r/Marxism101 • • Jul 27 '26

Why does Marx consider only labor time to determine value ?

0 Upvotes

Hello, I’ve started reading The Capital (the French translation), and in the chapter on the commodity, I don’t understand why he speaks only of the quantity of labor to determine the value of something. After all, aren't there other factors—like scarcity—that determine an object's value?


r/Marxism101 • • Jan 14 '26

Why do many “socialist” moderators on Reddit support fascists and condemn free speech?

0 Upvotes

r/Marxism101 • • Apr 05 '26

What country was the best / closest example of Marxism in practice?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/Marxism101 • • May 20 '26

Surplus value doesn't make sense to me

0 Upvotes

It rests on the premise that human labor has intrinsic value, which IMO it does not - human labor only has value if the commodity is actually sold or marketed efficiently, and the business is successful enough to continue in perpetuity.

The majority of businesses fail due to running out of cash or not having enough demand for the product/service they sell. If laborers had a 1:1 share in the value produced, many of their paychecks would be nonexistent (or negative, if they were to actually share in the profits/losses), so there would literally be no reason to work at that job - they would leave & go find a corporate job that actually makes a profit and can therefore provide a regular paycheck.

In general I am against capitalism because of its obvious lack of sustainability, but I think the line of reasoning behind this core concept is flawed and gives a lot of leftists a very incorrect understanding of the actual value of their labor.

What is my misunderstanding?


r/Marxism101 • • Sep 29 '26

Communism arguements

2 Upvotes

I have grown quite hateful of capitalism and started loving the idea of communism after years of hardship and academic success just to see some guys with generational wealth lives a better life. So I started doing research on communism here and there and when I tell my parents about communism they always hit me with name me successful communist countries and I am left speechless. What do I say back?


r/Marxism101 • • 18d ago

I’m MTF. Is desiring sex reassignment bourgeois?

3 Upvotes

I’m curious about this because I feel like desiring medical transition requires one to have a focus on individual anatomic self-actualization than a primary commitment on fighting with others for working class liberation.

Given that medical sex reassignment costs thousands of dollars, I feel like it also incentivizes first-world trans people to climb the corporate ladder and support social democratic policies such as universal healthcare that require imperialist super-profits, weakening their potential to support decolonization and liberatory movements in the global south.

I also feel like since trans people in the third world don’t have access to these procedures nor even legal protections against discrimination and violence, that it is inherently a form of first-world privilege to benefit from medical procedures and public healthcare policies that those individuals will probably never have access to in their entire lives.


r/Marxism101 • • Jul 23 '26

Claude tells me that serious Marxists concede that there is no demonstrated Marxist route from poverty to prosperity that isn't either state capitalism, market socialism, or dependent on being embedded in a capitalist world market. Do you agree? Is this correct?

0 Upvotes

I've been trying to get a more detailed academic understanding of development economics from a Marxist perspective.

Claude tells me that serious Marxists concede that there is no demonstrated Marxist route from poverty to prosperity that isn't either state capitalism, market socialism, or dependent on being embedded in a capitalist world market.

This feels like a stronger statement than any real life Marxist I've chatted to would be willing to concede.

Do you agree/disagree? If you disagree, what is the demonstration or counter argument you have in mind?


r/Marxism101 • • Feb 04 '26

Why am I a Marxist?

2 Upvotes

Hello, so I argued with my dad about China last night. He is a liberal(democrat we live in the US), and I am trying to explain what Dengism is, what the free market reforms were about. Say what you will about him, but my problem wasn't there. It was with how the Chinese government operates, we went back and forth, he said that the billionaires control it like an oligarchy, I said it is a meritocracy, and they have central planning and execute more corrupt billionaires than any other nation. Then he switched up and said it was a political oligarchy. I tried to reiterate that the members of the politburo passed the civil service exam and to progress, they must prove themselves on every level or else they would be removed. Then he went brainless mode and said communism only works on levels of 20-30 people. So I went on a tangent about how every Marxist experiment has been successful in ensuring a rise in QoL, literacy rates, stability, infant mortality, and access to food, but he didn't buy it. But I began thinking, and I just cannot shake it off. I know I am right, I know liberals are just capitalists, I know that working people need liberation, especially in the global south, I know that the USSR was a based country, I know that socialism is inherently democratic, but I could not shake off the question, why am I a Marxist even if I know that it is right. I just cannot answer that question.


r/Marxism101 • • Mar 30 '26

Suggestions for Marxist/communist podcasts

3 Upvotes

I'm looking for podcasts or YouTube videos I can listen to while I work. My job demands very little brain power, and I have my entire shift to listen to things. Not so much audiobooks (I am however open to suggestions) moreso something I can listen to in short (15-60 min) intervals to learn more about Marxism and communism.


r/Marxism101 • • Apr 30 '26

How is "value" added by employing someone, yet "value" is not added by simply rising the price of a commodity?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/Marxism101 • • Feb 17 '26

Regarding Internationalism

4 Upvotes

INTRO: I am generally speaking, a Libertarian Communist. I just wanted to bounce my thoughts around with other like-minded individuals about internationalism within Marxist/Communist thought.

CONTEXT: I consider myself to be realist when it comes to international systems and frameworks— due to my educational background in International Relations. During my studies, I learned about how Capitalism fits within the structure of the global order. What I mean by this, was coming to understand that Capitalism is NOT just an economic theory. Capitalism is everything. It sounds very generalist to say, but it is a living, breathing machine that evolve in every single aspect of our lives in the modern day. It developed along with liberalism (yuck) after society— within the Western World anyways, transitioned away from Mercantilism. Acknowledging this, one must also understand that Capitalism also serves the fundamental basis for global affairs. This is why (in my opinion like many others) "exporting the revolution" can never work. You can't export something that is illiberal and anti-Capitalist in a Capitalist system, since it devours everything within itself. A national revolution cannot topple the whole system, since Capitalism IS everything. To defeat Capitalism, you would have to do replace it globally... a global revolution would be the only answer.

WHAT I WANT TO KNOW: I have been really scratching my head recently since I am little confused to why there are not more subscribers to this school of thought. I know with Trotskyists it certainly is— with the core principle of the "Permanent Revolution." Admittedly, this is somethings that I agree with, but get lost with the rest of Trotskyism. As much as I ideologically oppose Capitalism, it is in my opinion that Capitalism is a necessary step for a Communist society, as Capitalism provides us with industry that will serve as the base for the post-Capitalist era. I know that in basic Marxian thought, that Communism is inherently internationalist— but I get lost as to why I feel like there is not enough attention to the internationalist perspective within the wider field-of-thought. I am just trying to educate myself some more since I have been very curious about this recently.


r/Marxism101 • • Jun 18 '26

Does Marx have any conclusions that don’t seem obvious?

0 Upvotes

I haven’t read any theory. I have read very brief excerpts with summaries such as “things with a price do not necessarily have value” and ”organized religion is a bourgeoisie tool”.

Essentially, is Marx simply seeking to provide thorough support for obvious thoughts or is he under the impression that these are difficult concepts?

Are there in fact concepts that simply don‘t get brought up as much due to their complexity?


r/Marxism101 • • 10d ago

What if they just try not to mind the change

0 Upvotes

Have American Marxist considered the more than present sect of American proletariat that simply don’t care for how the world around them operates or how it dictates their conditions, instead subscribing to a “fuck it we ball regardless” mindset even when their conditions are degraded? Would this uninspired group be beneficial in that as long as their needs are met they will go about their duties in a socialized economy because “that’s just what it is”?


r/Marxism101 • • Apr 05 '26

What is the Difference Between Marxism & Marxism-Leninism?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Marxism101 • • 10d ago

Nobody has done this before: a Historical Materialist reading of Final Fantasy VI

Thumbnail
reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Marxism101 • • 8d ago

Hello, I am genuinely quite interested in communism / Marxism; however I do have one question that feels like a thorn to my side. If communism (a classless, stateless, moneyless society) really was an achievable goal, why hasn't it been achieved yet, especially considering how many times it has been

0 Upvotes

r/Marxism101 • • 6d ago

I have become fairly far left through passive interaction without reading, which I find problematic. Should I somehow deradicalize myself to the center before making an honest attempt at reading the theory so that I can accurately say I got to a place with conscious thought?

1 Upvotes

Sorry if this is stupid. I took that one 12 Axes 200-question test which you may have seen and it said my closest comparison was Debord. Obviously not having any reading done I had no idea who he was and having looked him up he seems to be further left than I thought I was.

I worry that I am becoming this way without discipline. Can I somehow deprogram myself to the John Liberal I was maybe two or three years ago so that I can start again?

As an aside, should I just read in chronological order? I’m not just gonna start with Das Kapital or Hegel, because there’s something to be said about how the order of reading influences thought. My natural feeling is just to follow the history. Is this recommended?


r/Marxism101 • • Sep 10 '26

Question about dialectical materialism and its interactions with Humean skepticism

1 Upvotes

Sorry if this is too basic. I tried to make my question as clear as possible while still including all required context but it ended up being a little convoluted...

In Hegel's formulation of dialectics, the spirit (geist) resolves contradictions. When Marx inverted Hegel, he combined it with his own materialism. However, by removing the spirit, matter is now theorized resolve contradictions itself.

Hume's problem of causation states that causation can never be observed as our senses provide us with no possible way to make causal inference. Therefore, there is no way to prove a causal link. Even controlled experiments don't solve this since it could just be coincidence. He uses this to formulate the problem of induction. We can not use past experience to predict the future.

Hegel was able to avoid this critique by making contradiction a conceptual necessity, not a material one. This is idealist though so Marx rejects it.

Dialectical materialism is not able to do this since it relies matter itself being the force of change. It uses history and class analysis to determine that the end of capitalism is inevitable due to its inherent contradictions, but it can't predict that accurately since it's impossible to know whether contradictions will inevitably resolve without relying on causation.

Furthermore, Hume talks about the problem of necessity. We can't observe a necessary connection between cause and effect. Kant avoids this by saying that cause and effect exist as structures in the mind. Hegel adapted this cleanly by claiming the spirit to be manifested through human minds and part of objective reality, making the laws of cause and effect applicable to objective reality. Marx, however, can't do this since he is a materialist. Under dialectical materialism, there is no way to determine a necessary connection between contradictions.

Dialectical materialism, after a skeptical critique, can never establish a connection between a base and its negation and it can never make claims about inevitability or even the potential for a resolution. It appears less scientific and closer to rough pattern recognition.

So how does dialectical materialism deal with Humean skepticism? I'm not trying to start an argument. This is just something I've had on my mind for a few days.


r/Marxism101 • • Jul 01 '26

Regarding rule 3 of r/Marxism and 4 of r/Marxism101.

2 Upvotes

Taking for granted the relationship between the rules of moderation of these subs and the Marxist principles these subs are committed into promoting, I was intrigued by the reference to the concept of Europeanism.
What does Marx mean by this term?
Or, what meaning do the founders of this page associate with this term, from the perspective of Marxist thought?

I am new to the study of Marxism and I come from years of political activism little framed in a structured philosophical and political theory. For this reason I might discover that I have to deconstruct some thoughts born from the lack of formal study.

But as naive as it sounds, I was raised in the ideal of a Europe of peoples. A network of proletarian realities, transnational and involved in the revolutionary process. In political terms, although today's EU is nothing more than a centrist, neo-colonialist organisation colluding with organised crime, the union of European states in itself is not a negative fact. On the contrary. Having triggered the revolutionary processes in one or more member countries, their presence in the Union could represent an easier diffusion to the other members.
Science fiction or formal mistake? Please give me your honest opinion. I'm not afraid of being corrected, on the contrary I hope to learn.


r/Marxism101 • • Aug 31 '26

Capital, first section, already confused

2 Upvotes

I’m currently reading chapter 1, section 1 of Marx’s Capital, and I am a little confused trying to figure out Marx’s idea of value as being equivalent to expended labour. One common counter-example to refute this is the case of exorbidantly priced, low-labour art (since the  value as defined by the labour theory, and the price are seemingly so different). I have seen Marx defended by some who claim that he doesn’t consider price and value as the same thing, but in my understanding, Marx understands value as basically the ratio of the quantity of a certain item that will trade on the market for another given item? Isn’t this the same as price??

Thanks


r/Marxism101 • • 7d ago

My second question on his page: why is revisionism so looked down upon, and why do so many Marxist / communist seem to behave so dogmatically

2 Upvotes

  Marx's assessment of capitalism is a product of its time (the Industrial Revolution),Western countries aren't exactly filled with factories anymore, and yet consumption of commodities has definitely increased dramatically since then. Obviously, this is because most of the production has moved to where the labour is cheaper, i.e., third-world countries where the people are the most impoverished. Therefore, in my opinion, at least even though someone who works as a junior analyst in a firm in Paris and a child who makes soccer balls in Pakistan are technically both proletariat, I do not see them as equals in the ways that they are exploited.

So, to me, to effectively carry out Marx's ideas in the 21st century, we need to bend aspects of his original ideas not to the degree that it is an entirely new ideology, but just to an extent where it functions to critique modern Global capitalism more effectively. However, with all of that being said, I'm quite new to Communism, and I'm genuinely trying to learn, and I still see myself as an outsider looking in 


r/Marxism101 • • 24d ago

if i turn my own home into a bakery or a flower shop and work there all alone am i still a bourgeoisie?

0 Upvotes

NOW COME ON NOW GUYS this question is rly making me feel weird about marxism?? i feel like as a FREE SOCIETY we need to redefine what bourgeoisie is, aren’t we like in control (at least shouldn’t we be)?

by definition, those popular singers that earn millions without owning the means of production are not bourgeoisie, tho they hoard more wealth.

i’d create my own ideology and call it epiozfism, where i agree with mostly everything marx has said, except for this (and a few other things)

or maybe if y’all can change my mind, go ahead. xx


r/Marxism101 • • Oct 07 '26

what books should i read?

2 Upvotes

i know this is probably asked a lot im sorry, but im already a communist just from being educated by others, my own beliefs / opinions, and other external research, but im looking to further educate myself on marxism and communism as a whole to be able to understand it more thoroughly and be able to educate others. i haven't read any theory at all so i need a good starter


r/Marxism101 • • Jun 24 '26

Earnings of Non-Socially Necessary but still Necessary Labor

3 Upvotes

So something is only a commodity if it is socially necessary (i.e. it fulfills a tangible want/has use-value). So basic formula for commodity value is c+v+s. But there is still necessary work that doesn't fulfill socially necessary purpose, e.g. research.

Research produces (discovers) data, but data is not a commodity. It has no social use. It is just information about nature. That information can still be used to produce something of social necessity, but the information alone does nothing, and can be reproduced with essentially no labor once the information is harvested from nature (in the age of modern technology, organized, analyzed data reports may be copied and pasted essentially ad infinitum onto servers, emails, hard drives, etc. for effectively no labor, copying the information, and unlike physical assets a capitalist owns that wear and tear with use/time, information is infinitely reusable, or at least usable until a resource that information uses is consumed to extinction).

That being said, the original discovery work is still labor, and labor is paid equal to the value necessary to reproduce it (the cost of living, variable capital, v) plus its surplus value. For a company that funds its own internal research, that wage comes from the surplus value of those who do socially necessary work, producing profitable commodities. However, after being paid their wage to subsist, are the non-socially necessary laborers entitled to other compensation? They produce no surplus value themselves, and the wage they earned through their labor was another worker's surplus value. What incentive is there to do non-socially necessary work if your work requires years of labor to gain the skill necessary to perform, but only provides a subsistence wage?

I understand that skilled labor is complex labor consisting of dead past labor plus current labor, but I am struggling to see how it can be amortized over the course of their career if they don't produce something of social necessity. Is the variable capital that goes into paying a skilled laborer higher due to paying for past labor, despite having the same subsistence needs as the socially necessary labor?

The only way I could see research work being paid beyond subsistence is if data was commodified, the data becoming intellectual property belonging to the researcher, only being done on contract work (essentially existing CROs), not integrated with a manufacturing company, with the data and manufacturing process being bought by the manufacturing company.

Research is only an example. If my understanding of research's status as non-socially necessary is flawed, you can replace it with other non-socially necessary work that still is necessary.


r/Marxism101 • • Sep 05 '26

Why would I be Marxist if I am expected to be anti-Moralist?

3 Upvotes

Firstly, I know it doesn't mean no values or even personal morals (I think) but..

If the argument is "Capitalism will eventually fail due to it's contradictions"

Then why would I be Marxist? What purpose does it serve? There's no ground to gain following unless I appeal to myself or others in a moral manner as well.

If I assume that Capitalism were to fail regardless why would I bother advocating for Communism? UNLESS I believe that Communism is better for me and the people I care about, and if I think it's better, it's because we aren't exploited, and being exploited sucks. It's bad.

To me that is the reason I'd be Marxist, is it's advocating for a system that works, Capitalism is doomed to fail, and the system proposed is just and fair and without contradiction.

Sorry if stupid, new and need to understand