r/Marxism • • Mar 02 '25

I Feel Like I'm Living In Crazy Land

0 Upvotes

I dont know if this is the right place to post this.

Since the oval office release, liberals have come out the woodworks online in support of continuing the war in Ukraine.

I've been censored from one of my favorite subreddits for speaking out against this phenomenon.

No one seems to be aware of US involvement in the fascist takeover of Ukraine in 2014. No one seems to be aware of NATO encroachment. They have double standards for Russia. I've asked several people what they think would happen if Mexico joined a military alliance with Russia or China, if they think the US wouldn't consider it a national security threat and not launch a military intervention of their own, and they just shut their brains off.

I think the thing thats driving me crazy the most is the idea that these people think everyone supports their crazy bloodlust. Antiwar opinions are being censored, and it feels like people who know their history and want the war in Ukraine to end to spare Ukrainian and Russian lives are being thrown under the rug.

It definitely feels like there's fed involvement in this operation, manufacturing consent for possible nuclear war to "own the Ruzzians".

I take solace in the fact that offline, no one I know in my personal life supports continuing this war, as well as the fact that this seems to be a liberal European and US problem, that the rest of the world sees through this sham.

I'm absolutely disgusted. I feel like I'm living in some dystopian nightmare.


r/Marxism • • Oct 13 '21

Well it turns out the Tankies were right once again

1 Upvotes

There was no Uighur “genocide” The CIA admitted they made it up to destabilize China. However I do hope the sparks a larger conversation, and I want to know everyone’s opinion. How do you think we combat these western propaganda lies but actually be taken seriously by a majority of people?


r/Marxism • • Mar 31 '25

In the imperial core, oppressed groups like transsexuals and the disabled require bourgeoise democratic representation to advance from a form of semi-colonialism to capitalism before they can fight for socialism

0 Upvotes

In the imperial core, the markets of oppressed groups like transsexuals and the disabled more resemble those of oppressed nations and colonies than capitalism as is usually understand. These sort of oppressed groups are dependent on predatory non-profit industries which form a state within the state that mostly serve to pacify these groups, keep them super-exploited and useful as political scapegoats.

In the context of the imperial core, the proletarians of these groups must engage in bourgeoise "idpol" and achieve forms of bourgeoise autonomy and bourgeoise democratic representation before they can properly fight for socialism with the rest of the workers.

In the periphery, these groups have the greater problem of national liberation.

So socialists in the imperial core can make significant gains by pushing in reforms for bourgeoise autonomy and bourgeoise democratic representation.

Not sure how much sense it makes sense to apply Maoist ideas to domestic imperialism here. But I think the argument that you're just joining the system instead of knocking it down is very misguided.


r/Marxism • • Nov 12 '23

The New Atheist was more relevant to Marxist politics than it gets credit for

0 Upvotes

Most people look back on the New Atheist days with some level of embarrassment, or at least the feeling that it was misguided.

But if the rise in prominence of the right wing since 2016 tells us anything, it’s that the New Atheist movement was actually an important part of undermining right-wing ideology. And if you need proof, look at where we are now. Religion is a key component of the contemporary right, and there isn’t any sense of strong pushback in the public discourse.

To be clear: the pushback should be against religion as such, the fact that it is nonsensical dogma. They are asking us to believe in fantasies like a man rising from the dead 2,000 years ago, and that we should worship this person.

Right now, the right wing wants to frame the issue as religion versus LGBTQ+ rights, or religion versus abortion, etc. That way they can push the idea that they’re combatting “wokeism” or whatever. Get away from that narrative, and force them to defend religion as such. They won’t be able to.

By doing so, you will not only be undermining religion, but you will, by extension, be undermining their ideology universally, since they will always need to rely on some sort of quasi-fictional narrative, such as the idea of “the nation” or the fetishism of the commodity to justify their politics. By attacking their stupidest and most nonsensical shibboleth, by proxy, you’ll be attacking all of them.


r/Marxism • • Sep 06 '26

Iran is not anti-imperialist

0 Upvotes

The fact that Iran is fighting off an imperial aggression on it does not make anti-imperialist, much like fighting off a thief robbing our house does not make us crime fighters. To give a well-known example, France and the UK fought off genocidal fascist Germany although they were genocidal fascist states themselves.

What would make Iran an anti-imperialist force is its political program. Yet, it has supported and welcomed support from the colony, selling oil to it and buying weapons from it in the 80s. During the past 15 years, its allies in Syria and Iraq disregarded the U.S. occupation there. Although it has claimed “unity” of fields with Palestine, Lebanon and Syria against the colony for years, it never took military action when the colony aggressed these fields, including the genocide in the fields of Gaza and South Lebanon, although it was quick to respond decisively when its own “field” was aggressed. And back home, it has doubled down on the identitarian patterns used by imperialism to fragment society, discriminating in favor of Shiite males.

This does not mean it is the villain the aggressors are portraying it to be. For example, Iran does not seek to genocide Jews. It is one of the few countries in the world to support a one-state solution in Palestine, making a difference between Jewish Palestinians and Jewish settlers, and pushing forward a model where the latter would either remain in peace or leave in peace.

This also does not mean the colony and the U.S. are justified in their aggression on it, for a number of reasons too obvious to mention. Furthermore, a balance of power between the colony and Iran in the region offers a larger margin of maneuvering for actual anti-imperialist forces.

More importantly, black-or-white approaches are very common, and limit themselves to oral statements of support or condemnation. We can shout we’re with or against Iran all we like—it won’t affect the balance of forces. Instead, we need to figure out our own political program, see where it aligns with Iran and where it doesn’t, and figure out what to do —not what to say— accordingly.


r/Marxism • • Nov 07 '25

Non-Tankie Commie

58 Upvotes

Is it possible to be a Marxist without being a “Tankie”? I was just kicked out of r/LateStageCapitalism for being critical of Stalin. Apparently, any attempt at discussion is considered “propaganda” or some such nonsense. I personally prefer Trotsky’s ideas over Stalin’s, but I digress.


r/Marxism • • Sep 20 '24

Can intersectionality be a catalyst to achieving class consciousness?

1 Upvotes
  1. Class exist

  2. There are factors hindering people from prioritizing (reaching the consciousness) class as the main source of their problems (racial oppression, religious oppression, gender disparities, day to day grind)

  3. intra/inter solidarity among disenfranchised groups bring the issue of class to the fore

eta: https://www.reddit.com/r/socialism/comments/1am7r5z/why_do_some_white_leftists_view_the_integration/

eta: https://socialistworker.org/2017/08/01/a-marxist-case-for-intersectionality


r/Marxism • • Feb 11 '26

An Advaitic Critique of Marxism

0 Upvotes

I just read this piece by the Advaita philosophy teacher Acharya Prashant called “An Advaitic Critique of Marxism” and I am curious what Marxists here think about it.

My takeaway: he says Marxism is not “wrong” for seeking justice, but it is incomplete because it expects liberation to come mainly from changing external structures like property relations and class arrangements. From an Advaita perspective, suffering is always individual and awakening is individual, so starting with class consciousness can become a kind of collective ego rather than real self-understanding. He also pushes back on economic reductionism, saying needs and desire are not examined deeply enough, and that culture, belief, fear, and conditioning shape society as much as economics. His bigger point is that systems do not automatically liberate people because conditioned minds can recreate domination under any banner, including a revolutionary one. So he argues inner clarity has to accompany outer change, otherwise revolutions just rotate power.

I would like to know what you all think about this perspective ,do let me know in the comments.

Link to the full article: https://acharyaprashant.org/en/articles/an-advaitic-critique-of-marxism-acharya-prashant-on-the-pioneer-1_996db5eb5


r/Marxism • • Sep 25 '25

Moderated Is multiculturalism considered good or bad by marxists?

2 Upvotes

r/Marxism • • May 06 '25

how should we feel about the descendants of the settlers in the settler colonies

36 Upvotes

idk if i worded this question very well, i dont know exactly how to ask it. i work with the indiginous here in the usa for their liberation, ive lived on rez for a long time as a teenager and that was what radicalized me for real. consciousness is raising in regards to the colonial struggle in palestine here, and i thought this would he a good chance to show other white people at the protests the links and similarities between our 2 settler projects, here and israel. ive been let down, people have almost always sunk into denial, cognitive dissonance, acting like "yeah what a tragedy all the indians died too bad theyre all dead now we just have to move on with all the wealth we stole!", even though the genocide here is still ongoing, albiet in a much later stage than the phase palestine is in

the way ive always thought about this is, yk we are apart of the settler class in this society right? the colonization never ended, its ongoing, and we are all benefitting from and are complicit in the maintenance of this system. the homes we live in, the money we make, the political process we are apart of, literally every aspect of our lives in based directly on genocide, plunder and displacement, right? i feel like americans especially white americans have this hyper individualist view of this shit, "im not guilty for the sins of my ancestors" shit. and that may be true, but we are guilty of implicitly or explicitly supporting, maintaining, and benefiting from the systems our ancestors built up with their sins. we have a collective responsibility to right the wrongs of the past, and bring justice to those who we have tried our best as a society to destroy. we make up this society, we are the beneficiaries, therefore the responsibility for injustices of this society fall on our shoulders, even if we didnt ask for this and just happened to be born into this. we spend all day every day reaping the fruits of these injustices and we are so quick to abdicate any and all responsibility for those injustices ever have being comitting and all responsibility for the upkeep of those injustices up until today and tomorrow and the day after that

the indiginous are not apart of /our/ society. our society exists at their expense, they are fully excluded.

do yall know what i mean? i heard another marxist say that we arent responsibility for the sins of our ancestors, and he of course had a much more nuanced analysis than the typical average american, and im just asking here to see what yalls thoughts on this subject are

its been really disappointing to see so many newly minted pro Palestinian americans absolutely reject any sort of analysis or recognition of the indiginous on these lands and the settler colony we make up and the reality of our history. it makes me feel like this is all so disingenuous for a lot of people. that people here can "afford" to condemn genocide and settler colonislism only if its happening on the other side of the world, far away and which we dont feel any direct benefits of that genocide in our day to day lives. seems to hit too close to home, understanding the exact same thing is happening right here and that we hold responsibility for its continuation. is it just a moralism thing for so many? is that why we arent willing to do what must be done to force the hand of power into giving into our demands of withdrawaling all support for israel?

anyway, thanks a bunch, id love to hear your thoughts <3


r/Marxism • • Nov 25 '23

"Marxism has liberated the oppressed"

0 Upvotes

As growing in middle class, I always had found that the marxist thesis of "businessmen steal/oppress the worker" was kind of obvious and I didn't understand why the marxist heroes as Karl Marx, Lenin, Stalin, Gramci and others where so revered. I thought that because marxist are atheist, they needed a replacement of gods and myths of religion as a inner need. I went to college but didn't finished, so I started to work in fast food, warehouses and factories I'm surprised how the common worker puts the company which they work for, over their personal interest or even their well-being. When I ask them why the behave the way they act, the answer is: "we don't to be scolded", like if they were still in primary school. It'd make more sense that they didn't want to be fired tho.

Thats when I realize that, if marxism didn't exist, it will not exist middle class and everybody would work 12 hours shifts.


r/Marxism • • Mar 11 '25

Do Marxists support Trumps foreign policy agenda, when I to free trade and NATO?

0 Upvotes

(Edit spelling error in title.. when it comes to free trade and NATO)

OK, so ignoring everything he has said regarding Greenland, Canada, Panama and Palestine, isn't Trump enacting exactly the sorts of policies that were popular amoung marxists at the turn of the millennium?

  • Weakening NATO and with it America's ability to project power globally

  • Anti-NAFTA, anti-free trade and anti-globalization

  • Strong industrial policy

  • Attempting to end the war (in Ukraine) and calling on Russia, China and US to slash military spending.


r/Marxism • • Nov 09 '25

Why marxists always agree with everything only because Marx wrote?

0 Upvotes

I’m a marxist. I was reading State And Revolution -Vladmir Lenin-, and I noticed that one of the points that Lenin made, was that centralism is good because Marx did agree with it. Guys, this doesn’t make and sense. Marx was a philosopher. Philosophers need to question everything.


r/Marxism • • Dec 21 '20

Why have Western Marxists abandoned Cuba and North Korea?

1 Upvotes

Here we have two examples of actually existing socialism. They have made achievement but they also have problems. However, Western Marxists have made no effort in trying to help these countries. There are no Western Marxists who have made any serious analysis of the economic problems of contemporary Cuba and North Korea, they have made no policy recommendations, they do not engage with the leaders, planners, engineers, economists etc of these nations.

The same was observed during the time of the USSR. While the USSR was struggling to deal with the practical aspects of building socialism, related to matters of economic calculation, organizational structures, production efficiencies etc, Western Marxists simply contended themselves with denouncing the Soviet Union and made no effort with starting a constructive dialogue with the scientists, engineers, economists and politicians of the USSR.

They do not even study these countries to acquire practical knowledge that can help future socialist experiments. I am shocked by the lack of useful research done on the economies of these nations.


r/Marxism • • Jan 05 '26

Uphold Marxism-Leninism and reject the revisionism of Socialism with Chinese Characteristics

15 Upvotes

“The theoretical victory of Marxism compelled its enemies to disguise themselves as Marxists” -Lenin.

Section I- Class character of the party:

A majority of self proclaimed Marxists Leninists espouse a belief that China is either 1. Already a socialist state or 2. A dictatorship of the proletariat that is working towards socialism and will achieve it be 2050. This must come as quite a shock to The Party, which has allowed wealthy capitalists to join since 2001. According to Leninism, the party is meant to be the advanced detachment of the working class. That appears to be a contradiction. This act by the party is justified by saying they must keep their friends close and their enemies closer. Stalin outright rejects this idea of keeping enemies in the party:

The theory of “defeating” opportunist elements by ideological struggle within the Party, the theory of “overcoming” these elements within the confines of a single party, is a rotten and dangerous theory, which threat-ens to condemn the Party to paralysis and chronic infirmity, threatens to make the Party a prey to opportunism, threatens to leave the proletariat without a revolutionary party, threatens to deprive the proletariat of its main weapon in the fight against imperialism. Our Party could not have emerged on to the broad highway, it could not have seized power and organised the dictatorship of the proletariat, it could not have emerged victorious from the civil war, if it had had within its ranks people like Martov and Dan, Potresov and Axelrod. Our Party succeeded in achieving internal unity and unexampled cohesion of its ranks primarily because it was able in good time to purge itself of the opportunist pollution, because it was able to rid its ranks of the Liquidators and Mensheviks

-Stalin, Foundations of Leninism, 8. The Party.

Other times, this is justified by saying the party must represent the entire Chinese population not just workers, and thus bourgeoise must participate within the party. Indeed, this is exactly what Khrushchev espoused after he seized power in the 1950s. Stalin rejects this also:

The talk of Kautsky and Co. about universal equality, about “pure” democracy, about “perfect” democracy, and the like, is a bourgeois disguise of the indubitable fact that equality between exploited and exploiters is impossible. The theory of “pure” democracy is the theory of the upper stratum of the working class, which has been broken in and is being fed by the imperialist robbers. It was brought into being for the purpose of concealing the ulcers of capitalism, of embellishing imperialism and lending it moral strength in the struggle against the exploited masses.

-Stalin, Foundations of Leninism, 4. The Dictatorship of the Proletariat.

Section II- Property relation:

But all of this dancing around the elephant in the room: There is a bourgeois class in China. There are capitalists in China. The DOTP is not meant to be a state that manages capitalists, but a state that systematically suppresses, expropriates, and liquidates the bourgeoisie as a class. If China is a DOTP, why hasn’t this happened? The answer is quite simple. It’s a capitalist state controlled by capitalists. The definition of a capitalist state is one in which private ownership of the MOP exists and capital dominates society. Capitalist production begins when workers are bereft of the means of production and are compelled to sell their labor power as a commodity. That’s exactly what we see in China.

A decisive indicator is the legal form of ownership: joint-stock equity claims on enterprises, traded and transferable, which presuppose private appropriation and profit accounting. Ownership of the means of production resides in shares of stock, which are indispensable to a capitalist economy and permit the division and transfer of ownership. Even firms that formally remain state-owned have been restructured to operate according to capitalist imperatives. These SOEs now function as private multinational corporations, oriented toward profitability and market competition.

There is a fusion of party, state, and capitalist elites. Top party officials and their families have taken over the most strategic and profitable industries, such as banking and natural resources, enriching themselves through state assets and kickbacks. Over 90% of China’s richest 20,000 people are reportedly related to senior government or Communist Party officials. (Source: Peter Kwong, "The Chinese Face of Neoliberalism," Counterpunch, 7/8, October 2006.)

But what about state ownership? Capitalist state ownership must not be confused with social ownership. In reality, it’s just the concentration of capital in collective bourgeois form.

But the transformation . . . into state ownership, does not do away with the capitalistic nature of the productive forces. . . And the modern state, again, is only the organisation that bourgeois society takes on in order to support the general external conditions of the capitalist mode of production against the encroachments as well of the workers as of individual capitalists. The modern state, no matter what its form, is essentially a capitalist machine, the state of the capitalists, the ideal personification of the total national capital. The more it proceeds to the taking over of productive forces, the more does it actually become the national capitalist, the more citizens does it exploit. The workers remain wage-workers - proletarians.

-Engels, Anti-Dühring, Part III: Socialism, 2. Theoretical.

And this is exactly what we see in China today with the super exploitation of its population generating huge profits for a minority of the population, with 10% of the population holding 67% of wealth. (Source: Stanford Center on China’s Economy and Institutions, “The Rise of Wealth, Private Property, and Income Inequality in China,” China Briefs, Stanford University, n.d.)

I would ask you to consider: Is this how workers are treated under a DOTP?

approximately 70% of manufacturing work is done by migrants. Over the last 25 years, some 150-200 million Chinese have moved from the countryside to urban areas in search of employment. Although the great majority of these migrant workers have moved legally, they suffer enormous discrimination. For example, because they remain classified as rural residents under the Chinese registration system, not only must they pay steep fees to register as temporary urban residents, they also have no rights to the public services available to urban born residents (including free or subsidized education, health care, housing and pensions). The same is true for their children, even if they are born in an urban area. As a consequence migrant workers are easily exploitable. They typically work 11 hours a day, 26 days a month. Most receive no special overtime pay and commonly earn one-quarter to one-half of what urban residents receive.

(Source: China Labor Bulletin, "Migrant Workers in China," June 2008)

“But just because China doesn’t have a dictatorship of the proletariat and hasn’t abolished capital doesn’t mean they aren’t working towards socialism after all just look at the NEP!” Does working towards socialism necessitate becoming an imperialist country?

Section III- Foreign relations:

From 2000–2022, 89% of Africa’s exports to China were extractives like oil, copper, iron ore, alumina whilest 94% of Africa’s imports from China were manufactured goods. That means China captures significantly more value through manufacturing, contracting, logistics, and finance. This is “uneven exchange”. (Source: Boston University Global Development Policy Center, “China–Africa Economic Bulletin 2024 Edition,” April 1, 2024.)

For a specific example look at Angola where China uses oil backed, oil prepayment facilities where repayment is serviced through receivables from a designated oil contract. In plain jargon, the collection is the first claim on oil cashflows. The debt is structured so China takes priority. (Source: AidData, “China–Africa Aid Project Database: Project ID 53063,” accessed 01/05/26.)

Or look towards Kenya regarding the Standard Gauge Railway, the loans were structured to be “credit enhanced and secured” through a Railway Development Fund and multiple escrow accounts, plus a Long-Term Service Agreement that commits the Kenya Ports Authority to route minimum freight volumes to the railway. In plain jargon, it means cash flows are captured and controlled so debt takes first priority. That means the contract routes money into structures where the lender has direct leverage over repayment flows. The extraction channel shrinks fiscal space and forces Kenya to prioritize debt service over other spending to maintain the promised repayment stream. (Source: Kiel Institute for the World Economy, “How China Collateralizes,” Kiel Working Paper / Policy Brief.)

What does it mean to say a country is building towards socialism at that point? Does it only refer to China’s economic growth? Then every country that is growing economically is in the process of building socialism. What’s even the point of revolution? Just continue to maximize profit! This focus on simply making factories bigger and faster is a profound error that ignores the relations of production: who owns and controls the wealth. Rapid economic growth and even poverty reduction does not equal socialism when they occur through a capitalist mode of production and are funded via imperialism. That is, at best, social democracy.

And what of their foreign policy besides the imperialism? Would a country building socialism arm the reactionary Duterte regime of the Philippines to help put an end to the Maoist insurgency? (Source: Reuters, “Philippines Seeks China Defense Ties as U.S. Role Questioned,” October 18, 2016.) Would a country building socialism continue to do business with genocidal apartheid settler colonial Israel? Not even an embargo? They are even helping them continue their settler colonial project (Source: The Lausan Collective, “China Is Aiding Israeli Settlement,” 2025.)

But does this mean that it will thereby achieve the complete and final victory of socialism, i.e., does it mean that with the forces of only one country it can finally consolidate socialism and fully guarantee that country against intervention and, consequently, also against restoration? No, it does not. For this the victory of the revolution in at least several countries is needed. Therefore, the development and support of revolution in other countries is an essential task of the victorious revolution. Therefore, the revolution which has been victorious in one country must regard itself not as a self-sufficient entity, but as an aid, as a means for hastening the victory of the proletariat in other countries.

-Stalin, Foundations of Leninism, 3. Theory.

I’m sure the Dengists won’t read this. They will comment the same talking points, some anecdotes, talk about China executing billionaires, say something about building productive forces. Revisionism is always in the name of pragmatism, common sense, necessity. All critics are denounced as dogmatists. They call themselves Marxist Leninists but denounce everything written by Marx and Lenin as too dogmatic and outdated. But anti revisionists aren’t opposed to the idea that Marxism can grow, develop, be added to. We just oppose people replacing Marxism with bourgeois liberal ideology and the claiming it’s an improvement. That’s exactly what socialism with Chinese characteristics is:

We should let the market play the decisive role in allocating resources, while allowing the government to better perform its func-tions. This is a theoretical and practical issue of great importance. A correct and precise understanding of this issue is very important to further the reform and promote the sound and orderly development of the socialist market economy. We should make good use of the roles of both the market, the "invisible" hand, and the government, the "visible" hand. The market and the government should complement and coordinate with each other to promote sustained and sound social and economic development. The underlying issue is how to strike a balance between the functions of the government and the role of the market, and let the market play the decisive role in allocating resources and the government better perform its functions.


r/Marxism • • Oct 07 '24

Using NotebookLM AI to study Marx.

0 Upvotes

Just wanted to share this because I've found it incredibly useful. I've tried many times to read Marx, without much success. I got stuck a couple of times trying to understand some concepts and even if there's a huge amount of sources online trying their best to explain it, it can still be challenging. So when I learned about NotebookLM I knew exactly what to do.

I linked as many sources as possible and basically created an all-knowing marxist AI monster to which I can ask any questions about the texts and get a detailed explanation. Kind of like having a Marxist teacher at my disposal 24/7. I wouldn't use it to replace the original texts, of course, but I think It's a really useful tool to get through the most difficult parts. It can even generate a podcast discussing the main points in language that a teenager could understand. You can also get a pretty good overview of the sources that you're not that interested in reading in full at the moment. I swear this is not an ad haha, I just think it's a really powerful tool for anyone interested in understanding marxism (or anything, really).

I'm still testing the limits but I want to add some related authors and texts to get the full view and get into modern perspectives. Any recommendations?


r/Marxism • • Dec 31 '24

Are the petite bourgeoisie technically proletarians?

4 Upvotes

I recognize that they still in large part are ideologically in cahoots with the more powerful parts of the ruling class, but can it be said on pure technicality that they still have to sell their labor power to survive and are therefore proletarians? Esp those who work alone and don't employ people below them


r/Marxism • • Nov 29 '23

This chap has just replied to my post and I think he deserves more attention so I’m giving him his own thread.

1 Upvotes

“You guys are all idiots. I come from Eastern Europe. I emigrated as soon as I've good. As did everybody else from my friends. Marxisim/Socialism is DEATH, misery, suffering and then square that. There is no migration to ruzzia or Venezuela, but massive migration to US, Switzerland, UK, etc that are capitalist/market economy. You guys have NO IDEA what is life really like under marxist/communist regimes. It is a dictature of the worst kind.”


r/Marxism • • Jun 04 '26

Moderated Was Stalin really a Marxist?

25 Upvotes

r/Marxism • • Feb 21 '24

Marxism vs Land Back Movements.. Why did you choose Marxism?

0 Upvotes

It’s not that forms of Marxism can’t coexist with indigenous sovereignty at all, but to a degree, the imposition of a political philosophy onto indigenous people (as opposed to allowing full self-determination for various communities) seems contradictory.

The current status quo isn’t working. I want the empire to fall. Capitalism isn’t it. These are things I feel and I increasingly find myself drawn to other ways of being as a society. But I also deeply value indigenous sovereignty and land back, and I’m not sure why returning the land and having much smaller areas around the world (for example, there are over 250 different indigenous groups in Australia), wouldn’t be something better to fight for. We already know indigenous people tend to be far better caretakers of the land and protect ecosystems.

If you could share what you think and why you’re more hopeful about Marxism, or how you conceived of land back from a Marxist point of view, I would really appreciate it.


r/Marxism • • Feb 04 '26

Why am I a Marxist?

3 Upvotes

Hello, so I argued with my dad about China last night. He is a liberal(democrat we live in the US), and I am trying to explain what Dengism is, what the free market reforms were about. Say what you will about him, but my problem wasn't there. It was with how the Chinese government operates, we went back and forth, he said that the billionaires control it like an oligarchy, I said it is a meritocracy, and they have central planning and execute more corrupt billionaires than any other nation. Then he switched up and said it was a political oligarchy. I tried to reiterate that the members of the politburo passed the civil service exam and to progress, they must prove themselves on every level or else they would be removed. Then he went brainless mode and said communism only works on levels of 20-30 people. So I went on a tangent about how every Marxist experiment has been successful in ensuring a rise in QoL, literacy rates, stability, infant mortality, and access to food, but he didn't buy it. But I began thinking, and I just cannot shake it off. I know I am right, I know liberals are just capitalists, I know that working people need liberation, especially in the global south, I know that the USSR was a based country, I know that socialism is inherently democratic, but I could not shake off the question, why am I a Marxist even if I know that it is right. I just cannot answer that question.


r/Marxism • • May 05 '24

Fictional characters/worlds that best describe different types of Marxism?

0 Upvotes

Hello, I get confused by all the different branches but I find it easier when it’s compared to something I already know - example - Zaheer from legend of korra would be a ‘anarcho-communist’ right? Do any of you have any other characters/worlds that best describe when a branch is applied rather than just a definition of what it actually means?

PS there is absolutely no need to downvote my comments when I am simply asking questions and have an open and curious mind


r/Marxism • • 26d ago

I believe in capitalism, but i wanna read "Das Kapital"

0 Upvotes

How much will it take me to read it, can i understand it without any big background in economics and do you think it will change my mind on capitalism?


r/Marxism • • Jun 27 '19

And such people will always help ruling class by diverting people’s attention through their rhetoric of justice and equality. They have nothing substantial to tell people except lies and false promises. They are basically careerists disguised as socialists.

Post image
0 Upvotes