r/MetaAnime • u/danbuter • Sep 25 '14
Unresolved Change sub layout depending on Best Girl Contest winner?
Please consider changing the sub layout for a few days based upon whomever wins the Best Girl Contest (Horo or Kurisu).
r/MetaAnime • u/danbuter • Sep 25 '14
Please consider changing the sub layout for a few days based upon whomever wins the Best Girl Contest (Horo or Kurisu).
r/MetaAnime • u/HijackTV • Nov 19 '13
Inspiration: this.
As some of you may know, trash talk threads are most likely originates from /r/hockey . And seeing the popularity of such thread on /r/anime , is it possible for the mods to provide a weekly trash talk threads?
My 2 cents: if this ever works, please don't make this a Friday thread for obvious reasons.
r/MetaAnime • u/GarththeGarth • Mar 14 '14
This would really help curb the flood of low effort image posts, without stopping anyone who really wants to share something from doing so. It worked for /r/leagueoflegends and I think it can work here as well.
r/MetaAnime • u/Dinosaur_Munchies • Jul 17 '14
Post in question
http://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/2az7ua/before_my_body_is_dry_klk_cosdream_nsfw/
It was removed by a mod under the AnimeMod account.
I'm going to remove this.
I think this is too little cosplay, and too much nudity, for this subreddit.
"Reason". Seems like the post was removed based not on the rules but a mods own personal judgment.
Do not post Hentai here. Lightly NSFW things are okay, use your judgement.
Sidebar rules.
Personally I can see why a mod would remove this but, it seems like it was removed not because it broke any rules but because a mod made a personal judgment call without the rules giving him a valid reason to. How much initiative and flexibility are mods allowed when making calls like this?
r/MetaAnime • u/ookiisask • Dec 15 '14
Hello, fellow anime lovers. I'd like to talk to you about "Reddiquette".
What is reddiquette, you ask? Good question! It's the suggested etiquette for voting practices on Reddit.
But Ookiisask, what does that have to do with /r/anime? Why are you posting this?
The answer is simple. Lately, I fear our subreddit has gotten quite vindictive with its' voting habits. I've noticed it in pretty much any thread dealing with the good old subs/dubs discussion, anywhere someone states that they don't, in fact, like a popular show, or when someone tries to start a discussion on an old show that isn't being talked about otherwise.
This is a very bad thing for a multitude of reasons:
It breeds bitterness in the subreddit
It punishes anyone who wants to discuss older shows
It buries posts with unpopular but entirely valid and relevant viewpoints
It goes against the rules of reddit (Taken from the "Don't" section):
Downvote an otherwise acceptable post because you don't personally like it.
Think before you downvote and take a moment to ensure you're downvoting
someone because they are not contributing to the community dialogue or
discussion. If you simply take a moment to stop, think and examine your
reasons for downvoting, rather than doing so out of an emotional reaction,
you will ensure that your downvotes are given for good reasons.It is generally a dick move to downvote a relevant post.
But why is it a dick move? Why shouldn't I downvote a person for disagreeing with me or having an opposite viewpoint?
The answer is actually pretty simple. No, it has nothing to do with Karma, our precious internet points. It's because whenever a post is downvoted, it goes lower and lower on the page until it breaks into the negative, where it's completely hidden until people manually unhide it. Particulary zealous downvoters can completely censor views they disagree with.
This is entirely unfair and counter-intuitive to the purpose of reddit.
When should you downvote, then, you ask? the answer is simple! When a comment is off-topic or is not relevant of the conversation, or is particularly toxic and offensive. If someone states that they dislike your favourite show, or prefer english dubs, or think the manga was better/worse, or generally disagree with you, don't downvote.
Take a minute and think.
Are they offending anyone on a personal basis? Did that state something like "Show X is ****, anyone who likes is is an idiot, and should be ashamed"? If so, feel free to blast them. If they're just disagreeing with you, stay your mighty hand. Scroll on. Dismiss the post and banish it from your mind. They are another human, and no matter how "wrong" you may find their views, they're still valid.
That is the very reason this subreddit exists. To facilitate discussion of Anime. Discussions often have differing viewpoints and opinions. It's something to be celebrated, as it offers us a chance to peek into the other person's reasoning. So next time, don't downvote that person. Either ignore them, or ask them why they think the way they do.
Discuss. Don't downvote.
Thanks for reading this far. Stay frosty, /r/anime.
TL;DR: Don't be a dick. If someone disagrees, ignore them and move on instead of making it rain downvotes.
r/MetaAnime • u/doug89 • Jan 06 '15
I don't know if it's a problem worth doing something about but this goes through the flairs on /r/anime and removes any that don't contain a link to MAL or hummingbird. Let me know if you want to use it and need help. Or you could give me flair permission for half an hour and I can run it for you.
import praw
user_agent = ("Flair remove test by /u/doug89 v0.1")
r = praw.Reddit(user_agent = user_agent)
r.login("", "") #insert username and pw here.
subreddit = r.get_subreddit('anime')
#odd_flairs = [] #this is part of a system to output the list of flairs and usernames to a text file. Not needed.
for item in subreddit.get_flair_list():
if not "myanimelist.net" in item['flair_text'] and "hummingbird.me" not in item['flair_text']:
user = r.get_redditor(item['user'])
#Remove the "#" below to make it actually delete flairs. With it as it is it will give you a list of what it will delete.
#You should run it once like this to make sure you like what it is going to remove, and that it is finding the correct flairs.
# subreddit.delete_flair(str(user.name))
print(user.name + ": " + item['flair_text']
# odd_flairs.append("http://www.reddit.com/user/" + user.name + ',"' + item['flair_text'] + '"'
#This is to save the list of flairs and user names to a text file. Good if you want a backup.
#with open("/home/doug/flairs/odd_flairs.txt", "w") as f:
# for x in odd_flairs:
# f.write(x + "\n")You could probably accomplish the same with AM, but it would work as it saw comments and submissions. I think this might work but do some thorough testing on a test subreddit before implementing.
author_flair_text: ["myanimelist.net", "hummingbird.me"]
modifiers: includes
author_flair_text: inverse
user_flair_text: ""r/MetaAnime • u/CleanConductor • Jan 21 '15
I noticed recently that the some of mods of /r/anime have special flair that they use that does not link to an anime list.
Image and cdsboy's flair
Technically these aren't flair if you disable the css but they are still essentially flair. Note that airencracken's flair disguises his identity. The rule in /r/anime is that the users's flair must link to animelists, but if the mods are allowed to break this rule, what other rules are they exempt from?
I'd also like to point out that /u/OnlyMyWordsMatter was banned over this rule.
r/MetaAnime • u/vayuu • Apr 01 '14
If the current sticky is the most sarcastic meta AFJ of all meta posts then bravo
Otherwise I could swear some of mods are permanently having menstruating cramps the last few months.
edit: If you havn't realized, unless someone shit posts like i just did, your pretty much never getting a response to the any critical tough questions since there is nothing easy to attack like the 2nd sentence.
r/MetaAnime • u/ExomorphicLogorethym • Jan 25 '15
So I was recently banned from the mothership for having the words "Gibe gold" in my flair, alongside my MAL. However, I was not warned at all, or told to change it. I'd pin it on my relationship with some of the mods there, but my question is, what are users warned if they violate a rule, or is a straight ban every time?
r/MetaAnime • u/AdvanceRatio • Sep 06 '13
Right now, we've got this thread going on. In this thread, a disgustingly large number of people are proudly proclaiming their undying loyalty to illegally obtained anime. I'm not sure how this falls under the rule of "Do not link to/mention torrents or unofficial streams/downloads", but it seems to me like this is very strongly alluding to them, which is frustrating.
A while back, we were getting some cool AMAs. I would like to see some more of this happen, but as long as such a staggering amount of people are openly boasting about how they watch all anime illegally and refuse to pay for it, what studio or publisher would even bother to give us the time of day?
I propose that openly admitting to refusing to legally acquire anime should be a bannable offense. I know that no matter what, there will be the cancerous fanbase that does it, but this should not be the place for them to gloat about it.
r/MetaAnime • u/ExomorphicLogorethym • Jan 25 '15
So I recently decided to check out a certain power user's MAL, and discovered that the CSS used included a very interesting photo of a woman..
Since that appears to be the only way to view that user's anime list, if I want to see what they're watching, I have to deal with a gigantic vagina in my face for every second of it, unless I go into the inspect element tab and alter the page, which I can't be bothered to do.
Would it be possible to institute a rule that user's MALs must not contain such NSFW content, otherwise they can't have flair like that or they must be marked as such? E: Because it's pretty much linking to hentai/extremely NSFW content.
r/MetaAnime • u/[deleted] • Feb 03 '14
Here's my idea, i dont know if it has been posted yet. Could any moderator of /r/anime post a link to /r/animesuggest under the banner or in a sticky or something? There's at least 1 post every 2 days asking for an anime recomendation.
r/MetaAnime • u/doug89 • Dec 22 '14
One of the fastest ways to improve /r/anime would be to increase the number of moderators. For whatever reason, the current moderators seem hesitant to recruit more.
Currently there are many extremely active users with a long history of accurate psudo-moderator behaviour. For example frequently reporting submissions and comments, and informing users when they have violated a rule. If you don't want to make these people moderators, I have a suggestion on how to make better use of them.
A while ago I thought it would be great if you could have automoderator trust the reports of certain users more than others, and have those reports carry more weight when deciding whether to remove. As far as I know that isn't possible. I just had the following idea for a bot which may be similar.
Create a new account called /u/animemoderator (or similar) and invite it to the moderators.
Create a new subreddit called /r/psudoanimemoderators or /r/animehelpers and set it to private.
Invite trusted users to the new subreddit, or alternative accounts of trusted users (depending on whether a third party can see submissions made to a private subreddit and if the trusted users wants to remain anonymous.)
When a trusted user sees a comment or submissions that will obviously get removed, he goes to /r/animehelpers and makes a new self post
Title: A link to the comment or submission
Body: A professional sounding message which will be left as a comment for the offending submission or commentAfter the self post is made, the trusted user writes a comment justifying the removal.
/u/animemoderator checks /r/animehelpers/new every minute, and if it sees a new self post, it comments on the linked submission or comment with the body of the self post, and it removes the submission or comment linked in the title. It then can comment back to the self post saying "X was removed at DATETIME" or "Was unable to removed X at DATETIME, has it already been removed?"
/u/animemoderator includes anti-abuse features. It will only respond to users who are on a list, just in case an unauthorised user gets access to the private subreddit. It can also track how many removals a trusted user has made in the past hour/day, and not remove if that number exceeds a preset limit (which can be set individually for each trusted user, ie some users may be more trusted than others).
/u/animemoderator maintains a log of removals in the following format - DATE TIME|SUBID/COMMENTID|TRUSTEDUSERNAME This way even if the original self post requesting the removal is deleted, evidence remains of who performed what action.
This system allows for 100% accountability and auditing. All actions leave a trail of reports justifying their actions. If a trusted user abuses their privileges it will be extremely obvious, and action can be taken (removing them from /r/animehelpers, banning them from /r/anime, etc). This system can also be used as a type of probation or training. Trusted users who do well can be considered for becoming full fledged moderators.
The trusted users would follow a guideline written by the moderators, stating what kinds of things they should remove. It might want to state only remove very obvious violations (untagged spoilers, recommendation threads, etc), but leave ambiguous ones alone. It should also state that trusted users should never delete their self posts.
The bot's user account and the bot itself would be run by the moderators. I'm willing to write it then hand over the code.
What do you think? I literally had this idea while I was sleeping.
r/MetaAnime • u/e2h2 • Mar 31 '14
I know the sub is only a day old but some of the other subreddits on that page are completely dead, I was thinking maybe it would help it get off the ground a bit if it was listed on there.
r/MetaAnime • u/SHITTY_SPOILER_ALERT • Jul 11 '14
I made this account as humorous satire for people who post in comments with things like "this is a spoiler you should remove it/tag/censor, etc," while the item in question is completely safe. The person complaining about the item either forces it into a spoiler by pointing it out, or just makes up a ridiculous reason for why it's a "potential" spoiler.
I made only 4 posts, all of which were downvoted to negative karma. I did not have any negative interactions with anyone, and as far as I know, I did not break any subreddit rules.
Please help me understand why I was banned, or else I will be left with the impression that this is a case of mods removing and banning stuff just because they feel like it.
r/MetaAnime • u/danbuter • Oct 26 '14
At least one of the current mods is pretty much abusing his little amount of power. I had a review post about Gunbuster, and it was removed, because it was a "recommendation". However, there are literally hundreds of threads recommending other anime (especially Steins;Gate and Monogatari). If we are only allowed to talk about mod-approved anime, they really need to add a list of them on the side.
r/MetaAnime • u/[deleted] • Oct 20 '14
There was some arguments with a mod in the comment section, about whether this should be allowed.
r/MetaAnime • u/vetro • Nov 19 '14
What popular character do you dislike?
What annoys you the most about anime?
Who is the most stupid, annoying, or cliche antagonist in Anime?
What's your biggest anime pet peeve?
What anime has the most annoying fans?
What do you dislike about anime?
What Anime Cliché Do You Hate/Love The Most?
Which show has the worst MCs?
What anime you can't stand?
The list goes on and on. You can find many posts like these just by search up keywords like: popular, annoying, worst, cliche, hate, dislike
The reverse is also true for positive threads but those yield fewer results.
The problem is the same either way.
I don't know what could/should be done about it. Or if anything should be done at all.
I just know that constantly seeing these kinds of posts are really boring and irritating for me.
r/MetaAnime • u/ExomorphicLogorethym • Jan 21 '15
I've noticed that a lot of posts (specifically self posts) tend to get majorly downvoted, yet inspire a lot of discussion. Take these, for example:
http://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/2t4b56/defend_your_favorite_anime/
http://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/2t63fw/how_did_you_get_into_anime/
http://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/2t5qe5/how_do_you_explain_your_anime_hobby_breaking_the/
http://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/2t5gv9/how_would_you_get_people_interested_in_anime/
http://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/2t5f1e/reason_why_recent_animes_have_very_long_titles/
http://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/2t5nqv/what_anime_you_recently_watched_turned_out_to_be/
All of those have discussion going on, but are below the 50% upvoted ratio, and have a net score of zero. Because reddit removed the score totals, it impossible to see how many actually voted, but its fair to say something is up here.
Other posts are in the positives but are controversial:
http://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/2t5yub/what_is_your_idea_for_an_original_anime_series/
http://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/2t62p0/what_is_the_most_relatable_character_in_anime_for/
http://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/2t48pp/most_awkward_anime_moment/
Any possible reason why? Are we getting brigaded by /r/AnimeCirclejerk or /r/SEELE?
r/MetaAnime • u/Twilight_Scko • Jan 07 '15
I think having a new mod from the community every month will keep people from complaining about /u/MissyPie being the only mod interacting with the community.
Furthermore, mods that do well during that month should/could be considered for a more permanent mod position.
Sidenote: The #reddit-anime irc should be advertised more on the subreddit so as to bolster interaction between the mods and the community.
r/MetaAnime • u/[deleted] • Jan 12 '15
Honest question. I know the sidebar states that memes and such should not be posted, and it is a big problem in a lot of subs where the rule is not in effect. But what is the point of banning all jokes or interesting posts that don't link to a news article or are simply a discussion post?
Take a look at the front page; the whole thing consists of most Anime News Network articles, people asking random questions about their anime club or the like and a wallpaper dump. This morning there was discussion of an interesting GIF and it was removed. Someone posted a picture of an anime-related easter egg in their college and it was removed. Whats the point of even coming to this sub if you can't discuss anime outside of what ANN decides to publish?
Seriously thinking of unsubscribing, there's hardly any reason to be here when anything the mods don't like gets removed.
r/MetaAnime • u/mini_link • Apr 28 '14
I feel like this sub has lost a lot of its discussion qualities after more fanart is being posted. I mean, now that the front page is more than 50% "Check out this cool drawing that I/my friend did, its becoming less and less interesting as a site.
Now, how should we respond to this? I mean, most of it should get routed to a drawing sub instead, but I don't know, I'd like some other opinions on this.
r/MetaAnime • u/kiririno • Apr 17 '14
Here's what the rules say about proxies:
Finally, to those of you outside of the U.S., we realize that there aren't many, if any, services for you to watch anime online legitimately, and that even buying anime on DVD or BluRay is not always an option. I hope that you understand the position we've taken at /r/anime with respect to this issue, even if it may be inconvenient for you.
Proxy sites serve to circumvent licensing and usually aim to sidestep the intent of the distributors, and as such their mentioning/linking will not be permitted either. 99% of the times a proxy is brought up it's equivalent to the above.
Circumventing region restrictions is nowhere near as bad as piracy. If people are using proxies to watch Crunchyroll or what have you, they are still supporting Crunchyroll and by extension, the industry, because they are paying a subscription or viewing advertisements. Apart from proxies, what other alternatives are there? There's fansubs, which, being unlicensed, are not helpful to the industry. The other option is that the show just goes unwatched, which is even worse, as they are not then discussing it and recommending it to other people. If there is enough demand for a series in a country, it will eventually get licensed, but stifling that demand will prevent it from happening.
Do we really have an obligation to enforce the intent of the distributors? If a series is not licensed in a country, nobody in that country is making money on it, so nothing is lost when people flock to a distributor for another country. If a series is already licensed for a particular country, there is no reason to use a proxy anyways.
The other rules surrounding copyrighted content on /r/anime were justified with the intent of helping the anime industry. This rule is doing the opposite. In fact, if /r/anime wants to follow the spirit of helping the industry, it should be doing everything it can to encourage people to use proxies to stream anime, which although a grey area, is certainly more legal than downloading a fansub.
r/MetaAnime • u/Snowboi • Oct 06 '13
Is it just me, or is the content of /r/anime filled with too many spoilers. I only recently (Half a year ago) started watching anime. It's very difficult to get into a subreddit where I can only safely click on 2 or 3 links per day.
Is this just a problem related to the exclusivity of people who have watched "Major anime releases" or a problem with limiting the amount of spoiler related posts ? (If that is even possible)
r/MetaAnime • u/[deleted] • May 19 '13
The way I see it is that there are two levels of spoilers: first you have spoiler threads, and then there are spoiler tags. If you go into a spoilers thread, you're expecting spoilers about the anime in question. Therein, any manga/etc. spoilers can be covered using spoiler tags.
These split threads are ridiculous and make it difficult because now I have to go between two different threads for the same exact discussion. As long as source material spoilers are put in spoiler tags, nobody is going to have a problem.