confession where mere games play with societies norms and morals. On the the other had he might of killed her. It would of been out of character if so. Big deal . It's the police job too apprehend if need be. They failed.

To be honest my main admiration in this was the behaviour of DAA. Totally professional and abiding by rules. The question is did he kill her not? The judiciary says no.

The Judicial system isn't some morality game.


r/MurderAtTheCottage • • Jun 30 '22

The timing of this arrest in France in relation to what’s just been announced in the du Plantier case here… Just a little uncanny.

Thumbnail
rte.ie
3 Upvotes

r/MurderAtTheCottage • • Jul 03 '21

Has Ian Bailey taken a polygraph?

3 Upvotes

Nor podcast or the documentary mentioned whether he had taken a polygraph test


r/MurderAtTheCottage • • Jun 21 '25

Last goodbye' to Ian Bailey as ashes scattered in West Cork

Thumbnail
corkbeo.ie
7 Upvotes

r/MurderAtTheCottage • • Aug 09 '22

Alfie Lyons

10 Upvotes

Was it him? If not, why not?

Discuss.


r/MurderAtTheCottage • • Jan 22 '25

Ian Bailey’s ashes to be scattered in West Cork

10 Upvotes

Ian Bailey’s sister arranged his cremation quickly and privately when he died a year ago to avoid the inevitable media furore that would have surrounded a public event. I always thought it was sad that a person who had been hounded and maligned in life still suffered under that cloud in death despite being innocent. Now his sister and solicitor are arranging to scatter his ashes in West Cork so friends and family can pay their respects. Good to hear. No one, regardless of their faults, deserves to be shunned and slandered in death as he was.

https://m.sundayworld.com/news/irish-news/ian-baileys-ashes-to-be-scattered-in-west-cork-at-special-memorial-service/a1797842874.html


r/MurderAtTheCottage • • Sep 02 '25

Sand in Bailey's car

5 Upvotes

I recently read Senan Molony's book (I have also just finished The Blow In, so I don't come here definitively thinking anything)

One thing that I had never heard before was that the Gardai found sand in the footwell of Ian Bailey's car. The suggestion being the sand was likely from Bailey washing his boots in a near by beach / sandy area.

Any thoughts on this?


r/MurderAtTheCottage • • Sep 30 '22

Nature of Relationship between Jules Thomas and Jim Sheridan

5 Upvotes

r/MurderAtTheCottage • • Sep 13 '21

Jim Sheridan slams Nick Foster

5 Upvotes

r/MurderAtTheCottage • • Jan 14 '22

Ian Bailey's background and history.

5 Upvotes

Seems like an odd place for an investigative reporter to move to. Is he one or just hiding out. I think he's had a shady past. Anyone know about his beginnings and what transpired before he moved to such an isolated area?