r/Marxism101 • • Sep 23 '26

Natural Science, Social Science and the use of dialectics

11 Upvotes

I’m a scientist who has been reading more Marxist philosophy recently, and I’m trying to understand the distinction some Marxists, particularly Lukács and parts of the Frankfurt School tradition, draw between the natural and social sciences, and what that means for dialectics. Please correct me if my starting point is wrong, I’m interested to learn!

As I understand it, the argument is roughly that there is an important difference between studying nature and studying society. In natural science, the object I study does not normally change its behaviour because of my theory about it: an electron does not read my paper and alter its behaviour accordingly. Society is different because both the investigator and the object being investigated are human beings situated within the same historical society. Economic categories like capital, wages, private property and the commodity are therefore not simply timeless “things” waiting to be observed like atoms (though I am aware these abstractions about the natural world too are historically situated and will be developed); they are historically produced social relations created and reproduced through human activity. Our theories about society can themselves become part of that society and influence how people act.

This makes Marx’s dialectical method intuitive to me in the social sciences. Capitalism is a historically changing totality containing internal contradictions; workers and capitalists reproduce the system through their activity while simultaneously changing it; cause and effect feed back upon one another; and the subjects studying society are themselves products and potential transformers of that society. In that sense it seems difficult to understand society *non-dialectically*.

Where I become less convinced is the attempt, associated particularly with Engels to discover the same dialectical laws operating throughout nature. Statements such as “quantity transforms into quality” can certainly be illustrated using phase transitions, but as a physicist I’m unsure what explanatory work calling this “dialectical” actually performs. Statistical mechanics already explains why a phase transition occurs. I don’t insert a dialectical law into the calculation in order to obtain the result.

So I’d be interested in what Marxists here think about the Lukács/Frankfurt School side of this debate. Is dialectics principally a method for understanding historically constituted human society, or is there genuinely a dialectics of nature independent of human praxis? If the latter, what does dialectics allow a working natural scientist to *do* that ordinary scientific methodology does not?


r/Marxism101 • • Jun 28 '26

My child is interested in Marxist theory and I have a few questions.

10 Upvotes

Hello all!

I am new to Reddit so forgive me, but my friend mentioned that this was a good place to ask for questions regarding specific topics. My English is not good but hopefully this is understandable.

My daughter (16) has begun to read some works by Marx like The Communist Manifesto, Capital and some others. She is also very interested in Vladimir Lenin and Thomas Sankara. Her father and I didn't grow up with a lot of access to the level of education or resources she has, so we have always encouraged her to read as much as possible and to develop critical thinking skills, etc.

This is my mistake, but I am not familiar at all with Marxism. But my husband and I want to find out more and learn. These are some questions we have, if you don't mind answering:

  1. This is the big one, but my daughter asked if we qualified as 'bourgeois'.

I had heard that term before (in a song, so not great) and I thought it was best to ask people who were well-versed in Marxism instead of giving her an incorrect answer from Google. We also have a hard time reading in long-form because I'm dyslexic and my husband is legally blind, so forgive us if it seems lazy that we're asking. I know from researching a bit that it describes a sort of class, it says middle-class but my daughter says it refers to people who own the "means of production".

Both my husband and I grew up extremely poor: my family couldn't afford to buy cooking oil, I wore the exact same shoes (for school) from age 8 to age 16, we went to state-funded schools (which are not developed or maintained like in other countries), got scholarships to local universities and then international ones, had to work full-time as students to buy plane tickets/food/etc, and other things. He now works as a college professor for a graduate school and I'm a lawyer that mostly works with NGOs and charities. I'd say we are definitely upper-middle class now, especially in the country we live in.

Her issue is with her grandparents.

Both of us also come from immigrants (great-grandparents, so long ago). My husband's father worked as a painter and handyman, but they also owned a "bodega" which was handled by her grandmother, and my daughter is anxious it could count as controlling goods.

My mom inherited a farm from my great-grandfather, he came to this country and was so poor that he couldn't afford shoes, but he saved up along with my great-grandmother and bough plots of land (for farming) for his 7 children. Which my daughter says might be a problem because of land-owning. So, my parents are 77 and 82. Both still working and living in the farm, I have offered to buy them a home but they built their house by themselves (with bricks made of dirt and cement they mixed up) and don't want to move or stop working.

Another issue she has is that they have "employees". I say this lightly because those are family friends who, I've known since I was small and only work when they ask my dad for money since they have their own farms, so he gives them whatever they need in exchange for help managing crops.

2. What works/events/figures should we educate ourselves on to learn more about Marxist thought?

3. How can we encourage her to keep being motivated in learning about politics and how she can change the world (to her ability) for the better?

Thank you, and I'm sorry if this was too long or sounds dumb! We all want to learn more.


r/Marxism101 • • May 24 '26

How do i even study by books?

10 Upvotes

Hey! So, my question basically is, if i want to read a book about something that is of my interest, (for example, marxism, history or things like that), how do i even really learn? Do i just read it? Do you do some others things like use flashcards to remember better?


r/Marxism101 • • May 05 '26

Marxism and vulgar Marxism

10 Upvotes

I have read that orthodox Marxism (also known as vulgar Marxism, or economism) reduces everything to economic factors, and that this differs from Marx’s own approach. Who are the authors associated with this vulgar Marxism? In what ways do they differ from what Marx actually proposed? Is this related to the concept of base and superstructure? Did Marx later retract this idea of base and superstructure?


r/Marxism101 • • Aug 22 '26

What book after Capital Vol III?

9 Upvotes

I just finished reading Marx’s Capital Vol 3, I’m looking for a book that advances Marx’s theories. I prefer a book published within 3-5 decades after the publication of Capital. Also, should I read volume 4?


r/Marxism101 • • Jul 25 '26

Question on petty bourgeoise

9 Upvotes

Let’s say you were to own a business where you are the only worker, are you still considered petty bourgeoisie or are you proletariat still. Also would the business be considered personal or private property (I would assume personal property, I just want to make sure)


r/Marxism101 • • Sep 24 '26

Am I considered bourgeoisie

8 Upvotes

My father is the franchise of a danish furniture company in Scotland he has two stores which he does run but he does have a manager would he be considered bourgeoise I assume so. My question is am I considered bourgeoise as I make my own money working but I do live in his home he drops me places buys me food and so on so I just wanted peoples opinion.


r/Marxism101 • • May 02 '26

Marx's texts about ideology - which ones is it?

8 Upvotes

very very new to marxism, but i'm doing a paper about it and it's links to a show which illustrates how the working class are coercively controlled so to speak through the use of ideology. i started with Louis Althusser's stuff, which i know is based in what marx's theory was, but i did some more research and i thought that maybe marx's theory would be more related to my essay, since the ISA stuff that Althusser talks about doesnt add much depth to my work. could someone please tell me the relevant text to look for for marx's theory of ideology?


r/Marxism101 • • Sep 27 '26

How would one know if their (dialectical materialist) analysis was wrong?

7 Upvotes

I'm finally getting around to teaching myself not only to understand, but to apply dialectical materialism (with historical materialism to follow). I successfully (I think) analysed a chick hatching from an egg. But how would one know if their analysis was wrong? What would that look like? And how would one remedy such an eventuality?

Any help in developing my knowledge further on this topic would be much appreciated.
TIA


r/Marxism101 • • Jul 14 '26

How does capitalism enforce the patriarchy?

7 Upvotes

I’m just curious, what does capitalism do to enforce the patriarchy and male dominance since obviously tradition and traditional views will also play a part, how big of an influence is capitalism in upholding the patriarchy?


r/Marxism101 • • Jun 23 '26

14 year old how should i start

7 Upvotes

Ive read the principles of communism, started das kapital, and im starting socialism4all's study guide for Marxism-Leninism bc i find it easier to digest when someone else is reading it to me.

Im looking into any marxist groups/clubs near me as ive found the online ones to be pretty horrid.
thank you <3 sorry if this isnt in the right place! hope u all have a wonderful day


r/Marxism101 • • Apr 24 '26

My mom said that I'm a bad Marxist bc I use social media.

7 Upvotes

To clarify i am Marxist, my mother, however is not. I think she was using this as like a jab or gotcha moment but I feel like social media is a very important tool. While I also do read theory, its very hard for me as I have quite severe ADHD which makes it hard to read as lines seem to blend/merge together and i often zone out while reading making me re-read the same thing multiple times. While I have begun also listening to people read theory on yt, they don't have that much and I still zone out. I also feel like social is how I share theory and other stuff with my only friend who is as far left as I am. I js feel like that was a preatty bad argument from my mom but idk and i wanna know if you guys agree with her or if shes in the wrong and you can help me better formulate a response to her.


r/Marxism101 • • 22d ago

What should I read if I actually want to learn something about Marxism and Communism

6 Upvotes

Lately, I've been getting back into my childhood obsession of reading. I want to learn about Marxism, and Communism, and was wondering if you guys have any suggestions on what to read (other than the Communist Manifesto and das kapital)?


r/Marxism101 • • Sep 06 '26

Mao's blunders

6 Upvotes

I've recently taken an interest in Maoism and I find a lot of the core principles very reasonable, however I'm absolutely puzzled by the foreign policy of China under Mao.

The domestic policies of the Great Leap Forward and the Cultural Revolution were not very successful, and a lot of questionable/indefensible incidents have occurred throughout both. However, they were also critiqued within the CPC, and the motivations behind the policies were at least coherent with Mao Zedong Thought.

When it comes to foreign policy, however, Maoist China following the Sino-Soviet Split seems to be guided almost solely by the perceived necessity or countering the influence of the USSR rather than the proclaimed principles. They went as far as collaborating with the US on supporting bloody, rabidly anti-communist bourgeois dictators like Pinochet or movements like UNITA, all in the name of anti-revisionism. I find it very hard to believe that the USSR was a bigger threat to China and especially the proleteriat at large than capitalist imperialism. What do modern Maoists think about these policies? Do they view them as necessary measures? How about contemporary Maoists in countries other than China?

I specifically exclude China under Deng and his successors from this question, as China no longer follows the Maoist line, and would likely be classified as a social imperialist country by Maoists anyway.


r/Marxism101 • • Jul 08 '26

Which books did marx talk about lumpenproletariat and did he change his mind on them?

6 Upvotes

I had conversations with communists who seem to use moralist language against the lumpenproletariat. But as far as im aware marx doesnt really use much moralist language about peoples character in his works. So can someone plz give me a quick rundown on what marx meant by lumpenproletariat and which books he talks abt them in. I am a trans woman and many trans women I know are forced into sex work, does that make them lumpenproletariats incapable of having revolutionary consciousnes? Bcuz I know a few sex worker friends who have read marx and agree w him in many instances so I am curious what marx actually meant


r/Marxism101 • • Jun 13 '26

I need help understanding idealism?

6 Upvotes

I understand Materialism pretty well and can explain that myself, but how would you explain idealism? Anytime I try to explain Idealism, it just sounds like gobbledegook.

And how/why does idealism lend itself so well to the ruling class/oppressive power structures?


r/Marxism101 • • May 29 '26

How would society form itself once achieving communism

6 Upvotes

Because I understand the idea of a classless moneyless society but I’m unsure how a stateless society would function I can see it as like syndicalism but Since that is a separate thing i assume there is some other vision although i definitely need more theory


r/Marxism101 • • May 03 '26

How do Marxists respond to common criticisms of the labour theory of value?

6 Upvotes

I’ve been reading Capital and some secondary texts on Marxist economics, and I’m trying to better understand how Marxists today respond to common criticisms of the labour theory of value (LTV).

From what I understand, the LTV says that value is determined by socially necessary labour time, and that profit comes from surplus value extracted from labour. But I’ve come across a few issues that I’m struggling to reconcile, and I’d really appreciate clarification:

  • How does the LTV account for differences in prices across industries with different capital intensities (i.e. the transformation problem)?

  • If machines (“dead labour”) don’t create new value, how do we explain modern highly automated production where output (and profit) still occurs with minimal direct labour input?

  • How does LTV deal with cases where something takes a lot of labour but has little or no market value due to low demand?

  • Is the theory meant to explain prices directly, or is it more about underlying social relations (i.e. exploitation and class structure)?

  • Do contemporary Marxist economists reinterpret or modify LTV, and if so, how?

I’m genuinely trying to understand how these critiques are addressed within Marxist theory rather than from outside it.

Any explanations, reading recommendations, or clarifications would be really helpful. Thanks!


r/Marxism101 • • Apr 12 '26

marxist writings on disability?

6 Upvotes

hello! I'm starting to get stuck in reading theory and I'm enjoying the learning process! for personal reasons I'm interested in reading the marxist perspective of disability, specifically regarding those who are unable to work. Cheers :)


r/Marxism101 • • 11d ago

Relations of Production in ML

5 Upvotes

Hi I‘m pretty new to communism/socialism and I recently read “Dialectic and Historical Materialism” by Stalin for a overview, since my communist education has of now consisted of short form videos and snippets of various texts ripped out of context.

I was wondering how the relations of production was different in the USSR? I know the State-Capitalism argument is often met with insults, but i’ve never had someone explain to me how what the USSR or any other ML project did wasn’t just exchange bourgeois ownership with state control? I just know of early work place democracy models after the revolution but from what I’ve read they just got replaced with top-down state control.

Sorry if my question is incoherent or does not make sense…[https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/stalin/works/1938/09.htm](https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/stalin/works/1938/09.htm)


r/Marxism101 • • 26d ago

I believe in Capitalism, but i wanna read "Das Kapital"

5 Upvotes

How much will it take me to read it, can i understand it without any big background in economics and do you think it will change my mind on capitalism?


r/Marxism101 • • Oct 04 '26

What is the absolute bare minimum Marx and Engels' reading list before I start reading writings by other communist writers like Mao, Lenin, or Bordiga for instance?

5 Upvotes

So far I've read the Communist Manifesto, the critique Gotha Programme (but that kinda flew over my head, but I learned thats not usually a good book for beginners), and Michael Parenti's Black Shirts and Reds (i saw that at like a second hand bookstore and it is real hard to come by physical communist literature in my area so I just wanted to give it a read), and right now I'm in the middle of reading The Principles Of Communism by Engels.

I want to read some writings by Lenin, Mao, and other people like Huey P Newton or something. But before I read all that stuff, I feel like it is best to start with the basics, that being Marx and Engels writings. That being said, what would be like the absolute must reads by Marx and Engels before I move on to Lenin writings or Mao writings etc.?


r/Marxism101 • • Aug 26 '26

Electoral politics

5 Upvotes

From what I understand Marxists use parliamentary democracy as a platform to reach the working class. So what would they do if they suddenly get significant support but not enough to make a revolution, say 20% or 30%, and they have the chance to be the biggest party in a governing coalition?


r/Marxism101 • • Aug 26 '26

I want to know more about vanguards

5 Upvotes

For context, I'm a left libertarian socialist leaning towards anarchism, but (hope I) have an open mind towards other branches of leftism, including Marxism.

I want to better understand vanguard parties, since it's a specific point of contention anarchists often have with Marxists.

What are the origins of the idea of Vanguards, why do you see them as necessary? Are there historical examples of vanguard parties going particularly well, or particularly poorly? How do you avoid corruption within the vanguard party, power grabs, and infighting?
And from a specifically marxist perspective, are there any realistic alternatives to a vanguard party?


r/Marxism101 • • Aug 21 '26

Why are the capitalist class hellbent in AI investment despite being costly and not even benefiting them

5 Upvotes

Especially AI data centres? We all know about the diagram on circular investment between AI firms. Basically meaning that these AI firms dont really produce/extract much surplus value but just recycle it again and again, among other things, which creates concerns for a looming huge AI bubble.

The building of huge ai data centres (or better called as huge ai supercomputers) is not really to “keep up with the demand of AI use” as the huge data centres being built rn like the one the size of Manhattan are absolutely overkill. Engineering explanations aside, it’s all to keep producing much more supercomputing power to advance LLM intelligence and to basically “experiment” what said LLMs can do (less GPU for AI can generate prompts, more GPU can generate whole videos, what could much much more GPU mean for what AI can do?) therefore to be used later.

My guess is with capitalist logic, maybe they’re trying to invest so much on building these ai data centres to desperately find a way (like blindly trying to hit a dart into the centre) for creating an AI with skills that helps them produce much more surplus value with less costs (less workers to pay bc u have AI that can do alot more sophisticated human skills) especially in the 2020s where the rate of profit keeps going down and down as it tends to do.
Whats with the big capitalist class’s obsession in AI?