r/ModelNortheastCourts • • Jul 01 '19

19-04 | Dismissed Challenge to the Adoption of /u/mika3740 by /u/BorisTheRabid

0 Upvotes

May it please the Court—

The Secretary of State certifies official copies and commissions of U.S. documents and certain benefits, including but not limited to commissions to the potential benefit of military academies entered into by the dependents of military personnel.

Petitioner for adoption /u/BorisTheRabid is a pay scale level I retiree of the Department of Defense, and filed the “correct paperwork... for the Petition to Adopt” of claimed dependent /u/Mika3170 here.

The New York State Family and Surrogate Courts do not solely recognize a Petition to Adopt by Mr. Rabid of a dependent: a second motion, called Consent to Adult Adoption by Adoptee, must consequently be filed by the dependent Ms. Mika and approved by this Court. It has not been filed according to Court records.

At present, the adoption is not valid in the eyes of the Atlantic legislature and of the Secretaries of State, Defense/Homeland Security, Health and Human Servicea, Interior, or for any agency providing a federal benefit of adult adoption including but not limited to consideration under the Affordable Care Act at home or abroad under age 26: and could be referred to for analysis by the Department of Justice if any federal benefit was used by these parties.

Respectfully submitted,

caribofthedead

Secretary of State, Bureau of Consular Services


r/ModelNortheastCourts • • Aug 01 '18

Marriage Application for the marriage of /u/nothedarkweb and /u/realpepefarms

1 Upvotes

Application for Marriage, New York County, State of Atlantic Commonwealth

Comes the petitioner, /u/nothedarkweb

Honorable Justices, I petition that the following marriage license is accepted by this Court between myself and /u/realpepefarms. I further petition that this Court officates the ceremonial marriage between myself and /u/realpepefarms.The following persons are authorized to conduct a marriage ceremony: [...] a justice of the supreme court [...] Enclosed are the proper fees of New York County, the location of this Court, totalling $40.00

APPLICATION FOR MARRIAGE LICENSE, NEW YORK COUNTY, STATE OF ATLANTIC COMMONWEALTH

APPLICANT ONE

Name: /u/nothedarkweb

Requirements:

I have not been divorced within the last 30 days. ✓

I am not presently married. ✓

I am not presently delinquent in the payment of court ordered child support. ✓

The other applicant is not presently married. ✓

I am not related to the other applicant as: an ancestor or descendant, by blood or adoption; a brother or sister, of the whole or half blood or by adoption; a parent's brother or sister, of the whole or half blood or by adoption; a son or daughter of a brother or sister, of the whole or half blood or by adoption; a current or former stepchild or stepparent; or a son or daughter of a parent's brother or sister, of the whole or half blood or by adoption. ✓

I solemnly swear (or affirm) that the information I have given in this application is correct, /u/nothedarkweb

APPLICANT TWO

Name: /u/realpepefarms

Requirements:

I have not been divorced within the last 30 days. ✓

I am not presently married. ✓

I am not presently delinquent in the payment of court ordered child support. ✓

The other applicant is not presently married. ✓

I am not related to the other applicant as: an ancestor or descendant, by blood or adoption; a brother or sister, of the whole or half blood or by adoption; a parent's brother or sister, of the whole or half blood or by adoption; a son or daughter of a brother or sister, of the whole or half blood or by adoption; a current or former stepchild or stepparent; or a son or daughter of a parent's brother or sister, of the whole or half blood or by adoption. ✓

I solemnly swear (or affirm) that the information I have given in this application is correct, /u/realpepefarms


r/ModelNortheastCourts • • Dec 24 '21

OPINION | 21-04 Opinion for Dewey-Cheatem v. MyHouseIsOnFire, in re: Atlantic Defense of Firearms Act

1 Upvotes

21-04

/u/dewey-cheatem

Plaintiff,

v.

/u/MyHouseIsOnFire

in his official capacity as Governor,

Defendant,

in re: Atlantic Defense of Firearms Act

The Court has come to a decision in the present case, which challenges the constitutionality of the Atlantic Defense of Firearms Act. The full opinion may be found at the link below. The following is only a summary of the Court's decision, and constitutes no part of the opinion of the Court.

HurricaneofLies, C., delivered the opinion of a unanimous court. The court holds, among other things:

Held: Insofar as the Atlantic Defense of Firearms Act purports to supersede federal law or regulate federal officers, it is void and of no effect because it is conflict-preempted and violative of intergovernmental immunity under the Supremacy Clause of the U.S. Constitution. Because the remainder of the Act is inseverable, it is unconstitutional in its entirety.

  1. While the Legislature has every right to advocate for any constitutional interpretation of its choosing, it absolutely has no right to use the breadth of its legislative power to pass substantial regulations nullifying federal law and impeding the just supremacy of the United States. [paras 12-14]

  2. A state cannot impose liability on respect for federal law. [paras 15-18]

  3. The doctrine of intergovernmental immunity unambiguously sets out that federal officers ‘acting under and in pursuance of the laws of the United States’ enjoy absolute immunity from state regulation except as waived. [paras 20-25]

  4. The presence of a generic, pro forma severability clause has never been conclusive in our severability analysis, especially when there are serious reasons to doubt whether the Legislature would have enacted the remainder of the statute. [paras 26-28]


The full opinion may be found here


r/ModelNortheastCourts • • Aug 09 '17

17-04 | Decided In re: AB 152, The Means of Production Act

2 Upvotes

Now comes the petitioner /u/WampumDP, a resident of the Atlantic Commonwealth and a member of the Bar of the Atlantic Commonwealth Supreme Court, respectfully submitting a petition for a writ of certiorari asking the Court to question the constitutionality of A.B. 152, also known as the “Means of Production Act”.

There are many Constitutional questions in this law, but the first pertains to Amendment V of the United States Constitution. The petitioner argues that the actions in Section 3 Subsection 1-3 of AB 152 is an unjust “taking of property”, as there is no Due Process of Law, and it essentially eliminates the distinction explicitly made in the Constitution between “private use” and “public use” as all private use becomes public. Supreme Court Justice Sandra Day O'Connor voiced her concerns to a similar use of the taking clause in her dissent in Kelo v. New London. This use of the takings clause will only benefit "citizens with disproportionate influence and power in the political process". Keep in mind, the use of eminent domain, while Constitutional, was used to a much smaller extent than in AB 152. While a tax would not typically be deemed unconstitutional in accordance with the takings clause, this tax is clearly designed to confiscate businesses’ funds and the businesses themselves, which essentially makes it a "taking" rather than a tax, thus requiring compensation.

Amendment VIII of the United States Constitution is violated in the form of a 99% tax that certainly qualifies as an excessive fine, explicitly forbidden in the Constitution. AB 152 is grossly excessive, as there was no specific crime or wrongdoing at all. If lesser fines are imposed for actual wrongdoing, how can excessive fines be imposed for no wrong doing at all?

On top of the assertion that the taking of private property in Section 3 of AB 152 is unconstitutional in accordance with the takings clause, the actions of said section also qualify as an unjust seizure without a warrant as forbidden by Amendment IV of the U.S. Constitution.

Given the nature of this law taking away people’s livelihoods, and the harsh actions taken by the armed forces of multiple groups pertaining to this law, I ask that a stay be issued on any further actions pertaining to this bill’s implementation until the conclusion of the case.

Respectfully submitted,

/u/WampumDP, Lead Counsel, AC Citizen

/u/cubascastrodistrict, Former Legislator, AC Citizen


r/ModelNortheastCourts • • Oct 05 '18

Marriage Application for Marriage

2 Upvotes

Application for Marriage, New York County, State of Atlantic Commonwealth

Comes the petitioner, /u/AnswerMeNow1.

Honorable Justices, I petition that the following marriage license is accepted by this Court between myself and /u/Ninjjadragon. I further petition that this Court officates the ceremonial marriage between myself and /u/Ninjjadragon. The following persons are authorized to conduct a marriage ceremony: [...] a justice of the supreme court [...] Enclosed are the proper fees of New York County, the location of this Court, totalling $40.00 APPLICATION FOR MARRIAGE LICENSE, NEW YORK COUNTY, STATE OF ATLANTIC COMMONWEALTH

APPLICANT ONE

Name: /u/AnswerMeNow1

Requirements:

I have not been divorced within the last 30 days. ✓

I am not presently married. ✓

I am not presently delinquent in the payment of court ordered child support. ✓

The other applicant is not presently married. ✓

I am not related to the other applicant as: an ancestor or descendant, by blood or adoption; a brother or sister, of the whole or half blood or by adoption; a parent's brother or sister, of the whole or half blood or by adoption; a son or daughter of a brother or sister, of the whole or half blood or by adoption; a current or former stepchild or stepparent; or a son or daughter of a parent's brother or sister, of the whole or half blood or by adoption. ✓

I solemnly swear (or affirm) that the information I have given in this application is correct, /u/AnswerMeNow1.

APPLICANT TWO

Name: /u/Ninjjadragon

Requirements:

I have not been divorced within the last 30 days. ✓

I am not presently married. ✓

I am not presently delinquent in the payment of court ordered child support. ✓

The other applicant is not presently married. ✓

I am not related to the other applicant as: an ancestor or descendant, by blood or adoption; a brother or sister, of the whole or half blood or by adoption; a parent's brother or sister, of the whole or half blood or by adoption; a son or daughter of a brother or sister, of the whole or half blood or by adoption; a current or former stepchild or stepparent; or a son or daughter of a parent's brother or sister, of the whole or half blood or by adoption. ✓

I solemnly swear (or affirm) that the information I have given in this application is correct, /u/Ninjjadragon


r/ModelNortheastCourts • • Aug 21 '21

21-04 | Active In re A.B. 75: Atlantic Defense of Firearms Act of 2021

2 Upvotes

I. Introduction

A.B. 75, the so-called "Atlantic Defense of Firearms Act of 2021," describes itself as "a bill . . . to provide that all firearms manufactured, sold, purchased, and possessed exclusively within the Atlantic Commonwealth shall be exempt from federal law and regulations." The legislation then purports to do just that: "exempt" what it terms "intrastate ammunition, firearms, firearms parts, and firearms accessories" from "federal laws, taxation, regulations, and restrictions regarding firearms, including registration, under the authority of the United States Congress to regulate intrastate commerce." Sec. III(C).

The bill also provides that "[n]o official in the Atlantic Commonwealth shall be required or compelled by federal law enforcement officials to enforce federal laws, regulations, or restrictions in regard to" the so-called "intrastate ammunition, firearms, firearms parts, and firearms accessories". Id.

Neither of these sections is constitutional and should be so declared by this Court.

II. Violation of the Supremacy Clause

State law is under the Supremacy Clause "to the extent that it actually conflicts with a valid federal statute." Toll v. Moreno, 458 U.S. 1, 36 (1982) (quoting Ray v. Atlantic Richfield Co., 435 U.S. 151, 158 (1978)). Such a conflict exists where "compliance with both federal and state regulations is a physical impossibility" or where "the state law stands as an obstacle to the accomplishment and execution of the full purposes and objectives of Congress." Id.

Here, the challenged statute does that in the most obvious manner possible: by seeking to exempt persons within the jurisdiction of the state from federal law wholesale. State law that seeks to nullify federal law is per se in conflict with federal law, particularly when said nullification is undertaken with the specific purpose of being an "obstacle to the accomplishment and execution of the full purposes and objectives of Congress," Ray, 435 U.S. at 158, here, the lawful regulation of firearms.

For example, in Haywood v. Drown, 556 U.S. 729 (2009), New York State enacted a statute that deprived state courts of jurisdiction over suits by prisoners against state correction officers, including those filed pursuant to federal law, such as under 42 U.S.C. § 1983. The U.S. Supreme Court struck it down as unconstitutional, in violation of the Supremacy Clause. The Court explained that while states may "establish the contours of their judicial systems, they lack authority to nullify a federal right or cause of action they believe is inconsistent with their local policies." Id. at 736.

A similar situation exists here: Atlantic's legislature and executive passed legislation seeking to, in effect, "nullify" federal law within the state on the grounds that they believe federal law is "inconsistent with their local policies." As in Haywood, the challenged law here must fall.

III. Conclusion

For these reasons, and any others the Court deems appropriate, the Court should declare A.B. 75 unconstitutional.


r/ModelNortheastCourts • • Feb 17 '20

20-01 | Decided _MyHouseIsOnFire_ v. Nothedarkweb, in re: AB.285—The Green New Deal: 2019 Energy Act

3 Upvotes

/u/MyHouseIsOnFire

Petitioner,

v.

/u/nothedarkweb

in his official capacity as Attorney General,

Respondent.

In re: AB.285—The Green New Deal: 2019 Energy Act


Facts

Petitioner, Member of Congress for the state of Atlantic Commonwealth, is a resident of Atlantic submitting this writ of certiorari, in his personal capacity pursuant to Rule 2(c) and Atl. art. IV, to question the constitutionality of AB.285 The Green New Deal 2019 Act.

As an Atlantic citizen in the District, petitioner recently attempted to invest in Con Edison, a popular electric company in New York City.

The petitioner learned that AB.285 The Green New Deal 2019 Act has consolidated all electric companies into a single, state ran corporation:

State-Owned Utility: A corporation owned and controlled publically, by the Atlantic Commonwealth.

ACE is hereby established as a state-owned utility under the authority of the Atlantic Public Service Commission.

ACE shall be the sole entity allowed to use the Atlantic Electric Grid.

The total AB.033 Northeast Budget Beginning Oct 1 2019 has allocated around 360 billion dollars to the operations of the State of the Atlantic Commonwealth.

AB.285 The Green New Deal 2019 Act calls for appropriating one trillion, two hundred and fifty billion dollars in expenses over a ten year period. Spread evenly over ten years, the taxpayers must pay an additional one hundred and twenty five billion dollars per year.

Argument

Petitioner believes the Constitution of the Commonwealth law affects him personally, concretely, and particularly, like his constituents throughout the state. In “Argument” section I, plaintiff argues the law plainly violates the Atlantic Commonwealth Constitution, Article X, § A and the Atlantic Commonwealth Constitution, .

Corporations may be formed under general law; but shall not be created by special act, except for municipal purposes, and in cases where, in the judgment of the legislature, the objects of the corporation cannot be attained under general laws. All general laws and special acts passed pursuant to this section may be altered from time to time or repealed.

The petitioner believes that Amendment V of the United States Constitution is violated with the passage of AB.285. The petitioner argues that Sections 3 and 5 of AB AB.285 is an unjust “taking of property”, as there is no due process for the taking of said property. Amendment V also states “nor shall private property be taken for public use” showing their should be both public and private property. This bill effectively removes this distinction, turning private to public. In Youngstown Sheet & Tube Co. v. Sawyer, the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit ruled that the President of the United States does not have the authority to seize and operate steel mills, despite it being a time of war. This can be applied to AB.285 as property, and capital, is being taken from private individuals.

The petitioner also argues that Amendment IV of the United States Constitution is violated in §III of AB.285 with private property being unjustly taken without a warrant a violation of the taking clause.

The petitioner finally argues that Amendment VIII of the United States Constitution is violated by §IX of AB.285. Amendment VIII states “nor excessive fines imposed.” The total Atlantic Commonwealth Budget of October of 2019 has allocated around 360 billion dollars to the operations of the State of the Atlantic Commonwealth. A budget increase of 35% must occur in order to fund AB.285. The taxpayer will be the one footing the bill, so the taxpayer would be fined an excessive amount through §Xi of this bill.

Conclusion

Law AB.285 conflicts with the Constitution of the United States by taking the property of citizens of the United States without just cause. The line between public and private property is also blurred by AB.285. If the court finds this law, in its many sections, to be unconstitutional, the plaintiff asks for the court to strike the law down.


r/ModelNortheastCourts • • Jan 07 '20

19-14 | Decided BirackObama v. ohprkl, in re: AB.087—Community Health Act

3 Upvotes

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE ATLANTIC COMMONWEALTH

/u/BirackObama

Petitioner,

v.

/u/ohprkl

in his official capacity as Attorney General,

Respondent.

In re: AB.087—Community Health Act


The Court has certified the following complaint as substantially compliant with Atl. Rules of Court. It is reproduced in full as submitted, without modification.


In re AB.087: Community Health Act

Rep. BirackObama (AC-1) v. Gov. UnorthodoxAmbassador

“For a century, Connecticut farmers have grown some of the world's finest cigar wrapper tobacco.” — Connecticut Businessman Vince McMahon, Made in the Shade, Cigar Aficionado

Facts

Petitioner, Member of Congress for the First District, is a recent resident of Atlantic submitting this writ in his personal capacity pursuant to Rule 2(c) and Atl. art. IV.

As an Atlantic citizen in the District, petitioner recently attempted to patronize Staza Dei Sigari in Boston’s North End, complete an express delivery of Zig Zag Blueberry Blunt Wraps to his office, and planned a constituent forum with the shade tobacco growers of Connecticut (the second largest industry behind insurance).

In Dixie, petitioner had advocated for the safety and vitality of the national tobacco industry and was already familiar with the legendary role of the First District’s Connecticut River valley as a jewel of the international cigar market.

However, petitioner learned that AB.087: The Atlantic Community Health Act of 2019 recently prevented sales, commerce, and cultivation of Connecticut shade tobacco, the purchase of blunt wraps, and smoking sales at the city’s cigar and hookah bars, amongst other effects, mandating:

It shall be unlawful in this state for any corporation or other unnatural person to sell, make available for sale, advertise, cultivate any matter or substance containing tobacco.

It shall be unlawful for any corporation or other unnatural person to cause any matter or substance containing tobacco to be transported into this state, or to transport such substance or matter into this state.

Argument

Petitioner believes the Commonwealth law affects him personally, concretely, and particularly, like his constituents throughout the District. In “Argument” section I, plaintiff argues the law plainly violates judicial precedent and federal First and Fourteenth Amendments binding the state (Atl. Const. art. III, see also art. I: protection of civil rights).

The state law also is preempted by two bedrock federal statutes enacted to ensure uniformity in tobacco regulation described in “Argument” section II.

Separately, although not focused in this claim, petitioner relays to the Court his belief that this regulation is an illegal uncompensated taking of property prohibited by Atl. Const. art. I and X (excessive fines prohibited; requirement to pay for corporate “indebtedness” caused; free exercise of religion, see e.g. Atlantic Native American Mid Winter Ceremony tobacco offerings.

The statute fails the four-part commercial speech standard in the landmark Central Hudson Gas & Electric Corp. v. New York Public Service Commission, 447 U.S. 557 (1980).

In New York Public Serv. Comm., an 8-1 bench articulated a standing test for similar total restrictions on the promotion of electricity use during the 1973 oil embargo. The Court’s analysis in four parts was:

Is the expression protected by the First Amendment?

For speech to come within that provision, it must concern lawful activity and not be misleading. Tobacco use and in particular growing is a lawful and protected activity, yet the regulation does not address any specific trade practice for review to supersede that protected constitutional interest.

Is the asserted governmental interest substantial?

While a government interest in tobacco uses may be inarguable, the state’s approach is the nation’s first complete abolition of not only use, but trade and growth of tobacco.

Does the regulation directly advance the governmental interest asserted?

The regulation is not tailored to address a direct interest. While the title states “Community Health,” there is no explicit goal within the law toward community health. There is no preamble or statement. The law begins with the power of the state to preside over interstate commerce of tobacco into or out of the Commonwealth, and ends with a complete civil prohibition over the trade:

This Act shall not be interpreted as criminalizing the transportation, sale, or possession of tobacco by any natural person not acting as an agent or employee of any entity otherwise covered by this Act.

Is the regulation more extensive than is necessary to serve that interest?

There must be a "reasonable fit" between the government's ends and the means for achieving those ends. Abolition, as in alcohol prohibition, is historically found as overbroad and unreasonable under law.

As recently as 2001 in the First District, the Court applied the above standard to strike down laws banning tobacco advertising and sales within 1,000 feet of schools on the basis of freedom of speech. Lorillard v. Reilly, 533 U.S. 525 (2001) (Massachusetts' ban on advertising and tobacco sales was both overbroad and was preempted by the landmark Federal Cigarette Labeling and Advertising Act of 1966).

See also 44 Liquormart, Inc. v. Rhode Island, 517 U.S. 484 (1996) (holding that a complete ban on the advertising of alcohol prices was unconstitutional under the First Amendment, and that the Twenty-first Amendment, empowering the states to regulate alcohol, did not lessen other constitutional restraints of state power); Zauderer v. Office of Disciplinary Counsel of Supreme Court of Ohio, 471 U.S. 626 (1985) (finding that a state may require advertisers to include "purely factual and uncontroversial" disclosures without violating the First Amendment rights of the advertiser as long as the disclosure is in the State's interest in preventing deception of consumers: the Zauderer Standard).

The Atlantic regulation is expressly preempted and cannot stand review.

The Supreme Court held that the above Massachusetts regulation was preempted by federal law. See Supremacy Clause, U.S. Const. art. VI., § 2; see also Atl. Const. art. III.

As a member of the Social Concerns Committee, petitioner is familiar with the Family Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act of 2009 and points to the express preemption clauses within it.

The Tobacco Control Act preempts the Atlantic statute in at least four ways:

  • It constitutes a “tobacco product standard,” and the authority for this is expressly reserved to the FDA in Section 21 U.S.C. 387p(a)(2)(A);

  • HHS and FDA are prohibited from banning certain classes of tobacco products, explicitly cigars and cigarettes, and so state and local governments are prohibited from doing so through a sales regulation (id);

  • Even if state and local governments have the power to restrict the sale of a certain class of tobacco products, they are barred from completely prohibiting the sale of such products by law.

  • The Act’s saving clause excepts from preemption local laws that establish “requirements relating to the sale… of… tobacco products,” but not the absolute prohibition of covered trade.

See U.S. Smokeless Tobacco Mfg. Co. LLC v. City of New York, 708 F.3d 428 (2013) (holding that the City’s ordinance prohibiting the sale of any flavored non-cigarette tobacco product in tobacco bars was preempted by the Tobacco Control Act); Nat’l Ass’n of Tobacco Outlets v. City of Providence, 2012 WL 6128707, 13 (2012) (striking from the City ordinance prohibitions on the sale of flavored non-cigarette tobacco products in tobacco bars).

The Tobacco Control Act’s legislative history is clear: as part of a broad 2009 push for financial and healthcare reform, the act included benefits for the target industry.

  • The law separately prohibits the FDA from using its new authority to increase the new federal minimum age of 18 to a higher level, require prescriptions for the purchase of tobacco products, ban tobacco product sales in any particular type of sales outlet, or regulate tobacco farming directly.

  • It prohibits states from placing requirements on cigarette or smokeless tobacco product labeling or on the content of cigarette advertisements. It gives the FDA exclusive authority to establish tobacco product standards, prohibit adulterated or misbranded tobacco products, establish labeling requirements, and regulate manufacturing standards and modified-risk tobacco products, preempting previously existing state and local authority to do so. Similarly, the law preempts state governments from licensing tobacco manufacturers and suppliers exclusively for tobacco product regulation purposes.

  • Congress has deemed it proper to limit state product liability cases, which cannot claim that cigarette companies failed to warn them of the health effects of smoking after 1969, when the Advertising Act preemptive language went into effect. Nor can plaintiffs bring claims based on legal theories of negligence or misrepresentation by omission.

Conclusion

The Atlantic law completely prohibiting the sale and cultivation of tobacco products impermissibly conflicts with federal law by establishing disruptive tobacco product standards, overbroadly regulating the distribution of a lawfully protected product, while prohibiting an entire class of commerce without a reasonably tailored purpose.

Although not asserted in this claim, it likely exceeds petitioner’s First and Fourteenth Amendment speech and due process claims to stretch across the First District including unlawful taking of business and farm property with no statutory or Atlantic constitutional compensation. It also interferes with his constituent services to the migrant farmers of Atlantic and the religious interests of some residents (e.g., Native Americans).

Petitioner does not argue the power of the Commonwealth to regulate tobacco products, but by completely prohibiting the sale of a class of products or all of them, the Assembly is establishing an impermissible standard which is preempted by uniform federal law and a violation of federal and Commonwealth rights.

THEREFORE, petitioner respectfully requests declaratory relief from the Court pertaining to the constitutionality of the Atlantic Community Health Act.

Respectfully submitted,

Rep. Birack “Carib” Obama, Esq.


r/ModelNortheastCourts • • Nov 05 '19

19-11 | OPINION Opinion for Aubrion v. Parado-I, in re: Executive Orders 13, 15, 16

3 Upvotes

19-11

/u/Aubrion

Petitioner-intervenor,

v.

/u/Parado-I

in her official capacity as Governor of the Commonwealth,

Respondent,

in re: Executive Orders 13, 15 and 16


The Court has come to a decision in the present case, which challenges the legality of Executive Orders 13, 15 and 16. The full opinion may be found at the link below. The following is only a summary of the Court's decision, and constitutes no part of the opinion of the Court.

Hurricaneoflies, J., delivered the opinion of a unanimous court. The Court holds, among other things:

  1. The Governor has no authority, whether statutory or at common law, to impose a tax on income. Executive Order 13 is consequently held to be unconstitutional.

  2. The power to appropriate funding lies with the General Assembly and the Governor’s allocation of $1 million to the Attorney General is ultra vires the power of her office. Executive Order 15 is held to be unconstitutional insofar as it purports to appropriate such an amount.

  3. The clause of Executive Order 15 in question is severable and the remainder of the Order remains in force.

  4. A challenged provision of law must be afforded a loose construction even when doubts about constitutionality exist. Executive Order 16 is constitutional insofar as it directs the Department of Energy to employ its discretionary spending towards the purpose outlined in the Order.


The full opinion may be found here


r/ModelNortheastCourts • • Jun 23 '19

19-03 | Mistrial Criminal Complaint: Atlantic Commonwealth v GuiltyAir

3 Upvotes

Your Honor,

May it please the court, comes now Mika3740 Governor of Atlantic to present a criminal complaint.

Jurisdiction and Procedure

This court has jurisdiction over criminal matters in Atlantic, and no other court exists which offers relief besides this one. The Rules of Criminal Procedure of the Supreme Court of the United States assert jurisdiction only over federal law, and I come with a complaint under state law.

Unfortunately, this court provides no rules of criminal procedure. In order to make my complaint as clear as possible, I am seeking to following those rules as if you had adopted them for this court.

Per those rules, the Attorney General or a Special Prosecutor or the President may bring a complaint. As our executive is a Governor not a President, I have brought the complaint.

Pre those rules, the State should modmail a criminal complaint to the court. Unfortunately you are not a mod of this sub, so I have instead filed it publicly. Should you accept this complaint, those rules then allow you to summon the defendant for seating of a grand jury (as is required by New York State law for felony indictments).

The Complaint

The penal code of Atlantic (NY Penal L § 255.15 (2016) defines the crime of bigamy as marrying someone when you are already married. GuiltyAir was married in the former state of Sacagewea and again by this court. The State believes this is sufficient evidence of a crime to summon GuiltyAir and seat a grand jury for indictment and requests that you do so.


r/ModelNortheastCourts • • Jan 07 '20

19-15 | Decided Kingmaker502 v. UnorthodoxAmbassador, in re: Executive Order 25—Marriage and Polygamy

3 Upvotes

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE ATLANTIC COMMONWEALTH

/u/Kingmaker502

Petitioner,

v.

/u/UnorthodoxAmbassador

in his official capacity as Governor of the Commonwealth,

Respondent.

In re: Executive Order 25—Marriage And Polygamy


The Court has certified the following complaint as substantially compliant with Atl. Rules of Court. It is reproduced in full as submitted, without modification.


Kingmaker502 v. unorthodoxambassador, in re: Executive Order 25

Comes petitioner, /u/Kingmaker502, requesting the Honorable Justices of this Court to grant a writ of certiorari to review the constitutionality of Executive Order 25: Marriage and Polygamy.

1. Jurisdiction

The Atlantic Commonwealth Supreme Court has original jurisdiction for conflicts “arising under the Laws and Constitution of the Atlantic Commonwealth.” AC-ROC 2(a).

2. Claim - Executive Order 38 violates the Atlantic Commonwealth Constitution

Executive Order 25: Marriage and Polygamy was issued by Governor Parado-I on November 22, 2019. The order allows for the issuance of marriage licenses to multi-person relationships. Although Section 3 is not facially unconstitutional, it is worth discussing:

"[t]he Atlantic Commonwealth will prosecute no cases which deal with AC Penal L § 255.15."

It is within the power of the Governor to direct executive agencies under his purview (such as the Department of Justice) as he sees fit. Therefore, by itself, Section 3 is perfectly acceptable from a constitutional standpoint (both state and federal). However, Section 2 muddies the waters:

"[l]icenses to engage in "Marriage" or a civil union shall be issued to people with no discrimination in place being put in place with regard to the number of spouses."

This section directly urges clerks to violate the law by creating a new legal requirement that directly conflicts with AC Penal L § 255.15 as established by the Assembly. In addition, as with any legal requirement, the Executive Order seems to indicate a penalty for failing to break the law.

Article V(A) of the Atlantic Commonwealth Constitution states that:

"[t]he legislative powers of the Atlantic Commonwealth shall be fully vested in a General Assembly of the Atlantic Commonwealth."

The Executive of the Atlantic Commonwealth does not have the vested power of modifying state statutes to their will, and is effectively attempting to repeal law and establish their own by executive fiat. In no way or manner did the Assembly delegate such power to the Governor to legalize bigamy or polygamy, nor did the Assembly ever indicate that it desires as such (as evidenced by AC Penal L § 255.15).

3. Questions for the Court

  1. Does Executive Order 25, Section 2 violate Article V(A) of the Atlantic Commonwealth Constitution by conflicting with AC Penal L § 255.15?

4. Relief/Conclusion

I request that the Honorable Justices of this Court seek to provide relief as soon as possible by striking down E.O. 25, Section 2 as an unconstitutional exercise of executive power. Thank you.


r/ModelNortheastCourts • • Nov 06 '19

19-13 | Dismissed St. Thomas More Catholic High School v. Tucklet1911

3 Upvotes

The Court has certified the following complaint as substantially compliant with Atl. Rules of Court. It is reproduced in full as submitted, without modification.


ST. THOMAS MORE CATHOLIC HIGH SCHOOL

BY AND THROUGH THEIR ATTORNEY JOSEPH IBNEY

V.

/u/TUCKLET1911

IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS SECRETARY OF EDUCATION OF THE ATLANTIC COMMONWEALTH

Your honors,

Now comes Joseph Ibney, barred attorney in good standing with this mighty court, humbly requesting certiorari in the following action:

QUESTIONS PRESENTED

Whether the Secretary of Education may require Private and Religious High Schools to mandate classes which are in contradiction with their religion?


TABLE OF AUTHORITIES

CONSTITUTIONAL

CASE LAW

BACKGROUND

On November 5th, 2019, Secretary /u/Tucklet1911 released Labor, Education, Health, and Human Services Directive 12 which required all "high schools" defined as "any school which teaches grades 9th through 12th" to require LGBTQ+ classes within their curriculum, and requiring all students to pass such a class to graduate. That same day, the petitioner contacted the offices of Joseph Ibney and asked that suit be filed.


GROUNDS FOR GRANTING CERTIORARI

Your honors, the directive as it stands requires that all high schools within the Atlantic Commonwealth teach "about the LGBTQ+ community, LGBTQ+ rights movements, and other relevant topics." This is in direct violation of the first amendment by requiring the teaching of doctrine in contrast to plaintiffs' religious beliefs.

St. Thomas More Catholic High School is a religious school whose doctrine believes LGBTQ+ adherence and lifestyle is immoral. By the state requiring private religious schools to teach about such topics, plaintiff asserts that the state is mandating a doctrine against a religion.

In Reynolds v. United States, 98 U.S. 145 (1878), the First Amendment was applied to the many states within the United States. This thus applies to the Atlantic Commonwealth. The Constitution of the Atlantic Commonwealth even requires that all private religious schools receive no public funding within Article XI. There is no standing for the state to mandate any doctrine relating to religious beliefs.


RELIEF

For the reasons above, we request the court strike down Labor, Education, Health, and Human Services Directive 12 for violating the First Amendment of the United States Constitution.

Respectfully submitted,

Joseph Ibney esq.

Barred Attorney


r/ModelNortheastCourts • • Nov 06 '19

19-12 | Perm. Inj. OptimizedUmbrella v. Parado-i, In re: Executive Order 24

3 Upvotes

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE ATLANTIC COMMONWEALTH

/u/OptimizedUmbrella,

petitioner

v.

/u/parado-i

in their official capacity as Governor of the Commonwealth,

Respondent.

In re: Executive Order 24: Mexican Aid


The Court has certified the following complaint as substantially compliant with Atl. Rules of Court. It is reproduced in full as submitted, without modification.


JURISDICTION AND VENUE

The claims herein arise under Section 4 of the State Finance Law.

This court has jurisdiction over the matter pursuant to AC-ROC 2(b), which prescribes that the Court shall have jurisdiction to hear cases arising under the Laws and Constitution of the Atlantic Commonwealth and the former state of New York.

PARTIES

Petitioner /u/OptimizedUmbrella is a citizen of the Atlantic Commonwealth.

The Governor is the chief executive officer of the state, responsible for overseeing the operations of the state and the faithful execution of its laws.

QUESTION PRESENTED

Did the governor exceed their constitutional powers by issuing an executive order providing funds to state agencies contrary to Section 4 of the State Finance Law?

THE GOVERNOR ISSUED AN EXECUTIVE ORDER CONTRADICTORY TO THE STATE FINANCE LAW OVERVIEW

On October 3, 2019, Governor Parado-I issued Executive Order 24 (hereinafter the “Executive Order”), allocating ten million dollars to be disbursed to various aid groups. The executive order further provided that twenty million dollars be provided to the Department of Agriculture and Markets, and instructed the Department of Health to expend ten million dollars on medical supplies.

At issue here is whether the governor improperly applied Article IV of the Constitution of the Atlantic Commonwealth in order to allocate additional funds to various aid groups and the Department of Agriculture and Markets, as well as instruct the Department of Health to expend ten million dollars on medical supplies, in contradiction to the State Finance Law.

THE STATE FINANCE LAW HAS SUPREMACY OVER THE EXECUTIVE ORDER

Executive Orders are not laws. The Constitution of the Atlantic Commonwealth makes this fact abundantly clear, vesting the sole legislative power of the Atlantic Commonwealth in the General Assembly of the Atlantic Commonwealth. A.C. Const. art. V §A.

Executive Orders are meant to serve as directives to departments internal to the Executive branch. Article IV of the Constitution of the Atlantic Commonwealth makes this abundantly clear stating that, “The Governor may issue executive orders, demanding action by an executive department or branch.” A.C. Const. art. IV, § C, cl. C.

THE EXECUTIVE ORDER CONTRADICTS THE STATE FINANCE LAW

The Executive Order provides for the allocation and payment of forty million dollars to various internal departments, as well as external aid groups.

These provisions contradict the State Finance Law, which prescribes that: “no money shall be paid from any fund under the management of the state, or any agency or officer thereof except in pursuance of an appropriation by law.” N.Y. State Finance Law § 4.

As executive orders are not laws, the payment of money from state funds by the Executive Order does not constitute an appropriation by law for the purposes of the State Finance Law, thus placing the Executive Order in conflict with this provision.

THE STATE LAW SUPERSEDES THE EXECUTIVE ORDER

The Constitution of the Atlantic Commonwealth provides that, “Where there is no conflict [with the Constitution], the laws of the State of New York shall govern, except where the laws passed by the Atlantic Commonwealth conflict with them, in which case the simulation law shall be supreme.” A.C. Const. art III, § A.

The supremacy of New York Law, of which the statute at issue is part, implicitly means that relevant statutes will supersede inferior governing authorities, such as the Executive Order.

FIRST CAUSE OF ACTION

(State Finance Law - Appropriation of Funds)

Plaintiff realleges and incorporates the allegations set forth in each of the preceding paragraphs of this complaint.

Section 4 of the State Finance Law prohibits the expenditure of state funds without an appropriation by law.

Sections 1, 2, and 3 of the Executive Order expend state funds without an appropriation by law, in violation of the State Finance Law.

Respondent’s violation causes ongoing harm to petitioner.

PRAYER FOR RELIEF

WHEREFORE, Petitioner prays that the Court:

Declare that Sections I, II, and III of the Executive Order are unauthorized by and contrary to the Constitution and laws of the Atlantic Commonwealth;

Enjoin respondent from implementing or enforcing Sections I, II, and III of the Executive Order; and Award such additional relief as the interests of justice may require.

DATED this 3rd day of November, 2019.

Respectfully Submitted,
/s/OptimizedUmbrella

r/ModelNortheastCourts • • Aug 27 '19

19-05 | Dismissed cold_brew_coffee v. unorthodoxambassador

1 Upvotes

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE ATLANTIC COMMONWEALTH

/u/cold_brew_coffee

Petitioner,

v.

/u/unorthodoxambassador

in their official capacity as Attorney General of the Commonwealth,

Respondent.


The Court has certified the following complaint as substantially compliant with Atl. Rules of Court. It is reproduced in full as submitted, without modification.


Your honor,

May it please the court, comes, now concerned, God fearing, concerned citizen Mr. Cold B Coffee (/u/cold_brew_coffee) to present a complaint against the State Government of Atlantic. Your court has jurisdiction over this case as the law in question was an Atlantic State law passed by the Assembly and signed by Governor Mika 6footharvey.

I am seeking a review of [AB 073] (https://docs.google.com/document/d/1g0xlM5e9SMTFm5j5xUQJJE-6DXsE5q04wkFij5ub-Uo/edit) the Common Sense Gun Control Act on the grounds that it violates the right of individuals to keep and bear arms as established by the Second Amendment and affirmed by DC v. Heller. In McDonald v. City of Chicago the Second Amendment was incorporated to the states under the due process clause of the 14th Amendment. All in all, the complainant argues that AB 073 violates established precedent on gun control issues and by prohibiting concealed carry, violates an individual’s right to keep and bear arms.

References:

[The Second Amendment] (https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/second_amendment)

[The Fourteenth Amendment] (https://www.law.cornell.edu/constitution/amendmentxiv)

[DC v. Heller] (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/District_of_Columbia_v._Heller)

[Mcdonald v. City of Chicago] (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McDonald_v._City_of_Chicago)

[Caetano v. Massachusetts] (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caetano_v._Massachusetts#Opinion_of_the_Court)

[In Re: The Constitution of the Atlantic Commonwealth] (https://old.reddit.com/r/ModelNortheastCourts/comments/bvewnq/in_re_the_constitution_of_the_atlantic/)

Background:

The law in question prohibited the use of concealed carry firearms, preempted local concealed carry laws, and changed state statutes so that an individual can only receive a concealed carry permit from the attorney general after obtaining written recommendation from law enforcement. This law adds unnecessary and onerous restrictions to obtaining a concealed carry permit and violates an individual’s right to bear arms.

Why:

The complainant has come forward to the Atlantic Supreme Court asking the question of does Common Sense Gun Control Act violate an individual’s right to bear arms? The complainant hopes that the court hears the case and rules strikes the law due to its unconstitutionality.

In DC v. Heller, Washington DC’s handgun ban was ruled unconstitutional, and the case established the precedent that an individual has the right to bear and keep firearms. DC, being a federal district, is not a state; and the Heller decision was thus not applied to the states. However, the Mcdonald v. City of Chicago decision applied the Heller precedent to the states by invoking the equal protection clause of the 14th Amendment, meaning that the individual right to keep and bear firearms was valid precedent in state law as well.

In a per curiam decision, the Supreme Court, in Caetano v. Massachusetts, again ruled that the Second Amendment applies to the states and further ruled that the Second Amendment extends, prima facie, to all instruments that constitute bearable arms, even those that were not in existence at the time of the founding.

The complainant believes that by in most cases disallowing concealed carry, the Common Sense Gun Control Act hereby violates standing precedent and violates an individual’s right to keep and bear firearms.

The complainant also believes that his argument is “extremely convincing” and by using established Atlantic precedent, which was set in In Re: The Constitution of the Atlantic Commonwealth, believes that the court should side with the complantiant and rule that the law in question hereby violates an individual’s right to keep and bear firearms.00


r/ModelNortheastCourts • • Aug 27 '21

OPINION | 21-03 Opinion for KellinQuinn__ v. _MyHouseIsOnFire_, in re: Atlantic Borders Act

4 Upvotes

21-03

/u/KellinQuinn__

Plaintiff-Intervenor,

v.

/u/MyHouseIsOnFire

in his official capacity as Governor,

Defendant,

in re: Atlantic Borders Act

The Court has come to a decision in the present case, which challenges the constitutionality of the Atlantic Borders Act. The full opinion may be found at the link below. The following is only a summary of the Court's decision, and constitutes no part of the opinion of the Court.

HurricaneofLies, C., delivered the opinion of a unanimous court. The court holds, among other things:

Held: The Atlantic Borders Act is unconstitutional because the Commonwealth’s boundaries were fixed by democratic consent at the Constitution’s framing and cannot be expanded except by constitutional amendment.

  1. We are hesitant to invoke preemption and ultimately resolve the case on state constitutional grounds, since preemption does not arise unless it is the “clear and manifest purpose of Congress.” However, while preemption is a close question, the question of who lawfully owns Delaware and Maryland is not: Greater Appalachia indisputably does. [paras 11-17]

  2. The Atlantic Commonwealth is not only some mere abstract idea but rather a physical space with actual residents, and the Commonwealth Constitution is only supreme within the boundaries of this space. [paras 19-23]

  3. The constitutional definition of the Atlantic Commonwealth comprises the lands and waters in which the Commonwealth Constitution is supreme, which do not include Delaware or Maryland. [paras 24-27]

  4. Because the Legislature derives its substantive authority from the Commonwealth Constitution, the structural limitations of the Constitution serve to delineate the maximal breadth of the legislative power. Neither the legislature nor the executive departments may alter the definition of the Atlantic Commonwealth within our constitutional topology except by constitutional amendment. [paras 28-36]


The full opinion may be found here


r/ModelNortheastCourts • • Nov 30 '19

N/A | OPINION Advisory Opinion in the matter of Parado-I

Thumbnail
docs.google.com
1 Upvotes

r/ModelNortheastCourts • • Aug 06 '21

OPINION | 21-02 Opinion for Nat'l Org. for Reform of Marijuana Laws v. _MyHouseIsOnFire_, in re: Penal Law § 221.55

2 Upvotes

21-02

National Organization for the Reform of Marijuana Laws

Petitioner:

v.

/u/MyHouseIsOnFire

in his official capacity as Governor,

Respondent,

in re: Penal Law § 221.55

The Court has come to a decision in the present case, which challenges Penal Law § 221.55 on the theory that its enactment exceeds the Legislature's power under the Public Health Clause of the Commonwealth Constitution, or is in the alternative arbitrary and capricious.

In a per curiam decision delivered without noted dissent, the Court holds that Penal Law § 221.55 is a valid exercise of the Commonwealth's police power and is not arbitrary or capricious.

Disposition: Penal Law § 221.55 upheld.


The full opinion may be found here


r/ModelNortheastCourts • • Apr 15 '17

17-01 | Decided In re: CA 27 Right to Gainful employment

1 Upvotes

I, Fewbuffalo, do hereby petition the Chief Judge for a writ of certiorari on behalf of my client /u/goldencapitalist and act as his legal representative as a legal resident of the Atlantic Commonwealth in this case.

My Client /u/goldencapitalist has concerns in regards to the passage of CA 27. My Client and I believe it has failed to pass due to Article XV, Section B of the Commonwealth Constitution stating that “This amendment must pass the assembly by a ⅔ majority vote,” The Constitution of the Commonwealth is supplemented by the New York State Constitution which states in ARTICLE XIX that “ if the amendment or amendments as proposed or as amended shall be agreed to by a majority of the members elected to each of the two houses, such proposed amendment or amendments shall be entered on their journals, and the ayes and noes taken thereon, and referred to the next regular legislative session convening after the succeeding general election of members of the assembly,”

It is our belief that for an amendment to pass, the majority of the ELECTED members must be in favour. This has not happened in regards to CA 27.

Mr Chief Justice, I ask thee to consider this case.


r/ModelNortheastCourts • • Feb 05 '18

Meta Notice of suspension of the Atlantic Commonwealth Bar Requirement

4 Upvotes

The bar requirement to argue before this court is hereby suspended.

State courts can be a useful tool to prepare people for arguments before the Supreme Court, and given the infrequency of the Supreme Court Bar exam, this Court believes it is a helpful to suspend the bar requirement.

While the requirement is suspended this Court still recommends that parties find adequate legal counsel, which will often times be someone who has passed the SCOTUS bar or a one of the state bars.

Parties should remember that if they choose legal counsel that has not passed the SCOTUS bar, they will probably need to find different counsel if they wish to appeal to SCOTUS.

General rules regarding standing still apply of course.


r/ModelNortheastCourts • • Apr 03 '18

Meta Application For Marriage

1 Upvotes

Application for Marriage, New York County, State of Atlantic Commonwealth

Comes the petitioner, /u/Slothiel.

Honorable Justices, I petition that the following marriage license is accepted by this Court between myself and /u/GuiltyAir. I further petition that this Court officates the ceremonial marriage between myself and /u/GuiltyAir The following persons are authorized to conduct a marriage ceremony: [...] a justice of the supreme court [...] Enclosed are the proper fees of New York County, the location of this Court, totalling $40.00

APPLICATION FOR MARRIAGE LICENSE, NEW YORK COUNTY, STATE OF ATLANTIC COMMONWEALTH

APPLICANT ONE

Name: /u/Slothiel

Requirements:

I have not been divorced within the last 30 days. ✓

I am not presently married. ✓

I am not presently delinquent in the payment of court ordered child support. ✓

The other applicant is not presently married. ✓

I am not related to the other applicant as: an ancestor or descendant, by blood or adoption; a brother or sister, of the whole or half blood or by adoption; a parent's brother or sister, of the whole or half blood or by adoption; a son or daughter of a brother or sister, of the whole or half blood or by adoption; a current or former stepchild or stepparent; or a son or daughter of a parent's brother or sister, of the whole or half blood or by adoption. ✓

I solemnly swear (or affirm) that the information I have given in this application is correct, /u/Slothiel.

APPLICANT TWO

Name: /u/GuiltyAir

Requirements:

I have not been divorced within the last 30 days. ✓

I am not presently married. ✓

I am not presently delinquent in the payment of court ordered child support. ✓

The other applicant is not presently married. ✓

I am not related to the other applicant as: an ancestor or descendant, by blood or adoption; a brother or sister, of the whole or half blood or by adoption; a parent's brother or sister, of the whole or half blood or by adoption; a son or daughter of a brother or sister, of the whole or half blood or by adoption; a current or former stepchild or stepparent; or a son or daughter of a parent's brother or sister, of the whole or half blood or by adoption. ✓

I solemnly swear (or affirm) that the information I have given in this application is correct, /u/GuiltyAir


r/ModelNortheastCourts • • Jun 15 '21

INJ DEN | 21-02-A [21-02] Order Denying Preliminary Injunction

1 Upvotes

The Court of Chancery has DENIED the application for a preliminary injunction in Case No. 21-02, pertaining to Penal Law 221.55, criminal sale of marihuana in the first degree.


The link to the full order can be found here


r/ModelNortheastCourts • • May 25 '21

21-02 | Decided In re Atlantic Penal Law § 221.55

2 Upvotes

In the Court of Chancery for the Atlantic Commonwealth

In re Atlantic Penal Law § 221.55

National Organization for the Reform of Marijuana Laws v. MyHouseIsOnFire

NOTICE OF PETITION & PETITION

The filing can be found here in Google Document formatting, and here in PDF formatting. The PDF is the final version and controls — even though the document is an exact copy of the PDF.

<<electronic signature>>

Jacob I. Austin, Counsel of Record, Law Office of Jacob I. Austin, 401 Congress Avenue, Austin, Dixie 78701, [email protected], Attorney for Petitioner


r/ModelNortheastCourts • • Jun 20 '21

Rejected In re Atlantic Borders Act

1 Upvotes

r/ModelNortheastCourts • • Jun 23 '21

21-03 | Decided In re Atlantic Borders Act

2 Upvotes

In the Court of Chancery of the Atlantic Commonwealth

In re Atlantic Borders Act

Jacob I. Austin v. MyHouseIsOnFire, in his official capacity as Governor of the Atlantic Commonwealth

COMPLAINT & SUMMONS

The filing can be found here in Google Document formatting, and here in PDF formatting. The PDF is the final version and controls — even though the document is an exact copy of the PDF.

<<electronic signature>>

Jacob I. Austin, Counsel of Record, Law Office of Jacob I. Austin, 401 Congress Avenue, Austin, Dixie 78701, [email protected], Attorney for Plaintiff


r/ModelNortheastCourts • • May 22 '21

Granted Sorry to invade the court sub

2 Upvotes

I’m making sure it works