r/MetaAnime • • Jan 07 '15

Resolved I was banned from /r/anime. So what rules did I break?

128 Upvotes

Earlier today someone made a /r/MetaAnime post about a bot that remove people flairs if their flairs are not anime lists. Here is the post of that topic (it seem to have been removed): https://www.reddit.com/r/MetaAnime/comments/2rimqv/i_wrote_you_mods_a_bot_that_automatically_removes/

Since the post was removed from /r/MetaAnime, if any of the mods have a problem with me linking this post just let me know and I'll remove it. Instead of banning me.

Anyway, after that post was made I posted this comment

No. I like my flair of "GIVE ME GOLD". Plus some people don't have anime list accounts or prefer not to post their list. So instead of leaving it empty, many people add whatever.

That is really random, making a bot that remove flairs.

A while after I posted that comment, I was banned from /r/anime for

"Don't beg for gold and don't abuse the flair system." Image here http://i.imgur.com/yzIUKYM.png

If you look up at the image you'll notice that I sent back a reply. No mods has replied back. Except one (privately) but I don't know if he will get in trouble since the mod or mods have a tight grip on the ban hammer. So I won't name em.

So I checked the wiki and the rules of /r/anime, to make sure I didn't mess up on my part. Checking the rules of /r/anime I see absolutely no mention about anything relating to the flair system or about begging for gold. Unless of course I didn't read the rules correctly and it's actually on the wiki then I apologize.

Looking through Reddit site rules, I see no mention about people begging for gold, only upvotes. I have been on /r/anime for a while now and the only "begging for gold" I ever did is from my flair "GIVE ME GOLD!". The flair I used for /r/anime. The flair that I had for 1 to 2 months already. A little over a month I'll say. With a flair like that for about 1 month and not one mod comments about it or even mention it. So I was ban for "begging for gold" when that rule is no where to be found? Does me having "GIVE ME GOLD!" as my flair seem like I'm actually trying to get gold? It's just a flair. Plus not one mod ever mention about my flair or even tell me to change it. Edit 2: I have never begged for gold on /r/anime. So it isn't like I just kept doing it and ignoring warnings.

You state "and don't abuse the flair system". Because /r/anime does not have any rules about the flair system then my interpretation about abusing the flair system is, not posting your anime list and writing something different. If that is the case then there are many other users on /r/anime that are breaking this unwritten rule.

  1. With absolutely no warning at all I was banned from /r/anime and not only that, there are no rules on /r/anime that state you cannot beg for gold or "abuse" the flair system. Whatever that is. So how am I suppose to know it was against the rules when it's not on the rules page. There is no mention about it.

  2. If the mods didn't like my flair or if the mods don't want people begging for gold, a simple "please change your flair" would have suffice. Instead of giving a ban and no warning was giving before. Also I have never purposely broken any rules and I have never received any warning from any of the mods before.

So is it fair to ban someone because they weren't allow to "beg for gold" or "abusing" the flair system when there is no rules about that or even any warning about doing that?

Edit: Again, I do not see it on the wiki. If it actually there and I missed it then I apologize and this post is pretty useless. But a warning should have been better instead of a banning.

Edit 2: So my ban is for 3 days :/

well I guess i'll just wait it out. Maybe take a break from reddit. Since my account was created i have been on reddit everyday (i think)! Well nothing change and it seem the mods or mod won't change their decision. Might just be one mod. I don't know. I won't let this go.

As someone else also said here, it isn't like the unwritten rule is a given or "common sense". You can't just assume that people will have to know that you are not allow to put anything except profile links. I don't think a lot of people think it that big of a deal that someone will get a ban for it. Maybe a "please change your flair" comment.

I hope that this thread doesn't get remove since it now linked to SRD. I think many people from /r/anime should also be able to see this thread.

Edit 3: GUYS! STOP!

Yeah, I probably could have handled that better (referring to my original comment). The rule was in the original post about flair, but that's been long since deleted from the sidebar. We're working on revising the rule and adding it to the wiki. I believe your ban will also be overturned.

You see he admitted that he was wrong (kind of). So need for anymore downvotes and insults. So please keep all the stupid shit on the SRD thread where you guys are talking about underage characters for some reason. It seem like SRD love their pedophile discussion more than /r/anime.

Also

and Popcorn pissers, fuck off. Everything is aright.

So about that ban.. I'VE BEEN UNBANNED NO MORE DRAMA PLEASE. LET IT GO!


r/MetaAnime • • Jan 23 '14

Discussion The fact Meta posts must be posted here inhibits the development of the main sub.

49 Upvotes

Say someone has a idea for the sub that is at least worthy of discussion and entices a lot of users to state their opinion... The fact that all of these posts must be exiled to this more or less inactive subreddit, means that any momentum it had would pretty much be snuffed out. In the end it kills any incentive for change and progress.

I'm not going to bash the sub, but its not what it could be for a sub for this size. I'm fairly certain that most of the issues have been articulated already in some form.

I believe that posts like this that promote critical discussion are healthy and without continuous community input the sub-reddit is going to get more and more stagnant.


r/MetaAnime • • Dec 16 '12

Resolved Can we switch reddit-tan on r/anime back to how she looks on r/metaanime?

32 Upvotes

There may be some in-joke I don't get, but I find yaranaika'd reddit-tan kinda annoying. Please


r/MetaAnime • • Aug 27 '14

Resolved Why was /r/animesuggest removed from the List Of Anime-Related Subreddits?

30 Upvotes

Okay, guys. We get it. You want this kind of content for yourselves. And I understand that... Recommendation threads, however poorly received they may be by the rest of the subreddit, are directly related to anime, so you believe that /r/anime is their rightful home. Yet time after time, whenever the subject of /r/animesuggest has come up in the meta-discussions, you could at least point to that great big list over there and assuage us by saying "We acknowledge you! See? It's on the great big list!" And now we don't even have that much.

So yes, /u/airencracken. I am at least mildly perturbed by this, if not actually on my way to being mad. Especially seeing as how it was your edit that removed it. And while I do not actually expect an answer to the main question of why it was taken down, I will at least ask that our subreddit be given the same consideration as the other major anime-related subreddits and be put back on the great big List Of Anime-Related Subreddits... again.


r/MetaAnime • • Dec 16 '12

Discussion Proposal: Weekly Threads devoted to Screencaps

23 Upvotes

I think a good way to take care of this whole debate on getting rid of screencaps is to have a weekly self post made by a mod to contain screencaps that people have taken. This way people still get to post their godawful pictures and things that are blatantly supposed to be funny they found funny.

Obviously, I fucking hate them, but people are bitching about not being able to post them, so I believe this is a good compromise.

Before you say the obvious "That's what the discussion threads are for" I'd like to point out that not everyone gets to watch the anime before the discussion threads become irrelevant or they are watching an anime that is no longer airing.

On top of this, I would also propose a monthly "Buyfag Thread" in which people can post their anime swag, much like how the proposed screencap threads are set up.


r/MetaAnime • • Dec 27 '14

Write down the "unwritten" /r/anime rules.

18 Upvotes

Please put the lolicon rule and any other "unwritten" rules into the sidebar and the detailed rules page. It's sad when a quality contributor goes to this much effort then has it removed because of a rule he couldn't possibly know about since it isn't even listed.

http://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/2qiqpk/lolicon_anime_history/


r/MetaAnime • • Apr 03 '14

Resolved Linking to "illegal" content is not a violation of reddit's TOS.

17 Upvotes

I keep running across mods defending the ban on links to infringing streams, OSTs, etc. by pointing to /r/anime's rules, which justify the ban by referring to the reddit user agreement's prohibition of IP-violating user content. This is making me want to tear my hair out because it's based on an atrocious misinterpretation of the term "user content". User content, under the TOS, constitutes anything that a user uploads to the reddit servers. If I post a link to a pirate website, my "user content" is the URL, not the website it points to.

If the TOS worked the way /r/anime thinks it does, then this link to Crunchyroll's list of Kill la Kill episodes would be a violation, because I do not own the rights to that content, Crunchyroll does. I cannot grant reddit a "royalty-free, perpetual, irrevocable, non-exclusive, unrestricted, worldwide license to reproduce, prepare derivative works, distribute copies, perform, or publicly display" that webpage "in any medium and for any purpose, including commercial purposes", as reddit's user agreement requires me to do when submitting. All I can grant to reddit is the right to do all of that stuff with the URL and link descriptor I wrote myself. /r/anime's interpretation of the TOS would leave nearly all content on reddit's front page in violation, because it's mostly links to content which was not created by the linking users.

The mods are within their rights to ban links to pirate streams and whatever other content they'd like, but that is not a requirement of their agreement with reddit, it is a completely voluntary choice on their part.

EDIT: Oh I also wanted to point out an error in /r/MetaAnime's sidebar. The rules section reads "...all posts pertain the /r/anime and...", when I'm guessing it's supposed to say "...all posts pertain to /r/anime and...".


r/MetaAnime • • Aug 21 '13

Resolved Add giant, eyecancerous text to the submit box telling people that r/animesuggest/ exists and is a cool place for cool kids

17 Upvotes

Maybe you could make it pink. I like pink.


r/MetaAnime • • Nov 05 '14

Block Kotaku articles.

16 Upvotes

Is it possible to have auto moderator remove Kotaku articles? There are usually filled with misinformation and rarely ever relevant to /r/anime.


r/MetaAnime • • Sep 11 '14

Unresolved Require a show source.

16 Upvotes

Whenever someone posts a screenshot or really anything from a show, they should put the show's name in brackets in the title. /r/awwnime, /r/QUALITYanime, /r/animenocontext and /r/animegifs all require this rule, and I don't get while /r/anime still refuses to implement it. The poster should probably know what show they are posting about, and it's not like it takes much time to type it out. It saves people the trouble of having to ask (because reverse searches don't always turn up the show either), and the comments that often ask are usually near the bottom and not seen. Obviously would not be required for "What anime is this" types of posts, but for everything else it should.

It would also be nice if people sourced their fanart in the comments.


r/MetaAnime • • Feb 18 '14

Discussion Downvoting Is Getting out of Hand

16 Upvotes

Out of all the subreddits I'm subscribed too /r/anime is the worse with downvoting. Even asking a simple question gets downvoted into oblivion so no one ends up seeing the question. If you look at the new submissions over half of them have 0 or less points. This is something that shouldn't just be ignored

The way to deal with this is by making stickied posts, mentioning it in the rules, and even mentioning the reddiquette would be helpful.


r/MetaAnime • • Aug 09 '14

The /r/anime community has really been letting me down lately (x-post /r/anime)

15 Upvotes

Originally posted this on /r/anime, but I was told to post it here as it pertained to meta concerns.

I mostly lurk on /r/anime, and I have been doing so for close to a year now. Over the past couple of weeks, a certain issue that has always been prevalent here really began rearing its ugly head in full form. The issue of individual beliefs and tastes being essentially ignored.

On any given post about a specific anime, or comments even, there will always exist those who feel the need to share their own thoughts that lie in contrast to the OP's. And that's perfectly fine! In fact, that's exactly what breeds a good, complete community. It's imperative to have a healthy, two-sided discussion on a topic in order to keep our community diverse and interesting. Problems occur, however, when people attack others' opinions or label them objectively wrong. Because they're just that. Opinions.

These "Best Girl" and "Best Opening" tournaments forced this issue into the spotlight. I would like to first say that I think that having these tournaments remains a great idea. It's always fun voting on your favorite [insert topic here] and seeing how that compares to the rest of /r/anime community. Once again, it promotes healthy discussion about our diverse community's tastes. Unfortunately, the discussion didn't stop there. People started complaining that their personal favorite thing wasn't also other peoples' favorite thing. Following that, on every single new thread about the tournament the next day, one of the top comments mentioned something along the lines of, "Screw this, it's just a popularity contest." All of this led to the biggest offender: the cheating. People actually went out of their way to create bots (I assume) to make sure their favorite thing won in this largely meaningless little tournament. Granted, cheating is localized to tournaments and won't be found in any other post on /r/anime. However it's the spirit of what it represents that really threw me off.

First of all, this community needs to take a step back for a second and think. Are you really going to whine and throw fits over the fact that some random internet stranger doesn't agree with you? If you think about it, isn't it odd that a front page post about one side of a topic also contains a top comment focused on the other side? Now, I know this may come as a shock, but the internet is full of different people who like different things! Get over it. /r/anime is made up of the newest of viewers to the most experienced. When a new anime airs, people will hype it up and be excited about it. This comes with the territory and makes the show sound better than it is. Inevitably, contrarians will emerge that make the show sound worse than it is. Wherever the strength of the show truly lies, you need to understand and accept that there is no correct answer in a subjective discussion.

As for the second point, I can't help but chuckle that people hate how these tournaments are merely popularity contests. What did you expect when it's posed to a community of almost 200,000 people on the internet? The MLB All-Start Game is actually a great example of one such voting contest. Unsurprisingly, the most popular players are voted in by the fans over the strictly best players. It is complained about a lot, but those who don't like it have just come to learn not to put too much stock into the contest itself. They just enjoy the voting process and hype that comes along with it. If their favorite player wins, cool. If not, oh well, who gives a shit. In order to get the most out of these tournaments on /r/anime, we need to adopt the same mindset. Just have fun and enjoy it for what it is.

I'm not going to waste too much time talking about the cheating, as it mostly ties in with the first two points. If you seriously felt the need to cheat to validate your opinions on a meaningless contest voted on by one minuscule sect of the internet, please re-evaluate your priorities. I don't mean this as a personal attack to anyone. It's just that the effort and care you put into anime may be better served in other aspects of your life.

So please. Please stop freaking out about MAL rankings and what someone says about your favorite anime/best girl. It's just not healthy for the individual or the community as a whole.

TL;DR I think I can wrap this up nicely by just saying take a chill pill. Everyone has their own opinions and that's what makes the world beautiful. The sooner we understand and accept that as a community, the better off we'll be.


r/MetaAnime • • Sep 13 '13

Season Preview Discussions Prep

15 Upvotes

The purpose of the season preview is to:

  1. Educate people about upcoming shows

  2. Produce interest about upcoming shows

  3. Promote discussion about upcoming shows

Working plan:

  • 4 Sets (~12 shows each), only TV series, no OVAs or movies

  • Each show gets an individual comment thread

  • Each show will get a small amount of space at itsa initial comment for the most interesting things about the show (Staff, type of story, cast, etc)

  • Contest mode will be enabled

If you have any interesting tidbits about a show you think would be beneficial, leave a comment. Otherwise you're going off what I know.


r/MetaAnime • • Dec 17 '12

Proposal: Adding a [News] tag to posts that are from ANN/CR/MAL

15 Upvotes

Pretty much similar to how we handle Spoilers or Discussion posts. I think this would be helpful in separating threads that are reposts from anime news sites. User created content would stand apart. Tensorpudding's recently Nyarlko post is a good example. Placing "News" in the title.

At least for me, this helps me differentiate as titles are misleading at times or cleverly written to get people to click on it.

Just a thought what do you guys think? yay or nay?


r/MetaAnime • • Jul 14 '13

Resolved Why is /r/animesuggst not linked to in the sidebar?

14 Upvotes

Seriously. I'm getting real sick of seeing "Old anime name" and "what to watch next?" 3-4 times a day when that's what /r/animesuggest is for.


r/MetaAnime • • Apr 06 '14

Winter 2014: Interactive graph of /r/anime discussion threads

13 Upvotes

Graph

Shown on the graph: The number of comments (as of 3:00pm UTC 6th of April, 2014) in the /r/anime discussion threads for each episode of an anime aired during the Winter 2014 season. You can select which shows you want visible by clicking on them in the legend on the right.

If a show didn't get threads, it's not on there. Shows that are continuations from last season had their data for episodes 14 onwards recorded, and are noted in the legend with a (+13) suffix.

Shows that did get threads, but not enough to be worth graphing:

  • Show: Episode (comments)

  • Phi brain: 25 (6)

  • Gundam Build Fighters: 14 (24), 15 (6), 17 (5)

  • Pokemon X/Y: 14 (4)

  • Go! Go! 575: 3 (3)

  • Wooser no Sono Higurashi: Kakusei-hen: 1 (5), 2 (3), 3 (3), 12 (8)

Other notes:

  • Tonari no Seki-kun had a 6+7 combined thread, and Pupipo! had a 12+13 combined thread. I split the comments between the two in each case.

  • Witch Craft Works had an episode 1 pre-air and post-air thread. I combined their numbers.

  • All zeros are threads unable to be found, except for Pupipo 14, which actually had a thread with no comments.

  • /u/retrobrigade organised a "Medal of Perseverance" for Super Sonico, which IIRC, was something along the lines of people watching it despite disliking it, purely to bash it in the discussion threads (though to be fair, that's pretty much what everyone did with Pupa, unprompted).

No mean or median for this season, as I changed the method by which I took down the numbers to a way which was significantly quicker, but doesn't allow for data transformations.

As usual, if you can find any mistakes, let me know and I should be able to update the graph.


Autumn 2013 thread

Summer 2013 thread


r/MetaAnime • • Mar 23 '13

End of 2013 Winter CopyPasta

13 Upvotes

Here's the copypasta:

This is /r/anime's End of 2013 Winter discussion, kind of/sort of run by /u/violaxcore, /u/ThisManNeedsMe, & /u/Docoda. These threads will be for reflecting and discussing anime on the past Winter Season. We'll be discussing a topic a day until we run out of topics.

Rules

  • Spoiler tag your posts when appropriate. Read the sidebar for how to do that. If someone fails to do so, report them. Breaking this rule will not be tolerated.

  • Explain your decision. You don't have to be verbose, but we want to hear why you think what you think.

  • Don't downvote people just because you disagree with them.

  • Please keep on topic. I know this is reddit, but please try.

For a full list of discussion topics, click here. (Direct all questions to this link, not in here or they will be removed).


Insert topic prompt here.

Copypasta:

This is /r/anime's End of 2013 Winter discussion, kind of/sort of run by /u/violaxcore, /u/ThisManNeedsMe, & /u/Docoda. These threads will be for reflecting and discussing anime on the past Winter Season. We'll be discussing a topic a day until we run out of topics.

**Rules**

* **Spoiler tag your posts when appropriate**. Read the sidebar for how to do that. If someone fails to do so, report them. Breaking this rule will not be tolerated.

* Explain your decision. You don't have to be verbose, but we want to hear why you think what you think.

* Don't downvote people just because you disagree with them.

* Please keep on topic. I know this is reddit, but please try.

For a full list of discussion topics, [click here](http://www.reddit.com/r/MetaAnime/comments/1auc6l/end_of_2013_winter_copypasta/). (Direct all questions to this link, not in here or they will be removed).

* [List of 2013 Winter Anime](http://i.minus.com/iyv8pCODeNyyS.jpg)

* Fall Holdovers: Jojo's Bizarre Adventure, Little Busters, Magi, Psycho-Pass, Robotics;Notes, Sakurasou no Pet Na Kanojo, Shinsekai Yori, Zetsuen no Tempest

----------------------


r/MetaAnime • • Dec 31 '12

Arts and crafts

13 Upvotes

Right now 7 of the top 11 posts on /anime are variations of "look what I drew." If we're not going to outright ban crap like this can we at least force some kind of tagging so we can filter them out individually?


r/MetaAnime • • Dec 16 '12

Can there be a reminder for reading the sidebar on the submission page?

13 Upvotes

I keep seeing newer members posting recommendation threads without checking the wiki and I like how /r/awwnime has a reminder image on their page.

http://www.reddit.com/r/awwnime/submit


r/MetaAnime • • Dec 19 '12

2012 /r/anime awards and things

12 Upvotes

Figure this could be fun or awful or both. Right now I generally envision 3 periods.

  1. Select categories (best anime, best female seiyuu, etc) - probably optional if someone can come up with a good list.

  2. Nominations - Not quite sure an open selection would be the best idea.

  3. Actual voting. To be done in a google doc.

Would probably start this after Christmas if we do do it. Thoughts? And does anybody want to run it?


Okay, so we're doing an /r/games setup. List of topics:

For Sure:

Maybe

  • Original Anime (Note: Series not based on a Book, Manga, Game, or VN)

  • Anime Adaptions

  • Background Art

  • Anime of each season


r/MetaAnime • • Nov 12 '14

Resolved "The Attack on Titan/Marvel crossover does not belong here"

11 Upvotes

It's easily argued that it does. When the west gets involved in anime, it doesn't stop being anime. Do anime that have western people involved in the production stop being anime? A more lax approach would be more appropriate here. The crossover is of interest to anime fans and is clearly related to anime.


r/MetaAnime • • Nov 07 '14

[Suggestion] Incorporate something like /r/awwnime's Chiyo reminder to point submitters towards the sidebar and rules

11 Upvotes

Pretty basic. Chiyo pleasantly reminds the submitter to read the sidebar if they haven't already.

Here's a picture.

Just a simple little suggestion that I think could potentially go a long way to decreasing the amount of threads for /u/-Niernen to point in the right direction.

Quick little edit: Could have the speech bubble point them towards better subreddits for their post. eg. "Looking for recommendations? Check our /r/animesuggest or our weekly megathread"


r/MetaAnime • • Oct 11 '14

Flair to clickable link

11 Upvotes

I made a little Greasemonkey/Tampermonkey script that will convert flairs links to clickable links. (e.g. MAL flairs)

https://greasyfork.org/scripts/5650-mal-flair-to-link

Greasemonkey is a Firefox plugin that allows the users to change the look/structure of a website. (It also means that you shouldn't install scripts that you don't trust/understand.)

https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/greasemonkey/

Tampermonkey is the same for Chrome.

https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/tampermonkey/dhdgffkkebhmkfjojejmpbldmpobfkfo?hl=en


r/MetaAnime • • Apr 20 '14

Moderating images post: No image post from episodes that have their EP thread on the front page.

11 Upvotes

I realize that image post also serve as discussion starters, and atract people to watch shows they don't know about. But what about when the discussion is already there?

Right now, there are 3 Nisekoi images in the TOP4. Two of them are from the thread that's sitting at rank #17. While the 3rd post isn't really about Nisekoi (it's about fansubs) I fail to see the point for those two threads other than attract upvotes.

I think that a small 24hr limit wouldn't hurt.


r/MetaAnime • • Jan 29 '14

Resolved Anyone notice the page title of /r/Anime?

11 Upvotes